00:00Outlook's December issue focused on the 100 years of left in India and that had us questioning,
00:05who or what is a communist or a socialist?
00:08Well, according to the internet, the answer is almost everyone.
00:12When Gurudad, playing a struggling artist in 1955,
00:16talks about people sleeping on the footpaths with nothing to eat,
00:20Lalita Pawar's character, quite disgusted honestly, asks,
00:23are you a communist?
00:25And that just smiles and says, no, I'm a cartoonist.
00:28Fast forward to 2025, when Zohran Mandani rides a bike in Manhattan.
00:33Someone yells at him,
00:34On social media, if you say anything about rights or equality,
00:41congratulations, you're officially a commie.
00:44For your reference, communism, socialism, feminism and all the other isms
00:48are not interchangeable labels to define any free thoughts.
00:53Want to protect Palestinian children, you are red.
00:56Want women to walk safely at night,
00:58Red.
00:59Stand in front of bulldozers to save a forest,
01:02definitely red.
01:03And advocate for the homeless in Delhi who are shivering in the cold,
01:07also red.
01:08So is having blue hair a sure sign of being a commie radical feminist?
01:12Social media says yes.
01:14Wear glasses and read a book about inequality?
01:17You're plotting the downfall of capitalism.
01:19Post a thread about universal healthcare.
01:23Halfway to Gulag membership already.
01:24But let's pause.
01:27What actually is a communist, socialist, feminist?
01:31A communist believes in common ownership of production,
01:34like Marx sees the means and all that.
01:36A socialist supports welfare and public ownership,
01:39such as larki bhen schemes.
01:41And feminist wants gender equality.
01:44Though these meanings no longer hold any real value because media, social media and even politicians
01:50have induced fear against free thinkers who demand rights or equality,
01:54take for instance the Delhi police,
01:56claiming that intellectual terrorists are more dangerous in Supreme Court during the 2020 riots arguments
02:03or the government using urban naxus as attacks against students or even activists.
02:09So maybe the real communist, socialists, feminists of today are divorced from their original texts.
02:16They are the ones actually doing the work,
02:18analysing policy, fighting for equitable laws,
02:21supporting vulnerable communities,
02:22protecting the environment and not just yelling from a keyboard.
02:26Next time you feel the urge to call someone a commie,
02:30step back and ask,
02:31am I criticising ideas or just trying to sound edgy?
02:35So maybe today's socialists and feminists just want a slightly less absurd world.
02:40For minorities to live without punishment for their identity,
02:43for women to not be raped or killed for the crime of being women,
02:46for children to not be bombed in Gaza.
02:49And in 2025,
02:51that might be revolutionary enough.
Comments