In this video, expert scientist Yunus Çengel shares his opinions on the most popular science questions.
Intro
Who is Prof. Yunus Çengel?
Where Will Be Science in A Hundred Years?
Is The Statement “Most Scientists Are Atheists?” True? Why Do Smart People Cannot Arrive At The Conclusion Of Metaphysical Realm? Is Prof. Yunus Free To Publish Articles That Refer To A Creator?
Logical Examples Of The Symbol Of Knowledge.
God Has Established A Perfect System Or Just Left It To Function By Itself?
Respond To The Argument “God Of The Gaps”.
Scientific Explanation Of The Concept Of The Soul.
#ToughestAtheismQuestions #MuslimScientist #AtheismDebate #ScienceVsFaith #RefutingAtheism #IslamicApologetics #CriticalThinking #FaithAndScience #PhilosophyOfReligion #Skepticism #DebateSeries #LiveDiscussion #TruthInScience #CounterArguments #IslamicPerspective #ScienceOfIslam #ThoughtProvoking #IntellectualDebate #ChallengingBeliefs

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Is the statement, most scientists are atheists, true?
00:03Where do you think science will be in 100 years?
00:06When people go out into the streets, what kind of world will they see?
00:09Probably anything we hear about the future, everything is wrong.
00:13But probably in 50 years, 100 years, we will have such things that we haven't even imagined.
00:20That is beyond human imagination.
00:23And let's say 50 years from now, when the people look back to our time,
00:28this time will look like a stone age.
00:31All the scientists in the future will be, I think, strong believers and very conscious believers.
00:38They will know why they believe, who they believe.
00:42And the world will be at a different place then.
00:46As-salamu alaykum, Professor Yunus Cengel. Welcome to Towards Eternity.
00:49Thank you so much for accepting our invitation. We are very honored to have you with us.
00:52We know that you are the author of best-selling books that are used in engineering faculties.
00:56You have award-winning works that have been translated into many languages.
00:59What kind of work have you done and still have been doing so far?
01:03By training, I am a mechanical engineer.
01:05I finished my BS from Istanbul Technical University.
01:09And then I did my Master's and PhD in the USA at North Carolina State University.
01:14And then I was a faculty member at the University of Nevada, Reno for many years.
01:18And my specialty area is energy.
01:21I write books, I write articles, I give talks about energy.
01:26Where do you think science will be in 100 years?
01:29When people go out into the streets, what kind of world will they see?
01:33Oh boy!
01:34Probably anything we hear about the future, like 50, 100 years from now, everything is wrong.
01:40I can also give you my prediction.
01:43But again, probably I will be off by a large margin.
01:47Why?
01:48Because we are thinking using what we see today, what we have today.
01:53We simply make extensions of them.
01:55But probably in 50 years, 100 years, we will have such things that we haven't even imagined.
02:02That is beyond human imagination.
02:05It will be very exciting.
02:07And the good things will be, I think, amazing.
02:11But the bad things also will be very scary.
02:14I mentioned like, you know, dark matter, dark energy.
02:16We cannot perceive them.
02:18We cannot measure them.
02:20We cannot, you know, sense them.
02:22We know they are there.
02:23They exist.
02:24But they don't interact with physics.
02:27And now imagine we understand dark matter, dark energy better.
02:31And we have control of it.
02:34We have, let's say, the ability to manipulate it.
02:37It will be a new game in the universe.
02:40That is, we will be able to do things with raw material, which is nothing at all of the physical world.
02:48That is made of, you know, electrons, protons, neutrons, or photons, or whatever.
02:53Completely different.
02:54Still exerting an influence.
02:57Imagine, let's say, you will build a car or transportation or vehicle something.
03:00Doesn't have any weight.
03:02Doesn't have any friction.
03:04Is not, you know, limited by a lot of things.
03:07Who knows, you know, what kind of transportation we are going to have in that environment.
03:12So it is difficult, really, to imagine the future.
03:17But certainly, I think the, let's say 50 years from now, when the people look back to our time, this time will look like a stone age.
03:28Therefore, I think our predictions about the future as to what we will have, it will fall very short from what we will actually have.
03:38Is the statement, most scientists are atheists, true? Why is there such a perception?
03:43And it is thought that the more one is involved in science, the further they move away from faith.
03:47What do you think about this?
03:48Well, if you look at the statistics with people and with scientists, like the general population, about 90%, they believe in a creator.
03:59If you look at the scientists in the world, that ratio is about 50%.
04:04That is, more than half of the scientists in the latest research I have seen, they believe in a higher being, higher authority, a creator.
04:13Therefore, the notion of scientists, you know, don't believe in God or science, it is not true.
04:18That is, the research doesn't support that, because most of them do.
04:22But probably those who don't, they speak maybe louder, so that, you know, we hear them a lot, or they attract a lot of attention that way.
04:32But there is nothing between science and belief that is incompatible.
04:37Because science simply deals with the absorbable existence, physics, religion, deals with, you know, non-physical things, like deities, angels.
04:49Therefore, when a scientist says, for example, oh yes, there is a God, it reflects his or her belief.
04:56When a scientist says, oh, there is no life after that, for example, it also reflects his or her belief.
05:03Nothing to do with science.
05:05But science doesn't necessitate disbelief, that there is no such thing.
05:10So, in light of what you have explained so far, that it's really easy and clear to arrive at the conclusion that there is this metaphysical realm.
05:18Why do these smart people cannot arrive at that conclusion?
05:22What prevents them from seeing this reality?
05:24Oh, there are many reasons.
05:26One thing is, I think, the ego.
05:29Okay, many scientists have, you know, big egos.
05:31And, you know, they think, you know, they are the most knowledgeable people.
05:35And when they imagine, you know, a being capable of doing anything, seeing the entire universe, they have a difficulty imagining such a being.
05:47Because in their research, they haven't seen any such being.
05:51You talk about, you know, something that they have never seen, they'll be distant.
05:56They say, okay, can you show me something like that?
05:58They see the cause-effect relations, and then they think just knowing the cause is sufficient.
06:04They are blinded by this.
06:05They fail to see the secret hand behind the scenes, because every time you do something, you get the same result.
06:12Every time, let's say, you combine oxygen and hydrogen, you get water, to the point that it is like automatic.
06:19Let's say, when you put a seed into the soil, and you wait, and you see that, you know, that seed, growing roots, and then, you know, leaves, the trunk of the, et cetera, giving apples, cherries, you know, whatever.
06:33That is, when you resort to the cause, the result just happens.
06:38And you get the notion that it just happens by itself, because it is so easy there.
06:43And this gives the illusion that, you know, things just, you know, happen, and the laws and forces of physics are enough, but they are not enough.
06:51As I mentioned before, even a needle, simple needle, you know, a hole on one side, and a sharp edge, you know, on the other side, the laws and forces of physics cannot do it.
07:01When you find it, during an archaeological excavation, you say, there must be beings with intention, with knowledge, and with the ability to do it.
07:12But, when, let's say, they see an apple tree, when they see a cell, which with, you know, billions of, you know, molecules working together, when they see a leaf, you know, working like a chemical factory, somehow, they fail, I think, to use this logic.
07:31That is, you know, there must be things that goes beyond the laws and forces of physics, because in here, we see a lot of knowledge, a lot of purpose, and the laws and forces of physics, they are not purposive.
07:45So, I think, eventually, I think, they'll come to that.
07:48So, I think the scientific community is progressing in the right direction, that, you know, there is something, you know, beyond this.
07:56All the scientists in the future will be, I think, strong believers and very conscious believers.
08:04That is, they'll know why they believe and who they believe.
08:10And the world will be at a different place then.
08:12So, they are the majority, the ones that are believing in God.
08:15But, within the scientific community, are power and authority in the hands of disbeliever scientists?
08:21For example, are you free to publish articles that refer to a creator?
08:24Yeah, I don't see any problem.
08:26For example, my research area of expertise is energy.
08:30And it doesn't have any ideological connotations.
08:33You know, energy is energy.
08:34So, in physical sciences, in, let's say, physics, chemistry, engineering, we don't have any problem.
08:40But in life sciences, when living beings are involved, then I think there is a lot of prejudice there.
08:47There is a tendency to reduce everything to physics, including life.
08:52For example, you just have to call life, you know, chemical reactions.
08:56Okay?
08:57But chemical reactions has never produced life.
09:00That is, that contention is, you know, false from the beginning.
09:04And you have to subscribe to the ideology that everything is random and things just happen by themselves randomly.
09:14It is kind of imposed.
09:16If you do something that kind of goes against it, then you will have problems there.
09:22But things are, you know, getting, I think, to a more healthy environment.
09:27Let's say, in the past, matter was everything, the materialistic worldview.
09:32But nowadays, I think, the whole scientific community almost agrees that it is not really the matter.
09:38It is the knowledge.
09:40And right now, many prominent authors call life knowledge, which is non-physical knowledge.
09:47Not the symbols.
09:48Because, let's say, the knowledge on DNA, for example, they are simply symbols there.
09:53Clusters of atoms there.
09:55Okay?
09:56And they portray knowledge or the symbols of information as a powerful, knowledgeable, skillful agent, which they are not.
10:06So they still fall short.
10:08But I think it's a progress.
10:10That is, knowledge is important.
10:12And knowledge in action, obviously, is important.
10:16And eventually, I think what will happen is, people will see that the symbols of knowledge, they are not capable agencies.
10:26A recipe, for example, how to make a cake.
10:29Okay?
10:30You can have all the ingredients for a cake and then put a, you know, recipe there as knowledge.
10:35Now, imagine someone claiming, oh, the information is here, and that information will take these ingredients and make a cake out of it.
10:45That doesn't happen.
10:46That is, right now, they portray information as a knowledgeable, powerful being.
10:51Still an illusion there.
10:52But eventually, I think they will wise up and they will see that, you know, those clusters of atoms, whether it is a gene or a word, a sentence in a recipe book, they cannot do anything.
11:06They cannot read themselves, they cannot understand it, and they cannot simply execute those instructions there.
11:14If you look at a cell, for example, okay, RNA, you know, copies a gene, for example, and then using the right amino acids, they build the right protein.
11:26They give the whole credit to the gene.
11:29Instructions.
11:30Instructions don't do anything.
11:33You do things following the instructions.
11:36For example, you know, we get something, for example, you order a bicycle.
11:40It needs an assembly.
11:41It comes with instructions, right?
11:43And you take the parts out and put the instructions next to it, and you wait for the instructions to put the parts together.
11:51That doesn't happen.
11:53Simple logic.
11:54Simple logic.
11:55You need an agency with the ability to read, to understand, and the skill to put those pieces together and the power there.
12:05Other subjective qualities like, you know, consciousness, free will, initiation.
12:10Even that initiation, to initiate something.
12:12Again, nothing to do with the signals or whatever.
12:18For example, the telephone, the cell phone there.
12:21A lot of activity, right?
12:23Like a brain.
12:24But a cell phone never decides to call somebody.
12:29They are passive.
12:30Those signals don't do anything.
12:32We need an agency from outside to really tell, to call a person.
12:37If, let's say, you put your computer on the table or your cell phone, they'll just sit there, okay?
12:42They will not do anything there.
12:44So, eventually, I think, we will get there.
12:47So, recognizing knowledge as the centerpiece in creation, in existence, is, I think, a major step.
12:56So, eventually, we will see, and it is being seen right now.
12:59I think life is described as purposive in almost all the books and articles that I read.
13:05And if there is a purpose, then there is a being with purpose, obviously.
13:10And then, since it is done in a purposive way, then knowledge comes with it.
13:15And the skill comes with it.
13:17And the ability, the power comes with it.
13:20Does this mean that the Creator must intervene and manage all the events at every moment?
13:25Because some might find this hard to accept at first glance.
13:28Couldn't it be the case that God had established a perfect system and just left it to function by itself?
13:34So, He created and left.
13:35They gave the example of, you know, the grandfather clock, you know, kind of, you know, pendulum going back and forth.
13:40Once you set the clock, it will just, you know, doing this motion.
13:44If you look at the example for four simple things, okay, nothing wrong with that.
13:49But this is not a plausible notion because things are not that simple.
13:54The universe is very complicated.
13:57Imagine we have a factory and initially you set up everything.
14:02And then you put the rules and then you say, okay, now I don't need any managers.
14:08I don't need any workers.
14:09I don't need anything.
14:10So this factory will just keep running, okay?
14:13No one in the world dared to do that.
14:16Because when things get complicated, okay, many things will go wrong and it will come to a halt very quickly.
14:23You need, you know, to upkeep it.
14:25Okay, let's say the factory runs.
14:28But if let's say it is that way that you cannot have new factories, you cannot have new things, things will be stagnant.
14:36That is, take a picture of the universe today and next you will see the same things.
14:40But in the universe everything is changing.
14:43Everything is changing every second.
14:45New things are happening.
14:47A new universe every day.
14:49We have let's say the flowers for example coming, blossoming.
14:53We have let's say the animals, let's say the cells.
14:58Therefore, in this, you know, sophisticated universe, just living things to themselves and hoping that they'll keep running.
15:07Such things, none of them can be the making of the unconscious, non-purposive laws and forces of physics.
15:16Behind it there is intent, there is information and there is power, which requires continual involvement.
15:25Material scientists say this, there were many things we couldn't explain before but science has developed and those gaps began to fill.
15:31To prove the existence of a creator, you present the arguments about things that we cannot explain now, which science might explain in the future.
15:37What do you say about this?
15:38Let's say when it comes to life, it is non-physical because if it were physical, we would, let's say, discover it by now.
15:46This is not to change.
15:48And as for the, let's say, explaining things.
15:50And explaining alone doesn't resolve anything.
15:53We think that, or some people think that when things are explained, it is the end of it.
15:57Knowing how, let's say, this cell phone works, an engineer can explain exactly, you know, how this works.
16:04Explains everything, but we still need to acknowledge there is a team of engineers behind it.
16:11The laws and forces of nature, they don't do purposeful things.
16:15If, let's say, there is something with a purpose performing certain functions, there is intent, will, knowledge, and power behind it.
16:25That is a being with these features.
16:28I can show you a dialysis machine, which is an artificial kidney.
16:33And I can tell you as an engineer how it is made, what the parts are, how they function.
16:39It is not the end of it.
16:40Behind that machine, there is a team of engineers who had the conception and then the design and the knowledge and the ability to build it.
16:51That is being able to explain is not the end of it.
16:55So, how does science explain the concept of the soul?
16:58Can all our experiences be explained only by hormones, our happiness, our sadness?
17:03For example, when we feel happy, is it our soul feeling it or do we become happy just because our hormones are released in our bodies?
17:09Obviously, all these things that we feel, the subjective experiences, they are non-physical.
17:15Because, for example, I poke a needle on my hand. I feel it. I feel that pain right there, right?
17:22But physically, there is no need to feel the pain.
17:25What happens there? Electric signal is generated. It goes to the brain, which is really a piece of meat.
17:30No different than, you know, other parts of the body.
17:32Made of the same electrons, protons, and neurons there. No difference. It is simply a body there.
17:38It is not a, you know, superior physics or something. Same thing.
17:41And then, suddenly, suddenly, I perceive pain. And let's say pleasure. I do something very pleasurable.
17:48And then, same electric signal. Same signal becomes, you know, goes to the brain.
17:52I perceive as, let's say, eating something. Pleasure. And then, you know, fear. And then other things.
17:58And then, let's say, even sight. That is, all those things. These are non-physical.
18:05That because physics, body, atoms and molecules, they cannot perceive.
18:09They don't know, you know, they know electron, protons, neutrons, whatever, but they don't know, you know, subjective things.
18:14Let's say on the, on the, just let me give you one example. Let's say sight, seeing.
18:19For example, you think you are seeing me, right? But you don't see me. You cannot see me. Why not?
18:26Okay, now, there is light here. The light is reflected from my body. It goes to your eyes.
18:31And then, that light is absorbed by the eye and then converted to electric signal.
18:38So what happens is, now, the light is gone. And then, those signals, you know, go to the brain.
18:43That is, they go to the piece of meat. Then what happens? Physics stops there.
18:48Thousands, sometimes millions of signals, you know, go there. And then, using those signals, a secretive mechanism, which is not physical, takes those signals and then builds, let's say, my image somehow in your head.
19:03And then, what you see is that image, which is a virtual reality image that is generated in your brain. It is what you see. You don't see me. The whole thing is dark.
19:15Also, you don't really hear me. Again, electric signals, same signals, same, you know, ions, you know, just moving back and forth, thousands of them.
19:23And then, they are converted to sounds. So, in the brain, we don't have any membranes vibrating. There is no sound in the brain.
19:30It is created, again, by a mysterious mechanism as sound. When we eat something, let's say, the pleasure, the taste, whatever, all the tastes, again, are the same way.
19:41Now, that means, associated with the brain, there is something. That something is called, you know, the soul all over the world.
19:48Because the brain itself is a meat, piece of material, cannot do those things. We don't have any physical mechanisms.
19:55Obviously, based on that input, all these things, let's say, sound, taste, touch, you know, whatever, pain, pleasure, these are built there.
20:05They are constructed out of nothing. And then, we live in that world. That is, actually, we live in a virtual reality.
20:12It is, you know, three-dimensional. Right now, we don't have that technology. Right now, we do 3D imaging, okay?
20:19And then, the funny thing is, ha, you know, I wonder if there is something non-physical. You live in non-physical.
20:25Physics is not complete without the laws of physics, right? The laws of physics are not physical.
20:30They are not made of basic particles or electrons, protons, and neutrons there. And without the laws of physics, you don't have physics.
20:38Obviously, though, there is another dimension of creation, which is non-physical, which kind of acts on the physics as to what they can do, how they will do it, or whatever.
20:49Or whatever. And let's say, the forces, the push-pull effects, again, they are not physical. They are influences.
20:56And it is the reason that the laws and forces of physics, they are together. They are characterized as the agents of physics.
21:03And, again, called the government of the universe by Alfred Montaparte. And then, Einstein calls them the laws of physics as the spirit of the universe.
21:13Like, the universe has, you know, a soul, a spirit. And that spirit rules the universe. The laws of physics and, let's say, the influences, the forces of physics are together.
21:23And these are not physical. So, pure, let's say, material things, okay? The physics is not only that. Without, let's say, the laws of physics, forces of physics, the properties, you don't have physics.
21:34When, let's say, we have a hydrogen, which has one proton, it acquires hydrogen properties. When, let's say, we have helium with two protons, it acquires helium properties, which is very different.
21:44That is, the properties are non-physical. They don't come from the protons.
21:48Or maybe you give the example of gold. Let's say, seven to nine protons put together, they turn into gold. It acquires gold properties, same protons.
21:57This is like, let's say, a grain of rice. We know the properties of rice. You, let's say, tightly wrap two rice grains, it becomes, for example, hazelnut, something different.
22:07What happened here, for example? So, the properties are non-physical. And when, let's say, you make water from hydrogen and oxygen, you cannot predict what you will get.
22:18You have to see it. And then you get less water properties. If you break water apart, those properties are gone.
22:24That is, they are created out of nothing. And then, when you break it apart, they are, you know, they simply disappear there.
22:32Professor Yunus Jenga, thank you so much for your answers, for informative answers and insightful answers.
22:37Inshallah, we are hoping to meet you in future concepts and projects.
22:40Oh, thank you very much. It was a pleasure to talk with you.

Recommended