Skip to playerSkip to main content
Three MLB players whose current price tags do not match what they are likely to deliver in 2026.

One shortstop is going nearly 20 picks ahead of a player I would take over him every single time. One exciting young player on a bad team is being drafted like a top 30 fantasy asset, and I just do not see the improvement that would justify it. And one big-name free agent signing, maybe there is a little bitterness involved here, I think, has some real red flags that are not being priced in at his current ADP.

Am I wrong on any of these? Tell me in the comments.

#FantasyBaseball2026 #MLBOverrated #KyleTucker #ZachNeto #GeraldoPerdomo #FantasyBaseballADP #MLB2026 #FantasyBaseballTips #MLBPreview2026 #Baseball2026 #ChicagoCubs #LAAngels #ArizonaDiamondbacks #CouchPotatoDiary #PeterKlein


🎧 Listen on: Apple https://apple.co/49NGm2L | Spotify https://open.spotify.com/show/3QgazeHcSKSteZbBIubcuM?si=icY7NEBvT7yZadv_JFlT6Q

💬 Follow for live breakdowns: X.com/primetimepk | Twitch.tv/primetimepk | Kick.com/primetimepk

🔗 Support the Show:
- Tip Jar: https://streamelements.com/couchpotatodiary/tip (fuels more content!)
- Partners: C of Dead http://cofdead403.ca/ | Swift Energy https://www.swiftenergy.gg/?ref=mriusnqm PROMO CODE: PKPrimetime for 25% Off!

Category

🥇
Sports
Transcript
00:00We've already covered the teams. What about the players? Let's take a look at what players are
00:04being overrated in MLB going into another season. All right, just did the underrated players in MLB,
00:23so we're going to do the same format. Only three we have here for overrated,
00:25but going to use Fantasy Baseball ADP as kind of our barometer here. So at number three,
00:33it is Arizona Diamondbacks' Geraldo Perdomo coming in with an ADP of 62. I just don't see it with him.
00:41I think he's solid, but again, I think there are pieces around him that are fine, but he's going
00:4918 picks ahead of Bo Bichette right now. So I just, I don't get it with him. I'm sure there
00:55are arguments you could make, but just in general, like he is a solid, solid baseball player, but in
01:00terms of being top 60 or anything like that, even with Fantasy Baseball and the differences with
01:05Fantasy and regular, but I'm just, I'm not there with Perdomo. I think he is quite overrated coming
01:11into this season. Coming in at number two, it's Zach Netto from the LA Angels, 33rd in ADP. An
01:20exciting player, and I think he's going to be fine. I just don't know if you're going to see
01:24an improvement with him enough that some of those counting numbers and everything are going to hit
01:30for someone to be drafting him in the third round or anything like that for Fantasy Baseball. And then
01:36for regular baseball, like the Angels just aren't that great. Again, he's going to be a solid player,
01:41and I think he's going to be fun to watch at times and give the Angels a bit of hope
01:45where
01:45they haven't had that in a while. But in terms of him being that top 30 guy or anything like
01:49that,
01:50I just don't see it there. And at number one, maybe there is a little bit of bitterness happening
01:54here, but it's Kyle Tucker. Right now, ADP of 11. It was a down year for him last season,
02:01and I'm sure there will be some bounce back with him. But I think one of the things we are
02:05going to
02:06see is that, yes, he was the best player available in free agency. That doesn't make him one of the
02:10best players in baseball. I think having the pressure off of him is going to be just fine. But
02:18now that the Blue Jays aren't pursuing him, and you can kind of look at it, I think taking a
02:22step
02:22back, I think there are quite a few red flags with this guy and how he chose to go about
02:29things in
02:29free agency. And I think some of that could show up out on the diamond this year. So Kyle Tucker,
02:35I think in fantasy and probably in reality, the most overrated player in MLB for the 2026 season.
02:41I am sure there are going to be some disagreements. So who was left off the list and who shouldn't
02:45be
02:46on here to begin with? Let me know in the comments. And while you're there, like the video, hit subscribe,
02:51but also share this with some of your baseball fan friends really trying to grow the channel. And
02:55whether you want to spark debate, brag to a friend like, hey, see, this guy says your dude's
03:01overrated. So or if you just want to rage bait someone, either way, share it with your baseball
03:06fan friends. And we can keep that conversation going down in the comments.
Comments

Recommended