00:00You cannot call this season anything but a bitter disappointment.
00:03So let's see what went wrong for the Blue Jays in 2026.
00:13There is no other way to put it.
00:15This was a bitter, bitter disappointment for the Toronto Blue Jays.
00:18To come off of a year where you were two outs away from the World Series
00:22and a couple of inches away from the World Series with IKF sliding at home plate
00:27or the Ernie Clement hit out in left field that we don't need to re-legislate it.
00:30I'm going to start to cry.
00:31But to come from that season and have this year just be so not fun is, oh, it sucks.
00:41It sucks so bad.
00:42And the fan support was there the entire year.
00:44Over 3 million fans piling into the Rogers Center.
00:47They had over 60 sellouts for a team that, like, the final week of the season was irrelevant in baseball.
00:53I am still surprised that they never really got it figured out this year
00:59and incredibly disappointed that it got there.
01:01And look, it starts, that conversation starts with Vladi.
01:05There are other factors that go into it.
01:07But Vladi, like, if we're doing the blame pie, he gets more than half of it for the putrid season
01:12that he had.
01:13And I saw the comments.
01:14It was just, it was, it wasn't, it was just so poorly done by him.
01:19And I understand what he is saying.
01:21And it's something we have all kind of know, like, you don't really get paid for, like,
01:26your contract doesn't, the number on that isn't based off of, like, what you are going to be doing.
01:32It is a bit of a reward for what you have done.
01:34But you're still getting paid to do a job, you know?
01:38So, the comment was just, it was a bit of a dud.
01:42And to have it come off of such a disastrous season, just don't do that.
01:50Just really, really don't do that.
01:51Him apologizing was good because, like, this would have carried on throughout the entire offseason.
01:56There's still going to be some lingering of that.
01:58But him being like, yeah, no, I recognize what I said was dumb.
02:00It's not what I meant.
02:01I apologize.
02:02And I do kind of believe him.
02:03But I don't think there's a player in baseball who's going to be under more pressure next season,
02:08whenever that is, than Vlad Guerrero Jr.
02:10Because, again, this was lower than anything I thought his floor could possibly be.
02:15So, yeah, Vladdy needs to step up if this team's going to do anything the next time there is baseball.
02:23As far as the last day of the season goes, some nice send-offs there for Springer and Scherzer.
02:28A lot of debate about whether the Springer contract, was this actually a good deal?
02:32The guy hit a home run that sent them to the World Series.
02:35I think he did add legitimacy to the Blue Jays when he came in after Hyunjin Ryu.
02:40And just like, hey, this was a place that people can sign.
02:43Maybe not the Otanis and the Sotos of the world.
02:46But this is a place where guys can sign, can enjoy themselves, and still play competitive baseball.
02:50He made the playoffs a few seasons with Toronto.
02:53And obviously, the big run last season.
02:56And the big hits in that big run.
02:57So, I think to consider that contract anything less than a success, you're just trying too hard to be negative.
03:05Scherzer, I think he's going to be a great ambassador for Toronto and for the Blue Jays,
03:09talking up the city and talking about how much he loved his time there.
03:13And again, it was a big success bringing him in.
03:15Maybe not this year, but they needed it with all the injuries that they had.
03:20And when you are looking at where this all went wrong, obviously, Vladdy is number one.
03:25But the injuries were a killer.
03:26Not to make any excuses, but to get nothing this year from Ponce, Barger, and Santander.
03:33And like, the Santander one, like, who knows?
03:35But like, so much of the offense being punchless and the offseason game plan was, well, Barger.
03:41Like, this is, like, he hit the first pinch hit grand slam in World Series history.
03:45Like, this is a guy who is going to be able to step up now and be an everyday force
03:50in this offense.
03:51And I think he had, like, one hit this year, which is more than Santander had.
03:54Ponce's knee explodes on his first outing back in the big leagues.
03:59So, to get nothing from those guys and minimal from Yassavage and Bieber all season long.
04:05Like, that is, that's a lot to have to come back from, from a Blue Jays standpoint.
04:10Now, I still think they could have done it in a bit of a better way and should have done
04:13it in a better way.
04:14But those really were killers.
04:17And maybe the reason for some optimism going into whenever the next season is going to be.
04:21But the one thing I do know is that the goodwill from that World Series, I think, has worn off
04:27for Schneider and for Atkins.
04:29Now, I'm not saying everyone's going to say it's going to fire them.
04:33But they need to get off to a good start next season.
04:36Um, I think you look at Schneider sticking with Vladdy as long as he did high up in the lineup,
04:42right to the last day, basically.
04:44Putting him high up in the lineup when he's obviously struggling, he's obviously fighting it,
04:47and you have guys behind him better that are going right now.
04:51And he just kept coming up in big spots and kept not delivering for this baseball team.
04:56Sticking with Hoffman as closer as long as he did, right?
05:00Like, that, that, both of those things cost them enough games that they would have at least been relevant in
05:05the last weekend of the season.
05:07And been able to, to make more of a push.
05:09And then from the front office standpoint, again, like, the Bateman trade worked out really well.
05:13To get any human being for Varsho, who's not even healthy enough to play right now in the postseason, they
05:19did good work.
05:20But, in terms of keeping this team competitive, you could see from April that this lineup wasn't as good as
05:26it was a season ago.
05:27And that there needed to be some adjustments and some additions made to help this group out offensively.
05:33And just getting a bunch of three true outcome guys who really ended up being one true outcome, and that's
05:37home runs.
05:38Like, that, that wasn't it.
05:39And I get, it takes two to tango and all of that.
05:42But they're just, there was not enough urgency, I felt, from the front office to fix the issues that they
05:46were having with the, um, with the lineup.
05:50And so, like, coming off of losing Bo Bichette, and, no, no, no, no, no, it's gonna be fine.
05:55Our approach is gonna get us there.
05:56And everything like that.
05:58Like, okay, you guys brought us the most success we've had in most Blue Jays fans' lifetimes.
06:02So, you get a pass.
06:05But, that pass is gone.
06:06This needs to be an aggressive offseason, however that can be, in whatever the new landscape looks like.
06:11And this needs to be a season of greater results for the Blue Jays going forward.
06:16Um, or else I think both these guys are out.
06:18Um, because it was, it was getting pretty close to that last year.
06:21Um, before they, you know, turned it on and weren't the best team in baseball.
06:25Um, or the best team in the American League down the stretch.
06:28And, look, like, I've referenced it a few times.
06:30We're now going into an offseason of unknowns.
06:32We don't know when the next Blue Jays game is going to be.
06:36Hearing some people saying, like, oh, yeah, Memorial Day is probably when things are gonna get, uh, really figured out.
06:41It's like, does that mean Memorial Day 28?
06:42Because these suicides feel very, very far apart.
06:45And, like, this is a Blue Jays team that has been very aggressive in free agency.
06:52If everyone is allowed to spend the same, how does Toronto now stand out?
06:56Is it, like, guys like Bassett and Gosman and Scherzer talking about, like, how much they love the city and
07:02how much they love playing for that team?
07:03Is it the stuff in Dunedin?
07:05Or are they gonna have to go a bit of a different way?
07:07They have, they have a pitching coach that I think has been able to get the most out of so
07:11many guys.
07:12And that will be beneficial in bringing some players in.
07:16But this is not a system that's developed a ton of pitching.
07:19Right?
07:19Like, it's your savage.
07:20And, and that's it.
07:22There aren't many other, or any other, development stories that you can hang your hat on from a draft and
07:27develop standpoint.
07:28And, like, the minors are filled with a lot of, like, slap-happy guys.
07:32A couple of dudes who can rake, obviously.
07:34But, um, they, we, we just don't know.
07:39And the aggressive approach the Blue Jays have taken, while they have fallen short a number of times,
07:43um, like, if they can spend the same as the Yankees, that's a tough sell.
07:48If they can spend just the exact same as the Braves and everyone else, that's a tough sell.
07:52So how is Toronto gonna be able to stand out in a world where a lot of people are assuming
07:56the finances are at least gonna be,
07:58on the same level there.
07:59So, we will see what happens here with the Blue Jays going forward.
08:04Um, but yeah, what, what do you guys think?
08:06Like, am I being too hard on anyone, or not hard enough on the Blue Jays after the 2026 season?
08:11Let me know in the comments.
08:13Coming up later in the week, we're gonna go over the offseason.
08:16Based off of the rules that we have now, um, but I, um, I, I'm really interested to see what's
08:25out there for the Blue Jays.
08:26So we're gonna do an offseason look-ahead, an offseason wishlist for Toronto, uh, coming up later on here this
08:31week.
08:31So, make sure you like the video, hit that bell button so you know when we are going live,
08:35and, uh, just share this with a few of your Blue Jays friends,
08:38so we can keep these conversations going here with Couch Potato Diary.
08:42We'll see you next time.