- 7 months ago
The latest episode of Statecraft examines Pakistan's attempt to mediate ceasefire negotiations between the United States and Iran.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:22Hello and welcome. You're watching Statecraft with me, Geeta Mohan.
00:25Now, can one man turn diplomacy into power or end up risking both at the same time?
00:30And while global leaders scramble to control wars and negotiations,
00:34is an entirely different force quietly reshaping politics from the ground up?
00:39Tonight, two stories that seem worlds apart but are deeply connected.
00:44One is high stakes, personality driven and unfolding at the top.
00:48The other is leaderless, explosive and rising from the streets.
00:54Pakistan's Asim Muneer is trying to position himself at the centre of a global crisis.
00:58But as Iran plays hardball, that gamble is beginning to crack.
01:03And then shift your focus.
01:05Last year, protests erupted across the world, led by a generation often dismissed as passive.
01:11From Nepal to Peru, young people took to streets,
01:14not for trends but to challenge entrenched ageing administrations.
01:19But one year later, we ask, was this a turning point or just a moment?
01:25Did these protests actually bring change or did the system hold its ground?
01:29A global uprising now facing its verdict.
01:33One story of control at the top, the other of rebellion from below.
01:37All that and more, but first up, the headlines.
01:41As the two-week ceasefire ends on Wednesday, Iran plays hardball in participating in the second round of talks in
01:48Islamabad.
01:48Meanwhile, the U.S. is sending a delegation to Pakistan headed by Vice President J.D. Vance.
01:54Vance is expected to arrive in Islamabad any time.
01:58President Trump lashed out at the media in a post on Truth Social saying,
02:03Israel never talked me into the war with Iran.
02:05U.S.'s war on Iran has come under heavy criticism,
02:09with many suggesting that Israel led the U.S. into the war against Iran.
02:14Pakistan's Federal Interior Minister Mawseem Nakwee has met Iran's Ambassador Reza Amri Moghaddam
02:19to review preparations for the second phase of Islamabad talks.
02:23Though Iran said it will not attend the second round of talks,
02:26as Nakwee says, arrangements have been finalized with foolproof security in place for visiting delegations.
02:42Ahead of the second round of talks between U.S. and Iran,
02:44there are various conflicting reports of Vice President Vance's visit to Islamabad.
02:49As Iran plays the hardball, some reports suggest that U.S. VP J.D. Vance
02:54has not yet left Washington, while some other reports suggest that he will be landing in Pakistan anytime soon.
03:01Meanwhile, Iran has not yet confirmed about its delegation visiting Pakistan for a second round of talks.
03:11Earlier, I spoke in an exclusive conversation with Daria Safai.
03:14She's a member of the Belgian Parliament, delegation leader to NATO Parliamentary Assembly,
03:18and a women's rights activist.
03:20I asked her about the geopolitical times that we're living in,
03:23and what does she make of the talks between the U.S. and Iran on the West Asia crisis
03:30that is unfolding right ahead of us.
03:32You can watch the full interview on India Today Global's YouTube channel, but here is her answer.
03:40So, what is very important to know that is, right now, there is a big quarrel inside the regime of
03:47Islamic Republic of Iran.
03:48There are people who are for this negotiations, and there are people who are against it,
03:57and that's what makes it very fragile.
03:59But anyway, it's like it has been such a 47 years that the world is trying to find a way
04:06by diplomacy negotiations,
04:08and this regime has shown us that there is nothing possible through diplomacy,
04:16because they are a regime which inherently, they are naturally against the Western countries and against Israel.
04:24So, their mindset doesn't accept to sit even at the same table with America,
04:32which such a 47 years they have called great, great Satan.
04:38So, that's the problem, and that's the only reason that they are now saying we don't come to the negotiations.
04:46They use several attacks or whatever as an excuse.
04:50But the real thing is, inside Iran, there are extremists, Islamists, which they don't want that the government goes and
05:00talk to this great Satan America,
05:03which has killed their leader, Khamenei.
05:07So, this is unforgivable sin that the America, in their eyes, has done, and so they don't accept these negotiations.
05:16And anyway, in the nature, from the nature, the Islamic Republic is against Israel and Western countries,
05:23and wants to make them finish in the whole world, so they cannot accept such a thing for the long
05:32term.
05:34Pakistan is now at the center of one of the most dangerous diplomatic gambles of this decade,
05:38the second round of U.S.-Iran ceasefire talks called the Islamabad talks, which are expected to be held in Pakistan.
05:46And it is no longer just another negotiation.
05:49It is a make-or-break moment, a do-or-die test for Field Marshal Aasem Muneer.
05:54And who made that very clear?
05:56None other than the President of the United States of America.
05:59President Trump, in a post, said that Aasem Muneer will have to deliver.
06:05The man who tried to position himself as the bridge between Washington and Tehran
06:09is now at risk of being seen as the reason that bridge collapses.
06:14Because the reality is shifting past, publicly, firmly.
06:19Iran arm-twisting America to attend or not to attend the next round of talks in Pakistan
06:25has put Aasem Muneer in a tizzy.
06:27No delegation, no timeline, no commitment.
06:30And that changes everything.
06:32Because diplomacy does not fail quietly, it fails visibly.
06:37And when talks collapse on your soil, the failure carries your name.
06:42For weeks, Pakistan projected itself as the indispensable mediator,
06:47a country uniquely placed with access to both sides,
06:50a military chief with direct lines into Washington,
06:53and reported personal connections inside Iran's security establishment.
06:57It looked like strategic brilliance, but now that same positioning is becoming a liability.
07:04Because mediation is not about access, it is about outcomes.
07:08It is about outcomes, and so far, the outcomes are collapsing.
07:12The first ceasefire held briefly, but it was fragile from the start.
07:17Temporary, conditional, built on unresolved tensions over Iran's nuclear program
07:22and control of the Strait of Hormuz.
07:25The fundamentals were never settled, only postponed.
07:29And now the postponement is over.
07:32Iran is pushing back, hard.
07:34It is rejecting negotiations under pressure,
07:37rejecting what it calls unrealistic demands,
07:40and most importantly, rejecting the venue, Pakistan itself.
07:44That is not just a diplomatic setback, it is a direct signal.
07:48A loss of confidence in the process and the mediator.
07:54This is where the crisis deepens for Asim Muneer,
07:56because he did not just host the talks, he owned them.
08:00He led their back channel, he inserted Pakistan's military,
08:03not its civilian government, into the centre of global diplomacy.
08:06And that raised the stakes, dramatically.
08:10Because when you centralise diplomacy around one figure,
08:14success becomes personal, and so does failure.
08:17If the second round collapses completely,
08:20the question will not just be why talks failed,
08:23the question will be whether Muneer overplayed his hand,
08:26and the question will be asked by President Trump himself.
08:30There are already signs of that.
08:32Pakistan does not have the leverage to force concessions from either side.
08:37It cannot compel Iran to negotiate,
08:39it cannot dictate terms to the United States of America.
08:42It can host, it can facilitate, but it cannot enforce.
08:47And in high-stakes conflicts, facilitation without leverage has limits.
08:53And those limits are now visible.
08:55Iran's refusal is not happening in isolation.
08:57It comes amid continued U.S. pressure,
09:01naval deployments, strategic signalling,
09:03and actions that Tehran sees as coercive.
09:06In that environment, talks in Pakistan begin to look less like neutral diplomacy,
09:11and more like negotiation under imbalance.
09:14Which raises a deeper question.
09:17Was Pakistan ever truly neutral in the eyes of Iran?
09:20Or was it always seen as leaning towards the U.S. and its regional partners?
09:25Because perception in diplomacy is everything.
09:28And once trust erodes, the entire framework collapses.
09:33That is why this moment is so critical,
09:36not just for the war, but for Pakistan's global positioning.
09:40Because Islamabad tried to convert a crisis into influence,
09:44to transform itself into a geopolitical power broker.
09:48But now, it risks being reduced to something else entirely.
09:51A venue without authority, a mediator without credibility.
09:56And that is the danger of high-visibility diplomacy.
09:59If it works, you gain stature.
10:01If it fails, you lose relevance.
10:04There is no middle ground.
10:06And right now, Pakistan is sliding toward the latter.
10:10But the story does not end there.
10:12Because while Pakistan struggles to keep the talks alive,
10:16another contradiction is emerging.
10:18This time, inside Washington itself.
10:20On one side, there is Donald Trump,
10:23openly praising Asa Munir,
10:25calling him his favorite field marshal,
10:27signaling trust, signaling personal rapport.
10:30A relationship that appears strong, even strategic.
10:34But on the other side, there is growing unease
10:37within sections of the U.S. national security establishment,
10:40intelligence circles, policy analysts, strategic think tanks.
10:45And their concerns are not about personality.
10:48They are about proximity.
10:50Because according to multiple reports and assessments,
10:53Asa Munir's ties to Iran's military leadership,
10:56that's the IRGC, are now under scrutiny.
10:58Not casual contacts, not occasional diplomacy,
11:02but reported long-standing relationships with key figures
11:06inside Iran's security structure.
11:09And that is where the contradiction sharpens.
11:12Because the same man acting as Washington's back channel to Tehran
11:16is also someone reported to have deep familiarity
11:19with Tehran's power structure that makes Washington uncomfortable.
11:25For some U.S. officials, that is not an advantage.
11:28It is a red flag.
11:30Because diplomacy relies on trust,
11:33but intelligence operates on suspicion.
11:35And when those two collide,
11:37relationships become complicated.
11:39Very quickly.
11:41Critics argue that Munir's dual access
11:44creates strategic ambiguity.
11:46Is he a conduit for U.S. interests
11:48or an actor balancing multiple relationships
11:51for Pakistan's own positioning?
11:53In geopolitics, ambiguity can be useful,
11:56but it can also be dangerous.
11:59And this concern is not emerging in a vacuum.
12:02It is shaped by history.
12:04Long-standing doubts within Washington and Pakistan's reliability
12:07as a security partner,
12:09especially during the Afghanistan conflict.
12:11For years, U.S. policymakers accused Pakistan
12:14of playing a double game,
12:16receiving American support while tolerating or enabling networks
12:19aligned with the Taliban.
12:21A pattern that created deep mistrust.
12:24And that history is now influencing how current developments are being assessed.
12:30Analysts, including those from the Foundation for Defense of Democracies,
12:35are warning that Pakistan's role should be evaluated cautiously,
12:39not rejected outright,
12:41but not accepted at face value either.
12:43Because in a conflict as volatile as the Iran war,
12:47the margin for miscalculation is extremely small.
12:51A mediator with competing relationships could either stabilize the situation
12:55or complicate it further.
12:58So how do you balance personal trust at the top
13:00with institutional skepticism below it?
13:03Because President Trump's approach is relationship-driven,
13:06direct, personal, transactional.
13:09But national security systems operate differently.
13:12They assess patterns, history, risk.
13:15And right now, those assessments are raising questions.
13:20Is Asim Muneer a valuable diplomatic bridge or a strategic liability?
13:24That question is no longer theoretical.
13:26It is shaping real policy calculations.
13:29Because as the ceasefire talks continue, stall,
13:33or whether if Iran continues to play hardball,
13:36the need for a credible intermediary becomes even more urgent now than ever before.
13:41But credibility is exactly what is now under scrutiny,
13:44which means both storylines are converging into one reality.
13:49The failure of the talks in Pakistan and the growing doubts in Washington
13:53are not separate developments.
13:55They're connected.
13:56The Iran war is already volatile.
13:59Military pressure continues.
14:01Strategic choke points remain contested.
14:03And without a functioning diplomatic channel,
14:06the path toward de-escalation becomes narrower and more uncertain.
14:11So where does this leave Pakistan?
14:13And where does this leave Asim Muneer?
14:16At a crossroads.
14:17A decisive one.
14:19Because the second round of talks is no longer just about peace.
14:22It is about credibility.
14:24About influence.
14:25About whether Pakistan can sustain the role it claimed on the global stage.
14:29If the talks revive and produce results,
14:32Muneer emerges stronger.
14:33A power broker, a mediator, who delivered under pressure.
14:37But if they fail completely, the narrative flips.
14:42From indispensable intermediary to overextended actor.
14:46From strategic bridge to diplomatic risk.
14:48And that is the real story here.
14:50Not just the war, not just the negotiations,
14:54but the high-stakes gamble behind them.
14:56Because in geopolitics, positioning yourself at the center of a crisis
15:01can elevate you or expose you.
15:04There is no safe outcome.
15:06And right now, Asim Muneer is finding that out in real time.
15:11South Korean President Lee Ji Myung is on a state visit to India.
15:14A trip that could reshape the future of ties
15:17as Prime Minister Modi pushes trade, technology,
15:20and strategic cooperation to a new level.
15:22From chips to ships, AI to clean energy,
15:26both sides are now eyeing a $50 billion trade target.
15:30But is this the moment India and South Korea move
15:33from partnership to a true strategic alliance?
15:36Our next report.
15:43For the first time in eight years,
15:45a South Korean President is on a state visit to India.
15:49And this visit could reshape the future of India-South Korea relations.
15:54President Lee Ji Myung arrived in New Delhi for a three-day visit
15:58and held crucial talks with Prime Minister Narendra Modi
16:01at Hyderabad House, with one major goal on the table.
16:05Taking balanced trade from $25 billion to $50 billion by 2030.
16:12But this visit is about much more than trade.
16:15India and South Korea are now looking to upgrade
16:18their comprehensive economic partnership agreement
16:21and deepen cooperation in strategic sectors
16:24like shipbuilding, artificial intelligence,
16:27semiconductors, defense production, finance,
16:31clean energy, and critical technologies.
16:34Why does this matter for India?
16:36Because South Korea sees India not just as a market,
16:39but as a major global production hub
16:42and a trusted strategic partner
16:44in a time of growing global instability.
16:47With tensions in West Asia and disruptions around the Strait of Hormuz
16:52threatening global supply chains,
16:54Seoul is also turning to New Delhi for energy security.
16:57India already supplies nearly 8% of South Korea's NAFTA imports
17:02and that number could rise further.
17:05Shipbuilding is another key area.
17:07India wants jobs and industrial crew,
17:10while South Korea brings world-class expertise
17:13in shipbuilding and advanced manufacturing.
17:15Together, both countries see a major opportunity.
17:20Preston Lee also paid tribute to Mahatma Gandhi at Rajkhan
17:23and received a ceremonial welcome at Rashtrapati Bhavan,
17:27underlining the diplomatic importance of the visit.
17:31And now, the partnership is being backed by concrete action.
17:34Prime Minister Modi announced the launch
17:37of the India-Korea Financial Forum
17:39to improve financial flows between both countries,
17:42along with a new Industrial Cooperation Committee
17:45to strengthen business ties.
17:48As Economic Security Dialogue is also being launched
17:51to boost cooperation in critical technology and supply chains.
17:55To make it easier for Korean companies,
17:57especially small and medium enterprises,
18:00to invest in India,
18:02New Delhi will establish Korean industrial townships
18:05and upgrade the India-Korea trade agreement within the next year.
18:09Modi also unveiled the India-Korea digital bridge,
18:13aimed at deepening partnership in AI,
18:15semiconductors and information technology.
18:18Preston Lee announced another major people-focused step.
18:22India and South Korea will link their electronic payment system,
18:26allowing citizens of both countries
18:28to use local QR code payments while travelling,
18:32making tourism and business travel far more convenient.
18:35Cultural ties are also getting stronger.
18:38With K-pop and K-drama becoming hugely popular in India
18:42and Indian cinema gaining recognition in Korea,
18:46PM Modi announced that both nations
18:48will organise the India-South Korea Friendship Festival in 2028.
18:52From chips to ships,
18:54from trade to technology,
18:55and from culture to connectivity.
18:58This visit is not just diplomacy.
19:00It is the blueprint for the next decade
19:02of India-South Korea cooperation.
19:05As both nations strengthen
19:06what they call a special strategic partnership,
19:09this visit could mark the beginning
19:11of a completely new chapter
19:13in India-South Korea relations.
19:16With Sharik Shah,
19:17Bureau Report, India Today Global.
19:20When the youth makes up its mind,
19:23history doesn't move gradually.
19:26Last year, teenagers and 20-somethings,
19:29the same generation accused of being glued to their phones,
19:33put down their phones.
19:34Not for trends,
19:35not for clout,
19:36for power.
19:37From Nepal to Madagascar,
19:39Gen Z pushed back.
19:41They also picked up pirate flags,
19:43not metaphorical pirate flags,
19:45actually Jolly Roger flags
19:47from One Piece,
19:48the anime.
19:49They waved them in Nepal,
19:51Bangladesh,
19:52Morocco,
19:53Indonesia,
19:54Peru,
19:54and Madagascar.
19:56These were not random tantrums.
19:58Gen Z looked at corrupt governments,
20:01nepotism-soaked parliaments,
20:03and crumbling hospitals,
20:04and said,
20:05enough.
20:07Some governments fell.
20:09Some protesters got shot.
20:10So one year later,
20:11did Gen Z actually win,
20:14or did they fail?
20:15What triggered all of this?
20:17The usual suspects.
20:18Youth unemployment so crushing,
20:20it makes a participation trophy look like a career plan.
20:24Crumbling schools and hospitals,
20:26while governments blew money on soccer stadiums.
20:29Corruption so brazen,
20:30it stopped hiding behind paperwork.
20:32A Bloomberg economic study crunched 22 million data points
20:37and landed on a simple conclusion.
20:40Young populations plus high social media use equals a powder keg.
20:45Add a corrupt government on top,
20:47and you don't need a match.
20:49You need a fire extinguisher.
20:51Which brings us to the pirate flag.
20:54Because before getting into who won and who lost,
20:56this needs explaining.
20:58How did an anime symbol end up pinned
21:01to burning buildings in Kathmandu
21:03and protest squares in Madagascar?
21:05Here's how.
21:07The straw hat pirates Jolly Roger,
21:10that grinning skull in a straw hat,
21:12stood for exactly one thing in one piece.
21:15Fighting corrupt, power-hoarding rulers,
21:19while everyone else suffers.
21:22Gen Z looked at their governments
21:24and recognized the villain immediately.
21:27The flag jumped onto TikTok and Instagram,
21:29crossed borders without a visa,
21:31and landed in Nepal, Bangladesh,
21:33Indonesia, Peru, Morocco,
21:36and Madagascar.
21:37Sometimes adapted locally.
21:39Like in Madagascar,
21:41where protesters swapped in traditional hats.
21:44No headquarters,
21:45no formal coordination,
21:47just a shared meme that said,
21:49we see the same enemy,
21:51and we are not afraid of it.
21:53Now the results.
21:55And this is where people expected the punchline to be,
21:58and then nothing changed.
22:00Except,
22:01that is not what happened.
22:03How many regimes did Gen Z actually topple?
22:06Five.
22:07Bangladesh fell first in 2024,
22:10the original Gen Z revolution,
22:12where students protesting nepotistic job quotas
22:15brought down Sheikh Hasina's authoritarian government
22:18after a deadly crackdown.
22:20Then came Nepal,
22:22where protesters ousted an entire government
22:25in 48 hours flat,
22:27demonstrating against corruption
22:29and a social media ban.
22:30Six months later,
22:32a youth-backed party won elections
22:34and installed a 35-year-old rapper
22:37as prime minister.
22:39Madagascar followed,
22:41a colonel backed the protesters,
22:42the president fled the country.
22:45Peru saw yet another leadership collapse
22:47in a nation that burned through six leaders
22:50in one decade.
22:52That is not a democracy.
22:54That is a revolving door with a corruption tax.
22:58But not everywhere worked,
23:00and honesty matters here.
23:02Indonesia and the Philippines
23:04rattle their governments
23:05and received minor concessions.
23:07Crumbs, not change.
23:09Morocco's protesters got a crackdown.
23:11Thousands arrested.
23:12Little systemic reform.
23:14No apology.
23:16Turkey's Gen Z filled streets
23:18despite media bans,
23:19and Erdogan did not budge an inch.
23:23Kenya and Sri Lanka saw massive turnouts,
23:26and then movements splintered
23:28the moment the peak passed.
23:30The cold truth is this.
23:31Copying tactics does not copy outcomes.
23:35Nepal won because elites fractured
23:37and elections followed through.
23:39Where police stayed brutal
23:40and government stayed united,
23:42protests hit a wall.
23:44Speed and surprise work beautifully once.
23:47The second time,
23:48governments come prepared,
23:49and they come angry.
23:51So what comes next?
23:53This is where it gets genuinely uncomfortable.
23:56Youth unemployment already sat at 30-50%
23:59across many of these countries.
24:01That is, the existing fuel already soaked into the ground.
24:05Now, add artificial intelligence threatening to swallow
24:08the entry-level jobs Gen Z depends on
24:11just to get a foot in the door.
24:14The same grievances,
24:16no jobs, corrupt elites,
24:18aging, out-of-touch leaders
24:19do not quietly disappear.
24:21They stack.
24:22Turkey's youth kept pushing into 2026.
24:25Indonesia eyed a second round.
24:27When economic pressure rises
24:29and opportunity shrinks at the same time,
24:31movements do not wind down.
24:34They reload.
24:35And they reload angrier.
24:38That's all in this edition of State Crowd.
24:40But before we go,
24:41we'll let you go with this.
24:42Here's a moment that captures both progress
24:44and a hint of what's coming next in Beijing.
24:47Half marathon for humanoid robots.
24:50Something remarkable unfolded.
24:52A humanoid robot made by tech company Honor.
24:56Crossed the finish line in just 50 minutes and 26 seconds.
25:00Faster than the human world record.
25:02While people were focusing on who won the race,
25:05the robot which came last stole the limelight.
25:09Take a look.
25:10Have fun.
25:11Goodbye and take care.
25:48Bye and take care.