00:00What's going on everybody? Well here's another live service game that won't be making it to
00:04digital store shelves. Sony has officially cancelled Fair Games, where the S is a dollar
00:09sign, the multiplayer high shooter being developed by Haven Studios more than three years after it
00:14was originally announced. And honestly, I'm starting to wonder when Sony is going to realize
00:19that live service shooters aren't the golden goose they seem to think they are. The company
00:23has spent years trying to establish itself in this market, but the results haven't exactly
00:28been encouraging. So what happened to Fair Games, what does this mean for Haven Studios,
00:33and how many more projects will Sony cancel before reconsidering its strategy? Let's get into it.
00:39Fair Games was originally announced during the 2023 PlayStation Showcase. The project was being
00:44developed by Haven Studios, a studio founded by Jade Raymond before being acquired by Sony. The game
00:51was described as a competitive multiplayer high shooter where players would work together to pull
00:55off elaborate robberies. However, despite being announced more than three years ago, we never
01:00actually got a proper look at the game. Sony showed off a CGI announcement trailer, but actual gameplay
01:06was never formally revealed to the public. That meant we were left wondering what the finished product
01:11would look like, and more importantly, what would make it stand out in an increasingly crowded
01:15multiplayer shooter market. According to a Bloomberg report published on November 10, Sony has officially
01:22ended development on Fair Games for both PlayStation 5 and PC. The decision reportedly followed a recent
01:28playtest that left PlayStation executives unconvinced that the game could maintain a sufficiently large
01:34player base. In a note sent to Haven developers, PlayStation executives Sean Decker and John Doyle
01:40acknowledged that the test demonstrated strong operational performance, live service readiness,
01:45and community engagement. However, player feedback and retention results were mixed and fell short of
01:51the company's expectations. Sony also pointed towards challenging market conditions in the competitive
01:57player versus player shooter genre as another reason behind the decision. And this brings us to one of
02:03the biggest problems facing games like Fair Games. Getting people to try a new multiplayer shooter is one
02:08thing. Getting them to stick around is something else entirely. Players already have plenty of
02:13options. Whether it's established franchises like Call of Duty, free-to-play experiences like Apex Legends,
02:20or team-based shooters like Overwatch 2, there's no shortage of games competing for people's attention.
02:25A new live service game needs to give players a compelling reason to invest their time,
02:30and that means consistently delivering content, updates, and experiences that keep them coming back.
02:35And if a game can't accomplish that, it doesn't matter how much money was invested in development,
02:40or how impressive the original announcement might have been.
02:44What's particularly interesting is that Sony is dealing with these challenges, while also having its own live service shooter struggles.
02:51Take Marathon, for example. Bungie's extraction shooter launched on March 5th,
02:552026, but has reportedly struggled to build an audience on Steam.
02:59Now, Fair Games and Marathon aren't exactly the same type of game, but both demonstrate how difficult
03:05it can be for Sony to establish a successful presence in the competitive multiplayer shooter market.
03:10And that's where I start questioning Sony's strategy.
03:13How many times does the company need to see these projects struggle,
03:17before it recognizes that this particular market might not be the golden goose it believes it is?
03:22There were also signs that Fair Games was having a difficult development journey before the cancellation.
03:28According to Bloomberg, the project had been reworked several times,
03:31and was reportedly expected to be reintroduced under a different name.
03:35Studio founder Jade Raymond departed Haven in May 2025,
03:39while game director Daniel Drupue also left several months later.
03:43Those departures don't necessarily explain why the game was cancelled,
03:47but they do add to the story of a project that apparently struggled to find its direction.
03:52After more than three years of development,
03:54Sony has ultimately decided that Fair Games isn't worth continuing.
03:58And unfortunately, we'll never know whether the finished game could have delivered on its original concept.
04:04Now, while Fair Games is officially cancelled,
04:07there's some better news for the employees at Haven Studios.
04:10Sony has confirmed that there will be no layoffs associated with this decision.
04:14Instead, this studio will shift its focus towards collaborating with other development teams across PlayStation Studios,
04:20while also exploring new creative opportunities.
04:23Sony hasn't revealed which teams Haven will be supporting,
04:26or whether the studio will eventually return to developing a project of its own.
04:31Personally, I'm glad that the employees aren't losing their jobs over this cancellation.
04:35A game failing to meet expectations shouldn't automatically mean the people who worked on it have to pay the price.
04:41But it does make me wonder whether Haven might be better utilized working on something else from the beginning,
04:47rather than spending years trying to establish another competitive live service shooter.
04:52And this brings us to Sony's larger live service ambitions.
04:56Back in 2022, Sony announced plans to release 10 live service games by 2026.
05:02It was an ambitious strategy that represented a major shift for a company
05:06that had built much of its reputation around single-player experiences.
05:09But things haven't exactly gone according to plan.
05:12Concord was shut down shortly after its launch.
05:15Other projects have been cancelled or reconsidered, and now Fair Games joins that list.
05:20There have certainly been successes in Sony's multiplayer portfolio,
05:24with Helldivers 2 demonstrating that the company can still deliver a multiplayer experience
05:29that connects with a large audience.
05:31However, that doesn't change the fact that Sony has struggled to turn its broader live service ambitions
05:36into the kind of consistent success it originally envisioned.
05:40And here's where I want to make my position clear.
05:43Another live service game has been cancelled,
05:45and I'm genuinely wondering when Sony will realize that live service shooters
05:49aren't the golden goose they seem to think they are.
05:52Since Sony started pushing heavily into this always online live service shooter market,
05:57it hasn't achieved the level of success it was clearly hoping for.
06:01Yes, Helldivers 2 has been a success,
06:03and I'm not suggesting that Sony should abandon multiplayer gaming altogether.
06:07But there's a difference between creating a successful multiplayer experience
06:11and trying to build an entire strategy around constantly producing live service games.
06:16Sony has spent years building its reputation through games like God of War,
06:21Spider-Man, The Last of Us, Horizon, and Ghost of Tsushima.
06:25Those are the types of experiences that help establish PlayStation as one of the biggest names in gaming.
06:30I would much rather see Sony invest more resources into those kinds of experiences
06:35than continue chasing a market where success is far from guaranteed.
06:39At some point, the company needs to look at these cancellations
06:42and ask itself whether it's pursuing the right strategy.
06:46But that's my take on Sony cancelling Fair Games and Haven Studios moving into a support role.
06:51What do you think?
06:52Is Sony making a mistake by continuing to chase the live service shooter market?
06:56Should the company put more emphasis on the single-player experiences that made PlayStation so successful?
07:02And do you think Haven Studios will eventually get the opportunity to develop another original game?
07:07Let me know your thoughts in the comments below.
07:10If you enjoyed this video, please give it a thumbs up,
07:13subscribe to the channel,
07:14and ring that notification bell so you don't miss any of my future uploads.
07:18And if you'd like to support the channel even further, consider checking out my Patreon.
07:22It's only $1 a month, and you'll get access to exclusive content,
07:26including my latest Patreon exclusive,
07:29The Games You Don't Hear About,
07:30Why Smaller Games Struggle to Get Noticed.
07:33Your support helps me continue creating content like this,
07:36and I really appreciate everyone who decides to become a patron.
07:39Thank you all for watching, and I'll see you next time.
07:42Game on!
