• 1 anno fa
Questo testo esamina il Protocollo Annibale, una direttiva controversa delle forze armate israeliane (IDF) volta a prevenire la cattura di soldati, anche a costo di ferire o uccidere gli ostaggi stessi e i civili. L'autore traccia l'origine della direttiva negli anni '70, quando l'asimmetria nello scambio di prigionieri tra Israele e i palestinesi divenne militarmente insostenibile per Israele. La direttiva, sviluppata nel 1986 ma mai pubblicata integralmente, è stata a lungo circondata da teorie del complotto e applicata in modi distorsivi. Il testo documenta la sua applicazione più devastante durante il Venerdì Nero del 2014 a Rafah e le sue presunte applicazioni durante l'attacco di Hamas del 7 ottobre 2023, spesso risultando in "fuoco amico" e perdite tra gli ostaggi e i civili. Nonostante sia stata ufficialmente revocata nel 2016, la sua applicazione continua a sollevare gravi questioni etiche e legali sul valore della vita umana nel contesto del conflitto israelo-palestinese.
Trascrizione
00:00A soldier is better off dead than a prisoner. This is the logic, to say the least, chilling.
00:05behind the Hannibal Directive. But what happens when this same logic
00:10Is it no longer applied to the military, but to civilians? Today let's try to understand together
00:16one of the most controversial military doctrines ever.
00:20So, to clarify, this analysis we are doing today is based on an article
00:24by Federico Berti, published on Medium. The title is The Annibale Directive.
00:30and the Events of 7 October. Berti makes a very thorough investigation of this doctrine and the
00:37its possible and terrifying implications.
00:40It all starts with a question, a truly disturbing question. October 7, 2023, why the
00:46Would Israeli forces have opened fire on their own citizens? To prove
00:51To understand this, we have to take a step back. Shortly after the attacks that day, a lieutenant
00:56Colonel, Nof Eretz, in an interview with the Israeli newspaper Arez, uses an expression
01:01particular. He describes the military intervention as a massive Hannibal, speaking of many
01:08vehicles with and without hostages. But what exactly does Hannibal mean?
01:13Okay, let's go back to those days for a moment. Immediately after October 7th, the confusion was total,
01:19the so-called fog of war. Yet, amidst the chaos, some clues have begun to emerge.
01:24some truly disconcerting testimonies, which at the time seemed to have no basis whatsoever
01:30sense. The voices were conflicting and also very
01:34alarming. Some Israeli hostages, once freed, told a story
01:39Incredibly, they were deliberately attacked not by their captors, but by Israeli helicopters.
01:47Others have spoken of continuous bombing by their own armed forces. Then it is
01:53Channel 12 reported that a tractor carrying hostages was
01:58hit by the IDF. And finally, a partial mission from the army itself arrived.
02:03Yes, some casualties had been caused by friendly fire.
02:07But how is such a thing possible? To find a possible answer,
02:12we must shift our gaze from the chaos of that day and take a leap back in time to a
02:17controversial military doctrine, born decades ago and shrouded in secrecy.
02:22Here it is, the Hannibal Directive. A secret military order, from 1986, with a logic to die for.
02:30not very brutal. The kidnapping of a soldier must be prevented by any means necessary,
02:35even at the cost of wounding or killing the soldier himself. In practice, a dead soldier is considered
02:42better than a prisoner soldier. And one wonders, doesn't it? What is the strategic logic that
02:48can stand behind such an extreme order? Why would an army ever consider
02:53sacrifice your own soldiers to avoid capture? Well, the logic is based on what
02:58The problem of asymmetric exchange is defined. On one side there is a captured Israeli soldier,
03:04usually a trained military man, whose captivity becomes a huge pain in the ass
03:09politics for the government. On the other hand, thousands of Palestinian prisoners, who in the past
03:14were released in exchange for a single soldier. According to the source, most
03:19of these prisoners are not combatants, but civilians, including elderly people, doctors, journalists,
03:24many of whom are held without formal trial through administrative detention. Consider
03:30that for years and years the existence of this directive was a military secret
03:34jealously guarded. But you know, secrets sometimes struggle to stay secret, and little by little
03:40Hannibal has gone from a whispered order in the barracks to a full-blown controversy
03:46public. Let's take a look at its history, how it came to light. It was born in 1986, created
03:53by three high-ranking officials, but the original text has never been made public. The silence is
03:58breaks in 1999, when the newspaper Arez talks about it for the first time, after a doctor
04:05The military had reported it as illegal. Then, in 2014, the directive was implemented
04:11to Rafa, with devastating consequences. And finally, in 2016, it was officially cancelled, but
04:17replaced with new orders, these too classified. And to truly understand the mentality
04:24behind this directive, this 1999 quote from Shaul Moffaz, who was at the time
04:30IDF Chief of Staff, is, well, enlightening. He said, a kidnapped soldier, unlike
04:37of a dead soldier, becomes a national problem. And this, in his eyes, justified all the
04:43rest. Okay, but has this directive ever been used? And with what consequences? To understand this,
04:50we must look at the most documented episode before October 7, the so-called Black Friday
04:56by Rafa, in 2014. The story of that day is a true tragedy in four acts.
05:02First, Hamas fighters capture an Israeli soldier, Lieutenant Adar Goldin. Second,
05:09The Hannibal Directive is immediately invoked. Third, to prevent his escape,
05:14Israel unleashes enormous firepower on residential areas in Rafa. Fourth, the result,
05:21Lieutenant Goldin dies and hundreds of Palestinian civilians die with him.
05:26Clearly, something like this did not go unnoticed. Following those events, a
05:32Amnesty International report defined the events of Black Friday as a potential crime
05:38of war, raising international condemnation. And all this, all this
05:44historical context, brings us back exactly to the starting point, October 7, 2023. Because,
05:52knowing the history of the Nibale directive, those confused and disconcerting testimonies of
05:57that day they begin to take on a completely different and perhaps even more disturbing light.
06:03And this is where we come to the heart of Berti's analysis. The central accusation is this. Despite
06:10was officially revoked in 2016, there is evidence to suggest that the logic of
06:16Hannibal was reapplied on October 7, with one fundamental difference. This
06:22once not against soldiers, but against civilians. There are data to support this thesis. One
06:28in particular comes from an investigation by another Israeli newspaper, Yediot Aronot. They have
06:33inspected about 70 vehicles on the roads leading to Gaza and found that they had been
06:38hit by friendly fire, by IDF fire. What did this investigation uncover? Well, it put in place
06:45There are some very specific facts. It seems that around noon on October 7, the IDF gave an order
06:50All units must stop the return of Amasa Gaza at all costs. Those 70 vehicles were hit.
06:56from helicopters, tanks, or drones. And the investigation's conclusion is that, at least in some of these
07:01cases, all the occupants of the vehicles were killed. And be careful, it's not just about
07:07journalistic investigations. Confirmations seem to be coming from very high up. The former president himself
07:13Defense Minister Joav Gallant confirmed that the directive has been implemented in certain places
07:19near Gaza. And even a United Nations report dedicates a specific chapter to the use
07:25of the Hannibal Directive on that day. So, the crux, the real crux of the matter
07:30question, this is it. A controversial military doctrine, designed for soldiers and officially
07:36erased, it seems to have resurfaced, and has in fact been applied, against civilians. And this
07:43Obviously, it raises enormous ethical and legal questions. And ultimately, the question remains there,
07:49suspended. In trying to prevent a kidnapping, what price are you willing to pay?
07:56And most importantly, who decides when that price has become too high?

Consigliato