Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 10 months ago
Transcript
00:00What do you make of the Philadelphia matchup for a good Shanahan offense
00:04and a defense that, like you said, is kind of being held together with glue and duct tape?
00:08It was probably the best matchup the Niners could have.
00:10Because offensively, the Philadelphia Eagles, for lack of a better word, had been yuck.
00:17Now, back to Dillard and Wibbs on 95.7 The Game.
00:22It's an interesting word, yuck.
00:25And I don't think he lacked for a better word.
00:27Like, for lack of a better word, no, that was the perfect word.
00:30So you didn't lack for a better word if you wanted it to be yuck.
00:34Like, unless you wanted to use a three-letter word that's a synonym for a donkey.
00:38Like, their offense is A-blank-blank.
00:41Like, yuck.
00:43Yuck.
00:43Yeah.
00:44Yeah.
00:45Beat the Bills 13-12.
00:47Right.
00:48Yuck.
00:49Niners scored three against Seattle.
00:51Yuck.
00:52Yep.
00:53You're saying bet the under.
00:55Not necessarily.
00:56As we've learned repeatedly, every matchup is new and different.
01:02Yep.
01:02Which is the, quite frankly, it's the only reason why I'll sit here and go, sure, the Niners
01:07have a chance this weekend.
01:08I get that there's, it's very difficult to come up with a reasoned answer as to why.
01:15Like, Jordan Elliott tweaked his knee in practice today.
01:19He's been added to the injury report.
01:20He was limited.
01:21Sure.
01:21Let's do that, too.
01:23Just to start and nose tackle, no big deal.
01:25Yep.
01:25Lane Johnson for the Eagles, the right tackle, who's very important to them.
01:29He actually practiced today.
01:31Limited, but yes.
01:32He's out there.
01:32Yeah.
01:33He's out there.
01:33Trent was not out there.
01:34I mean, here's the so.
01:35Pearsall was not out there.
01:36Correct.
01:36And I think this is a good little kind of window.
01:39Cam Inman, his Twitter put it out there.
01:42Brock Purdy, remember, had the stinger.
01:44He looked fine.
01:44So don't worry about Brock.
01:46Dee Winters, Trent Williams, Ricky Pearsall, Keon White, all did not practice.
01:52Jordan Elliott tweaks the knee in warm-ups, continued to practice, but was listed as limited.
01:59And then this is also important, I think, the order in which the linebackers actually
02:04went out there to play.
02:07Kendricks and Wallow.
02:09Yep.
02:10Sounds like a law firm.
02:11I was just going to say the same thing.
02:13Good afternoon, Kendricks and Wallow.
02:14No.
02:16Please hold.
02:17Would you like Mr. Kendricks or Ms. Wallow?
02:18Please do.
02:19Please hold.
02:19Can we just hold until Fred Warner gets healthy?
02:22Kendricks and Wallow are the first ones out there.
02:25That's probably going to be your starting linebacker core.
02:27Okay.
02:29Because you're white, who just signed, was last, and Luke Gifford was limited.
02:36That's your group.
02:38And God knows what happens if one of them gets hurt when they go out there and play this weekend.
02:42I'm sorry, Mr. Wallow's not available to take your call right now.
02:45He's in the blue tent.
02:46Can I take a message?
02:47So, like, I want to be clear.
02:49If somebody just asked me straight up, do you think the Niners are going to win this weekend?
02:53No.
02:55No.
02:55I don't think they're going to win.
02:58Don't throw your hands up, Luke.
03:00Mark, you out here sounding like a hater, my brother.
03:03No, no, no.
03:03There's two.
03:04I'm not saying that they can't, though.
03:07They're allowed to.
03:08I don't think that they're going to, but they could.
03:12They could.
03:13And I think it's hard to find that sort of, like, smart reason why.
03:21Do you know what I mean?
03:22Like, if you're like, the Niners are going to win.
03:25If you go, okay, tell me why.
03:27Like, because, bang, bang, Niners gang, because I believe.
03:31Okay, great.
03:32Now, give me an action.
03:34Yeah.
03:35No, no, no.
03:35Give me a reason.
03:37It's hard.
03:38It's a bunch of injuries.
03:40It is.
03:40It's a bunch of hurt people.
03:42It's a bunch of hurt people, but, I mean, he talked about yuck as the Philly offense,
03:47and if you want to go through the numbers and just glancing at some of them,
03:50the one thing that they do really well is they don't turn the ball over.
03:53They have 15 turnovers on the year, which is great, but yards per play,
03:59they're 20-something.
04:01Yards per rush, they're in the 20s.
04:03And the one that I really like to look at is scoring percentage.
04:07What percentage of your drives end in a score?
04:10Touchdown or field goal.
04:12The Niners are No. 3, 47.6, and Philadelphia is No. 26.
04:17So they don't turn it over, and they don't score a lot,
04:21which tells me that they do a lot of punting.
04:23So this game, it feels to me like it's a matchup.
04:27Every game's a matchup, but the Eagle offense is not that great.
04:31The Niner defense, not that great.
04:33Not that great, right.
04:34And the Eagle defense, really good.
04:36The Niners offense, also really good.
04:38Pretty good.
04:38And the Eagles defense, really good, but it does have more holes than the Seahawks.
04:44I think it has attackable spots.
04:46Will they do it?
04:47Will they do it well?
04:48I don't know.
04:49You heard what Bucky's answer was, and it's always the Kyle Shanahan thing,
04:53and that's get a lead.
04:54Could they?
04:55Sure.
04:56Sure.
04:57You know what this feels like?
04:58And I don't even think it's as intense of a situation,
05:01but when the Niners went to go play the Rams on Thursday night football
05:04with Mac Jones as the quarterback,
05:07I think this right now is how a lot of Niner fans felt.
05:11It was sheepish.
05:13You're like, I mean, that'd be great if they won, but, like, come on.
05:18Mac Jones against this Rams team?
05:21Ah, it doesn't feel.
05:22I remember that week.
05:24We did not feel like they were going to win.
05:27Then we sat down, and before your seat was warm, it was 14-0.
05:31I was still on BART.
05:32There you go.
05:33I'm watching it on BART, and it's like, and I picked the Rams,
05:35and so I was like, ooh, this pick doesn't look good.
05:37And then the Rams roared back, and I'm like, okay, maybe I got this one right.
05:41And then overtime, and that game was back and forth and Seesaw,
05:44and, I mean, if you had no scoreboard and you just looked at the game,
05:48the Rams probably outplayed them,
05:50but the Niners made a couple, two or three of the huge plays in the ballgame.
05:54There you go.
05:55I think they were seven-point dogs in that one.
05:58I think you're right.
05:59And this one's four-and-a-half.
06:00Yeah, like, I do think the 49ers could win.
06:03I'm not going to sit here and tell you I've got this blueprint
06:06and this reason why the Niners are definitely going to win.
06:10But Bucky says, yuck.
06:14Baldy says, yup.
06:16And here's what I mean.
06:17He was asked yesterday on the Joes, is the Eagles the worst matchup?
06:23Yes, it's the worst matchup.
06:25It's a 4-30 game on Sunday.
06:27The crowd will be juiced out of their minds.
06:30I was just there on Sunday doing the game against Washington.
06:33There's people in the building, in the Eagles building,
06:36that were pissed that they sat all their key starters to be ready for this game.
06:41The whole offensive line rested.
06:42The receivers rested.
06:44The quarterback, the running back.
06:45You're going to get a very rested, Jalen Carter is rested.
06:49Like, he told me he's healthy.
06:51His shoulder's been bothering him all year.
06:53He had some procedures done.
06:54Jalen Phillips rested.
06:56Like, they're going to be Cooper Dejean, Quinion Mitchell.
07:00Everybody took the week off to get ready for this game.
07:02You're going to see the Eagles fully rested.
07:04I mean, I would think that Trent will be back and Pierce Hall will be back,
07:07which will help.
07:08They don't have Seattle skiing, which is good.
07:11I love Baldy, but here's why I'll disagree.
07:13I think that the Eagles are a difficult matchup.
07:18Obviously, the best matchup would be, check notes, the Carolina Panthers.
07:22I'm not saying that this is the easiest matchup,
07:24but if you ask me right now, who do the Niners have the better chance to beat,
07:28and I listed three NFC playoff teams, and you said Philadelphia, the Rams, or Seattle,
07:34I definitely would say send me to Philly.
07:36No, no thanks.
07:37And here's what, I'll explain myself, here's why.
07:40First of all, with the defense being in the situation that it's in,
07:44the Rams offense is easily the one that scares me the most.
07:47I think Matt Stafford can pick the 49ers defense in its current form apart pretty well.
07:52And he did that twice, pretty much.
07:54Correct.
07:55And now, as for Seattle, we just saw this last week.
07:57Now you would transfer it up to their building, and I just don't like either sides of the ball
08:04in this current form with the 49ers against the Seahawks.
08:08They have the better defense.
08:11The Eagles are a very good defense and difficult to attack, but attackable.
08:17I do think you can run the ball on them.
08:19And the Niners, you can.
08:20The Bears certainly did a couple of weeks ago, and Kyle loves to do that.
08:25Will the Niners have Trent?
08:26Will they do it?
08:27I can't sit here confidently and tell you they will, but I think they can.
08:31And here's the last thing I'll say, because I know you agree with Baldy.
08:35Yeah.
08:36The last thing I'll say is, I think that Baldy's immediate reasoning,
08:43if you listen to what he said, yes, this is the worst matchup.
08:46And then that's the first point that he makes.
08:48He talks about the crowd.
08:49What?
08:50And he talked about how they're all rested and they're getting healthier.
08:54Okay, that's different.
08:55That's an actual reason.
08:56Well, you can't talk about Seattle as a hostile environment
08:59and then poo-poo Baldy for saying Philadelphia is a hostile environment.
09:02I didn't say anything about Seattle being a hostile environment.
09:04You said playing up there.
09:05I just said we saw it here and now you're playing there.
09:08Yes, playing on the road is harder.
09:10Right.
09:10But I'm not like...
09:11You made it seem like, oh, and playing up there, and you're right.
09:13No, it's harder.
09:14And playing in Philadelphia is a lot harder than playing out here.
09:18No doubt.
09:18I'm not saying it's easy, but here's what I will say.
09:22And I speak from experience on this one.
09:25I have been to the link.
09:27Go ahead.
09:27Hit it.
09:28I've been to the link.
09:29I've been to the link multiple Eagle-Cowboy games.
09:33And do you want to know what my number one takeaway was?
09:35Because it was back when I was working with Bruno,
09:37and we would go out there for the Eagle-Cowboy game every year,
09:40and Bruno would tell me each time,
09:43you don't even know what it's going to be like in that link.
09:47The Eagle fans, they don't take nothing.
09:50And I know what we've all, especially this station,
09:52what we've experienced with what Bonte and Joe dealt with when they went out there.
09:56I'm not saying they're not jerks.
09:59There are a lot of jerks at the link.
10:02But they're not as scary as they think they are.
10:05They do not have the effect on the game that they think they have.
10:09It is the playoffs, and I would hope all buildings are loud.
10:14If they're not loud, you suck as a fan base.
10:18Like really bad.
10:20If you can't create excitement in a playoff game in your building,
10:24I don't even know what you're doing here.
10:26So Seattle is a louder building.
10:30There's no question Seattle is a better defense.
10:34The Philadelphia Eagles,
10:36because they are so bombastic with the way they go about it,
10:40their fan base loves to think that they've got some massive effect on the game.
10:45They don't.
10:46Whatever effect they have, I mean, it doesn't matter.
10:48Crowd noise is a factor no matter what.
10:51But it's just a road game.
10:52And the Niners have been pretty good at that.
10:55Their fan base is pretty good at getting tickets.
10:57That is not on my top three reasons why this weekend is going to be hard.
11:03It's not on my top three reasons either, but I still agree with Baldy.
11:06And you can poo-poo their defense as much as you want it to.
11:10They're not Houston.
11:12They're not Seattle.
11:13It's a good defense.
11:14Yards per play, they're No. 7 in football.
11:17And when it comes to how they do against the run,
11:20they're slightly in the middle average-wise against the pass.
11:24They're better than they are.
11:25So you look at the 49ers,
11:27and you can talk about any metric you want with the 49ers and running the ball.
11:33They don't run the ball very well.
11:34McCaffrey is averaging about three a tote,
11:37and he has a lot of them.
11:38They are 30th in the league in running the football.
11:42And so you have a Philadelphia defense that I think is really good,
11:45not elite, they're a top third, maybe a top quarter defense,
11:50and you don't blitz a lot.
11:52And you've got a Niner team that doesn't really run the ball very well
11:55and an offensive line that's coming off a shaky game
11:58against a good defensive front.
12:00And the big one that has me thinking about this is a bad matchup,
12:02and I saw this, and I'll give credit to Chase Sr.,
12:06who tweeted this out.
12:07The last four times that Shanahan faced a Fangio defense,
12:11they scored 11, 6, 15, and 9.
12:14That's correct.
12:14So that is 41 points in four games.
12:17That's an average of 10 a game.
12:19Yes.
12:1910 points is not going to win the game.
12:21Not going to do it.
12:21On Sunday.
12:22Not going to do it.
12:23Yet the crowd, whatever, and the fans are going to be all lubricated.
12:26I get it.
12:27Every fan base is going to be loud and lubricated.
12:30I look at the big matchups.
12:33Phillies D against the Niners offense,
12:35that might be somewhat of a toss-up.
12:37Phillies offense against the Niners defense,
12:39I think Phillies offense is better than the Niners defense.
12:41I don't think any matchup against the Niners defense right now is a good one.
12:44It's not great.
12:45Again, I'm not sitting here telling you the Niners are going to win.
12:48I'm telling you that the Eagles is not the worst place for them to be this weekend.
12:51I think it is the worst place to be.
12:53And it's the travel spot, and also the Philly offense,
12:57it may not be as explosive as it was last year when they won the Super Bowl,
13:01but they don't turn the ball over.
13:03Hurts doesn't throw interceptions.
13:04The Niners don't really turn the other team over anyway.
13:07They've gotten to 12-5 without getting turnovers.
13:09Correct.
13:10And what you said a little bit ago about they need the lead,
13:14they are 11-0 this year, the Niners, when they lead at halftime,
13:18and that would make them 1-5 when they don't lead at halftime.
13:22Yeah.
13:23I mean, get the lead.
13:25For sure.
13:26And that's always been a Shanahan thing.
13:28It's also a funny stat.
13:29I do love the stats about, like, if you're way ahead, you win,
13:32and if you're behind, you lose.
13:33Like, that's very true for most coaches.
13:37Right.
13:38Most teams.
13:39You're winning at half, you're usually going to win.
13:41Like, you're down to the Rams 21-0.
13:43Okay, you're going to lose that game.
13:44Almost every team is going to lose, but especially a Shanahan team,
13:47it's not built to come from behind.
13:49You're listening to 95.7 The Game, KGMZ, FM, and HD1 San Francisco,
13:52and Odyssey Sports Station in the home of the Golden State Warriors and Valkyries.
13:55Always live on the free Odyssey app.
13:57Coming to you live from the Laughing Monk Studios.
13:58We'll go live to Philly and talk to our buddy Jason Dumas in 15 minutes.
14:02We'd love to get you in on this conversation.
14:06Brian Baldy says, this is the worst matchup for the Niners.
14:10Bucky Brooks says, this is the best.
14:12Again, based on what's available.
14:15What's available, I don't think Bucky would have disagreed if we'd said,
14:18well, what about Carolina?
14:19Sure, sure, sure, sure, sure.
14:20That's better, but I do not think Philly is the worst place
14:25the 49ers could have ended up this weekend at all.
14:30I just don't think that.
14:32But what do you all think?
14:34Because I did hear a lot of that when it first came out.
14:37Like, ooh, that's not where I want to go.
14:40And in fact, by the way, 888-957-9570.
14:43We'll take your calls on that right now.
14:45There was even a debate going on in my own home.
14:47As we're watching the Niners not score against Seattle.
14:51And then we get to the next day, and you know the Niners have lost.
14:55And then the Bears are doing their thing, and the Eagles are doing their thing.
15:00And there was a debate between sons and daughter about whether or not you'd rather go to Chicago
15:07or Philly.
15:08Like, where would you, how do you weigh in on that one?
15:10I'd rather go to Chicago.
15:12You would.
15:12Yep.
15:12And I think Caleb Williams is more likely to give you one.
15:16He's more likely to, you know, not be quite ready for the moment,
15:20making his first ever playoff start.
15:22Philadelphia's defending champions.
15:24And you as a franchise, and I know a lot of these guys weren't on the team
15:27that went there when Brock got hurt, and they all weren't on the team
15:30when you went there and you rocked them a couple years ago in the regular season.
15:34I think that Philadelphia is a more hostile environment.
15:37I think Philadelphia is a better team, and even though their offense has been
15:40maybe yuck, according to some, they still have, and they do things
15:45that can give you problems.
15:47A team that doesn't rush the passer, Jalen Hurts is elusive, he can run.
15:51Saquon Barkley hasn't had a great year.
15:53You don't really stop the run very well.
15:55And they've got two wide receivers who can be big-time deep threats.
15:59And the Niners, at least once or twice a game, you break coverage.
16:03I'll tell you what.
16:04You break.
16:04I think I fell into my own recency bias when I was thinking about this
16:10over the weekend.
16:11And now maybe I'm waffling a little bit because of what is actually reality.
16:17At the time, I probably would have agreed with you.
16:21I'd rather go to Chicago.
16:22Why?
16:23Well, we just saw them.
16:24We just beat them.
16:26And I know we can score on that team.
16:28Yep.
16:28Because they did, like, every time they were unbelievable on offense against the Bears.
16:35Now, very different to go to Soldier Field and, you know, like I'll almost puppet Baldy here.
16:41Like, if you were going to Philly, it's like, ooh, the fans are going to be jacked up.
16:45They're not going to be jacked up in Chicago.
16:47They're going to be jacked up in Carolina.
16:48Well, right.
16:49Although that's a little different just because it's going to be 70 degrees and it doesn't have a vibe to it.
16:55But, yes, they'll be jacked up in Carolina like they never get to go.
16:59That's what I would actually say about a fan base.
17:02The Chicago fan base and the Carolina fan base starving.
17:06Philadelphia fan base is like, this is what we do in January.
17:09This is what we've been doing every year.
17:10But those are crazy people.
17:11Of course.
17:12So, like, even if it's a preseason game, they're going to have 71,000.
17:15I think, in general, fans overrate our effect on the game.
17:20Do you have special socks or underwear that you wear?
17:23Is there a certain spot on your couch that you sit?
17:26Like, yes, home field advantage matters.
17:30It is not more important than the X's and the O's.
17:35Or the Jimmy's and the Joe's.
17:37No doubt.
17:37And so here's where I've arrived on the Niners because of where they sit.
17:41I don't think anything is a great matchup for them right now.
17:45They're very, very hampered.
17:46But for me, this ends up sort of being the bottom line.
17:50Their defense is in such a rough spot.
17:54Just give me the worst offense to go against.
17:58The worst offense you can find to go against.
18:01That's what I want the Niners to play.
18:03Carolina, for me, would have been numero uno.
18:06Number two in the NFL right now?
18:09In the NFC, yeah.
18:09It might be Philly.
18:12It might be Philly.
18:13Like, they don't, they're not going to run away from you.
18:17Well, A.J. Brown might.
18:18Well, he's a very good player.
18:20And you don't rush the passer and you don't always cover people down the field.
18:23I get it.
18:24I get it.
18:25So, again, I'm not telling you the Niners are going to win.
18:28But I do think, listen, it's the playoffs.
18:31I'm going to give all of these teams a shot.
18:33Even the Panthers.
18:34Like, I give them a shot to go out there and have the ball bounce their way.
18:39I, for the Niners, give me the least dynamic offense you can find to play right now.
18:47And the Eagles are, they're on that list.
18:52They're on that list.
18:53They have the ability to be dynamic, but they haven't been consistently that this year.
18:57I just think about the Bears and just looking at the numbers.
19:00The Bears give up six yards per play defensively.
19:04They are tied for 29th in football in yards per play allowed.
19:07And you saw that.
19:08So, if the 49ers are going to do anything in this playoff run, they're going to have to outscore teams.
19:14And I know that that's, like, Captain Obvious because if you don't outscore the other team, you don't win.
19:18But what I mean is they're going to have to score 30 to win these games.
19:22I don't think you go to Philly and you win.
19:24You probably don't win this game 14-13.
19:26No, but I could see it 24-23.
19:29And that's about what the over-under is.
19:30The over-under is 44-1.
19:31Yeah, I could see that.
19:32So, the expectation is 24-20.
19:35Philly wins.
19:36That's the ballpark of it.
19:37And so, yeah, your defense had better be better than what they've been the majority of the year.
19:43100%.
19:43And Philadelphia's offense, while they don't have great numbers, they haven't put up a bunch of points,
19:48they have the ability to be explosive.
19:51And I don't know if the Niner defense has a great ability to change a game.
19:56Let's take some calls on this.
19:57And by the way, we want to mention real quick, we probably should have mentioned it earlier.
20:01We know on Wednesday, you are used to hearing Greg Cosell on this show.
20:05So, NFL Films, the deep breakdown, the matchups, all of that.
20:10Because it's playoff week, we decided we wanted to push that as close to the weekend as possible.
20:16So, Greg is not going to be on today, but Greg joins us Friday.
20:20Friday at 2.30, a special deep Niners-Eagles dive with Greg Cosell of NFL Films right here on Weatherton Dibs.
20:29So, we'll do that Friday instead of today.
20:31All right, let's go to Lucky in the city.
20:32Hi, Lucky.
20:33Thanks for the call.
20:34What's up?
20:36I'm not too bad, man.
20:40I was telling your man up on the line that I feel we're in the perfect spot where we need to be, man.
20:48It's sad to lose the number one seed.
20:51I get it.
20:52But we're not a number one seed team right now.
20:56We're a number six seed team.
20:58So, I would rather be in the spot where we are right now, and I predicted it to a guy who I work with.
21:06We're going to play you guys in the playoffs.
21:08And we're going to defeat you on our road to try to get back to the Super Bowl.
21:14This is my feeling, Willis.
21:16I mean, number six, we're not number one, but we're trying to get to be number one to get number six.
21:22That's a synonym.
21:23That's kind of like a symbol.
21:24So, I'll take that.
21:27Just be positive.
21:28Be patient.
21:29Let's watch it.
21:30Yeah.
21:31I mean, Lucky.
21:31Thanks, Lucky.
21:32Again, this is kind of my feeling.
21:35I even joked earlier, and there's nothing wrong with this, but when you ask people, most of the reasoning I've heard,
21:40why do you think the Niners can beat the Eagles?
21:43People go, bang, bang.
21:44Because we're going to do it.
21:46And because I believe it's like, awesome.
21:49Awesome.
21:50Just be a crazy fan.
21:52Get an old starter jacket and wear it this weekend.
21:55Do it.
21:55Do it.
21:56But that's not a reason.
21:58Like, that's not.
22:00Like, why did we beat Jalen Hurts?
22:02Because bang, bang.
22:03Because we're going to wear that red.
22:05He's a little runt.
22:07So, I mean, that's fun, but that's not going to get somebody by the offensive line this weekend.
22:16Probably not.
22:16And, you know, if you are going to beat Philadelphia, it's going to be because you were able to stop them where they are absolutely at their best,
22:24and that's in the red zone.
22:26Number one in football, Philadelphia 70.5%.
22:30And I was just looking at their touchdown log, and Jalen Hurts has five rushing touchdowns of one yard.
22:37So, they get in the red zone, and then they bibbidi-bop their way down to the one, and then they tushy-pushy him, and he scores.
22:44And so, if you're the Niners, you've got to keep them out of the red zone.
22:47Niners, by the way, are fifth in red zone efficiency of 65%.
22:51No slouches, but Philadelphia is very tough to stop once they get down there.

Recommended