Skip to playerSkip to main content
PlayStation has responded after receiving major backlash over concerns that physical game discs could disappear by 2028.

But even if Sony reassures fans, it raises a much bigger question: What happens if the gaming industry eventually goes all digital?

In today's video, I'm breaking down PlayStation's response, discussing why so many gamers still want physical games, and exploring the alternatives available if physical media eventually disappears.

Do you still buy your games on disc, or have you already switched to digital? I'd love to hear your thoughts.

https://www.patreon.com/cw/JamesSchierer

#PlayStation #Gaming #GamingNews #PhysicalGames #PS5 #RetroGaming
Transcript
00:00PlayStation's return to social media sparks fresh backlash following digital-only announcement.
00:06After remaining silent for nearly a week following its controversial decision to phase out physical
00:11game disc, PlayStation has returned to social media, and the response from fans was overwhelmingly
00:17negative.
00:18Sony's official PlayStation account posted for the first time in six days on July 7th,
00:23sharing a promotional video for its upcoming wireless arcade fight stick.
00:27Rather than celebrating the new accessory, many gamers flooded the comments with criticism
00:32over Sony's recent announcement that future PlayStation consoles will abandon physical
00:37game disc.
00:39One of the most widely shared replies came from gaming preservation group Does It Play, which
00:44wrote, Wireless Fight Stick?
00:46More like Spineless Corpo, accusing Sony of sacrificing game ownership in favor of an all-digital future.
00:54That sentiment was echoed throughout the comment section.
00:58Thousands of users demanded the return of physical media, posted photos of their disc collections,
01:03and criticized the company for what they see as an attack on game ownership.
01:07Others questioned why Sony chose to resume posting promotional content without addressing
01:12the backlash surrounding its announcement.
01:15Within the first hour, the promotional video reportedly accumulated more than 12,000 negative
01:20comments and nearly 4,000 quote posts, with very few users defending Sony's decision.
01:27The criticism stems from Sony's announcement that it will discontinue physical game discs,
01:32beginning with future hardware.
01:33If those plans remain unchanged, the PlayStation 6 would become Sony's first digital-only home
01:39console, ending a tradition that has existed since the original PlayStation launched in 1994.
01:44The announcement has sparked a growing movement among collectors, preservation advocates, and
01:50long-time PlayStation fans.
01:51Many argue that removing physical media reduces consumer ownership, limits preservation efforts,
01:58and leaves players dependent on digital storefronts and licensing agreements.
02:03Adding fuel to the controversy is Sony's history with digital content.
02:08Critics have pointed to previous situations where purchased digital movies were removed from users'
02:13libraries after licensing agreements expired, arguing that digital purchases do not always guarantee
02:19permanent access.
02:21The backlash had also extended beyond social media.
02:24A petition launched by PNP Games CEO Jade Pierce has surpassed 160,000 signatures, with supporters
02:31urging Sony to reconsider its decision and continue offering physical editions of future PlayStation
02:37games.
02:39Some long-time PlayStation fans are now questioning whether they will purchase a PlayStation 6 at
02:44all.
02:45Instead, many say they are considering moving to PC gaming, citer greater platform flexibility,
02:51wider storefront options, and access to DRM-free games through services like GOG.
02:58Others believe Sony could still reverse course, pointing to Microsoft's decision in 2013 to abandon
03:03its original Xbox One policies after facing significant consumer backlash.
03:08At the time, Microsoft scrapped plans for mandatory online connectivity and restrictions on used games,
03:15following widespread criticism and weaker-than-expected consumer support.
03:19Whether Sony follows a similar path remains uncertain.
03:23While some fans remain hopeful that the company will reconsider, others believe PlayStation is fully committed to an all-digital
03:30future.
03:30Reports have even suggested that at least one manufacturing facility responsible for producing PlayStation
03:36game disc has already begun transitioning its production lines toward other products.
03:42But now, Sony's return to social media has done little to calm the controversy.
03:46Instead, it has reignited criticism from fans who continue to demand one thing above all else.
03:52The option to keep buying and owning their games on physical discs.
03:56I do have to say that this is a blunder, it's a mess-up by Sony.
04:06And honestly, I'm seeing a lot more backlash from what Sony is doing than when Microsoft tried this with the
04:22Xbox One original in 2013.
04:26When they tried to, you know, go all digital on the Xbox One and saying,
04:33if you want to trade games with friends, you're going to have to trade the license.
04:38And that's just, it's not just, you're not going to be able to sell your games back to GameStop.
04:43You're not going to be able to sell them to someone else, like on eBay or anything.
04:51Because the license there would be, it'd be, you know, you can't sell it to just whoever.
04:57And then that disc, and wait until the disc is sold, and then you got, that would never work.
05:04Because when you sell a game to GameStop and they sell it to someone else,
05:06you don't know who that person is unless you just happen to be in the store when it sells.
05:13But now with Sony, you know, I've seen a lot of people, I've said this for a long time,
05:21but I think it's probably, it's probably, it's probably more likely to happen now if it was ever going to
05:35happen.
05:35And that's with just a backlash.
05:38People have been canceling PlayStation Plus, as the article said.
05:43People are now reconsidering buying a PlayStation 6 at all,
05:47whether or not Grand Theft Auto 6 will be on it or not.
05:53So, that's a good thing.
05:57I used, I did, I said it before, I'll say it again.
06:00Again, in the, like 2022, 2023, I had moved away from digital, even on my Xbox One.
06:11And I was basically moving away from Xbox One games.
06:14I was going back to PlayStation, PlayStation 2, PlayStation 3.
06:19Because I have, and just basically getting more of the games that either I wanted and never completed,
06:28that I had at one time and never completed, or that I never got to play in the first place.
06:34As long as they were affordable with my budget.
06:39And, um, and most, and most, and obviously that had no effect on digital.
06:46Digital just continued business like everyday normal.
06:49And I figured, well, I'm the only one who can do it.
06:52You know, that can, I'm the only one, I can only control what I do.
06:57I can't control what other people do.
07:00Uh, but we knew this day was coming.
07:03Uh, before even PlayStation made that announcement.
07:06Um, but I do have to say, uh, one thing I was getting ready.
07:14I can play these games anytime I want.
07:17And I don't need an online connection.
07:21Um, and I'll show my disc also.
07:27Make it so you can see it.
07:29Um, this is not going as smoothly as I'd hoped, but whatever.
07:37All, you know, I can play these games, and as long as I got electricity, and the game works, and
07:44my console works, I'm good to go.
07:47Um, that's what, and that's honestly what I think I'm going to do if PlayStation does not reverse course.
07:53Because, think about it, we all know Microsoft is going to do the same thing.
07:59There's, they're going to, um, Microsoft is going to, uh, go all digital, because they wanted to do it before
08:07Sony did.
08:08And then, what's left?
08:10Nintendo?
08:12And isn't Nintendo already trying to do that with their, um, with their key cards?
08:19Now, I do want to say, some people, um, I watched RGT85's video on this, this morning.
08:27Or this afternoon, rather.
08:29Um, and I do have to disagree with him, because he was like, what does gaming look like in the
08:35past, you know, in the next five years or so?
08:38And what I have to say to that is, maybe not modern gaming, maybe not current day gaming, but I'm
08:46actually excited for retro gaming.
08:49Because if us, and a lot more people are spending their time on retro gaming, uh, we're, we're going to
08:57be going through games, or we're, uh, everyone that just chooses to go retro gaming, like, like I probably will,
09:03they're going to, uh, be playing games that they've never played before, or playing games that they love, but maybe
09:10never completed.
09:13And before anyone says, well, you know, you probably know of every game.
09:18Um, I already did it, uh, last time on Twitch, where I tried to name just 10% of the
09:24N64 library.
09:26And actually, I couldn't do it.
09:27I watched that video back.
09:28I named, um, uh, I named three different games twice.
09:33In that 29.
09:35And there's 288 N64 games.
09:39And if you say, well, a lot of them are sports games, and this goes for any console, a lot
09:44of them are sports games, so what if there are a lot of sports games?
09:48You know what, uh, at this point, I would take, uh, Major League Baseball featuring Ken Griffey Jr. on N64
09:54for a game or two, see if I could get used to the N64 controls, or, um, because I'm used
10:02to playing, uh, PlayStation 3, um, sports games.
10:08Um, you know, so, even if a lot are sports games, okay, but there's still games out there that we
10:15maybe never heard of, or maybe that we heard of, but never heard anything about, that we never got to
10:22play before.
10:23Uh, one game I'll bring up, 40 Winx, other than the title, and that it was released for N64 and
10:28PlayStation Original, I know nothing about that game.
10:31Um, so, you know, like I said, uh, there's, and, you know, maybe use your favorite, um, AI, ChatGPT, Claude,
10:41Gemini, um, to suggest these games based on whatever console you already have.
10:48You know, as many, as many, as many people that dunk on the Sega CD, there's good games on the
10:53Sega CD.
10:55So, you know, maybe that's a, you know, it all depends on what games, what console you're interested in, and
11:02what's in your budget.
11:05And if, and I don't blame anyone getting upset for digital, especially since these, uh, developers, or these console developers,
11:14anyway, that want to go digital, they don't protect you.
11:17They're not looking out for you.
11:18If you get screwed, they say, too bad, buy our next product, though.
11:23So, so, you know, I mean, that's really, you got really three options here.
11:29You can either deal with whatever direction that gaming is going in, you, if you have the money, you can
11:37go to, uh, PC gaming, or you can go retro.
11:42My laptop, they can't handle anything current, anyway.
11:46Um, it's like, um, anything, uh, with my, with my specs the way they are, I could probably run, like,
11:56something like a PS3 game from Steam, or PS3 era game from Steam.
12:02Um, um, uh, like on medium, maybe.
12:06My, maybe I could stretch it to a PS4 launch title, because the technology and specifications that would be needed
12:13to run those games between a PS3 and a PS4 launch title was not that different.
12:20But, you know, my, my laptop that I use for everything couldn't play, uh, current games anyway.
12:29So, maybe I'll, maybe, you know, maybe instead of console, maybe instead of PC, I'll go to retro.
12:36Because I do have a lot of consoles, old consoles, that still work.
12:41And, you know what, there's, like I said, there's games I never completed.
12:45There's games that, um, I wish I hadn't sold that I'd love to play again.
12:51More, really, in the first category.
12:54And, that's where I'll spend most of my gaming time.
12:57Let me know what you think.

Recommended