Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 18 hours ago
Tuesday, June 3rd, 1913

Reported That She Is Being Held as Witness—Defense of Prisoner in the Tower Outlined.

Another arrest was made yesterday in the Phagan mystery. Minola McKnight, cook and servant in the Leo Frank household, was sent to police headquarters by Detectives Starnes and Campbell when she hysterically created a scene at Pryor and Mitchell streets, sobbing and moaning that "they were going to hang her for something she knew nothing about."

She is being held under a charge of suspicion. Chief Lanford said last night, however, that she will likely be used as a witness against her suspected employer. She has not been questioned yet by the police or detectives, but will be put through a cross-examination some time soon.

Although officials at headquarters will not talk regarding the arrest of the McKnight woman, the general impression prevails that she is being held as a material witness and that she was taken into custody because of discrepancies rumored to have been found in her statement to Solicitor Dorsey.

It is reported that she has told a number of conflicting stories, and for this reason the solicitor ordered her confinement until time of trial. The solicitor will have nothing to say on the subject.

Leo Frank's Defense.

[…] sources Monday that Frank's defense.

It was learned from responsible will be in the production of an alibi. Five witnesses, it is said, are prepared to testify that the suspect was at home by 1:30 o'clock on the day of the tragedy. They are Mrs. Frank, Miss Corinthia Hall, his mother-in-law, Mrs. Emil Selig, his father-in-law, Emil Selig and the negress who was arrested Monday.

Testimony before the coroner's inquest indicated strongly that Frank reached his home by 1:20 o'clock, and that he did not leave until 1:50. It was during this time that Conley, the sweeper, accuses him of having written the murder notes found beside Mary Phagan's body. Another contention, it is erported [sic], to be made by the defense in that the murder was committed on the first floor instead of the second, and that Conley is the guilty man.

Luther Z. Rosser, Frank's counsel, maintains his usual silence. He will give reporters no inkling of his line of defense, but neither denies nor affirms the rumor of an alibi. The defense, it is reported, will claim that Conley, made passionately insane by liquor, was in hiding on the first floor when Mary Phagan entered at noon, and that she was attacked by him as she left Frank in the office and came downstairs on her way to the street.

Many bits of evidence, it is said, will be produced to corroborate this contention. One of which is the fact, or alleged fact, that the elevator was not run on the tragic day—another, that there were no blood spots in the metal room alleyway in which Conley vows he discovered the body.
Transcript
00:00Leo Franks Cook, put under arrest, Atlanta Constitution, Tuesday, June 3, 1913, reported
00:06that she is being held as witness defense of prisoner in the tower outlined. Another arrest
00:10was made yesterday in the Fagan Mystery. Manola McKnight, Cook and servant in the Leo Frank
00:15household, was sent to police headquarters by Detectives Starnes and Campbell when she
00:20hysterically created a scene at Pryor and Mitchell Streets, sobbing and moaning that
00:24they were going to hang her for something she knew nothing about. She is being held
00:28under a charge of suspicion. Chief Lanford said last night, however, that she will likely
00:33be used as a witness against her suspected employer. She has not been questioned yet by
00:38the police or detectives, but will be put through a cross-examination sometime soon. Although
00:43officials at headquarters will not talk regarding the arrest of the McKnight woman, the general
00:47impression prevails that she is being held as a material witness, and that she was taken
00:52into custody because of discrepancies rumored to have been found in her statement to Solicitor
00:57Dorsey. It is reported that she has told a number of conflicting stories, and for this
01:02reason the Solicitor ordered her confinement until time of trial. The Solicitor will have
01:07nothing to say on the subject. Leo Frank's defense. Sources Monday, that Frank's defense.
01:12It was learned from Responsible will be in the production of an alibi. Five witnesses,
01:17it is said, are prepared to testify that the suspect was at home by 1.30 o'clock on the
01:22day
01:22of the tragedy. They are Mrs. Frank, Miss Corinthia Hall, his mother-in-law, Mrs. Emile Selig,
01:28his father-in-law, Emile Selig, and the Negress who was arrested Monday. Testimony before the
01:34coroner's inquest indicated strongly that Frank reached his home by 1.20 o'clock, and that he
01:39did not leave until 1.50. It was during this time that Conley, the sweeper, accuses him of having
01:44written the murder notes found beside Mary Fagan's body. Another contention, it is reported,
01:49to be made by the defense, and that the murder was committed on the first floor instead of the
01:54second, and that Conley is the guilty man. Luther Z. Rosser, Frank's counsel, maintains his usual
02:01silence. He will give reporters no inkling of his line of defense, but neither denies nor affirms the
02:07rumor of an alibi. The defense, it is reported, will claim that Conley, made passionately insane by
02:13liquor, was in hiding on the first floor when Mary Fagan entered at noon, and that she was attacked by
02:19him as she left Frank in the office and came downstairs on her way to the street. Many bits
02:24of evidence, it is said, will be produced to corroborate this contention, one of which is
02:29the fact, or alleged fact, that the elevator was not run on the tragic day another, that there were
02:35no blood spots in the metal room alleyway in which Conley vows he discovered the body. Also, it will be
02:41contended that there were no gunny-sacks on the second floor during Saturday with which Conley could
02:46have attempted to pack the body as he has described in his confession, use confessions against him.
02:52Conley's previous confessions will also be used against him. It will be shown how he repeatedly
02:57lied, finally to make the startling confession of Thursday night. Explanation of the blood spots on
03:03the second floor will be made, it is rumored, by testimony showing that frequently employees cut
03:09their hands and fingers, allowing the blood to drip to the floor, at the identical spots where the
03:14stains were discovered. Conley remains at police headquarters. He has expressed a strong desire
03:20to face Frank with the confession. Chief Beavers, Monday afternoon, tried to communicate with Attorney
03:26Rosser with a view of getting the counsel's permission to confront his client with the Negro
03:30and his story. Rosser was at the courthouse at the time and could not be reached. The McKnight
03:35woman, who is now held at headquarters, is reported to have given important information to solicitor
03:40Dorsey Monday morning. She was arrested just as she left the solicitor's office, where she has been
03:46subjected to a cross-examination. Dorsey will not divulge the nature of her testimony, but intimates
03:51that it is valuable. While she was being questioned, the Negress fell into hysterics, requiring several
03:57minutes to recover composure. She remained in the solicitor's presence for an hour or more, but will be
04:03questioned again today, this time by the police authorities and detectives. She is a young woman,
04:08apparently 20, and lives on Pulliam Street.
Comments
VERDICT VOYAGER
Creator
#MurderofMaryPhagan

Recommended