00:00I'm Annie Kreicher, nuclear engineer and physicist.
00:03Let's answer some questions from the internet.
00:05This is nuclear physics support.
00:11The Trading Chick asks, WTF is nuclear energy?
00:15Nuclear energy is energy that's released from the nucleus of the atom.
00:19Unlike other forms of energy that we know and love, where it's rearranging chemical bonds or
00:24electrons, this is directly coming from the nucleus.
00:26And the way that that happens is by splitting the nucleus apart or combining two nuclei together.
00:33That energy is released through Einstein's equation, E equals mc squared.
00:38So that's energy equals mass times the speed of light squared.
00:42And when you have a small reduction in mass, that translates to a huge amount of emitted energy.
00:49Cauliflower Nice asks, Wait, didn't scientists finally get more energy out of nuclear fusion
00:54than they put in? How did they do that?
00:56Yes, that's exactly right.
00:57In 2022, we finally generated more energy from the fusion
01:01than energy that was required to make the fusion in the first place.
01:05The way that we did that was at the National Ignition Facility.
01:08We shined the biggest laser in the world.
01:11It's actually 192 individual laser beams, all coming into the end of a hollow cylinder
01:17about the size of a pencil eraser.
01:19Those laser beams hit the can itself and that creates a 3 million degree x-ray oven.
01:24This tiny little capsule that is suspended in the center of the can with a very thin tent holds our
01:31deuterium-tritium fuel for fusion.
01:33When we make this 3 million degree x-ray oven, it heats up the outside of that capsule material,
01:39which is carbon in the center of the can, that blows up that carbon, expands it outward.
01:44And just like a rocket, when the rocket fuel goes down, the rocket goes up.
01:47When we explode out that material, it squeezes and compresses the fuel inside
01:52from about the size of a BB down to half the width of a human hair.
01:56So this little tiny miniature star is being created and we hold it together for about the time it takes
02:01light to travel one inch.
02:03So it's a very, very intense power for a brief moment in time.
02:07What I mean by a miniature star is we're making it so hot and so dense that it actually exceeds
02:13sun-like conditions.
02:15So we're five times hotter than the center of the sun and two times higher pressure.
02:20So the major challenge here is getting the plasma hot enough and fast enough before it tries to cool itself
02:27off,
02:28so that you can create the conditions for self-sustaining ignition and burn,
02:33where the fusion reactions actually heat the plasma and that's what gives you your yield.
02:38If you don't have self-heating of the plasma, you could never have the biggest laser in the world
02:42to heat all the fuel to fusion conditions on its own. You need that self-heating.
02:47So for the first time, the thing that made this experiment unique is we ignited the core of that fusion
02:53plasma,
02:53like igniting a match, and then it sat there and burned up the rest of the fuel in the experiment
02:58and enabled us to generate more energy from the fusion than it took to make the fusion plasma.
03:05MB Gelman asks,
03:06My wife is trying to figure out how to use an Instapot and I'm pretty sure that's what caused Chernobyl.
03:11While not exactly true, it actually is an interesting analog.
03:14Both systems heat water under high pressure. An Instapot heats water electrically.
03:20A nuclear reactor heats water through neutron deposition.
03:23The difference is at Chernobyl, it was a neutron temperature spike that caused a runaway reaction,
03:30additional heating, and that generated a lot of steam which blew the reactor lid off and spread radioactive waste.
03:35Another example is Fukushima, and this is when the core gets so hot it actually melts,
03:40and so this can happen in a fission reactor. It actually cannot happen in a fusion reactor,
03:45which is another advantage of fusion energy.
03:48Star Chode asks,
03:49Iron Man uses an arc reactor for power. We have already invented nuclear reactors.
03:53Why can't we just make them smaller?
03:55Well, as much as I love Iron Man and wish that I myself could fly,
03:59the fusion arc reactor in Iron Man is fictitional.
04:03The major challenge with fusion reactors is that you need large amounts of driver energy
04:08to put enough of that energy into a very small space that you can create these fusion conditions,
04:13and you could never do that in a small enough space that would fit on a human body.
04:18On top of that, there's all the other things of the system that need to be included,
04:22like cooling the reactor parts and also shielding. So you wouldn't want a nuclear reaction to happen
04:29that close to your chest. It would destroy your body.
04:33Zai Mazza asks,
04:34When they finally crack nuclear fusion, how will they convert that energy into electricity?
04:39Don't tell me it's just going to be boiling water again.
04:42Well, I hate to break it to you, that's exactly what we're going to do.
04:45So a few things need to happen first though, before we take that result and scale it to commercial fusion
04:50energy.
04:51You have to scale the whole system bigger, you have to make parts of the system more efficient,
04:56and you need to do it continuously over and over and over again. It's a pulsed system.
05:00But once you do that, and you have continuous fusion energy production,
05:05what you do is you actually take the neutrons that come out of that fusion reaction,
05:09and you use those neutrons to heat materials. So you boil water,
05:13and that is exactly how we're generating electricity. It's the same way that current
05:18nuclear fission reactors generate electricity. There is also a market for high temperature heat,
05:24which lets you bypass that electrical energy production. But that is how we produce energy.
05:29So what we're going to do here when we have continuous fusion energy generation,
05:33is we're going to capture the neutrons that come out of the fusion reaction,
05:38which carry most of the energy from that fusion reaction away, 17.6 MeV.
05:44We capture that energy and we use it to boil water, the steam turbine, and that's how we generate our
05:49electricity.
05:50Gomi Panda wants to know, what exactly does it mean for something to be radioactive?
05:55When a nucleus is unstable, it wants to release energy and become stable. So it can release energy
06:01by emitting alpha particles, gamma, beta particles. It wants to emit that energy as radiation and become
06:08stable, and that's what it means when it's radioactive. So in nuclear reactors, some of the materials that surround
06:14the core can become radioactive. When particles hit those materials, they become excited and then they
06:20decay energy away. Radium is naturally radioactive. Radon, which can exist in some people's basements,
06:27is radioactive, emits radiation. There's also radioactive waste that's generated from nuclear reactors,
06:33which is radioactive like forms of uranium and its products. Tomlensdown asks,
06:38what is the difference between nuclear fusion and fission? Nuclear fusion is squeezing together
06:43two atoms to get them to fuse and create energy, and nuclear fission is splitting the atom apart to
06:49create energy. In both cases, this generates energy because the products weigh slightly less than what
06:55goes into them, and that mass is converted to energy through Einstein's equation E equals mc squared.
07:01The missing mass in the products, what you end up with, is directly converted into energy. So fission has been
07:08around for many decades. It was actually first discovered in 1938, and this actually fed into the
07:14idea that you could use this as an extreme source for the fission bomb during the Manhattan Project.
07:20It's actually quite easy to get fission to happen. You just send in a neutron and you need enough
07:25critical mass so that you can start this chain reaction. Fusion, on the other hand, just had its
07:30breakthrough moment not too long ago in 2022, where we finally generated more energy out from fusion than it
07:37took to create fusion conditions. Ian Lasko asks, what makes fusion energy so difficult to produce and
07:43sustain compared to fission? Fusion energy is so difficult to produce because you have two atoms, both
07:49positively charged, and to get them close enough where the strong nuclear force takes over, you need to get them
07:55going at high speed and be very close together. So that requires extreme temperatures and densities, more hot than the
08:02center of the sun, and higher pressures than the center of the sun. There's many different ways scientists
08:07have tried to create these plasmas and confine them for long enough, which is also a major challenge. One
08:13is with large high-powered magnets, so like a magnetic bottle, and the other main approach is inertial
08:18confinement fusion, where you're confining this little hot plasma with its own inertia for a brief moment in
08:25time. And that's the approach that we took at the NIF, where we're making a tiny little star from the
08:30fusion
08:30plasma in the center of a can here, and holding it together with its own inertia for a brief moment
08:36in time. So each different confinement method has its own set of challenges, and we're continuing to
08:41explore all the different methods. From the Explain Like I'm 5 subreddit, how can we make something hotter
08:47than the sun? So the way that we get our plasma or our miniature star hotter than the center of
08:52the sun
08:52is through energy density. We're squeezing and compressing fusion fuel down to tiny, tiny volumes.
08:59We're doing this extremely rapidly with a lot of energy. So we're using a high-powered laser to come
09:06in here, create a three million degree x-ray oven by hitting a can. Then that oven heats up the
09:12outside
09:13of a carbon capsule that sits in the center of the can. That capsule explodes material out just like a
09:19rocket, and that squeezes and compresses the fusion fuel down to these very hot, dense conditions. On top of
09:27that, we actually need the fusion reactions to heat the plasma itself. So without the fusion reactions
09:34self-heating, we won't get to these crazy hot, dense conditions. We actually need to get hotter than the
09:41center of the sun and higher pressure because we don't have the sun's massive gravity behind us. The sun
09:46also has the same process of fusion, a different reaction, but it fuses light elements to generate
09:53energy. It's huge and massive and billions of years of confinement, and that helps the reactions happen
10:00even at a slow rate. But that's why you don't need the extreme temperature and density that we need here
10:06on Earth. If we can't get to higher temperatures and higher densities, we can't get enough fusion
10:11to occur before it blows itself apart. Omar Khak asks, how is plasma created? Plasma is created when
10:19you're heating material to high enough temperatures that you can actually rip electrons off of the
10:24atoms, and that's how you're creating a plasma. There's a lot of different ways to create plasmas,
10:28and actually plasmas are all around us. So plasmas are in neon tubes, for example. The way that we
10:35create plasmas in fusion systems is by dumping laser energy in very quickly into a material.
10:42Janice Cantspell asks, why are bananas radioactive? Well, bananas are radioactive because they contain
10:48an isotope of potassium that is radioactive and decays. It's a very tiny amount of radiation that's
10:54emitted. It's such a tiny amount of radiation that's emitted that it's inconsequential to human
11:00life. It's extremely safe. Nairobi Trending asks, how does uranium enrichment happen and total time
11:07taken? So uranium-235, it's an isotope of uranium. It's what's mostly used in our nuclear fission
11:15reactors. It's naturally occurring in small fractions where U-238 is more abundant. We try to separate
11:23238 from the 235 so you can concentrate the amount of 235 into your fission fuel. And the way they
11:31do
11:31this is because these two isotopes have slightly different mass because one has three more neutrons
11:37on it. You can attach them to gas and spin them around in a centrifuge so some stick further to
11:44the
11:44wall and you can separate them out that way. TheRealHogRida asks, explain to me the difference between
11:50something as a nuclear reactor and something like a nuclear weapon. How are they different and how
11:56are they the same? Well a nuclear weapon releases huge amounts of energy in a very short amount of
12:02time whereas a nuclear reactor releases much much less energy and power but continuously over time for
12:08power generation. The other difference between a nuclear fusion reactor and a weapon is that you can
12:14only get a tiny fraction of the fuel to ignition and fusion conditions with our traditional ways of
12:20doing it here on earth. And so you want all the fuel in the system to burn all at once.
12:25There is no
12:26chance of a runaway fusion event or explosion because you can't get the amount of fuel that's in a nuclear
12:32weapon to those fusion conditions in a reactor. Question from eggflip1020. Question from not a nuclear physicist.
12:41How possible is it to use nuclear reactor powered engines for space travel? So we already have versions of
12:49using nuclear energy in space. We have radioactive decay which heats material and convert that to
12:56electricity. We've also tested using fission reactors in space, small fission reactors. They pose a lot of
13:03challenges because of shielding, cooling, weight, cost, safety. How can you cool that reactor system? How can you
13:11shield the crew from the radioactivity that's happening in that reactor system? So far we have not been able to
13:18scale down a fusion reactor for space conditions. In terms of nuclear fusion, the challenge there is
13:24the scale of the reactor required to generate nuclear fusion in the first place and that poses a situation
13:31where there's too much mass on your spaceship. So in terms of nuclear fission, some of these things were
13:36ground tested, small fission reactors, kind of like the ones that we put on submarines. There you actually have
13:42advantage of the water cooling the system. In terms of a fusion reactor in space, it's just conceptual and
13:48theoretical, experimental at this point. Currently there's no way to generate fusion on a spacecraft
13:54that's light enough where you can shield the crew from the intense radiation. Dear Mothika asks,
14:00WTF are quarks? So they make up the protons and neutrons and ultimately for nuclear fusion in the laboratory or
14:08fission. It's about how those protons and neutrons come together and react with the material around it.
14:14So it is the building blocks of the building blocks of our nuclear systems.
14:18Panic Salt Pork asks, what is the deal with the Hadron Collider? Why is it considered dangerous by some
14:23people? Well, the Large Hadron Collider in Switzerland is a large machine that accelerates protons at extreme
14:30speeds close to the speed of light and smashes them together. And some people are afraid of this because they
14:36think what can happen when that occurs is something like a black hole. That's so much energy in a small
14:42space. Can this create a black hole? Well, on relative terms, it's actually less energy than some of our cosmic
14:49rays hitting Earth. So really it's not dangerous at all. It's a great facility where many important
14:55scientific discoveries have been made, such as a Higgs boson, which tells us important things about
15:01building blocks of matter, such as how does electrons have mass, and also lets us study the building
15:07blocks of life, including quarks. Tommy's Lawyer asks, how much of Christopher Nolan's Oppenheimer movie
15:15was accurate versus exaggerated and fake? This movie was extremely fun for me to watch. Most of the history
15:21was actually accurate. They exaggerated some of the bits, but one of the parts that stood out to me
15:26personally was how Oppenheimer felt right before the big test. So right before the Trinity test,
15:32he made a comment, this is hard on your heart. He was stressed about a lot of things, it going
15:38well,
15:38it creating a thermonuclear burn throughout the atmosphere. All these things weighed heavy in his
15:44heart. Every time we do a fusion experiment at the lab, I have the same exact feeling. One of the
15:50fears
15:50leading up to the Trinity test was that we would ignite thermonuclear burn in the atmosphere, getting
15:56nitrogens to fuse and burn throughout the atmosphere. And although this was an actual concern, it was
16:03sensationalized in the movie. So you have a lot of tests before the actual experiment happens. All these
16:09people are coming together, working together, trying to make this thing happen. So much effort, so many
16:14years. Everybody wants their part of the system to be exactly right, so it actually works. And you're
16:19sitting there waiting for a moment in time when it'll either work or it won't. It's very suspenseful,
16:25exciting, but also hard on your heart, as Oppenheimer puts it. Okay, next question from Berzik.
16:32How do you build a laser? Do you put fire in a tube? Well, laser actually stands for light
16:37amplification by stimulated emission of radiation. To put that simply, what you're doing here is you're
16:43taking a big slab of glass, you're exciting this glass up to an excited state so that you can send
16:50a
16:50little tiny laser beam in and all the photons that are excited come down, join that laser beam that
16:56comes in, and amplifies it significantly so you can get the power that you need on the short time
17:02scale that you need. So here's a comment from Elon Musk. The sun is an enormous free fusion reactor
17:08in the sky. It's super dumb to make tiny fusion reactors on Earth. Elon Musk is right. The fusion
17:14reactor in the sky is amazing, but we can't capture all of that energy all at once on Earth. We
17:21still need
17:21other sources of clean energy to power the world's needs. And another nice thing about fusion power
17:27and nuclear power is the sun doesn't have to be shining, and also we don't have to cover the entire
17:32world in solar panels. The world needs as many sources of clean energy as possible. These aren't in
17:38competition with one another, but complementary. Those are all the questions for today. Hope you learned
17:43something. Thanks for watching.