Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 6 weeks ago
A television news debate examines the political and civilisational dispute surrounding the Krishna Janmabhoomi in Mathura following remarks made by Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath on Sri Krishna Janmashtami. Bharatiya Janata Party spokesperson Anila Singh asserts that reclaiming the temple site is a constitutional and civilisational right for Sanatanis, declaring, 'The issue of Shri Krishan Janmabhoomi is not an ordinary land dispute but a matter of faith, identity and a resolve of liberation.' Samajwadi Party spokesperson Anurag Bhadouria accuses the ruling party of invoking religious issues near elections to distract the public from core governance topics such as civic infrastructure, schools, employment, and alleged financial mismanagement at temple trusts. Maulana Sajid Rashidi questions the statements made by political leaders ahead of court verdicts, invoking the Places of Worship Act of 1991 and past Supreme Court observations. The debate centers on historical claims regarding Mughal emperor Aurangzeb's 1670 demolition order and ongoing legal adjudication.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Now, there is a trail of evidence and it's linked all throughout
00:04since the demolition ordered by Aurangzeb in 1670
00:09all the way down to date about the ownership of that land, Krishnalala Virajman.
00:16But you've heard the legal position politically.
00:19Has the Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath sounded the pole bugle
00:22on Sri Krishna Janmarshami saying his government has faith in Sri Krishna,
00:27Sri Ram, Baba Vishwanath and Maa Vindhavasani.
00:31Those who have faith in Babar and Aurangzeb will not respect Hindu Aastha,
00:37says the Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh.
00:39So let me now throw it open for a wider discussion.
00:41Let me bring in Moulana Sajid Rashidi into this conversation,
00:45Anila Singh of the BJP, Anurag Bhadori of the Samajwadi Party
00:48and Anila Singh, if you look at election data, madam,
00:522014 BJP had won 24 seats in Western Uttar Pradesh in 2019
00:57it came down to 19 and in 2024 it had shrunk to just 13.
01:04Is this statement of the Chief Minister just ahead of UP elections
01:08an attempt to regain lost ground?
01:13My Ram Ram to all and I wish you, my co-panelists and your viewers,
01:19a very happy Janmarshami.
01:22Gaurav, the issue of Sri Krishna Janambhumi is not an ordinary land dispute
01:27but a matter of faith, identity and a resolve of liberation,
01:33the humiliation imposed by historical invaders for 1.4 billion Indians.
01:40I will include my Muslim brothers and sisters also into it
01:43because, you know, their DNA is our only, Sanatani Hindu.
01:49But if you want to exclude Muslims from it, more than welcome.
01:55But just as we reclaim the Grand Temple of Lord Sri Ram
01:59within constitutional and legal bounds,
02:02no force can stop the truth from emerging at the birthplace of Kana.
02:06We have got all the rights.
02:08All the Sanatani Hindu, they have got all the rights to claim it.
02:11Nobody can stop them.
02:13Regardless of how many hurdles the opposition creates
02:16for vote bank appeasement,
02:17the Bharati Jantabadi maintains an unicurical stance
02:21and we stand steadfast with the constitution.
02:24Fair enough.
02:25So you insist, you absolutely insist that this is not politics,
02:29this is Sanatana Asta.
02:31Moulana Sajid Rashidi,
02:33क्या आप अनिला सिंग से इतिफाक रखते हैं
02:36कि वो कहती हैं कि जो
02:38इस्लामिक आकरांताओं ने,
02:40उनके वंशजों ने अत्याचार किये
02:42भारत के मूल निवासियों पर
02:44वो सभी के उपर एक कलंक है
02:46चाहे वो भारत के हिंदू हो और मुस्लिम हो
02:48और इसलिए अगर ये
02:50दिव्य भव्य स्री कृष्ण मंदिर बनेगा
02:53जनभूमी मतुरा में
02:54जिस तरह से आयोध्या में बना
02:56तो ये बहुत अच्छा कदम होगा
02:59आप उत्तर प्रदेश के मुख्यमंत्री
03:01के बयान को किस रूप में दिखते हैं
03:04देखें मुख्यमंत्री जी ने जो कहा है
03:07कि ना कर्फ्यू है
03:08ना दंगा है
03:09सब चंगा ही चंगा है
03:12आदी बात तो इसमें सही है और आदी बात गलत है
03:16ना कर्फ्यू है
03:17ndangga hai ye baat toh sahih hai
03:19lekin sab changa hai ye baat sahih
03:21nahi hai
03:22ek samvidhanik pad par baithe huye kisi bhi
03:25ádmi ko
03:26court se pahle fayasla suna dhena
03:28kya hum yehaan divye aur bhuwye mandir
03:30banayi nghe
03:31aur banna chahiyye
03:33aap khud batayin imanadari se patrkar honne
03:36ke nate kya ye samvidhanik hai
03:39ye court ki bhi
03:40ammanna hai
03:41aur ye haamare samvidhan ki bhi ammanna hai
03:44is tarha ka biyan
03:46samvidhanik pad par baithe huye loggon ko
03:48nahi dhe na chahiye
03:49douseri baat
03:49abhi maamla court mein hai
03:51ji
03:52or court mein aapne dekha hooga
03:54bhabari masjid ka
03:54jab fayasla aya tha
03:56toh semse pahle court ne ye kaha tha
03:58kye jhoot jho phelaya gaya tha
04:00kye mandir toad ke masjid beni hai
04:01court ne saaf kaha
04:03kye hume aysa koi saboot nahi mila
04:05jis se pata chalhe
04:06kye mandir toad ke masjid beni ho
04:09اور court ne ye bhi kaha
04:10kye 1949 muretiaan galat rakhi gai
04:12court ne ye bhi kaha
04:14kye 1992 muree bhabari masjid ko illegal
04:16طریقے سے tođa gaya
04:17اور court ne ye bhi kaha
04:19kye jho log isme shamil thae
04:20unke khilaaf karawai honi chahiye
04:21to iske baad bhi kya
04:231991 ka palaces worship act
04:26اور mohan bhagwet ka wo biyan
04:28kye bhabari masjid ka jho
04:30maamla tha wo slat gya
04:31ab her masjid ke nyeche
04:32mandir kye u ڈھونna
04:33kya ye log abhi ڈھٹائi ke sath
04:36be hayaii ke sath
04:37be sharmii ke sath
04:38masjidon me mandir ڈھوننے
04:41kyanun ki kyanun ki koi inke
04:43anndar koi kisi tarah ka rahimukaram
04:45nahi hai
04:461991 ka
04:47anurag bhadoriya ka pahla
04:48pahla response leloo
04:50phera apke paas
04:51waapas nautun gaha
04:52court se bade ho gayi
04:55thicc
04:56thicc
04:57anurag bhadoriya
04:58uttar pradish ke mukhi
04:59mandiri yogi
05:00aditnaat ka
05:00kye na hai
05:01ki jinki
05:01aasthah
05:02babar
05:02aur aurangzeb
05:03me hai
05:03woh hindu
05:04aasthah
05:05kya
05:05s'mjhen
05:06ghe
05:07aap
05:08kis rup
05:09me uttar pradish
05:09ke mukhi
05:09mandiri ka
05:10iso biyan
05:10ko
05:10dhek te
05:13dhekhe
05:13mujhe
05:13lagta
05:14hai
05:14ki
05:14sbse
05:14pahalye
05:15to
05:15eek
05:16mujhe
05:17ڈilli
05:17ki
05:18bjp
05:18اور
05:20lakhanu
05:20ki bjp
05:21me
05:21thoda
05:21sa
05:21kuch
05:22hame
05:22gharwan
05:22najar
05:23aar
05:23aar
05:23aar
05:24aar
05:24to
05:24ojwikistan
05:25se
05:25dhek
05:26ke
05:26pradhan
05:27mantiri
05:27ji
05:27ko
05:27award
05:28milta
05:28hai
05:29usi
05:30ojwikistan
05:30se
05:31to
05:31mujhe
05:31lagta
05:31abawar
05:32bhi
05:32aar
05:32to
05:33is
05:34kya
05:34aar
05:35jwajwikistan
05:36se
05:36milao
05:37to
05:37nai
05:37lena
05:37chahi
05:37agar
05:38bhi
05:38uttar
05:39pradish
05:39ki
05:39bát
05:39kere
05:39aar
05:40dous
05:40ab
05:41kya
05:42uttar
05:42pradish
05:42me
05:43pravuram
05:44ke
05:44nama
05:44phe
05:45bharati
05:46janta
05:46party
05:46ab
05:46bát
05:47nai
05:47kira
05:47nai
05:47chahi
05:48chahi
05:48chahi
05:49chahi
05:50chahi
05:52chahi
06:14huwa
06:14to
06:15koon
06:15aya
06:15us
06:15ko
06:15uzagar
06:16karne
06:16ke
06:16liye
06:16us
06:17ke
06:17chahi
06:17chahi
06:17chahi
06:18chahi
06:49chahi
06:53chahi
06:54chahi
06:55chahi
06:55chahi
06:55chahi
06:55chahi
06:56chahi
06:58chahi
06:59chahi
07:00chahi
07:00chahi
07:01chahi
07:01chahi
07:01chahi
07:02chahi
07:27that's point one and point two equally significant
07:29moolana sajid rashidi raises the point that
07:33why is it don't you have any faith in the places of worship act 1991
07:41so
08:06Thank you very much.
08:32Thank you very much.
14:21You know, this is perhaps exactly the reason why this matter must be decided in courts of law.
14:29Courts of law should decide this matter. That's point one.
14:32Point two, equally important, this is a question that even Muslims must ponder.
14:38For Hindus, Mathura and Kashi are places of civilizational worship like Ayodhya.
14:43So if there is no justice from the time of Aurangzeb and the British and so many years,
14:49do Hindus don't have a right to civilizational justice in their own country, even through courts of law?
14:56And perhaps it's best for courts of law to decide.
15:00It's best for courts of law to decide why would some continue to defend the actions of invaders and their
15:08descendants?
15:09You know, we'll let viewers decide. We'll let viewers decide.
15:13I've run out of time. I want to thank our guests. I've run out of time on this part of
15:16the show.
15:16There's a very big story.

Recommended