• 6 hours ago
Why do great employees become bad managers? Promoting your best employee into leadership could be hurting team performance, employee engagement, and retention without you realizing it.

Being a top performer doesn't automatically make someone an effective leader.

In this episode of The Workforce Alchemy Show, host Mason Duchatschek interviews Leah Pitzenberger, founder and CEO of A People Revolution, about why talented employees struggle after being promoted into management and how CEOs, business owners, and executives can develop stronger leaders.

With nearly 20 years of HR and leadership experience, including roles at Target, the Minnesota Wild, and eight years as a Chief Human Resources Officer, Leah shares practical strategies for improving management performance and building high-performing teams.

WHAT YOU'LL LEARN:

✅ Why great employees become bad managers: What executives should evaluate before promoting top performers.

✅ Delegation vs. micromanagement: The simple test that reveals whether managers are actually delegating authority.

✅ Difficult employee conversations: How to address poor performance without creating unnecessary defensiveness.

✅ Why leadership training fails: Why workshops and online courses don't always translate into better management behavior.

✅ Building trust and accountability: How acknowledging mistakes and inviting honest feedback strengthens leadership.

✅ Stop rescuing employees: Why effective managers coach employees instead of doing their work for them.

✅ Leadership in the age of AI: Why human connection, compassion, and communication remain essential.

A QUESTION EVERY CEO SHOULD ASK:

Are your managers developing employees who can make decisions independently, or creating teams that depend on them for every answer?

Leah also shares a real-world example of recognizing her own leadership mistake during a difficult performance conversation and turning it into an opportunity to strengthen trust.

If you're a business owner, CEO, HR executive, or manager looking to improve employee engagement, develop future leaders, reduce turnover, or strengthen management performance, this conversation offers actionable insights.

CONNECT WITH LEAH PITZENBERGER

A People Revolution: https://www.apeoplerevolution.com/

TAKE THE WORKFORCE ALCHEMY CHALLENGE

Want less employee turnover, less workplace drama, and more discretionary effort from your employees?

Apply for the FREE Workforce Alchemy Challenge. It takes approximately six minutes to apply and could provide access to valuable workforce tools and training.

https://workforcealchemy.com/

CONNECT WITH WORKFORCE ALCHEMY

Website: https://workforcealchemy.com/

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@WorkforceAlchemist

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ReverseRiskConsulting

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/workforcealchemy/

X: https://x.com/WorkAlchemist

CONNECT WITH MASON DUCHATSCHEK

Website: https://masonduchatschek.com/
Transcript
00:02Welcome to the Workforce Alchemy Show. I'm today's host, Mason Dukacek, and this episode
00:08is brought to you by WorkforceAlchemy.com, where business leaders discover practical ways to select,
00:14engage, and retain their best employees. Leah Pitsenberger is the founder and CEO of
00:20A People Revolution, where she develops leaders and managers from growing businesses to Fortune
00:26500 companies. She spent almost a decade at Target, served as the head of HR for the Minnesota Wild
00:31Hockey Team, and spent eight years as a chief human resource officer. With a master's degree in
00:37psychology, Leah has spent nearly two decades solving a problem almost every growing company
00:43faces. How do you turn great employees into great leaders? Leah, welcome to the show.
00:48Thank you so much. I'm so excited to be here, and this is a topic that you won't get me
00:52to shut up
00:53about. Well, I'm glad you're here. So you've spent years watching talented employees get promoted
00:59because they were great at their jobs, only to discover that managing people requires an entirely
01:04different skill set. What should an executive look for before deciding someone is actually ready to
01:10become a manager? Yeah, I feel like this is the problem that we all face, which is we look out
01:15at
01:15our workforce and we think that person is a superstar, and we just want to engage them. We want to
01:22promote
01:22them. We want to retain them. And so what are we going to do? We're going to move them into
01:26leadership.
01:26They're going to be a great leader. But the issue that we have is that oftentimes the thing that made
01:32you really, really good as an individual contributor is quite the opposite of what's going to make you
01:36great as a leader. And so when you look at your talent, you actually shouldn't look at how are they
01:42performing in their current role. That is an important indicator of their abilities. But if you want to
01:48know if someone's going to be a great leader, you should look not at them, but you should look at
01:52the
01:52people around them, right? So things like, are they making the people around them, their peer group
01:57better? Are they a natural coach? Do people ask them or seek out their insight and their help? When
02:05they present a perspective, do they explain themselves? Do they share credit, right? Do they
02:12pause and say, hey, yeah, I came up with this part of the idea, but it was a team effort.
02:18Are they giving
02:18credit where credit is due? And then I think one of the most important things is paying attention to
02:24how they handle disagreement. So when things in the room, whether it be a virtual room or a physical
02:29room, get tense, what do they do? Do they kind of shy away and fade into the background? Or are
02:35they
02:35someone that leans in and helps the room come to a solution? And so I think it's a pretty significant
02:40shift. And at least it was for me as I grew in my career. I think that was something that
02:45I got better
02:45at when assessing whether or not someone was ready for leadership. They don't have to have all those
02:50skills. But I think starting from a place of how are they interacting with their peers and are making
02:55are they making their peer group better is a great place to begin the assessment process for is this
03:01person going to naturally transition into leadership or are they going to take more of coaching or
03:07investment before they get to that next level? So a lot of people listening were promoted into
03:12management because they were good at their jobs, but nobody ever taught them how to lead.
03:16So if that's you, where do you start? What are the first things you need to learn or change?
03:21Yeah. You got to start by recognizing that you're in a different job. I think a lot of times,
03:26or at least in my experience, I moved from being an individual contributor into being a manager of
03:32people. And I thought, okay, what made me really successful as an individual contributor were these
03:36five things. And that's how I got the attention of the leadership.
03:40And so we were just talking about right there.
03:43That's exactly right. That's exactly right. So I'm just going to do more of that,
03:47right? Like I'm just going to do what I was doing before, but I'm going to do more of it.
03:51And then
03:51I'm going to teach other people how to do what I did. And I think I got that wrong, terribly
03:55wrong,
03:56because what happened to me, and I think I would imagine that this is relatable is that I got put
04:01in
04:01a leadership role and the people around me, I thought needed to be more like me. And if we were
04:06all just
04:06like me, everything was going to be great. And I had to go through a lot of maybe some hard
04:11conversations with people, giving me some pretty, I don't know, stern feedback, if you will,
04:17to say like, this isn't good. I am not enjoying being on your team. And it was a wake-up
04:23call for
04:23me. And it was an opportunity for me to say, gosh, actually, I need to do something different.
04:29And so I think what I wished I had known is that the job isn't just a transition. It isn't
04:35just
04:35more, it isn't the next step. It's actually a completely different job. It's like taking a
04:40computer engineer and saying, now you're going to go be an accountant. It can be that dramatic of a
04:47shift. And I think when you think about it that way, you start to open your eyes and approach this
04:53new role that you're in with more of a beginner's mindset. The goal isn't that you need to know how
04:58to do
04:59it right out of the gate. It's that when you step into that role, you're open to the idea that
05:04what
05:04defines success in this new role is different. It is more about relationships. It's more about how
05:12people experience you and less about your work product. There was a, there's a gentleman I'm
05:17having on the podcast in a couple of weeks, and he's the CEO of Skillpath, which is a training company
05:22that's been around for a long time. And I noticed a post on LinkedIn this morning that he made that
05:28resonated with me and was relevant to this conversation. It was, I'm going to butcher it a
05:33little bit, but something along the lines of he's been involved in collegiate sports for many years.
05:38And he listed some of the colleges, Oklahoma, Oklahoma State, Wichita State, probably Arkansas
05:42State, a couple others. And what his comment was, was he was around athletes, 19-year-old, 20-year-old
05:48young men and women who sat down with their coaches and analyzed game tape,
05:55movement, strategy, ball placement, timing, all of these little things. And then they go to the work
06:01environment and they don't get any coaching. And then people wonder why they're not playing well.
06:06Isn't that crazy?
06:06It was just a stark contrast to me that coaches in college spend that much time and energy and
06:12effort. I mean, even in high school for that matter, even the little league spend time and effort
06:16teaching, observing, commenting on like, this is what I saw. This is an adjustment you can make that
06:21will deliver a better outcome. Let's try it. But once you become a professional, they throw you to
06:28the wolves and say, good luck. And that doesn't make sense to me. And the analogy that he drew in
06:33that post this morning resonated with me. I'm like, he's right.
06:36Such a good analogy. And I would take it even one step further, which is like as athletes,
06:42because I was an athlete and I have two little boys who are athletes and we are constantly talking
06:48about what's going well, what's not going well. How do you improve your skills? That's how we get
06:52better. And it is interesting, sure, from a coaching perspective and a leadership perspective,
06:57but we also have these expectations of ourselves. I think sometimes that we should just know how to
07:03be a leader, even though we've never actually been one before.
07:07So that leads to my next question. How do you know which leadership skills you're missing
07:12when you've never actually been taught what good leadership looks like?
07:14Yeah. I think going back to the analogy that you drew about coaching, you got to lean on the
07:19people around you, right? Because I think that a lot of times you are looking at yourself and
07:25you're not going to be able to see yourself clearly without that tape. And, you know, we don't really
07:29have tape in the same way that sports have tape. We can't go back and do a replay. I mean,
07:33maybe we
07:34could in some instances, but we're never going to see it clearly. And so you have to lean on the
07:38people
07:38around you. And I think the easiest way to do that is to ask the people who experience your
07:43leadership, right? And make it safe for them to answer honestly. But before that, what's so
07:49important, and I think we skip this step so often, is that in order to do that, you have to
07:54build
07:55relationship with those people first, right? It is an environment that is built on relationships.
08:01And the easiest way to do this, and this is like my favorite tip or trick for all leaders. And
08:06honestly,
08:07I was on a call with a fortune 500 executive just last week, and I gave him the same advice
08:13as I give
08:14brand new managers, which is the best way to invite feedback into your life and invite ways to find your
08:21own kind of blind spots or create more self-awareness is to admit what you're not good at right out
08:27of the
08:27gate. Like we know we're not good at everything and that's not, we're not expected to be great at
08:32everything. But to start from a place of, for me, I say things like, hey, I know that my passion
08:39sometimes comes across as inflexibility. And so when I'm in a room and I'm really like firing on
08:45all cylinders, I know that what you might experience is me telling you to do a bunch of things. And
08:50that's
08:50not what I'm trying to do. And so I want your help with that. And if you start with something
08:54that
08:54you already know, right, and you admit that there's a weakness, it creates space for other people to
09:01invite themselves in to helping you with your blind spots. It also just creates a really safe environment
09:07for you to eventually be giving them feedback, for them to be giving each other feedback, right? It's a
09:14win-win-win. But I don't think the expectation is that you know what your blind spots are. I think
09:20you
09:20have to create an environment where other people care enough about you and feel safe enough about
09:26you to tell you the truth. I'm reflecting on a conversation I had, and this episode hasn't aired
09:30yet, but will soon. I was visiting with Debbie McKinley. She's the chief people officer at Hershen
09:36Family Entertainment, like Silver Dollar City and Bollywood and whatnot. And she was a VP of HR for Home
09:43Depot before. So we were having this almost a very similar conversation. And she said that one of the
09:48temptations that she sees young managers making is they want to tell people what to do. She's like,
09:53oh, no, no. She was like, at first, she said early in her career, she was tempted to do it
09:56too. She said,
09:56I recognize I'm not the quarterback. I'm the coach. I'm the one that points these things out and helps
10:01them so that they don't become dependent upon me, which I thought was a very, very important
10:06distinction. So you distinguish between doing and leading. What does someone, in your opinion,
10:11have to stop doing when they become responsible for getting results through other people?
10:14Yeah. It goes back to what she said, which is you have to stop doing their work for them. Earlier
10:20in my career, I felt like my way of helping my team was to make sure that they were all
10:26doing the
10:27things that they should be doing. And if they weren't doing them, I would step in and kind of
10:32save them, rescue them, help. I said help them, but really what I was doing is rescuing them,
10:38right? But I'm just helping them. And so I would step in and I would help them. And in a
10:42lot of
10:42cases, I would do the thing for them so that it wouldn't. And I was doing it from a place
10:47of not
10:47wanting to feel like my leadership was failing. Because if my team dropped something, I felt like
10:53then I was accountable or responsible for that. And I think what you have to do is really shift from
10:59your job isn't to make sure that they get everything done. It's to set clear expectations,
11:05make sure that you remove roadblocks for them so that they can get everything done. It's their job to do
11:11the thing. And if you are stepping in and doing things for them, you'll never know if they are
11:17capable or if they actually are willing to do the things, right? And so that when you have to,
11:23when you ask the question, what should they stop doing? It's doing the things. And it is honestly,
11:28I think one of the hardest things to do when you step into a leadership role is to stop doing
11:33the
11:34things that you were doing before to get outcomes and instead become, to use that language,
11:39the quarterback of the team. You're calling the plays. You're not throwing the ball necessarily.
11:44Maybe that's a bad example. You're moving from quarterback to coach is the example, right? So
11:48you're maybe on the sidelines, but you're calling the plays. You're not throwing the ball. You're not
11:53running the ball anymore, right? And then the other piece of that is as a coach, you can't control.
11:59So the quarterback has to have the authority on the field to take that analogy a step further
12:04to, to call an audible. I can't believe I'm taking this analogy all the way down because I don't know
12:09that much about football, if I'm being honest. So my husband and my kids are going to be very
12:14impressed if they hear this, but the quarterback has to be able to call an audible based on what
12:19they're reading on the field. Right. And as a coach, you can't run out there and be like, stop.
12:24I told you to throw it this way and you're not throwing it. You can't do that. And that is
12:28the other
12:28thing you have to, once you make the call, you have to stop trying to control the outcome.
12:33There was a mentor of mine earlier in my career, his name's Bill Pernat. And if he's listening,
12:37I'm going to give a shout out to him. But he told me something I've never forgotten. He said,
12:41anytime there's an interaction between two people, one is teaching the other one how to behave.
12:45And if you are that senior leader trying to teach a new leader and you are jumping in and doing
12:50everything, you're just teaching them that I don't have to do anything. I just sit back and say,
12:54oh, I need help. And they'll do it for you. And those employees will let you do it for them.
12:58Absolutely. Absolutely.
12:59What are the biggest mistakes new managers make when they're learning leadership through
13:03trial and error? And which mistakes can do lasting damage to a team, in your opinion?
13:07Oh, man. So I think there's a lot of mistakes, but I actually don't think the mistakes are the
13:13problem. I think what you do with the mistakes is where the magic is.
13:17Ooh, good answer.
13:18And so this idea that you're going to step in and you're going to have it all figured out and
13:23you're not going to make mistakes, to me, isn't really, it's just not realistic. I have been in
13:29leadership for decades at this point and I make mistakes all the time. And so really the skill
13:35that you need to learn is what are you going to do with a mistake? And that's what can either
13:40build
13:40trust or build capability or is the thing that can cause damage. And so the goal isn't to be
13:46right. It's to be relatable. And in those instances, when you make a bad call or when you mess up
13:52or
13:52when you get frustrated because something didn't go the way that you wanted to be able to repair
13:58and say, hey, that is not how I wanted to show up. Or I can tell that I'm getting really
14:04frustrated
14:04or I'm coming across as really frustrated. I had this scenario like two weeks ago. I was on the phone
14:09with someone, a leader, and we've been working on some things and he was supposed to deliver
14:14something and he hadn't delivered it. And I was frustrated and I was irritated that we'd had the
14:20same conversations three, maybe even four times. And I was kind of getting on him and you could just
14:25see, Mason, you could see his body. We were virtual, but I could just see him getting smaller
14:30and smaller on my screen. And I, I, the mistake was right. That was an opportunity for me to either
14:37acknowledge what was going on or to ignore it. And I think the mistake would have been to ignore it,
14:42but instead I said, okay, I'm sorry. I can tell that the way I'm coming across right now
14:47is really intense and that it's making you feel bad. And that's not what I'm trying to communicate.
14:53That's not my intention. I don't want you to feel that way, but I am really frustrated
14:57because I feel like we've had this conversation multiple times. And so what is it that we need to
15:02do together to fix the situation that we're in so that we can deliver the thing that we both
15:07agreed upon? What kind of response did you get? He, I mean, he immediately was like,
15:11thank you for saying that. I am feeling that way. I appreciate that you're frustrated. And I do
15:18listen, people generally speaking, like I'm in a broad stroke here. Don't wake up in the morning
15:24and think, I hope I disappoint everybody around me. I hope, right? Like, I hope I fail miserably.
15:31I hope my boss gets annoyed and that I don't do anything that she or he expects of me.
15:36They don't. So if you start from that place, always as a leader, that they're doing the best
15:41that they can, right? With what they've been given on any given moment. If you start with that little
15:47bit of grace to me, it changes the perspective and the relationship. And so in that instance,
15:53I had to acknowledge in my, myself, the opportunity that I had, it wasn't that I'm never going to get
15:58frustrated or impatient or make a mistake. It's that when I do make a mistake, I can acknowledge it.
16:04And I think the leadership super skill, Mason, is that being able to acknowledge it in the moment.
16:10You won't be able to at the beginning. At the beginning, it'll be later, right? Just like when
16:14you argue with your spouse. Very rarely when I'm arguing with my spouse, am I in the moment being
16:18like, actually, you're right and I'm wrong. Doesn't happen. At least in my house, it doesn't happen
16:22very often, right? It happens after the fact. After I've had some time and I've calmed down and I think
16:28about it, I think, oh, I really could have handled that better. And then I go back to my spouse
16:33and I say,
16:33hey, I'm really sorry. And that's a great place to start. And the more that you practice the
16:39acknowledgement of the mistake and the repair after that, the better you'll get at being able
16:44to handle it in the moment like I was able to. But it took me a decade at least before
16:50I was able
16:51to pause myself in the moment and notice in the moment. So starting by saying, when you make a
16:57mistake, go back. Go back and repair and say, I didn't do that. I didn't show up in the way
17:01I
17:01wanted to. That wasn't my best self. I appreciate you sharing this because one of the reasons I
17:06love doing this is I get exposure to new ideas and reminders of old ones. And it's such a nice
17:13reminder. I'm sure people are watching and listening thinking, she just kept me from tripping over the
17:19same rocks because those obstacles are in front of these folks. And sometimes they just need to be
17:23reminded, hey, they're there. And here's how you get over them. Keep maintain your speed,
17:27keep rolling. And it's just a nice reminder of how to handle what would ordinarily be an awkward
17:33situation. And speaking of awkward situations, one of my friends, Marlene Chisholm, wrote a book
17:39From Conflict to Courage. And I think this is such a big topic because, well, she wrote a whole book
17:44on
17:45it and I'm a fan of her stuff. So shout out to Marlene too. But I know you talk a
17:49lot about the
17:49conversation you're avoiding. Why do otherwise capable leaders, in your opinion, put off difficult
17:54conversations and how should they approach a conversation they know they need to have?
17:59Yeah. Well, because they're hard. Like I, they're really hard. And so I think it's in human nature
18:06to avoid things that are hard for as long as human. But you got to choose your hard because it
18:11may be
18:11hard right now, but it's gonna be a lot harder if you let stuff compound and get worse. So it
18:17can be.
18:18It's sometimes hard and harder. And when are you gonna step in? But I didn't want to rain on your
18:25parade there.
18:25No, I don't. I think that's a really good point. I think it can be harder, right? But like your
18:30initial,
18:31generally speaking, people avoid conflict. It's uncomfortable. It's hard. It's not fun,
18:39right? And you just want it to be fixed. And that's, that's just our human nature.
18:45And so what I have found in like practical terms, right, is there's lots of tools and techniques and
18:52whole books about how to have really hard conversations. And those techniques are really,
18:57really helpful, I think. And so reading a book and getting some advice and watching videos,
19:02those are all really great. The thing that was most impactful for me before all of the techniques
19:07was kind of going back to that, that perspective that I shared earlier, which is people genuinely,
19:13genuinely don't wake up and think I want to disappoint everybody. And so when you step back
19:18and you think about less about how uncomfortable you are, and more about why this conversation is
19:24important for them, you can start to get out of your own head about how uncomfortable or how hard
19:30this message is going to be delivered, right? If they are in a role or they're doing work that is
19:38not
19:38meeting expectations, most of the time, not all, but a lot of the time they can feel it,
19:43they can sense it, right? Because they'll show up and they'll do a presentation and it'll flop.
19:48And that doesn't feel good. And so being able to get ahead of some of that so that they can
19:53be more
19:53successful, I think is really, really helpful. And then the second thing that I do is I name
19:59how hard it is. So the, I go into those conversations every single time and I say,
20:03this is really hard for me. I'm not great at, I'm not great at giving direct feedback. I'm working
20:09on that. And so this might come out clunky or this conversation might seem awkward because I'm not
20:16great at this. And so I'm learning, but it's important. And so I'm going to work through that
20:21discomfort so that I can talk to you about it. And when you name the uncomfortability, when you name
20:27that it is a hard conversation, I find that they then give you more grace and they sit in the
20:34discomfort with you versus sitting across from you in that discomfort. It creates something you're
20:39together. You're eliminating defensiveness by the way you're teeing it up. I literally just an hour ago
20:47talking to Bryant Wright, he was co-author of a book with me. I rewrote a couple months ago called
20:51Built Right. And he always positions correction as care. It is. And he says that he wanted,
20:59there's three criteria. He wants it to be calm. He wants it to be very specific and grounded in
21:04observation for some of the same reasons that you're talking about, about not putting someone
21:08on the defensive. It's like, Hey, I'm very calm. I'm being very specific. I saw this, this, this,
21:12this, this take place. And it's not a matter of opinion. It's an observation that was there for all
21:19to see. And then being curious about what other things went on that I didn't see so that you can
21:24have a positive conversation moving forward, not judgmental, but help. Is there something I'm
21:29missing? Is there something I don't understand? And how can I help? Because this, we need to pivot
21:35and not do this and do that instead next time. And here's why it's important. So they understand the
21:41why too. So I love, I love how you were talking about a way to just do it in a
21:47way that doesn't make
21:48them defensive. So shift gears a little bit. If what should a CEO do when a manager or a senior
21:54level executive, what should they do when they see that a manager has tolerated an underperforming
21:59employee for months and everyone else on the team can see it? Yeah. Oh, that's such a good question.
22:05So I think the first thing that I always do when I'm seeing and when I'm hearing, because oftentimes,
22:13how does that come to you? Right. It's coming to you because there's some frustration or there's
22:17some discord on the team. It's rare that you have an executive that is just like noticing it over
22:22there on their own. Right. And so you're hearing something. There's some discord on the team. And so
22:27I always start from a place of understanding what's getting in the way before I assume that they're
22:32unwilling to address the problem. Right. So oftentimes there, maybe they don't notice it. Maybe they
22:39don't understand the impact of underperformance on the people on the team. Maybe they're unaware of it.
22:46Maybe they are aware of it and they don't care. And so I love to start every conversation about
22:52performance, not with a statement, but with a question. So, hey, as an example of this,
22:58I'm curious, how do you think your team is performing? Would be the question that I would
23:01ask if I was an executive going to a VP. And if they were like, great, I would say, okay,
23:07is it okay with you if I share some insight that I gathered? And then I would share my perspective.
23:13I find starting with a question does two things.
23:16Number one, it's just the kind thing to do. Like, I don't know why we would come in and just
23:21start peppering statements at them to your point. Right. It helps them understand you actually care
23:27what they think before you share what your opinion is, but it doesn't let them off the hook.
23:33Right. And you can use this with an executive and you can use this with a first time manager.
23:38Right. You can use it when you're giving feedback to an individual contributor. Hey,
23:42how do you think things are going? How are you working with your peers? Like whatever the
23:46question is. And then when you ask, is it okay? And by the way, nobody says no, but just positioning
23:53it that way. Is it okay with you if I share some of my observations? Allows them the control to
23:59invite
24:00you into the conversation versus I'm going to swoop in and I'm going to tell you what I think.
24:04Of course, you're going to be defensive. Of course, they're going to feel like you're not on the
24:09same team. And that's really what leadership is about. We are on the same team. My job as a leader
24:14is to make my team the best versions of themselves possible. Period. End of story. In order to deliver
24:21great results for the organization that we work for. So you touched on that a little bit. I want to
24:25go
24:25in a little bit more depth and dig a little deeper. How do you delegate without micromanaging,
24:30but also without simply handing someone a responsibility and hoping they figure out?
24:34Because that's a delicate balance. And I'm curious what your take is on that.
24:37Yeah. So I think in my experience, we confuse delegation and micromanaging for sure. And I
24:44think it's important we go back to definitions. So to me, delegating means that you hand over the
24:51outcome or the output. You hand over control when you delegate, which is really scary. What we like
24:57to do is micromanage, even though we don't like that term. I think we do like to hand over the
25:02task
25:02or the doing, but we like to keep some control, decision rights, authority. So to me, delegating
25:08means that you hand over the outcome, right? And then you define what success looks like when it's
25:14due, right? But you allow them a lot of autonomy and ownership in how they get to that outcome.
25:22Micromanaging is you're handing over the task, but you're going to keep ownership. So you're still
25:26controlling how they get the thing done, right? They're carrying out your plan, but they're in
25:32charge of getting it to the outcome. The quickest test I think to know, did I delegate something or
25:38did I micromanage something is to ask a simple question? Can they make a decision without coming
25:43back and checking with me? If they can make an impactful decision, that means that you delegated
25:48it. If they have to come back and check in with you, you're micromanaging. You assigned it,
25:53but you didn't delegate it. That's a great, isn't it? Perfect. You've argued that traditional
26:00leadership training often fails to change what managers actually do when they return to work.
26:05Yeah. I wouldn't disagree in a lot of cases. So in your opinion, why does that happen and what
26:11actually causes leadership behavior to change? I love this question and here's why. I think that
26:17far and away, traditional leadership development is completely out of date and out of touch. I think
26:22it's one of the industries in human resources ecosystem that has not evolved with the changes
26:28in the environment, the changes in the workforce, changes in expectations, changes in our generational
26:34impact. It hasn't evolved. And what I'm starting to see is kind of two ends of a pendulum or a
26:40spectrum.
26:41On one end, we've got a really traditional in-person or virtual workshop-based learning where I attend
26:51an experience. I learn a bunch of things in this kind of bubble. And then I like go back to
26:56my day
26:57job. And I think from a psychological perspective, it's really hard to transfer skills or behaviors that
27:04you're learning in a theoretical environment to a practical environment. It's also hard to remember
27:09them. My husband went to this amazing workshop five days. He came back and he was like, oh my gosh,
27:17I am changed. And three months later, I asked him, I said, hey, I'm just curious. And he's a VP
27:23in
27:23sales. This experience that you had was so insightful and so impactful. I would be curious to know now
27:28three months later, what about a Tuesday has changed for you because of that? And Mason, he couldn't
27:34really answer the question. So he had this amazing experience. And sure, his philosophy maybe changed
27:40a little bit. But practically, when you're operating theoretically and then you get to like, I just got
27:46to answer a thousand emails and get shit done, it doesn't transition. So that's one end of the spectrum.
27:52The other end, we have the self-paced learning online, build my own path, get my badges kind of
28:01thing. Really, really cool, can be very impactful. But again, it's not embedded in my reality every
28:09single day. And so I think that we have to do a better job as an industry in balancing both
28:16of
28:16those pieces, the context and the learning and the AI and the enablement and the technology. But the
28:23third piece that I think we lose sight of is the human piece. For now, we could have a whole
28:28conversation
28:29around AI if we want. Yeah, I'm going to dive in on the AI. Yeah, what the future of work
28:33looks like.
28:34But for now, leadership still requires personal behaviors, personal interactions. It requires
28:41relationship. And those things on both ends of the spectrum don't take into account how do I
28:47interpersonally relate to other people and how do I understand and motivate behavior change. And that
28:57is the piece that I think is missing. And that can only happen in relationship with people.
29:01You can't learn that from a course online, in my opinion.
29:05So you touched on AI a little. I'm going to dig a little deeper there. In your opinion, as AI
29:09takes
29:10over more of the work employees and managers traditionally perform, which human leadership
29:15skills are going to become more valuable and what should leaders start developing now?
29:19Yeah. Compassion, motivation, and understanding behavior change. And so I always kind of lean
29:28back on my master's in psychology. And I think about kind of human motivation in different ways. And I
29:36think a lot of other leadership development people do. And so for me, it's looking at endorphins,
29:42dopamine, serotonin, and oxytocin. And AI, we are hardwired as human beings for connection. And AI
29:51cannot fill that gap. It can impact it in certain ways. How we get connection has dramatically changed
29:58from when I started my career 20 years ago when I went into an office every day. Connection looks
30:04different. It sounds different. But at its core, we cannot run businesses without people today.
30:10And so we skip that very important conversation a lot of times when we think about leadership skills.
30:17We talk about the skill of giving feedback. We talk about the skill of prioritization and delegation.
30:24But what we talk a lot with our clients about is how do you build trust? How do you communicate
30:31with connection in a way that actually, and using technology as a vehicle, right? Technology as a tool
30:39to create connection through communication, right? So we don't assume that people are in person ever.
30:46And so we're talking about how are you creating relationships in the environment that you're
30:51operating in today. And quite frankly, Mason, that looks different at every organization. And so the
30:57idea that there's a course out there that can teach everybody to be an effective communicator in their
31:02current role, I don't think that exists anymore. So I think when we look at AI, what is AI going
31:07to do?
31:07It's going to streamline knowledge. It's going to democratize information. It's going to evolve
31:14how work gets done. But the one thing that it can't do today is it really cannot connect people
31:21in a meaningful way that makes them motivated to do more for the organization and for the leaders that
31:28they work with. Because this is a fascinating topic because you touched a little bit on the concept
31:32of the future of work. And I was at an event maybe two weeks ago, and the speaker was talking
31:37about
31:38how some of the folks just out of college treat AI like a human being, like a friend. Like they
31:44talk
31:44to it like it's literally dating advice. Like, hey, this guy texted me that. How should I respond if I
31:52want to accomplish this? Or if I want to come off like that? And vice versa. The point is, it's
31:58like
31:58AI is their dating coach. And it boggles my mind a little bit if I'm being open that that is
32:09in the
32:10future of our work, where people are going to machines to ask how to talk to real people instead
32:15of just double. And I'm old school. I believe in the connection with people. And I had a guest on
32:23David Holman a few months ago and he wrote a book and he convinced me that there's a huge difference
32:27between having a network and a community. Network might be people that are on an email list or follow
32:34you on social media, but the community is comprised of people who will pick up a phone and call you
32:38or will go out of their way to do something for you, even if it requires effort or sacrifice on
32:44their
32:44part. And when I heard him make that distinction, it was a reminder to me, I choose and the people
32:52that
32:52choose to double down on the human side and focus on the connection and the community, not network
33:00numbers, speed. And I think in the future work, everything has its pendulum of swings back and
33:05forth. But me personally, I'm going to bet on those that cling to the human side of it and developing
33:12those relationships. I mean, at a certain point in time, if you've got computers talking to each
33:15other, who cares? That's right. Yeah. And I think I love the network versus community analogy
33:20because I think, I think of it as transactional versus transformational relationships.
33:25100%. That's a great way to look at it too.
33:27Yeah. And I think there is. So when you use the example of like kids coming out of, you know,
33:33college that are using that, that is a transactional relationship that they're having with AI.
33:38Now, where is it going to go?
33:40They haven't bothered to think about what happens if they actually, if it works and they get in a
33:44relationship and they're in a relationship with someone, not because of who they are, but because
33:48of what AI told them to be. Who wants that?
33:50Right. Yeah. And I think, you know, we're just, it was so interesting about this conversation,
33:56I think is that it is all so it's moving so quickly and we don't know where it's going.
34:02Right. And so what I always come back to is what do we know? What can we control? And how
34:09can we leave
34:10space for technology to elevate the conversation? And that's where we're always going, right? In our
34:16leadership development conversations and programs. I love AI. I use it all the time in, in our,
34:22with our clients. We have it embedded in our learning programs. Like we have AI coaches in
34:28our learning programs. So in our feedback one, they kind of try out some feedback in our, in our
34:33feedback lesson, and then they click coach. And we've worked with a bot that like gives them
34:38real time feedback. I think that's a perfect place for us to leverage technology and AI specifically
34:45is to get real time feedback on something that maybe you don't have access to a coach like
34:51me or like other individuals in my organization at any given moment. It's a great way to use it,
34:57but I don't think it can be the only tool. That's like saying, I'm going to build a house
35:02with a screwdriver and I'm only going to use that one tool and it'll work for some of the things
35:07that
35:07you need. And could you maybe hammer a nail with a screwdriver? Maybe, but it's really,
35:12really hard to build a really nice house with just a screwdriver. And I think we need to
35:16expand the conversation around the future of work and AI and technology and really think about where
35:24does it elevate and push our thinking and where is it just the wrong tool at the wrong time? And
35:29I'm not saying it'll never be the right tool, but right now it is the wrong tool at the wrong
35:33time
35:33for some things that we're trying to talk about. So you mentioned access to you and members of your
35:40team. If people want to know more about you, the work you do, what are the best ways for them
35:44to
35:44connect and learn more? Yeah. Two places connect with me on LinkedIn. So I go by Leah Pitts. My full
35:50name obviously is Pitts and Berger, but that's a mouthful. So yeah, LinkedIn, Leah Pitts and Berger
35:54or our website, which is a people revolution.com. It's got all the info about our unleashing leadership
36:00program and clients and things that we do. And yeah. And I'd love to, to chat more with anybody that
36:07wants to chat about this because I think that when we come together and we have conversations, like
36:12I, I am not, I have not figured it all out. Right. But I do feel like I have a
36:18lens into a lot of what's
36:19happening, both in enterprise organization, fortune 500 companies that we work with all the way down to
36:25one of our clients is a HVAC company. And so we get to kind of see the gamut of what
36:30it's like to be working
36:31with small organizations and large ones. And I think the more that we openly talk about what's
36:36working, what's not working and what, what this next phase of the world of work needs from leaders,
36:42I think we all get better and the conversation only elevates. So I get excited about that. So
36:47I'd love to talk to people. It's been an absolute pleasure having you on. And before we wrap up,
36:51I just want to leave people listening with one practical next step. If you want less turnover,
36:55less workplace drama and more discretionary effort from your existing employees,
36:58I want to invite you to apply for the workforce alchemy challenge at workforcealchemy.com
37:03costs nothing to apply. It takes about six minutes and can give you access to the tools
37:07and training on how to use them. And many of America's top employers have used some of these
37:12tools for years to leverage your talent in advantageous ways. And it makes me happy to be
37:16able to share it with you. So thank you for joining us and we'll catch you next time.

Recommended