00:00Independent Senator Michael DeLavesteed, senior counsel, is opening debate from the
00:05independent bench saying the time has come for Trinidad and Tobago to finally give legal
00:12force to long-standing common law principles.
00:15And I think it is time that we did so.
00:21So I commend the government in bringing this bill to parliament to the extent that it represents
00:32an attempt to, through legislation, to clarify, develop and codify the common law with respect
00:43to the law on self-defense in the home invasion context.
00:50But the senior counsel says he has serious reservations about several provisions of the bill.
00:56He pointed to the definition of a dwelling house, which includes adjacent land or structures
01:02within the same curtilage, but does not require the area to be fenced or enclosed.
01:08My concern is someone may enter into a dwelling house without realizing that he's doing so
01:17because he enters into unfenced open land, which happens to be used by the adjoining occupant
01:25of the dwelling house for maybe intermittent activities related to the dwelling house such
01:30as, I don't know, burning rubbish from time to time or parking cars from time to time.
01:34Senator DeLavesteed says that issue could be resolved through a minor amendment, but he highlighted
01:41a more fundamental problem, the provision that allows an occupant to use deadly force even when
01:48their life or limb is not in immediate danger.
01:51I agree with what the law association said in its comments to an earlier version of this section.
02:01In saying that the section seems to elevate the interest in the occupant's interest in his property
02:09above the right to life of the home invader, and I don't think to that extent the bill could be constitutional.
02:24He warns that the public may walk away with a dangerous misconception, believing that the
02:30bill gives them wide new powers to kill home intruders without consequence.
02:35It's important that the public understand that from their point of view, this bill by itself changes
02:41very little for them, at least the majority of the public. The bill at least in terms of permitting
02:49occupants to defend themselves against home invaders largely follows the common law.
02:54Senator DeLavesteed added that the legislation will have no real deterrent effect on criminals.
03:01It would be fanciful to suggest that prospective home invaders are going to have second thoughts about
03:07invading homes because of this legislation. They are not going to be deterred from invading
03:11someone's house with weapons on the basis that this bill will make it more likely that they will face
03:16resistance or greater resistance. Generally speaking, the persons which this bill may have some interest
03:23is firearm users because they are the ones licensed firearm users. They are the ones who have the real
03:30potential, real potential to resist to defend themselves.
03:34The debate on the home invasion bill continues with government lawmakers defending the reforms as
03:40critical, while independent and opposition voices warn that clarity, constitutionality and public
03:48understanding must remain at the forefront.