Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 days ago
DORSEY WELCOMES AID OF BURNS AGENCY IN CLEARING UP MYSTERY

Solicitor Hugh M. Dorsey announced Saturday that his so called "greatest detective in America" would not play any further role in the Phagan investigation, and that it was extremely doubtful he would be recalled to testify at trial.

"He has finished his investigation," said the Solicitor, "and we have no further need for him. A detective is one thing and a witness is another. His investigation led us to witnesses. It is not necessary for him, or any detective, to tell the jury what a disinterested witness will tell."

Dorsey declined to say whether his decision also extended to the city, Pinkerton, and Burns detectives.

Grand Jury Convenes Wednesday

The Solicitor announced that the Grand Jury would hold a special session next Wednesday, though he indicated the Phagan case would likely not be taken up at that time. Several other matters demanded attention, and the extra session would probably be used to clear the calendar in preparation for the Friday session, at which the Phagan case was expected to be formally presented.

Dorsey also clarified remarks he made on Friday, in which he stated that Burns investigators would operate under the same conditions as the Pinkertons. He said some had wrongly taken this to mean he did not welcome the Burns agency's involvement.

Dorsey Welcomes Burns Cooperation

That was not his intention, Dorsey stated plainly. He said he would in fact welcome William Burns personally and extend every cooperation to his men, with the sole exception of sharing evidence already secured. He added that he would continue examining witnesses right up until the case was formally submitted to the Grand Jury.

Bernard L. Chappell, attorney for Newt Lee, the Negro night watchman held in connection with the case, announced Saturday morning that unless the Grand Jury acted on the Phagan matter within the coming week, he would file habeas corpus proceedings seeking his client's release.

Handwriting Clues Under Intense Examination

Using powerful microscopes, magnifying glasses, and a series of reflecting mirrors, Solicitor Dorsey and city detectives, working alongside a handwriting expert described as one of the finest in the country, are conducting a thorough examination of the written clues connected to the Phagan mystery. Officials are confident that significant developments will follow.

Dorsey declined to reveal the identity of the penmanship expert, explaining that the man had offered his services voluntarily and on the condition that his name remain undisclosed unless it became absolutely necessary to place him on the witness stand. The Solicitor affirmed, however, that leading detective agencies regarded the man's analysis as virtually infallible.

Transcript
00:00New Fagan witnesses have been found. Atlanta, Georgian, Saturday, May 17, 1913. Solicitor
00:06General Dorsey declares work of his greatest detective has been completed. Welcomes aid of
00:11Burns in clearing up mystery. Solicitor Hugh M. Dorsey said Saturday that his greatest detective
00:16in America would not figure again in the Fagan investigation, and that it was extremely doubtful
00:21whether he would be recalled to testify at the trial. He has finished his investigation, said
00:26the solicitor, and we have no further need for him. A detective is one thing and a witness is
00:30another. His investigation led us to witnesses. It is not necessary for him or any detective to tell
00:36the jury what a disinterested witness will tell. He would not say, however, whether his decision not
00:42to put the greatest in America on the witness stand would apply to the city, Pinkerton and Burns
00:48detectives. Grand Jury Meets Wednesday. The solicitor announced that the grand jury would meet next
00:53Wednesday for an extra session, but said it was hardly probable the Fagan case would be considered
00:57then. He said there were a number of cases that demanded attention, and the extra session would
01:02more than likely be called to dispose of everything on the calendar to prepare for the session Friday,
01:07when the Fagan case would more than likely be presented. Mr. Dorsey said that his interview of
01:13Friday, in which he said the Burns men would work under the same conditions as the Pinkertons,
01:18had been misconstrued by some to mean that the services of the great detective were not needed.
01:23Welcomes Burns' aid. He said that he did not intend to create that impression, when, as a matter of
01:28fact, he would welcome Mr. Burns in the case and give him every cooperation, except giving out
01:33information or evidence that had already been secured. He will continue to examine witnesses up
01:38to the day the case goes to the grand duty sick, he said. Bernard L. Chappell, attorney for the Negro,
01:44Newt Lee, said Saturday morning that unless the grand jury acted on the Fagan case next week,
01:49he would bring habeas corpus proceedings in an effort to secure his release.
01:54Pursue writing clues.
01:55With powerful microscopes, magnifying glasses, and a series of reflecting mirrors,
02:01Solicitor General Hugh M. Dorsey and the city detectives, assisted by a handwriting expert,
02:06who is said to be one of the best in the country, are minutely examining the handwriting clues in the
02:11Fagan mystery. They confidently expect important developments. Solicitor Dorsey would not disclose the
02:18identity of the expert on penmanship, because, he said, the man's services were voluntary and given
02:24with the understanding that he was not to be known unless it became absolutely necessary to place him
02:29on the witness stand. The solicitor said, however, that he was one of the best in the country, and the
02:35great detective agencies considered his tests infallible. The two notes found in the basement of the
02:41pencil factory, specimen of the handwriting of the two men held in the tower in connection with the
02:47murder, letters and notes written by the slain girl, and the handwriting on the books of the pencil
02:52factory are being subjected to rigid tests. Accurate measurements of each letter and each word,
02:58the angle of the slant informing the letters, and the formation of certain letters that experts claim
03:03no two men write alike, are some of the tests applied.
03:07Byrne's man works quietly. The Byrne's investigator who took up the case Friday morning has not yet
03:13reported to the office of the solicitor. He is quietly and systematically working out his own
03:18idea of the case after a comprehensive outline given him by Colonel Thomas B. Felder. He has succeeded
03:23so far in keeping his identity secret. Colonel Felder was confident the Byrne's agency would
03:28satisfactorily conduct and conclude the Fagan case.
03:31We will have the slayer in less than a month, said Colonel Felder. I am confident the Byrne's men
03:37will meet with every success. With Mr. Byrne's in Europe, the man he has sent to Atlanta is certainly
03:42the best detective in America. He has charge of the Byrne's work in this country and is his chief's
03:47right-hand man. Mr. Byrne's himself will be on the scene shortly after June 1st, and then I am
03:53confident the case will be cleared up beyond any shadow of a doubt. Believe Newt Lee Innocent.
03:59Officers working to solve the Fagan strangling mystery Saturday declared they were more firmly
04:04convinced that Newt Lee, the Negro night watchman, had no hand in the tragedy and that he has told
04:10all he knows. As the result of a conversation between the night watchman and two other Negro
04:15prisoners in the tower which was overheard by Deputy Sheriff Drew Liddell, the deputy shadowed Lee's
04:20cell for thirty-five minutes, while the night watchman, unconscious of the fact that an officer
04:25was secreted but a few steps away, casually discussed the great pencil factory crime with
04:31Oscar Dewberry, a Negro under sentence of death, and Jack Wright, a Negro murder suspect brought here
04:37from Gwinnett County for safekeeping. To these fellow prisoners, Lee time and again protested his
04:42innocence, and insisted that he knew nothing more of the tragedy than what he had told the officers,
04:48that he absolutely had no part in it beyond the finding of the slain girl's body in the basement.
04:53Whether this incident will figure in any way in the investigation before the grand jury has not
04:58been announced by Solicitor Dorsey, deputies try strategy. Deputy Liddell first visited the tower
05:04with Deputy Don Burdett and talked with the Negro. Lee related the same story told to detectives and
05:09to the coroner's jury. The detective then determined on a ruse. He told the Negro he would go back and
05:15talk to him again, and the second time returned with Deputy John Owens and J.L. Coogler,
05:20a court officer. When Lee had again reiterated his same story, the trio of officers left the cell.
05:27As Owens and Coogler walked away, Liddell, however, noiselessly stepped behind two big steam pipes just
05:33on the outside of the Negro's cell. The other two officers walked heavily enough to leave the
05:38impression that all three had gone. As the footsteps died away in the distance on the metallic floor,
05:44Jack Wright asked Lee,
05:46Say, why don't you tell them white folks what you know about that killing? If you know who done it,
05:50tell them. That's the best way. Lee replied without hesitation. I ain't gonna tell no lie about it. I
05:57can't help what they do with me. I ain't gonna lie. I've done told them all I know. None secured
06:03information. The Gwinnett Negro then asked Lee if he knew the girl's body was in the basement before
06:07the time he discovered it at three thirty o'clock in the morning. Good gracious, nigger, I'd tore that
06:13building down getting out of there if I'd known that body was in the basement, exclaimed the night
06:17watchman.
Comments

Recommended