- 13 hours ago
The military manoeuvre aims to restrict maritime movement and cut off revenue streams, threatening global energy supplies and vital oil shipments to Asian markets, including India.
Category
ЁЯЧЮ
NewsTranscript
00:00Good evening, hello and welcome. You're with the news today. This is your prime time destination.
00:04As always, news, newsmakers, talking points Monday night, start of a new week.
00:08Let's tell you what we have on the show tonight. The U.S. blockade of the Strait of Hormuz has
00:13begun.
00:15What is Donald Trump's real game plan? Top military strategist, Colonel Douglas McGregor,
00:21will join us once again in an exclusive. That and plenty more, as always, on India's prime time show.
00:28But first, let's turn to the nine headlines at nine to nine.
00:34Donald Trump's Hormuz blockade kicks in. Trump warns will hit every Iranian ship that comes close,
00:41says Iran's navy is at the bottom of the sea.
00:47Despite the failed Islamabad peace talks, Pakistan pushes for diplomacy in U.S.-Iran tensions.
00:53Pakistan claims it's working to diffuse the crisis.
01:00Trump versus Pope over the West Asia war. Pope vats for dialogue and diplomacy.
01:06Trump says he isn't a big fan of the Pope.
01:12Ahead of the special session of Parliament, later this week, Prime Minister Modi makes a big Nari Shakti pitch,
01:18says efforts are aimed at empowering women.
01:21Opposition, though, dismisses the Modi claim, says the real goal is delimitation and an assault on the Constitution without consultation.
01:51The Supreme Court flags concerns over the manner in which the SIR is being conducted in poll-bound West Bengal,
01:58asserts that voters have a continuing right to be on the electoral rolls.
02:03However, it still backs off from interfering at this stage.
02:10Neetish Kumar expected to resign from the Bihar Chief Minister's post tomorrow afternoon,
02:15swearing-in ceremony for the next Bihar CM, scheduled in the Lok Bhavan.
02:19On April 15th at 11 a.m., Samrat Chaudhary remains a frontrunner.
02:26Noida workers' unrest turns violent, arson, vandalism on the streets of Noida.
02:32Angry workers hit the streets, seeking rise in wage, crowdstorms offices, vandalizes property.
02:40Delhi excise poll.
02:42Former Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal maintains the Delhi High Court judge must recuse herself,
02:48alleges political bias, and claims only cases against the opposition are past track in the High Court.
02:57And it's the end of an era, but the legacy remains.
03:00Asha Bhosle passes away at 92 last rites, held with full state honours at the Shivaji Park Crematorium.
03:24The big story that we are breaking at this moment,
03:27Donald Trump has now gone ahead and activated his threatened naval blockade
03:33of the Strait of Hormuz of all ships of Iran and other countries that come into or go out of
03:41the Strait.
03:41The United States says, we will hit every Iranian ship that comes close.
03:46Trump says, Iran's navy is at the bottom of the sea.
03:49Trump claiming the U.S. has obliterated 158 Iranian ships.
03:54Trump warning, come close, get hit.
03:57We'll hit every Iranian ship that comes close.
04:00Fast attack ships now on target.
04:02We will blow up these ships is what Donald Trump is threatening.
04:06Joining me now on that big story, our Diplomatic Affairs Senator Geeta Mohan is joining me.
04:12Pranay Upadhyay, who's on the Iran-Israel-Lebanon border is also with us.
04:18I want to come to you, Geeta, first.
04:20It seems almost that we are back to square one in terms of the upping of the rhetoric.
04:24What are you picking up?
04:26Are we now heading for a potential conflict after all the talk about two weeks ceasefire?
04:32Well, I don't think it's a conflict right now, but yes, the situation is tense.
04:37We'll have to wait and see how the blockade is going to hold Rajdeep.
04:42On the one hand, we're looking at America holding a naval blockade.
04:47Iran's saying it's going to respond.
04:48There has been no military action per se.
04:51But meanwhile, we also have the Russian and the Chinese foreign ministers who are going to meet in Beijing.
04:57And Russia has already said that shutting the Strait of Hormuz and a naval blockade does not work,
05:04especially for the global economy.
05:06Chinese ships will try leaving.
05:09Will America then confront China directly?
05:11Because if they harm any of the Chinese vessels leaving,
05:15then it would be a direct confrontation between China and America.
05:20So we'll have to wait and see how this pans out for now.
05:22I don't think anybody has the appetite and the stomach for military action.
05:26But should it come to such a pass, I don't think either side will move back.
05:36Well, at the moment, the war of words, as you say, has escalated.
05:39I'm joined by Pranay Upadhyay.
05:40Pranay, you're on the Israel-Lebanon border.
05:42And that is a conflict that remains unresolved.
05:44And there are now reports that Israel may well return into conflict mode in some form or the other.
05:50What are you picking up?
05:53The clear indications are here, Razeev, that Israeli Defense Forces are not backing down
05:58or going for any restraint or restriction in their operations in southern Lebanese territory against Hezbollah.
06:04On the other side, IDF, Israeli Defense Forces have initiated a two-day military exercise.
06:10It's a big exercise in Carmel area of the northern Israel,
06:14clearly indicating that they want to show their preparedness,
06:17that the ceasefire, which was already on a very fragile ground, is only hanging on the cliff.
06:24And you can very well see that this conflict has now entered the naval domain, the maritime domain,
06:29where the naval blockade initiated by U.S. military, U.S. Navy,
06:33is going to only escalate a situation or further complicate a situation.
06:37But amid all these things, the larger worry remains, Razeev, here, about the opening up of the state of Hormuz.
06:43Be it the blockade, you know, implemented or done by the U.S. Navy,
06:46or the Iranian Navy implementing a naval blockade or making it selectively permeable.
06:51The real issue remains that for over 45 days, the state of Hormuz has largely disrupted.
06:57Those international waters are largely inaccessible for all the ships.
07:00And in fact, the global energy supplies remain disrupted.
07:03And in the present situation, we see a more further complicated situation
07:08where, you know, we can see this disruption getting extended even for a further period of time.
07:18Right.
07:19Pranay Upadhyay, putting some context to what's been happening, I appreciate you joining me.
07:24Now, remember, the Strait of Hormuz is a waterway strategically located near Iran,
07:30which is a gateway for oil supplies to several parts of the world, including to us here in India
07:35and indeed to China and Japan.
07:38But it is now at the heart of a high-stakes economic and military standoff
07:43with United States and Donald Trump threatening to choke Iran's oil lifeline.
07:49Iran is saying they will see this as an act of aggression and promise to hit back.
07:54How will all of this play out?
07:56India Today looks at it.
07:58Take a look.
08:05First, Iran blocked the Strait of Hormuz.
08:08Now the United States has joined too, as Donald Trump unleashes one more weapon at his disposal
08:14in a bid to corner Tehran.
08:17Trump, in a message on Truth Social on Sunday, announced no ships will be allowed through the strait.
08:24He also threatened to stop vessels that pay toll to Iran.
08:30The President also declared the US will be destroying mines laid by Iran.
08:36Later, the United States Central Command clarified,
08:39ships that are headed to or coming from Iranian ports will be blocked.
08:45The US strategy is simple.
08:47Deny Iran any revenue to fund the war.
08:51Ninety percent of Iran's oil exports go to China.
08:55And there are reports that Beijing is helping Tehran.
08:59Trump on Sunday did not take kindly to question on alleged Chinese help to Iran.
09:06China is preparing the ship, whether it's Iran.
09:09Well, if China does that, China is going to have big problems, OK?
09:13The Strait of Hormuz is turning out to be Iran's biggest leverage and America's biggest headache.
09:21Over 20 percent of global energy passes through the strait and is currently unavailable.
09:27Even as the two-week ceasefire remains in place, the US focus is on opening up the Hormuz Strait.
09:35We've defeated all of their water boats, too.
09:37Their navy has gone 158 ships.
09:40They have 28 water droppers, mine droppers, they call them.
09:44All of them are sunk.
09:46They probably have a couple of mines in the water.
09:48We have mine sweepers out there who are sweeping the strait.
09:52And now all we do is we'll open up the strait, even though we don't use it,
09:56because we have a lot of other countries in the world that do use it.
10:01Iran, meanwhile, says a breakthrough was never expected in just one round of talks,
10:07after more than a month of war.
10:14It was natural from the beginning.
10:16One couldn't have reached an agreement in a single session.
10:20I don't think anyone can have such expectations.
10:23Despite that fact, this was the longest session in the past year.
10:32After Trump's announcement of Hormuz blockade, crude prices have crossed 100 mark again.
10:38Incidentally, the US sanctioned waiver for Iranian oil at sea, which expires on April 19th, remains.
10:46And it is not clear how the latest US strategy to starve Iran of funds by blocking its exports will
10:54play out.
10:55Bureau Report, India Today.
11:00Well, let me go across straight to my first guest, someone who's always made news headlines when he's come here
11:05on the news today.
11:06Colonel Douglas McGregor, US Army colonel, former senior advisor to the Secretary of Defense under President Trump.
11:13Good to have you, colonel.
11:14Once again, on the show, you've just heard the latest or seen the latest Donald Trump tweet.
11:19He's threatening to obliterate any ship that tries to prevent this US blockade.
11:24It says the Iranian Navy has been destroyed, obliterated.
11:27It's down at the bottom of the sea.
11:29Is this rhetoric or do you believe Donald Trump means business when he talks of this blockade?
11:35Well, it's hard to know what he means.
11:37If you're in the United States Navy right now, you are asking, what is this blockade?
11:42How are we supposed to implement it?
11:44How do we sort through the various vessels that want to go into or come out of the Gulf?
11:49So I think he's made sweeping statements without having sat down, first of all, with the naval leadership and asked
11:56them what he thinks or what they think he can do.
12:00I think it's a very dangerous thing to do right now.
12:02We could end up at war very quickly with China and potentially with any number of different nations simply because
12:09we're halting their lifeline.
12:11We're stopping the lifeblood that needs to reach them.
12:15You know, Arnold Toynbee said that great powers do not die from attack from the outside.
12:22They die by suicide.
12:24And right at the moment, I think many of Donald Trump's policies are frankly suicidal.
12:30Yeah.
12:33You're saying that you're saying Donald Trump's blockade or threat of a blockade of Iranian ship of any ship entering
12:40or exiting the Strait of Hormuz is suicidal.
12:44You're suggesting it is impossible or very difficult to actually implement in the high seas.
12:50Am I correct?
12:51Yes, I think it's very difficult.
12:53And ultimately, the Iranians, I think, can outlast us.
12:56How long can we sit out there and interfere with global traffic before we end up in a fight?
13:01As I said before, with other nations, specifically China, we forget that higher oil feeds straight into inflation that hits
13:10farmers, truckers and family budgets.
13:11So this has got to stop.
13:15And the talks, unfortunately, ended with the submission of Israel's demands from Iran.
13:22We can't make Iran meet Israel's demands.
13:26That's the problem.
13:31But let's for a moment, we'll come to those demands, but let's once again focus on the Strait of Hormuz.
13:37Iran is claiming territorial sovereignty over it.
13:40But Donald Trump claims the Iranian Navy has been obliterated and is in no place to actually enforce its writ
13:50over the Strait of Hormuz.
13:52Do you believe he's bluffing or do you believe that is the reality that the Iranian Navy has been obliterated?
13:57I think that's something he believes, but it's meaningless because the Iranian Navy is not a force on the scale
14:04of, say, the Royal Navy, the Indian Navy or the United States Navy.
14:08They only have forces available to do limited operations, and that means that they can very easily block the Strait.
14:16They can mine it.
14:17They can use unmanned submersibles.
14:20They can send out speedboats that are unmanned with missiles.
14:23There are all sorts of things they can do.
14:25But the most important thing they can do is that they can target any U.S. naval vessel headed through
14:30the Straits.
14:31Two destroyers tried to get through there within the last 36 to 48 hours, and they were turned back very
14:37quickly.
14:38By men in small boats, who made it very clear that if they didn't turn back, they would be attacked
14:44by cruise missiles.
14:46Both Navy destroyers wisely retreated.
14:49So I don't think President Trump understands the extent to which warfare has changed and how effective Iran's missile and
14:58unmanned systems really are.
15:05There's, of course, also the danger which Iran has also, from its own point of view, threatened that there could
15:12be mines under the sea.
15:14Do you believe that the Iranians are also engaging in their own bluster here?
15:18Do they have, after this 40-day war, do you believe they have the capacity to once again confront the
15:24United States and Israel?
15:25Oh, absolutely, without question.
15:28And I think that's coming in another week when the ceasefire expires.
15:31They have mined portions of the strait.
15:34There's no question about that.
15:36And we have very limited demining capabilities.
15:40We don't have very many mine-clearing ships.
15:43In fact, I think we've got one.
15:45I'm not even sure it's fully commissioned and seaworthy.
15:48I don't think President Trump consulted with the naval leadership before he made these threats.
15:54He's saying one thing without understanding another.
15:58And that's very, very dangerous for any statesman at this point.
16:06Colonel, every time you've come on the show and a couple of times that you've come, you've said this is
16:11a war without a strategy.
16:12You seem to suggest this is another example of a war without a strategy.
16:16What would have been a better strategy, according to you, purely from a military perspective?
16:21What could Donald Trump have done that he hasn't done?
16:25Well, the first thing is he's got to recognize that this ISR strike system that the Iranians have built cannot
16:32be defeated.
16:33He refuses to do that.
16:35He's got to find a way to negotiate out of this mess.
16:38He's got to come to terms with the reality that the entire world is suffering economically, very dangerously, from our
16:45actions.
16:46He needs to think in terms of India, of Japan, of the Republic of Korea, Southeast Asia, Europe.
16:55All of these countries are dependent upon the oil from the Persian Gulf.
17:00He's utterly refused to do that.
17:02So he's irresponsible, to put it bluntly.
17:05Now, militarily, he's got to accept the fact if we can't defeat that system that I just mentioned, intelligence, surveillance,
17:12reconnaissance linked to strike systems, then militarily, there isn't a great deal that we can do.
17:18And if he tries to stop traffic from going in eventually, he's going to end up at war with someone
17:24somewhere.
17:25And I think the most likely candidate is China.
17:28And a war with China is the last thing anyone in their right mind wants.
17:31It doesn't make any sense, and it's unnecessary.
17:34But to do this, he's got to acknowledge what Iran has done.
17:38And he's got to also acknowledge that the country most likely to control the Straits in the future is Iran,
17:46just as Turkey controls the Straits of the Dardanelles.
17:50Same reason, same rationale.
17:52Turkey is the dominant power in the eastern Mediterranean.
17:55Iran is the dominant power in the Persian Gulf.
18:01You know, you've mentioned now on more than one occasion today the role of China.
18:06Just to put it in some context, Colonel McGregor, China accounts for about $32.5 billion worth of Iranian oil
18:15exports, representing roughly 90.8% of the total, averaging around 1,460,000 barrels per day.
18:22Do you believe that, therefore, any blockade of the Straits of Hormuz you see as a red rag to the
18:28Chinese, who are already in discussion with the Russians to try and bring an end to this blockade?
18:34Oh, absolutely.
18:36In fact, long before this war started, President Xi and his foreign minister both pleaded with Donald Trump to seriously
18:45reconsider the wisdom of employing military power against Iran.
18:50We didn't listen.
18:51China has always argued against the use of military power in the Gulf.
18:57For that matter, so has India, very wisely.
19:00None of this was necessary.
19:02This was all done at the behest of Israel and its agents in the United States.
19:07This is not in the American interest.
19:10So now what do we do?
19:12China has a great deal to lose.
19:14But China is already searching for and finding alternatives to supplement what it needs for its scientific industrial base.
19:24Russia will double down and provide more oil than it ever has before, obviously, to China, but so will other
19:29countries.
19:30But that's not enough, and that's not a long-term solution.
19:33So again, you need to end the conflict.
19:36There needs to be a great power conference.
19:38We need to come up with a new arrangement, a new convention for the Persian Gulf.
19:43We need to recognize this is a multipolar world.
19:47We are not the only game in town.
19:49We behave as though we're the center of the universe.
19:52We are not.
19:52This is the problem.
19:57You know, you're putting it very succinctly and very, you know, straight, you're shooting straight from the hip.
20:05But the Chinese reportedly, according to some reports, are also supplying potentially military hardware to the Iranians.
20:12Do you go along with those reports?
20:14Is China already in some form or the other involved in this conflict?
20:20Well, so are the Russians.
20:21The Russians have provided technical support and assistance, particularly with radars and missiles, so have the Chinese.
20:28And I'm not surprised by that.
20:30No one should be.
20:31We have been trying to build up a Ukrainian force inside Ukraine whose entire purpose was to destroy Russia.
20:39That has failed.
20:40But the Russians haven't forgotten what we did.
20:43Neither have the Chinese.
20:44The Chinese look at Iran and ask the following question.
20:48If the Americans are allowed to destroy Iran, even at the expense of the entire world, what will the Americans
20:55do to harm us over Taiwan?
20:58Now, if Taiwan is allowed to, it will vote itself into China eventually.
21:02That's quite clear.
21:03But we have made it clear that we want somehow or another to keep Taiwan out of China.
21:08So the Chinese have said, well, if we're going to help anybody, we better help the Iranians.
21:12And if we can help them and stop this madness now, then we can avoid future conflict with the United
21:18States.
21:19But I don't think anybody bargained for a naval blockade.
21:22And naval blockades are very, very risky affairs.
21:25It's very easy to get into a fight, sink the wrong vessel, and suddenly you find you're at war.
21:31And most of our major wars have begun at sea with naval forces.
21:36We are, after all, a global maritime and aerospace power.
21:39We are not a global land power.
21:41That's why we have an army that's far too small to mount any significant operations against Iran.
21:51So what you're saying, just as there are dangers in a ground invasion, which was being talked about a couple
21:56of weeks ago,
21:57there are serious dangers in trying to enforce a naval blockade, particularly because these ships will carry flags of different
22:04countries.
22:04And you cannot, you believe, enforce a blockade of this kind in an area as sensitive as the Strait of
22:13Hormuz at the moment.
22:14Am I broadly correct?
22:16Yes, and remember that anything that comes within 500 to 800 miles of the Strait of Hormuz can be targeted
22:24and attacked by the Iranians.
22:26For ships, that's deadly.
22:28Very easy to sink a destroyer.
22:30And they've already damaged many of our ships.
22:32So this is not an easy operation.
22:35And if you can't get closer to the Strait of Hormuz, what makes you think you can open it?
22:41And the answer is you can't.
22:42But here's the worst part.
22:43If we proceed down this road, in another week, the ceasefire will end and the war will resume.
22:51And when that resumes, the Iranians will do what they've said they will do.
22:55They will destroy all the remaining oil infrastructure on the western coast of the Gulf.
23:01That will put the Gulf out of reach for us for perhaps five to ten years, maybe longer.
23:07People are not going to go back into that area and rebuild.
23:10You are not going to get insurance organizations, corporations to underwrite shipping as long as the Strait of Hormuz is
23:17at the center of conflict.
23:19This needs to end.
23:21President Trump needs to be made to understand.
23:27So are you saying that you have very little hope that this ceasefire will now last?
23:32Do you fear the worst that post-April 22nd, given the belligerent position particularly Israel is taking and Donald Trump
23:39at the moment?
23:39Or do you believe all of this is posturing that eventually Donald Trump has to pull back, like it or
23:45not?
23:46I think eventually he does have to pull back, like it or not, or he will be removed from office.
23:52But as far as the Israelis are concerned, they want the complete destruction of Iran and the Iranian state.
23:59They want total domination of the region.
24:03And they have already said that Turkey is increasingly at least as dangerous, if not more dangerous, than Iran.
24:10So backing Israel at this stage means perpetual war.
24:13We have no interest that justifies that.
24:16Americans are not interested in this war.
24:19Americans are not interested in depriving anyone around the world from the oil resources they need and the petroleum products
24:25they need.
24:26So I think it's time for someone on the Hill, in the Congress, which is sat quietly taking money from
24:33Israel, and get down to the tough facts.
24:37Either President Trump stops or we remove him.
24:44In conclusion, one of those tough facts, General McGregor, is what started off about Iran's nuclear arsenal has become about
24:52the weaponization of the Strait of Hormuz.
24:54It almost seems as if the goalposts have completely changed.
24:58And that is part of the bizarreness of what we've seen over the last 40 days.
25:03Well, we also weaponized the financial system against the world.
25:07It's been weaponized against you, against China, against all countries, against the whole global South.
25:13We have been brutalizing and bullying people for years.
25:17This has got to stop.
25:18Now you're making smart moves.
25:21You have accumulated large quantities of gold.
25:23So has China.
25:24So has Russia.
25:25Russia, increasingly bricks, of which you are a critical part, are ultimately going to become gold-backed currency.
25:33In other words, they will become a serious economic player.
25:37What we have done, what the United States has done under Trump, is we have marginalized ourselves.
25:42We have done to ourselves what no one else could do.
25:45So my point is, either we stop this quickly and we recover over the next few years, or we persist,
25:53and it'll take us a decade to recover.
25:55Everyone, me as well as you.
25:57Our prices, by the way, for fuel oil are up 21%.
26:01We haven't seen anything like this since 1967.
26:08So in conclusion, 30 seconds, if you had a tweet to give Donald Trump as a counter-tweet to what
26:14he said, what would you tell him?
26:15What is that one piece of advice you would give the U.S. president today?
26:20As the person who describes himself as the leader of the quote-unquote free world, he has a responsibility, indeed
26:28an obligation, to end this conflict as soon as possible, to let the strait reopen on its own and allow
26:36oil to be transferred to the countries it desperately needed.
26:39In other words, he should be interested in protecting and nurturing commerce for international prosperity.
26:46At the same time, he should offer to sit down, along with all the other great powers, and come up
26:52with a new convention for the Strait of Hormuz, similar to the convention, the Montrose Convention, which governs the Dardanelles
27:01Strait.
27:05Okay, I'm going to leave it there, Gunan McGregor.
27:08As always, as I said, for bringing your clarity, speaking your mind out, appreciate you joining me here on the
27:14news today.
27:15Thanks very much.
27:19So how will Tehran now respond to Trump's decision to blockade ships entering or exiting the Strait of Hormuz?
27:27Joining me now, another special guest, Professor Alex Watanka, a senior fellow at the Iran Center of the Middle East
27:34Institute in Washington, D.C., someone who knows Tehran very well.
27:38He's been born in Tehran.
27:40Appreciate, Professor Watanka, you joining us.
27:42How do you see Iran responding?
27:45As of now, they're making it very clear that they see this blockade as an act of aggression being committed
27:51by Washington.
27:52But what are Iran's realistic options?
27:56It's great to be with you.
27:57Look, I agree.
27:58I think the Iranian side will look at this issue of a blockade of Iranian ports as an act of
28:07aggression.
28:08And we've already heard that they are retaliating or they're promising to retaliate in kind.
28:13I think the Trump administration had this card.
28:16They could have played it later.
28:18I think they are playing the blockade card too prematurely, simply because the talks in Islamabad, while they were not
28:25successful, they left the door for diplomacy open.
28:28And I would have played something like this card, blockading Iranian ports later on if diplomacy started looking like it
28:35was impossible to achieve anything.
28:37But we're not there yet.
28:38Diplomacy has just started at the highest level since 1979.
28:42So I think the Trump administration played this a bit prematurely.
28:47And I think they're still in the belief that the Iranian side only responds to threats and pressure, which is
28:54true to some extent.
28:55But as I said, we are where we are.
28:59We haven't really yet seen if this is going to be escalation that can be rolled back.
29:05I hope it can be rolled back.
29:06But obviously, both sides are still very much busy trying to posture and show the other side that they're not
29:13ready to cave in.
29:15But essentially, caving in and compromising is exactly what we need for some kind of deal to be reached.
29:24What we've seen, Professor Valanka, right through this conflict is tit for tat.
29:31What is Iran's likely response, given the fact that if this blockade continues, what are Iran's realistic options here?
29:42Well, the Iranians are saying if they cannot sell anything out of their ports, then nobody from the region can
29:47sell anything to the world from their ports.
29:49But basically, with the situation, with the energy crisis, the food crisis, it's just going to get even worse.
29:55And in a worst-case scenario, you could maybe see a situation where we have another crisis emerging nearby in
30:01Bab al-Mandeb,
30:02with the Houthis stopping to flow into the Red Sea of traffic, of shipping.
30:08And the Red Sea, as we know, is about 12% of global trade goes through the Red Sea.
30:12So, you know, I'm hoping we're not going to get there, because the world doesn't want to see that.
30:16And I'm hoping Iran and U.S. are still posturing to sort of show up in the next round of
30:22diplomatic talks,
30:23should they happen to get the best deal they can have.
30:26But right now, they have to soften their positions.
30:29Both of them have maximalist demands that are unrealistic.
30:32And if they can do that, then hopefully talk of blockading the ports of Iran and so forth
30:39will just be that talk and not much action.
30:42But obviously, we've seen both Iran and U.S., as you pointed out, engage in tit-for-tat for 40
30:47days of war,
30:48so they could continue that as well.
30:53I just want to understand, who is taking the decisions in Tehran, according to you, Professor Watanka?
31:00Because it was Mohamed Bagheir Galibaf, the parliamentary speaker who led the negotiations to Islamabad.
31:06Is he the one taking the calls?
31:09Is it the IRGC leadership which is taking the calls, even after several of their top commanders have been assassinated
31:15in the fighting?
31:17Is it the foreign minister?
31:19Who is really taking these big calls of how to respond to what the United States is doing?
31:25Yeah, I think it's a mistake for us to look for one individual or one group of people and say
31:31they are the key decision makers.
31:32Right now, decisions in Iran are being made collectively by different factions.
31:38The most important one, the Revolutionary Guards, Galibaf, comes from that school.
31:43But you've got also the diplomatic cadre of Araqchi, the foreign minister, and others.
31:48But it's a mistake to look at one individual.
31:50What we can say for sure is the Iranian side overwhelmingly want a diplomatic solution to this crisis,
31:57and that in itself is very good news.
32:02But do they have time on their side?
32:04Do you believe the Iranians have time on their side?
32:07Given that they've suffered pretty heavy bombardment, can they afford more days of bombardment along with the blockade?
32:13Israel again is threatening to once again carry out strikes.
32:18Does Iran really have time on their side or is this pure posturing?
32:23Remember the deadline itself, Professor, expires on the 22nd of April for the ceasefire.
32:28Do you see Iran holding out at least till then?
32:32Well, it's what they think.
32:34And they think time is on their side.
32:36It's not what I think or what the Americans think.
32:38They think.
32:39The Iranian side clearly thinks time is on their side.
32:42They say they have much more to gain by not giving up now that they have now shown that nobody
32:49can defeat the Islamic Republic militarily and that they have been sanctioned for decades.
32:53They have paid hundreds of billion dollars in damages over decades.
32:58They can continue to do that for a few more months and years as long as they can get what
33:03they think is their right, which is, in this case, enrichment of uranium and so forth.
33:07But I think they feel that they're in a good place to engage in a war of attrition.
33:12And they consider the American president, Donald Trump, as someone who wants to get out of this war.
33:17He wants to focus on other things like the World Cup, like upcoming elections in the United States.
33:21And not to mention, this is the year the United States is celebrating 250 years of the American Republic.
33:27I don't think Donald Trump wants to go into that celebration with a big war at least.
33:32So that's how the Iranians look at it.
33:34They could easily be wrong.
33:35They have miscalculated with Trump before.
33:38They could miscalculate again.
33:39But as of today, I think they think time is on their side and they're not ready to just give
33:44everything away just because Donald Trump says so.
33:51There are two aspects, of course, critical to the Iranians.
33:54One is dismantling of their nuclear infrastructure, which they've said is unacceptable to them.
34:00The other is the Strait of Hormuz.
34:02They want to retain their territorial sovereignty over it.
34:06Which of these do you believe the Iranians could blink at?
34:09Or are these two simply non-negotiables from an Iranian perspective?
34:14Well, look, one is a short-term issue.
34:16One is a long-term issue.
34:17The short-term issue is obviously Strait of Hormuz.
34:19Because the world is feeling the pain because of the blockade or what Iran is doing, hijacking the traffic at
34:27the Strait.
34:28So that's a short-term issue.
34:30The Iranians have put that up front and center in their demand so far in Islamabad and even before Islamabad
34:37talks.
34:38So I suspect they want something in return.
34:40They have mentioned a couple of things that are important.
34:43One is unfreezing of AmericanтАФI'm sorry, of Iranian assets around the world, $100 to $120 billion.
34:49And then they are trying to get the Israelis to back off from attacking Lebanon, which is another Iranian red
34:55line.
34:55So that's in the short term.
34:57Going forward long-term, the nuclear issueтАФIran's nuclear program right now is not a threat to the United States.
35:02It's not a problem for tomorrow or next week or next month.
35:06It will be a problem if Iran has gone back to rebuilding.
35:09And again, they want something in return for that.
35:11And that's why diplomacy is so critical, that Iran can prove that it's a civilian program and not aimed at
35:19a nuclear weapon, as Trump fears it is.
35:23Okay, I'm going to leave it there.
35:25Very fascinating listening to you, Professor Watanka.
35:28You are with the Iran Center, the Middle East Institute.
35:31I appreciate you joining me here on the news today.
35:39So what does this blockade, this proposed blockade, naval blockade by President Trump mean for us in India?
35:46That's what I want to turn to.
35:47First, let's get some hard details.
35:49Crude oil shipments, listen carefully, passing through the Straits of Hormuz are heavily directed towards Asia.
35:56For us, that is the main route for our oil supplies.
35:59China is the largest recipient at about 4.6 million barrels per day.
36:05India follows next, 2.1 billion dollars per day, while other, about 80% of our oil comes through it.
36:11While other Asian nations collectively account for the biggest share at around 6.2 million barrels per day.
36:18And that includes, remember, Japan.
36:21In contrast, much smaller volumes go to the other countries.
36:24Europe receives approximately 0.6 million barrels.
36:28The Americas about 0.5 million barrels.
36:30Africa, the least at roughly 0.2 million barrels per day.
36:35Overall, the data highlights that a vast majority of the oil transported through this critical choke point.
36:42And the big leverage that Iran now has is destined for Asian markets.
36:48I'm joined at this moment by another special guest, Ambassador Navdeep Suri, former Indian Ambassador to UAE, Egypt and Australia.
36:56Appreciate you joining us.
36:58Mr. Suri, what are you making out of Donald Trump's naval blockade in the context of India specifically at the
37:04very outset?
37:05Is this something that we should be raising our voice and saying, sorry, Mr. Trump, you cannot hold just as
37:12the Iranians are being accused of a chokehold.
37:14You can't respond with a naval blockade that will only escalate and worsen the problems that countries like India face,
37:22particularly with oil supplies.
37:24We should, we must, whether we do it publicly or we do it privately is a different matter.
37:30And that's something that our tactics or our approach on diplomacy will decide.
37:36But there's no doubt that right from the attack launched by Israel and the United States on the 28th of
37:42February, our vital national interests have been hurt badly by this unwanted and illegal war.
37:49And so we are, we have every right to protest.
37:54And what you're seeing, Rajdeep, is really an utter breakdown of the international order.
38:01Americans used to talk about the rules-based order.
38:04And today, the wantonness with which it is being flouted by the Americans, by the Israelis, by the Iranians, doesn't
38:14leave very much left.
38:17So just as the Iranian attempt to blockade Hormuz is illegal, and I know your previous speaker, Rajdeep, was speaking
38:30about possible comparisons with the Montrose Protocol and the Strait of Dardanelles, which cuts through the Bosphorus.
38:39You have Turkey on both sides on that.
38:41So to that extent, it has a different status that on either side of the straits is Turkey.
38:47Here, you have an international waterway with Oman on one side and Iran on the other.
38:54And if you allow Iran to get away with this notion of a toll gate, then think the consequences at
39:02Malacca, at Sunda, at Gibraltar, at all of these other international choke points which are so crucial to international commerce.
39:10And that's why you have the UN Convention of the Law of the Sea, to enable that commerce to happen.
39:16So I really hope that we raise our voice on both, on the Iranian closure and on the American blockade
39:25or the plans to blockade it, which are going to be terrible from our point of view.
39:30You'll see oil prices go up immediately.
39:36You know, you're making an important point.
39:37You're saying India has to speak out both against Iran, trying to use the Strait of Hormuz as a toll
39:43gate, and you've got to speak out against the United States, trying to enforce a naval blockade.
39:48We've already seen the British Prime Minister, Mr. Starmer, today speak out strongly on it.
39:53We've seen Australia and its foreign ministry speak out strongly on it, that they are opposed to this blockade.
39:58Should we be, in your view, therefore, being a little bit more willing now to tell both Tehran and Washington
40:05enough is enough?
40:07Are we in a position, in your view, to do that in our, is it in our national interest to
40:12speak out at this moment and not too late?
40:16Absolutely. Even if it is late, we should still speak up.
40:19It is never too late for that.
40:21And I really think that we are a large country.
40:25For us, no matter whether we get oil from Venezuela or Russia or even from the United States, the most
40:32proximate source of energy for us is the Gulf.
40:35It's just a few days sailing from any of the ports in the Gulf to our West Coast, and our
40:41refineries are geared for that.
40:43So, and it isn't just, Rajdeep, I should add, when you talk about a blockade by Iran or by the
40:50United States, it isn't just what is coming out.
40:52It's also what's going in, right?
40:55All of these countries around the Gulf are heavily dependent on food, imported food grains and other stuff.
41:02Our basmati shipments, I know from Punjab, are completely stranded today.
41:06Tens of thousands of tons are stranded because they can't get through.
41:10Our exporters are suffering as well.
41:12So, it's not just the energy shock for the Indian economy, but also what the exporters are going through.
41:17Because remember, the GCC is our largest single trading partner.
41:23UAE alone, with $100 billion of two-way trade, is our third largest trading partner after the United States and
41:29China.
41:30And today, those markets are choked for our exporters.
41:37Out of this, you know, I want to understand, Mr. Suri, though, the GCC countries, you've been an ambassador and
41:45served in UAE.
41:46You've seen Iran drop their missiles on UAE, on Kuwait, on Qatar, on Saudi Arabia, on Bahrain.
41:55Do you believe that these countries will also now speak out because they also stand to lose out, both from
42:02the toll gate that Iran imposes if they do one, and from the blockade?
42:06Should there therefore be now a more concerted effort to try and ensure that this conflict does not just spiral
42:14out of control once again?
42:16Some of them are speaking up.
42:18The Emiratis have probably been the most vociferous about it.
42:22And their CEO of ADNOC, Dr. Sultan Jabbar, has gone ahead and said that Iran doesn't own the strait.
42:30It's an international waterway.
42:32The Qataris are upset as well.
42:34But I think we are some distance away from a concerted or coordinated GCC approach because there are intersea differences
42:44between the GCC member states in terms of how aggressive they wish to be against Iran.
42:51There's one school of thought which says that this is not our war.
42:54And if we get into it with a larger, more powerful neighbor, understanding that the United States will back us
43:02up, well, they've had a reality check on that, that the U.S. can walk away at any point of
43:07time, leaving them high and dry against a wounded and angry neighbor.
43:13On the other hand, they are also concerned that if Iran is weakened by this continuing offensive to a point
43:20where Israel emerges as the regional hegemon, and given how belligerent it has been in attacking half a dozen countries
43:30over the last year, and how expansionist it seems to be with Lebanon, Syria, and other places, there is a
43:38genuine concern, which is worse for us?
43:40Is it a belligerent and expansionist Israel, which is unchallenged regional power, or is it an unstable and unpredictable Iran?
43:49And these are real dilemmas for them.
43:54Right. I'm going to leave it there, Nadeem Suri.
43:58I think you've put it in some kind of context for our viewers, particularly of the need why India must
44:03speak up at this moment.
44:05Thank you very much for joining me.
44:06And one of the reasons we must speak up is because what we are doing is a costs of war
44:11series.
44:11It's not making the headlines, but it is there on the ground.
44:14Now, even in Mumbai, the real estate sector facing a serious setback as labor shortage is hitting construction sites in
44:22the city.
44:22Rising cooking gas prices, expensive food, and even migration linked to elections in states like West Bengal are forcing workers
44:30to return home.
44:31Take a look at tonight's cost of war package.
44:56The construction activity in Mumbai is slowing down, not due to lack of projects,
45:02but due to severe shortage of workers.
45:07Builders say the situation is unprecedented.
45:21At some sites, only a handful of workers remain.
45:49Added to the problem, the cost of raw materials has surged.
45:54With labor shortages, the cost of raw materials has surged.
45:55And rising costs hitting the sector simultaneously, delays in project delivery now seem inevitable.
46:01With Mustafa Sheikh, Bureau Report, India Today.
46:06India bid farewell today to the one and only Asha Bhosle.
46:11The most amazing, versatile singer Asha Bhosle, who passed away yesterday, was today cremated with full state honors at the
46:19Shivaji Park Crematorium in Mumbai.
46:22Several actors, music composers, and indeed politicians and public figures were there as Asha Bhosle was given full state honors.
46:32Remember, she's a Padma Vibhushan and someone who dazzled with her music and her sheer range of songs for several
46:40decades.
46:41With her passing away, Indian music has fallen silent in a way because she was part of what is often
46:49described as the golden generation of Indian music.
46:53I want to, at this point, pay a special tribute.
46:56And joining me now to pay that is Shamir Tandan, his music composer and one of the last people to
47:02record with Asha Bhosle.
47:04I'll ask my producer to slightly put the volume of the music down.
47:08But Shamir, you tell us, what was Asha Bhosle like?
47:13You, in a recent blog, have called her I, which is a mother.
47:17What was she like for many of the younger music composers?
47:22Well, Rajdeep, I must say that she took a promise from me as early as last week that she wants
47:31to exit.
47:32And when she moves on to the other side, we should all smile and happily bid her farewell and celebrate
47:40her music more than a life, which, of course, had its own traumas, but a musical career.
47:47So, that's why today I stand robust and I speak for her.
47:52Well, I was a managing director of a very big multinational corporation by Richard Branson.
47:57And she was the one who converted me from a managing director to a music director.
48:03And hence, she is an I for me.
48:05In fact, she's almost, I mean, she's always treated me as a son.
48:11I have spent a lot of time and I have learned life lessons from her and management lessons from her,
48:16which no business school taught me, including my visit to Boston before I turned a composer.
48:21Well, what I learned from her is what she used to tell me, you know, Shamir Panchamda, which I used
48:26to tell me, you know, Shamir Panchamda, which I always said, that if you're going to be able to understand
48:29the technology, you're not going to be outdated.
48:33That's why I recorded her song in the page screen.
48:36She was in San Francisco back in 2003.
48:38There were no Zoom calls like this.
48:40But I sent her some files on an email and she sang,
48:47And she sent multiple files.
48:49And when I, when she came back from Frisco and I did Sashal Namaskar to her and I asked her
48:54why for an income poop, a newcomer, did you sing?
48:56You know, sitting there, you could have just told me, no, it's just a small film called Vesri, why I
49:01lend my voice.
49:03But she said that Panchamda had said that Asha, till your last breath, you need to update yourself with technology.
49:11And even at 92, she would have discussions with me on copyrights and royalties and AI and podcasts and so
49:18be it.
49:19You know, I mean, and I was fortunate that two weeks ago I recorded a song with her.
49:28Go ahead, go ahead, complete.
49:29I said, I was fortunate a few weeks ago to have recorded a song with her written by the exemplary
49:35Prasoon Joshi,
49:37which is a song which she actually relates to, related to, because it said,
49:42Jane do, jane do, thud se milna hai, ab jane do.
49:49Na roko na toko, ab bas jane do.
49:52I want to ask you though, you, you know, I have to ask you because I have prepared today the
50:01fact of my Asha Bosley favorites.
50:03I was on a flight and this is just a selection.
50:05I could pick many, many more songs because from gazelle to pop, she masters all genres.
50:11So I'm going to relate my top 11 and then you can tell me your top three.
50:16Think about it, but look at my top 11 and I've chosen songs, which I believe in some instances,
50:22no one else could have sung.
50:23Pia tu ab to aja, Karwa, Helen, R.D. Burman, Monica, oh my darling.
50:29You know, that entire song was magic.
50:31Rat Akeli hai, composed by S.D. Burman, absolute magic in terms of haunting music, jewel thief.
50:38Diwana Hua Badal, my favorite all-time duet, Kashmir Ki Kali with Mohamed Rafi.
50:43Abhi Na Jao, chhodke from Hum Dono, another duet with Rafi Saab, Jai Dev's music, classic again.
50:51Churaliya hai, tumne jo dil ko, yadu ki bharatma entire generation grew up on Zinat Aman, listening to that song.
50:59Mera Kuch Saman, tumhare paas padha hai, she won a national award for it, penned by Gulzhar Saab and R
51:05.D.
51:05That's the ultimate triumvirate.
51:08Paan Ghaiyo Sahiya from Tisri Kasm, because just the different nature of that song.
51:13Dam Maro Dam, Hare Ram, Hare Krishna, captured the sort of early 1970s again with Zinat Aman.
51:20Aaja Aaja, mein huu piyaar tera, from Tisri Manzil, a classic again.
51:26And she was, you know, able to do all the kind of yodeling and other things that was required.
51:31In Aakho Ki Masti, classic gazal, Umrao Jaan, penned by, composed by Khayam Saab.
51:37And finally, duniya mein, logo ko, you know, I just played a video of that earlier today on Twitter with
51:44R.D. and her.
51:45Out of all these songs, what for you is a song that defined Aasha?
51:49Is there a song that, in your view, defined who Aasha Bhosle was?
51:55Rajdeep, you allow me to say, to speak my heart.
51:58While these are, of course, the songs which are the songs that define generations galore.
52:05But I must say that she narrated an instance to me when she was doing an album with Ghulam Ali.
52:13And she said, you know, Pakistan ke itne diggach kalakar aare hai hai, to mujhe bhi dikhana padega ki mai
52:20ek mangesh kar hun.
52:21Aur mujhe, and we all know, and hum mazak karte thee ki, you ate all those people for breakfast when
52:29you actually sang.
52:30Similarly, when she sang with Musrat Pateli Khan, po kacche dhaage, you know, she was very nervous.
52:36She would tell me ki, ye sab bade-bade khasab aare hai, or hum Marathi hai, aur unko pata nahi
52:40wo kis tarikaya ki Urdu ko leker aayenge,
52:42kya hum usko nipha pahenge mukammal taur se.
52:44And she said, but then I went and I just prayed to God and I prayed to my own sister
52:49and I said,
52:49Didi, give me that ashirwaad that today I go and ram that song.
52:54And we all know that when she sang duets with all these people on the other side of the border
52:59also,
53:00she actually ate them all for breakfast.
53:06You know, so she, in a way what you are saying, her genius was that she could adjust from the,
53:12from 1943 she sang her first song at the age of 10.
53:16She sung bhajan, she sung gazal, she sung kawali, she sung disco, she sung pop.
53:22There's nothing that she didn't do in every language and that in a way makes her so remarkable.
53:28Shami Tandan, for sharing some of those memories, including that last recording that you had with Asha Bosley,
53:34the one and only Asha Bosley, I had the privilege of interviewing her as she turned 90 in August 2024.
53:40I will never forget that experience.
53:42And I only want to say to Asha Thay, you know, what people don't know is you were a great
53:47singer,
53:47but you were also someone who cooked the best prawn curry rice that I knew of.
53:52And I will leave you with a song, my friends, today.
53:55A song that for me typified Asha's just range.
54:01Because she had that range, which no other singer had.
54:08Good night, good bye, thank you for the memories.
54:12Bye for now, listen to me.
54:26Bye for now, listen to me.
54:44Bye for now, listen to me.
55:14Bye for now, listen to me.
55:18Bye for now, listen to me.
Comments