- 1 year ago
Catch up on all the latest political news from across Kent with Rob Bailey, joined by KCC councillors, Richard Streatfeild, deputy leader of the Liberal Democrats and Nigel Williams from the Conservatives.
Category
📺
TVTranscript
00:00Welcome to the Kent Politics Show on KMTV. I'm Rob Bailey. And this week we've seen
00:26Kent leaders fighting for their political careers. Later we'll talk about Sevenoaks where the
00:31district council leader has lost a vote of no confidence. But first it's a crisis for reform
00:36at Kent County Council. A leaked video showed leader Lyndon Kim-Karren swearing at her colleagues
00:42and silencing them during a fiery private meeting. Four of her councillors have since been suspended
00:47and at least five more have since lodged formal complaints about KCC's leadership.
00:53Local democracy reporter Ollie Leader has more.
00:56Four suspensions and suspicion in the halls of Sessions House.
01:01The fallout from a leaked meeting obtained by The Guardian last week that laid bare the infighting
01:08and divisions between Reform UK backbenchers and the Kent County Council leadership.
01:16Sometimes I will make a decision that might not be liked by everybody in the group. But I'm afraid
01:22you're just going to suck it up, OK? Because I am the democratically elected leader.
01:28Physically isn't time at this stage. So what we've done...
01:31I'm not asking you to run through everything. I'm just asking you...
01:35Well you are. That's exactly what you're asking me to do.
01:37There was as much fury in the aftermath as on the Zoom call. A message sent to the Reform
01:44Group by the leader Lyndon Kim-Karren slammed the people who did this as cowards with no political
01:51future. And a day later, four members of the group were stripped of the whip, including Paul
01:58Thomas, the man at the heart of the leaked call.
02:02An investigation is currently being undertaken, which I'm fully cooperating with. I expect
02:08to be exonerated from all charges, at which point I will welcome back into fold and continue
02:14the great work that I've been doing, chairing committees and working for my local residents.
02:18This is obviously a setback on a political journey. However, I would reassure the local residents
02:26that voted for me, I am still working tirelessly.
02:30But the opposition say the leader's position is now untenable.
02:34These things are shocking. I've never seen anything like it from this level of politics,
02:40particularly the content of the policies where members of her own group have not been consulted,
02:46haven't had any input in the policy that's come forward. And it's not just the Reform
02:51Group that's having to suck it up, it's the whole county.
02:54There are rumours that a motion to dismiss Lyndon Kim-Karren as leader could be on the table,
03:01or even potentially defections.
03:03Well, I would say to you, or simply say to you, that it's very early days at the moment.
03:09Obviously, contacts have been made. I would be foolish to say otherwise. But at the moment,
03:16no decisions have been reached or made.
03:18Six months on from the May elections, the sunshine for Reform UK at KCC has disappeared.
03:25And with a budget to set in the coming months, it's not going to clear up any time soon.
03:32Ollie Leda in Maidstone.
03:35We invited Reform onto the show, but they've declined. But here with me are two councillors
03:40who won't be muted for the next half an hour, KCC and Sevenoaks Conservative Nigel Williams
03:45and Richard Strepfield, the Liberal Democrat Deputy Leader at Kent County Council.
03:49Thank you both for joining us.
03:51Richard, we heard from you in the video there as well.
03:54If Reform were here today, they might well say that this was a private meeting,
03:58a place where loose tongues are expected, a place where members should be able to butt heads
04:04a little bit. Is there a storm in a teacup element to this?
04:08No, it's unprofessional. And it's how you behave when you think no one else is looking
04:14that really are the most important aspects of leadership.
04:17And to be swearing at your own members, to be ignoring their views on key policy platforms
04:27and then to be kind of, to sack them without having had a proper investigation
04:36all shows incredibly weak leadership. And I don't think Lyndon's position is tenable anymore.
04:42Andrew, you're Conservative. We know that the Conservative has had its own issues
04:46with dirty laundry being aired in public over the last few years.
04:49Give us some insight. I mean, does that look completely unfamiliar to you,
04:52the footage we've seen now? Or have you been in meetings like that yourself?
04:55No, I've got to say I've been in many meetings in my life. I've never been in one like that.
05:00And I'd have a lot to say if I was, if I was treated like that as well.
05:04But I think it's borne out of frustration by the reform representatives.
05:13They've obviously got their seats. They won and worked hard for their seats.
05:18And you'd expect, or they'd expect to have some say in how things are formed at the KCC.
05:24They've got a big majority. And I think they didn't expect to be dictated to from above.
05:29I mean, it's not just Lyndon. It's Nigel Farage. He's very dictatorial.
05:36What he says goes, and it goes passed down the line to them.
05:40And I think there's a lot of frustration about this sort of dictatorship at the top,
05:45where people have worked hard to get into power and want to make a contribution and can't.
05:50This is an interesting moment for reform anyway,
05:53obviously gearing up towards their first budget at Kent County Council,
05:56which is the big political set piece.
05:59And obviously central to the, when being elected,
06:01was the promises they made about council tax, about spending and about cuts.
06:06Is this a distraction that they don't need?
06:09Well, I think it's borne off of that problem.
06:11Because you hear in the video, Lyndon and Kim Caron saying,
06:14we want to be able to not put council tax up by 5%.
06:19If we can do that, we'll have made good on our promise.
06:21And already they've got cabinet members coming out saying they are going to put it up by 5%.
06:26They are going to break the promises they made.
06:29They can't find the cuts.
06:30The Dolge team has come forward to us to ask whether we've got any ideas
06:34that they can use for efficiencies at Kent County Council.
06:37It is the most ridiculous situation.
06:40And it's borne of people who didn't know what they were doing before they arrived at the county hall
06:45and have discovered it's not as the way they thought it was.
06:49There aren't those kind of pots of money just swilling around the county
06:52that they can use to cut taxes or to increase services.
06:56And they are completely at sixes and sevens about how they're going to deal with it.
07:00You've said you don't think her position is tenable,
07:03which obviously leads possible vote of no confidence, possible change of leadership.
07:08But for the people of Kent who are relying on Kent County Council
07:11to deliver a good council tax offer, good services at the right cost,
07:15is this the right time for reform to be looking for a new leader?
07:17Well, she's shown that she can't lead her group in a coherent fashion
07:22and she can't keep the promises that they made at the election.
07:25So it is up to the reform group.
07:27There are mechanisms at the county to have a motion to dismiss
07:31that only require five signatures to be able to bring that motion forward.
07:36But if we were to put that motion forward, it would be a whipped vote.
07:40I can count as well as you can and we'd lose.
07:42But for reform to be saying, yes, this is the leader that we really want,
07:47this person who's going to be delivering for the people of Kent,
07:50I mean, that claim looks ridiculous now.
07:52We've seen news coming out since this about the Pledge of Allegiance
07:55that all of the reform councillors are being asked to sign up to.
07:58What do you make of that? Is that meaningful?
08:01It's very 1984-ish, isn't it?
08:03I'll get back to the dictator syndrome of the party.
08:07No, it's not useful.
08:09People should be free to say what they feel,
08:12at least behind closed doors,
08:13and they shouldn't face that level of wrath from the leader, from Lyndon.
08:18Although, as I keep saying, she gets it from above.
08:22It's a fairly undemocratic party, it would seem.
08:25And what they've forgotten about, we all serve the people.
08:29We're elected by the people to work hard and serve them.
08:32They've got a very large sideshow going on.
08:35They're obviously not concentrating on the people.
08:38They're not concentrating on what they are democratically elected to do.
08:42Their budget is all smoke and mirrors.
08:45They really don't have the quality of individuals
08:46with the knowledge to push a budget or even create a budget.
08:51And you rest assured, council tax will go up to the max.
08:56Obviously, you know, the Conservative group knows better than anyone
08:59what that financial situation is.
09:00You were in charge of it for a very long period of time
09:03until reform took over.
09:04I mean, what are those big issues?
09:07Where are the spending pressures, do you think,
09:09that reform needs to be looking at?
09:10Well, adults' care is the big one.
09:13It takes about 70% of the budget.
09:15It's enormous.
09:16And a lot of juggling has to be done.
09:18Then you've got Senn.
09:19You've got home-to-school issues for Senn children.
09:23It's very, very, very difficult.
09:25There's no money around or there's very little money around.
09:27So we've all, I mean, the Conservatives, with the help of the Lib Dems,
09:31you know, worked hard last year to get it right.
09:35And what the reform group are doing now is just smoke and mirrors.
09:40They're using what we all created last year,
09:43the savings and the sensible decisions,
09:45and saying it's theirs, it's not theirs.
09:48And they're saying it's new.
09:49It's not new.
09:51There's a very good piece by Andrew Kennedy,
09:54a Conservative at KCC.
09:56If you can get hold of it,
09:57he debunks every single one of those claims.
10:00So, yeah, it's real smoke and mirrors.
10:02And that's dangerous for KCC and anyone, actually.
10:07It's particularly adult social care.
10:09That's where the cost growth is.
10:11It's a demographic issue that we have with an ageing population.
10:14People aren't living any longer than they used to.
10:16In fact, life expectancy has gone down,
10:19but we have a much, much bigger, over 65 population
10:22who are living with lots of different issues
10:25and needing a more complex level of care.
10:30They have higher levels of needs,
10:31and that costs a lot more money.
10:33And that's really difficult.
10:34I mean, one of the things I always like to say
10:37is that when reform first came in,
10:39they wrote to the Labour government
10:40to extend migrant care visas,
10:43which was completely against their national policy
10:47because they realised that
10:48unless we had more migrants in Kent
10:50looking after our elderly people,
10:53we weren't going to be able to look after them at all.
10:55And so reform have broken so many promises
10:58on council tax,
10:59on what they're going to do for immigration,
11:00what they're going to do by way of local government reform.
11:05They're just...
11:06Yeah, it's a kind of chaotic situation.
11:08They were in way over their head.
11:09Nigel, very quickly as we end,
11:11do you expect to see defections?
11:14Yes.
11:15I mean, we would expect...
11:17I mean, both parties would expect...
11:19The natural party to come back to, I guess,
11:21is Conservative,
11:22because we're more to the right.
11:24We've had a few people talk to us already.
11:27We'll be quite careful who we accept back, obviously.
11:30We don't want any loose cannons rolling around.
11:33But, yeah, we expect a few...
11:37You know, not a lot, probably,
11:39but it's...
11:40You know, they've just got to get on to do their job.
11:42We'll be very, very soon
11:44talking about Sevenoaks District Council
11:45and a vote of no confidence there.
11:47Stay with us.
14:50Welcome back to the Kent Politics Show on KMTV.
15:06And next tonight, Sevenoaks Council leader Roddy Hogarth admits he's considering his future
15:11after losing a vote.
15:12After losing a no confidence vote.
15:13He lost overall control of the council back in May when nine councillors left the Tories
15:18to form the West Kent independence.
15:20It leaves the Conservatives as a minority administration and now with a weakened leader.
15:25But what does that mean for public services in Sevenoaks?
15:28Local democracy reporter Oli Leder found out.
15:31Knives out in Sevenoaks as darkness descended on the district council, where inside the Conservative
15:38leader faced a vote of no confidence that could determine his political future.
15:44The extraordinary meeting was brought forward by the West Kent independence, who had previously
15:50left the ruling Tory group as a minority in power when they split over the summer.
15:57It's not something we wish to do.
15:59There was so much division within the group and the wrong decisions were being made by
16:04the leader at that stage.
16:06We're not proud to be here.
16:08We've done what we felt we had to do in order to progress things with the limited time that
16:12we've got left on Sevenoaks District Council in order to deliver the legacy projects that
16:17we need to do for our residents.
16:18And we're very much standing in this independent group for our residents and our communities.
16:22So yeah, it didn't bring us any joy at all.
16:24We are very pleased with the result that's come through.
16:26But as you can see, there's no joy in our faces.
16:29The Conservative leader says he tried negotiating with the wikis.
16:33But despite a last-minute deal being offered, the vote went ahead, with the Liberal Democrats
16:40helping carry the motion 24 votes to 15.
16:45Had no stake in the personal and very bitter personal rivalries which we saw played out tonight
16:51in public.
16:52They've been going on in private for a long time, clearly.
16:55And that has done immense damage to the council.
16:57I think what we've said tonight is that needs to stop.
17:00We need to get beyond that.
17:02The poison of the past needs to be replaced by some sort of progress for the future.
17:07And we will play our part in that to the extent that we possibly can after tonight's events.
17:12All eyes will now be on Roddy Hogarth.
17:15After all, how long can he really go on as leader after losing the confidence of the council?
17:23I'll certainly be considering my position as a responsible leader would.
17:28But to be honest, this was a party political set of votes, which if the numbers are here
17:36this evening, regrettably there were quite a few people who were unable to be here due
17:41to serious illness and prior arrangements because of the short notice of this.
17:46So actually I don't take the overall result to be particularly serious.
17:51But with the district council set to be abolished in the coming years, there was also a general
17:57feeling in the room that their evenings could be better spent helping residents rather than
18:04on party politics.
18:05Olly Leader in Sevenoaks.
18:08Still with me are Nigel Williams and Richard Stretfield, both of whom sit on Sevenoaks District Council.
18:15Nigel, you're obviously as a Conservative, that's your leader we've just heard from.
18:19A sense of deja vu here a little bit.
18:21He's trying to brush off that vote of no confidence to an extent.
18:25Can he do that?
18:26Or is his position tenable at this point?
18:28Well, he can't brush it off because it happened.
18:30He was right in what he said.
18:33Nine of our group were missing, some quite seriously in the hospital.
18:37And obviously the Liberal Democrats joined the breakaway group.
18:41But that's their job.
18:42Their opposition, their job is to oppose.
18:44So I don't blame him at all for that.
18:47Is his position tenable?
18:50He is a gentleman.
18:52I mean, this is all very personal against the breakaways.
18:55The breakaways have a personal thing against him.
18:58He beat Julia Thornton twice for the leadership, which is quite strange.
19:05He then tries to get it by the back door, if you like.
19:09But he thinks of the people.
19:12He thinks of his constituents.
19:14So within the next week, he'll think deeply about it.
19:19And, you know, I don't know what way it's going to go.
19:22But he is a gentleman.
19:24And if he wants to step down, he will.
19:28And if he feels that's the way forward, you know, we've got to serve the people.
19:33This is another sideshow, you know, which we don't want.
19:37We have to serve the people.
19:38We've got, you know, the plan 2042, which is for 17,000 houses in 15 years,
19:45which is my portfolio I have to look after.
19:47And we have land east of the high street where we're trying to develop,
19:51with the town council and the Lib Dems and our independents,
19:54you know, a town centre for the future, which we can be proud of.
19:59So, yeah, I think he will reconsider his position.
20:02I don't know which way he'll go.
20:04But he's, as I say, a gentleman.
20:06And he'll do what's best for Sevenoaks.
20:08For now, Richard, that leaves Sevenoaks with a minority administration,
20:11with a leader whose authority is in question.
20:14Does that serve the people of Sevenoaks well?
20:16No, it doesn't.
20:17Nigel's laid out very well that the challenges that are ahead of us,
20:20we've got a big issue with the local plan.
20:22We've got a reorganisation of our waste disposal services
20:25because we don't recycle half the amount of waste
20:28that we're supposed to.
20:30We've got a huge issue with land east of High Street being developed.
20:34And we've got a leader who is in office but he's not in power
20:38because he can't command the confidence of the chamber.
20:41It's that politics ultimately is a very simple game.
20:44You need the votes to be able to put your business
20:47through the chamber and the council.
20:50And he doesn't have that confidence.
20:53Nigel, does that mean effectively he has to resign?
20:57Well, as Richard says, it is a numbers game.
21:01If he doesn't have to, but if he does, then I think
21:05the whole crux of the matter was a lot of the breakaways
21:09didn't really get on with Roddy or didn't like his management style.
21:13So do we have to now move forward with a different leader?
21:16Maybe so.
21:17And do those West Kent independents then come back into the fold?
21:21Yeah, I think we talked to them all the time.
21:24I talked to them a couple of days ago.
21:27They're naturally conservatives.
21:29So we're disappointed in what they did.
21:31But yeah, I think they'll...
21:33I don't think they'll come back as conservatives into the group.
21:37But, you know, they are conservatives, so we'll work with them.
21:40And the indications are...
21:41I mean, there's some very good people in their group.
21:43There's some very good people all over the council.
21:46Lib Dems, Independent, everyone.
21:47Some very good minds there.
21:48So we've all got to work together.
21:50They will come back and cooperate.
21:53You know, it is a numbers game, as Richard says.
21:56So we've got to get all that stuff through.
21:58What you're hearing is some very wishful thinking going on.
22:02Because if he is a true conservative, he would have respect for our traditions.
22:07And by convention, if you lose a vote of no confidence, you resign.
22:12And that is because he has shown that he is not the person who can bring the chamber or a majority of the chamber together and then get his business through the council.
22:24What we are looking for is a plan from the largest party who are still the conservatives as to how they want to govern Sevenoaks over the course of the next two years.
22:35But it's quite clear that Mr Hogarth cannot be the person to do it.
22:39You want to come back on that?
22:40It's behind closed doors at the moment and not the way you like reform.
22:45It's all very polite.
22:47Yeah, we have a plan.
22:48You'll find out what that plan is very, very shortly.
22:52But I reiterate that everyone's got to stop this nonsense and start working for the people who elected us.
22:59We've got a lot of work to do.
23:01And our job is to serve the people, not argue amongst ourselves.
23:04You say, not like reform, that it's more polite.
23:06But of course, to an awful lot of people out there watching this,
23:09they'll see one party at Kent County Council having internal squabbles that distract them from their duties.
23:14They'll see another party at district level doing the same.
23:17One of the big narratives over the last couple of years in politics has been the rise of apathy and the sense that politicians aren't really reflecting the needs of the people.
23:27They're more interested in their own ideological squabbles.
23:30Do you think that at the moment Kent is falling into that trap?
23:34I think maybe the KCC, but I don't think the SDC.
23:37I mean, we get on quite well.
23:39This is obviously a large bump in the road.
23:43But I think everyone's aware nothing's suffered yet and we won't let it suffer.
23:47We've got to get on with the job.
23:48That's why I say we've got to sort this out quickly and get working for the people.
23:52You saw on the screen earlier on that a lot of the public came in with their placards and I'm hearing that all over the Sevenoaks area.
24:01What is all this?
24:03Come on, guys.
24:04We elected you to do a job.
24:06Do it.
24:07Nigel's trying to downplay the bump in the road.
24:09The plain facts are that the plan coming forward to build all of these houses is currently being opposed all the way by our Conservative Member of Parliament in Sevenoaks.
24:22So we've got a Conservative plan coming forward being opposed by a Conservative Member of Parliament.
24:27That is a ridiculous situation to be in.
24:30And it's one that can only do damage to the credibility of the Conservative Party.
24:37And the only people I think in Sevenoaks who have a plan to go forward in a more united way are the Liberal Democrats.
24:43I don't agree.
24:44Laura Trott we're talking about.
24:45She is a great Greenbelt advocate as we know.
24:49What she's trying to do is minimise the damage to the Greenbelt.
24:54We're 93% Greenbelt in Sevenoaks.
24:56I want to minimise as portfolio holder the damage to Greenbelt.
24:59You've made lots of it Greybelt.
25:01Well it's Greybelt because that's an invention by the Labour government.
25:04You know it's a very subjective story.
25:08It's Greenbelt.
25:10So we've got to get on with it.
25:12But to bring Laura in she naturally tries to protect the Greenbelt.
25:15What will happen we have to we're going through consultation now.
25:18Regulation 18.
25:20Let's see what comes at the end of that.
25:22It's not nothing's written in stone.
25:24We're going to just do our best to get this through.
25:27Well this will go through.
25:28But do our best to mitigate the damage to the Greenbelt as we get it through.
25:31It's a bit of a ticking clock here for all councils in Kent isn't there.
25:34Because you're trying to make a strategic plan for the future of Sevenoaks.
25:37Knowing that Sevenoaks council won't exist.
25:39And that a new authority might eventually have the opportunity to revise and look again at those plans.
25:43Have we got time for a distraction about leadership when those decisions need to be made?
25:48No we don't.
25:49So that's why in a very few days we'll have a resolution absolutely.
25:55Too little too late.
25:56The plan going forward we had a chance to adhere to the principles that we set out.
26:02Nigel gave us some reassurances that there would be a fair distribution of houses across the district.
26:08There would be services.
26:09The Greenbelt would be protected.
26:11And none of those things have happened in the plan that's been brought forward.
26:14And therefore it makes it very difficult for members to come together to support what's currently on the table.
26:21Infrastructure is the centre of this plan.
26:24And that's what's happened in the past.
26:26There's never been any infrastructure.
26:27I want infrastructure to come in at the beginning and during the building of 2042.
26:36I don't want it as an afterthought.
26:39So let's get on with our job and get it done for the people here.
26:42That's all we've got time for tonight here at the Kent Politics Show.
26:45Thank you to both of my guests for coming in.
26:47Stay tuned because Kent Tonight is coming up and we'll be back next week.