- 7 weeks ago
36- Who Wrote Anne Frank's Diary_ من الذي كتب مذكرات آن فرانك؟ الجزء الأول
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:30We hear it from Anne Frank's diary
00:31Of course we all hear about Anne Frank, the Jewish girl.
00:35who was hiding with her family in a house in Amsterdam
00:40She remained in hiding for two years.
00:44until they were discovered
00:48and taken to a concentration camp
00:54They moved from one camp to another.
00:56until she died in 1945 from typhus
01:03Which was widespread at that time, especially among Jews.
01:07The book that we will discuss today is the book
01:10The question arises as to who wrote these memoirs.
01:18He asks several questions, and discusses these notes.
01:23And there is a shadow of doubt that it is Anne Frank herself.
01:26She is the one who wrote this book
01:28But the writer's name is Diet Lip Filtria.
01:33It is not said that Anne Frank did not write the diary.
01:38We all say that she wrote a small part of it
01:42The rest of the book is someone else's.
01:46Who wrote these notes?
01:48He says that her father is the one who completed writing this memo.
01:51So I try to discuss his book, present it, present it and ask questions about it.
01:59Because there are many logical questions and there is no logical answer to them
02:05Because the book, and in this case the book, is small
02:09I mean, it's only 80 pages now.
02:11and published it in 1978
02:14But even though it is a very small book
02:18But it's hard to cover it all in one episode.
02:23Because it is a book about history
02:25Every page
02:30Every page means we can't ignore it.
02:33There is logic in it, there is something that can be raised and discussed
02:38And it is brought to your attention that means
02:40So, should I try to divide these episodes into parts?
02:44It might take me two or three episodes.
02:50We will see, but we will try to keep the episodes as short as possible.
02:55I will try from 20 minutes to 30 minutes at most.
02:59So let's begin
03:02The author's name is Dietlieb Feldra.
03:05He was born on April 23, 1942.
03:09It means next Wednesday
03:12Almost next four
03:14He is 78 years old
03:16He is Swedish
03:18He was imprisoned in 1988.
03:21for ten months on charges of
03:24You are a simist
03:27Against anti-Semitism
03:33He is an anti-Semite.
03:35In 1994, he was charged with the same offense.
03:39And also imprison him for ten months.
03:42The sentence was for one year.
03:44The year was reduced to ten months.
03:47on charges of anti-Semitism
03:49on charges of anti-Semitism
03:51In Canada, it was considered a prison.
03:55Three and eighty I said eight and eighty
03:56No prison medication in eighteen months
03:58And in eighteen months
04:00Eight years left
04:02He was killed by his witness in
04:05In Canada in a court in Canada
04:07In court
04:10German publisher
04:13He is known to deny
04:16The Holocaust and Pinker
04:18Gas chambers and deny all talk
04:20His name is Ernst Zendl.
04:23Ernst Zindel Dutt was also imprisoned for seven years.
04:28In Canada and Germany
04:30He recently passed away at my age there.
04:34seventy-eight
04:36And amazingly, any word said about this matter
04:42Not Holocaust denial
04:46Or just downplay the number of Jewish deaths.
04:56They just killed the ignorant.
04:59There are not six million licks or anything
05:02This suspicion is enough to send a person to prison.
05:08And a lot, a lot, I mean it's not up for discussion
05:13For the time being, I remember who to imprison and who to jail
05:16It only has six long, wide letters with people's names.
05:20Historians imprisoned in Western countries
05:25Because they either denied the Holocaust
05:28Or they doubted the six million dot number.
05:31This means that this makes us question the credibility of freedom of opinion in it.
05:36In Western countries in general
05:40Of course, when we compare it to freedom of opinion in France and Denmark.
05:46Because there are bad pictures of the Messenger, peace be upon him, that appear
05:50We find that they do not even allow Muslims to object under the pretext of freedom of opinion.
05:56But if anyone said a word against the Holocaust
06:00Or doubt the number of deaths, he is at risk of imprisonment for a long time
06:06double standard
06:12The important thing is that before I ask the questions that Fielder mentioned in his book...
06:21Let's give a very quick overview of the girl herself and her family.
06:25Before we get into discussing her memo
06:31She was born on June 12, 1929 in Frankfurt, Germany.
06:37She has an older sister named Margot.
06:41Her father's name is Otto Frank.
06:43Her father's name is Edith Frank.
06:45Her father established a company in Amsterdam, Netherlands.
06:53He moved to Amsterdam to start and manage this company.
07:00This was in 1933
07:06In December 1933
07:09Edith Frank, whose wife followed him with her daughter Margot.
07:15Who is the older sister now?
07:17In February 1934
07:20Anne Frank followed them because until then she had stayed with her grandmother.
07:27When they smile first
07:29From 1933 to 1939
07:33About 300,000 Jews
07:36They left Germany for the Netherlands.
07:40But in 1940 Germany invaded the Netherlands.
07:45The persecution of Jews began.
07:49And search for them
07:51Otto Frank was forced to take his family and hide in a secret apartment inside a building.
08:02It has a secret door
08:04We will talk more in the next parts, Part 2
08:08About the shape of the apartment from the inside, the foundation of the building itself, etc.
08:14But he moved there to this apartment starting from July 6, 1942.
08:22On July 13, 1942, another family of three joined them.
08:28A family known as the Dhan Bells
08:32This is the man, Baser, with his wife and son, Peter.
08:36They were joined by another dentist named Fritz Piva.
08:42Frank, as I said, died in 1945.
08:50The first version of her novel was published in 1947.
08:56Year 47
08:58She wrote her memoirs in Dutch.
09:04Of course, when she was in Germany
09:06She didn't speak Dutch.
09:08But when I went to Holland and joined the school there
09:10I learned Dutch
09:12The memoirs were written in Dutch and German.
09:16And sometimes in some English words waiting means
09:24The book in its Dutch version was published in 1947, meaning two years after Anne Frank's death.
09:32The book is called Hatakhtehuis
09:36Hatkhuthuis means back house in Dutch.
09:40On October 52, 52, the first English translation of the book was published.
09:48Which was called The Diary of a Young Girl
09:51Diary of a Little Girl
09:54In another version in 63 it was 240 pages.
09:59It has an introduction by George Stephens.
10:03This means we start very quickly about the family
10:07We don't want to go into details.
10:09Because the topic of the episode
10:11not
10:13Not the family
10:15no
10:17Her baggage
10:19The topic of the episode is not the book or the memo.
10:21Which she wrote specifically
10:23The topic of the episode is the book
10:25Who writes on the diary?
10:27Who is discussing these notes?
10:31That is, we will take this book and present the questions in it.
10:35We will see if the questions are answered.
10:37It means logical
10:39We do not agree with her
10:41Because
10:43Feldra means what is in his life?
10:45To study this history of World War II
10:51To study what happened to the Jews at the hands of the Germans
10:55He is a Holocaust denier.
10:57Pinker originally gas chambers
10:59He is not the only one who says that
11:01In a large group of new historians
11:05That's their name
11:07New Historians
11:09New Historians
11:11The new historians are not from Germany.
11:13only
11:15Even from countries
11:17victorious allies in the war
11:19Give another version of what happened.
11:23And I am casting doubt
11:25According to the story that was transmitted to us
11:29About what happened in World War II
11:31And he did not start World War II in the first place
11:33because
11:35We must remember
11:37That history
11:39Written by Al-Montaser
11:41and that
11:43If the party
11:45The defeated is the one who won
11:47But we
11:49We study history
11:51In another way
11:52But there is
11:54We used to say different things.
11:56And our time is convinced of completely different things.
12:00Because the victor is the one who writes history
12:02The defeated is not present
12:04To deny
12:06Or confirm
12:08The version that is told to us
12:10So now we will raise some questions that he mentions in his small book Dot
12:24He knows for example
12:26This gas question
12:28We start with the gas chambers.
12:30We will talk about it later
12:32Because he himself left
12:34And he saw
12:36so-called gas chambers
12:38The one who built
12:40newly
12:42I mean, after World War II
12:44after
12:46Russia's entry into Germany
12:48And the Nabus
12:50They are the ones who built the gas chambers.
12:52The important thing is that this is a percentage
12:54In another episode
12:56It is a special episode about who
12:58who started world war 2
13:00And its causes
13:02What happened exactly?
13:04I mean, as I say
13:06The history that we know and that is being told to us
13:08This is not exactly what happened
13:10I'm not saying everything is wrong
13:12But there are many things
13:14The Victorious
13:16He told us a certain version of history.
13:18We are supposed to believe it.
13:20But no, we are not supposed to believe her.
13:22We are supposed to study and read
13:24We use our minds
13:26These three things
13:28So
13:30So
13:32He says, for example, about gas chambers
13:34He says that
13:36coercion
13:38After being discovered, she was sent to three camps.
13:43The first camp is called Westerbork.
13:46Three detention camps inside Germany
13:49Westerbork's name is the first prisoner.
13:51The second famous camp, Auschwitz
13:56This is the second camp on September 2, 1944
14:00Then they moved to the third camp where Anfranc died.
14:05The third camp is Bergen-Belsen
14:09And there she died in March 1945
14:14She died of typhus
14:19Typhus disease in English
14:23Which is a disease that is characterized by fever
14:27Its name in Arabic is almost Hama Al-Nashamiyya
14:30It is a kind of flattening that appears on the skin.
14:34Its color is purple
14:38With fever, cough and contagious disease
14:43I pass it on to another person
14:45It was very popular during World War II.
14:48There are tens of thousands of Germans, Jews and non-Jews.
14:51Tens of thousands died, but it was widespread among Jews.
14:56He says that she is Frank and she is Jewish.
14:59Why didn't you die from the gas?
15:01I would like to hear her family's story that she died of typhus.
15:04The second thing is that her father is Otto Frank.
15:07He was taken to a hospital in Auschwitz.
15:11He was treated there and came out safe.
15:14What I want to say here is that if the Germans had put Jews in gas chambers
15:20Her father was working at the Autoshopitz Hospital.
15:23He was cured, treated, and recovered and came out safe and sound.
15:27Why didn't he die in the gas chambers?
15:30Why did Anne Frank not die in the gas chambers?
15:33She died of natural causes, like tens of thousands of others who died from this disease.
15:38There are other questions left. Let's talk about the book itself and the notes themselves.
15:44Logical questions posed by the writer
15:50For example, why does Frank's father say that he is Otto Frank?
15:59Why did he keep the original copy and never show it to anyone?
16:05When Dietlieb Wilder himself, the writer, contacted him in 1977,
16:11Try to contact him or contact him already
16:15He asked him for information confirming the authenticity of the original copy.
16:23The man meant Lord positively and that he would help him, but when Dietleb Feldtra asked to see the original copy himself,
16:37The man told him that he had sent him a message and that he had told him everything he could.
16:43I don't want to hear from you again
16:45I mean, I don't want any contact between you and me again.
16:49Even when Dietleip Wilder was the writer, he is Swedish, by the way.
16:55When he tried to contact or even know where the handwriting expert lives
17:05Who came back and looked at the original copy of the notes
17:12He didn't know who separated from her and he didn't know that he called her or anything at all
17:18I don't know how to reach her. I don't know how to reach her. Her name is Fagaw Mina Beka.
17:24Fgaw Mina Bika De means Mrs. Mina Bika is the handwriting expert
17:29Who confirmed that these lines are original notes?
17:34But it is a mysterious character that the writer never knows how to reach.
17:40By the way, even after the Dutch government helped a private foundation,
17:55Foundation established Anne Frank Foundation
17:59The Dutch government helped them buy the entire house where Anne Frank's family lived.
18:06And the houses next to it, so that the whole block becomes like a historical museum.
18:12Indeed, the house was converted into a historical museum for the people.
18:17For tourists to visit
18:20But the surprising thing is that the opening day of this museum
18:25Or Madhhaf in classical Arabic means we speak naturally
18:29The Classical Qur'an
18:31When this museum was opened
18:36Otto Frank did not display the original copies of the diaries.
18:42Okay, why? And he continued even after he died.
18:46He died in 1980.
18:49The first time the original copies were released and displayed in that museum was in 2010.
18:58That is, 30 years after the death of Otto Frank.
19:04Anne Frank's father
19:06Fifty years after the founding of this museum
19:10When we see the copies displayed in a glass case
19:15Glass box like this
19:17We find doubts and questions
19:21Veldra questions in place
19:24For example,
19:27He says this handwriting is not the handwriting of a 13-year-old girl.
19:34One big line
19:36Assuming this is Nabegah's handwriting
19:40This is the handwriting of a 13-year-old girl.
19:43The girl stayed for two whole years
19:46From 13 to 15 years old
19:49How come her handwriting hasn't changed?
19:51All notes are written in one handwriting.
19:53There is no change
19:56And the second question is who are you going to?
19:59The notes were written in
20:02The first note written in the agenda
20:05This agenda was Anne Frank
20:08She bought it with her on a shopping trip.
20:11With her father and mother on her birthday
20:13When it was 13 years old
20:15I bought this agenda, it's a small agenda.
20:19This is my agenda. I will tell you the Surah.
20:25It has squares like this now
20:28red and white
20:30And it closes
20:32And she started writing a note that she didn't get tired of
20:36And after that, this is not over
20:39I started using notebooks for school.
20:41As we know, school notebooks are not huge.
20:46You can't write a book on it.
20:51But the book is the houses that were published
20:54These notes were published.
20:57It was published in 240 pages.
20:59Or at least 230 pages depending on the edition.
21:03The question is how?
21:06Yes, three copies, three agenda notebooks and two notebooks.
21:10It is possible that they contain a book of 230 pages.
21:18A book of 230 or 240 pages requires fifty notebooks.
21:24Because handwriting
21:29The word remains larger than the printed word
21:33The space between each line and the next
21:36The page on the notebook will not take up a page from the book.
21:40He told me three pages from the notebook.
21:42for example
21:44The whole notebook will be like this:
21:4630 pages
21:4848 pages
21:50Things like this a lot, I mean.
21:52I need a large number of notebooks.
21:56He wonders how he said this
21:58However, Otto Frank says that her father says that not everything that was kept secret in the memoirs was published.
22:06Only part of it
22:08I mean, part of it was published in a huge 240-page book.
22:14So how?
22:15How much is the size that was published?
22:17Your duplicate is as big as what is not published
22:20He said that the things that were not published
22:23It was not published because it contains words that may upset some people who know them.
22:30It also has parts that contain sexual content and parts that do not.
22:34It has some explicit words.
22:38I mean, don't imagine that a 13-year-old girl could write such things.
22:43Some of the things are mentioned and some of them are not.
22:46All of this is confusing because these paragraphs are written by the same girl who wrote these words.
22:53And her father is the one who wrote these words as a kind of best seller and to find popularity with foreign readers.
23:04In America in particular, I mean in Europe in general
23:10In the West in general
23:12The other thing, for example, which could mean an online phone, comes in the same topic.
23:24Anne Frank always called her father or referred to her father in her diaries as
23:33She points to Ben BM, that's his pet name.
23:37How can a 13-year-old German girl refer to her father by a pet name?
23:44I say this is not the personality of any German girl, especially in her junior year.
23:49I say this is the German way
23:51I mean, can I believe this if it comes from an American girl?
23:55But it does not come from a German girl
23:58She is 13 years old
24:00It is permissible that she received or was educated and raised well.
24:08And the expert, Mina Bakr, is the only handwriting expert who has seen the original version.
24:16She confirmed that it was correct, saying that the notes were in three parts.
24:22Three notebooks, that means
24:23Agenda and two other notebooks
24:25So the agenda and two other notebooks could fill a huge book of 240 pages.
24:32This raises doubts that her father is the one who completed writing these memoirs.
24:39There is a part, yes, that Frank actually wrote.
24:42He denied it, there is no doubt about that.
24:44But the writer Detlef Wildra's opinion remains that this part is a very small part of the book.
24:53Most of the book was written by her father, Watteau Frank.
24:59The second thing that also raises some doubts for him is how eight people can live in one small place.
25:12And no one ever notices that Frank is writing her memoirs.
25:18Because her father himself said that he did not know that she was writing her memoirs. The first time he saw these memoirs was in 1945 after he consulted Amsterdan.
25:29Frank says in her memo dated October 9, 1942, pages 34 and 35, that Jews are being taken to concentration camps to be killed by gas.
25:49But Feldra says that it was written on December 13, 1942, page 54. She wrote that she saw two Jews walking in the street.
26:06From the window of the house means
26:09He says how there were Jews walking in the street like this comfortably
26:13At the time when they were being persecuted and taken to detention centers to be killed by gas
26:21There is a book called The Twentieth Century Hoax written by A.R. Potts, in which he says on page 174 that BBC broadcaster Thomas Mint says that German hospitals kill between 2,000 and 3,000 people every day.
26:39They send the linguistically injured, the elderly, and the physically weak to the gas chambers.
26:53The question means
26:55I mean, if Germany wanted to send the Jews to the gas chambers to be executed...
27:01Why did you send them to the hospital in the first place?
27:03You treat them first, you treat them first, and then you send them to the villages for gas.
27:07Why do you send special care to the elderly, those with language injuries, and those who are physically weak?
27:13First of all, it follows the youth.
27:15This is what this broadcaster, whose name is Thomas, from the BBC, was mentioning.
27:25Later, everyone knew that his words were lies and that he was paid by the Zionist propaganda machine.
27:33And she says in her diary on June 20, 1942, on page three:
27:45And on July 9, 1942, page 14, it says that the Germans are the ones who...
27:53Jews were forced to wear the yellow Star of David on their chests.
28:01So that they can be distinguished and recognized as Jews
28:05The fielder says that this is a lie because the saucers originally used the Star of David as their logo to make them feel proud.
28:19Their affiliation with this star is evidenced by the fact that the world newspaper, De Welt, which was edited by Hertel,
28:30The Zionist newspaper logo was the Star of David, and in a gathering that took place in the city of Chicago on July 3rd and 4th, 1933, the flag of the Zionist entity was placed with the Star of David between the two lines.
28:54He says, "This is a lie. The Star of David was originally the symbol of Zionism and the symbol of the Jews. They took it as a symbol, not the Germans. They are the ones who made it bigger."
29:06We end the rest of the episode. I don’t want the episode to be long because there are many questions and inquiries, and I will leave them for the second part.
29:18But I ended the episode by saying that the memoirs were full of hateful expressions against the Germans.
29:30Although any word against Zionism is against Judaism and against Jews in general, Judaism
29:42It is considered a crime in the West, a hate crime, a hate crime, a hate crime, a crime of inciting hatred.
29:50Until all the words that call for hatred of Germans in the memoirs that Frank
29:56There is no talk about it. For example, she says in her book:
30:01She wrote the diaries in the form of diaries in the form of letters, meaning she wrote them to an important person named Kitty.
30:10A friend of hers had a friend named Kitty, but then she discovered that there was no one named Kitty.
30:16This character received it from a story like this, I hate it
30:20In a daily journal dated November 19, 1942
30:26It says on page 42 to 48
30:29You say that Germans are the most remote people on earth
30:32And she says in a diary entry dated November 17, 1942:
30:36From page 42 to 46
30:38You say in the order
30:42Speak in a low voice and all civilized languages are allowed.
30:48That's why speaking German is not allowed.
30:52All of these are racist words and phrases that incite hatred towards Germans.
30:58The writer says that the aim of the memoirs is to spread hatred of the Germans.
31:06As if the Jews were the only ones affected by World War II
31:13To give the Jews this first goal
31:15The second goal is to give the Jews an excuse.
31:22To seize Palestinian lands and commit all the crimes they committed against the Palestinian people
31:29And the legend of Anne Frank must live on.
31:34Because the memoirs of Anne Frank de Hee are the pillar on which it is built.
31:42Because I use the definite article, but it is a strong pillar on which the Zionist state was built.
31:51Zionist entity
31:53This is what Feldran himself says about the meaning of this legend.
31:58Proving its falsity is a strong blow against the Zionist entity.
32:04That's why they are so protective of this myth being perpetuated.
32:09Because it is very clear that there are people from the West who want to
32:14Not only Germans, but also English, French, Russians, and Americans.
32:24Not convinced by everything said about the Holocaust and the Ghassam rooms
32:31There was persecution of the Jews
32:34Nobody can deny this and nobody can accept this
32:37We do not accept it, we do not approve of it, and we cannot deny it.
32:43But to this extent what is said to us and transmitted to us
32:49No, here we need to take a pause and study both sides and see what was said here.
32:59We see the historical evidence provided by new historians.
33:05God willing, I will have enough time to discuss some of their topics.
33:10But I'll stop here so the episode doesn't get too long.
33:14The second part, God willing, will contain evidence and very interesting and important questions raised by the book.
33:24Because it deals with the life of Anne Frank's family inside the house
33:29How did they live and how was the whole book full of questions?
33:33Very logical questions, but unfortunately there are no logical answers to them.
33:38Or at least we propose it, I mean I propose it now
33:42I mean, quoting from the book
33:44Even if there are logical answers to it
33:47There will be a dialogue, there is no argument
33:52We always say that freedom of opinion is the most important thing as long as this freedom of opinion is presented with respect, politeness and in a decent manner.
34:03We are against suppressing freedom of opinion and against the suppression of freedom of opinion
34:10So thank God I am in Hong Kong
34:13There is no crime called anti-Semitism
34:18anti-Semitism
34:20No, everyone is free to think, ask questions, and discuss anything without fear of being thrown into prison.
34:32See you in the second part
34:35It won't be after tomorrow, before Ramadan. I have to finish this, God willing, if I have time.
34:43May the peace, blessings, and mercy of God be upon you
35:00Think of your duty as you think of your right
35:06He worked in pursuit of mastery
35:09Not seeking fame or reward
35:12Do not expect more from people than they have the right to expect from you.
Recommended
25:49
|
Up next
26:03
Be the first to comment