- 6 weeks ago
37- Who Wrote Anne Frank's Diary_ من الذي كتب مذكرات آن فرانك؟ الجزء الثاني
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00May the peace, blessings, and mercy of God be upon you
00:09Today is the second part of the book discussion, The Diary of Anne Frank, by Swedish author Dietleb Wilder.
00:16The book, as I said in the previous episode, is a very small book, only 80 pages.
00:24But the book raises dozens of questions about things that seem illogical to him.
00:34In fact, I find these questions to be legitimate questions, and it was the duty of Anne Frank's father to...
00:44If Otto Frank could answer these questions with some logic
00:50But let's continue with the second part. Let's continue asking the questions that...
00:59It was presented by Detlieb Feldra, and we will see at the end of the episode whether his words are logical or not.
01:09For example, in the dot part, we start by asking how a 13-year-old girl writes her memoirs.
01:19She writes about her family history in some detail, and she writes about the nature of her father’s work and the nature of her father’s company’s relationship with another company in some detail, as if she is familiar with the work in the region.
01:37By working on tracking her, her nature, who her partners are, and her family history.
01:47Here, Detlieb Veldra says, “How can a 13-year-old girl ask these questions? He wasn’t the only one who said this.”
02:00This question or this point also caught his attention in a book called The Twentieth Century Hoax by A.R. Potts, in which he said the same question.
02:13He also asked and wondered how a 13-year-old girl could write her daily diary and review with such precision the details of her family and also review the procedures.
02:27The German government's actions against the Jews in some detail, so it is difficult to believe that this was written by a 13-year-old girl for Al-Kalam Dot.
02:39But this is a question that is considered the most important of the reasons. There are other questions that are much stronger. For example, let us start with the topic of the hiding place.
02:54The place where Otto Frank and Anne Frank's father chose to hide
03:01He hid in his workplace, which is a warehouse.
03:08A spice store because he used to trade in spices
03:12He hid in the same building.
03:19In the same building, I will show you a detailed design of the place where they were hiding.
03:33Or as they say, they were hiding in it.
03:38The question here is why did he choose the place where he works to hide in?
03:45I mean, isn't this the case? It's as if it were an easy place for the Germans to find him in. If the Germans were looking for him, it would be an easy place for them to find him in.
03:56How did he choose this place, which is considered a disgraceful place, a place where people come and go?
04:04Because according to Anne Frank's diary entry dated July 9, 1942, on page 14:
04:14She says that the Germans were searching for, hunting down and chasing Jews.
04:22There was no worse place to hide than his workplace.
04:29In addition, there was a Jewish pharmacist working in his workplace.
04:34If the Jews were oppressed, forbidden from working, and persecuted by the German Gestapo
04:43How could these Jews work in the same place where Otto Frank's company worked?
04:50How come the German Jews did not find these Jews and did not discover the secret of the hidden place and all of this?
04:59But the issue remains that the Germans were not, according to what Detlik Feldrup said, searching for Jews.
05:10They were just looking for stolen food and stolen bikes.
05:16Because during this period theft spread in a striking way
05:20Even Anne Frank herself wrote in her diary that her bicycle was stolen.
05:26This was on June 24th in her diary, which she wrote in the form of a diary.
05:35Every diary has a date, such and such date.
05:39In a memorandum dated June 24, 1942, page 7
05:46She said her bike was stolen.
05:49Here, the author of the book, Feldra, says that the Germans were not looking for Jews or anything.
05:55They were looking for stolen food.
05:57On stolen tools
05:59On stolen electrical appliances
06:01On stolen bikes
06:03Another strange thing is that the owner of the house
06:07I mean, the memo also says that they suddenly found that a new owner came to inspect the place to buy it.
06:19So the question is, how is the owner of the house?
06:23He sold the house without informing the company owners.
06:28And the people who work in the building, that is, without him informing them
06:33And without him coming to help the house at all
06:37That means someone will sell his house
06:39He should at least come and appoint the place
06:42He is supposed to come with the new buyer to inspect the house.
06:47But the new buyer, the new owner, came with an architect to inspect the place.
06:56The surprising thing is that there is a locked door
07:02This is the door that separates the workplace from the apartment where he was hiding.
07:09Or the part of the building, the back house, where Otto Frank was hiding
07:16And with him was another Jewish family named Van Tan.
07:21The closed door that separates them
07:26According to Anne Frank's diary
07:29The office manager
07:33He said to the new owner
07:37He told him that he didn't have the key to open the door so they could see the rest of the house.
07:43And the owner after that did not ask about the secret place, so he did not ask him to open the door to see the rest of the house. He did not ask him. So how can someone buy a house without seeing half of the house? He is the one behind this door, the secret apartment, so many floors, this, this, this, this, this, this, this, half the house exactly, half the house.
08:01The second thing is that after that there is a shelf in the bookcase, a shelf in the library that covers the entire door. So the question here is how did the owner of the new house not ask to suffer?
08:19In a shelf book shelf in a library that covers the entire door, so the question here is how did the new owner of the house not ask about this library, how it came, when it came, and who put it there, and wasn’t there a door behind it? Where did this house go?
08:38If this library had existed when he first saw the house, how could Frank have said in her memoirs that...
08:49The office manager told the new king that he did not have the key to the door.
08:54If the library is what prevailed
08:56The door was definitely there.
08:59Medicine and the library were destroyed after that
09:01The king's house is not surprised or inquired
09:05He has no curiosity to even know what is behind that door.
09:09The architect who was with me
09:12This is all written in Anne Frank's diary.
09:15The architect does not have a blueprint for the whole building.
09:22I know that behind the door is the other half of the house
09:28How can they buy a whole house without even seeing half of it?
09:32I mean, it's not logical, of course.
09:35Illogical talk
09:37The upper room, which is called the attic
09:41It was full of food.
09:44That means a very large number of legumes, meat, sausage, water, and fifty cans of vegetables.
09:54All of this did not attract the attention of the new owner to ask.
09:59I mean all these foods
10:02In addition, the two families who lived together, the Frank family and the Vandan family
10:10And the dentist who was with them
10:12All of them were adults, apart from the children. All of them were smoking cigarettes voraciously.
10:17I mean, the Adlas used to smoke cigarettes voraciously.
10:22I mean Chain Smoker
10:24Cigarette after cigarette
10:26Cigarette after cigarette
10:27All that cigarette smoking didn't make a stink.
10:31No smoke coming out
10:33Leave it to the new king who comes to see the house
10:36Nor do the employees who are present every day work during the day.
10:41None of them noticed that there was cigarette smoke and the smell of cigarettes coming from the other part of the house.
10:50The secret door dot
10:52Or the closed door
10:54This is Al-Ghamid
10:55There was a ladder in front of him
10:57Salma disappeared later
10:59It was taken away
11:00Who took it?
11:01When was it removed and why was it removed?
11:02Nobody knows
11:04Frank in her memoirs says that the stairs that were
11:10This secret door and the stairs that lead to it
11:13You say it wasn't like the Dutch stairs.
11:17It was not a step like the Dutch stairs.
11:19Step means
11:21sharply rising or sharply falling
11:25She is a 13 year old girl
11:29Yes, yes, it is known as the Dutch stairs.
11:33To compare its writing
11:35To compare in writing between the shape of this ladder and the shape of the Dutch ladders
11:40I mean the way of writing, the style of writing is one big style
11:45He entered many houses and knows all kinds of people
11:49I know the Dutch style, the German style, and the English style.
11:56One means a senior, experienced person
11:59It is not the style of a 13-year-old girl to write a simple diary.
12:05The hideout remained. How did the German Gestapo police not notice that there was a hole in the middle of the house? They had not searched it before. How did they not notice this point?
12:25The notes continue to say that the German police are not accustomed to and not experienced in the engineering of Dutch houses.
12:37So I don't realize that half of the house is dot, they haven't seen it before.
12:43But the memoirs always referred to the police as the Dutch police, not the German police.
12:50That is, in a diary entry dated March 29, 1944, page 171
12:56She pointed out to the police that it was the Dutch police, not the German police.
13:00Daily Newspaper, April 11, 1944, pages 179 to 181
13:07On May 6, 1944, page 20
13:11All of these have police references, meaning the Dutch police.
13:15The only time I mentioned the German police
13:18When she said that the German police were taking the Jews and transporting them to camps
13:24She heard all this talk on the BBC.
13:30I heard it on the BBC, even the officer who discovered them
13:36And the Jews took all these two families, I mean
13:42He himself says according to what he saw
13:44He did not know that these Jews were selling him to gas chambers.
13:48Every time he hears this from the same notes
13:51And he wonders how a 13-year-old girl
13:54Imprisoned knew the subject of the gas chambers
13:58He is the same officer who knows nothing about him.
14:00I've never heard of it before
14:02But of course it is clear that she and her family were always listening to the media.
14:06On the radio every day all day
14:09And the BBC was publishing such talk
14:13Since England was at war with Germany
14:16The English media was controlling it.
14:20Zionist propaganda machine
14:23All these answers were understandable in their promotion and dissemination.
14:29Second question, second point, I mean
14:33Veldra Piothera is the windows that are always closed.
14:38There were windows in the first hall.
14:41First floor lobby
14:43The hallway, the back door
14:48His hiding place
14:51The window was covered all the way around.
14:56covered in squares
14:59I mean in a carton
15:01I mean squares like this
15:04Who needs light to shine on the lights?
15:06This is what is written in the notes
15:08But here Veldra is wondering
15:11Spices are supposed to be put in a drawer.
15:14Or in Jars, I mean
15:17In boxes, for example, or bottles
15:23The concept is placed in something
15:25And placed away from the pressure
15:27Keep it locked well
15:29Also, so that its smell does not change.
15:32But don't put it on the floor
15:34In her reply on the first floor
15:36He says that the notes say that the window on the first floor
15:41It is sealed to protect the spices from light.
15:45nonsense
15:46Because there were no spices on this first floor at all
15:49The spices were stored in the attic.
15:53The second thing is the fire and safety laws.
16:00They were not allowed to close the window and cover it constantly.
16:05They put a piece of paper on it to block out the light.
16:09Because of course it is unhealthy and legal, fire laws, security and safety
16:17You couldn't allow this talk
16:19Because it makes her whole life dark and gloomy
16:23If only this window was completely closed
16:25I am completely covered
16:27The notes say that they used electricity at night.
16:35And once the bill was very expensive
16:39Fayzai electricity that works at night
16:43I didn't notice any of the neighbors
16:47Anyone walking outside knows that there are people living in this part of the house.
16:51This is three roundabouts
16:53Fayzai Al-Thalatha, a roundabout in which two families live.
16:57No one takes his door or any of the neighbors'
17:01It means he feels that there is a light going off and on
17:05Even the windows, they said, were covered with curtains.
17:11Even behind the curtains, it is clear that there is light.
17:15Night Special
17:17Even if she says that she once went upstairs
17:23Attic and binoculars
17:25It means I mended
17:27The families of the neighbors on the opposite side
17:31She saw a family having dinner.
17:35And there is another family watching a movie
17:37The same story would have happened if she did this to her neighbors.
17:41What is possible for their neighbors as well?
17:43When they notice that there is something strange happening in the place
17:47They also spy.
17:49They did not discover that there were people living in the place.
17:51This is supposed to be empty
17:55Besides that
17:57Her diary also says that they were
18:01They watch movies and books at home.
18:03I mean they had a projector
18:05They had a projector and they were
18:07They watch movies
18:09Inside the house
18:11Also the projector and lighting
18:13Those who came out of the projector
18:15And the sound of movies
18:17All of this is not a file
18:19Anyone who looks at it has a resident
18:21There are residents
18:23So that the files are not seen by the police
18:25There are people living here in the place
18:27This
18:29And she says that all the windows were covered.
18:35In the ten efforts
18:37Everyday efforts
18:39And all the curtains are closed
18:43So
18:45Also, no one noticed all of this.
18:49Be careful, there is movement starting at ten o'clock
18:51Everything is closed
18:53And even you say that during the day they were also staying
18:57Pull the curtains
18:59But there are certain windows
19:01They put cartons on it to close it completely
19:05Smoke from the stove
19:07Another point
19:09How does the smoke from the stove
19:11Chimney rising
19:13It didn't catch anyone's attention.
19:15There are people living in the wake
19:17Those who are sprayed on him
19:19And the heater in the winter
19:21How is the smoke rising?
19:23From the chimney
19:25It didn't catch anyone's attention.
19:27And as I said, continuous smoking
19:29All adults
19:31They were very nice.
19:33In smoking
19:35This is the smell of smoking, it did not affect the spices.
19:37They were covering the nets.
19:39On the light
19:41Escalating
19:43And smoking itself
19:45It did not affect
19:47The smell of spices
19:49It is supposed to stay pure.
19:51Where did they store the food?
19:53They were all
19:55They were greedy.
19:57Smoking like this
19:59All this cooking
20:01Where did they store it?
20:03I did not find the storage location
20:05How can people be hiding?
20:08They are supposed to save their money for essentials.
20:14They spend their money like this on cigarettes and smoking.
20:19All of this is a risk that their affair will be exposed.
20:24And the police discover their secret
20:27Even she herself wonders in a diary entry on July 8, 1944, page 227:
20:38The writers say, "Amen, we're really supposed to be hiding."
20:42I mean, she herself doesn't believe they are hiding.
20:46They want a very normal life.
20:50It was so natural that she and her sister were reminded at school of it through the messenger.
20:56The school followed them according to what is mentioned in the notes
21:01I followed up on their homework and school lessons.
21:04They pay zakat at home, do homework, and send it by mail.
21:07There was mail going back and forth between them and the school.
21:11All this and no one is at the post office
21:14He did not notice that there were no people living in this house and that mail was delivered to the house.
21:21He didn't find people living there, so he started to suspect that Margot and her father were Margot's older sister.
21:27And the father himself, Otto Frank, also began to study Latin through the mission as well.
21:38There is a natural and continuous correspondence between them and the school.
21:45All of this did not catch anyone's attention at all.
21:48Which point is stronger than that?
21:51The noise that was always coming out of them
21:55That means she is saying that they are forbidden from making any sound or noise.
22:02Starting at 8:30 until she wrote in her diary on August 23, 1943
22:09Page 95: It says 8:30 in the morning.
22:14No water allowed. Walk quietly. Not a drop of water is not allowed. Not even a drop of water.
22:20No bath, no walking, everything is completely quiet.
22:24Even though she lied, it came in a diary entry dated September 2, 1942.
22:32Page 22 says that there was a big fight between Mr. and Mrs. Van Daan.
22:39I've never seen anything like this in my entire life.
22:42My mom and dad can never scream at each other.
22:46Oh, and these notes are full of quarrels and betrayals between all members of the two families.
22:54They were all at odds with each other.
22:58Even the writer, Feldra, says that their problem was not with the Germans.
23:05This is their problem between them, they could not stand each other
23:08It even says in another diary dated January 15, 1944, page 122:
23:18There is no point in telling you every time the details of our quarrels and arguments.
23:24She said that she was beaten for dancing ballet every evening.
23:30In the diary of January 12, 1944, pages 122 and 121
23:36And on December 10, 42, page 52, it says that Peter, who is Aiden Vandan, is the other family.
23:42He was cutting wood. They used this wood for fuel in the winter for payment.
23:48They use it as fuel for cooking.
23:52For the position, he was cutting wood and performing acrobatics in the room with his cat.
23:58All this noise and their daily chores, one is cutting wood
24:04It breaks wood
24:06And all of this without the sound coming out at all
24:12No one heard of it, no police are looking for Jews.
24:14Don't pay attention because something abnormal is happening in the house.
24:18We will stop here in today's episode
24:22God willing, there will be a third and final part to conclude the discussion of this book.
24:28Anne Frank's Diary is a hoax by the Swedish writer
24:32Dietlieb Feldra
24:34See you soon
24:36God willing, I will record this episode before the beginning of Ramadan.
24:40Say goodbye to her before the beginning of Ramadan
24:42And the holy month of Ramadan
24:44May the peace, mercy, and blessings of God be upon you.
25:02See you in the second part
25:06It will not be tomorrow
25:08They are before Ramadan
25:10I have to finish this
25:12God willing, if I still have life
25:14May the peace, blessings, and mercy of God be upon you
25:30Think of your duty as you think of your right
25:34He worked in pursuit of mastery
25:36Not seeking fame or reward
25:38Don't expect anything from people
25:40More than people have the right to expect from you
25:42Do not expect more from people than they have the right to expect from you.
Recommended
25:38
|
Up next
26:03
Be the first to comment