00:00 Hi, hello, this is Abhigvendra Charia from Outlook Magazine.
00:03 Today we are going to discuss,
00:05 or rather talk about, Women's Reservation Bill.
00:08 So for the last three decades, as we know,
00:10 there have been struggles to pass
00:12 this Women's Reservation Bill.
00:14 But what has been the major concerns of the bills?
00:18 Rather, we have found that several parties,
00:20 from Samajwadi Party, Rashtriya Janata Dal,
00:22 earlier even JDU, recently, recently Congress,
00:26 they have said that this Women's Reservation Bill
00:30 doesn't give proper representation
00:32 to the marginalized woman,
00:34 that is the OBC woman and the minorities.
00:38 So in this context, we have to understand
00:40 there are two trajectories of the bill,
00:44 or the whole reservation scenario.
00:46 Number one, as far as the Women's Reservation Bill
00:48 is concerned, in its current form,
00:51 it offers 33% reservation to the woman, number one.
00:55 Number two, it offers 33% reservation to the SCST woman
01:00 from the SCST quota.
01:03 If we just break it down to understand it in a simple manner,
01:08 then we get some numbers that in current Lok Sabha situation
01:13 there's 543 seats, among which 181 will be reserved
01:17 for the woman, that is one third of it.
01:19 And in current situation, 131 is the total number
01:22 of the SCST seats, among which 44 seats
01:24 will be reserved for the SCST woman.
01:27 But the condition is, in today's time,
01:29 we have 78 women MP in the Lok Sabha,
01:32 but among them only 20 women MPs are from SCST community,
01:37 the percentage is around 26%.
01:39 This percentage will remain intact.
01:42 Why is it important?
01:43 Because Mayawati, during 90s and even during
01:47 the last few years, claimed it very clearly
01:49 that the SCST quota should not be touched.
01:52 What she rather said, that the woman from the SCST community
01:56 should be given some reservation
01:59 from the total woman's reservation chunk.
02:02 She said that otherwise, what rightfully
02:06 is SCST community, SCST women, they will not get that.
02:10 So in this context, as it has not been done,
02:13 the sub quota has not been given,
02:15 will it affect the SCST community, this woman,
02:18 or will it some way or other affect
02:21 the whole marginalized groups?
02:22 This is one part of the second part
02:23 is the reservation of the OBC and minorities.
02:27 So in this case, for the last 30 years,
02:30 as I was just saying that for 30 years,
02:33 OBC reservation and the minority woman reservation
02:35 have been the major issue of concern.
02:37 So why is it so big issue?
02:39 Because the point is, we don't have any caste census,
02:43 we don't know the population of OBC,
02:45 but if the Mundell Commission is concerned,
02:47 the Mundell Commission's point is to be taken seriously,
02:51 then we have 52%, at least in 90s,
02:53 we had 52% OBC population.
02:56 But recently, if I just go by the recent data
02:59 that's published in 2021
03:02 by the United District Information System
03:04 for Education Plus, they take the school enrollment data
03:07 and what they do in this case,
03:08 they just find out that what is the proportion
03:10 of the OBCs in this case.
03:12 And so they found out that 45% of the population is OBC.
03:16 So this huge number of OBC population
03:20 cannot be just denied the reservation
03:23 the way it has been denied.
03:24 And that's the major context of the debate
03:26 in Baldigarjun Khargi yesterday,
03:27 Sonia Gandhi is backing for this as well.
03:29 So why is this government so feared of rather
03:32 any upper caste government has been feared
03:34 of OBC communities or the minority communities
03:36 in terms of giving a reservation?
03:37 For this case, we have to understand,
03:39 rather I would like to quote one article
03:43 written by Nivedita Menon,
03:44 where she clearly says that's very important
03:47 that I quote Nivedita Menon,
03:48 as Vasanthi Raman points out,
03:50 OBCs and Muslims given their numerical strength
03:52 as well as their social location,
03:54 pose a greater threat to upper castes than SC/STs
03:57 about whom some complacency was still possible.
04:01 So in this case, as we have already seen
04:03 that the OBCs and minorities
04:04 don't have their representation,
04:06 SCs and STs have their representation,
04:07 but whatever the representation earlier was,
04:09 it will almost be remain intact.
04:10 So in this context, we have to ask,
04:13 will the marginalized voice be heard in the parliament
04:16 or will the subaltern woman speak ever?
04:19 For more, just click the link below.