- 5 weeks ago
This edition of Newstrack explores the massive geopolitical implications of US President Trump's sweeping decree linking the proposed Iran peace deal directly to the Abraham Accords.
Category
đź—ž
NewsTranscript
00:00Good evening, you're watching NewsTrack with me, Maria Shaquille.
00:03Just when backchannel diplomacy over Iran appeared to be gaining momentum,
00:08U.S. President Donald Trump has raised the stakes dramatically
00:11with a sweeping Abraham Accords decree in what could become the biggest attempt
00:17yet to create a new West Asia power order.
00:22Trump has linked the proposed Iran peace deal directly to the Abraham Accords
00:27and is virtually demanding that key Arab nations sign on the dotted line.
00:32Donald Trump has said that negotiations with Iran are proceeding nicely
00:37but has also issued a blunt warning, great deal for all or no deal at all.
00:42And the biggest headline here is that Donald Trump now warns Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Pakistan and Turkey
00:51to join the Abraham Accords framework with an extraordinary pitch
00:55that even Iran itself could eventually become part of the bloc.
01:01The message from Trump is crystal clear, sign the Accords are risked being left out of the new regional order.
01:08But this decree comes with massive geopolitical implications.
01:13Remember, the Abraham Accords were originally built as an anti-Iran strategic bloc,
01:19bringing Israel and Gulf Arab nations together to isolate Tehran.
01:25The U.S.-backed Israel-Gulf axis was designed to counter Iran's regional influence
01:31through security cooperation, intelligence sharing and economic partnerships.
01:36Now, Trump warns to flip that very framework by pulling Iran into the same regional arrangement.
01:43Supporters say this could trigger the biggest West Asia reset in decades,
01:49while critics warn that Abraham Diktat could derail the Iran peace talks
01:54or create deadlocks in negotiations and test ties between Washington and key Arab allies
02:04reluctant to openly align with Israel.
02:08So, what really is the big message?
02:10Why has U.S. President taken to Truth Social to put out this message?
02:16Or should I say his latest diktat?
02:18Geeta Mohan is joining us live.
02:20Geeta, by linking Abraham Accords to Iran deal,
02:26is this almost like a non-starter?
02:29Or is Donald Trump essentially saying that there are several facets of the Iran deal
02:34which is yet unraveling?
02:36Absolutely, Maria.
02:38There are two very important aspects apart from all the others
02:41which are layered in the entire West Asian geopolitics.
02:46Firstly, telltale signs of what Prime Minister Netanyahu and Israel really want.
02:52They do not really want an end to the conflict or the war with Iran
02:57unless and until there is a desired result,
02:59which is basically regime change, giving up of nuclear ambitions completely.
03:05None of that has really come through for the United States of America or Israel.
03:10Secondly, there are political compulsions that we see within America.
03:14When President Trump announced the deal with Iran or the so-called deal that the two sides could sign in
03:21the near future,
03:22then there were Republican senators and lawmakers who had come out and criticized it in Lindsey Graham fronting that charge,
03:31saying that it is absolutely unacceptable.
03:33So domestically, he will have to face a lot of heat if he goes ahead with a deal with Iran
03:39without having secured Israeli interests.
03:43And so he has now found a way wherein he wants to have the conversation, negotiate with Iran,
03:50but also ensure that there is normalization of ties between Israel and the Arab world.
03:55And not just the Arab world, this time they have included Turkey and Pakistan as well.
04:00So again, we have to wait and see how Iran responds to this.
04:03It certainly seems like an absolute deal breaker, should Abraham Accord, which, like you very rightly pointed out,
04:09was an accord that was built as an anti-Iran bloc.
04:15And to have that not just exist but expand is absolutely unacceptable to Iran.
04:22Would you say that the word mandatory, which has been used by U.S. President, has complicated the situation right
04:30now?
04:30And what could have been the last stages that we were discussing of U.S.-Iran deal has actually taken several
04:38steps backward?
04:38Or are you of the opinion that, like in the past, Donald Trump can do a rethink and he'll say
04:43that that was just a statement that he had put out?
04:45Well, I think it's the former.
04:47That it has complicated matters, particularly for countries like Saudi Arabia.
04:52Remember, there's a huge, and we've been discussing this off-screen as well, Maria,
04:56there's a tiff between MBS and MBZ and that's out in the open when it comes to West Asian politics.
05:01Saudi Arabia and the UAE do not see eye to eye.
05:04The UAE, not so long ago, aligned itself with Israel.
05:08It is a part of the Abraham Accord.
05:10And Saudi Arabia has fronted the charge against Israel when it comes to the actions in Gaza at the United
05:17Nations and the United Nations Security Council.
05:19So for Saudi Arabia to really come and engage Israel in a manner where ties normalize and they have diplomatic
05:28relations is something that might not be absolutely feasible right now.
05:32But remember, Donald Trump also said for some countries where it is not a workable solution right now, there is
05:38some leeway he's going to give.
05:39And I suppose that leeway would only exist for Saudi Arabia, a very important strategic partner of the United States
05:45of America and one where the Trump family has huge stakes and investments.
05:50So maybe Saudi Arabia is the only country that might get that leeway, Turkey, of course, being a NATO ally.
05:56But everyone else, for Pakistan, it's going to be a real catch-22 because, Maria, Pakistan will have to pay
06:03heed to what America, what President Trump says.
06:06But on the other hand, with more than 20% population, Shia population in Pakistan, aligning itself and recognizing Israel
06:14is not an option.
06:15All right, Geeta, thank you for joining us and putting the story in context for our viewers.
06:19Joining me on the show tonight, Dr. Tara Kartha, former director of NSCS, James Borden, is a Middle East expert
06:26who's joining me as well.
06:27James, I'm going to come to you first.
06:29How should this latest diktat of Donald Trump be seen?
06:33I mean, for him to say that this is mandatorily requested Muslim majority nations like Saudi Arabia, Qatar, to join
06:44the Abraham Accords as part of the West Asia peace deal,
06:47what was supposed to be a U.S.-Iran, has now expanded into the entire Arab world and not just the
06:53Arab world, other Muslim nations as well, which includes Pakistan and Turkey.
06:58Well, so let me analyze this through a couple of different lenses.
07:03I think this is where you're going to see the United States.
07:05I think he's going to be seeing the United States, which is a little bit ahead of himself and a
07:09little bit drunk on his own success, where he saw a lot of breakthrough with Iran and an advancement.
07:15I think now it's gone to his head a little bit, and he's thinking, hey, now I can, you know,
07:20push this a little bit further.
07:21And he has really pushed it, I think, too far for many of the reasons that have already been stated.
07:28But let's understand at root here the entire reason why we are in this conflict.
07:34This all started because Saudi Arabia was going to join the Abraham Accords back in early 23.
07:42And the Palestinians, the Gazans, wanted to interrupt that and break that from happening.
07:49And so they invaded, they attacked Israel and brought us into the Israeli Hamas War, which has morphed into these
07:56Iranian wars.
07:57So the entire reason that has gotten us to this point is all of that in the past.
08:04And since that time, Israel has done nothing but build up a tremendous amount of discredit with themselves towards the
08:12Arab countries.
08:12Let's go back to just September 9th of 2025, when Israel hit Qatar, hit Hamas, and I think killed at
08:21least one, maybe two Qatari officials in Doha.
08:25So Trump is not heeding the lessons of the immediate past and understanding that these countries that he wants to
08:35suddenly turn around and sign a huge agreement with Israel.
08:38They've got a lot of problems with this current government in Israel.
08:42Yes, that's right.
08:43And it would take...
08:44So, but is it a win more for Netanyahu, less for Donald Trump, James?
08:51Oh, I...
08:53Well, I don't think Netanyahu is going to get a win out of this because he's got, again, so much
08:58ill will built up against him.
09:01I think that any benefactors of this agreement would be the next government, which could come in between...
09:07Any time between now and October the 27th, that's when Israeli elections are mandated.
09:14I don't think that any of these governments want to do anything to bolster the image and the success of
09:22Netanyahu.
09:23Okay.
09:23Dr. Tadakarta, the deal, that is, Abraham Accords, was first brokered under Donald Trump's first presidency.
09:32That was in 2020, and it did lead to some kind of normalization of ties between Israel and Saudi Arabia.
09:41But given the tension, or should I say several Arab nations, but given the tension which has emerged in the
09:49current West Asia war,
09:51which has changed the dynamics totally, can Abraham Accords really take this forward?
09:57Can that be really the direction of a possible deal between Israel and the Arab nations?
10:04Or is that a tall ask?
10:08Maria, it's an extremely tall ask.
10:12And from, I mean, we all know that, I mean, even President Biden, right, he had tried to push the
10:17same line.
10:18Abraham Accords, you know, Accords.
10:19And the fact that, you know, Bahrain, UAE joined at all, it was because Saudi Arabia agreed.
10:24I mean, they actually facilitated that whole process.
10:29Now, I mean, Saudi Arabia has a huge Shia minority.
10:34Bahrain has a Shia minority.
10:37There's this whole Israel's, you know, this bombing they've done in Lebanon.
10:42How can you do this now?
10:43It's, I mean, it's literally asking for the moon.
10:46It's not possible.
10:47Even should the political leaders quietly want an end to this whole thing, they cannot do it, given the rage
10:56in most countries at what Israel has done.
10:58My sense is this is, again, a move to, I mean, thank God he's not linking this directly to the
11:08Iran peace deal.
11:09He's saying it's a follow on.
11:10Hopefully that's what he means.
11:11I'm not sure what he actually means.
11:14I hope this is an Israel's attempt to stop this peace deal.
11:18If that is the case, then, well, that's one move.
11:22Because even Israel knows that this is not going to happen.
11:26Because there has been silence on most fronts, if you look at it.
11:29We haven't heard from the Arab nations, any of the countries, and particularly Pakistan, which is actually being a dealmaker
11:37in this entire equation between Iran and U.S.
11:43Pakistan has been named as one of these nations who will come on board for this Abraham Accords.
11:49And, you know, to expect that all these nations, which have much to complain about Israel, will come on board,
11:57given the backdrop of a conflict, a life conflict with Iran, given what we know the role of Israel has
12:06been, what exactly is Donald Trump thinking?
12:09Or is he just not keen on a deal with Iran?
12:14You're asking me?
12:15Yes, ma'am.
12:15Yeah, see, let's face certain facts.
12:19Saudi Arabia has had underground deals with Israel since at least the 1960s, as far as I know.
12:25That's the reality.
12:26So has Pakistan.
12:27Not to that extent, but to many times it has reached out to Israel.
12:32Right?
12:32So that is a different entity.
12:34It's a different issue that at this point, that's what your point is, right?
12:38It is that now, after all this, that it is difficult for anyone.
12:42Iran, the great field marshal, who is the only person he, I think, mentioned, he didn't even mention the Prime
12:48Minister, Shabba Sharif, he's talking to the field marshal.
12:52The field marshal can't do this.
12:54It can't be done.
12:55So he will either have to, maybe, migrate to Texas or something like that.
12:59I mean, I don't know what this is going to happen.
13:02But, I mean, what Trump is talking to is actually this undercurrent of relations which goes on.
13:09They are all talking to each other.
13:11Okay, that is the reality.
13:13But the question is timing.
13:17And do you think that timing then, James Borden, is actually a problem?
13:21Or do you think that will also be, that Donald Trump understands that this deal will prolong, the talks are
13:29going on, there has been a lot of back and forth on the deal with Iran.
13:33So might as well throw another, you know, spanner in this argument and test it.
13:40Well, I think it's probably closer to that.
13:43You know, remember, I think it was late January, early February of 25 when he first came into office and
13:49Benjamin Netanyahu and he had a joint press conference.
13:53And at that press conference, he introduced the idea of rebuilding Gaza and doing it almost like a resort par
14:00excellence.
14:01And Netanyahu was just totally blown away because they had not talked about this at that moment.
14:06And again, I think this just really goes back to that fundamental, mental issue that we have with our president
14:13currently right now, where he has these off-the-cuff, very moments of great whimsy, where he tries to introduce
14:21something like this and accomplish a lot.
14:24And it's very scary because, yes, it does undermine what he is actually in the process of accomplishing, which is
14:32probably far more concrete and more immediately necessary.
14:35So I really want to put it in that context that Trump is such a moving and hard to pin
14:45down kind of metric here.
14:47And so in that context, I just think that we should not look at it too deeply as being some
14:54grand plan to either get it going forward.
14:57So why would he raise the stakes the way he has done and complicate the entire picture?
15:04Because, again, I think that Donald Trump really doesn't know his limitations.
15:10He's got these great ideas that run through his head.
15:13He doesn't check them with the NSC.
15:15He doesn't check them with any other important person.
15:17He just issues these things by fiat and wants them to be happening.
15:22And his people underneath him start running around trying to figure out how to put the pieces into place and
15:28put things back together.
15:30Trump is a very off-the-cuff, ad hoc kind of person.
15:35That is the way that he has been operating forever.
15:39But I think that has gotten up on steroids since he has gotten older and he is getting less mentally
15:46structured and competent.
15:47And we're beginning to see how that is really impacting foreign policy.
15:52I mean, he just really doesn't realize the impact of these kind of moments and suggestions that they really have.
16:00Okay.
16:02Dr. Tadakarta, Donald Trump has said that the proposal actually emerged during discussions with several regional leaders,
16:10which included MBS, President Erdogan, Emir Tameem bin Hamad Al Thani, and Pakistan's Army Chief, Asim Munir.
16:20So that's what he has said, that these are the countries with whom he seemed to have discussed.
16:29Is it about Iran deal at all then?
16:32Or is he just trying to have a blanket approach towards the entire Arab world?
16:40Listen, this is domestic politics.
16:43He has to show that he's got something out of the deal.
16:47Right now, he's back where he started.
16:49In fact, he's not even back where he started because Iran still has some control over Hormuz.
16:55And they're talking of, you know, environmental control, all that stuff.
16:59So you're actually minus one.
17:01So now how do you sell it back home?
17:03He can say, oh, you know, I've done this grand deal and everybody's on board.
17:07And it need not happen today or tomorrow or the day after or even six months.
17:12He just has to announce something.
17:14If this thing gets into everybody's news, you know, that's good enough for him.
17:19So his MAGA base gets a boost.
17:21And the same goes for Israel.
17:24Israel is also, he's also looking at his, I mean, this is all about domestic politics now.
17:28Both Israel and in the US and Iran, of course, I don't know who's in charge.
17:32But still, that's a different issue.
17:36But then where do we head from here onwards or are you, you know, because as we have seen,
17:43Donald Trump makes some announcements in the morning and he changes another announcements in the evening.
17:49But then because he has thrown in this entire new picture into the puzzle, the puzzle has got complicated.
17:5930 seconds to both of you.
18:00James Borden, go first.
18:02Oh, well, this might be a, you know, a two or three day news cycle item.
18:07And then I think that it will drop out, as you suggest.
18:10I think that it's going to, it has already brought Lindsey Graham back into the Trump fold.
18:17But I think that eventually it's just going to process out and nobody's really going to remember it.
18:24So I don't see anything long term really resulting from it.
18:28Okay, so nothing long term.
18:31How do you look at it, Dr. Tadakarta?
18:34Well, ideally, it would be great if it went on.
18:37I mean, finally, if that damn cold thing settles.
18:40But the fact that, I mean, remember, even the JCPOA didn't go through Congress.
18:43So he might just have this whole executive order thing going at.
18:47He really needs something before, you know, midterm polls.
18:51So maybe this could be it.
18:52But like you said, and as the other, the previous speaker said, nobody knows what is in his mind tomorrow,
18:59what's today.
19:00But in an ideal world, this would be the way to go.
19:05And it's been tried for some time.
19:08James Warden, Dr. Tadakarta, really appreciate your time.
19:11Thank you so much for joining us.
19:13Shifting focus to another story now.
19:15The Thrinamul Congress's crushing assembly poll defeat is now triggering visible cracks within the party.
19:22Senior Member of Parliament, Kakuli Ghosh Dastidar, has resigned as the party's Barasat Organizational District President,
19:29taking moral responsibility for the poll debacle.
19:32But Kakuli Ghosh Dastidar's resignation came with sharp criticism of the party's campaign style and internal functioning.
19:41She has also blamed IPAC for the election loss and has alleged that pressure from the consultancy team during the
19:48campaign disrupted the party's organizational functioning.
19:52Earlier today, I spoke with the TMC MP from Barasat and listened in to what she told me.
19:58I'm leaving you with this.
19:59Thanks so much for watching.
20:05TMC MP from Barasat, chairperson of the women's wing of the TMC and a four-time member of parliament.
20:15Ms. Ghosh Dastidar has been associated with Mahmata Banerji and has participated in multiple movements along with her.
20:24So she is the ultimate TMC insider.
20:27So I really appreciate your time, ma'am.
20:28Thank you so much for speaking to India today.
20:32Ms. Ghosh Dastidar, what has made you take this decision of quitting from the organizational district president's post of the
20:41TMC?
20:46This organizational district contains seven assembly segments where we used to have seven elected members of the legislative assembly in
20:59the past.
21:04So when five of those seats are lost in the election, then I take moral responsibility that there must be
21:14something wrong in my work or in my system of functioning for which I should not be there and let
21:22somebody else more efficient take over.
21:25You are saying moral responsibility is the reason why you have quit from the party post, but ma'am, it
21:32was a BJP wave with the BJP winning with a landslide of two-third majority in the assembly.
21:39So it is not just your assembly segments which have been lost.
21:43Similar is the picture across Bengal.
21:49Who do you hold responsible then?
21:51I have been in politics for the last 40 – let me finish.
21:56I have been in politics for 45 years.
22:00The other district presidents may not be there for so long as I have been.
22:05I have been with Mamata Banerjee since 1984.
22:09I know her method of functioning.
22:12I know how she works for the common man.
22:14I know how hard she works.
22:16So the other people, the other district presidents are yet to realize or take decision, I guess.
22:25But since I have been here for so long, then I took this decision and I feel that the party
22:32to undergo revival and have a turnaround.
22:37More efficient people should take over.
22:40Okay.
22:40And will you be continuing in the TMC or are you having a rethink of staying within the TMC also?
22:50Of course, I am working.
22:51Even yesterday we had a meeting.
22:53We are working for the people.
22:54I will be working as a common worker.
22:58Who do you hold responsible for this route of the TMC?
23:05The overall dismal picture.
23:07One thing is that after 15 years of governance, anti-incumbency creeps up.
23:17So that might be one issue.
23:19The other issue definitely is the specialized intensive revision which actually should have been given much more time because it
23:30takes a long time to do this kind of intensive revision.
23:33And after the intensive revision, some of the names were left out, lacks of voters, valid voters were left out
23:42under adjudication.
23:43So all the voters couldn't cast their votes, couldn't practice franchise.
23:48That's another issue.
23:49But these people standing in the line and voting definitely points to some kind of grievance towards the governance which
23:57we have to accept because government changes every five years in Kerala or in Tamil Nadu, in other states, in
24:04other countries.
24:05In democracy, people have a right to choose their government.
24:09So that issue is also important.
24:11There must be some kind of dissatisfaction for which people didn't vote.
24:17Yes, the dissatisfaction and the anti-incumbency certainly was palpable on the ground.
24:22And I'm saying as a journalist who was traveling across the state, Ms. Dastidar, how much of the strategy of
24:31the TMC went wrong?
24:33How much of the IPAC functioning was responsible?
24:38Did IPAC keep you informed about the ground shifting, that the things on the ground are not in the favor
24:46of TMC?
24:47They would be doing some surveys and research.
24:52They have no clue about electoral politics.
24:56The young people who came in, they might be highly educated.
25:00They might be having knowledge from the books.
25:03But people who work on the ground, the workers were maligned, the workers were left idle.
25:10The workers were not included in the day-to-day electioning process.
25:14And those IPAC people who were working, they took all kinds of wrong decisions.
25:20And at every step, they failed their job.
25:23They failed their job.
25:23And so they failed his job.
Comments