Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 1 day ago
Wednesday, June 4th, 1913

Despite Gruelling Third Degree, Woman Maintains Denial of Having Told Conflicting Stories.

FACED BY HUSBAND, SHE CONTRADICTS HIM

Her Release Came After Her Attorney Had Threatened to Take Out Habeas Corpus Proceedings.

Minola McKnight, the servant girl held in the Mary Phagan case, was given her freedom early last night, and left police headquarters for her home on Pulliam street. She was not liberated, however, until the detectives had obtained her signature to an affidavit telling what she knew of Frank's actions the day of the murder.

Her husband, who was also carried to the police station at noon, was freed a short while before his wife left the prison. He was present during the third degree of four hours, under which she was placed in the afternoon. He is said to have declared, even in the presence of his wife, that she had told conflicting stories of Frank's conduct on the tragedy date.

She is reported as having denied the man's statement in whole, clinging to her first story, which corroborated Frank's story before the coroner's jury. The detectives are silent regarding her statement; in fact, more so than during any other stage of the investigation. It is believed that on her story hinges a development fully as important as any of the results previously obtained.

Charge Is Suspicion.

The charge on which she was put in prison was "suspicion." Her attorney, George Gordon, informed the authorities Tuesday afternoon that it was illegal to hold a person more than twenty-four hours on a suspicion charge, unless their charge was obviously well founded, and had threatened habeas corpus proceedings. No direct accusation could be made against the woman, and she therefore was entitled to the freedom given her at dusk.

The examination was through and exacting. It was conducted by Detective Starnes and Campbell at the order of Solicitor Dorsey, to whose office the two headquarters men have been attached throughout the Mary Phagan investigation. No one else connected with headquarters was admitted. Two strange men, however, whose identity was kept secret, were present.

After she had been quizzed to a point of exhaustion Secretary G. C. Febuary attached to Chief Lanford's office was summoned to note her settlement in full.

Statement Long One.

It was the longest statement made by the woman since her connection with the mystery. It will be used, probably in the trial. The negress was calm and composed upon emerging from the examination.

It was learned Tuesday afternoon that both James Conley and the servant girl have obtained counsel. Attorney William M. Smith, a conspicuous figure in many of the city's famous criminal trials announced that he had been retained by the negro sweeper and would represent him throughout the case.

George Gordon, a well known local attorney, has been elected to represent the negress.
Transcript
00:00Servant of Frank is liberated after long examination, Atlanta Constitution, Wednesday,
00:04June 4, 1913. Despite grueling third degree, woman maintains denial of having told conflicting
00:10stories. Faced by husband, she contradicts him. Her release came after her attorney had threatened
00:16to take out habeas corpus proceedings. Manola McKnight, the servant girl held in the Mary
00:20Fagan case, was given her freedom early last night and left police headquarters for her home
00:25on Pulliam Street. She was not liberated, however, until the detectives had obtained her signature
00:30to an affidavit telling what she knew of Frank's actions the day of the murder. Her husband,
00:35who was also carried to the police station at noon, was freed a short while before his wife
00:39left the prison. He was present during the third degree of four hours, under which she was placed
00:44in the afternoon. He is said to have declared, even in the presence of his wife, that she had
00:49told conflicting stories of Frank's conduct on the tragedy date. She is reported as having denied
00:55the man's statement in whole, clinging to her first story, which corroborated Frank's story before
01:01the coroner's jury. The detectives are silent regarding her statement. In fact, more so than
01:07during any other stage of the investigation. It is believed that on her story hinges a development
01:12fully as important as any of the results previously obtained. Charge is suspicion. The charge on which
01:18she was put in prison was suspicion. Her attorney, George Gordon, informed the authorities Tuesday
01:23afternoon that it was illegal to hold a person more than 24 hours on a suspicion charge, unless their
01:29charge was obviously well-founded, and had threatened habeas corpus proceedings. No direct
01:34accusation could be made against the woman, and she therefore was entitled to the freedom given her at
01:39dusk. The examination was through and exacting. It was conducted by Detectives Starnes and Campbell at
01:46the order of Solicitor Dorsey, to whose office the two headquarters men have been attached throughout
01:50the Mary Fagan investigation. No one else connected with headquarters was admitted. Two strange men,
01:56however, whose identity was kept secret, were present. After she had been quizzed to a point of
02:02exhaustion, Secretary G.C. Febuary, attached to Chief Lanford's office, was summoned to note her
02:07settlement in full. Statement Long One. It was the longest statement made by the woman since her
02:12connection with the mystery. It will be used, probably in the trial. The Negress was calm and
02:18composed upon emerging from the examination. It was learned Tuesday afternoon that both James
02:23Conley and the servant girl have obtained counsel. Attorney William M. Smith, a conspicuous figure in
02:29many of the city's famous criminal trials, announced that he had been retained by the Negro sweeper and
02:34would represent him throughout the case. George Gordon, a well-known local attorney, has been elected to
02:40represent the Negress. He was at police headquarters all Tuesday afternoon and sat outside the doorway
02:45leading to the room in which his client was being cross-examined. The detectives would not admit him
02:50to the interrogation. Just who is defraying the woman's expenses for counsel is not known.
02:56Attorney Smith admits, however, that Conley is employing him personally. He spent two hours Tuesday morning
03:02interviewing his client and declared to reporters his belief that the Negro was telling the truth.
03:07He was confident that he would maintain the story during trial. There was little, if any, developments
03:12in the case Tuesday. Headquarters detectives who have been investigating the crime were all summoned
03:17before the grand jury and were forced to spend their time at the courthouse. The solicitor, too,
03:22was engaged with the jury. Only Starnes and Campbell were at work on the case. Their energies were devoted
03:27to the McKnight woman's examination. Evidence is important. That some important testimony has been
03:33developed by the cross-examination of the Negress is evinced by the secrecy cloaking the nature of
03:38her statement and affidavit. Chief Lanford has declared that he is hands-off in her connection
03:43with the mystery. Solicitor General Dorsey, he says, has personally requested to be allowed full sway
03:49in investigating the woman, and the chief has granted the wish. Mr. Dorsey said to a reporter Tuesday
03:54night, I will not talk regarding the McKnight woman. Too much publicity at this stage will do
03:59inestimable injury. He emphatically refused to answer any and all questions, as did the two
04:04headquarters detectives assisting him in the case. More mystery is added to the Negress connection by
04:10the presence of Ernest H. Pickett of 295 Rawson Street and Roy L. Craven of 11 Campbell Street,
04:17both of whom assisted the detectives in subjecting her to the third degree. Pickett and Craven,
04:22immediately when the examination was over, eluded reporters at police headquarters and,
04:27when afterwards seen, refused to explain their connection with the case. Employees of Beck and
04:32Gregg. Both men are employees of the Beck and Gregg hardware concern, the head of which L.H. Beck is
04:38foreman of the grand jury which indicted Leo Frank. Significance is attached to this connection of the
04:43jury's foreman, but the veil of mystery is lifted slightly by the fact that Albert McKnight, husband
04:49of the imprisoned servant, is also a porter at the Beck and Gregg establishment. Solicitor Dorsey will not
04:54explain the nature of a big picture now locked in his office, over which he and his detectives
04:59poured last night for an hour or more. When a reporter entered his place at nightfall,
05:04Starnes and Campbell, perspiring freely, their shirts open at the throat and their coats and
05:09collars removed, were examining the mysterious picture. The reporter's view was obstructed by a
05:14sheet of paper, thrown hurriedly over the picture. Whether it is a diagram of some sort,
05:19or whether it is a clue found in the woman's home, is a matter of conjecture. The affidavit
05:24sworn by the servant girl is rumored to contain the statement that Frank arrived at his East Georgia
05:29Avenue home between one and two o'clock on the murder afternoon, and that he departed after
05:34remaining only five or ten minutes. Also it is said to state that he came home about five o'clock
05:39in
05:39the afternoon. The rest is not known.
Comments
VERDICT VOYAGER
Creator
#MurderofMaryPhagan

Recommended