• 15 hours ago
Nuclear engineer and physicist Annie Kritcher joins WIRED to answer the internet’s burning questions about nuclear physics. What is nuclear energy? Why are bananas radioactive? Why can’t we make smaller nuclear reactors, like Iron Man’s arc reactor? Answers to these questions and many more await on Nuclear Physics Support.

Category

🤖
Tech
Transcript
00:00I'm Annie Kreicher, nuclear engineer and physicist.
00:03Let's answer some questions from the internet.
00:05This is nuclear physics support.
00:11The Trading Chick asks, WTF is nuclear energy?
00:15Nuclear energy is energy that's released from the nucleus of the atom.
00:19Unlike other forms of energy that we know and love, where it's rearranging chemical bonds or
00:24electrons, this is directly coming from the nucleus.
00:26And the way that that happens is by splitting the nucleus apart or combining two nuclei together.
00:33That energy is released through Einstein's equation, E equals mc squared.
00:38So that's energy equals mass times the speed of light squared.
00:42And when you have a small reduction in mass, that translates to a huge amount of emitted energy.
00:49Cauliflower Nice asks, Wait, didn't scientists finally get more energy out of nuclear fusion
00:54than they put in? How did they do that?
00:56Yes, that's exactly right.
00:57In 2022, we finally generated more energy from the fusion
01:01than energy that was required to make the fusion in the first place.
01:05The way that we did that was at the National Ignition Facility.
01:08We shined the biggest laser in the world.
01:11It's actually 192 individual laser beams, all coming into the end of a hollow cylinder
01:17about the size of a pencil eraser.
01:19Those laser beams hit the can itself and that creates a 3 million degree x-ray oven.
01:24This tiny little capsule that is suspended in the center of the can with a very thin tent holds our
01:31deuterium-tritium fuel for fusion.
01:33When we make this 3 million degree x-ray oven, it heats up the outside of that capsule material,
01:39which is carbon in the center of the can, that blows up that carbon, expands it outward.
01:44And just like a rocket, when the rocket fuel goes down, the rocket goes up.
01:47When we explode out that material, it squeezes and compresses the fuel inside
01:52from about the size of a BB down to half the width of a human hair.
01:56So this little tiny miniature star is being created and we hold it together for about the time it takes
02:01light to travel one inch.
02:03So it's a very, very intense power for a brief moment in time.
02:07What I mean by a miniature star is we're making it so hot and so dense that it actually exceeds
02:13sun-like conditions.
02:15So we're five times hotter than the center of the sun and two times higher pressure.
02:20So the major challenge here is getting the plasma hot enough and fast enough before it tries to cool itself
02:27off,
02:28so that you can create the conditions for self-sustaining ignition and burn,
02:33where the fusion reactions actually heat the plasma and that's what gives you your yield.
02:38If you don't have self-heating of the plasma, you could never have the biggest laser in the world
02:42to heat all the fuel to fusion conditions on its own. You need that self-heating.
02:47So for the first time, the thing that made this experiment unique is we ignited the core of that fusion
02:53plasma,
02:53like igniting a match, and then it sat there and burned up the rest of the fuel in the experiment
02:58and enabled us to generate more energy from the fusion than it took to make the fusion plasma.
03:05MB Gelman asks,
03:06My wife is trying to figure out how to use an Instapot and I'm pretty sure that's what caused Chernobyl.
03:11While not exactly true, it actually is an interesting analog.
03:14Both systems heat water under high pressure. An Instapot heats water electrically.
03:20A nuclear reactor heats water through neutron deposition.
03:23The difference is at Chernobyl, it was a neutron temperature spike that caused a runaway reaction,
03:30additional heating, and that generated a lot of steam which blew the reactor lid off and spread radioactive waste.
03:35Another example is Fukushima, and this is when the core gets so hot it actually melts,
03:40and so this can happen in a fission reactor. It actually cannot happen in a fusion reactor,
03:45which is another advantage of fusion energy.
03:48Star Chode asks,
03:49Iron Man uses an arc reactor for power. We have already invented nuclear reactors.
03:53Why can't we just make them smaller?
03:55Well, as much as I love Iron Man and wish that I myself could fly,
03:59the fusion arc reactor in Iron Man is fictitional.
04:03The major challenge with fusion reactors is that you need large amounts of driver energy
04:08to put enough of that energy into a very small space that you can create these fusion conditions,
04:13and you could never do that in a small enough space that would fit on a human body.
04:18On top of that, there's all the other things of the system that need to be included,
04:22like cooling the reactor parts and also shielding. So you wouldn't want a nuclear reaction to happen
04:29that close to your chest. It would destroy your body.
04:33Zai Mazza asks,
04:34When they finally crack nuclear fusion, how will they convert that energy into electricity?
04:39Don't tell me it's just going to be boiling water again.
04:42Well, I hate to break it to you, that's exactly what we're going to do.
04:45So a few things need to happen first though, before we take that result and scale it to commercial fusion
04:50energy.
04:51You have to scale the whole system bigger, you have to make parts of the system more efficient,
04:56and you need to do it continuously over and over and over again. It's a pulsed system.
05:00But once you do that, and you have continuous fusion energy production,
05:05what you do is you actually take the neutrons that come out of that fusion reaction,
05:09and you use those neutrons to heat materials. So you boil water,
05:13and that is exactly how we're generating electricity. It's the same way that current
05:18nuclear fission reactors generate electricity. There is also a market for high temperature heat,
05:24which lets you bypass that electrical energy production. But that is how we produce energy.
05:29So what we're going to do here when we have continuous fusion energy generation,
05:33is we're going to capture the neutrons that come out of the fusion reaction,
05:38which carry most of the energy from that fusion reaction away, 17.6 MeV.
05:44We capture that energy and we use it to boil water, the steam turbine, and that's how we generate our
05:49electricity.
05:50Gomi Panda wants to know, what exactly does it mean for something to be radioactive?
05:55When a nucleus is unstable, it wants to release energy and become stable. So it can release energy
06:01by emitting alpha particles, gamma, beta particles. It wants to emit that energy as radiation and become
06:08stable, and that's what it means when it's radioactive. So in nuclear reactors, some of the materials that surround
06:14the core can become radioactive. When particles hit those materials, they become excited and then they
06:20decay energy away. Radium is naturally radioactive. Radon, which can exist in some people's basements,
06:27is radioactive, emits radiation. There's also radioactive waste that's generated from nuclear reactors,
06:33which is radioactive like forms of uranium and its products. Tomlensdown asks,
06:38what is the difference between nuclear fusion and fission? Nuclear fusion is squeezing together
06:43two atoms to get them to fuse and create energy, and nuclear fission is splitting the atom apart to
06:49create energy. In both cases, this generates energy because the products weigh slightly less than what
06:55goes into them, and that mass is converted to energy through Einstein's equation E equals mc squared.
07:01The missing mass in the products, what you end up with, is directly converted into energy. So fission has been
07:08around for many decades. It was actually first discovered in 1938, and this actually fed into the
07:14idea that you could use this as an extreme source for the fission bomb during the Manhattan Project.
07:20It's actually quite easy to get fission to happen. You just send in a neutron and you need enough
07:25critical mass so that you can start this chain reaction. Fusion, on the other hand, just had its
07:30breakthrough moment not too long ago in 2022, where we finally generated more energy out from fusion than it
07:37took to create fusion conditions. Ian Lasko asks, what makes fusion energy so difficult to produce and
07:43sustain compared to fission? Fusion energy is so difficult to produce because you have two atoms, both
07:49positively charged, and to get them close enough where the strong nuclear force takes over, you need to get them
07:55going at high speed and be very close together. So that requires extreme temperatures and densities, more hot than the
08:02center of the sun, and higher pressures than the center of the sun. There's many different ways scientists
08:07have tried to create these plasmas and confine them for long enough, which is also a major challenge. One
08:13is with large high-powered magnets, so like a magnetic bottle, and the other main approach is inertial
08:18confinement fusion, where you're confining this little hot plasma with its own inertia for a brief moment in
08:25time. And that's the approach that we took at the NIF, where we're making a tiny little star from the
08:30fusion
08:30plasma in the center of a can here, and holding it together with its own inertia for a brief moment
08:36in time. So each different confinement method has its own set of challenges, and we're continuing to
08:41explore all the different methods. From the Explain Like I'm 5 subreddit, how can we make something hotter
08:47than the sun? So the way that we get our plasma or our miniature star hotter than the center of
08:52the sun
08:52is through energy density. We're squeezing and compressing fusion fuel down to tiny, tiny volumes.
08:59We're doing this extremely rapidly with a lot of energy. So we're using a high-powered laser to come
09:06in here, create a three million degree x-ray oven by hitting a can. Then that oven heats up the
09:12outside
09:13of a carbon capsule that sits in the center of the can. That capsule explodes material out just like a
09:19rocket, and that squeezes and compresses the fusion fuel down to these very hot, dense conditions. On top of
09:27that, we actually need the fusion reactions to heat the plasma itself. So without the fusion reactions
09:34self-heating, we won't get to these crazy hot, dense conditions. We actually need to get hotter than the
09:41center of the sun and higher pressure because we don't have the sun's massive gravity behind us. The sun
09:46also has the same process of fusion, a different reaction, but it fuses light elements to generate
09:53energy. It's huge and massive and billions of years of confinement, and that helps the reactions happen
10:00even at a slow rate. But that's why you don't need the extreme temperature and density that we need here
10:06on Earth. If we can't get to higher temperatures and higher densities, we can't get enough fusion
10:11to occur before it blows itself apart. Omar Khak asks, how is plasma created? Plasma is created when
10:19you're heating material to high enough temperatures that you can actually rip electrons off of the
10:24atoms, and that's how you're creating a plasma. There's a lot of different ways to create plasmas,
10:28and actually plasmas are all around us. So plasmas are in neon tubes, for example. The way that we
10:35create plasmas in fusion systems is by dumping laser energy in very quickly into a material.
10:42Janice Cantspell asks, why are bananas radioactive? Well, bananas are radioactive because they contain
10:48an isotope of potassium that is radioactive and decays. It's a very tiny amount of radiation that's
10:54emitted. It's such a tiny amount of radiation that's emitted that it's inconsequential to human
11:00life. It's extremely safe. Nairobi Trending asks, how does uranium enrichment happen and total time
11:07taken? So uranium-235, it's an isotope of uranium. It's what's mostly used in our nuclear fission
11:15reactors. It's naturally occurring in small fractions where U-238 is more abundant. We try to separate
11:23238 from the 235 so you can concentrate the amount of 235 into your fission fuel. And the way they
11:31do
11:31this is because these two isotopes have slightly different mass because one has three more neutrons
11:37on it. You can attach them to gas and spin them around in a centrifuge so some stick further to
11:44the
11:44wall and you can separate them out that way. TheRealHogRida asks, explain to me the difference between
11:50something as a nuclear reactor and something like a nuclear weapon. How are they different and how
11:56are they the same? Well a nuclear weapon releases huge amounts of energy in a very short amount of
12:02time whereas a nuclear reactor releases much much less energy and power but continuously over time for
12:08power generation. The other difference between a nuclear fusion reactor and a weapon is that you can
12:14only get a tiny fraction of the fuel to ignition and fusion conditions with our traditional ways of
12:20doing it here on earth. And so you want all the fuel in the system to burn all at once.
12:25There is no
12:26chance of a runaway fusion event or explosion because you can't get the amount of fuel that's in a nuclear
12:32weapon to those fusion conditions in a reactor. Question from eggflip1020. Question from not a nuclear physicist.
12:41How possible is it to use nuclear reactor powered engines for space travel? So we already have versions of
12:49using nuclear energy in space. We have radioactive decay which heats material and convert that to
12:56electricity. We've also tested using fission reactors in space, small fission reactors. They pose a lot of
13:03challenges because of shielding, cooling, weight, cost, safety. How can you cool that reactor system? How can you
13:11shield the crew from the radioactivity that's happening in that reactor system? So far we have not been able to
13:18scale down a fusion reactor for space conditions. In terms of nuclear fusion, the challenge there is
13:24the scale of the reactor required to generate nuclear fusion in the first place and that poses a situation
13:31where there's too much mass on your spaceship. So in terms of nuclear fission, some of these things were
13:36ground tested, small fission reactors, kind of like the ones that we put on submarines. There you actually have
13:42advantage of the water cooling the system. In terms of a fusion reactor in space, it's just conceptual and
13:48theoretical, experimental at this point. Currently there's no way to generate fusion on a spacecraft
13:54that's light enough where you can shield the crew from the intense radiation. Dear Mothika asks,
14:00WTF are quarks? So they make up the protons and neutrons and ultimately for nuclear fusion in the laboratory or
14:08fission. It's about how those protons and neutrons come together and react with the material around it.
14:14So it is the building blocks of the building blocks of our nuclear systems.
14:18Panic Salt Pork asks, what is the deal with the Hadron Collider? Why is it considered dangerous by some
14:23people? Well, the Large Hadron Collider in Switzerland is a large machine that accelerates protons at extreme
14:30speeds close to the speed of light and smashes them together. And some people are afraid of this because they
14:36think what can happen when that occurs is something like a black hole. That's so much energy in a small
14:42space. Can this create a black hole? Well, on relative terms, it's actually less energy than some of our cosmic
14:49rays hitting Earth. So really it's not dangerous at all. It's a great facility where many important
14:55scientific discoveries have been made, such as a Higgs boson, which tells us important things about
15:01building blocks of matter, such as how does electrons have mass, and also lets us study the building
15:07blocks of life, including quarks. Tommy's Lawyer asks, how much of Christopher Nolan's Oppenheimer movie
15:15was accurate versus exaggerated and fake? This movie was extremely fun for me to watch. Most of the history
15:21was actually accurate. They exaggerated some of the bits, but one of the parts that stood out to me
15:26personally was how Oppenheimer felt right before the big test. So right before the Trinity test,
15:32he made a comment, this is hard on your heart. He was stressed about a lot of things, it going
15:38well,
15:38it creating a thermonuclear burn throughout the atmosphere. All these things weighed heavy in his
15:44heart. Every time we do a fusion experiment at the lab, I have the same exact feeling. One of the
15:50fears
15:50leading up to the Trinity test was that we would ignite thermonuclear burn in the atmosphere, getting
15:56nitrogens to fuse and burn throughout the atmosphere. And although this was an actual concern, it was
16:03sensationalized in the movie. So you have a lot of tests before the actual experiment happens. All these
16:09people are coming together, working together, trying to make this thing happen. So much effort, so many
16:14years. Everybody wants their part of the system to be exactly right, so it actually works. And you're
16:19sitting there waiting for a moment in time when it'll either work or it won't. It's very suspenseful,
16:25exciting, but also hard on your heart, as Oppenheimer puts it. Okay, next question from Berzik.
16:32How do you build a laser? Do you put fire in a tube? Well, laser actually stands for light
16:37amplification by stimulated emission of radiation. To put that simply, what you're doing here is you're
16:43taking a big slab of glass, you're exciting this glass up to an excited state so that you can send
16:50a
16:50little tiny laser beam in and all the photons that are excited come down, join that laser beam that
16:56comes in, and amplifies it significantly so you can get the power that you need on the short time
17:02scale that you need. So here's a comment from Elon Musk. The sun is an enormous free fusion reactor
17:08in the sky. It's super dumb to make tiny fusion reactors on Earth. Elon Musk is right. The fusion
17:14reactor in the sky is amazing, but we can't capture all of that energy all at once on Earth. We
17:21still need
17:21other sources of clean energy to power the world's needs. And another nice thing about fusion power
17:27and nuclear power is the sun doesn't have to be shining, and also we don't have to cover the entire
17:32world in solar panels. The world needs as many sources of clean energy as possible. These aren't in
17:38competition with one another, but complementary. Those are all the questions for today. Hope you learned
17:43something. Thanks for watching.

Recommended