Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 days ago
Pinkerton agency insists state holds no significant evidence beyond what has already been reported; identity of solicitor's secret investigator remains unknown

Saturday, May 10th, 1913

Investigation Presses On

Two weeks after the discovery of little Mary Phagan's body, the investigation into her death shows no sign of slowing. A large and varied force of professional, amateur, city, state, and private detectives continues to pursue the case with undiminished energy.

The Mystery Detective

The identity of Solicitor Dorsey's private investigator, whom the solicitor himself has described as among the best in the country, remains a complete mystery. Dorsey refuses to name the man, and even members of his own office claim not to know who he is.

Chief of Detectives N. A. Lanford, who has not known a twelve-hour workday since the crime was discovered, takes a relaxed view of the mysterious newcomer. His opinion is that the celebrated sleuth is nothing more than a capable and conscientious young deputy already working within the solicitor's office.

Pinkertons: The Public Already Knows Everything

Officials of the Pinkerton Detective Agency, retained by the National Pencil Company to investigate the murder, expressed satisfaction with the progress of the case Saturday. They added a striking assertion: the public is now in possession of practically every significant piece of evidence the state holds.

The Pinkertons said they were unaware of the identity of Dorsey's mystery detective.

"We welcome any assistance which the alleged detectives can give the state, for we are only interested in seeing the mystery cleared and the guilty party brought to trial. However, working with the city department, and giving it the benefit of everything we learn, we have done all that is humanly possible for detectives to do, and we are continuing the probe with the intention of leaving no stone unturned."

The agency singled out the testimony of Monteen Stover as among the most important evidence developed so far.

Gantt Interviewed; Lee Retains Counsel

Solicitor Dorsey spent most of Saturday on the investigation, meeting with city detectives throughout the morning. Among those he interviewed was J. M. Gantt, who was briefly held by detectives in the early days of the case. Gantt is said to have made a statement concerning the behavior of Superintendent Leo M. Frank when the two men encountered each other at the factory door on the afternoon of the murder, two Saturdays ago. Investigators noted Frank appeared visibly nervous at that meeting.

Newt Lee, the night watchman held by order of the coroner's jury, informed Deputy Plennie Minor on Saturday that he would no longer speak to anyone except through legal counsel.
Transcript
00:00Public now knows all facts in murder case, say detectives, Atlanta Journal, Saturday, May 10th,
00:051913, page 1, column 1. Pinkertons declare the state has no evidence of importance that hasn't
00:11been given to the newspapers. Identity of solicitor's detective, a mystery. Chief Lanford
00:16believes he is one of sheriff's capable deputies. Gant questioned, Newt Lee has lawyer. The probe
00:22into the mystery of little Mary Fagan's death two weeks ago still goes on. The small army of
00:27professional, amateur, city, state, and private detectives, which took up the chase of the
00:32murderer soon after the horrible details of the crime became known, still pursues the investigation
00:37with unabated vigor. Solicitor Dorsey's detective, heralded as the best in the world and admitted by
00:43the solicitor to be an A1 man, remains a mystery. Mr. Dorsey refuses to divulge his identity, and even
00:49the attachés of his office profess not to know his name. N. A. Lanford, chief of the city detectives,
00:55who has known not even a twelve-hour working-day law since the crime was discovered, and who has
01:00been vigorously following every tangible lead, treats the entry of Mr. Dorsey's sleuth into the
01:05limelight very lightly, and expresses an opinion that the mysterious man is no other than a very
01:10conscientious and efficient young deputy in the solicitor's office. Public knows all. Officials of
01:16the Pinkerton Agency, which has been employed to ferret out the mystery by the National Pencil
01:21Company, declare that they are well satisfied with the progress made, and add that the public
01:27is now in possession of practically all of the really important points in the state's case.
01:32They regard as highly important the testimony of Miss Monteen Stover. The Pinkertons state that
01:38the identity of the mysterious detective who has been brought into the case by solicitor Dorsey
01:42is not known to them. We welcome any assistance which the alleged detectives can give the state,
01:48for we are only interested in seeing the mystery cleared and the guilty party brought to trial.
01:53However, working with the city department and giving it the benefit of everything we learn,
01:58we have done all that is humanly possible for detectives to do, and we are continuing the
02:03probe with the intention of leaving no stone unturned. Solicitor Dorsey on Saturday again gave
02:08practically his entire time to the Fagan investigation, and interviewed during the
02:13morning many of the city detectives who are working on the case. Gant interviewed. Among the
02:18witnesses whom he saw Saturday was J.M. Gant, who for a few days was held by the detectives in
02:23connection with the case. Gant, it is said, made a statement relative to the nervousness of
02:28Superintendent L.M. Frank when he met Gant at the door of the factory Saturday afternoon two weeks ago.
02:34Newt Lee, the Negro ordered held by the coroner's jury, stated to Deputy Plenty Minor Saturday that in
02:40future he would refuse to talk to anyone except his attorney. The Negro didn't remember his lawyer's
02:45name, but it was later learned that he is being represented by Attorney Bernard L. Chapelier of
02:51609 Temple Court Building. Attorney Murray Donnell, who was first reported to be counsel for the
02:57incarcerated Negro, states that the report is a mistake. As the result of the Fagan investigation,
03:03it is probable that the city council will be asked to allow the city detectives money for
03:08reasonable expenses incurred in their investigations. The city detectives, who are working 16 hours a day
03:14on the case and who have been at the grueling work steadily for two weeks, have incurred considerable
03:19expense, which must come from their own pockets since they are allowed nothing but car fare by the
03:24city. Important witness. Monteen Stover, a 14-year-old girl of 171 South Forsyth Street, has made an affidavit
03:33declaring that she went to the office of Superintendent L. M. Frank of the National Pencil Factory at 12.05
03:39o'clock on last Memorial Day, and remained there until 12.10 o'clock without seeing any person in the
03:45building. The young girl, who is a former employee of the factory, is regarded as one of the state's most
03:51important witnesses, and her testimony will be used to help strengthen the state's case when the Fagan
03:57murder mystery is investigated by the grand jury. Mr. Frank testified at the inquest that he remained
04:03in his office from the time the stenographer, Miss Hall, left as the noon whistles blew until the arrival
04:09of Lemmy Quinn at 12.25 o'clock. He also declared that Mary Fagan entered the office about five minutes
04:15after 12 o'clock, the time Miss Stover says that she came to the office and found it empty. According
04:21to Miss
04:21Stover, she walked up the steps at 12.05 and looked at the clock, which she was accustomed to punch,
04:27and went straight to the office. There was no one in the outer office, so she went to Mr. Frank's
04:32private office and found it empty. She waited for five minutes, she says, and having heard no one in
04:37the building left. The detectives found this witness last Saturday when she returned to the factory to
04:42get the pay envelope, which she failed to get on her trip to the factory the week before. She was
04:47with
04:48her mother on this second trip, and they told of the former visit when the officers who were stationed at
04:52the door of the factory stopped them. Miss Stover is a daughter of Mrs. Homer Edmondson, a boarding
04:58housekeeper, and she is now employed as salesgirl at a local store. She worked at the pencil factory
05:03for about a year, she says. The solicitor has another unpublished affidavit in his office, which is of
05:08doubtful value in the case. Heard screams. A woman pedestrian, whose name Mr. Dorsey has not made public,
05:15testifies that she passed the pencil factory about 4.30 o'clock on Saturday, April 26th. Then she was
05:21attracted, it is said, by several shrill screams, which came apparently from the basement of the
05:26building. There were three screams in rapid succession, and then they suddenly stopped,
05:31as if the crier had been choked. This witness has been known to the police since Monday following the
05:36tragedy, for then she reported the occurrence to the officials. This is in conflict with the theory
05:41of the detectives that the girl met her death shortly after noon Saturday, county to pay bill.
05:47According to Shelby Smith, chairman of the Fulton County Board of Commissioners,
05:51that body, and not Solicitor Dorsey, is going to pay the bill for the independent investigation
05:56of the Fagan murder mystery, which is being conducted by the Solicitor General.
06:01Mr. Smith states that more than a week ago, the members of the commission agreed to stand the
06:06expense of an investigation, in order that Mr. Dorsey might not be hampered in getting to the
06:11truth of the matter. The commissioners, so Mr. Smith says, have nothing more to do with the case.
06:16They simply told Mr. Dorsey to go ahead, and don't even know who he has employed,
06:20according to the chairman. Mr. Smith will not discuss a pecuniary limit to the cost of the probe,
06:26but says that the board expects Mr. Dorsey to be conservative.
Comments

Recommended