Peter Klein breaks down a bitterly disappointing Blue Jays season, putting most of the blame on Vladimir Guerrero Jr.'s late-season comments and a brutal run of injuries, while asking whether the goodwill from last year's World Series run has finally worn off for John Schneider and Ross Atkins.

Do you think Schneider and Atkins deserve another season to fix this?

Couch Potato Diary is available wherever you get your podcasts.

#TorontoBlueJays #MLB #BlueJays

🎧 Listen on: Apple https://apple.co/49NGm2L | Spotify https://open.spotify.com/show/3QgazeHcSKSteZbBIubcuM?si=icY7NEBvT7yZadv_JFlT6Q

💬 Follow for live breakdowns: X.com/primetimepk | Twitch.tv/primetimepk | Kick.com/primetimepk

🔗 Support the Show:
- Tip Jar: https://streamelements.com/couchpotatodiary/tip (fuels more content!)
- Partners: C of Dead http://cofdead403.ca/

Category

🥇
Sports
Transcript
00:00You cannot call this season anything but a bitter disappointment.
00:03So let's see what went wrong for the Blue Jays in 2026.
00:13There is no other way to put it.
00:15This was a bitter, bitter disappointment for the Toronto Blue Jays.
00:18To come off of a year where you were two outs away from the World Series
00:22and a couple of inches away from the World Series with IKF sliding at home plate
00:27or the Ernie Clement hit out in left field that we don't need to re-legislate it.
00:30I'm going to start to cry.
00:31But to come from that season and have this year just be so not fun is, oh, it sucks.
00:41It sucks so bad.
00:42And the fan support was there the entire year.
00:44Over 3 million fans piling into the Rogers Center.
00:47They had over 60 sellouts for a team that, like, the final week of the season was irrelevant in baseball.
00:53I am still surprised that they never really got it figured out this year
00:59and incredibly disappointed that it got there.
01:01And look, it starts, that conversation starts with Vladi.
01:05There are other factors that go into it.
01:07But Vladi, like, if we're doing the blame pie, he gets more than half of it for the putrid season
01:12that he had.
01:13And I saw the comments.
01:14It was just, it was, it wasn't, it was just so poorly done by him.
01:19And I understand what he is saying.
01:21And it's something we have all kind of know, like, you don't really get paid for, like,
01:26your contract doesn't, the number on that isn't based off of, like, what you are going to be doing.
01:32It is a bit of a reward for what you have done.
01:34But you're still getting paid to do a job, you know?
01:38So, the comment was just, it was a bit of a dud.
01:42And to have it come off of such a disastrous season, just don't do that.
01:50Just really, really don't do that.
01:51Him apologizing was good because, like, this would have carried on throughout the entire offseason.
01:56There's still going to be some lingering of that.
01:58But him being like, yeah, no, I recognize what I said was dumb.
02:00It's not what I meant.
02:01I apologize.
02:02And I do kind of believe him.
02:03But I don't think there's a player in baseball who's going to be under more pressure next season,
02:08whenever that is, than Vlad Guerrero Jr.
02:10Because, again, this was lower than anything I thought his floor could possibly be.
02:15So, yeah, Vladdy needs to step up if this team's going to do anything the next time there is baseball.
02:23As far as the last day of the season goes, some nice send-offs there for Springer and Scherzer.
02:28A lot of debate about whether the Springer contract, was this actually a good deal?
02:32The guy hit a home run that sent them to the World Series.
02:35I think he did add legitimacy to the Blue Jays when he came in after Hyunjin Ryu.
02:40And just like, hey, this was a place that people can sign.
02:43Maybe not the Otanis and the Sotos of the world.
02:46But this is a place where guys can sign, can enjoy themselves, and still play competitive baseball.
02:50He made the playoffs a few seasons with Toronto.
02:53And obviously, the big run last season.
02:56And the big hits in that big run.
02:57So, I think to consider that contract anything less than a success, you're just trying too hard to be negative.
03:05Scherzer, I think he's going to be a great ambassador for Toronto and for the Blue Jays,
03:09talking up the city and talking about how much he loved his time there.
03:13And again, it was a big success bringing him in.
03:15Maybe not this year, but they needed it with all the injuries that they had.
03:20And when you are looking at where this all went wrong, obviously, Vladdy is number one.
03:25But the injuries were a killer.
03:26Not to make any excuses, but to get nothing this year from Ponce, Barger, and Santander.
03:33And like, the Santander one, like, who knows?
03:35But like, so much of the offense being punchless and the offseason game plan was, well, Barger.
03:41Like, this is, like, he hit the first pinch hit grand slam in World Series history.
03:45Like, this is a guy who is going to be able to step up now and be an everyday force
03:50in this offense.
03:51And I think he had, like, one hit this year, which is more than Santander had.
03:54Ponce's knee explodes on his first outing back in the big leagues.
03:59So, to get nothing from those guys and minimal from Yassavage and Bieber all season long.
04:05Like, that is, that's a lot to have to come back from, from a Blue Jays standpoint.
04:10Now, I still think they could have done it in a bit of a better way and should have done
04:13it in a better way.
04:14But those really were killers.
04:17And maybe the reason for some optimism going into whenever the next season is going to be.
04:21But the one thing I do know is that the goodwill from that World Series, I think, has worn off
04:27for Schneider and for Atkins.
04:29Now, I'm not saying everyone's going to say it's going to fire them.
04:33But they need to get off to a good start next season.
04:36Um, I think you look at Schneider sticking with Vladdy as long as he did high up in the lineup,
04:42right to the last day, basically.
04:44Putting him high up in the lineup when he's obviously struggling, he's obviously fighting it,
04:47and you have guys behind him better that are going right now.
04:51And he just kept coming up in big spots and kept not delivering for this baseball team.
04:56Sticking with Hoffman as closer as long as he did, right?
05:00Like, that, that, both of those things cost them enough games that they would have at least been relevant in
05:05the last weekend of the season.
05:07And been able to, to make more of a push.
05:09And then from the front office standpoint, again, like, the Bateman trade worked out really well.
05:13To get any human being for Varsho, who's not even healthy enough to play right now in the postseason, they
05:19did good work.
05:20But, in terms of keeping this team competitive, you could see from April that this lineup wasn't as good as
05:26it was a season ago.
05:27And that there needed to be some adjustments and some additions made to help this group out offensively.
05:33And just getting a bunch of three true outcome guys who really ended up being one true outcome, and that's
05:37home runs.
05:38Like, that, that wasn't it.
05:39And I get, it takes two to tango and all of that.
05:42But they're just, there was not enough urgency, I felt, from the front office to fix the issues that they
05:46were having with the, um, with the lineup.
05:50And so, like, coming off of losing Bo Bichette, and, no, no, no, no, no, it's gonna be fine.
05:55Our approach is gonna get us there.
05:56And everything like that.
05:58Like, okay, you guys brought us the most success we've had in most Blue Jays fans' lifetimes.
06:02So, you get a pass.
06:05But, that pass is gone.
06:06This needs to be an aggressive offseason, however that can be, in whatever the new landscape looks like.
06:11And this needs to be a season of greater results for the Blue Jays going forward.
06:16Um, or else I think both these guys are out.
06:18Um, because it was, it was getting pretty close to that last year.
06:21Um, before they, you know, turned it on and weren't the best team in baseball.
06:25Um, or the best team in the American League down the stretch.
06:28And, look, like, I've referenced it a few times.
06:30We're now going into an offseason of unknowns.
06:32We don't know when the next Blue Jays game is going to be.
06:36Hearing some people saying, like, oh, yeah, Memorial Day is probably when things are gonna get, uh, really figured out.
06:41It's like, does that mean Memorial Day 28?
06:42Because these suicides feel very, very far apart.
06:45And, like, this is a Blue Jays team that has been very aggressive in free agency.
06:52If everyone is allowed to spend the same, how does Toronto now stand out?
06:56Is it, like, guys like Bassett and Gosman and Scherzer talking about, like, how much they love the city and
07:02how much they love playing for that team?
07:03Is it the stuff in Dunedin?
07:05Or are they gonna have to go a bit of a different way?
07:07They have, they have a pitching coach that I think has been able to get the most out of so
07:11many guys.
07:12And that will be beneficial in bringing some players in.
07:16But this is not a system that's developed a ton of pitching.
07:19Right?
07:19Like, it's your savage.
07:20And, and that's it.
07:22There aren't many other, or any other, development stories that you can hang your hat on from a draft and
07:27develop standpoint.
07:28And, like, the minors are filled with a lot of, like, slap-happy guys.
07:32A couple of dudes who can rake, obviously.
07:34But, um, they, we, we just don't know.
07:39And the aggressive approach the Blue Jays have taken, while they have fallen short a number of times,
07:43um, like, if they can spend the same as the Yankees, that's a tough sell.
07:48If they can spend just the exact same as the Braves and everyone else, that's a tough sell.
07:52So how is Toronto gonna be able to stand out in a world where a lot of people are assuming
07:56the finances are at least gonna be,
07:58on the same level there.
07:59So, we will see what happens here with the Blue Jays going forward.
08:04Um, but yeah, what, what do you guys think?
08:06Like, am I being too hard on anyone, or not hard enough on the Blue Jays after the 2026 season?
08:11Let me know in the comments.
08:13Coming up later in the week, we're gonna go over the offseason.
08:16Based off of the rules that we have now, um, but I, um, I, I'm really interested to see what's
08:25out there for the Blue Jays.
08:26So we're gonna do an offseason look-ahead, an offseason wishlist for Toronto, uh, coming up later on here this
08:31week.
08:31So, make sure you like the video, hit that bell button so you know when we are going live,
08:35and, uh, just share this with a few of your Blue Jays friends,
08:38so we can keep these conversations going here with Couch Potato Diary.
08:42We'll see you next time.

Recommended