- 6 months ago
38- Who Wrote Anne Frank's Diary_ من الذي كتب مذكرات آن فرانك؟ الجزء الثالث
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00May the peace, blessings, and mercy of God be upon you
00:10Today is the third and final part of our discussion of the book The Diary of Anne Frank: A Hoax by Swedish author Dietleb Wilder.
00:19Which refutes everything that was mentioned in Anne Frank's diary and casts doubt on the source of these diaries
00:31And that Anne Frank was the one who wrote most of what was in it
00:36In the last episode, we stopped at the noise that was coming from the hidden house.
00:45Which was living with Anne Frank's family and another Jewish family, Vandan, and with them the dentist Dussel
00:54So all this noise didn't attract anyone's attention, especially the German or Dutch police.
01:04Except they were supposed to be looking for hidden Jews.
01:10And the house was always in a state of noise, all along it was in a state of noise, uproar, quarreling and arguing.
01:19Every member of the two families was always quarreling and arguing with everyone.
01:27This is what she said on August 9, 1943, page 89
01:32Although they were in another place, another situation or another position, she said that her sister Margot had caught a severe cold and they had forbidden her even to cough.
01:48How could they have been in a situation where they forbade their daughter who had a cold from coughing so that no one would hear them have a cold?
01:55All the notes are about their betrayal of each other, their disloyalty, their shouting and screaming.
02:03And the radio is also one that cuts wood and the roads are in my way and he does acrobatics and Peter's son
02:12They listen to the radio all the time, every day, until eleven o'clock in the evening.
02:19We listen to them on the radio, and the obesity doctor, whose name is Dossel, was shocked.
02:25Once, he treated Mrs. Van Daan and the treatment turned out to be wrong. I mean, his hand was too heavy for her, so she screamed really loudly.
02:35She and they were all laughing at her, and whenever they laughed, she screamed, and her screaming stuck.
02:42This screamer did not attract anyone's attention, even after his experience, he was able to bring a dental drill.
02:52Dental Drill Performance Dentist Uses for Teeth Cleaning
02:58By someone who brought him a dental drill, this is the one that cleans teeth
03:09And he kept it in the office downstairs in the basement. He was treating people who married him.
03:17It was in business, meaning he opened a clinic, so how could someone hide and see patients? Something else, I mean, there was nothing abnormal.
03:31There were people who used to come to visit them, two girls, I mean two friends of the family.
03:37They used to come and visit them, and they spent the night with them. One time, on October 20, 1942, they spent the night with them.
03:49This is mentioned on page thirty-seven and thirty-eight, and a week later another one came named Elie.
03:57They also have visits, people coming in and out, and people come to visit them and come back with them and spend the night with them.
04:07I mean, this is a normal life. It's not people hiding from anything.
04:14Besides, the good and comfortable life remained. These are people who were supposed to be hiding and living in hardship.
04:21He only said that they were living in comfort and luxury.
04:27In more than one place in the memo, it clearly indicates this.
04:32And you say that they are very lucky, that they are very lucky compared to Jewish children.
04:39Those living in Germany and the Netherlands
04:42This is represented by the abundance of food. Their food was in unusual abundance.
04:48especially in times of war
04:50Especially since they have an abundance of food, meat, vegetables and fruits.
04:54Not only that, but there are also cigarettes and alcohol.
04:58That is, in the diary entry dated December 17, 1942, page 95, it was mentioned that they were drinking cognac.
05:08On page 27 of May 13, 1944, they were drinking beer.
05:16Of course, they don't drink cognac, beer and wine only during these three days.
05:22But it was clear that they were constantly drinking alcohol, and it was always present with them.
05:26She only mentioned the dates on which she mentioned these drinks.
05:32And in another place it is mentioned that they were cooking cakes and dumplings.
05:34It meant a family living in luxury and comfort.
05:36Not a family hiding, living in hiding, afraid to make any noise
05:56Live in luxury
05:58A family in hiding, living in hiding, afraid to make any sound, living in terror all the time
06:06The memoirs say otherwise. This is not an impression we can get that there is a family living in terror and living in hiding, afraid.
06:17Her secret could be revealed at any moment.
06:20Let's talk about Al's character herself. She says on page 202, dated May 8, 1944:
06:29That is, a few months before her matter was revealed, she said that she was dreaming of making a lot of money after winning the war.
06:38That means her dream when she was still a child was to have a lot of money and make a lot of money.
06:45And he also acknowledged her, saying that she was a spoiled brat.
06:51She says that her father and mother are the reason for this pampering.
06:56She wrote a text that meant her pockets were full of sweets, what more could one ask for?
07:05A little girl with her pockets always full of sweets, what more could she want as a little girl?
07:11And in another place also, we discover that she was taking a huge amount of valerian pills.
07:25Valerian is an herb extracted from the valerian plant. It is taken to treat insomnia, anxiety, and psychological and nervous stress.
07:36This is mentioned on September 16, 1943, page ninety-seven.
07:42We notice that this girl has internal violence and suppressed anger, which she mentioned in her memoirs more than once, about her desire to punch so-and-so and so-and-so.
07:54She said that it was her habit when she got angry at someone to punch them.
08:02The counter means that she no longer has any money, and she wishes to have it again.
08:09She said she wished to beat Mr. and Mrs. Vian Dard with punches, I mean.
08:16Now let's talk about her romantic relationship with Peter, Mr. Dan's son.
08:26The truth is that she wrote about her relationship with Peter Dott, which is shocking writing, shocking that it came from her 13-year-old daughter.
08:41Not only does Nabit Shiul have a crush on Peter, but she also has idealistic tendencies.
08:48This is evident in her thinking, her thoughts and imaginations, which she wrote down in these memoirs.
08:57It is very clear that this entire large part of the writing is by an adult who wrote these words, not the words of a child.
09:08A big one wrote this and it was written specifically for the book to be sold clearly
09:15Even the writer, Veldra, says that he considers her a child sex trafficker.
09:26Because this is not a book, it is not a child who writes these words, and even religious Jews
09:35The Jewish rabbis declared their extreme anger and dissatisfaction with the book and considered that it offended the Jews.
09:47I mean the religious Jews themselves, not the slutty Jews who are sluts, not Jews.
09:56There are many Jews who are not honest, as religious Jews have strongly expressed their dissatisfaction with this book and that it offends the Jewish character.
10:09She herself, because she means that she describes herself as a playful girl.
10:18A playful girl wrote this on March 19, 1944, page 160.
10:24A girl who covers her hair for a year describes herself as a playful girl
10:28Make it clear that this whole part is fictional.
10:33Unless the girl has had a disturbed personality since childhood and an abnormal and abnormal personality
10:40But, I think this part was written by an American who wrote the part dot
10:46Or her father who wrote it
10:50Or another one who helped him write from the publishing house, I mean
10:55But this is written by a person from Jabal who wrote these words.
10:59The final question remains: were these countries really hiding?
11:05People live like this and with this daily routine
11:10From the hustle and bustle and listening to the radio and watching movies
11:14They make cakes and smoke cigarettes constantly.
11:20And drink cognac, aperitif and all that.
11:24She is the one who mentioned this in her memoirs.
11:29Does all this give the impression that these are people in hiding?
11:32And the worst thing is that it got worse
11:34Peter says on April 11, 1944 on page 183
11:40You say Peter walked around the building twice a day.
11:458:30 and 9:30 in the morning he was circling around the house
11:50Why is he circling around the house?
11:52I mean why were they circling around the house?
11:54If they were hiding from the Germans?
11:56Why does the boy go out every morning and walk around the building?
11:59They are commissioners hiding from the Germans?
12:02But it is clear
12:05That's what Fielder said.
12:07I think the talk is very logical.
12:09Unless the people who promote this myth or this talk, I mean
12:17If they respond with logical answers
12:21They refute these questions and respond to them with logical answers.
12:26Reply to this writer
12:28On Detail Fielder
12:30And give logical answers
12:32It is just a mouthful that says that they were not hiding from the Germans and there is no need for that.
12:37He says that they do not deny the existence of this family.
12:41And do not deny the existence of your enemy
12:43He says yes the family was there
12:44Yes, I lived in this place
12:46But they weren't hiding from the Germans or anything.
12:49They were just living in the workplace.
12:54So that they keep an eye on their merchandise.
12:58At their workplace
13:00So that Otto Frank would be the garages of the managers who run the office
13:04And the employees' groin
13:05And because of you, theft became very widespread in those regions during the war.
13:11His eyes will remain on his merchandise.
13:13On his spices
13:15And all the office tools
13:21and all his possessions
13:23This is my opinion, which is closer to the truth.
13:26It is more logical when we read the notes.
13:30We will see what their lives would have been like if the time of the wicked Arabs had passed, you gentlemen.
13:33Another thing, you say on April 11, 1944, page 177, what do you write? What do you say?
13:43They were working on breaking into the warehouse.
13:46I mean, she and he are up on the first floor
13:48You are talking about thieves one day on April 11th
13:52There were some thieves around him, trying to open the store and steal what was in it.
13:57So what do you say? In the blink of an eye, my father, Fandan, and Peter rushed downstairs.
14:05Okay, what if these people are hiding from the German police?
14:10Samoa movement on the ground floor
14:14They are on the first floor and Samoa movement is on the ground floor
14:17How do you know these texts?
14:20It could be the German or Dutch police trying to open it.
14:25They are coming down to chase away the thieves.
14:31I mean, how did they know they were thieves?
14:34Not German police or Dutch police
14:37Writer A.R. Potts, as I said in the second part of the episode
14:44Author of the book The Hoax of the Century Nashi
14:46He wrote, "The memoirs are written in a journalistic style."
14:50Chronicles the Frank family
14:52And the measures taken by the Germans against the Jews after their invasion of the Netherlands
14:57It is unbelievable that a thirteen-year-old girl would write this.
15:03Another need for the filter is to not change its font.
15:07I mean, she started writing her memoirs when she was 13 years old.
15:10And until their matter was discovered in Wa’eda, 15 years later, two years later
15:16Her handwriting has not changed over time.
15:19It has not changed, but rather we find that there is more than one line.
15:25He wrote large parts of the memoirs.
15:32It's not a matter of her handwriting changing.
15:34No, this is a completely different line from hers.
15:37More than one line
15:39How in one period of time?
15:44The font has changed dramatically.
15:49And how, over the course of two years, it began
15:53In 42 and ended in 44 the line is as it is
15:58In the middle, the line has been changed to a line that is marked as the line of an adult man.
16:03Not a child's handwriting
16:06And before Otto Frank died
16:09I mean, I'm doing research on the internet
16:12I found news in it that before the death of Otto Frank, who is her father, he died
16:17Died in 1980
16:19German intelligence is like the FBI in America.
16:23German detectives returned these notes.
16:26And I discovered that a very large part of it
16:29Anne Frank couldn't have written it.
16:33When I tried to take a screenshot
16:36The news has reached the news
16:39I tried in every way to bring him back
16:43I didn't know, but I showed him
16:46All evidence supports this.
16:49I mean, how are there three notebooks?
16:52Three school notebooks, a small agenda
16:56too small
16:58As I translated it to you
17:01He has two notebooks and some papers. He has a book of 240 pages.
17:07This 240-page book requires at least two-thirds of forty notebooks.
17:13So that we can own the handwriting and everything in it
17:17The last thing left
17:19Which means we conclude the discussion of this book with it.
17:22Before I go on, I want to show you some paintings.
17:26And the state is far away
17:29The book is the book of the pen and ink
17:33But it has many large parts.
17:36And a lot is written in dry pain
17:41Dry Pain hit European markets in 1949.
17:48The notes are supposed to be written from 42 to 44.
17:52Who wrote the parts that were written with such dry pain?
17:56Impossible, of course she died in 45
18:02In March 45
18:04I mean, four years ago, before the dry pain even hit the market.
18:09They were discovered in 44
18:13It took five years before the dryness subsided.
18:16It was made clear that her father was the one who wrote all these parts.
18:19This is why the German investigations said that a large part of the notes
18:27Anne Frank didn't write it.
18:29I present to you now some maps and some drawings of my design for the house
18:39To see how Anne Frank lived in the house dot
18:45For example,
18:48This is the house dot
18:50Is it him?
18:52The part on the north
18:56Where do we see the house divided into parts?
18:59The part on the left is the work
19:03Office
19:05Ground part of the goods
19:08Part 1 Offices
19:12The second floor is between offices and a warehouse for goods.
19:16Notice that there is a small corridor.
19:18In the door of Aho
19:20The door is what separates the two buildings.
19:24The second building on the right is the one they were hiding in
19:27It is not on the ground floor, but we note that the ground floor was also a storeroom.
19:32But the first dish
19:35The first floor above ground was inhabited by the Frank family.
19:43The second floor above ground was inhabited by the Zandan family.
19:49The third floor remained the upper room.
19:52It also means a storage room for spices.
19:55You will notice the corridor with the door separating the two buildings.
20:02Notice that there is a bookcase
20:06In Bokshilf, opposite the door, surrounded directly along the way
20:10If we look at this door, the first thing you will find when it opens is the bathroom.
20:18Then Otto Frank and his wife went to sleep.
20:23Then he went to sleep with Anne Frank and her sister Margot.
20:27The plate above is a bedtime table for the Zandan family.
20:34Waldtest Dussel
20:42The upper room is like a storeroom.
20:46In which the spices were placed
20:50This is a realistic picture of the Boukshelf.
20:59This bookcase is a picture of Adima.
21:03When will the bookcase be available?
21:07Not mentioned
21:09I would like a picture of the kitchen
21:14And you see the amount of bottles placed on top of this?
21:18For Bertie's bottles or what, light up top
21:21This is a recent, imaginary picture of the living conditions they were in.
21:32Here's another picture of the kitchen. A color picture of the kitchen they were in.
21:36I also did not say all the questions that Fielder asked
21:44I mean, I was satisfied with the strongest questions available.
21:49Although the book is a very small book
21:52But it is full of questions and worth reading.
21:56Because I think his questions are logical questions
21:59Whoever thinks these are not illogical questions should give a logical answer.
22:05convincing answer
22:07gives a convincing answer
22:09Otherwise, the whole thing remains in doubt.
22:13By the way, many Europeans and Westerners are not convinced by this whole story.
22:21Not convinced that Frank's family was hiding from the police.
22:28From the German police and no love
22:31Of course, yes, there was persecution of the Jews.
22:34But this story in particular
22:36Why do we focus on this particular story?
22:38Why do they focus on it?
22:40Because they used it as an icon of Jewish suffering.
22:46They used it as an icon to pressure the conscience of the Western world.
22:52To make the Western world and force the Western world to remain silent about their crimes against the Palestinians
23:01And their crimes in stealing Palestinian land
23:05In the Western world, he was forced to remain silent.
23:08Because it happened with a guilty conscience
23:11Anne Frank is an Indian woman whose story and the girl herself became a symbol of the suffering of the Jews.
23:20Just to prove that this story is not true and lacks credibility.
23:33And full of flaws and full of questions that no one can answer
23:45It throws Zionist allegations into the wind.
23:50It is considered a strong blow to the global Zionist movement.
23:54It's very good that all this talk comes from the West.
23:58It was not issued by Palestinians, Arabs or Muslims.
24:03Otherwise, he would always look at their words with suspicion.
24:07No one will ever benefit from them.
24:09But in the West, it is clear that it is very good that there is
24:14Neo-Historians
24:16Revivalists
24:18New Historians Countries
24:21They read history in another way.
24:25And they study history in a different way
24:27They do not just resort to what the victorious party told them.
24:32This is what we need to do, God willing, in other episodes after Ramadan.
24:38I also dedicate some episodes to discussing some of the books of this type.
24:44Which will make us re-read history and understand history again
24:49I hope that the episode will be three episodes, these three parts will be of any benefit
24:58Happy Ramadan
25:00See you all, peace, mercy and blessings of God be upon you.
25:04music
25:19Think of your duty as you think of your right
25:25Work for perfection, not for fame and reward.
25:32Do not expect more from people than they have the right to expect from you.
Comments