Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 days ago
A debate on whether Tamil Nadu politics is witnessing a structural transformation beyond traditional Dravidian parties, featuring political analyst Dr Sumanth C. Raman and senior journalist Shekhar Iyer. Dr Raman argued that neither actor Dhanush nor former state BJP chief Annamalai match the cinematic mass appeal commanded by TVK chief Vijay. Emphasising the political landscape, Dr Raman remarked, 'Vijay owes his office to the DMK and its ruinous governance of five years.' Shekhar Iyer noted that Annamalai's initial momentum and social media drive had plateaued, leaving him unable to sustain his base for civic polls. The panellists examined whether actors such as Dhanush and Sivakarthikeyan can successfully convert fan associations into viable political vehicles, highlighting the critical role played by caste coalitions, minority backing, and women voters in deciding electoral outcomes across Tamil Nadu.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Let's open this up. Joining me on this broadcast is Sumansi Raman as well as Mr. Shekhar Iyer to decode
00:06whether we're seeing a further churn in Tamil Nadu politics.
00:09Mr. Sumansi Raman, good evening to you first, sir. With all that we've seen in the last few months, many
00:14would say that there's already been a complete change and transformation in Tamil Nadu politics.
00:18But just looking at the result of the bi-poll and the fact that you've got now Annamalai who's stepping
00:23in, making it clear that look, in the next few years he will be looking at state elections.
00:28And then you have Dhanush who's setting the base perhaps for him to also step into politics.
00:33Do you think the whole narrative of Dravidian parties leading really in Tamil Nadu is all changing that they could
00:40perhaps also disappear completely?
00:43Okay, so first of all, Dhanush and Annamalai are nowhere comparable with Vijay in terms of their public appeal and
00:53stardom.
00:53Dhanush is a much, much smaller star when compared to Vijay and he's not in the same league at all.
00:59So he would like to try his luck because Vijay made it big and that has attracted not only Dhanush,
01:07it has also attracted another actor called Sivakarthi Kayan to try his luck as well.
01:11He's also gone the way of, you know, setting up his fan clubs in the format of a political party.
01:20You know, so that is something that is happening.
01:23But I do not believe that these are, you know, people who are guaranteed success in any manner whatsoever.
01:30Mr. Annamalai himself has become a bit of a bit player at the moment.
01:35And he's yet to prove himself. He's contested two elections and lost both of them.
01:40So, you know, the charge against him is first become a councillor and then talk.
01:44So whether he will succeed in that now that he's moved from Parliament Assembly election to Parliament election and now
01:51to local body election.
01:53First of all, this is we the leader. Is it a political party? Is it a social movement?
01:58No, it's clearly moving towards becoming a political party.
02:00Yeah, so he will have to register a political party and then, but of course, local body elections, you know,
02:07local issues do dominate.
02:09So very often there are parties, independents who win in large numbers against established political parties.
02:15But I think it's good that more players are coming into the electoral fray.
02:20Simply because Tamil Nadu is sick and tired of same two parties for last 70 years.
02:26So anybody coming into politics is welcome.
02:29Do you think, sir, though, that there's a void, that, you know, these leaders stepping in or stars stepping in
02:34will fill a void, essentially?
02:37And it's a question of the number two position, not so much number one, because like you said, you know,
02:40Vijay is, at this point at least, currently, leagues apart.
02:45So, look, there are two clear players now, as Vijay himself says.
02:49There is the TVK and there is the DMK.
02:51What will happen to the AIA-DMK remains to be seen.
02:54But there are, let us say, two and a half major players in politics in Tamil Nadu.
03:00Now, does that mean if TVK does not deliver on governance, then it creates a huge opportunity for a new
03:09player?
03:09Because with a weakened AIA-DMK, the DMK then goes back to being the preeminent force.
03:15And who against the DMK?
03:17Because in Tamil Nadu, the vote bank is largely an anti-DMK vote bank.
03:21If the anti-DMK vote bank unites, they win elections.
03:25That's very simple.
03:26So whether, so there is definitely going to be space for a third player or a new player.
03:32Who that new player is, is really the million dollar question.
03:35What will it take, Mr. Shekhar Ayaan?
03:37What will it take for a Dhanush or an Annamalai to be successful?
03:40You know, Dhanush sure has a star power, not perhaps at the same level of Vijay.
03:45But he's got a couple of years, if he chooses to enter politics, to actually work on ensuring that he
03:50has more time than Vijay to set the base for a political debut.
03:55As far as Annamalai goes, he's never really tasted any electoral success, but is known to have some sense of,
04:01you know, a following.
04:02At least if you look at social media, he has a following.
04:05So what will it take for them to actually create an impact?
04:09Well, Akshita, in the case of Annamalai, we have already seen even his social media, you know, thing has hit
04:15a plateau.
04:17Because not much has happened since he announced the party, that there was this drive for membership.
04:23Then he held meetings in some places.
04:26But then he has been unable to keep up that initial momentum.
04:30And when the elections finally happened, say the civic elections, I don't think we the leader, even it puts up
04:37candidates.
04:38That is going to make a big impact because what Dr. Sumant P. Rahman just said, the battle is between
04:44Vijay and those who are opposed to Vijay, including the DMK.
04:48And there is already a lot of talk that for Annamalai, the choice is either, you know, he has to
04:55join the anti-Vijay bandwagon, or he has to be with, by joining hands with DMK, or he has to,
05:03you know, look at ways of joining hands with even Vijay.
05:06I don't know whether that's a possibility.
05:08But the big thing is, Annamalai doesn't have an extra cinematic appeal at a time when there are so many
05:15players coming with cinematic appeal.
05:17As far as Danush is concerned, well, he is, he may be estranged son-in-law of Rajini Khan, the
05:24superstar.
05:24But there has been a lot of buzz about Rajini Khan's wife, Lata, coming to Delhi, meeting a lot of
05:30people, talk of, you know, her own possibility of making a debut, you know, in politics.
05:37So there are a lot of speculation.
05:39But Danush, you know, at the moment it looks like, I mean, the path we have seen of Kamala Hassan.
05:45The Kamala Hassan, seen as a top-of-the-mind kind of actor, but, and he set up that Makkal
05:50Nidhi Mahiyam, but finally failed to click because he could not, you know, have a way with what he was
05:58actually trying to achieve.
05:59He's also not, he's not a Masi star, sir, like, you know, Vijay or Rajini, Masi.
06:03They have, in fact, appeal across the state.
06:06And Danush, Danush is again not a, you know, mass-miss actor.
06:09So there is, and by the way, let us not forget Ajit also, actor Ajit, who has a fan following,
06:17and recently the Vijay meeting up with Ajit in UK.
06:23Yeah.
06:23The direction with the motor race, sporting event, and et cetera, et cetera.
06:27But that is also a lot of talk of buzz, because I can say for a fact that some attempts
06:33were made before the Tamil Nadu elections by one political party to, you know, contact Ajit.
06:38To see whether he could come in.
06:40But then Ajit and Vijay are good friends, so personal friendships do matter in this kind of political possibilities.
06:47Well, nobody would believe that on social media because of the rivalry that their fandom is involved in.
06:52And also, sir, I will say that I've spoken to Mr. Ajit multiple times, and he's very, very clear.
06:57His passion is motorsports, not politics.
06:59He wants nothing to do with politics, and he's made that amply clear to me.
07:03But Mr. Sumansi Raman, if you look at Dhanush, if you look at Anna Malaya, and the timing, really, of
07:07them making these moves,
07:09it's not like, you know, they're taking the full-fledged political plunge immediately.
07:12They're taking their time, they're setting their base, because they know that, you know, if they're looking at elections and
07:17create an impact,
07:18they have time right up till 2031.
07:20And many would argue now is perhaps the best time for new players to step in, because they've seen, one,
07:25the success of Vijay.
07:26Second, that there is a fatigue with Dravidian parties.
07:29Yeah, I think that they, both of them, and including the likes of Sivakarthike, and also, they sense that.
07:36They sense, what if Vijay fails?
07:39People are not extremely keen to go back to the DMK.
07:43So, who, if not the TVK?
07:47Becomes a very, very interesting question.
07:49So, if people are looking for a younger generation of leadership, and they do not want the two Dravidian parties
07:56back,
07:57then that leaves you with TVK versus who?
08:01And that is the void that these various, you know, people are trying to target and fill.
08:09So, I'm not too sure that either Annamalai or Danush would be very successful, simply because of the track record
08:18that they have shown.
08:19But what if, and this is of course a hypothetical situation, because it hasn't happened, but what if Rajini Khan
08:25steps in to back Danush, sir?
08:27No, I don't think so.
08:28I think, see, Mr. Rajini Khan's time in politics is long over.
08:33I don't think that if he, even if he endorses, and I don't see him endorsing his son-in-law,
08:40even if he did that, I do not expect it to have any impact.
08:45In fact, had Rajini Khan himself contested also, he would have lost.
08:50He would have lost quite badly in those days.
08:52The reason for Vijay's success is the timing, and most importantly, the DMK's government's performance.
09:02Without the DMK, Vijay would not be in power.
09:06He owes his office to the DMK and its ruinous governance of five years.
09:12Okay, so that you say is the biggest factor.
09:14Mr. Shekhar Iyer, you know, if I were to focus for a moment on Danush,
09:18and the fact that you have all of these stars, like Mr. Sumansi Raman also highlighted,
09:22the fact that Shivakarthi Kane has also been dropping these hints that he could be looking at starting some kind
09:26of a movement.
09:27These stars sure may be inspired by Vijay, but do you think that it's easier said than done
09:33for all of them who are setting up these fan associations, thinking that the next step will be politics?
09:39Akshita, you know, just by adding Yakam to their, you know, fan club,
09:45you know, they are not going to follow the Vijay's route, because Vijay also did it in 2009.
09:50See, one more thing, see, Danush, Shivakarthi Kane, they are looking at their own social background,
09:56which is also very important in Tamil Nadu politics.
09:59But then, Vijay will command the support of women for some more months to come, or if not years,
10:05because that is his biggest plus point.
10:08And Danush or Shivakarthi Kane do not exactly fall in the league of being extremely popular,
10:15like Vijay with women voters particularly, because Vijay's success is largely because
10:20the minorities vote shifted, the women vote shifted, and also some sections of OBC votes.
10:27So therefore, you know, Tabernad is again back to this caste arithmetic, how it works.
10:32Well, Danush has also, and Shivakarthi Kane also, they have always played that, you know,
10:38the kind of youth from those underprivileged backgrounds, you know, working hard against
10:42the system and making it big.
10:44This is a typical of their stories compared to Vijay, whose films have been largely entertainers,
10:50more of a romantic thing, and also a person who fights for women.
10:54No, sure, sir, messaging matters in these films, but ultimately, I think it comes down to
10:58the kind of support, the fan base, the craze over these stars, and I don't think any of
11:04them can really compare to Vijay.
11:06Their film's success will matter for them to also be successful in politics, whether
11:10they like it or not.
11:11That's what helps, really, in setting them up for success in the manner that Vijay tasted.
11:16But thank you very much, Mr. Subhansi Raman, Mr. Shekhar Iyer, for joining us.
11:19Interesting that, you know, you're seeing the Tamil Nadu political landscape expanding, because
11:23for decades, it's been essentially ruled by just two political parties.
11:27And suddenly now, there are so many more options entering the fray.
11:32And so already, I can tell you, I know it's very, very early on, but in the next few months,
11:37years, we're going to see some very interesting political developments shaping up for 2029
11:41and 2031.

Recommended