• 3 months ago
A recent Athletic report revealed that 1 in 4 NFL players who passed away had CTE. Ted Johnson has been vocal in his experience with his brain trauma from playing football. The guys talk about what can be done to better protect players at all levels of the game.
Transcript
00:00At least one in four former NFL players has had CTE and they ended up looking at every former NFL
00:07player who died from 16 to 2016 to 21 of the brains that were donated.
00:12And so this is a very conservative number. Yeah, right. They're saying that this could be an underestimate underestimation because,
00:19you know, out of the 878 players that were there, like 643 of them did not have their brains examined.
00:25This is based on the ones that they were able because you can't diagnose CTE until you've passed away, unfortunately.
00:31So, Ted, you have worked very close in the research in this field.
00:35And I know that, you know, you have firsthand experience in helping out and dealing with the medical community when
00:41it comes to this.
00:41Yeah, no, this is a topic very near and dear to my heart. I retired because I had head trauma.
00:47I didn't really know what was wrong, why I was feeling the way I was feeling.
00:50There was not a name for it. CTE was not discovered as a neurological brain disease until 2006.
00:59Dr. Ben and Amalo did an autopsy and he found this tau protein that is basically just it's only prevalent
01:06in these these, you know, in cases where it's multiple subconcussive hits over and over and over again.
01:14And that's that's the tell the truth guy right from the Will Smith movie.
01:17Yeah. Yeah. Concussion. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
01:20Ben and Amalo. So it it's we're so relatively new in this field.
01:25I mean, if you think about it, that's only 20 over 20 years ago.
01:28So it's it's, you know, really the next big step was my buddy Chris Lewinsky at the BU Med.
01:35And they have a brain bank in which they ask people to donate brains, their brains, because they need to
01:41get, you know, study these brains so that they can help prevent it.
01:46It's like you said, for one out of they basically did an autopsy of eight, 878 brains between the years
01:542016, 2021, because I guess there was a bump in brain donations.
01:59And that largely was because of some high profile stories.
02:04Junior Junior Seau, Kenny Stabler, Gifford was was a high profile story.
02:11So more guys were donating their brains.
02:14But it's it's something that's obviously it was some players.
02:19There was a class action suit that was settled years ago.
02:23I don't know if we have our my my buddy on the line.
02:25Yeah, he is. But we we have let's bring in.
02:27So this is this is Brad.
02:29So Brad's a good friend of mine was my lawyer.
02:31He's part of a quarter point in leadership for the NFL concussion litigation.
02:35He's a candidate for executive director of NFLPA.
02:38And he's got he's obtained some of the largest results in U.S.
02:41civil litigation history on behalf of the pro athletes, cares about his players, cares about his clients.
02:45And I thought this was a good time to have him on with this study.
02:48What's going on, Brad? How you doing, bud?
02:50Thanks for having me on, guys. Good to talk to you, Ted.
02:52Good to talk to you.
02:53But I I'm assuming you've read this this new recent study that the the came out.
02:59There's great articles on it everywhere.
03:01But just what you've you've been there from the very beginning, Brad, and you were you were with me.
03:06Thank God the whole way through.
03:08Where where are we with this?
03:10Have what what are you seeing in advancements and technologies or just attitudes, if you will,
03:15when it comes to athletes and football players specifically getting getting concussed and then having to live with CTE later
03:23in life?
03:25Yeah, I mean, I think let's let's start just just by the numbers, because I think it's really shocking.
03:31When you unpack it, you guys you guys basically got it right.
03:34But there were there are about seventeen hundred NFL players, people who have played at least a game between 2016
03:41and 2021 who were deceased.
03:44And of the brains that were studied, ninety two percent of them had CTE in them, which was approximately twenty
03:51five percent of the players that were dead, deceased between those years.
03:56So you're absolutely right.
03:58Like it's it's it's it's an extremely conservative estimate.
04:01The question is, if if the total number of dead NFL players between those years, twenty five percent of them
04:07had CTE just because of what was studied, how many others are out there?
04:11And what do those numbers really look like?
04:12Like it's probably way, way higher.
04:15And and that's something that I think, you know, the good news, thanks to, you know, efforts that you personally
04:22have made and a lot of other really courageous retired players and active players have made.
04:27People are talking about this stuff more now and it's important because, you know, it's it's not only CTE, but
04:32it's it's all of the symptoms of CTE that people have in life, like dementia and early onset dementia and,
04:38you know, mood and impulsivity issues and stuff.
04:41And and, you know, the more the more people are aware of those things, you know, the more the more
04:45they can, you know, make informed choices, whether it be, you know, when to start playing football, whether to continue
04:51playing football, whether to take yourself out of certain situations and stuff.
04:54So I I think that in in the broadest sense, we're definitely headed in the right direction.
05:00There is, you know, a hell of a lot of work to be done, you know, and at some point
05:05there has to be a recognition by the league that, look, if we know that, you know, this stuff will
05:10kill you.
05:11And I hate to be so blunt, but if we know this stuff will kill you, we got to take
05:14care of these guys.
05:15We got to take care of these guys for for, you know, the entire of their lives.
05:18So so so I don't I if you don't mind me asking, I don't really know how much changed from
05:24when the whole big major lawsuit went down and the NFL had to basically admit that it had been covering
05:30things up.
05:31Like, what is the like, what have they done to make this information more available to change the game?
05:37And and and what are you going to have to do to lower this number?
05:39Like, are you going to have to change the game of football and how it's played?
05:43Well, they've done a really impressive job at lying more effectively, I think, Rich, frankly, I think that, you know,
05:51a lot of the changes that have been made, it's stunning to me when given the choice between doing the
05:57right thing and looking like they're doing the right thing.
05:59The NFL always chooses looking like they're doing the right thing.
06:01And, you know, there is there is a lot of cosmetic changes that have been made to the game, you
06:06know, things about the kickoff rule, which like I'm not even sure I can explain how it works now.
06:11You know, purportedly better helmet technology and stuff.
06:15The reality is that exposure to getting hit in the head over and over again leads to CTE.
06:21And it's as simple as that.
06:23Reducing concussion numbers and how we define concussion and all these things.
06:27They're important, very important things for a whole bunch of reasons.
06:30But it's not going to impact, you know, what happens as far as CTE goes.
06:34If you are exposed for, you know, at minimum, you're probably looking at, you know, nine seasons of football.
06:42If you're talking about high school and college before you get to the NFL, you know, the odds of you
06:47getting, you know, ultimately having the, you know, CTE protein that Ted was talking about before on your brain are
06:54very, very high.
06:55And so the question becomes, you know, what do you do about it?
06:59Number one, you tell people truth and you make sure that, you know, that everybody understands that, you know, that
07:05these are the risks.
07:05And if they choose to go forward with it, you know, they're doing it on an informed basis.
07:10But there are, you know, there are head health things that we can do that everybody can do that, you
07:14know, that can make a difference.
07:15And, you know, I think as far as, like, league-wide changes, the biggest thing is there just needs to
07:21be an acceptance of responsibility.
07:23Yeah, that would be nice, Brad, for sure.
07:27I'm curious what you think because I just think, you know, there's not many things that could maybe change the
07:34game in the form of what we're watching now other than maybe this.
07:38And I'm curious what you think is when and if there's ever new imaging technologies that are discovered, that are
07:46found, where you can detect CTE in the living, what do you think that does to the game of football
07:53or does it impact it at all?
07:56Well, you know, I don't know about that specifically impacting it.
08:00But, you know, what I will say is that, you know, the more studies that are done and the more
08:05we learn, you know, the more we can do things like and justify things like, you know, having contact be
08:14more sporadic.
08:15I mean, you know, as a guy who by no means was you, you know, I played at Duke and
08:22then at Harvard.
08:23But, you know, Ivy League football went non-contact during practice a few years ago.
08:28And, you know, the on-field quality of play is really not that different.
08:32And there are issues like, you know, offensive lineman development.
08:35If you talk to coaches around the league and stuff, they will absolutely say, you know, just not having the
08:40ability to be in, you know, shoulders and helmets like as much, you know, time per week and stuff makes
08:46a difference.
08:47But the reality is, like, people like a fast aerial game anyway.
08:51And I think that's what we've been trending towards, you know, for the past 20, maybe even 30, 40 years.
08:57And so, you know, I don't think – one thing that I think is important to emphasize is football doesn't
09:02have to end because of CTE.
09:05We just have to do certain things differently and smarter and, you know, stop looking at certain things as solutions
09:11that really aren't.
09:12You know, the biggest one that I always bring up is helmets.
09:15But, yeah, I think it's possible.
09:19Brad, it is interesting, though.
09:21I mean, can you think of another occupation, another profession that is – where it has hazards like this?
09:28I mean, where the tau protein is in the brain because of subconcussive hits.
09:35It feels like – I mean, it doesn't feel like there's another occupation that compares.
09:38And it's interesting when you think of dementia or Parkinson's or Alzheimer's or other brain diseases.
09:46There's – you don't know – you can't always prevent those.
09:51Sometimes it's just going to happen where, clearly, you can prevent yourself from ever getting CTE by never playing football.
09:59It's fascinating.
10:01Do you ever think of it that way?
10:01And do you think of another occupation that would have the risk that football does for CTE?
10:08It's a stuntman.
10:09No, we think about it –
10:09A stuntman.
10:11Well, yeah.
10:12But I think, I mean, you know, you go way back in time and, you know, the best analogy that
10:18I usually –
10:19I think it's the best analogy that I can make with CTE is you think of shipyard workers back in
10:26the 50s getting exposed to asbestos.
10:28And then they would come down with all these diseases later.
10:31And it's very, very different – excuse me, very, very similar.
10:35The difference is that, you know, 80,000 people don't go nuts screaming about, you know, asbestos.
10:41They do for football.
10:43And, you know, and I think – and the point being, like, there are really positive things that the game
10:48gives us that I know it gave to you, that it gave to me.
10:50That, you know, it's the kind of thing where, you know, obviously, you know, when you're dealing with toxic substances
10:58and, you know, workers being exposed to them, you know, it's – there's less of a – there's a lot
11:06of risk and there's a lot less benefit.
11:08Whereas with football, there are good things, you know, and there are good things about, you know, little kids getting
11:13off the couch and being active.
11:14And so, you know, it's much more of a balancing act than, you know, than other forms of, you know,
11:22really serious public health threats because it's not as simple as, well, just don't do it.
11:27But, you know, at the same time, no, there's nothing riskier than playing pro football.
11:34And there's nothing worse than you can, you know, do for brain health than, you know, have 12-plus seasons
11:40of exposure to, you know, getting hit in the head over and over again.
11:43It's just the way it is.
11:44Well, Brad, thanks for coming on with us.
11:45And more than anything, thanks for fighting the good fight along with Ted.
11:48I know that you guys are, you know, right in the middle of all of this and on the forefront.
11:52And I'm sure that there's other players in the league that thank you for all the work that you've done.
11:56So we appreciate you coming on.
11:57Brad, you're the best, man.
11:58Not all lawyers are –
11:59Thank you, guys.
12:00Yeah.
12:00Not all lawyers are like you, man.
12:01And you make it – it's a personal thing for you and all your clients appreciate it, buddy.
12:07I appreciate you, man.
12:08Well, no, I love you, man.
12:09And thank you so much.
12:10And can I – can we have one moment of levity since that was a pretty sobering topic?
12:14Bring it on.
12:15Let's get a nice little pivot here, Brad.
12:17I just thought it was – I thought it was really a cathartic thing.
12:21You know, however long it's taken the NFL to admit it has a CTE problem,
12:25Ken Laird finally admitted that salary cap isn't real.
12:29I'm sure that was a direct quote.
12:30I'm sure that was a direct quote.
12:31I know Brad's a Curtis guy.
12:33That's fine.
12:35He's definitely a P1, man.
12:37Thanks, Brad.
12:37Thanks, Brad.
12:38Appreciate it.
12:39Thanks, man.
12:40You know what?
12:41Real quick, because I know we have to break, but I just – it's the one thing about this
12:44study that is – that I think everyone is thinking about and a lot of people are fearing
12:51is let's say the science gets to the point where we realize that 70, 80% of the people
12:59who are playing are truly playing with CTE, like, which is just an awful thing to live
13:04with.
13:05Or if you can track it, Rich, in real time.
13:07Like, I think we'll get to the point with some of this AI advancement where you have a
13:10player take a hit and they know instantly he took – he had a brain issue and he's got
13:13to come out of the game.
13:14Or he's like, you know, it's week three and he's taken five hits.
13:16I think that's a game changer.
13:17I think that's a game changer.
13:18Totally.
13:18But is it a game changer in the way where these people won't get CTE anymore?
13:22Because the question that I think we're all – it's all coming towards is that if it
13:27gets uncovered that you know that 80% to 90% of these people are all playing with a
13:32form of brain damage, are you willing, as a fan, to accept a game that does not have
13:39tackling anymore?
13:40Would it be enjoyable enough to you if the return is you know that people aren't damaging
13:45their brains?
13:46Nope.
13:47And not just football, by the way.
13:48Text line is true.
13:49It's boxing.
13:49It's MMA.
13:50It's hockey.
13:50It's soccer.
13:51I mean, obviously there are high-risk jobs in the military and, you know, firefighters.
13:56We've talked all the cancer risk for first responders.
13:58So there are a lot of jobs that have risk.
14:00But this is, to your point, for our entertainment, there's a certain standard that we've come
14:05to know our whole life, you know?
14:06And I'll be honest, Rich, people know all about this CTE.
14:10I mean, it's not – this isn't a brand-new thing.
14:12And people still – it's a $23 billion industry.
14:15And I don't blame the fans.
14:17You know, I think maybe some of them watch with some guilt.
14:20But at the end of the day, what they're saying is the players that are out there playing,
14:24they know the risk.
14:25You know, before, my generation and the generation before me never knew really what the long-term
14:30impact were.
14:31We do now, so players are going in there being more educated.
14:34And they're deciding, even though they know what the risks are, that they're willing to
14:37play.
14:37So I think that's how fans probably manage it in their head.
14:41Can I ask you this?
14:42If you had the same players that are in the NFL right now, the same talent that was there,
14:46and you had a league where you weren't allowed to – like, it was not tackle.
14:50It was flag.
14:51Let's say it's like a flag football league with the same people.
14:54Would you watch that?
14:55If you couldn't have the NFL, would you watch that?
14:57I'll tell you this.
14:58You know what that game's called?
14:59It's called rugby.
14:59And I never watched rugby.
15:01Oh, no, no.
15:01Rugby's concussions all over the place.
15:02They're getting stomped on.
15:04They're getting – oh, dude, rugby is brutal.
15:06Yeah, I mean, that's – you're getting concussions all over the place.
15:09Are they making $23 billion annually to play that game?
15:13Yeah, it's a physical game.
15:14Can he just cancer play that game?
15:16Right.
15:17That's my point.
15:18Penis cancer, you mean?
15:20If you can't – if you take the helmet out of the game, it's not football.
15:25It won't be football, and no one's going to watch that.
15:27The helmet – wearing the helmet makes the game watchable.
15:32Brady's Saudi Arabian flag football league is going to take off.
15:35He and Turkey on the shake are going to be – yeah.
15:38I'm only asking that because it seems like we're on a road to that.
15:41It seems like we're on a road to where we're going to have to ask that question.
15:43The more information that comes out – like, if you truly find out that 90% of the people
15:47that are playing out there are brain damaged, and to – I mean, with – you know, like,
15:52to the point where the CTE is obviously all over, like, way more than we've ever seen.
15:58I'm wondering if that's a question that's going to be asked.
16:00And you have to say, is it still going to be entertaining if you don't have that?
16:03And, Ted, I understand what you're saying, but you know what?
16:06Listen, there's a lot of sports that were huge back in the day that aren't huge anymore.
16:10Like, I mean, I guess, like – I mean, boxing isn't as big as it was back in the day.
16:14Horse racing used to have – it used to be big, and people get injured with horse racing.
16:17Yeah, what about horse safety?
16:18But I'm just – but so you're saying if they take the helmets off and they don't tackle,
16:22then you think the NFL will still be – it's going to go the ways of boxing then.
16:26It's going to – no one's going to care.
16:27I'm not saying it will be.
16:28I'm just saying that's a question we're going to have to start asking.
16:31I think it's leading towards that right now with all this information.

Recommended