#idblacklist #ID #investigação #discovery #dublado #dementes #assassinos #ambição #misogino #misoginiaa #covardia #pedofilia #pedofilo #extorsão #traição #mistérios #pântano #mulheres #assassinas #amantes #filha #filho #mãe #madrasta #verdade #por.trás #do.crime #psíquicos #forense #exame #psicólogos #psiquiatria #jovem #moça #lago #gente #charlesStarkweather #tedbundy #jeffreydammer #btk #palhaço
Categoria
📺
TVTranscrição
00:00The content of this program is intense and not recommended for minors.
00:03Some details have been changed.
00:06Carolyn Clark spent her entire life in the Pentecostal Church.
00:11She was a God-fearing woman.
00:13God was no joke to her.
00:15Amen.
00:16But when a power-hungry bishop took control, everything changed.
00:22They should follow and believe in him, not in God.
00:25I am God. God speaks through me.
00:30When Carolyn watched her beloved church become a hostage of evil.
00:34He controlled everything.
00:36She vowed to save her children from the hell that awaited them.
00:40She tried to steer us away from something that was doomed: destruction.
00:44At any cost.
00:46What I saw, I will never forget.
00:49I want to hear them say amen.
00:50Amen.
00:51Amen.
01:00Deadly Cults
01:14The Macabre Bishop
01:17If you are treacherous, the Bible says that the wages of sin is death.
01:22Bishop Charles Keyes
01:23On May 7, 2005, at 2:00 AM, a loud bang interrupted the peaceful sleep of a 10-year-old child.
01:34I heard a scream.
01:35Oh my God, he has a gun! He has a gun!
01:39Then I saw a shadow at my bedroom door.
01:42And he left.
01:47Everything went silent.
01:51That's when I stood up.
01:55And there she was.
01:57With a pool of blood around his head.
02:00And I screamed.
02:07My mother always joked with people.
02:09Whenever she entered a place, everything lit up.
02:18Carolyn Butts grew up in a large, close-knit family.
02:23His vivacity and cheerful personality cheered everyone up.
02:29She could turn any situation into something comical.
02:32She was relaxed and pleasant.
02:39During his childhood in Portsmouth, Virginia,
02:42Carolyn and her family were devout members of the Pentecostal Church.
02:46an evangelical Christian denomination that emerged in the early 20th century.
02:51Her father was a deacon.
02:54And the mother was a missionary.
02:59As descendants of one of the founding members of the religion,
03:02Carolyn's parents were keen to pass their beliefs on to the next generation.
03:08Look what daddy gave you.
03:10When Carolyn was little,
03:12They gave her a Bible.
03:13and they said that all the rules for leading an honest life
03:17They were in that book.
03:19From Genesis to Revelation.
03:21Those are the rules.
03:23It is God's book.
03:24Read and study all night.
03:28And He will speak to you.
03:34Carolyn read the Bible and attended church services several days a week.
03:38Pentecostals believe that pastors were chosen.
03:41to spread God's message.
03:43And Carolyn's pastor was one of the most important people in her life.
03:48For God so loved the world.
03:50who gave his only begotten son.
03:52Do you trust the pastor?
03:56And you honor and respect his authority.
04:00For a child who grows up in this type of Pentecostalism,
04:04It's a very emotional experience.
04:16It was an intense place, full of energy.
04:22And Carolyn's pastor was mesmerized by the congregation's enthusiasm.
04:38She was even more moved when ecstasy led to language.
04:41which the church believes to be the means of communication with God himself.
04:45Those unfamiliar with Pentecostal religion think
04:53Wow, that's strange, exaggerated.
04:57But it is a faith based on allowing oneself to be led by the Holy Spirit.
05:01It is through His blood that we will all be whole.
05:04In the name of Jesus.
05:05Hallelujah!
05:05He draws close to God to the point where He answers his prayers.
05:08Hallelujah!
05:09Have mercy on her!
05:10But it requires dedication on your part.
05:14Overwhelmed with emotion, Carolyn, still a child, swore devotion to God.
05:18and followed the rules of his faith.
05:21This meant adhering to strict message-taking standards.
05:24The women dressed conservatively.
05:26Some wore ornate hats.
05:28Women did not wear pants to church.
05:30And church members were not allowed to date anyone outside the religion.
05:34But as Carolyn grew up, the intolerant community she had so adored as a child began to crumble.
05:42It started to feel oppressive.
05:45When she entered a secular school, her world expanded.
05:49Hey!
05:50Hey!
05:51We're going shopping.
05:52I'm throwing a party on Friday.
05:54I can't.
05:55I have to go to church.
05:55Carolyn still put her faith first.
05:58But the temptation to break church rules
06:01They became more difficult to resist.
06:03Hey, where are you going?
06:05Church.
06:07She was forbidden from doing several things.
06:09I'm going to bother you until you go out with me.
06:11This is going to get me into trouble.
06:13She told me that she felt controlled when she was younger.
06:17Young people are rebellious.
06:19And one day, Carolyn did exactly that.
06:24I'll go out with you.
06:24At 17, she accepted a boy's invitation to go out.
06:29Goodbye.
06:30And for the first time in his life, he lied to his parents.
06:33The couple met in secret for several months.
06:42So Carolyn needed to talk to her parents.
06:45because he had devastating news.
06:48She was pregnant.
06:49And the boyfriend didn't want to take responsibility.
06:51The church completely condemned anyone who had children out of wedlock.
07:03Is she pregnant?
07:04Who is the father?
07:07It doesn't matter.
07:09She was sad and hurt by the guy who got her pregnant.
07:12Carolyn's son, Terence, was born in February 1981.
07:21Carolyn adored her little son, but she knew she had made a mistake by straying from the teachings of the church.
07:28You bring great shame to your family if you do certain things.
07:32So, imagine what it was like for her.
07:34More than ever, Carolyn longed to return to the good graces of her faith.
07:42and raise your child in a loving, Christian home.
07:46By God, you can change.
07:48This may be what He desires.
07:50At 19 years old, Carolyn reaffirmed her commitment to God.
07:53and vowed never to stray from the church again.
07:56But in the eyes of the church, Carolyn needed to get married to fully restore her reputation.
08:10To find a suitor worthy of her lineage,
08:14Their parents turned to the most respected and highest-ranking member of the denomination,
08:19Bishop Ory Keyes, the chief apostle of Ashtabula County, Ohio.
08:24The power of God.
08:28Ory Keyes was a stern leader.
08:32He hoped to be honored as the shepherd of his flock.
08:36When evil is necessary.
08:39But his wise opinion was a spiritual beacon in the lives of his followers.
08:43And their influence extended to personal matters, such as arranging marriages.
08:48Carolyn's parents asked him to find someone for her.
08:51They paired a boy and a girl from different families.
08:56They had to get married.
08:57Therefore, the couple would stay at the church.
09:00In 1982, Carolyn and her parents traveled to Ohio to visit Bishop Keyes at his humble white church.
09:08Carolyn prayed that he would find a husband who would help erase the shame he had brought upon the family.
09:13When they arrived, the bishop had good news.
09:17He introduced Carolyn to his nephew, Ralph Clark, her future husband.
09:22Ralph, how are you? Nice to meet you.
09:24He was a deacon.
09:25He was a handsome guy.
09:28Very peaceful.
09:30And this is their daughter, Carolyn.
09:32Despite her initial shyness, Carolyn believed the arrangement was God's will.
09:37I'll show you the church.
09:39The bishop said they would get married.
09:41And they obeyed.
09:43But she was surprised to learn that the bishop wanted her to live in Achtabula.
09:48and marry Ralph immediately.
09:50She loved the Lord, and they made her think that if she didn't marry Ralph, she would live in sin.
10:03So, just five days after meeting him, Carolyn married Ralph Clark and joined Bishop Keyes' congregation.
10:12She felt it was her duty as a faithful member of the church.
10:20But blind faith can be dangerous.
10:24And Carolyn had no idea what the future held for her.
10:28Something is happening in that church that doesn't... doesn't make sense.
10:31Amen!
10:36Just five days after meeting, Carolyn Butts and Ralph Clark got married.
10:42according to the plans of the powerful Bishop Ory Keyes.
10:45Bishop Keyes brought the two together and said it was God's will that they marry.
10:51Leaving her family and moving to the city of Ralph, Ohio, left Carolyn filled with insecurities.
10:58But she believed that God would help.
11:00Carolyn was definitely nervous about coming here for an arranged marriage.
11:04She didn't even know Ralph.
11:06Bishop Keyes said, they will learn to love each other.
11:09Carolyn quickly noticed Ralph's virtues.
11:16She sincerely believed that he was a good man.
11:22Dedicated to family, devoted to her.
11:25And it was true.
11:27Over the years, they were blessed with many children.
11:30We were very close during childhood.
11:36We had a lot of fun together as a family.
11:40Especially at Christmas.
11:42I have memories of Christmas.
11:44We always got together, opened presents, had dinner, and prayed.
11:52Carolyn knew she had made the right choice.
11:55God's path has never been lost.
11:58And Bishop Keyes' modest church had become his spiritual home.
12:03The power of God.
12:09Bishop Keyes' influence was evident in Carolyn and Ralph's marriage.
12:14And the family's life revolved around the Pentecostal faith.
12:20The church meant everything to Carolyn and Ralph.
12:24The church was our priority.
12:28Then came marriage and family.
12:35And most importantly of all, he had to please Bishop Keyes.
12:40This place is full of sin.
12:42And to have the approval of your family.
12:45Especially from his son Charles.
12:46In his forties, Charles was the oldest of the bishop's five children.
12:53And despite not having any official role, Charles made a point of being noticed.
12:58Charles Keyes demanded respect from church members.
13:02He had a striking presence.
13:04He is a very intimidating figure.
13:06In addition to making their presence in the church clear,
13:09Charles also helped his father in various family businesses.
13:12who employed members of the congregation, including Ralph Clark.
13:17Oricis owned a car wash and a junkyard.
13:22It wasn't just a small white church in the middle of a cornfield.
13:27That was a company.
13:29And despite the high profits, the wages were low.
13:37Ralph had several jobs connected to the church.
13:40But none of them paid well.
13:41Are you coming to dinner?
13:43Not today.
13:44I have that night shift at the junkyard.
13:47Life wasn't easy, but the couple managed to overcome the situation.
13:50And they were grateful for the opportunities that Bishop Keyes offered.
13:53Oh, come on.
13:54He was a sort of king, who ruled over his flock.
14:00But he was a kind ruler.
14:05One day in June 2002, Bishop Keyes did not go up to the pulpit.
14:10Instead, his son Charles gave the congregation shocking news.
14:16My father is sick.
14:18And it is my duty to continue God's work.
14:21Oricis had dementia.
14:24When he could no longer lead the church, Charles took over.
14:30Not him.
14:31He went through all the stages to become a bishop.
14:34So he basically got himself elected.
14:38More important than references,
14:40Charles had a letter from his father naming him as his successor.
14:45And everyone was always supposed to obey the wishes of Bishop Keyes.
14:48Caroline soon realized that Charles Keyes had his own ideas about the church.
15:07Unlike his father, he allowed women to go to church wearing short skirts and other inappropriate clothing.
15:15He did several things that we didn't approve of.
15:18They started to cake their faces with makeup and wear short dresses.
15:21It was clear that things would be different under Charles' leadership.
15:26But Caroline had learned early on to respect the pastor's authority.
15:30And he accepted the changes.
15:32Little did she know that these changes were just the beginning.
15:36I can't understand how one person is capable of killing another.
15:40much less a person who should be loved.
15:43You only truly know a person if they let you know them.
15:47Perfect strangers.
15:49No Investigation Discovery.
15:52Hi Tara. It's me, Laura.
15:54Sunflower 82 offers online yoga classes.
15:57Yes, I would love to go to class with you.
16:00Thank you for the recommendation.
16:01But wait, why don't we do this class at my house?
16:04With wine afterwards, of course.
16:07Or do you find that a little strange?
16:08I don't want you to find it strange.
16:10It would be amazing.
16:11I'll send you the address.
16:12I live in the back, behind the stairs.
16:14I'll see you tonight. I can't wait.
16:17Falsity.com
16:18No Investigation Discovery.
16:27I am the father of a murdered child.
16:29I have already brought more than 1,400 fugitives to justice.
16:32My name is John Walsh and I am far from the end.
16:34Many of these fugitives remain at large.
16:37Don't turn a blind eye.
16:38Join me.
16:38Let's arrest these criminals.
16:42Good evening, brothers and sisters.
16:44Goodnight.
16:46The transition from Ori to Charles was quite significant.
16:50Charles's religious services were more personal and captivating than his father's.
16:54And over time, the members formed deep personal bonds with the charismatic leader.
17:01He was the guy I dreamed of being.
17:04He was arriving.
17:05He was like a bride.
17:08Ready to get married.
17:09Everyone stood up and looked at him.
17:11Everyone was amazed.
17:12And he intended for it to stay that way.
17:17Instead of preaching the Bible like his father, Charles' sermons were all about himself.
17:22And God spoke to me.
17:25And he said, you are my son.
17:28I felt like Jesus.
17:31I think Charles had a huge ego.
17:32Are you faithful?
17:34Are they loyal to me for everything I've done?
17:36More than that, the devil had taken control of him.
17:40I feel that God came and said that I should lead you.
17:45Please take a seat.
17:48He wanted, more than anything, to control and dominate the people of that church for his own cruel pleasure.
17:57Charles, standing on the pulpit, is a fascinating study of how people can be manipulated.
18:04Before me, you didn't pay rent.
18:07He would take everything apart and rebuild it.
18:09And it offered them the only path that existed.
18:13Is it now that I'm paying rent?
18:14Early!
18:14AND!
18:16Praise the Lord!
18:18I want to hear an amen!
18:19He was fascinating.
18:21How he manipulated religion to make a person the center of someone else's world...
18:28and capable of ordering them to do whatever she wants.
18:31Carolyn and the other members seemed oblivious to the fact that Charles had turned that church into a personality cult.
18:40My sister!
18:41God said, follow me!
18:43Are you all following me?
18:44They saw a great leader, a driving force.
18:49And not the controlling narcissist that Charles really was.
18:53What have I done for you?
18:55I made them better people.
18:58He always harped on the same theme.
19:01I am the voice of God.
19:03I am the prophet.
19:05And as the Bible says, the truth will set you free.
19:09I am God.
19:11God speaks through me.
19:13And within this context, people couldn't challenge him.
19:18The only obstacle in Charles Keyes' rise to power...
19:21It was the regulatory body of Virginia...
19:23who was not at all happy with the changes he had made.
19:28We noticed that the women in your church...
19:31They dress like prostitutes.
19:32The denomination learned of some of Charles Keyes' practices in the church...
19:38And they rebuked him.
19:40It seems you follow your own rules...
19:43not the rules of the church.
19:44Unless they agreed to make changes and follow the rules...
19:48The elders refused to maintain an affiliation with him.
19:51Well, in that case...
19:53We'll have to separate.
19:58Reluctant to accept the rules...
20:00Charles severed ties to become an independent bishop.
20:04Caroline, Ralph, and the congregation readily accepted.
20:09With no one to obey...
20:10Charles now had complete control.
20:13People have stopped worshipping Jesus Christ...
20:17to worship Christ Charles.
20:19But Caroline had no idea...
20:24that his sincere devotion to Christ Charles...
20:26It would destroy everything she loved.
20:29I believe that...
20:30He tried to protect us.
20:35Caroline Clark was devoted to her pastor, Charles Keyes.
20:38Amen!
20:39But Charles had severed ties with the official Pentecostal church...
20:42to create their own rules.
20:45And power was addictive.
20:46That was the defining moment...
20:50when Charles...
20:51He thought he knew everything...
20:54that he was God.
20:55I want to hear an amen!
20:59Amen!
21:03And Charles took full advantage of it...
21:06exploring the members...
21:07to line their own pockets.
21:09Charles Keyes' financial demands...
21:14They were extreme.
21:16While Ralph and Caroline...
21:18They struggled to support their families...
21:20They couldn't help but feel angry at Charles.
21:24They obeyed him...
21:25even when it was something that harmed them.
21:29They couldn't see that...
21:30How to serve Charles...
21:32and yes, serve Christ Charles...
21:35God on Earth.
21:36Yes, yes, yes!
21:39More than money...
21:40Charles wanted absolute control...
21:42about the lives of church members.
21:44Including how to raise children...
21:46your future flock.
21:47When I met you...
21:48You didn't study.
21:50He didn't do his homework.
21:52He didn't obey his mother.
21:53Now do you do that?
21:54Yes!
21:55Praise be to the Lord!
21:57I don't think we would know how...
21:59how to behave...
22:00how to behave...
22:01In everyday life...
22:02And my parents wouldn't know...
22:04How to discipline ourselves.
22:06And Charles didn't hesitate to take control...
22:10to discipline children.
22:13The Bible says you should punish your children.
22:17He was a big man...
22:19robust and strong...
22:20which said...
22:21I'm going to whip your children...
22:23And you will allow it.
22:24And it will be good for them...
22:26And it will be good for you.
22:27It's a whole different level of...
22:30to surrender to a religious leader.
22:32We all got caught in the crossfire.
22:34once...
22:36He threw a child...
22:37through the window...
22:38because it was disrupting the sermon.
22:41I think...
22:42that my mother...
22:43questioned...
22:44Some things with him...
22:45But Charles...
22:46He was God's messenger...
22:48So what was he saying...
22:49That was the law.
22:51I want to hear an amen!
22:53Despite being devout...
22:54her faith as a mother...
22:56Caroline was constantly worried...
22:58With what could the bishop do...
22:59with their children.
23:00She had already witnessed terrible things.
23:06But one night in 2004...
23:08She realized that her fears...
23:10They were going in the wrong direction.
23:12Ralph?
23:14What?
23:15What happened?
23:18He was beaten so badly...
23:19who could barely walk.
23:21Who did this to you?
23:24Charles Christ.
23:26He helped me drive away the devil.
23:29Caroline couldn't believe it...
23:30that the pastor would be capable of...
23:31to attack her husband.
23:33Look at your face!
23:34But what did Ralph say next...
23:36It was even more disturbing.
23:38I did it myself.
23:40What?
23:41I asked.
23:43It's OK?
23:43Ralph told Caroline...
23:45that the beating...
23:46It was his fault.
23:51He went to the bishop to confess...
23:53who felt resentment...
23:54for giving money to the church.
23:55And he asked to be saved...
23:57Or in their jargon...
23:59rescued.
24:00The concept behind the rescue...
24:02and...
24:03to endure a scourge...
24:05to try...
24:06try to purge the...
24:08sin.
24:09Jesus was...
24:10Whipped and assaulted.
24:12And if you want to be like Jesus...
24:13That's a good thing...
24:15to go through this beating process.
24:19I hold a lot of resentment...
24:21of you...
24:22when I'm at home...
24:24I have no money to support my family.
24:27He was expressing...
24:29remorse for feeling...
24:31The bishop's envy.
24:32I need to get rid of this sin.
24:35Do you want to be rescued?
24:37Yes.
24:45Charles Keyes brought together what he called...
24:49rescue team.
24:50If you felt you were wrong...
24:52It was his choice...
24:53to be rescued.
24:56And they almost make you feel like you're going to...
24:58To hell with it...
24:59Or that something very bad is going to happen...
25:01if you don't do that...
25:02But he was a volunteer.
25:04Rescue yourself!
25:05Repent!
25:07Charles Keyes...
25:09He used the story of Jesus...
25:11as a tool...
25:13to beat people up...
25:15to break them down...
25:16And then...
25:17to offer a way out.
25:18And the way out was through him.
25:21He became...
25:22the path to salvation.
25:26I was rescued.
25:28Caroline and Ralph...
25:30They have always been united by their faith...
25:32but for the first time...
25:34They were divided.
25:35I would let him do that...
25:37With our children?
25:38Please.
25:40Huh?
25:40Whatever Bishop Charles wants.
25:44Caroline couldn't believe it...
25:45based on what I heard.
25:46She feared that her husband...
25:48was completely indoctrinated.
25:50And the children too.
25:51Back then...
25:53Ralph Junior...
25:53I was still a teenager...
25:55but his devotion to Charles...
25:56It was already ingrained.
25:58I believed so much...
25:59in that man...
26:00that I've reached the point...
26:01to be willing...
26:02to do anything...
26:04that he should send...
26:05I do.
26:10Imagine the rescue team...
26:12hitting their children...
26:13Caroline was terrified.
26:15And his faith began to waver.
26:17His doubts increased...
26:19when she started working...
26:20working part-time in a factory...
26:21and met people...
26:23outside the church.
26:25She started talking...
26:27with other people...
26:28about their church.
26:29That's just how things are.
26:30And he began to reconsider...
26:32the level of power...
26:33and control that Charles...
26:35It was on her.
26:37My church doesn't do that.
26:42Caroline Clark...
26:44Little by little...
26:45He began to open his eyes.
26:47For the first time...
26:48since high school...
26:50she considered...
26:50A life outside the church.
26:53I think we need to leave the church.
26:55But what's the problem?
26:57She realized...
26:58that this was not normal...
27:00and tried to convince her husband...
27:02as they were leaving the church...
27:03like a family.
27:04This is not safe...
27:05for us.
27:05But Ralph believed...
27:10that Charles wanted...
27:11He had saved him...
27:12And now he was even more devout...
27:13more than ever before.
27:15You are my wife.
27:17You should support me.
27:20Caroline was torn.
27:22She loved her husband...
27:23But I couldn't anymore...
27:24Ignore the abuse...
27:25and the cruelty...
27:26that were happening in the church.
27:28Then...
27:29when Charles called her...
27:30in his office...
27:32She became apprehensive.
27:35Did you call me?
27:36As soon as he arrived...
27:38she felt...
27:38that something bad would happen.
27:40This is not common behavior.
27:43This is not normal at all.
27:50Caroline Clark...
27:51I was living a nightmare.
27:54His family was...
27:55under the control of the sadistic pastor...
27:56Charles Keyes.
27:59She beat her husband.
28:01And now...
28:02She was the target.
28:10According to a sworn statement...
28:13that Caroline presented to the court...
28:15She was raped...
28:16by Bishop Charles.
28:19No!
28:24No!
28:30Caroline returned home...
28:33seeking solace with her husband.
28:36Ralph...
28:38Something happened.
28:39What it was?
28:39he speaks.
28:41The bishop...
28:42He put his hands on me.
28:44But the betrayal didn't end there.
28:46But that was the agreement.
28:48What?
28:51He did not support his wife.
28:54On the contrary...
28:55He joined...
28:56Charles Keyes.
28:57Ralph, what are you talking about?
28:59I am a devotee...
29:00to Christ Charles.
29:01He is well?
29:04I am your wife.
29:06I...
29:07I'll tell you...
29:08what other man...
29:09He put his hands on me...
29:10And that's your reaction?
29:12She needs to be rescued too.
29:15My...
29:15That's when she got so frustrated...
29:18who picked up an object...
29:20and threw it.
29:21Hey!
29:23She didn't manage to hit him...
29:25But she was very angry.
29:26He was brainwashed...
29:28He doesn't see that!
29:28And at that moment...
29:29Carolin knew...
29:30that if one wanted to protect the children...
29:32The situation would reach extremes.
29:38Blinded by his devotion...
29:40Ralph told Bishop Charles...
29:41about his fight with Caroline.
29:43Another day...
29:44She threw an object at me.
29:46What?
29:46Ralph had to do...
29:48Everything the bishop ordered.
29:49Is she going to hurt my brother?
29:52He made him call the police...
29:54And Caroline was accused...
29:55domestic violence.
29:57But Charles didn't stop there.
30:00You should file for divorce.
30:03Stay with your children.
30:04Raise your children.
30:05Like always...
30:06Ralph obeyed.
30:09He asked for a divorce...
30:11and won custody of the children...
30:13because she threw an object at him...
30:15during a fight.
30:17Hey!
30:19Caroline was devastated...
30:21when she left her family home...
30:22without being able to take the children.
30:24I don't know...
30:25What was he thinking?
30:27He's not thinking.
30:29And in December 2004...
30:31She moved upstairs...
30:33from her friend's duplex...
30:34Helen Waits.
30:35It was the first time...
30:37where she would spend Christmas...
30:39Far from family.
30:41He's not like that.
30:42It's Bishop Kiss's fault.
30:44He suggested the divorce.
30:46Helen was one of her only friends...
30:47by Caroline...
30:48outside of Charles' congregation...
30:50and an indispensable confidante...
30:52during this difficult time.
30:54She said...
30:55He wants a divorce...
30:57But he won't be able to keep my children.
30:59I'm willing to face him...
31:01and the church.
31:02I'm taking my children...
31:03as far away as possible.
31:04She is safe here.
31:09In March 2005...
31:12Caroline gave a statement...
31:13hoping that one day...
31:14to regain custody of their children.
31:18She was brave...
31:20Why do you do that?
31:22She had to wage a war.
31:24And she needed to say things...
31:27about the church...
31:28which I never wanted to admit publicly.
31:31Caroline described...
31:32the terrible abuse...
31:33that she witnessed...
31:34and suffered.
31:37Caroline...
31:38wrote in the deposition...
31:40who witnessed...
31:42Children being beaten.
31:44She could hear them crying...
31:46and felt powerless...
31:47to do something about it.
31:49And for the first time...
31:51she revealed...
31:52Another unpleasant truth.
31:53She also said...
31:57Charles...
31:58who sexually abused me.
32:03Caroline wrote...
32:04which was forced...
32:05to go to bed with the bishop.
32:10Caroline said...
32:11all that I knew...
32:12about Charles and his church.
32:13to protect the children...
32:15It was the only thing...
32:16What did it matter?
32:17She said...
32:18which was a sect.
32:19She said that her husband...
32:19and the children...
32:20They were under the bishop's control.
32:23It was a place...
32:24very wicked.
32:27Caroline succeeded...
32:29an order to remove me from my position...
32:30against Ralph.
32:31But I should have waited...
32:32the judge decides...
32:33Regarding child custody.
32:36About that...
32:37social assistance...
32:38opened an investigation...
32:39Regarding the practices...
32:40by Charles Keyes...
32:41with Caroline's cooperation.
32:43And when Charles found out...
32:46His fury was...
32:47ruthless.
32:50It seems that someone...
32:52He's speaking ill of the church.
32:53Someone spread lies...
32:55about the bishop.
32:56Without Caroline knowing...
32:58Charles had decided to manipulate...
32:59What she loved most...
33:01your children.
33:02And he would not rest...
33:03until I leave them...
33:04totally against her.
33:06We know who that person is.
33:07Who?
33:08Caroline.
33:11His wife.
33:13He said that she was...
33:15The devil.
33:16And she was cruel...
33:17for abandoning us...
33:19leave us alone.
33:20And I remember that I ended up...
33:21calling her the devil.
33:24They suffered...
33:24A brainwashing...
33:25that the mother...
33:26He was a bad person.
33:27The things they said...
33:29about her...
33:29They definitely influenced...
33:31what I was feeling at the time.
33:33You know who she is.
33:34I had no idea...
33:35that she was trying...
33:37to protect us.
33:38Two months later...
33:43to present the testimony...
33:45Caroline's courage...
33:46She was rewarded...
33:47And she won...
33:48temporary custody...
33:48of the children.
33:49But his hope...
33:50of a happy meeting...
33:52He soon disappeared.
33:53Amen!
33:54Amen!
33:54The older children...
33:55They refused to live with her.
33:57It was very difficult...
33:58because children...
33:59They didn't want to live with her.
34:01They wanted to stay...
34:02in church.
34:04The youngest children...
34:05by Caroline...
34:06They were the only ones...
34:07to live with her.
34:08This is where Mom lives.
34:09But after months apart...
34:10Even they hesitated...
34:12in accepting it...
34:13After all things...
34:14terrible things they heard.
34:16I still thought...
34:17that she was the devil...
34:18for me.
34:20AND...
34:21every time she held out her hand to me...
34:22I was walking away.
34:24There's a surprise.
34:26But Caroline...
34:27I was determined...
34:28erasing the lies...
34:29that your children heard...
34:30with a celebration...
34:31Late for Christmas...
34:33to make up for the season...
34:34where they stayed away.
34:35She bought...
34:37several Christmas presents...
34:39for us.
34:40So I thought...
34:42Ah...
34:43You thought of me...
34:44during that time...
34:45during which we were separated.
34:46Legal.
34:46And he bought gifts.
34:48So I said...
34:49Thank you, Mom.
34:50Caroline took advantage...
34:52their reunion...
34:52with their beloved children.
34:54Thank you, Mom.
34:55But did you know that the influences...
34:56toxic aspects of the church...
34:57They were always nearby.
34:59And liberation...
35:01It would only be complete...
35:02far from there.
35:02She intended to go...
35:05to her parents' house...
35:06in Portsmouth...
35:07on May 7th...
35:09where I expected...
35:09so that they would be safe.
35:11She called...
35:12for some relatives...
35:13And Caroline...
35:13I was going to get the children...
35:15and...
35:16Return to Virginia.
35:19The night before...
35:20on the trip...
35:21an unexpected visit...
35:22It appeared in the duplex...
35:23that Caroline shared...
35:25with her friend Helen.
35:26What are you doing here?
35:28I want to talk.
35:29ignored the precautionary measure...
35:30And then it appeared...
35:31in Caroline's apartment.
35:32I want to stay...
35:33with my children.
35:35I heard an argument at the door.
35:37Get him out of here!
35:38You shouldn't be here.
35:40I asked Caroline...
35:41If everything was alright.
35:43She said...
35:44yes I am well.
35:45Are you safe here?
35:46It's not a threat.
35:48I'm not afraid of him.
35:49What was he thinking?
35:51A few hours later...
35:53Helen woke up...
35:54with a sound of breaking glass.
35:56She said...
35:58Ralph doesn't scare me.
36:00She forgot about Charles.
36:01Don't let yourself be the leader of a cult.
36:08I don't know what's normal.
36:11She picked up that knife...
36:12and coming straight...
36:13Come up above me.
36:15Who died?
36:16Your father.
36:16Stephanie's father.
36:17He killed him.
36:18What?
36:19Living with the enemy.
36:20No Investigation Discovery.
36:23Our beauty lies in imperfection.
36:24in the mix of stories, desires, experiences and achievements.
36:30There are many of us.
36:32And we are unique.
36:33Even with so many differences...
36:35We share a common narrative.
36:37Together we inspire each other...
36:39to build a journey that is free.
36:41That has no definite destination.
36:43But it belongs to everyone.
36:44We are plural.
36:46Without ceasing to be unique.
36:48We have many voices.
36:50And faces.
36:51Our experiences are personal.
36:52But our learning happens together.
36:56Then come.
36:57Let's dive into this plurality together.
37:01Go with them.
37:03Would you like to increase your professional opportunities?
37:07Learning English with Open English is the perfect idea.
37:11Make the most of your time at home and take unlimited live classes with American teachers.
37:16Learn English easily and quickly without leaving home.
37:19Get started today at OpenEnglish.com
37:22Hi, Tara.
37:24It's me, Laura.
37:25Sunflower82 from the Online Yoga class.
37:28Yes.
37:29I would love to go to class with you.
37:31Thank you for the recommendation.
37:33But wait.
37:33Why don't we have this class at my house?
37:35At home.
37:36I'll agree later, of course.
37:38Or do you find that a little strange?
37:40I don't want you to find it strange.
37:41It would be amazing.
37:42I'll send you the address.
37:43I live in the back.
37:44Behind the stairs.
37:45I'll see you tonight.
37:46I can't wait.
37:48Falsity.com
37:50No Investigation Discovery
37:52I am the father of a murdered child.
38:01I have already brought more than 1,400 fugitives to justice.
38:03My name is John Walsh.
38:04I'm far from the end.
38:06Many of these fugitives remain at large.
38:08Don't turn a blind eye.
38:09Join me.
38:10Let's arrest these criminals.
38:11In the early hours of May 7, 2005, the friend and owner of the apartment
38:18Carolyn, Helen Waits, was terrified.
38:23I heard a ban.
38:25A window was broken.
38:27I looked at the clock on the dresser and saw that it was two in the morning.
38:31I could also hear Carolyn screaming, so I grabbed my phone and called the police.
38:35While Helen was speaking with the police, she briefly saw the intruder driving toward the store.
38:43But he couldn't identify who it was.
38:47And when she entered her friend's apartment, what she feared was already too late.
38:55I saw Carolyn lying on the floor like an angel.
38:59He was drowning in his own blood.
39:02It was awful.
39:04Children, go back to your room.
39:05Carolyn's life still hung by a thread when the police arrived.
39:14While paramedics attended to her, the children were removed from the house.
39:19When the police arrived, we asked if we could retrieve our belongings.
39:23They said no.
39:24You witnessed a crime.
39:26We need you.
39:27The police were talking to the homeowner, Ellen, when three men in suits appeared in front of her house.
39:37She was furious when she found out who it was.
39:40What are you doing here?
39:42Calm.
39:42And then suddenly Charles appeared.
39:45With all those men.
39:46And nobody was wearing pajamas.
39:48Two thirty in the morning.
39:49You did this to her.
39:51Police officer, it was them.
39:52The police questioned Charles.
39:54You did this to her.
39:55At first I thought it was suspicious that he showed up.
39:58Get off my property.
39:59Get out!
40:00Get him out of here!
40:01Get out!
40:01Ellen believed that Charles was involved in the attack.
40:05Get out!
40:06While doctors prepared to take Caroline to the hospital, her son Ralph Jr. stayed by his mother's side.
40:15What I saw...
40:17I will never forget.
40:22She was almost unrecognizable.
40:29Sorry.
40:29At 2:55 a.m. on May 7, 2005, Caroline Clark finally lost the fight and was declared dead.
40:42When I saw that, I screamed.
40:50Meanwhile, Detective Sean Ward was examining the crime scene.
40:54Although Caroline was not shot, he recovered confusing evidence.
41:02In the living room area, there was blood on the carpet.
41:06Ammunition was scattered on the ground.
41:10But no weapons were fired.
41:12Caroline's injuries indicated that she had died from severe blows to the head.
41:18The police now had to determine who was responsible for beating her to death.
41:22I was informed that the children were awake and had a clear view of what happened.
41:29My brother, Brian, was the one who saw him.
41:34A social worker spoke with the children.
41:37Detective Ward was eager to find out what they had seen.
41:42They said a man came in and killed Mom.
41:45Ward soon discovered the man's identity through a social worker.
41:49They said it was the father.
41:53The children said that their father had committed the murder.
41:59We also discovered that one of the children had called the bishop's house.
42:06The phone call explained why Charles and the other church members arrived so quickly.
42:10What do you think you're doing here, huh?
42:12What are you doing here?
42:13Two hours later, Ralph Clark was arrested.
42:18Detective Ward interrogated him at the prison in the city of Ashtabula.
42:23He confessed immediately.
42:26I freaked out, man.
42:28She was going to take my children away from here.
42:31He said he couldn't bear the thought of being away from his children and made a decision.
42:39Ralph told the police a story of fear and hatred.
42:44He said he took his brother's gun and broke into Carolyn's apartment.
42:48Oh my God, he has a gun! He has a gun!
42:51But he didn't know how to use the weapon and couldn't fire it.
42:55I think the gun jammed and...
42:58When he realized he wasn't going to be able to use the gun, he said...
43:03I picked up the gun like it was a bat and...
43:06I hit my wife on the head.
43:13But was anyone involved?
43:15No, just me.
43:17But some still believe that Charles Keyes bears some responsibility for the murder.
43:23Carolyn's son, Ralph, remembers overhearing a certain conversation in October 2004.
43:31Your wife is wreaking havoc on your life.
43:35Then he mentioned the story of Samson and Delilah from the Bible.
43:39The only way Samson could redeem himself with God...
43:42It was about killing himself and killing Dalila.
43:46You need to get rid of anything that's blocking your view.
43:50Your path to God.
43:52My first reaction was...
43:54Is he telling my father to kill my mother?
43:57But then I thought...
43:59No, that's impossible.
44:01Ralph Clark chose to follow the teachings of Charles Keyes.
44:06Based on this, he believed he needed to kill his wife.
44:11But that doesn't mean that Charles Keyes...
44:14Be criminally responsible for the death of Carolyn Clark.
44:18Detectives examined the evidence...
44:20But only one person was charged with the crime.
44:24Ralph Clark.
44:25On January 13, 2006...
44:28He pleaded guilty to aggravated murder...
44:31He was sentenced to 28 years to life imprisonment.
44:34But the news of Carolyn's death...
44:40And the allegations she made about Charles Keyes' abusive practices...
44:44They were not ignored.
44:45The child protection services investigated the church.
44:51After a while, 21 children were removed from Charles Keyes due to abuse.
44:58AND...
44:58Charles suddenly found himself in the spotlight.
45:03The negative publicity soon led Charles to leave town...
45:12And he dismissed his followers.
45:13The bishop narrowly escaped.
45:17When things started to get worse, he packed his bags.
45:21And, shortly after...
45:24They disappeared.
45:25Charles went to Las Vegas.
45:27He said that God wanted him to live there.
45:30Strange.
45:31Because, as far as I know...
45:34God wouldn't want a prophet in the city of sin.
45:37Even at the cost of her life, Carolyn fulfilled her mission of exposing the truth about Charles Keyes...
45:47And to save their children and many other people from a dangerous cult.
45:52In the end, Carolyn's death was completely in vain.
45:55All I do now is try to find peace in my life.
46:02I understand that it's the only way to overcome it.
46:06I thank her, from the bottom of my heart, for doing what she did.
46:10I see her death as a beautiful sacrifice.
46:15Not just for me, but for all of us.
46:17Because if she hadn't done that...
46:20Only God knows where we'll be today.
Seja a primeira pessoa a comentar