Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 6 weeks ago
The Court of Appeal has rejected a bid by the State-run Urban Development Corporation, to fast-track its appeal to evict vendors from the iconic Breakfast Shed.
Today's decision means that vendors at the waterfront food hub are legally protected and can remain open for business until a full trial takes place next January.
Alicia Boucher tells us more.
Transcript
00:00For the vendors of the Femmes du Chalet cooperative, today brought a crucial, even if temporary, sigh of relief.
00:07The Court of Appeal dismissed the Urban Development Corporation's application to treat its eviction appeal as a matter of extreme
00:15urgency.
00:16In delivering the oral ruling today, Chief Justice Ronnie Boudou Singh was clear, stating that,
00:22quote, we find no justification for departing from the orderly judicial process already established, end quote.
00:30The Chief Justice went on to note that, quote, the threshold for an urgent expedited appeal has not been met
00:37as there is no immediate irreparable damage to the public interest in preserving the status quo, end quote.
00:45Quote, crucially for the families who depend on the facility, the court concluded that the balance of justice is best
00:52served
00:52by allowing these vendors to continue their trade until their substantive rights are fully determined at trial.
01:00At the heart of this legal battle is a bitter financial and historical dispute.
01:05Udicot claims the cooperative owes nearly $2 million in unpaid rent, but the vendors contend the situation is skewed.
01:12They argue that they have been crippled by electricity charges levied far above what they were supposed to pay
01:18due to the wrong classification for the building.
01:22More fundamentally, the cooperative argues that it holds an equitable lease on the land.
01:2875 years ago, these vendors voluntarily relocated from the site now occupied by the Hyatt Regency
01:35to facilitate national development.
01:37They argue that history earned them the right to stay.
01:41The substantive trial to resolve these deep-rooted claims is set for January 2027.
01:47For now, the legal maneuvering is paused.
01:50The courts have twice agreed that this nearly century-old culinary institution cannot be swept away overnight.
01:58Alicia Boucher, TV6 News.
02:03Co-ind�s In 168
02:04Co-inds In 178ns
02:06In 228 In
02:06188
Comments