00:00The Tobago House of Assembly has secured a major legal victory after the High Court dismissed a more than $90
00:07million claim arising out of the construction of the Lance Fomi Charlotteville Road in Tobago.
00:13The lawsuit was brought by Raghunath Singh and Company Limited, which alleged it was owed millions of dollars for variations
00:19to the project, delays, cost overruns, overhead expenses, environmental requirements, retention monies and other works connected to the contract.
00:29Court documents show the project was awarded in 2022 at a cost of approximately $34.7 million and was scheduled
00:37to be completed within 18 months.
00:40Instead, the project was not completed until 2007, roughly three years behind schedule.
00:47The contractor claimed that changing designs, weather conditions, rising costs, additional environmental requirements and other factors significantly increased the cost
00:57of the project.
00:57By the time the matter reached court, the company was seeking just over $90.6 million, including more than $53
01:05million in interest.
01:07But Justice Frank C. Pessard found that the company's legal challenge came far too late.
01:12The judge noted that the final payment certificate under the contract was issued on August 3, 2007.
01:19However, legal proceedings were not filed until November 2022, some 15 years later.
01:25In his ruling, Justice C. Pessard concluded, quote,
01:28The claimant commenced these proceedings in 2022, which is 15 years after the date of issue of Certificate No. 31,
01:36and accordingly, the claimant's claim in contract is statute barred, end quote.
01:41The court also found that many of the claims being advanced had already been rejected years earlier by the project
01:47supervising engineers,
01:49According to the judgment, claims relating to bridgeworks, piling design changes, fluctuations in labor and material costs,
01:58and additional expenses had either been rejected or never properly certified under the contract.
02:04Justice C. Pessard noted, quote,
02:15The judgment was also critical of the company's handling of its final account.
02:23The court found that the contract required the contractor to submit a draft final statement of account
02:29to the supervising engineers within 30 days of the issuance of the provisional acceptance certificate.
02:35Instead, the company submitted what it described as a final account to the THA years later
02:41by passing the contractual certification process altogether.
02:46Justice C. Pessard emphasized, quote,
03:07The THA also argued that it was not the proper party to the claim because the contract was executed
03:13on behalf of the government of Trinidad and Tobago.
03:16However, the judge rejected that argument, finding that the project was undertaken for the benefit of the THA
03:22and fell squarely within its statutory responsibilities for roads and infrastructure on the island.
03:29Despite that finding, the court ultimately concluded that the contractor had failed to establish any legal entitlement
03:35to the millions of dollars being claimed.
03:38In dismissing the action, Justice C. Pessard ruled that the claims were statute-barred,
03:42unsupported by the evidence and contrary to the contractual procedures agreed by the parties
03:48more than 20 years ago.
03:50Arvishita Wari Rupnarein, TV6 News.