The Government is expected to table amendments to the Employment Insurance System Act in Parliament, to introduce the Extended Maternity Leave Assistance, or Elaun Pasca Cuti Bersalin (EPCB). But could a maternity benefit designed exclusively for women inadvertently reinforce the perception that childcare is primarily the mother's responsibility? A new UNICEF Malaysia policy brief examines how the government can tweak and strengthen this proposed scheme. This episode of #ConsiderThis Melisa Idris speaks to Lee Min Hui, Social Policy Specialist at UNICEF Malaysia and Dr Haniza Khalid, Director at the Centre of Excellence for Research and Innovation in Islamic Economics at the ISRA Institute under INCEIF University.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:11Hello and good evening. I'm Melissa Idris. Welcome to Consider This.
00:15This is the show where we want you to consider and then reconsider what you know of the news of
00:19the day.
00:19The government is expected to table amendments to the Employment Insurance System Act in Parliament
00:26to introduce the Extended Maternity Leave Assistance or EPCB for short.
00:35The question we want to explore tonight is whether or not a maternity benefit that is designed exclusively for mothers,
00:43could that inadvertently reinforce the perception that childcare is primarily the woman's responsibility
00:53and what a new UNICEF Malaysia policy brief has done is examine this proposed initiative
00:59and how the government may tweak or strengthen this proposed scheme.
01:06So joining me on the show today is the co-author of the policy brief, Lee Minhui,
01:11who is a Social Policy Specialist at UNICEF Malaysia.
01:13I also have with me in the studio Dr. Haniza Khalid,
01:17who is Director at the Centre of Excellence for Research and Innovation in Islamic Economics
01:21at the ISRA Institute under UNICEF University.
01:25Welcome to the show. Thank you so much for joining me today.
01:28Minhui, if I may start with you since you are the co-author of the policy brief,
01:32I want you to maybe start with the basics.
01:33Introduce us to what the government is proposing,
01:36this Extended Maternity Leave Assistance Scheme.
01:39What is it trying to address and trying to solve?
01:42Because we currently have, what, 98 days of maternity leave. Is that not enough?
01:46Thank you for the question.
01:48So what the EPCB is trying to do is to really allow eligible mothers
01:53an extended month of leave at 80% of her wages.
01:59So what essentially this means is that it moves for eligible mothers
02:03the maternity leave duration from 98 days to about 126 days,
02:08which brings it closer to actually the best practices globally,
02:12as set out by the ILO.
02:14Where we are with 98 days is the minimum.
02:16Okay.
02:17And now we are moving closer.
02:18But one thing to think about when we're talking about the EPCB
02:21is that it's trying to encourage mothers to take longer maternity leave,
02:26understanding that it supports maternal and child health
02:29and can also increase job attachment and return to the workforce after.
02:33Okay, alright.
02:34So you said it brings us closer to international best practices.
02:37Do we know, so what's the international best practice?
02:41How long is maternity leave?
02:43How long should maternity leave be?
02:44So globally that's about 128 days, 18 weeks.
02:47That's where the standard is set.
02:49That is where the best outcomes for mother and child tend to be seen.
02:53Okay.
02:54So at 80% of the wage of the mother for the extra one month period.
03:01And this is going to be funded, or the government is proposing this be funded through Percaso's employment insurance system,
03:08rather than maternity leave being under the employer's cost usually, right?
03:15So talk to me about that.
03:17Is this a good idea?
03:18Well, I would say there are actually potentially more pros than cons in this space.
03:23Because the EPCB being funded by the employment insurance system, EIS, means that it is part of a social insurance
03:29approach
03:30that enables the redistribution of maternity costs from individuals like women and their families
03:36to the wider contributing labour force.
03:38And this can actually reduce the disincentives of hiring or promoting women in the workforce.
03:44And it's also important because it minimises the direct costs for businesses.
03:49We know that Malaysia's economy is 97.4% made up of SMEs.
03:56And SMEs are the ones who are saying it's really expensive and difficult for us to pay for extra family
04:02-friendly policies
04:02beyond what is already mandated in the Employment Act.
04:05So this really is something that is also aligning with a lot of the movements a lot of countries are
04:10moving to.
04:11In Southeast Asia, most countries are already transitioning away from pure employer liability models,
04:17which is what we have in Malaysia, towards hybrid or social insurance-based financing.
04:22Well, countries like Vietnam and the Philippines, for example, have also adopted fully pooled systems.
04:28And our research finds that countries that rely more on social insurance or public financing mechanisms
04:34tend to exhibit higher women's labour force participation rates
04:38because it promotes risk-sharing when it comes to supporting women's employment outcomes.
04:43Okay, if I may bring Dr. Haniza into this.
04:45You're an economist, you look at social protections, you've done significant work in this.
04:51Talk to me a little bit about this, the social insurance financing and the risk-sharing approach.
04:56Why is that important to think about it beyond just an employer cost perspective?
05:02Thank you, Melissa.
05:05The protection that comes from this scheme is mainly to protect the right of the women
05:12to take extra leave without risk of losing her job or risk of losing income or going for lower income
05:26and so on
05:27because of her desire to have extra months.
05:31All right, so that gives a little bit more confidence and certainty for women who go off on maternity
05:38and comes back that she can, she can opt for this extra month.
05:42And when she choose to, it will not be denied from, it will not be denied to her
05:48because the money that comes, the money that goes into this expense comes from the EIS.
05:53Not the employer.
05:54Not the employer.
05:54Not the employer.
05:54So the employer does not have any reason to, you know, not to give.
05:58But at the same time, it will disincentivise the employer from taking women in
06:04because now they have that option to go on the longer maternity leave.
06:09So it's not about the money now, but it's about the interruptions that the employer feel they might have to
06:15deal with,
06:16with, you know, all these longer, these longer allocations of leave.
06:20So in terms of it being part of the social insurance, I think this fits perfectly well.
06:28One is because, of course, EIS is already a scheme that's funded by the government
06:32and it covers 100% of the formal workers.
06:36And it is a contingent case, you know, I mean, not everyone will be using it.
06:41So it's not, it's not your savings that's being used.
06:44It's when one of you needs to use it.
06:46This is the social, you know, the social contribution of everyone to help you, to help you obtain your rights
06:53and so on.
06:54Sorry to interrupt.
06:55Would that, is that a sustainable way to think about this?
07:00Using Perkeso, essentially using the EIS to fund this.
07:05Is that sustainable?
07:07Because the other option is that you can only go for this kind of extra benefit by taking from your
07:13own savings.
07:14Okay.
07:15So when you use Perkeso, you're not taking from your own savings.
07:18It is a pool of risk, I see.
07:20So this is where that one person is socially funded by the rest of us to be able to enjoy
07:26that extra month raising her child.
07:29A form of social insurance, which is one reason.
07:32This is why this comes under social protection.
07:35Okay, right.
07:36You know, you wanted to weigh in.
07:37So we might talk about how employers may be disincentivized to hire more women.
07:45But let's, let's put that, put a pin in that and come back to that.
07:47I want to talk about using Perkeso as the vehicle to fund this.
07:52Is that, is that a smart idea to fund it through the employment insurance system?
07:57I understand that not everyone is covered by this, right?
08:00Yes, you're right in saying that because only a fraction of women would be able to enjoy this.
08:06We do know that only formerly employed women who contribute to employment insurance system would be able to enjoy this.
08:13But let's think a bit broader because when we talk about family friendly policies as UNICEF,
08:18what we really get all the time that we get from employers are that it's really expensive.
08:23The full cost is borne by us.
08:25And when the Employment Act was actually first implemented, there was, you know, some evidence from surveys saying that employers
08:32were not very keen on hiring women
08:35because of the perceived cost of having to pay for longer maternity leave.
08:39Now, these are the unintended or unintended discriminatory effects that are held on women.
08:44And that's where policy design is really important.
08:48And why do we think social financing is the key?
08:51A lot of countries are already moving away from employer liability models because what is more sustainable is when the
08:56cost of something as important as childbirth,
08:59something that everybody has an interest in to have a child, to see a child being born, being born well
09:04for mother and child to prosper,
09:06is to have that cost shared between the parents, the employees, the employers and the public itself.
09:13So moving forward, this is ideally a model that we can move towards.
09:16Okay, so let's look at some of the concerns around policy design.
09:20We all agree this is a good policy, but can the design be tweaked or strengthened or improved in any
09:26way?
09:26And one of the concerns, I think the chief concern that UNICEF has had is that if you have this
09:32benefit designed exclusively for mothers,
09:35that reinforces the perception that women are the primary caregivers for children.
09:41So talk to me about this unintended consequence.
09:45Well, firstly, I want to say that the EPCB in itself is still extremely a very progressive form of policy
09:51because it is a great move towards ensuring that women are able to enjoy best practices in maternity protection.
09:58It is enhanced maternity protection.
10:00But what the policy brief is also trying to ask is,
10:03do our policies effectively redistribute care more equitably within the family
10:08and help reduce the gender gap in the workforce?
10:11And how can better design of policies improve the achievement of better outcomes?
10:16And why do I say this?
10:17It's very normal for a lot of governments to have care policies that target women
10:22because women are across the world the primary caregivers.
10:25But if policies do not also target men, if this is not offset by targeting men,
10:31they may fail to address why care is such an issue in the first place.
10:35So worse, they may even reinforce the idea that you said that care is a woman's job.
10:40And ideally, we move away from such gender discriminatory effects.
10:44We do know that longer maternity leave supports mothers and infants,
10:47but without leave for fathers to balance out,
10:50it may deepen the perception that women are more costly to hire.
10:53And this is why we're looking at including fathers in the EPCB
10:57because that would send a very strong message.
11:00When we look at the EPCB, we ask the question,
11:03what if we were to use EIS to add on another extra seven days for fathers' paternity leave?
11:08We know that fathers enjoy seven days now.
11:10How about another seven days?
11:12Because that would bring it up to two weeks,
11:13and that would be the recommended benchmark across the world.
11:17A lot of developed countries kind of settle on two weeks at the average.
11:20And so this will be positive because fathers taking paternity leave
11:24actually increase their household capital and boost their relationship to their children.
11:28But it can also reduce the child penalty for women
11:31and even reduce the intra-household gender wage gap and the macro-level gender wage gap.
11:36Okay, so we have extended maternity benefits,
11:39but you're proposing also extended paternity leave with benefits,
11:45with 80% wage benefits as well?
11:47Ideally at 80% because benchmark with what we already have.
11:50Dr. Anizo, I'm going to come back to what we put the pin on the table
11:55about the employers being disincentivised to hire women
12:00with the perception that women are costlier to hire
12:04because they'll be out of the workforce or disruptive to operations.
12:08Could extending paternity leave maybe even out this balance
12:14or address the child penalty that Min Hui was talking about?
12:18I think what Min is referring to is that using the same EPCB mechanism,
12:23instead of paying, instead of just paying women who wants to take it,
12:27they can pay men who wants to take it, again from EIS,
12:31at the 80% cap, at the 80% wage and the $6,000 cap.
12:37What I'm trying to say is that the paternity leave in other countries
12:41have been in place for a long time and many of them go beyond seven days.
12:45But we need to look at the take-up rates of this paternity leave
12:50and secondly how they are used.
12:53Both the paternity leave, whether it is given as unpaid leave or EIS covered leave,
13:01does not cost the company a single cent.
13:06It is the employee themselves, whether they take it up and how they use it.
13:12And at the end of the day, we are looking at the overall impact on women's gender,
13:18child penalty, whether it changes the distribution because this is not about leave and payment.
13:26This is about your cultural norm, your social norm, how you take redistribution of work in the family,
13:33the dynamics of sharing care work and children's responsibility,
13:38which is something that needs probably a bigger nudge than just, you know,
13:43you have seven more days and you have five more, you know, and salary and so on.
13:49Can I ask you the same question I asked about funding it through the Perkesos EIS?
13:55If we do want to redesign this scheme to include fathers with an extra seven days, extra week,
14:04would that be a sustainable financing option to do this?
14:08Would that be more expensive? Is that something that the system can handle?
14:11Okay. Whether it is women or men enjoying the EPCB benefit,
14:17it all depends on the fiscal space or fiscal sustainability that we have.
14:22Yes.
14:22Because the EIS is a contribution-based scheme, right?
14:26So it all depends on how many people contribute.
14:29So when the labour force shrinks, we have less contributors.
14:34So today we might be okay, but in the future we'll have to consider the inflow coming from the number
14:40of contributors that we have
14:41versus the outflow, which is the claims on that year, as well as because we are sharing it with employment
14:48insurance.
14:49So it also depends on what other claims are being put to that pool of funds.
14:54It would also depend on demographic changes.
14:56But I'm thinking this is a wonderful way of keeping women in the workforce, right?
14:59It is.
14:59So you actually incentivise mothers to continue working after the birth of a child. Yes?
15:07Exactly.
15:07I also wanted to go back to what you said earlier.
15:10Is it sustainable?
15:11Well, based on our calculations, and if we account for the higher wages among insured male workers
15:16and higher, of course, male labour force participation rates,
15:20we estimate that the total annual cost would range between RM70 million to RM90 million,
15:25or about 7% of total EIS contributions.
15:28So this would mean that they would come at an additional cost, but it will not be a massive additional
15:34cost.
15:357% is manageable, right?
15:37I think it's something that we can consider because if we want to reduce the gender gap
15:41and think more critically about how we are redistributing care work within the home,
15:46it is potentially an important investment to make at this stage.
15:49Can we talk a little bit about the motherhood penalty, or child penalty as it's referred to in the policy
15:56brief?
15:57Talk to me about that, about what it is culturally, what the evidence is,
16:02because this has been backed by statistical data.
16:05This is an actual phenomenon that's happening in workplaces.
16:08Tell me about the cost to working mothers. Minhui, if you want to start.
16:12Sure. So the motherhood penalty, or the child penalty, is essentially defined as the reduction in wages
16:19that a woman experiences once she has a child.
16:24But the research in Malaysia shows that women don't necessarily need to have children
16:29to even experience that form of a child penalty.
16:32And I want to bring up some research that was done by the Women's Aid Organisation a few years ago,
16:36where women who were trying to be hired during interview stages,
16:41employers would ask them, are you planning to have a child?
16:44And this sort of implicitly brings the idea that employers kind of don't want you to have a child.
16:49At the same time, women would be considered not performing well, maybe lazy because they need to take time off.
16:56And when they come back, they don't necessarily have the kinds of opportunities that they had before they had a
17:00child.
17:01So the child penalty and motherhood penalty is real. It happens in all countries.
17:06You know, Malaysia is no stranger to this. So we're not an exception, that's what I'm saying.
17:10And therefore, when we include fathers, there's a potential for that motherhood penalty to be reduced over time.
17:16Right. What about you, Dr. Haniza? When we look at maternity and paternity benefits, often think about it as leave,
17:25right?
17:26We think about parental leave. But what is the cost of it to the individual, the motherhood penalty?
17:33Also, the cost to the country, to productivity as having mothers who are not back in the workforce after childbirth.
17:44Yeah. But first, I just want to note that the childhood penalty is not the same across different industries.
17:51Okay.
17:52It is most probably significantly felt when you have competition between men and women for the same set of jobs.
18:02You don't see this in the nursing, for example.
18:04Oh, because it's very heavy gendered.
18:07Because it's very heavy gendered.
18:07And they have worked out some kind of way, you know, some kind of a solution to deal with the
18:14rate of, you know,
18:16mothers getting pregnant and going off on leave and so on. But when you have situations where you need to
18:23break the glass ceiling,
18:25when you need to, you know, you need to put your, that momentum, yes, it is sort of interrupted for
18:31a while, right?
18:32But the employer should not make it worse or pre-conceived, this preconceived idea that it will happen
18:46and it will jeopardize the company's momentum or the person's productivity momentum and so on.
18:53So that kind of prejudgment is not what we want.
18:56Okay.
18:58And if we think it through and think really hard, there must be ways for us to adjust and to
19:06accommodate such situation
19:08without, you know, putting pressures on, I mean, without losing out.
19:12In what ways?
19:14For example, flexible work arrangements, interim support, you know, and then all sorts of arrangements,
19:21especially what you can find in this current age and time, to not allow that consequences to be felt.
19:33I mean, we are in the AI age and so on. So we have to also re-look that.
19:39But if you have employers that are still old school in that thinking, you know, so it's very hard.
19:47But as I said, to be fair, it is very, the sense or the possibility of a child penalty happening
19:59is not equally distributed across all industries.
20:03It depends on the sector.
20:04Some industries have managed to work through that and some industries where the competition or where, you know,
20:10you don't have that balance, you're still suffering from it.
20:14So, Min Hui, the policy brief, the UNICEF policy brief actually looks at more than just parental leave, right?
20:20Yes, I wanted to jump in on that, also frame it in terms of the consequences we are facing right
20:25now.
20:26Because just basic stats, we know that women's labour force participation rate is lagging in Malaysia behind men's at 56
20:33.6%.
20:33And it's also lagging within the Southeast Asia region.
20:36And if we look at, in 2025, of the 3 million Malaysians outside the labour force due to household responsibilities,
20:4497% of them were women.
20:47So, we are already facing that cost.
20:49And on an individual level, what does this mean?
20:51This means that when women age, they're going to have less retirement savings, less job-related social protection.
20:57And in an ageing nation, these costs will only compound.
21:00And that's why we also talk about going beyond parental leave.
21:04We talk about care and support systems.
21:06It's really an ecosystem.
21:07Care and support doesn't stop in the first five years of life because we know that, you know,
21:12parents who are caring for a young child, during the zero to five, that's when they need the most support.
21:17That's when income drops and that the resources that are needed to survive increases.
21:23But we also talk about things that are equally important within the life cycle.
21:27So, we talk about policies like childcare access, quality childcare.
21:32We talk about flexible work arrangements, breastfeeding support because that enables the health of the child in the long term.
21:38And we also talk about labour protections, basic labour protections and adequate wages.
21:42So, it really is an entire system that supports the family.
21:45It goes beyond just childbirth as well, right?
21:48Exactly.
21:49As you said, it's part of the life cycle.
21:51Okay, I'm going to give Dr Haniza the last word.
21:53What would you like to see?
21:55How would you like to see Malaysia extend child benefits or parental benefits beyond just the proposed per case?
22:06So, the EPCB scheme?
22:12The EPCB is definitely a step in the right direction because at least it removes the burden,
22:17the financial burden on the employers, for example, the SMEs from allowing this extra one month, right?
22:27So, that's definitely something to add to the whole story of how we support mothers.
22:32And when we support mothers, we have to remember we are actually supporting the country
22:36because that's where our labour is going to come from.
22:39That's where our innovation, our consumption, our demand is going to come from.
22:43This is real economics here, you know?
22:45And the fact that we are ageing is actually simply part of the story is because we don't have enough
22:52children.
22:52So, we do not have enough, we cannot replace ourselves as a population.
22:57Replacement rate.
22:57Yes.
22:58And therefore, we totally have an economy that could be mismatched at one time
23:04because you're producing for a population or a demographic that's no longer there.
23:08And you need to respond to the demographic that you have in front of you.
23:15So, all of this is interconnected.
23:19So, supporting women is actually supporting yourself, supporting the economy, supporting the country.
23:24And we do not need to say this is a woman's problem or this is an employer-employee problem.
23:34It goes beyond that in that sense, right?
23:37So, definitely, yes, this is a step in the right direction.
23:44And wherever we, and then the workplace changes needs to happen, the workplace norms needs to happen.
23:50The home norms at home needs to happen as well to make it easier.
23:57And I think even having said that, I will still say that women in Malaysia has a very good working
24:04environment in that sense.
24:05I mean, we can get the childcare support and also compared to other countries.
24:12And we are accepted at the workplace very well.
24:16So, yeah, but we're always striving for more.
24:18We can always improve, definitely.
24:20I really like that.
24:21Thank you both for being on the show and highlighting some of these really important ways we can make life
24:28better for parents in general.
24:30Thank you for your time. I appreciate it.
24:32Thank you so much for this.
24:33That's all the time we have for you on this episode of Consider This.
24:36I'm Melissa Idris signing off for the evening.
24:38Thank you so much for watching.
24:39Goodnight.
24:40Bye.

Recommended