• 11 months ago
On this Special Report, the focus is on the political debate surrounding the Prime Minister's engagement with the Christian community. A speaker highlights that while the PM's Christmas outreach is appreciated, there are unresolved concerns, stating, 'We have approached the Prime Minister... over this past year... for several concerns... We haven't really received any satisfactory answer.' Another panelist counters, arguing that 'It is the Hindus' liberalism that the Christian population is residing in India peacefully,' and dismisses the narrative of persecution. The discussion also touches on upcoming elections in Kerala and Tamil Nadu, allegations of 'harvesting' or conversion, and recent incidents in Raipur and Bareilly.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Dr. Williams, I'm going to begin with you. One would say that the Prime Minister has been regularly engaging with the Christian community. He values and respects them. How should this be read politically, particularly with the allegations coming in from the political opponents of the BJP, in particular the poll-bound states, the states which have a significantly high population of the Christians,
00:28and go to polls next year, that is Kerala and Tamil Nadu.
00:32You know, you started off by, first of all, let me wish all the viewers a very pleasant, safe, Merry Christmas and a wonderful year ahead.
00:41You started off by saying that the Prime Minister has been regularly engaging with the Christian community.
00:48However, I'll be honest with you, we see this engagement mostly every year around this time of the year.
00:53Otherwise, there's very little engagement. We have approached the Prime Minister, the Home Minister over this past year, over several years, for several concerns that are there for the Christian community.
01:08We haven't really received any satisfactory answer or a sit-down at any time with the Home Minister or the Prime Minister.
01:17It's only during Christmas that we're able to see. We are grateful to the Prime Minister that he acknowledges the Christian community.
01:23He does show up at church service on a Christmas day. Last year, he invited some of us for a Christmas lunch to his meal. That is wonderful.
01:33But there has been no real, there has been no credible and there has been no such interaction which has been fruitful and profitable for the Christian community.
01:45Okay. Okay. You have expressed your concerns. Let me bring in Rakesh Sina quickly on this.
01:50Rakesh Sina, you heard what one of the panelists here, Dr. Michael Williams, had to say.
01:56His concerns are that these are engagements just around the Christmas time when it is about regular year-long engagements, which is the need of the hour. That's not happening.
02:07Now, in fact, BJP and RSS have been constantly trying to outreach the Christians and this is our record that we condemn any kind of violence in any part of the world.
02:25It is not only India. We are the peace-loving people and we understand the meaning of diversities.
02:31Diversity is the essence of India. Without diversity, India can't exist. It is the Hindu's liberalism that the Christian population is residing in India peacefully and they are also engaged in convergence.
02:47It is the modesty of the Hindus. It is the modesty of the Hindus that have been acknowledged by the Parsis.
02:53There has not been absolutely one complaint by the smallest minority community, Parsis.
02:59There has not been any single complaint by the smallest minority community, that is Jews in the country.
03:05Parsis population, we all know, is very small. They have also five temples, but no complaints.
03:11So, there are disputed areas, gray areas between the Hindus and the Christians.
03:17The Christians also acknowledge that. Their literature says harvesting the Hindus.
03:21Harvesting means converting the people. We are not the cops that you will harvest.
03:27So, there are disputes in certain places.
03:29But, Mr. Sina, the concerns are that this is also timed to elections.
03:33Let me complete this sentence. Let me complete this sentence.
03:36And I am looking at the percentage of Christians in Kerala say they are roughly around 19%, 18.38% to be specific.
03:46In Tamil Nadu again, 6.13%. And that is the reason why this outreach.
03:51No. Prime Minister Narendra Modi's inclusive social philosophy has been acknowledged by the entire world.
04:02He is visiting Gurdwara. He is visiting temple. He is visiting church.
04:06It is not to appease any community. He acknowledges and he endorses.
04:10We all want that all communities should acknowledge the diversity.
04:20They should not only enjoy the diversity. They should also strengthen the diversity.
04:24You can strengthen diversity only when you acknowledge others' existence.
04:31You don't engage in converting others.
04:33If Hindus would start converting Christians and Muslims, naturally there would be some kind of crisis.
04:39At the same time, I am telling you that no violence can be acceptable.
04:43And at the same time, all Hindus are not the RSS themselves.
04:48Suppose a Hindu group has certain grievances they are doing.
04:51It is very easy for all of certain people that Prime Minister Modi is silent, RSS is engaged, BHP goons are doing that.
04:59How it is easy to call BHP workers as goons?
05:02Bhdrang Dal workers as miscreants?
05:04If there are incidents, rising incidents of attacks, I mean, recent attacks, the data shows about Raipur, Bareilly, Assam, Jabalpur, Ghaziabad, Gorakhpur, all in December of 2025.
05:26There are concerns. That should be addressed as well.
05:28When there is a Durga Puja process in Raipur as well, certain incidents take place in the country and, you know, don't create a narrative out of that.
05:45Problem is that when you create a narrative that Christians are under threat, churches are unsafe, minority are being attacked, these are the narratives which are unacceptable.
05:55Yes, certain incidents have taken place. And my problem is, suppose there is a procession by Hindus, Muslims or Christians at their religious festival, they take police permission for that.
06:07Then the police comes to protect. So, my question, I am not giving certificate to anybody, but my question is that whether you have taken the permission from the police.
06:16If you feel that you are threatened, you go...
06:18No, but why is there an assumption that there is no permission taken?
06:21You feel certain...
06:23No, I am just asking, I am just raising the question that the gentleman who is saying that they have been attacked in Bareilly because on the road, the people coming for Hanuman Chalissa.
06:35You know, all Hindus are not RSU sensible. And if certain Hindus have grievances, local grievances, don't make it an old India phenomenon.
06:46Don't say that it is some narrative which is going all over the country.
06:50Christians are 3%. They are safe because Hindus acknowledge that. Hindus acknowledge the diversities.
06:57And Prime Minister Narendra Modi's programs, policies, addressing each and every individual. Do you find that Prime Minister Narendra Modi's any program is discriminatory?
07:14The toilets are not going to the Christians? The grains are not reaching to the Christians?
07:19Right. Or any facilities which are eligible and that is not reaching to Christians?
07:26So, my problem is that when Prime Minister is going to church, they say rhetoric for the Kerala election.
07:31Christmas is here. Kerala election may be there. So, how are you connecting the Christmas to the Kerala election?
07:38Absolutely. So, let's wish you Merry Christmas and bring in Matthew Anthony now.
07:44Merry Christmas, Mr. Sina. Thank you for joining us.

Recommended