Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 days ago
Crowd in small, smoke-filled room breathlessly follows the Phagan slaying inquiry

Father Weeps Silently

Jurors, officials and detectives manifest intense interest in replies of witnesses

In a small, crowded and smoke-filled room at police headquarters, Coroner Donehoo on Thursday morning opened what is expected to be the final session of the jury impaneled to inquire into the death of Mary Phagan, strangled in the basement of the National Pencil Factory on April 26th.

The atmosphere was charged with tension and possibility. The investigation was visibly drawing toward its conclusion, and officials had acknowledged that new and important evidence would emerge from the day's witnesses. These factors drew a large and curious crowd.

At one end of a long table heaped with notebooks and typewriters sat Coroner Donehoo, flanked on either side by members of the jury. At the foot of the table sat the newspaper reporters and four official stenographers. The witness faced Coroner Donehoo and the jury directly, while spectators, relatives of the dead girl, and friends of the witnesses lined the walls. Every available chair in the room had been taken long before the inquest was called to order, and latecomers settled onto the window ledges.

Dorsey Takes Active Part

Among the prominent figures present were attorneys for Frank, Pinkerton and city detectives, and various county and state officials. Solicitor Hugh Dorsey sat just behind Coroner Donehoo and took an active role in shaping the examination of witnesses. Though Dorsey asked no questions directly, he conferred with the coroner on several occasions about the best approach to take with particular witnesses.

Attorney Luther Rosser occupied a seat near the coroner and followed the proceedings with close attention. He raised no objections to any questions bearing on the actions of Leo M. Frank on the day of the murder.

Ranged against the wall behind Coroner Donehoo stood Detective John Black, who heads the city investigating squad, alongside Detective Starnes and Pinkerton Detective Harry Scott. All three officers followed the examination of witnesses with careful attention. To the coroner's left sat Dr. J. W. Hurt, the county physician who examined the body, whose own testimony is awaited with considerable interest.

Father a Pathetic Figure

J. W. Coleman, father of the dead girl, stood against the wall to the coroner's right, a sorrowful and affecting presence. He kept his eyes fixed on each witness throughout their testimony, and as the grim details of the discovery of his daughter's body were recounted, his eyes filled with tears.

The jurors, all six of them, sat with their arms on the table and gave their full attention to every word spoken. Most questions came from the coroner, though jurors occasionally interrupted to ask a witness to clarify a point.
Transcript
00:00Inquest scene is dramatic in its tenseness. Atlanta, Georgian, Thursday, May 8, 1913.
00:05Crowd in small, smoke-filled room breathlessly follows the Fagan slaying inquiry. Father weeps
00:11silently. Jurors, officials, and detectives manifest intense interest in replies of witnesses.
00:16In a small, crowded, and smoke-filled room at police headquarters, Coroner Don Who on Thursday
00:21morning began what it is thought will be the last session of the jury impaneled to inquire
00:25into the death of Mary Fagan, strangled to death in the basement of the National Pencil
00:30Factory April 26. The situation was tense and pregnant with possibilities. The fact that
00:36the investigation of the case is rapidly drawing to a close, coupled with the admissions of
00:41officials that new and important evidence would develop the examination of the witnesses
00:45today, brought out a large and curious crowd. At one end of the long table, heaped with notebooks
00:52and typewriters, sat Coroner Don Who, flanked on each side by members of the jury. At the
00:58foot of the table sat the newspaper reporters and the official stenographers, four in number.
01:03Facing Coroner Don Who and the jury sat the witness. Ranged along the wall were curious
01:08spectators, relatives of the dead girl and friends of the witnesses. Long before the inquest was
01:13called, every available chair in the room was taken, and latecomers ensconced themselves
01:18on the window ledges, Dorsey takes active part. Prominent among the spectators were the attorneys
01:25for Frank, Pinkerton, and city detectives and county and state officials. Solicitor Hugh Dorsey
01:30sat just behind Coroner Don Who and took an active part in the questioning of the witnesses.
01:35While Mr. Dorsey asked no questions himself, several times he conferred with the coroner on the best
01:41manner in which to examine the witnesses. Attorney Luther Rosser also occupied a seat near the coroner
01:46and took keen interest in the proceedings of the inquest. He did not object to any of the
01:51questions asked the witnesses that had bearing on the actions of Leo M. Frank on the day of the
01:56murder. Ranged against the wall behind Coroner Don Who were Detective John Black, in charge of the
02:02city investigating squad, Detective Starnes, and Detective Harry Scott of the Pinkertons. All of
02:08the officers paid close attention to the examination of the witnesses. To the left of the coroner sat Dr.
02:14J.W. Hurt, county physician, who examined the body, and whose testimony is awaited with considerable
02:21curiosity. Father, a pathetic figure. J.W. Coleman, father of the dead girl, stood against the wall
02:27to the right of Coroner Don Who, a pathetic figure in his sorrow. Mr. Coleman evinced keen interest in
02:34what was transpiring. He kept his eyes fixed constantly on the witness who sat at the foot of
02:38the long table, and his eyes filled with tears, as the tragic details of the finding of the child's
02:44body were related. The attitudes of the individual members of the jury showed their realization of the
02:50responsibility that rests upon them. Each of the six sat with his arms on the table, paying closest
02:55attention to the statements of the witnesses. Most of the questions were asked by the coroner,
03:01but now and then a juror would interrupt to ask the witness to make some point clearer.
03:05The air of tense eagerness with which the jurors awaited the replies of the witnesses
03:09was communicated to those whose only interest in the case was the satisfaction of curiosity,
03:15crowd tense and quiet. The crowd in the room was one of the quietest that has ever attended a session
03:21of the inquest. Save for the occasional scratching of a match or the dragging of a chair across the
03:26floor, nothing was heard but the voices of the coroner and the witnesses. All of the witnesses
03:32brought in were subjected to a close examination by coroner Donahue, and all bore the ordeal well.
03:38Boots Rogers, one of the policemen who found the body, was on the stand more than an hour.
Comments

Recommended