- 20 hours ago
Jeff and Dan talk about how much they like the addition of Rhys Hoskins to the Guardians' roster and how they think it makes the lineup much better.
Category
🥇
SportsTranscript
00:00I didn't set the bar high enough, Dano.
00:03What do you mean?
00:05Free agency started in baseball rather than say, you know what?
00:12I'd really like to win the Powerball.
00:16I'd really like to win the Powerball.
00:18It would be nice.
00:19Omega Williams would be fine.
00:20Rolling cash.
00:22It all helps.
00:23I didn't ask for any of that.
00:24No.
00:25All I asked for was...
00:27Pete Alonzo.
00:28Well, he was my original choice, but we knew that one was kind of out of question
00:33because you figured Pete was going to get big money.
00:35Kyle Tucker.
00:37And I didn't even go there.
00:39But remember, we were going to do the Let's Recruit Pete Alonzo campaigns,
00:43and we thought it was such a futile thing, we stopped it after like two tries.
00:47Well, that's actually partially because the Orioles pounced really early on Pete Alonzo.
00:51They really did.
00:51Yeah, we didn't even have time to get it going.
00:53We didn't have time today.
00:53But then I said, and you were right there along with me,
00:57we're like, hey, Rhys Hoskins isn't going to cost you a whole lot of money.
01:04And though he's injured now, he has a history of producing,
01:10and you could get him cheap, and you need right-handed hitting.
01:13And we just kept saying and kept saying and kept saying, Rhys Hoskins.
01:18Rhys Hoskins.
01:20It's right there.
01:21Rhys Hoskins.
01:22Go get him.
01:22And guess what?
01:23Yes?
01:24The Guardians did.
01:25Yeah, baby.
01:26Isn't that fabulous?
01:27It's a beautiful thing.
01:28That's fabulous.
01:29Here's what you want.
01:30Let's be honest here.
01:32He has to go in.
01:33He has to show that he's healthy, and he has to win a spot.
01:38But this is a guy who the Brewers did not pick up his option for $18 million.
01:44He had made, what, $17 million?
01:47Guardians are getting him for $1.5 million.
01:50Yep.
01:51There's got to be incentives in there, I would think.
01:54But you have a motivated baseball player who needs to show that he can still do it,
02:01was doing it when he was healthy.
02:03Yeah.
02:03He was really good in the first half of the season for the Brewers.
02:05That's the thing I think that you have to remember here.
02:08When he was healthy, he was playing really well.
02:11You could say, well, he's 33 years old.
02:14He's getting up there.
02:15Well, he's not as old as Jose Ramirez.
02:19They just gave Jose a contract.
02:21So it's not like Reese is an old guy.
02:23He's turning 32 in March, or 33 in March.
02:28And he's got a track record of productivity that this team sorely needs,
02:34especially out of a right-handed bat.
02:36He's a first baseman, designated hitter.
02:39And it screams to me, Dan, okay, Manzardo's at first today.
02:45Now Manzardo's a DH.
02:48And Hoskins is at first base, and then Hoskins is a DH.
02:52I would hope that they both stay healthy and both get 500 at-bats this year.
02:59I think that would be a really good thing.
03:01Hoskins, Manzardo, Jose in the middle of the lineup, go hit the ball.
03:08I want you to be right.
03:10I want that to be exactly what happens.
03:12You just throw those guys out there, and you just let all of them hit.
03:16I partially wonder if they're going to put Hoskins in a platoon.
03:20A platoon with what?
03:21Well, CJ Kephas would be the one you'd circle.
03:23At DH?
03:24Yeah, maybe DH.
03:26Maybe you play one at first base, and then one plays right field,
03:28and it turns into a multi-position platoon.
03:31Hoskins has played the outfield, but not a ton of it.
03:34He's played left field mainly.
03:36You probably don't want to do that.
03:38That's not ideal.
03:40Reese Hoskins can hit the cover off the ball.
03:42He walks, and he's an A-plus teammate.
03:44And he's a guy with a...
03:46You hear great things about him as a teammate,
03:47so that screams Steven Vogt type of player.
03:50And he is a guy who has an OPS in his career over 720.
03:55And you don't have many of those guys.
03:57In fact, last year you had two.
03:59And mind you, that 720 number I keep throwing out,
04:02yes, we heard it a lot when it came to spins,
04:05when it came to snowboarding and skiing and all that fun stuff in the Olympics.
04:08That's league average as a hitter.
04:11You had two.
04:12Now you have three.
04:13If anyone has a problem with this signing, I don't know what to tell you.
04:17I don't know how you could have a problem with this signing,
04:20because it's not even costing you any money.
04:21Right.
04:23So...
04:23In seasons, and he's played eight seasons,
04:27he's had some injury issues.
04:28I'll explain those in a second.
04:30But he's played at least 107 games in five of his eight seasons.
04:35At least 107.
04:38In five seasons.
04:39In those five seasons,
04:41he averaged 29 home runs and 82 runs bedded in.
04:44I did the math.
04:45Now, his injury issues are real,
04:49but they're not chronic.
04:51And by that, I mean,
04:53it's not as if the guy has like a bad elbow all the time.
04:57Or, you know, he's always got calf injuries
04:59or always has a hammy.
05:02He was out two months last season.
05:04And he was playing really well.
05:06What happened was he made a tag play at first base,
05:08had to come off the bag and tagged a guy.
05:10And the guy jammed his thumb.
05:12And he had a UCL tear or sprain in his left thumb.
05:17So, he's out.
05:18When he was out,
05:20Andrew Vaughn came up,
05:22hit like crazy from Milwaukee.
05:24Yeah, he fixed something in a swing.
05:25And Pat Murphy has said,
05:27hey, we're going to play the hot guy.
05:29Well, Andrew Vaughn was the hot guy.
05:30And Jake Bowers, former Indian, was there as well.
05:34So, Hoskins was not on their postseason roster.
05:37But was in the dugout throughout the entire run.
05:39And was there throughout the entire thing.
05:43They loved him in Milwaukee.
05:45It's just a similar situation the Guardians find themselves in,
05:48which is they lost their local TV revenue.
05:50They don't have the ability to turn around and pick up that option.
05:53Nor do they kind of want to,
05:55because Andrew Vaughn gave them exactly what they wanted
05:57after they fixed a swing.
05:58At a fraction of the price.
05:59Exactly.
06:01In 2023, in spring training, late in spring training,
06:05Hoskins tore his ACL.
06:07So, he missed the entire 2023 season.
06:10Those aren't chronic injuries.
06:12Boy, that's a big injury you're hurt.
06:14And he did it while he was out on the field,
06:16playing at first base.
06:17And then, he tore the UCL in his left elbow.
06:21And he's a right-handed thrower.
06:23So, he tore the UCL in his opposite, not throwing arm,
06:28in a collision at first base.
06:30So, his two big injuries happened in collisions at first base,
06:34and the other happened while playing first base.
06:36So, he missed the end of the 2020 season,
06:38and then part of 2021.
06:41If he's healthy, then he's going to hit.
06:45I mean, that's what he's done in his career.
06:47If he is healthy, he hits.
06:50And you're not making a major investment,
06:52and you're not setting back your gargantuan youth movement
06:55that you have going as well,
06:57or putting up any kind of roadblocks of anyone else
07:00that you would be interested in watching play baseball
07:01for this team at those positions.
07:04Kyle Manzardo's still going to get his 500 at-bats.
07:06Fantastic.
07:07Yes, he is.
07:07Kyle's going to get them.
07:08CJ Kavis is probably going to find his way to 300 to 350 at-bats,
07:12if not more if he catches fire.
07:13Fantastic.
07:15This only adds in one more guy into this lineup
07:18if he makes the ball club out of spring training.
07:20That can, A, hit the ball hard, B, draw walks,
07:23and C, have a leadership role inside of that locker room,
07:26and it means less David Fry,
07:28which we all love David Fry as a human being.
07:31He's a delight.
07:32I was just going to bring up David.
07:34But I don't thoroughly enjoy watching him play baseball,
07:36and I know some of it came back to the fact that,
07:38well, you know, he had the torn UCL last year.
07:40He had a DH.
07:41He couldn't be able to play the field
07:43and be as valuable as he was as a third catcher,
07:45and that's fine.
07:47I'll listen to that argument,
07:48but I've watched him hit enough to know that this isn't going to improve a whole bunch.
07:52He had the really, really great start two years ago
07:56and made the all-star team,
07:59but didn't really follow it up in the second half
08:01and had the injury last year and everything else,
08:04and that's the best stretch of hitting that David has done in his career.
08:08And I, again, good player, good teammate, everything else.
08:12If you were counting on David to be your right-handed DH,
08:15you were doing it with your fingers crossed
08:18because he just doesn't have a great track record of being a big-time productive hitter.
08:23And, you know, again, as you said, good guy, extremely versatile.
08:29We'll see where his throwing arm is.
08:30You know, could he help you at catcher?
08:32Maybe.
08:33You're going to have a limited number of bench spots.
08:36Yep.
08:37But, and Reese Hoskins is not taking one of them.
08:40He will be, I would think, in the starting lineup.
08:43What does that do?
08:44Please give him 500 at-bats.
08:45Well, it takes the at-bats away from David Fry completely.
08:50I mean, that's where most of those come from.
08:53And then if you look around, let's just, for the sake of argument right now,
08:57put Hoskins just a DH.
08:59So you know who's around the infield unless something changes,
09:02and that's Manzardo, Rocchio, Arias, and Jose.
09:07Jose Ramirez.
09:09Yeah, Bo Naylor, a catcher.
09:10In the outfield, let's just say some combination of at least a start somewhere,
09:18Stephen Kwan, Chase DeLauter, and George Valera.
09:23Now, you got two big question marks there, and they both involve mainly health.
09:28Can DeLauter stay healthy?
09:30If so, you want to give him as many at-bats as you can.
09:34And George Valera, I don't think, has as long of a look as Chase DeLauter.
09:39I think George might have to produce pretty quickly.
09:42And if George doesn't, you could see CJ Cephas out there.
09:46There's another guy we're forgetting about, and they brought him back,
09:49and I would assume they brought him back for a reason.
09:52Austin Hedges?
09:54That's Nolan Jones.
09:58They haven't given up on Nolan Jones, and I thought they would, to be honest.
10:02I thought they would.
10:03They can't quit Nolan Jones, and they can't quit Gabriel Arias.
10:05They just can't quit these guys.
10:07There's another guy that we haven't mentioned, Juan Brito.
10:11Does Juan Brito hit enough in spring training to make the team?
10:14I mean, we could also throw in the Jonathan Rodriguez, Angel Martinez, CJ Cephas, Daniel Schneeman.
10:23You know, all those guys are out there, too.
10:26Unfortunately, you just mentioned four or five guys who you, again, have your fingers crossed on
10:32and think, well, okay, and where would you play them?
10:35Well, okay, we could play Martinez at second or even at shorter, and certainly in the outfield.
10:40That's great.
10:40And Cephas can play first in the outfield.
10:43The only thing for Cephas, now he has two guys ahead of him for the exact same spot, really.
10:51Although I don't see Hoskins in the outfield too much.
10:53Yeah, I don't think they'll put Reese Hoskins in the outfield.
10:55I wouldn't think so, but you never know.
10:57I can't see that.
10:58He's played some left field, but it's been a while.
11:00He played some for Philly earlier in his career, but I don't see that.
11:06That guy's in my lineup every day.
11:07Yes.
11:09And Manzardo's in my lineup every day.
11:11Yes, please.
11:12And Jose Ramirez is in your lineup every single day.
11:15Yeah, if Manzardo and Hoskins are healthy, 150 games each.
11:20You know, you'll give them the occasional day off, but they've got to play 150.
11:24Because that gives you some oomph.
11:27It just gives you a little bit of pop.
11:29Again, the dude has averaged 29 homers and 82 runs batted in, in the five seasons where
11:35he's played at least 107 games.
11:36And I explained the injuries to you.
11:39And, you know, it's not like he chronically has a bad shoulder or something like that.
11:44These were big time injuries that happened by colliding with people.
11:47Basically, nobody on the team last year, other than Jose Ramirez hit 29 homers and nobody
11:52drove in 82 runs.
11:54And this guy's averaged that over five years.
11:57Yeah.
11:57So, please be healthy.
12:00And Steven Vogt, please put him on the field and leave him alone.
12:05Yes.
12:06By the way, his splits, lefty-righty, they're pretty comparable.
12:09Yep.
12:09His batting average OPS down a little bit against right-handed pitching.
12:14But, again, it's the major leagues.
12:17You're going to see mostly right-handed pitching.
12:20There are lefties, and he's done a little better against lefties.
12:24Yeah.
12:24But he's hit right-handers real well.
12:25It's not drastic enough that you're taking a bath by throwing them out there against righties.
12:29You wouldn't even, I wouldn't even think you would even consider platooning him based
12:32on his past of hitting right-handed pitching and hitting it well.
12:36This is a great move.
12:38It's the reason why we've been screaming, this is the move that you need to make for three
12:41months.
12:42This is a great move.
12:43This is a perfect move.
12:45It's a perfect Guardians move.
12:46Just put him out there and let him go, and then start making decisions at other positions
12:52so that you can set up a position where Kyle Manzardo gets 500 plate appearances, Reese Hoskins
12:59gets 500 plate appearances, Jose Ramirez gets 500 plate appearances, and let's go.
13:04And everywhere else, you can figure out as you go, but at least those three guys need to
13:08be out there for that amount of time.
13:09Folks, it seems like you have a middle of the batting order right now.
13:12You got guys, you can hit three, four, and five.
13:17You didn't have that last year.
13:19Can you give the Guardians credit for making what looks like an absolutely no-brainer move?
13:24I certainly can.
13:25And we have 216-474-0092.
13:28All right, dude.
13:29All right.
Comments