• 11 months ago
AWANI Global looks at key shifts and trends in conflicts and security issues across the Asia-Pacific and Southeast Asia in 2025. Join Nailah Huda with Prof Rebecca Strating and Dr Bradley Jensen Murg as they unpack tensions potentially unravelling in the coming year.
Transcript
00:00This is Awani Global with me, Naila Huda.
00:10And this month we take you through a series of reviews and reflections from the year 2025
00:15and what we can expect from the coming year.
00:18With this episode, looking specifically at issues surrounding conflict
00:23and the overall security environment in the Asia-Pacific region.
00:28From maritime tensions to strengthened alliances and new forms of cooperation,
00:33we want to understand key shifts and trends in the year 2025
00:37which could potentially spell the fate for the region in the coming year.
00:41And joining us to unpack some of these key questions,
00:43we're very lucky to be joined by Professor Rebecca Stratting,
00:47Director of La Trobe's Centre for Global Security
00:50and Professor of International Relations at La Trobe University, Melbourne.
00:53Thank you so much for joining us. How are you doing?
00:56Thank you so much for having me. It's always wonderful to be in Malaysia.
01:00Very happy to have you.
01:01If we could perhaps start with a sort of bigger picture kind of question,
01:04how would you describe the overall security environment
01:07in the Asia-Pacific region in the past year?
01:10I think probably the word that I would use to describe the security environment is uncertain.
01:16So one of the things that we are seeing in 2025 is a lot of, I think, uncertainty about the direction
01:27of some of the major countries in the Asia-Pacific region.
01:32So I think one of the big news stories across the year has been the United States
01:38under the new Trump administration and what the Trump administration's policies in Asia will be.
01:47I think even though we've seen the national security strategy recently released,
01:53there's still a lot of uncertainty or confusion about what the United States really plans to do in this region
02:01and how that's going to affect its relationships with other countries.
02:06So on top of that, you also have the coercive tactics being employed,
02:13particularly by the People's Republic of China in maritime domain.
02:18We see it in the South China Sea, for example, which is also exacerbating tensions and concerns
02:26among regional countries about how to deal with that.
02:30And then there are sort of smaller conflicts that are breaking out in the region
02:34that are also concerning when we think about security.
02:37We saw, for example, the tensions between Cambodia and Thailand this year in the region.
02:44So I think there's a lot of turbulence in the region and countries and analysts like myself
02:53are trying to make sense of a world that feels very different from the one that we know
03:00and the one that we are used to.
03:03So I think if we're talking about security, I really think that one of the biggest issues
03:09is just not being really clear about the intentions and the priorities,
03:16particularly of the two major players being the United States and China.
03:21You pointed out a lot of interesting points there.
03:23One of them being, of course, maritime tensions, getting a lot of attention this year.
03:27And we've seen these persistent tensions in the South China Sea, the Taiwan Strait,
03:32these key maritime routes.
03:34Do you think there are any sort of key shifts or trends that stood out to you particularly
03:39in the region in 2025?
03:42I think what we see in 2025 is a continuation of what we saw in 2024.
03:47When we think about the West Philippine Sea, what the Philippines calls the West Philippine Sea,
03:54and the coercive tactics that China is employing in that particular maritime domain.
04:02So this is the use of fishing vessels of Coast Guards, the use of, say, water cannons to try to deny other people
04:17from other countries using maritime space.
04:20So these are more dangerous manoeuvres.
04:23We're also seeing unsafe and unprofessional manoeuvres in the airspace above these maritime areas.
04:32And one of the issues around these sorts of encounters between different assets,
04:40whether they're military or non-military, is that it amplifies that risk,
04:47that something might spark a broader conflict.
04:51And that adds to that uncertainty about the security environment.
04:56There's also a question about what sort of channels there are within the region,
05:02whether it's bilaterally or multilaterally, to reduce conflict or to manage crisis.
05:10So if crisis does occur and there is an encounter that might potentially lead to some sort of outbreak of violence,
05:23the question is, what can countries do to reduce the likelihood of conflict breaking out in that situation?
05:32Talking about the approach in tackling these kind of risks and concerns,
05:36maybe I want to shift gears a little bit and talk about alliances,
05:39where we're seeing one trend this year with the Asia-Pacific becoming somewhat more inclined,
05:46or perhaps this has been going on for a couple of years now, not just this year,
05:49towards alliances.
05:50You know, we're seeing AUKUS to the Quad, US-Japan-Korea coordination,
05:54even new forms of cooperation with ASEAN.
05:57We're seeing ASEAN GCC China, a lot of Global South sort of movements as well.
06:02Do you think that these sort of frameworks, this cooperation,
06:06help to stabilise the region in 2025, or perhaps put it even more at risk?
06:12That's a really interesting question.
06:15And I think what we're seeing is this shift towards strategic minilateralism.
06:21So these smaller groupings of countries that might form around big issues,
06:27like the Quad has a long list of agenda items,
06:31or around smaller issues, you know, focusing in on specific areas of cooperation.
06:38And this is quite different from a regional order that is premised on multilateralism.
06:46So big institutions where there are lots of different actors
06:51and it focuses on inclusion and, you know, a lot of actors being at the table
06:58who are able to set the agenda.
07:00So the strategic minilateralism is, I think, comes out of the fact
07:06that there are countries that are losing faith in multilateral organisations,
07:12or they want to get things done, but they're also coming out of the fact
07:17that there are concerns about other actors.
07:20So the Quad, for example, yes, it is an organisation
07:26that is devoted to delivering public goods,
07:32but it is also concerned about the rise of China in the region.
07:37So we're seeing the security environment deteriorating,
07:43and it's not clear to me that strategic minilateralism
07:46is really helping to improve the security environment,
07:51but neither is it contributing to the deterioration either.
07:56Right. I want to bring this back a bit closer to home.
08:00Do you think from Australia's point of view, how do you think it looks at,
08:05you know, the overall sort of regional security environment,
08:09perhaps evolving or changing in 2025?
08:12So Australia, in its regional diplomacy, has been really focused on conflict prevention
08:19and working with other countries to develop a conflict prevention agenda
08:25that can do things like manage crises or develop early risk warning systems
08:34or engage in risk reduction.
08:36And the reason why Australia, in my view, is dedicating a lot of resources and time
08:44to the conflict prevention agenda in its work with ASEAN
08:49is because it is concerned about the security environment.
08:52It's concerned about what is going on in the maritime space.
08:56It's concerned about what is going on in airspace.
08:59And it is concerned that there is an environment in which there's not a lot of trust
09:07between particularly the big powers, the United States and China.
09:12There isn't a whole lot of channels of communication dedicated to crisis management
09:18that will be useful if there is an incident.
09:22And so the question is how can countries across the region work together
09:29to try to create the creative diplomacy required to reduce the risk of particularly great power conflict
09:41because conflict that involves a great power will be the most consequential in the region.
09:47You mentioned about this concern in ASEAN.
09:50How do you think perhaps we can contextualise this with the Thailand-Cambodia border issue,
09:57which is of course very current and it's ongoing.
10:00Things are developing very fast.
10:01But how central do you think is Southeast Asia to the broader Indo-Pacific strategy for Australia?
10:09I think Southeast Asia is very important to Australia's Indo-Pacific concept.
10:17It says it quite often.
10:20So even when Australia is talking within the context of the Quad, for example,
10:28it always makes reference to ASEAN centrality.
10:32Australia tries to make it very clear that these minilateral arrangements are not trying to compete
10:39with ASEAN or the ASEAN-led mechanisms and that also Australia is a central player in those ASEAN-led mechanisms
10:52that do include countries beyond the 11 ASEAN countries.
10:57So I think Southeast Asia is very important to Australia's concept of security.
11:02I think individually in Southeast Asia there are countries that are really developing pathways of cooperation.
11:11Australia and Indonesia, for example, just signed a very weighty defence agreement.
11:17Australia's relationship with the Philippines is going from strength to strength,
11:22particularly thinking about defence cooperation.
11:25And so I think Australia's messaging to Southeast Asia is sort of one of consistent engagement
11:35and wanting to support ASEAN initiatives.
11:41And so I expect to see in 2026 there will be more investment or a prioritisation of conflict prevention
11:52in terms of how Australia engages in the region.
11:56And this is really about preventive diplomacy.
11:59But we are also very interested in things like maritime security and economic security.
12:08Understanding, for example, that things like online scamming and scam centres is an increasing concern.
12:17Also thinking about, you know, technology and cyber security.
12:22So there's a range of complex interconnected issues that affect the security environment.
12:30And they're traditional.
12:31They're, you know, about militaries and they're about technology,
12:34but they're also non-traditional about things like climate change and the environment.
12:38That means that it is increasingly difficult, I think, to find good solutions to some of these problems.
12:52And what that means is that countries across the region really need to double down on their cooperation
12:59and the collaboration to try and mitigate some of these very big and transnational problems.
13:06Perhaps we'll see more of these mini lateral strategic frameworks coming into the new year.
13:11Perhaps we will.
13:12Yep.
13:13Plenty more.
13:14I'd like to pick your brain on.
13:15But that is all the time that we have today and we will let you go.
13:18Thank you so much, Professor Rebecca, for joining us.
13:20That is all on Awani Global at this session.
13:22But we'll be back shortly with another session taking a closer look at Southeast Asia.
13:27Shall we be back shortly?
13:42This is Awani Global.
13:43And in the previous session, we looked at issues surrounding security and conflict in the Asia-Pacific region.
13:49But now, we want to take a closer look at conflict, tensions and instability in Southeast Asia.
13:56From the Thailand-Cambodia border dispute to the overall security environment in Southeast Asia.
14:03What are some of the key shifts in 2025?
14:06And perhaps, spelling the fate for the region in 2026.
14:10That's what we want to discuss in this session.
14:12And joining us to help unpack some of these key shifts from 2025.
14:16We have joining us Dr. Bradley Jensen-Merg, Senior Advisor at the Cambodian Institute for Cooperation and Peace, CICP.
14:24Dr. Bradley is also Provost and Professor of International Relations at the Paragon University.
14:30Thank you so much for sitting down with us and not standing.
14:34It's a pleasure to be here.
14:35Or otherwise, I'd have a sore neck throughout the entire session.
14:37How are you doing?
14:38Oh, wonderful.
14:39Thank you for chatting.
14:40We're very happy to have you.
14:41And I think we'd like to start with a sort of bigger picture kind of question.
14:44What do you think are some of the key shifts, trends, patterns coming out of Southeast Asia looking at conflict and tensions in the region?
14:52Sure.
14:53I think the big theme of 2025 has been one of internal fragility combined with essentially external pressure.
14:59The conflicts that we see that are blown up between Thailand and Cambodia as well as the continued expansion and lack of resolution of the Myanmar issue.
15:07This is a fragile region where these issues are going to continue.
15:11But at the same time, the U.S.-China rivalry has resulted in much more intensely this year, I think.
15:18ASEAN states very often conditioning their responses on the anticipated response of either Washington and or Beijing.
15:25And this produces a much more brittle security reality than we've seen in the past.
15:32Do you think 2025 marked the sort of turning points for some of these conflicts or do you think this was a continuation or sort of simmering issues and tensions that was just blowing up this year?
15:45For Myanmar, I do see it as continuity essentially as they lead up towards the election that they've declared.
15:50Of course, many competing views on that.
15:52The Cambodia-Thailand border dispute, this is obviously very long standing and goes back to the French colonial period.
15:58And the historical side is continually there.
16:02But I think the scary aspect that we've seen from the conflict this year is just how much it's tied to internal factors, how much to domestic politics.
16:09And very much hoping that this will come to a conclusion by the end of 2025.
16:14But it looks very unlikely that that's going to be the case.
16:17This appears to be a very, very drawn out issue that is going to take some time to resolve.
16:21You mentioned a little bit there about how, you know, we want to focus specifically on the Thailand-Cambodia border dispute.
16:27Looking at these long standing sort of historical grievances, but at the same time, you know, combined with these, you know, domestic political pressures.
16:36How do you see this sort of going into 2026?
16:40You don't see this resolving very quickly anytime soon, but looking specifically at these domestic political elements,
16:47what do you think are some of the trends we should look out for in 2026?
16:51Absolutely. I think when this all began, and from just a pure political science perspective,
16:55there were definite political gains on both sides domestically.
16:58The standard rally around the flag effect and the focus on rallying popular nationalism
17:02against a standard traditional other state, the neighbor state.
17:06But as things have developed, particularly since the ceasefire in September,
17:10I do think that things have shifted in terms of the political dynamics.
17:13Within Cambodia, Cambodia has a very consolidated government.
17:16It does not have an election on the cards for quite a while.
17:19And any political gains domestically it really will have taken off the table at this point.
17:23I've never seen this level of support within the kingdom for the royal government at this point.
17:28So Cambodia is consolidated and fairly stable.
17:31Conversely, I think at this point what we're seeing is Thailand is going into a general election in February,
17:35and our very big concern in Phnom Penh at present is that this will not be resolved until that election has taken place,
17:42and Thai politics have hopefully reached a new political equilibrium.
17:47Because at this stage, and we look at some of the polling in Thailand, both on the ceasefire as well as next steps,
17:52and there's not a lot of will for it.
17:54So Thailand's political leaders do confront a challenge of if they want to resolve this,
17:59they also have to deal with, well, how do you resolve this while potentially being perceived to be weak by your voters,
18:05as well as political opponents playing the more nationalist than thou card.
18:11So our big concern right now is that this could simply, even if we get a temporary ceasefire in two or three days,
18:17until Thai election happens, this could continue to flare up again and again.
18:21And of course in Cambodia, the humanitarian situation is becoming much worse.
18:26Would you say this is more so a symbolic sort of conflict or do you think it carries some strategic economic security risks for both sides?
18:38It definitely carries economic risks for both sides.
18:40I mean security, let's actually go back there to begin with.
18:43Yes, for the reason that we are seeing obviously violent conflict and civilian casualties and so on and so forth.
18:49And the economic costs for Cambodia, very, very high.
18:52For Thailand, not as high, relatively, but still significant.
18:55For both countries though, the costs that they're seeing, particularly this time of year,
18:59for two highly tourism-dependent economies, this is wiping out the high season,
19:04which for a country like Cambodia, where 17-18% of GDP is tourism,
19:08and it's mostly made during these four months, this is a major impact.
19:12The long term, and even the medium term though, I think are even more serious.
19:16The longer this goes on, the more we see hardening on both sides in terms of future relations and future engagement.
19:23There is a declining will for deepening economic cooperation,
19:28and even the opposite, moving towards sort of a local version of decoupling,
19:31which is the antithesis of what every development institution,
19:35multilateral development bank says needs to happen in the greater Mekong sub-region,
19:40which is deeper trade, deeper investment, deeper integration.
19:43And this conflict already has set us back three, four, five years minimum.
19:47I mean, before we started the interview, we were having a little bit of a chat,
19:50and we talked about how this has also sort of developed into becoming a social media warfare as well,
19:56with disinformation and perhaps even misinformation.
19:59How do you think this perhaps complicates this conflict even more?
20:03Oh, I think it's become terrifying since it began, the amount on both sides.
20:07And this does simply serve, I mean, the worst outcome is it simply gins up and it builds this hyper-nationalism more and more and more.
20:15It results in pressure being placed on leaders who otherwise would be very much willing to compromise,
20:19who are realistic about some of these outcomes, saying, well, I simply can't because the popular nationalism is simply so intense.
20:27And I've been stunned to see how much misinformation.
20:31I mean, I would say this is Southeast Asia's first full social media war.
20:35Yeah. No, that is scary.
20:37But perhaps coming into play as well is ASEAN potentially trying to flex its muscle a little bit in terms of conflict resolution mechanism.
20:47And, you know, we're seeing this role played by Malaysia as the mediator, one of the mediators, one of the external players getting involved.
20:55How do you see ASEAN coming into play and particularly Malaysia's role as chair of ASEAN this year?
21:02Do you think their mechanisms in, you know, managing this conflict, did it hold up?
21:06Or do you think this is where we saw their limitations exposed, you know, with, you know, issues of non-interference, of course?
21:14So, Malaysia's role itself, I think Malaysia's done everything it possibly can within the unfortunate confines of ASEAN's institutional abilities.
21:24And to such an extent that there is very much a desire that Malaysia stays on even after its chairmanship, holding a mediating role,
21:32because it's been very successful, it's highly trusted by both parties.
21:36The issue though, however, is that ASEAN is much better at dealing with how to enforce peace agreements and how to mitigate the outcomes rather than trying to find peace.
21:46Because of the principle of non-interference and so, et cetera, et cetera, ASEAN is in practice very, very limited.
21:52Now, the fact that we still have, we have the Cambodia-Thailand conflict at the same time that we have the Myanmar conflict,
21:58to my view, and I think to many other folks who specialize in studying ASEAN politics,
22:04it's, and we've been saying it for a long time, but it's time to reconsider whether ASEAN is fully fit for purpose.
22:11We all love ASEAN, we all want ASEAN to succeed, but do some structural changes potentially need to be made to make it more effective in this space?
22:18Other than Malaysia, of course, what got a lot of attention in the media was the role played by the U.S. and China.
22:25How do you think this then complicates this as well?
22:29So, I think, so the U.S. was essentially the lead actor in July, but also that was very much a coincidence of timing.
22:35The U.S. was just about to roll out its final tariff numbers, everybody was absolutely panicked,
22:41and this gave the U.S. the perfect tool to bring everybody to the negotiating table.
22:45And again, and do it, and points to Washington on this, and do it essentially under an ASEAN leadership.
22:50China took a somewhat different approach.
22:52China's generally less confrontational on these lines, and did some private meetings in Shanghai.
22:59Had a different approach that it was going to go with, wanted to go with, but the states chose the ASEAN track.
23:05So, overall, this initially worked.
23:07At present, however, I think we're seeing a bigger challenge, and that's precisely because the Thai elections have come.
23:13So, what might have worked for Washington, what did work, rather, for Washington in July, an economic threat that's essentially not long-term,
23:21but it's a while off in terms of economic effects, that's really powerful when you're looking at it long-term.
23:27But if you're a government looking at reelection in the next 45 days, you're not as concerned about long-term economic effects if it's something that could really harm you maintaining power.
23:39So, that change in timing is why a lot of us are concerned at present, that the U.S. will have to intervene, utilizing other tools.
23:47Looking specifically at the Thailand-Cambodia border clashes, what do you think will continue or change in the new year?
23:55I think that if we're able to, if there's some, Thailand has, as of earlier today, basically stated that it would consider returning to a ceasefire,
24:04but with very clear requests for Cambodia. Cambodia said it's always been at the table.
24:09If, hopefully, we do see a ceasefire in the very, very near term, I would expect that it will not likely be durable, though, that we will see continued flare-ups.
24:18Again, I think the outcome here has to be the development of political stability in Thailand post-election.
24:26Absent that, it's going to be the domestic politics running it, not the broader security questions.
24:31You know, of course, we have to keep in mind this episode is airing about a week or two weeks from the date of recording today, so there might be a lot more developing in the next few days.
24:43But, you know, taking a step back and looking at the region as a whole, what do you think are the biggest risks for Southeast Asia heading into 2026?
24:53I think there's, they all kind of stem off the same word, spillover.
24:57We know the situation in Myanmar is becoming more challenging, and they have the election coming, et cetera.
25:03But, so the possibility of continued spillover effects from that conflict are a big challenge.
25:08I think one issue that we've seen much more in northern mainland Southeast Asia that we need to pay attention to much more fully as a region are the spillover effects and the continuing genuine issues of scam compounds.
25:18The scam compound cyber scamming issue is billions and billions of dollars.
25:23At the same time, the negative effects otherwise on criminality in the region, et cetera, are simply huge.
25:28So dealing with that and paying attention to that is vital.
25:31The third, and I say this because I know what's coming in 2026 in terms of our friends in the Philippines take over their chairmanship,
25:38and the Philippines has made very clear that they'd like to spend their focus on the South China Sea issue.
25:43It's a vital issue. South China Sea is the greatest security issue, if not in the region, obviously, but also globally in terms of the potential for, with the exception of Taiwan, however you include it, whether inside or outside.
25:55But preparing for a very, very serious, very challenging, very frank discussion of a South China Sea code of conduct next year.
26:04And this is a very large opportunity for ASEAN. It's also something that's absolutely essential.
26:11And this is going to be one of those areas where we're going to see a massive amount of disagreement, but it could also end up being one of the most important milestones in regional security in some time.
26:22Keeping this in mind, what do you think are some of the sort of agenda items that should be prioritized by either policymakers, security planners, either within or outside the ASEAN framework for 2026?
26:36Within ASEAN, I think it's continuing to focus on de-escalation.
26:40And I mean, whether it's in Myanmar or in the Cambodia-Thailand conflict, these are at the front of the table, front of the room, and they need to be focused on.
26:50Other areas of focus, I think, that we haven't touched on that aren't necessarily on a security side.
26:55I mean, South China Sea, et cetera. But for me, the other enormous area coming out of ASEAN this year or next year is the Digital Economy Framework Agreement,
27:04which is the new digital trade package, harmonization package across ASEAN estimated to double GDP in that sector from one trillion to two trillion.
27:13It's been delayed for a while. There's challenges still going on.
27:16But getting that through for the economic future of every single country is absolutely essential.
27:22So seeing how that goes is my other area of concern.
27:27Definitely a lot to look out for in the years to come.
27:30Absolutely. Absolutely. Nothing's ever boring in ASEAN.
27:34That's true. Plenty more I like to pick your brain on, but that is all the time that we have today.
27:39Thank you so much, Dr. Bradley, for joining us.
27:41Thank you so much. My pleasure.
27:42That is all on Awani Global this week and potentially this year as we wrap up our reflections for 2025.
27:49Plenty more to look out for in 2026, of course.
27:52So stay tuned to Awani Global as we bring more discussions on what to expect around the world in terms of conflict, security and tensions, geopolitical issues.
28:02But definitely a lot of trends to look out for.
28:04But that is all with me on Awani Global with me, Naila Hoda. We'll catch you next time.
28:22All right.
28:34All right.

Recommended