• 1 year ago
John and Charles discuss the complex roots of the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR), tracing it back through the Latter Rain movement and exposing its deep ties to authoritarian frameworks laid in the 1940s. They examine the influential role of John Wimber and the Vineyard Movement in uniting various strands of Latter Rain theology—particularly through Wimber’s associations with the Shepherding Movement, the Kansas City Prophets, and figures like Paul Cain. The episode emphasizes how key Latter Rain doctrines, such as five-fold ministry and the Manifested Sons of God, re-emerged in modified forms under Wimber’s leadership, setting the stage for what C. Peter Wagner later named the NAR. Despite reform efforts late in Wimber’s life, Charles and John argue that the foundational control structures remained intact and dangerous.

The conversation repeatedly returns to the danger of reforming a toxic system without changing its core foundations. Charles warns that removing a central figure like Branham while preserving the underlying authoritarian dynamics leaves people vulnerable to re-victimization in sister movements. Wimber’s role is critically examined—not only for promoting dangerous doctrines but for platforming problematic figures like Cain, who brought radical Latter Rain teachings into the mainstream. Both hosts stress the importance of recognizing loaded language and historical continuity to avoid falling into rebranded expressions of the same high-control systems.

00:00 Introduction
01:14 Origins of the New Apostolic Reformation
02:46 Complex legacy of John Wimber
04:03 Why examining Latter Rain branches matters
05:04 The three senior branches of Latter Rain
07:14 Early influence on the Jesus People Movement
08:46 Birth of the Third Wave of Pentecostalism
10:02 Doctrines merging inside the Vineyard Movement
11:08 What makes a cult: story of a Branhamite pastor
12:56 Cult structure without a central figure
14:54 The foundation beneath modern churches
16:26 Subtracting William Branham still leaves the system
17:46 Why “reformation” isn’t always safe
19:04 Comparing Vineyard splits with Message splits
20:11 Wimber’s friendship with Shepherding leaders
22:00 Cross-pollination of authoritarian teachings
23:29 Deliverance teachings and loaded language
24:52 Joel’s Army and coded speech in revival culture
26:53 Signs and wonders versus Jesus’ message
31:02 Wimber’s legacy and complicity
33:28 Breakdown of what the audience was really absorbing
35:03 Clip preview: altered states and authority
37:11 Response to the clip and disturbing implications
38:01 Attempts to control the historical narrative
39:40 Patterns repeating from Branham to present
41:00 Doctrines can change but the danger remains
43:02 Language hijacking and parallel definitions
44:02 Kansas City Prophets join Vineyard
45:44 Paul Cain’s promotion and influence
47:06 Traveling evangelists and spread of teachings
48:02 Final destination metaphor for false reform
49:08 Attempts to keep th

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:00:30Hello, and welcome to another episode of the William Branham Historical Research Podcast.
00:00:36I'm your host, John Collins, the author and founder of William Branham Historical Research
00:00:41at william-branham.org, and with me I have my co-host, researcher, minister, and friend,
00:00:46Charles Paisley, the founder of christiangospelchurch.org, and the author of Come Out of Her, My People.
00:00:53Charles, I'm a little excited for today's episode. We have in our Revival History series walked through
00:00:59from the early origins of Pentecostalism and some events that happened before, all the way through
00:01:05the rise of the latter reign and into the birth of the charismatic movement, but today we're getting
00:01:12into the birth of the new apostolic reformation. And a lot of people don't realize how early it
00:01:18actually started. They see Peter Wagner as the one who named it much later after it already had
00:01:24existed, but even Wagner admitted this thing already exists. I just put a name to what people
00:01:29are calling it. And then he rebranded basically the latter reign movement, but they shifted some
00:01:35doctrinal elements. So what happened is, by and large, the charismatics didn't pick up what they
00:01:41were doing. The doctrines had shifted, but it essentially was the framework that was laid down
00:01:46by latter reign that enabled the authoritarian control of apostles, prophets, etc. And today
00:01:53we're talking about the origins of how this really developed into the new apostolic reformation.
00:01:58There is a book that I recommend anyone read who is interested in this history. Charles and
00:02:05I aren't really inventing anything new. This is all documented. But one of the best books that
00:02:10was recommended to me was the new apostolic reformation history of a modern charismatic
00:02:16movement by John Weaver. Great book. It walks you through a lot of this history. They obviously
00:02:23did not have all of the Branham history that Charles and I have laid down. Whenever Weaver
00:02:29wrote it, had he had the information from us, I'm sure the book would have taken a much larger,
00:02:34thicker form because there's so much to go through. But today we get to talk about the birth of latter
00:02:39reign 2.0, which everybody else in the world knows as the new apostolic reformation.
00:02:44That's a great introduction, John. And I also am in some ways looking forward to recording today.
00:02:50You know, as I kind of already said in the last two episodes, as we've started down this arc,
00:02:55there is within me a reluctance to record this topic for a variety of reasons, which is part of
00:03:02the reason I've avoided really going too deeply into this stuff for, you know, for the years that
00:03:07we've been doing these podcast series. But I still have that same reluctance today. And part of my
00:03:12reluctance is just the complex legacy of some of the figures in this movement. John Wimber,
00:03:19who we'll talk about quite a fair bit today, being one of those people with a particularly complex legacy.
00:03:24And it's just very hard to approach these complex movements and complex legacies in just short little
00:03:35one hour episodes. And even though we're probably going to record three or four or five on it,
00:03:40we're probably not going to really cover all the nuance and complexity in it. And for me,
00:03:46when we as we go through these things, and as I as I wrote in chapter 10 in my book,
00:03:50I'm out of my people volume two, where I examine these things, it's primarily an exercise for me in
00:03:56identifying the other branches of the latter rain movement. So that as as I personally and anyone
00:04:03else who is, you know, my persuasion, as we leave the message, which is perhaps one of the main branches
00:04:11of the latter rain movement, that we don't fall into another sister cousin branch of the movement,
00:04:17which is just going to end up as another cult, right? It's not not being re-victimized, leaving
00:04:21the cult. And so that is really the the main purpose I see as I look at these things. It's where
00:04:28where is it not safe for me to go, having left the message? And for me, what made the message a cult
00:04:36was not that we had a prophet that told us some made up stories. What made the message a cult was the
00:04:42underlying framework, which actually came out of the latter rain movement and can be found in all of our
00:04:46sister branches of the movement, many of whom are also equally destructive or even more destructive
00:04:52cults in some cases. And so that is part of the reason, John, that I am interested in in looking at the
00:05:00other branches of the latter rain movement and where they're at today. Now, if you think of the latter rain
00:05:05movement, the way I look at it, there are coming out of the latter rain in the 40s, there are three senior
00:05:12branches of the latter rain movement, three senior branches that each trace a line of direct ordination
00:05:19and dissent from the elders of Sharon Orphanage, okay? And the three senior branches of the message
00:05:25are, um, number one, Global Missions, which is the group that actually maintained control of Sharon
00:05:31Missions. Global Missions is the Sharon Orphanage today, okay? Global Missions is one of the senior branches
00:05:38of the latter rain movement, regardless of what they may say. They are one of the senior branches
00:05:43of the latter rain movement. The second one of the senior branches of the latter rain movement is the
00:05:48shepherding movement, John. We're talking Derek Prince, Ern Baxter, those guys. The shepherding
00:05:53movement is one of the senior branches of the latter rain, which also claims a direct line of ordination
00:05:56out of Jim Watt, another one of the original elders of Sharon Orphanage. The third senior branch
00:06:03of the latter rain movement, John, is the message. It's where we come from, which had three of the
00:06:10original seven elders. The Houghton brothers, John, all came into the message as all those things broke
00:06:15up. The Houghton brothers remained in independent assemblies of God, and they fellowshiped in message
00:06:19churches for many of their, for most of their lives, and a significant number of the early, um,
00:06:24message preachers, especially my sect of the message, John, um, had direct lines of ordination from the
00:06:30Houghton brothers, okay? So the, the message is also one of the main branches of the latter rain
00:06:36movement, and those are the three senior branches. Besides that, there are so many branches. I mean,
00:06:42the latter rain movement seeded itself all across the independent assemblies of God, across the Elam
00:06:46Fellowship, across quite a number of independent churches, um, and, and there are so many factions
00:06:52of the latter rain movement, um, some of which we covered starting back in episode 32. Someone wants to
00:06:57go back and understand how they, those all broke up the way they did and why they did, but those three
00:07:03senior branches, John, all in some degree or another played a role in producing the new apostolic
00:07:11reformation. We want to talk about that a little bit again today. If you remember in our last episode,
00:07:15we, we talked through the vineyard, uh, basically how the Jesus people movement got started,
00:07:20and in the early Jesus people movement, John, the shepherding leaders, via Lonnie Frisbee and a few
00:07:28others, got a back door into the early Jesus people movement, and they influenced some percentage of
00:07:34the early Jesus people movement with their ideas, which were latter rain ideas. The shepherding
00:07:39movement is one of the main senior branches of the latter rain ideology. They influenced those,
00:07:44those, those teachings into the early Jesus people movement, and the Jesus people movement took a
00:07:50softer version, a less extreme version of all those latter rain teachings early on, and as they did,
00:07:58they ended up breaking away from Calvary Chapel and forming the vineyard churches. The vineyard churches
00:08:03started as the, um, charismatic hippies who were influenced by the shepherding movement breaking away
00:08:11from Calvary Chapel. That is who the vineyard movement was when they started, and John Wimber
00:08:15rises up as the most senior guy in the vineyard movement for its first decades. Okay, so the
00:08:23influence into the vineyard movement from latter rain came from multiple angles, though. There's
00:08:27multiple waves of it. The first wave of it was the shepherding movement influencing at the very
00:08:32beginning really why they were still in Calvary Chapel, and then following them over to vineyard,
00:08:38and then once they're in the vineyard, then the second wave of latter rain influence happens.
00:08:44And that second wave of latter rain influence is what we're going to talk about today. And although I say
00:08:50it's the second wave of latter rain influence into the vineyard movement, historians actually call this
00:08:54period the third wave of Pentecostalism. That's what starts. What is born in the vineyard movement
00:09:00is the third wave of Pentecostalism. Pentecostal history is broken into three distinct phases,
00:09:07if you read most historical books. Phase number one of Pentecostal history started with Azusa Street.
00:09:13That's the first wave was Azusa Street. And then what came after that? The second wave of
00:09:18Pentecostalism started with William Branham and the healing revivals. William Branham initiated the
00:09:24second wave of Pentecostalism. Okay, so he's this really the leading figure most people will acknowledge
00:09:30in the second wave of Pentecostalism, which is where we come from. Then that goes on. And then the third wave
00:09:36of Pentecostalism starts, John, generally agreed in the 1980s. And it starts among churches in the vineyard
00:09:43movement, which is where we're talking about today. And they are churches, John, who have been influenced by the
00:09:49latter rain practices and William Branham's practices from the second wave. Okay, and so that's where we're at
00:09:55today, John. We're going to start talking about these other influences that came into vineyard and combined with the
00:10:02already maybe softer version of latter rain that they had adopted through the vineyard movement and
00:10:08takes it and starts turning it into the more radical version. They're progressing towards the radical
00:10:15version of this ideology in the vineyard movement as time goes on. And eventually, as we probably get in
00:10:21our next episode, John Wimber wakes up on his deathbed and realizes, uh-oh, you know, I'm going to go to hell
00:10:27maybe if I don't make this right. I don't know. But whatever, at the end of his life, he realizes, and he
00:10:31largely kicks them out and pushes them out of vineyard. And so our next two episodes, we're going
00:10:35to go through that phase. But what John Wimber pushes out of vineyard at the end of his life
00:10:41is the New Apostolic Reformation. The New Apostolic Reformation was born in vineyard during the third
00:10:48wave of Pentecostalism as these influences came together. And towards the end of John Wimber's life,
00:10:53he wakes up, maybe, I don't know. We'll talk about that in the next episode. And they get pushed out
00:10:59of vineyard, and they are the New Apostolic Reformation, already fully formed by that point.
00:11:05And that's in the late 1990s. So here we go, John. It's going to be a fun episode today.
00:11:10It will. But before we go there, I want to go back to something that you said, because it is
00:11:15very important that people understand. You're describing what makes a cult, and you are absolutely
00:11:21correct. It isn't just the central figure, or having a central figure. So whenever people look
00:11:27at a particular group, they might say, well, this group's not a cult. There is no central figure.
00:11:31I don't see a face like Jim Jones that is hovering over the people and beating them into submission
00:11:36verbally. But let me tell you a story about a minister that I knew. I came in contact with a
00:11:44minister. He actually reached out to me, who had been in the Branham cult for decades. And he realized,
00:11:50he woke up towards the end of his life, he woke up and realized that I don't agree with some of the
00:11:57doctrine and the control and all of the things that William Branham stood for. And so I have tried
00:12:02for the past few years to shift my church away from Branhamism. And he said that I basically, I don't
00:12:10say the word Branham anymore. I just take the doctrines that he taught that were good. I avoid the doctrines
00:12:16that were bad. And I'm trying to slowly bring my church into truth. And that's something I can
00:12:22support. That's a good thing, right? However, in the midst of all of this thing, I'm helping this guy,
00:12:29I'm giving him information that I have. In the midst of all of that, his wife secretly contacts me
00:12:35and is pleading for help. John, what do I do? This church is, yes, it is taking the name Branham out
00:12:43of the church, but the level of control that they have over the people, the governance,
00:12:48the authority of the pastor. And she's talking about her husband. And the sad part is this man
00:12:53died not long after. So at the end of his life, he recognized that he had made a grave mistake and
00:12:59he had led his entire church down a path of no return. It was awful. And he thought that he had
00:13:05reformed. And he, in his conversations, when I talked to him as his half of the equation,
00:13:11he truly believed that he had reformed and changed his church for the better. His wife was like,
00:13:20oh my gosh, what do we do? I grew up in a normal, healthy church. I came into Branhamism later,
00:13:26and I'm still seeing this vast difference. So what happens is whenever you are indoctrinated in a cult,
00:13:32you learn the cult framework of authoritarian control. And that gets to be a deep part of your
00:13:38doctrine. And though he is claiming that he has shifted his church toward reform and he's abandoning
00:13:45what he disagrees with, the problem is his frame of mind is swayed so far from the truth such that he
00:13:52believes that the doctrines that he has kept are actually biblical when they're not. And so he still,
00:14:00even though it had no central figure, he, you know, people wouldn't call him a cult leader.
00:14:05He had taken the false doctrines and he had ran with them. And it's all the doctrines of
00:14:10authoritarian control. There's another book, Dr. Stephen Hassan wrote, Combating Cult Mind Control.
00:14:16And it talks about the bite model, which is behavioral control, information control, thought
00:14:22manipulation and control, emotion, emotional manipulation and control. And if you take those
00:14:30elements and you apply it to this destructive church that thought it had reformed, many elements
00:14:35were still there. Yes, they had wiped away large portions of the mind control elements, but it still
00:14:42existed. And so therefore, the church was, it was not a healthy church. I'll just say it like that.
00:14:48Now, when we look at some of the churches that we're examining in our revival history series,
00:14:55yes, they may not have a central figure. Yes, they may have greatly reformed. But the question for me
00:15:01is what foundation was it built upon? And so for that, I'm excited to get in today's episode because
00:15:07we're talking about literally that foundation that was laid. And you have to ask the question,
00:15:13yes, they've reformed, but how much and how much of the movement itself is still very controlling
00:15:20and manipulative? You're exactly right, John. And there's such a risk when you leave the message or
00:15:26another branch of the Latter-day movement of being re-victimized by another cult. Because, John,
00:15:30if you take the message and you demote William Branham from central figure to just average prophet or
00:15:37maybe just ignore him altogether, what are you left with? If you just take the message and
00:15:44subtract William Branham, what do you have? You have the New Epistolic Reformation. So it looks
00:15:50mighty appealing to people who leave the message. The other branches of the Latter Rain look mighty
00:15:55appealing to someone leaving the message. And it looks like, oh, okay, we subtract William Branham,
00:16:00he led us astray. Let's retrace one or two steps. Okay, then let's go into the Latter Rain. Because
00:16:07if you back up a couple steps from William Branham, you end up in one of the other branches of the
00:16:11Latter Rain movement. And I think what I have landed at, John, in my own thinking is you actually got to
00:16:17go back about five steps at least. You got to get out of the Latter Rain, man. Like, you don't even
00:16:21want to be in a branch of the Latter Rain. Because, like I said, and you said, it's not the made-up
00:16:27stories from William Branham that made the message a cult. It is the framework that allowed
00:16:32him to get away with everything he did. That is the underlying problem. William Branham got
00:16:40scot-free away with what he did and ended up forming a cult that grew into millions of people
00:16:45around the world. And there was no structure, there was nothing to stop him, to slow him down,
00:16:51barely even a speed bump, John, to stop this cult in this movement. And you and I know the horrors
00:16:59of this movement. We've covered it in the podcast. So what allowed that to happen? It wasn't the
00:17:05made-up stories of the Prophet. It was the framework that he was already operating within, in large
00:17:11part that preexisted him, John, that allowed all of that to happen. And you're correct.
00:17:17That underlying framework of the brainwashing techniques, of the authoritarian leadership
00:17:23model, and of really the crazy ideology that leads to radical behavior, manifested sons of
00:17:30God, all of that exists in these other branches of the movement. And it's important to be aware
00:17:37of them. That way, I mean, if you're leaving the message, I think you're at high risk of
00:17:41being re-victimized if you go to one of these groups. And so I'm just, I myself am incredibly
00:17:46cautious. You know, if I was going to join myself into another branch of the latter rain
00:17:51movement, I know there are people who've left the message and that's what they've done.
00:17:54And I don't begrudge them at all. I'm sure, here's the thing, John, there's not, there's
00:17:58quite a lot of branches of the latter rain movement that are a whole lot less dangerous
00:18:02than the message and where we come from. But then there are other branches of the latter
00:18:05rain movement that are just as dangerous and more dangerous, right? And so people just kind
00:18:10of have to use their wisdom and, you know, decide what they're going to do. But as we
00:18:16come back here and what we're talking about today, so in the vineyard movement, John, as
00:18:20the vineyard movement breaks away from Calvary Chapel, this starts to begin really in the
00:18:24late 1970s. And by 1982, it's more or less a full, clean break from Calvary Chapel. And
00:18:32the break between Calvary Chapel and the vineyard churches, John, is not like the splits that
00:18:38happen in the message, right? John, you know, if we're in the message and two groups split,
00:18:43you're dead to each other, right? And you basically, you walk on other sides of the street and you
00:18:50spit on the ground as you pass, basically, you know, it is that bad almost, John. Kind
00:18:54of like me and you at the blue boar, right? We, you know, you stare narrowly at each other
00:18:59across the blue boar because they're not from our section of the message and they're going
00:19:03to hell. They're apostates of the, right? When you have a split in the message, it's
00:19:09like that. But when this division happens between Calvary Chapel and vineyard movement, it's
00:19:13not like that, John. It is not like that. It is, they're not, they're not in the same
00:19:18level of radicalness as the message back, okay? And, and they're still kind of friendly
00:19:22with each other. And, and there's still kind of a cross thing happening there for, for
00:19:26quite a few years. And so anyway, vineyard breaks away and they go down this route where
00:19:32they have, they have basically taken all of the shepherding movement influenced guys from,
00:19:40um, from Calvary Chapel. And Calvary Chapel starts on its path and it's reforming. So
00:19:45Calvary Chapel has been reforming away from this ideology, John, since really the, the late
00:19:49sixties and early seventies. The vineyard movement only started its reform away from this ideology
00:19:54in the late nineties. Okay. So Calvary Chapel has like a 30 year, 30 year lead in reforming
00:20:00over the vineyard movement. So, you know, you can keep that in mind for yourselves if you,
00:20:05if you're thinking about these things, but the vineyard movement, John, um, as you come
00:20:12into the 1980s, John Wimber really, um, starts making very good friends with the shepherding
00:20:20leaders. And I've say Lonnie Frisbee played a role in the introductions and Lonnie Frisbee
00:20:25was the initial gateway through which a lot of this came, but John Wimber more or less
00:20:29steps into that role, uses some of Lonnie Frisbee's popularity to draw some of the Jesus
00:20:35people movement over. And, and, and, you know, in a sense, I feel bad for Lonnie Frisbee,
00:20:40John, like Lonnie Frisbee is a guy that got used. I just, you know, when I look at the history
00:20:44of Lonnie Frisbee, Lonnie Frisbee is a guy that a whole lot of people just used him,
00:20:48honestly. Um, and they kind of threw him away like trash at the end of his life. The poor
00:20:54guy, you know, you feel bad for him. Uh, but he was, he was pretty badly used by a lot
00:20:59of people. And so he got used and, you know, Lonnie Frisbee, I don't know, honestly, John,
00:21:05here's a book I'll point out. It's called the Jesus people movement. We actually, this
00:21:08was actually recommended to me by one of our listeners, John. It's actually a really a good
00:21:12read. If you want to look into some of this stuff, the Jesus people movement by
00:21:15Richard Bustrad. Well, Lonnie Frisbee, I mean, I don't know, John, I just what to do
00:21:23with him, but basically he eventually died of HIV. He was, he was a homosexual. Um, and
00:21:28he died of HIV. And, you know, as you come into those years, basically he collapses in
00:21:33any real influence. And John Wimber is more or less the undisputed, um, leader of this
00:21:39faction of the Jesus people, you know, by the time you come into the 1980s. And, um,
00:21:46as that happens, John, the shepherding guys and John Wimber start becoming buddies. And
00:21:54what happens, John, is you see John Wimber regularly invent, inviting all of the top
00:21:59shepherding guys to speak at the vineyard churches and the vineyard conferences. Um, they start featuring
00:22:05John Wimber in New Wine Magazine. And there is a full-on cross-pollination out in the open,
00:22:11public, all the records are there. Anybody go look at this. A full-on cross-pollination
00:22:16of the shepherding movement ideas into the early vineyard movement. And they're bringing
00:22:20in five-fold ministry. They're bringing in the positive confession stuff. They're bringing
00:22:26in the deliverance stuff. And they're bringing in a soft version of manifested sons of God.
00:22:30All of that is coming into the early vineyard movement in spades from the shepherding movement.
00:22:36And you can look in the magazines that they published. And in the magazines they published,
00:22:40you've got John Wimber endorsing five-fold ministry. You've got him endorsing the deliverance
00:22:46practices. There's sermons you can get of John Wimber teaching Derek Prince's deliverance
00:22:53formulations, John, you know, where bitterness causes arthritis, you know, all of this crazy stuff.
00:23:00You know, John Wimber taught this stuff. And he's imbibing it. He's bringing it into the
00:23:08movement. And it's a softer version. John Wimber. Here's the thing. John Wimber, whenever
00:23:12he preached it, he himself always preached a softer version of it, John. But then alongside
00:23:18him on stage was the crazy nuts who preached the hard version. And so he preaches the soft
00:23:24version. They preach the hard version on the same platform at the same conventions, right?
00:23:29And it's affecting the people. The people are absorbing this stuff as time goes on.
00:23:35It's such a complicated history to detangle. You know, I've had people who are fans of Wimber.
00:23:42And much like the minister who has, you know, he's shifted his church away from it, anybody
00:23:49who's in that church who has gradually shifted away from Branhamism, they might openly condemn
00:23:55the things that Branhamism declared that was incorrect or wrong. The difference is, whenever
00:24:01you're in a destructive cult, one of the key indicators, according to Dr. Stephen Hasson,
00:24:07is how open they are with their information. If they try to conceal it from you, that's a
00:24:10cult strategy. And what I find is there are a lot of people who, like it or not, they are supporters
00:24:18of people like Wimber. And Wimber is just one in a crowd of hundreds. It's not that we're singling
00:24:24him out in this. But he's one guy who has a history that really is critical to understand
00:24:31how the New Apostolic Reformation came to be. Yes, on his deathbed, he may have done whatever
00:24:37said whatever he said. But that history still exists. That history was there, it was written,
00:24:42and a historian would look at this and say, this is what happened. But what you find is a large number
00:24:48of people trying to cover up what happened, which is a cult-like structure. That's something that is
00:24:54indoctrinated. That's not something that you learn. The other key indicator for me, you're talking about
00:25:00the shepherding movement, years, whenever Wimber is a big part of this. Anybody who's of the frame of
00:25:06mind that all the history can be erased would totally glaze over this. But you and I, we grew
00:25:13up in this history. We know what this is. So we know the loaded language. Whenever we see people
00:25:19like Paul Cain, who's preaching, we need this end-time army, this Joel's army, we know the exact
00:25:26statements by William Branham that is referring to the second passage of Joel. This was a common
00:25:32Latarine theme. And Paul Cain is reinventing Latarine, basically Branhamism 2.0, which would
00:25:39ultimately it would develop into IHOPKC, International House of Prayer. But what happened is you have
00:25:47people on stage like Cain, and Cain is one of a line of, like I said, there's hundreds of these guys.
00:25:53They're using the loaded language that we are familiar with. Whenever they're talking all of these
00:25:59military terms, they're talking about building Joel's army. And we, you and I, Charles, we pick up on this
00:26:05because we were indoctrinated in this way. The general audience who has been indoctrinated in the
00:26:11same way during those same years, they pick up on it. Whenever they talk about anything to do with
00:26:17army or military or any of these phrases, they know that Paul Cain and others are referring to Joel's
00:26:23army. On the same platform, you have people like John Wimber, who is making statements to the same
00:26:31crowd of people. Wimber, who is fully, fully aware of the loaded language, and he starts using the
00:26:38same terminology. In fact, his slogan is what was picked up by the New Wine Magazine and some of the
00:26:44others, we're building an army. And that's what carried forward into that, that literally developed
00:26:49into IHOPKC, if you understand how that went. The loaded language is key. Now, separate yourself
00:26:56from this from a long distance. You look at Calvary today, you look at some of the offshoots of this,
00:27:02some of the splinter groups. They have, many of them have reforms. Some of them have erased their
00:27:08history. And if they were to hear Wimber saying things like, we're building an army, they would just
00:27:14discount it because that means nothing to them. Yes, Wimber's talking about an army of Christians
00:27:19this is a good thing. That's, that's how you would think of it today. But think back then
00:27:24to the audience that he's speaking to, who are fully aware that Wimber is saying, we're building
00:27:30an army, we're building Joel's army. This is a big deal. The other thing that I want to point out
00:27:35is that Matthew, what is it? I think it's Matthew 12. Jesus says, an evil and adulterous generation
00:27:44seeks after a sign. One of the key elements of latter rain was that they wanted to ignore that
00:27:52passage from Jesus. And they would broadly advertise, even in the newspapers, signs, wonders, miracles.
00:27:59They were inviting this evil and adulterous generation that seeks after a sign. Well, that is
00:28:05what Wimber was most remembered for his signs and wonders conventions and all of these things that are
00:28:11declaring, we are a people who is looking after signs and wonders. That framework didn't originate
00:28:18with Wimber. You can't even credit him with this. You can't say that he's to blame, but he's part of
00:28:24a system. He's part of a foundation that has been laid that has taught the people to believe that
00:28:29focusing on signs and wonders is a heavenly thing instead of Jesus openly said, this is the evil and
00:28:36this is the adulterous generation. So for me, I look at the history. I want to know the loaded
00:28:41language. Whenever I look at these old sermons and recordings by not just Wimber, but many of these
00:28:47guys, I want to know what is the time period in history and what was their loaded language at the
00:28:52time. You can generally find if this is a offshoot of randomism or not, simply by looking at the audience
00:28:59in the time period. Have you ever wondered how the Pentecostal movement started or how the
00:29:05progression of modern Pentecostalism transitioned through the latter reign, charismatic and other
00:29:10fringe movements into the new apostolic reformation? You can learn this and more on William Branham
00:29:17Historical Research's website, william-branham.org. On the books page of the website, you can find the
00:29:24compiled research of John Collins, Charles Paisley, Stephen Montgomery, John McKinnon and others with
00:29:31links to the paper, audio and digital versions of each book. You can also find resources and
00:29:37documentation on various people and topics related to those movements. If you want to contribute to
00:29:43the cause, you can support the podcast by clicking the contribute button at the top. And as always,
00:29:49be sure to like and subscribe to the audio or video version that you're listening to or watching.
00:29:55On behalf of William Branham Historical Research, we want to thank you for your support.
00:30:00You know, if you go all the way back to the early days of this ideology in the 40s, one of the big
00:30:06things that was frequently used as a appeal or selling point for this ideology was, look, we have signs,
00:30:15wonders, and miracles. And this is therefore going to make us more effective in missions because we can
00:30:20demonstrate power to these people. We can demonstrate signs, wonders, miracles, and they
00:30:25will believe because of the signs, wonders, and miracles. And we can therefore have an edge on
00:30:30converting these people to Christianity. And that is still a major rationale in this ideology to the
00:30:36present day. But what you're pointing out there is very correct. And you know me, John, like I hardly
00:30:42ever in our podcast series talk about, you know, Bible and stuff like that. But yeah, you're right.
00:30:47Jesus said, what did he say right there? He said that wicked and adulterous generation seeks after a
00:30:52sign. But what's the very next scripture? And no sign will be given to them except the sign of the
00:30:57prophet Jonas, the sign of the resurrection, three days and nights in the heart of the earth and the
00:31:02resurrection, right? And what Jesus is saying in that passage, John, is like, if the truth of the
00:31:09gospel message, if the truth of the resurrection isn't enough to convert these people, right? And
00:31:13you're trying to convert them with signs, wonders, and miracles, you're actually fundamentally doing
00:31:19it wrong, right? The sign to convert the people is the resurrection of Jesus, not signs, wonders,
00:31:25and miracles, right? And that is the very context of what Jesus is saying in that verse. And when
00:31:31people do that, and they go down that route, oh, well, our signs, wonders, and miracles are going to
00:31:36convert the people. They are really directly contradicting the Bible, John. I mean, it's so
00:31:41anyway, set that aside, moving on. You're right, John, when it comes back to John Wimber.
00:31:48John Wimber, the New Apostolic Reformation is just as much a part of the legacy of John Wimber as the
00:31:55Vineyard Movement. There is no New Apostolic Reformation today without John Wimber. He is critical
00:32:01to the formation of the New Apostolic Reformation. He is the man who platformed and
00:32:08brought the leaders who formed the NAR to the masses. Without John Wimber, you don't get it. John
00:32:15Wimber was a critical man in this path. And he might have been a nice man. And he did not preach.
00:32:22I agree, I don't think he preached to the radical extreme as the rest of them did. But he let them
00:32:27preach the radical extreme right next to him, on the platform, while he sat beside them and said
00:32:32amen, right, and indoctrinate the people, who he then kicked out at the end of his life. But he's
00:32:38the one who enabled it all, right? And you can't do this thing where you whitewash all this. No.
00:32:44John Wimber made some very terrible mistakes that ended up producing an incredibly destructive cult.
00:32:52And yeah, John Wimber himself was maybe not crazy. And yes, maybe at the end of his life,
00:32:56he recanted this stuff. But nevertheless, this is a horrible, horrible mistake that John Wimber
00:33:03made in his life. And it makes him a model that we should not emulate. I mean, the stuff he did on
00:33:10this respect, I don't, this is what, again, I'm not going to vineyard churches myself, John, because
00:33:14I, this is kind of scary to me. I see this is, this produced something really ugly. And I'm glad
00:33:20the vineyard movement's reforming. I don't want nothing to do with this stuff myself. This is,
00:33:25it's too dangerous. And so, let's do this, John. Let's put up a clip for our listeners.
00:33:32And we're just, I'm just going to very simply, let's play a clip. And before we play it, John,
00:33:36here's what I'm going to point out to our listeners. This is what I want you to watch
00:33:39for in this next clip, so you can understand what we're talking about. In this next clip,
00:33:44I want you to listen. John Wimber is encouraging the people to go into an altered state of mind.
00:33:49And as they're in this altered state of mind, he's shouting submission and obedience at them.
00:33:55He's using the terms of the five-fold ministry language. He's promoting the elements of that
00:34:01authoritarian leadership model to them while they're in the altered state of mind. And he's
00:34:05also using the loaded language of Joel's army manifested sons of God in this clip. And all the
00:34:11while that he's doing it, the man behind his shoulder is Paul Cain. Paul Cain, William Branham's
00:34:19protege, who was absolutely teaching the radical versions of this ideology. When John Wimber leaves
00:34:27the stage, he gets up and he preaches a whole sermon on the radical elements of this ideology,
00:34:32okay? And did the average person in the crowd realize that's what's going on? Maybe not.
00:34:38Did John Wimber realize that's what he was doing? Yeah, I think so. Yeah, I think so. And did a
00:34:44percentage of the people leave that crowd indoctrinated with this ideology and ended up
00:34:50in the New Apostolic Reformation? Yeah, absolutely. A percentage of the people in this crowd ended up
00:34:56in the New Apostolic Reformation as a result of what happens here on this stage in this clip we're
00:35:00going to play. So let's go ahead and roll the clip.
00:35:02But he needs a clean vessel. He needs a cooperative and obedient child. Not childish, but a child
00:35:15who will believe and step out on the things that he senses he's being called to do.
00:35:22Is that where your heart is tonight? Is that what you want to be? You want to be the children of God?
00:35:28You want to minister in his power and authority? Then you must become as a child. Because the kingdom
00:35:35is given to children. Not childish ones, but those that are innocent, pure, responsive, obedient,
00:35:45quick to do bidding. And what we're talking about is kingdom power and kingdom activity. This is what
00:35:53the king does. The king does through his people. Speak in tongues. Let it come. Let it out.
00:36:05Let it come. That's it. Speak out. Speak out. That's it. Let it come. Let it come. That's it. Hallelujah.
00:36:18Let the spirit of prophecy come over you. Lord, open their eyes that they may see the things of the
00:36:28spirit. Open their ears that they may hear the voice of the Lord. Open their being, O God, that they may
00:36:36enter into the things of the divine. That they may do your bidding and work and know your mind, O God.
00:36:43Let the spirit of counsel and wisdom come upon them. In Jesus' name.
00:36:54Don't worry about that. That's just a little darkness. It's getting cleaned out.
00:36:58When life comes, darkness must go.
00:37:02Let the power come. We need more. Capture them, Lord. Take them captive for your purposes, O God. Raise
00:37:24up an army for yourself, O God. Pure and clean and empowered. Perfected. Joined to the body of
00:37:39Christ. Under authority. In obedience.
00:37:44All right, John. Now, you just saw that clip. I mean, tell me what you think. I mean, it's pretty
00:37:50obvious there that this is, I mean, to me and you. And I think to anybody familiar with this ideology
00:37:57and reading the other stuff happening in the new apostolic reform or in the vineyard movement at this
00:38:02time, that's pretty disturbing what we just saw. And roughly what you have here is John Wimber
00:38:10setting up the people for this crazy state that is gradually going to evolve into the new apostolic
00:38:17reformation. It is scary. And you know, I had some time ago, I had somebody who wanted to work with
00:38:24me and the whole thing appears to be a setup. They were working with me about John Wimber. And
00:38:29essentially what happened is they were wanting to control the narrative and later came out and tried
00:38:36to quote unquote expose everything that I was doing. But what they were essentially doing was trying to
00:38:41control the narrative and keep the people from understanding correctly the history as it was
00:38:47written. And things like this, things that you're playing here, things that we're talking about.
00:38:52If you're in this movement and you have given undue reverence to Wimber or anything, anyone who came
00:39:01out of this movement, not just Wimber, this is a broad movement with hundreds of people,
00:39:05thousands of people. If you're giving undue respect to people and trying to erase their histories,
00:39:13I have a problem with it. I will always have a problem with this because that's what makes a
00:39:17cult. And that's how people get not only deceived, but they get controlled and manipulated and their
00:39:22lives get ruined. So if you're in one of these movements, how many of these movements have told you
00:39:27that there are instances in history like this, where this very destructive, very controlling,
00:39:35authoritarian, cult-like behavior was happening with not just Wimber, but any of these men that
00:39:42are in these movements that develop from latter rain. And in the new apostolic reformation,
00:39:47there are several, it's like a spider web. There are several different apostolic networks that make
00:39:52all of this up. We find the same thing with, we recently did the podcast on Derrick Prince.
00:39:59Look at the comment feeds and watch the people say, but in the last years of his life,
00:40:04brother Derrick completely denied and rejected all of this doctrine from Branham.
00:40:10So burn all the surnums, ladies and gentlemen.
00:40:11He may have, but how many of the people in the Derrick Prince cult are aware that Derrick Prince and all of
00:40:18this history, all of this connection to Branhamism, not many people are aware because they're erasing
00:40:22that history. But like I said at the beginning of this, the problem is, I can't say that there's
00:40:29a Derrick Prince cult and that Derrick Prince is a central figure. No, I can't say it like that.
00:40:34But look at the framework that was laid by Branhamism, this authoritarian control, and now take the church
00:40:41that exists today. Many of the churches that are built on top of Prince. The question for me is,
00:40:47they may not be destructive today, but they have that same exact foundation, the same foundation
00:40:52that was laid by Branham. What about the children of the people in that church? What about their
00:40:57grandchildren? Are they headed into destruction? Are they going to be in a cult? And that can apply to
00:41:03Derrick Prince, John Wimber, any of the people that we've described that are in this movement.
00:41:08When you trace your lineage back to a foundation that was fully designed, as we've gone through the
00:41:15history, it was designed specifically to control the people for politics. You trace it all the way
00:41:22back to Branhamism and the men Branham was working with. This was a political cult designed to control
00:41:28the people. If that is your framework, if that is your foundation, if that is your history,
00:41:33are your children safe? Are your grandchildren safe? For me, I'm like you. There's no way you
00:41:39could get me to attend one of these churches. No way you could get me to do it. But there are people
00:41:45who are, and it scares me. You know, John, when you think back to that clip that we played, there's
00:41:51lots of them we could play. I think that's just a good little sample. There's a lot of people that
00:41:57would watch that and see what's going on there, and it wouldn't sound too bad, right? And they would
00:42:03even think it's a good thing that's happening. Oh, the Spirit of God is falling, and it's obedience
00:42:08and submission to God, and it's an army to spread the gospel, right? There's people in normal
00:42:15Christianity or even, you know, healthy or Pentecostal Christianity. That's what they hear when
00:42:21they see that. And it's because it's using the same language that this cult ideology uses.
00:42:28Now, is that what John Wimber meant when he said all those things? Maybe he did. But I'm telling you,
00:42:33the man standing behind him on the platform there, Paul Cain, who came from the message,
00:42:37that is not what he meant when he said those things. It's the same language with different
00:42:42words, different meanings. When he says army, he means manifested sons of God. When he says
00:42:48obedience and submission, he's talking about five-fold ministry, authoritarian leadership
00:42:51structures, right? And this is what's so important. And a lot of times, I think, John,
00:42:57people may be from more traditional, normal, normal Christianity, when they hear this terminology,
00:43:04and then the people like us who come from the cult with this exact same terminology, we almost
00:43:09can talk past each other because we don't, you know, the words don't mean the same thing.
00:43:14We're actually speaking in a different language when we say these words, right? And that's what's so
00:43:21problematic with these cults is they've hijacked the words and they've changed the meanings of them,
00:43:26right? And absolutely, the language around submission and obedience all flows out of the five-fold
00:43:34ministry teachings of the latter reign that that is what they're imbibing there. And the talking about,
00:43:40you know, forming the army and so forth, yes, it's absolutely the entry point into the manifested sons
00:43:46of God ideology. Now, the other thing I want to point out to you, John, is I mentioned how
00:43:50the latter reign influence came into the vineyard movement in two phases. They started, they started
00:43:56from the get-go with that shepherding movement influence. Well, another thing happens, John, as you
00:44:02come into the early 1980s, roughly 1981-82, the Kansas City Prophets join the Vineyard Fellowship,
00:44:10John. If you go back in the 80s, where were the Kansas City Prophets? They were in the Vineyard
00:44:15Fellowship. They were the Vineyard Church of Kansas City. That is who the Kansas City Prophets were.
00:44:21They were in Vineyard. Okay, so poor John Wimber, my goodness, John, he starts out inviting the
00:44:29shepherding movement. It's going downhill. And then he invites in the Kansas City Prophets. Who
00:44:33is the chief lead of the Kansas City Prophets? Mr. Paul Cain. Who is Mr. Paul Cain? John,
00:44:42now we're talking about a branch of the latter reign movement that you and I are deeply familiar
00:44:46with. Paul Cain is one of William Branham's protégés. He was advertised himself as another
00:44:53William Branham. Paul Cain was in message churches in these same years. Mr. Wimber,
00:44:59you have a message preacher standing on the platform behind you. Vineyard folks, you have
00:45:06a message preacher touring your churches teaching you in those years. Now, don't you tell me,
00:45:12don't you tell me that there's no connection. No, you have. And here's the thing, John. In
00:45:18those years, John Wimber is telling the people as he introduces Paul Cain, a message preacher,
00:45:23John, from message roots, from Branhamism. He's telling the Vineyard people that Paul
00:45:28Cain is the greatest living prophet in the world. He's telling that to them. He's the
00:45:35most supernaturally gifted, powerful prophet in the world. This is what John Wimber is saying
00:45:39as he introduces Paul Cain. And Paul Cain is the senior miracle man of the Vineyard movement
00:45:45in those years. And who are they platforming? They are platforming a homosexual man who worked
00:45:54closely with William Branham and was living out near Prescott with the park and all of that stuff
00:45:59when all the horrors happen. And God only knows, John. God only knows all of the horrors, you know,
00:46:07and the things we know about Paul Cain now. Paul Cain was a terrible, terrible person on so many
00:46:14levels. And John Wimber has got this man on the platform telling the people he's the greatest
00:46:21prophet, parroting language of the latter rain movement, which maybe he's giving a different
00:46:27definition to. But Paul Cain is most absolutely certainly using the latter rain and message
00:46:32definitions and terminology as he teaches this to the masses in Europe, in the United States, in Canada,
00:46:40in Australia. You know, they do this all over the place, John. And as they throw open the doors,
00:46:47Paul Cain and the other Kansas City prophets in the 80s and the early 90s, this is before Mike Bickle
00:46:53had Kansas City Fellowship and all that, they are traveling around the Vineyard movement. Just like
00:46:59the message evangelists travel the message circuit, John, Paul Cain was traveling the Vineyard circuit,
00:47:05spreading this stuff all over the Vineyard movement. Now, did the whole Vineyard movement
00:47:09accept this ideology? No, absolutely not. Did the majority accept it? I don't even think the
00:47:15majority accepted it, John. But did a sizable minority accept it? Absolutely. And that sizable
00:47:23minority of Vineyard, which accepted this ideology, which John Wimber opened the doors and promoted
00:47:28and let in, is the people who are going to start the new apostolic reformation and are going to be
00:47:33pushed out of the Vineyard movement at the end of John Wimber's life.
00:47:37It's scary, man. I don't know if you've seen the movies. There's a movie series,
00:47:41The Final Destination. And in the series, when somebody cheats death, then suddenly all of these
00:47:47bad things, like horrifically bad things start happening to them because they've cheated death
00:47:51and death is coming to get them. All of this reminds you, if you understand the framework of
00:47:57this thing, it is like, it's worse than the Final Destination movies. And ironically, people are
00:48:03choosing their false final destination in it. But many of the people who were in this trail of
00:48:10history were fully aware that bad things were happening because of the false foundation,
00:48:14bad doctrines. Men were rising up. And they would actually condemn, like in the early years,
00:48:20I think we pointed out that Jim Jones actually condemned Branham. He and I think Branham said there
00:48:25were 300 ministers that condemned him. They realized that it was a cult. Before that happened,
00:48:30you have the entire Assemblies of God who recognized this is a foundation that is destructive. It is
00:48:36extremism. And we reject it. So the Assemblies of God rejected in the late 40s, 1949, I think it was.
00:48:44All through history, you have people rising up to reject it. Those who stayed in it were fully aware
00:48:51of the reasons why it was being rejected. As they would watch people splinter off and break away from
00:48:56it, those who stayed and remained, they knew that it was bad. They knew the foundation was bad.
00:49:02But what they kept trying to do was shift everything that was built on top of the foundation.
00:49:08Let's leave the foundation. We love the signs and wonders things. It makes lots of money for us.
00:49:13Let's keep the signs and wonders. Let's keep this foundation. And let's keep all of the elements that
00:49:19enable us to claim power over the people who are submitting to us their authority. They wanted to
00:49:27keep all of that, but they kept trying to change doctrines and try to make it seem as though this is
00:49:32a fresh new thing with a fresh new doctrine. Same foundation. Well, just like the Final Destination
00:49:37movies, bad things continue to happen. And this recurs over and over and over and over again.
00:49:43And we're in a cycle where it is reformed so much so that if you were to look at the movement today
00:49:50and then compare it to the Branhamism that we grew up, it is two, it looks like two completely
00:49:56different things. This is not the same thing. But if you know the foundation and you have all of that
00:50:02structure and you recognize that, yes, the doctrines are new, but the foundation, the very foundation that
00:50:08it sits on is the same thing. You're essentially playing a game of Final Destination with yourself.
00:50:14Bad things are going to continue to happen.
00:50:17I think what's important, John, too, you know, when people say, well, the doctrine has changed and stuff,
00:50:23I would actually argue, John, that it hasn't that changed that much. And the people saying that are
00:50:29actually just unfamiliar with the branches of the latter rain movement. Yes, John, there are the two of the
00:50:36senior branches of the latter rain movement did continue on with dispensationalist theology and
00:50:43rapture and all that, right? But one of the senior branches of the latter rain movement did not.
00:50:48And that is actually one of the very reasons that they broke off in the very earliest days into their
00:50:53own branch of the movement. The global missions branch of this, John, became amillennial. They stopped
00:51:01believing in dispensationalism. They stopped believing in the rapture. And they took on the
00:51:06viewpoint of manifested sons of God that basically everyone will just become a manifested son of God.
00:51:12They will seize control of the world through the power of the spoken word, okay, and usher in the end of days.
00:51:20That is much more similar to what the Kansas City guys and stuff believed, okay? It's not what we believed in the
00:51:28message, right? Because we had varying interpretations of this, right? There's varying interpretations of these
00:51:34things in the branches of the latter rain movement. And as I said before, within the vineyard movement, you have a
00:51:40reconvergence of multiple branches of the latter rain movement, okay? I've already explained how the shepherding
00:51:46movement came in in the beginning. Well, here we're talking about how the message branch comes in through
00:51:50Paul Cain. But John, that's not it either. It don't stop there. As Paul Cain comes in and the shepherding
00:51:57movement comes in, they open the doors to some of the original elders of latter rain. Bill Britton and
00:52:03some of those kind of guys are also coming into vineyard and teaching and sharing things. And they
00:52:09bring in that amillennial view from them. They bring in that dominionist view from them. John Wimber lets in
00:52:15the three senior branches of the latter rain movement into vineyard, John. And they recombine their
00:52:22ideologies and produce the Gnar. And, you know, there's so much there, you know, a person could
00:52:28spend so long talking about all that, John. But John Wimber made just a absolutely disastrous mistake
00:52:36in what he did. And I'm so glad that he changed his mind and started a reform process for vineyard at
00:52:42the end of his life. But the fallout of the negative choices, the bad side of the choices he made
00:52:48continues with us to the present day. And I do know, I am putting a lot on John Wimber's
00:52:54shoulders here because I do believe he is that responsible for all this. I don't think there's
00:52:58anybody more responsible in vineyard for what happened than him. I think he is by far the
00:53:03most responsible person for what happened. And to be clear, John Wimber platformed sex perverts,
00:53:11homosexuals, R-worders, child molesters, drug addicted people, people who killed some people
00:53:22too, and promoted them as senior leaders in this thing. He did. That is the reality of it,
00:53:28right? And to kind of downplay all that, I mean, it happened. It happened. And Paul Cain was one of
00:53:34those people that he platformed in all of that. And they produced something really, really ugly
00:53:39and something that turned dangerous, in my opinion, certainly. Now, what happens next, John, is
00:53:46as vineyard starts to bring all these guys in, and you come into the 1980s, by the middle 1980s,
00:53:53guess what happens? The shepherding movement starts to implode. Pat Robertson is launching that
00:53:58campaign against the shepherding guys. The shepherding movement is imploding. It's falling apart.
00:54:03And guess what happens? The shepherding people need a new home. The shepherding churches need a new
00:54:09home. And so, as we've mentioned already, John Wimber and the shepherding guys had already
00:54:15become friends. And John Wimber's in their magazines and all that. And as the shepherding
00:54:20movement implodes, a sizable percentage of the shepherding movement migrates and builds a new
00:54:27home and vineyard, John. And so now vineyard, as you come into the late 1980s, vineyard is made up of
00:54:33multiple factions. One of those factions are the charismatic hippies who were brought in from the
00:54:39Jesus people with the influence of shepherding teachings. Another faction is the actual shepherding
00:54:46movement people who joined them after the shepherding movement imploded. Shepherding preachers, shepherding
00:54:51people. The third branch is, John, you have the Kansas City Prophets and all of the latter rain-tangled
00:54:58web that they're connected to also in as a third faction in this thing. So you've got three deeply
00:55:05latter rain-influenced factions in the vineyard movement as you come into the middle and late
00:55:111980s. Now, these are not the only factions. There's other people in vineyard besides these. But you've got
00:55:15these three factions. And they are combining together, John. It is like, I don't know, you know that stuff
00:55:21when you're in school and you mix it together and then the volcano explodes out the top?
00:55:26John Wimper, they're pouring these things together, John. And then what happens as you come into the
00:55:33early 1990s? You get the Toronto Blessing, okay? The Toronto Blessing, and this is not exactly where
00:55:40it started, although this is the point it became very popular, famously well-known all over the world.
00:55:46The Toronto Blessing is when all of these elements have combined and are shaking it up,
00:55:51and kaboom! You get the Toronto Blessing, John. That's when the Toronto Blessing happened.
00:55:56You know, it's funny, but it's also scary when you think about it. I have ministers and friends who
00:56:02are in the Branham cult. And the Branham cult, whenever you're on the outside looking in, it's
00:56:08all one and the same. This is one big group. This is a cult of people who have, by and large,
00:56:15accepted William Branham's false doctrine as authority, and basically his spoken word has
00:56:20replaced the Bible with the written word. When you're outside looking in, that's what it looks
00:56:25like. But when you're on the inside, it looks much different. You have factions within the message
00:56:30that they're somewhat benign. I wouldn't call them really a healthy church because of the foundation,
00:56:37but they're not as bad as the others. On the far extreme, you have all of the things that you just
00:56:42mentioned, from predators to – I won't even go how far bad it goes. If you want to know that history,
00:56:51go to Colonia Dignidad. Just type that in Wikipedia. You'll see the far extreme of what this can be.
00:56:56But there's that vast of a difference in the sects of the message. There are people who are killing other
00:57:03people, and there are people who think they're in a somewhat healthy church. But in the midst of all of
00:57:08this, they have the same foundation. So whenever somebody who's in one of the more benign churches
00:57:14who – I had one minister who tells me he's trying to make it a healthy church, and he's going through
00:57:20all the proper steps of a healthy church. And in the back of my mind, I'm thinking, but wait a minute.
00:57:25You have the same foundation as the rest of them. Yes, you may have good intentions. What about whenever
00:57:31you're no longer pastor? What about when you die, when the next guy takes over? That next guy, if he studied
00:57:37Branham, studied Branhamism, he has all of the elements necessary to make it a very destructive cult.
00:57:44And that same mentality applies to all of this movement from start to finish. Yes, the church
00:57:50may look healthy. What about when this current minister dies? Is the foundation something that
00:57:56breeds a healthy church, or is it something that breeds a very destructive one?
00:58:00You know, when you think about the vineyard movement in its early days, the vineyard movement
00:58:05was an easy target. And as I said in our last episode, I actually believe that the shepherding
00:58:11leaders purposefully targeted Lonnie Frisbee for recruitment. They purposefully target leading
00:58:17Jesus people for recruitment. And they did it because they wanted to gain access to this audience
00:58:26of easy marks. And, you know, it's kind of sad to say that, John, but I really think when you when you look
00:58:32at the origins of all this, a lot of these people were just easy targets for this ideology. They were
00:58:37people who had come from not many of them, not really Christian backgrounds. They had come.
00:58:46They were young people, predominantly young people. And they were just, there's not a lot of
00:58:53eldership, real serious eldership, you know, from a, you know, a good authoritative source that you
00:59:00can trust and rely on going on in these things. And they just were easy marks. And, and like the
00:59:06latter rain movement, the entry bar into leadership is incredibly low in these movements. Now, it's not as
00:59:12low as the latter rain movement today, but you go back to the early days, John, like you, you,
00:59:16you go back, you know, forgive me for talking bad about Calvary Chapel, John, because I, I,
00:59:21I'm trying, I'm not throwing Calvary Chapel under the bus here. If anybody from there thinks I'm
00:59:24listed, you know, thinks that's what I'm doing. But you go back to Calvary Chapel in the early days.
00:59:29In what universe should Lonnie Frisbee have ever been made a leader? Never any universe should Lonnie
00:59:35Frisbee ever been made a leader of anything, right? But he, you know, he was empowered into leadership.
00:59:40You can kind of go down the list of the people. There is a very low bar of entry into leadership
00:59:49into these things, right? And that is easily abused by this movement, right? And the latter rain ideology
00:59:58around fivefold ministry and so forth jives with that very well, right? It jives with some of the
01:00:05spot that these people already were. And so they just come in and they're easy marks for this ideology.
01:00:10And a percentage of them were converted into it. And John, I, I think it's very true that as they
01:00:17came in and converted these people, you know, are you aware anywhere of Derek Prince saying,
01:00:22hey, I used to pastor a church with the elders to share an orphanage. Derek Prince never told you
01:00:27guys that. What is that? That's deception, ladies and gentlemen. That's what that is. You guys did,
01:00:33they didn't tell you all that they were, had worked with the latter rain movement. In fact,
01:00:37they bad mouth the latter rain movement, you know, is what they would do to some extent,
01:00:41all the while teaching you latter rain stuff. That's, you know what that is, John? Again,
01:00:44that is deception. I'm going to tell you, yeah, the latter rain movement was bad, but hey,
01:00:48let me teach you some of their ideology. That is exactly what they did, John. And it, the people kind
01:00:55of imbibed on it. And by the time you, you come up into the eighties, I mentioned before how they,
01:01:01they kind of just had a very soft version of manifested sons of God at the very beginning
01:01:06from the shepherding movement. Well, as they bring in the Kansas City prophets, and they bring in all
01:01:11of the latter rain influence that those guys were connected to, John, they start to bring in the
01:01:16radical form of manifested sons of God. It makes its radical form of manifested sons of God begins
01:01:23to make its appearance as they bring in the Kansas City prophets. And Paul Cain is teaching
01:01:28latter rain by name to the vineyard conferences. And he's teaching manifested sons of God by name
01:01:34to the latter rain conferences. And so are others of the Kansas City prophets. And they're going down
01:01:41that radical path. So it starts out more benign in the sixties, seventies, as you come into the eighties.
01:01:48Now that piece of manifested sons of God comes in. They already got the positive confession.
01:01:54They've already got five-fold ministry, these guys. And now the radical, the radical manifested
01:02:00sons of God is coming in, in, in the middle and late eighties. And this is when they start to go
01:02:05crazy, right? The, the combination, it's not just the combination of people. It's the combination of
01:02:09ideas that produce the explosions and this ideology all throughout its history is all coming together
01:02:15in vineyard in the late eighties. And so, yeah, you end up with the Toronto blessing. And there is,
01:02:22you know, Randy Clark is the minister there and Randy Clark, you know, I mean,
01:02:26we could do, there's so many things here we could just do. We do three or four episodes on each one
01:02:30of these topics and guys, John, but things, things, things went crazy pretty fast. And I'm not just
01:02:35talking about, you know, the people barking and foaming at the mouth and all that. That's crazy.
01:02:40But I mean, you know, very harmful stuff started to happen too, through the deliverance practices,
01:02:45people started to be harmed, people started to be injured, people started to be really taken advantage of,
01:02:51financially, a lot of really bad things started to happen as you come into the nineties, you know,
01:02:58as this ideology starts to get crazier and crazier. And all the while, some of these senior guys are,
01:03:04you know, in the back rooms, absolutely, you know, terrible monsters of people, which has now,
01:03:10you know, come to the light. Mike Bickle was already doing his bad stuff back then, John,
01:03:14you know, this period we're talking about, Mike Bickle's already doing his bad stuff back then.
01:03:17Paul Kane was already doing his bad stuff back then. Bob Jones was already doing his bad stuff back then.
01:03:23And where were they doing it in back then? In the Vineyard Movement. They were in the Vineyard Movement
01:03:28when all that stuff happened, John. And as you come up, John, and I think in our next episode,
01:03:33this is where we're going to go. As you come up into the middle and late 1990s,
01:03:39John Wimber and other leadership in Vineyard start to enter into territory where there is going to
01:03:49be a schism over this stuff. And what's going to happen is John Wimber is actually going to vocally
01:03:54reject the fivefold ministry. That's the piece that he's really going to reject. He's going to reject
01:03:59fivefold ministry. And as he does that, the people who want fivefold ministry, they're breaking away
01:04:04and they are the New Apostolic Reformation. But during these years that they're all in Vineyard,
01:04:10C. Peter Wagner is also in Vineyard. And C. Peter Wagner looks at all of this that is happening and
01:04:17he says, this is a New Apostolic Reformation. And C. Peter Wagner names this thing that he's seeing.
01:04:24And what's he seeing? What does he see when he calls it New Apostolic Reformation? He's specifically
01:04:29looking at the fivefold ministry teachings, John. Fivefold ministry is New Apostolic Reformation.
01:04:36It's the same thing. And he looks at this and he says, oh, these guys are commissioning prophets.
01:04:40Oh, they're commissioning apostles. This is a New Apostolic Reformation. No. He was mistaken.
01:04:49This thing was not new then. There's nothing new about the New Apostolic Reformation. The New
01:04:54Apostolic Reformation is a continuation of the original fivefold ministry structures
01:04:59that were set up in the latter rain movement. Paul Cain is a prophet of the message. He's a
01:05:05he's a he's a latter rain message ordained prophet. He's from one of our fivefold ministry
01:05:09structures, John. You know, Derek Prince and all those guys were ordained out of one of the
01:05:13fivefold ministry structures. All of these things were the fivefold ministry structures set up in
01:05:17the original latter rain movement that broke into competing fivefold ministry structures recombined
01:05:24in vineyard. Okay. See, Peter Wagner sees it. They call it the New Apostolic Reformation. John Wimber
01:05:31says, oh, these guys are going crazy. Let's kick them all out. And they're the gnar, John. It's the New
01:05:36Apostolic Reformation is the fivefold ministry structures that were pushed out of vineyard in the 1990s.
01:05:42I'm not a big fan of beating a dead horse, but one last time I'm going to beat the dead horse because
01:05:48you said something there that actually proved my point to the letter. And I don't think many people
01:05:55recognize this. When any of these guys on their deathbed, whether they said it or not, I sometimes
01:06:01question whether they really did. When they have this deathbed confession, I rejected the whole thing.
01:06:07Think about the words that are used when somebody rebutched the argument that these guys have had
01:06:13this history. They say he rejected the whole thing, whoever it was. But they're overloading that word
01:06:18whole. They're saying he rejected the whole thing. Did you reject the whole foundation? Or did you just
01:06:24reject one part that you disagreed with? Are you like that minister that I mentioned who rejected
01:06:30most of Branhamism but kept most of the authoritarian control? And you mentioned Lonnie Frisbee, how
01:06:38it didn't take much for him to be appointed to leadership. Think of what it looks like to somebody
01:06:43who's outside of this cult, who has a minister with strong biblical understanding, who knows the Bible,
01:06:50knows theology, a very sound teacher, and he's leading a church. Someone in that church looks into
01:06:57this thing and sees Lonnie Frisbee. What are his credentials? Where did he learn his theology? What
01:07:03theology does he even have? And it all goes back to this one central point. The foundation was laid,
01:07:11was completely opposite to Jesus' words about the evil and adulterous generation seeks after a sign.
01:07:18That phrase is pointing directly to what was created here. If you could have a sign, if you could
01:07:24display some miracle, you instantly got leadership. And if you go all the way back to the assemblies of
01:07:31God rejecting it in 1949, 1948 or 9, whichever that was, that was their rejection. If you understand what
01:07:39they're saying, this creates the scheme to bring people into leadership roles who have no business
01:07:46being there whatsoever. So we, the assemblies of God, we're breaking away. We don't want this thing.
01:07:51But look what's happening with Lonnie Frisbee. Because he, you know, this guy's high on LSD,
01:07:58you don't know what his signs and wonders really are. Is it a manufactured chemical sign and wonder?
01:08:04You know, it's nonsense when you think about it. But because he could do whatever it was that he
01:08:09did, he was appointed to leadership with no scriptural doctrinal foundation to what he was
01:08:16doing. It was the signs and wonders. That was his foundation. And that's what all of this is built
01:08:22upon. If you can display some sign and not even if you can display it, if you can convince somebody that
01:08:28you did have a sign, that's enough to be in a leadership role in this. That is the foundation.
01:08:33So I question, you know, whenever somebody says they rejected the whole thing, whoever it is,
01:08:39I really question that because you still see it continuing after they allegedly reject it.
01:08:44Yes, they may have eliminated one small piece of it, but that's what happened. So this is a big mess
01:08:50that continues today. And with that, I'll stop beating the dead horse.
01:08:53Well, John, I think this is probably a good place to stop the episode today. Maybe in our
01:08:59next episode, we'll continue with this a little bit. We'll talk about what happened in the 90s,
01:09:05you know, in Vineyard and how the New Apostolic Reformation, which was not new,
01:09:10but thusly named the New Apostolic Reformation, how it ended up becoming what it is today,
01:09:18how it broke away from Vineyard, you know, in the events around John Wimber's
01:09:24separation from it. So I think that would be good. And I think it's also very important
01:09:29to talk about the message's reaction to all this when it happened. Because the people in the message,
01:09:35my sect, especially John, we were very aware of all of this as it transpired. Because as I mentioned,
01:09:41Paul Cain was coming around all our churches back then. And this was an issue back when all of these
01:09:46things happened, that Paul Cain was fellowshipping with the false anointed ones.
01:09:52And so, John, we'll talk about the false anointed ones in our next episode.
01:09:58John Well, I look forward to it. If you've enjoyed
01:10:00our show and you want more information, you can check us out on the web.
01:10:03You can find us at William-Branham.org and ChristianGospelChurch.org. For more about the history
01:10:09of William Branham and the healing revivals, read Come Out of For My People. And for more about the dark
01:10:14side of the New Apostolic Reformation, you can read Weaponized Religion from Christian Identity to the
01:10:19NAR, both available on Amazon, Kindle, and Audible.
01:10:34David, cup country with all the weeds such as the multiv than artists,
01:10:43connected and teledetron to a more Sepulist of konkret from that resource page.
01:10:48Takeations to the NAR and Toon on said that you could be a new aide and the environmental community in California
01:10:53and enter you to pull out your calendar in a book.
01:10:56That was something I говорил, and I really or do that for you.
01:10:58It's not the Vale of For Your Trust.
01:10:59We'll see you next time.

Recommended