- 4 months ago
Did the Nationals make the right call with Foster Griffin? Grant & Danny discuss whether Washington could have kept Griffin and extended him a qualifying offer, what that decision would have meant, and how it compares to the move they ultimately made before the MLB trade deadline.
Category
🥇
SportsTranscript
00:00We've been talking Nats trade deadline.
00:01We'll get into the commander's wide receiver room.
00:03I got an interview with Traylon Burks, some cuts from Jeremy Fowler,
00:06VSPN on the show yesterday, predicting that Diggs is still very much in play
00:10for Washington, so that's all coming up.
00:12But we haven't had a chance to take calls after yesterday's deadline until right now.
00:18Danny, we're trying to get a feel for if people are okay with what Washington did.
00:23I think it was a really prudent deadline.
00:25They took a arm in Griffin, who's probably walking at the end of the year,
00:29and they tried to add pieces to the system.
00:32They took a guy in Luis Garcia, who they don't perceive to be the player that he was
00:37as he turned into Barry Bonds this year, and they sold him at peak value.
00:40And I don't think the mead trade was one they were really looking to make.
00:44He wasn't on the block.
00:45He's a controllable talent on the cheap that turned into a good player.
00:48They were able to get a starting pitcher of five years of control.
00:53Why not do that?
00:54So in the end, I'm okay.
00:56I think the Connelly early deal was an A.
00:59I like the Luis Garcia Jr. trade as an A probably, maybe a B+.
01:05The one that is not going to sit as well is just that it's a really mediocre return
01:10for Foster Griffin.
01:11I just think that's what the market was.
01:12So unless you want to just have him sit around until the end of the year
01:16and possibly walk for nothing, I'll take it.
01:19I'm going to give it a C, but it's a deal I would have made.
01:21Yeah, how much the only – I think I'm with you on all those.
01:23Maybe it's a B+, A-, for Garcia.
01:25Of course, time will tell on all of these.
01:27But if it's a legitimate question as to what's more valuable, the compensatory pick,
01:33a sandwich pick they would have gotten for giving Griffin the qualifying offer
01:36and having him walk, or the return of middling prospects,
01:42if that's a legitimate question, it's hard to feel excited about this trade in particular.
01:46Does that make sense?
01:47If they just let him stay here, kept trying to sign him to an extension again,
01:50we don't know all the conversations that were going on behind the scenes
01:53and how close they were, if it was never going to happen,
01:55if the agent said, you know, miss me with that mess, we're going to free agency, period.
01:59We don't know everything about that.
02:01So to me, you know, how much better off would you be with that sandwich pick
02:05or with, you know, kind of their mediocre haul?
02:09I think that's the only one where you kind of go, yeah, it sort of is what it is.
02:12You kind of shrug your shoulders.
02:13That's the least exciting of the group, but I understand why it happened.
02:15Yeah, so two other thoughts before we hit the phones.
02:18The first is on Luis Garcia, just something that I've been kicking around myself
02:21the last day or so.
02:23What is Luis Garcia really from a value standpoint?
02:27Let's be honest about this.
02:28He's leading the league in slug.
02:30I think that's what's so complicated and why so many people are thinking differently about him.
02:35But just as relevant is that he almost wasn't even kept on the 40-man roster this offseason.
02:40And if you really look at the player, take his name and how he's performing in the moment
02:45in the last month, in the last couple months out of the equation, he's a left-handed hitter
02:49who doesn't hit left-handed pitching, hasn't in his career.
02:52He is a guy without a defensive position, really.
02:55He's been better at first than second, but he's still fringy average, a tick below average at first.
03:00He's a bad defender at second.
03:01And he's a bad base runner who's a slow base runner.
03:04I think he's 22nd percentile in speed.
03:06Now, that sounds very negative for a guy that has been great for the Nats this year
03:10and that I actually like because he's mashed.
03:12But my point is, if you're looking at this as a GM adding a piece,
03:16really good offensive player, having a great year, always going to make contact,
03:20not swing and miss, but he chases a ton.
03:22But he is a left-handed hitter who's probably going to mash righties and not hit lefties,
03:27who doesn't run well, who doesn't defend well.
03:29How much are you really getting for him?
03:31Like, we're, what do they call it, Ashburn syndrome, as I'm sitting in Ashburn?
03:35We're doing, you know, Anacostia River syndrome or, you know, Navy Yard syndrome.
03:43You're not going to break the bank for Luis Garcia.
03:46The one thing I'd want to know from an ownership standpoint,
03:49as people are trying to tie this deadline back to the ownership, not committed, not spending, what have you,
03:55I asked Paul Taboney about this, as a matter of fact,
03:58in his little media Zoom that he did after the deadline yesterday.
04:02You know I've brought up the qualifying offer a bunch.
04:05Did he have the ability to keep him around and extend a qualifying offer to him?
04:12Because the way that that would work is it would be about $22 million, a one-year deal.
04:17It's like a franchise tag in baseball is the way to think of it.
04:20One-year, $22 million offer to Foster Griffin where you just slap this qualifying offer on him.
04:25Now, unlike in football with the franchise tag, Danny, he does not have to accept it and be there.
04:29He can turn it down, but when he turns it down, you get draft pick compensation.
04:34That would have been just outside of the second round, like a top 60-ish pick,
04:39that would return a prospect way better than anything they got in the Griffin deal.
04:43Now, they might say we like the quantity of four lottery tickets over the quality of one prospect
04:48who ranks fifth, sixth, seventh in the system, something like that.
04:51But the reason I want to know this is, did ownership tell Paul Toboni,
04:55yeah, we'll offer him the qualifying offer, one-year, $22 million?
04:58Because if he accepts it, that's them paying him more than they've paid anybody by like $7 million.
05:04Three times more.
05:05Well, from a pitching standpoint.
05:07They gave Nelson Cruz $15 million.
05:09But you're right.
05:10I think, what is it, Trevor Williams at $7 million?
05:11$7 million.
05:12Yeah, 3X for a pitcher.
05:16Maybe, you know what, I think it was a $9 million deal for Soroka, maybe if I remember.
05:19But regardless, they have not paid a pitcher even half that much.
05:23But if he goes to them and he goes, hey, I'm thinking I want to do this qualifying offer thing.
05:26We're going to ride this out with Foster for the rest of this season.
05:29Let's slap a qualifying offer on him, and you either pay him $21 million for a year,
05:34and we keep a good pitcher around, or he says no when we get a draft pick.
05:37If they said, yeah, we're not doing that.
05:39There's no chance we're risking him making $20 million.
05:42That's like a quarter of the payroll.
05:44We can't do that.
05:45That's a third of the payroll we want for next year.
05:48Well, if that's the case, now ownership's complicit in essentially not allowing you
05:53to build a big league roster and not spending.
05:55But I asked Toboni about this, and I didn't get the vibe or the feeling
06:00that he wasn't allowed to do the QO, but I would love to know that with some truth serum.
06:04I think it's the essential question.
06:06Because, again, whether he's allowed to or not, but just do the balance sheet,
06:10are you better off with the compensatory pick or four middling prospects?
06:14If that's the legitimate question, and I think it is a legitimate question,
06:17you can make arguments either way, it's hard to be excited about the trade haul.
06:21And that's kind of my only semi-negative from this trade deadline.
06:25You know, and the fact that, yes, here we are again.
06:28But the Griffin question, it sort of relates to ownership, to your point,
06:33whereas the others are just regular old baseball things.
06:35Hey, they've got a good offense, and they're dealing with a position of strength with Garcia.
06:39They've got replacements in Ortiz and Brady House coming back up, et cetera.
06:42We think we'll get similar production, not as good, but similar, and we'll be just fine.
06:46We needed some pitching help.
06:48The Griffin one, I think, kind of relates to the big picture, and we don't have answers.
06:51We have no clarity on that.
06:52Darius, play the clip.
06:53This is to Boney on the QO yesterday.
06:56Yeah, I did have ongoing conversations with ownership with all that.
06:59I'm not going to get into the details of what it looked like when we had those conversations.
07:04But the qualifying offer one is a tricky one,
07:06because what teams are balancing is whether the player is going to accept it,
07:11whether the player is going to turn it down, and basically what happens if the player does accept it,
07:15what happens if the player does turn it down, and you get the draft pick compensation and all that.
07:19So it's a really tricky one to balance,
07:22and it's one that I'm not sure that any team approaches with the utmost amount of confidence.
07:32But, yeah, we were comfortable to roll the dice and having Foster here through the rest of the year
07:38without an extension and potentially considering that.
07:42Having said that, you know, I think a lot of what happens over the course of the next two months
07:48would have dictated, right, whether, like, Foster was going to receive a QO,
07:53and then it's up to him, like, whether he wants to accept it or not and kind of what comes
07:57with that.
07:58So he said we were comfortable to roll the dice,
08:00and then he talked about how he finished the season would have determined if he accepted it or not,
08:05meaning if he really struggled,
08:07then if you're rolling the dice that you're going to offer him the qualifying offer,
08:10one year and $20 million is a no-brainer if he finishes the year with, like, a 4.2 ERA
08:15and he had a terrible August and September, right?
08:17But I took that to mean almost, like, they were nervous that maybe he'd take the offer.
08:23And I don't think this is an ownership thing.
08:25I think this might be a Tobonian front office thing.
08:28Do they want to pay a 92-mile-an-hour throw-in lefty with seven pitches over $20 million?
08:34They talk about the raise.
08:36You know, like, I talk about the handsome dude with abs that I want to be.
08:39You know what I'm saying?
08:40Like, I don't know that they want to pay that kind of money for this player.
08:44Not to say you'll never pay $20 million for a pitcher,
08:47but a guy that, you know, you're going to give 4X to after you brought him over from Japan
08:51who'd never pitched in the big leagues before this season.
08:54Let's go to the phones.
08:55800-636-1067.
08:57Start you off with Carlos and Alexandria on the fan.
08:59Carlos, trade deadline yesterday.
09:01Were you okay with it?
09:02I kind of like it.
09:06And here's my main point, okay?
09:09Actually, I've got three main points, but here's the first one.
09:11Don't knock quantity over quality.
09:14Quality and quantity in prospects is a really relative thing.
09:18I remember on this station, when you guys, when we discussed the Soto trade several years ago,
09:24people were mentioning James Wood and Robert Harrell in the same sentence.
09:28That's the first point.
09:29So you don't know what's going to come out of it.
09:31You're going to judge this trade three years down the road.
09:34The second thing is, is I think this club thinks they had a version of Griffin in the Connelly kid
09:41under control for five years.
09:43And so they're sort of slotting him in there.
09:47The other thing is, is it's very clear to me that they didn't see him as a piece of the
09:52puzzle
09:53going two, three years down the road when these sluggers, if they're still here in the lineup,
09:57are matching up on pitching and they can go out in the free market next year
10:02and probably get better starting pitching.
10:04And the last thing I will say is don't knock 92-mile-an-hour lefty pitchers with seven pitches
10:11or Tom Glavin will have a word with you.
10:13Carlos, thank you, buddy.
10:14A little bit different sport now, but well said.
10:16I think Tom Glavin would get knocked around pretty good these days.
10:19Well, the essential part of that to me, again, is we don't know if they didn't think
10:24Griffin was going to be part of it.
10:25Again, there was buzz about them trying to sign him and it ended up going nowhere.
10:31So that's the only part of that for Carlos that it doesn't quite jive with me.
10:35I think what happened was they realized it was not going to happen for one reason or another.
10:39It takes two to tango, of course, or it wasn't going to be at the price they wanted or whatever.
10:44So now, okay, we're going to move on from Foster Griffin.
10:46And once you get to that point, it's not a great market for that guy.
10:49And I'm actually more with Carlos.
10:51I care way less about velocity than everybody who's obsessed with it now.
10:54I care about effectiveness and getting outs, and there's a million ways it's going to catch.
10:57But velocity is one of the great predictors of pitching success.
11:01Because that's all that comes through now.
11:03In other words, there's no Greg Maddox.
11:06There's no Glavin.
11:06There's no Dennis Martinez.
11:07I understand, but I'm saying the guys that throw slower don't have the success as the guys that throw harder.
11:13And batting average against, as velocity goes up, goes down.
11:17Teams wouldn't be chasing it if it wasn't analytically proven that you have more margin for error and it's harder
11:22to hit velocity.
11:23It's a self-fulfilling prophecy because that's all they're looking for.
11:25That's all that makes it to the major leagues.
11:27And yes, you were certainly looking for that.
11:28That's the cheat code.
11:29That's the easy way.
11:30I'm not saying it's easier to not throw harder.
11:32I'm saying there's no room at the table for anybody that does it any differently at this point.
11:37And someone's going to figure that out and have a staff that maybe is undervalued that actually produces some decent
11:43results.
11:44But that's another conversation for another time.
11:48But does that make sense to what I'm saying about Griffin specifically?
11:51I think it was a, hey, behind the scenes, I think a couple people were like, yeah, we'd love to
11:54sign him.
11:55And maybe there's some overtures.
11:56Let's try to do that.
11:57And then it doesn't happen.
11:59That's different than the, yeah, he's not part of their plan, so they just moved on.
12:02Yeah, I think he's part of their plans for sure.
12:05Well, it was.
12:06I guess I have to use past tense.
12:07I mean, they would tell you they're going to try to sign him once he gets to the market this
12:11offseason.
12:11I've never bought that.
12:12Like, if a guy's going to stay with you, he's going to stay with you.
12:15Generally, when you break, like breaking up to then go on dates with other people and see if you like
12:20me best, you've already told me how you feel.
12:24But I think that they went to him and pretty quickly found out he was not going to sign a
12:29deal ahead of market at whatever they were offering.
12:32Now, I'd like to know, were they offering $12 million a year or $18 million a year or $20 million?
12:37Who knows?
12:38But that wasn't going to happen, and then they pivoted.
12:41The qualifying offer thing is still what's most interesting to me because I just want to know if they had
12:47the ability.
12:48He said we were comfortable.
12:50I took that to mean they were allowed to go that route if they wanted to.
12:55Let's go to Scott in Lake Anna on Grant and Danny after the trade deadline.
12:58Scott, how did you feel about what the Nats did?
13:00I'm kind of okay with it.
13:03My point is I don't think, as good as that front office is, I don't think they really appreciated the
13:12chemistry that had bonded those really young players, Meade, Wood, C.J., Garcia.
13:21They became a musketeers group that thrived off of each other's performance.
13:29And that drove the team to do things that nobody expected them to do this year.
13:35And I think you're going to see, and we've seen it already, that the stress of that trade deadline and
13:43the potential for losing guys that they felt were really part of the team, from the team member's perspective, it
13:52just took the wind out of their sails.
13:54It's a good call.
13:55Yeah, thank you.
13:56It's a really good call.
13:57I mean, I wonder about that.
13:58Like, they're going to have to try to reinvent this.
14:00They created a culture that allowed for the chemistry that you're talking about to take hold.
14:04It's hard to reinvent.
14:06I will say I'm thinking a lot about the Orioles, who had this great farm system and never really took
14:12their shot, Danny.
14:12They never really shot the gun.
14:14You know, and they wouldn't trade the prospects, and they hoarded them all, and they all got ready at the
14:17same time.
14:18And, you know, they won 100 games on accident.
14:21Mike Elias always thought next year was the year.
14:23Like, you do have to have some feel of being willing to break away from your vision, break away from
14:28your plan, and really going for it.
14:29I just don't think this was the year to do that by any means for the Nationals.
14:33But he's definitely right that they had a special thing in that clubhouse.
14:36Devoni talked about that yesterday, being aware of that.
14:39But they're going to have to recreate that.
14:42It's hard to do.
14:43They're not going to just be able to show up in West Palm and do the exact same thing and
14:46be number one in offense next year.
14:48It's not going to work like that.
14:49No, but again, can you be a better baseball team?
14:51And I think that is a variable.
14:53Yes, you're weaker offensively, but maybe you don't have the worst pitching staff ever assembled, both with starters and relievers.
14:58It's a balancing act, certainly.
15:00And it is something that does matter, and I give you more credit than me.
15:04You've always kind of always tried to point out that human element of things.
15:07And they've kind of been able to get away with some of those, I don't have a better word for
15:10this, indignities along the way,
15:12sending guys down for too long, calling a guy up to get his teeth kicked in,
15:16and then sending him down for two weeks and kind of churning and burning through guys.
15:19They kind of kept the chemistry going.
15:21This may have been, I don't want to call it the death blow, I don't want to overstate,
15:24but this may have kind of been that last final arrow that took, as the caller, I think very well
15:29said,
15:30took some of the wind out of their sails on this one.
15:32And maybe it's harder to come compete every day.
15:34Now, also, your major league club got worse over the last week in the short term.
15:38I think that's obvious.
15:40Totally.
15:41They were already losing with that club, and I feel like that was still an inevitability.
15:46I just don't know how long you can kind of keep everything together with Myles Michaelis making a start every
15:53five days
15:53and Zach Littell making a start and Andrew Alvarez making a start and opening with Carson Palmquist.
15:59It's like, that's not what a playoff team looks like.
16:02That's not what a wild card team looks like.
16:05Let's go to Kevin in Arlington on the fan.
16:07Kevin, trade deadline came and went.
16:09Are you okay with what the Nats did?
16:12For the most part, I am, Grant, and thank you for taking my call.
16:16And, you know, I was really down on the learners,
16:20and then they hired my nephew's Calgary teammate, Paul Stoney.
16:24All of a sudden, I got back on the bandwagon, and I just know great things about Paul,
16:29and I wanted to see how he did, and he's been phenomenal.
16:32So, my only concern, and it's not even Paul, and it does center around the Griffin trade.
16:41First of all, just a couple of things.
16:42Is it a small sample size?
16:44Yes, it is.
16:46But, you know, starters are hard to find, particularly left-handed starters.
16:52He's a mature voice in the room.
16:54I know in recent years, there was talk about we just don't have any adults.
16:58We don't have any mature guys who sort of lead the youngsters.
17:05So, I do want to know that too well.
17:07I don't know if we ever will.
17:09I think what we're going to find out is, in the offseason coming,
17:13what are the winners willing to spend?
17:15Because if you think about it, a lot of those relievers we added,
17:18and I'm glad we pre-stopped the reliever pool,
17:22but we have barely spent anything.
17:25So, when you can get cheap and good and proven relievers in the offseason,
17:30you go do it.
17:31We haven't.
17:32So, we kind of have to – so, for me, there's still this question about
17:38how committed truly is ownership.
17:40And, I don't know, we'll just not know until we get to the offseason.
17:45Kevin, thank you, buddy, as always, man.
17:46Good to hear from you.
17:47Grant, I mean, that is the essential question.
17:48That's the sort of Damocles.
17:49It's the billion-dollar question, whatever number you want to put on it,
17:53is what's the engagement, right?
17:55What's it going to be?
17:56And with this backdrop of the labor stoppage here,
17:59that's also kind of hanging over everything,
18:01how are they approaching that?
18:03There's been a lot of data that indicates they're not interested in any contract
18:07that goes beyond this year if they can help it, given that backdrop.
18:10Who knows if that's because that's when Strasburg's coming off the books
18:12after this year, or because of the labor thing, because of the sale,
18:15the murkiness around ownership and their engagement level.
18:19Of course, it's the question.
18:20We're just peons here down on the ground getting whatever crumbs
18:24that come off the table trying to figure out kind of the on-field product.
18:27Yeah, I can't wait for the offseason for that reason, if I'm being honest.
18:30Because there's no good excuse.
18:32There have been plenty of years during rebuilds where there's no reason
18:36for the Wizards to go actively try to get better in the tank mode, so to speak.
18:40But you are now, you've proven you can compete.
18:43You need to add a starting pitcher.
18:45That's going to cost money.
18:46You need to spend some money on this bullpen.
18:49That costs some cash.
18:50And they're probably going to need a bat as well.
18:52That's not going to be the marquee move of the offseason,
18:55particularly if Abrams is still around.
18:57But I think there's a chance they trade C.J. Abrams this offseason.
19:00And they do recoup a bevy of what we're talking about,
19:03a plethora of the options that they need in some of these roles.
19:06But they're going to need to spend a little bit of cash at this point as well.
19:10And if they don't this offseason, then it's indicative of the fact,
19:13like post-lockout, whenever that ends, whatever,
19:15that it's not happening with this ownership group.
19:18I'm getting tweets from people throughout the day at Grant Paulson.
19:21I saw our buddy Tailgate Ted even tweeted today something to the effect of,
19:25like, I will not be spending any more money or buying any more tickets
19:28to go to Nats games.
19:29And I don't tell people I had a fan.
19:30That's your own prerogative.
19:32I'll see you when you come back, I suppose.
19:34But my point on that would be, like, save that tweet for when you find out
19:39they're not spending this offseason.
19:41To me, the deadline, what just happened, this was prudent business on taking a step
19:45from a pitching staff standpoint, trying to, you know, sell high on a couple of guys.
19:50I don't view this as a major referendum on ownership time.
19:53If you feel like the offseason was that, no problem.
19:56They should have spent on relievers.
19:58They should have spent on starters.
19:59I personally think they thought they were going to lose 98 games.
20:02So, again, it's like the Wizards.
20:04Should they be spending on things?
20:05But this offseason is go time.
20:07If they don't spend, if they're not committed, if they don't bring in pitching,
20:10if they are this close with this young lineup in the prime years,
20:13think of James Wood contract as, like, the Jaden Daniels deal that we talk about.
20:17Before he gets his big contract, you have this controllable time of him
20:20and Abrams, do something.
20:22What are you waiting for?
20:24And that's, to me, when I'd be firing off my, you won't see me at Nats Park's tweets.
20:28I get that.
20:29I mean, again, I also understand, as you said, I'll teach people how to fan
20:32or lecture them about it.
20:33It is your dollar, right?
20:35Totally.
20:35It's your investment.
20:36No, no, no.
20:36People can do whatever they want to do.
20:37I'm just saying that, like, the take to me, and a lot of people feel this way,
20:41is, like, the deadline yesterday, Danny, was Groundhog's Day of,
20:46Luis Garcia became really good, and they immediately traded him.
20:49And it feels like Soto or any of the other guys that they've moved on from.
20:53I just don't think it's apples to apples.
20:55That's all.
20:56I agree with you 100%.
20:56But I can understand the person that, this is my fun thing,
21:00and it got less fun yesterday for the short term.
21:02And it's not like you're getting a refund.
21:03You don't get the, you know, the percentage of your committed dollar back
21:08of the joy that Luis Garcia would have provided
21:10as he's leading the league in slunging percentage.
21:12But I understand, again, in a vacuum, on a binary, looking at these trades,
21:17I'm like, yep, I get it.
21:18I'm in.
21:18I understand in that span perspective, though, going, look at my watch.
21:21Seven years, man.
21:23Seven years of this.
21:24100%.
21:24When does that end?
21:25And I understand that.
21:26I guess that's all.
21:27From a 10,000-foot view looking down,
21:30they have not done anything financially that signals that they want to win
21:36pretty much since the World Series.
21:39That's a hard argument to come back from.
21:42Right.