- il y a 34 minutes
Watch Marketplace, Season 54 Episode 7 on Dailymotion (2026).
Catégorie
📺
TVTranscription
00:00Sous-titrage Société Radio-Canada
00:30It's very, very addicting.
00:32But before you hit that buy button, find out what to watch for.
00:36They're enticing you to keep browsing, keep shopping
00:38until they finally hit on something that you just can't say no to.
00:42It does feel like deceptive marketing.
00:44You won't shop the same after you watch your Marketplace.
00:54We're putting online shopping to the test.
00:58These are so cool.
00:58Every time I wear them.
00:59Seriously, I get compliments.
01:01I'm a browser and a buyer.
01:03Full disclosure, some of my fave online finds are from Timu.
01:08This is my Timu haul, including this shirt.
01:12Timu, Timu, Timu.
01:14Some more Timu.
01:16But we want to know, is spending more online by design?
01:20That's why we're tracking some popular brands.
01:23Timu, Amazon, Shein, and Walmart.
01:27Checking them out each week for about a month to see if they're steering us to buy more.
01:34And we're meeting up with four shoppers to do a real-time spot check.
01:39Welcome, everyone.
01:41Nice to see you all here.
01:42Tricia, what do you like about going on Shein?
01:48Mainly the price.
01:50Bronwyn's got Amazon.
01:51Ritu's watching Walmart.
01:53I love Walmart.
01:54I go there in person all the time.
01:56It's one of my comfort stores, to be honest.
01:58And Ian's testing Timu.
02:00When you're in the moment and in that shopping experience, do you end up buying more than you expected?
02:08Yeah, I end up looking at things that I didn't initially go on to look at.
02:12I think especially, like, when someone's having a sale, like, that definitely gets me.
02:17So how often do you hit that buy button?
02:20Quite often.
02:21I'm too familiar with add to cart.
02:25You're all here because you're going to be shopping on some sites and some apps
02:29because we want to discover whether they're designed to deceive.
02:34Are you ready to do that?
02:36Yeah, definitely.
02:37We've invited an expert to give us the play-by-play.
02:41Ryan Fritsch is a lawyer with the Law Commission of Ontario
02:45and an advocate for updating consumer protection laws.
02:48Hey, Ryan.
02:49Hi there, Asha. How are you today?
02:51What sneaky tactics are you going to be watching out for as they browse these sites and apps?
02:58Techniques that are used to try and trick consumers into making choices that may not be in their interest.
03:02Those design tricks are called dark patterns.
03:06What's spooky about it is that people don't even know what's happening.
03:09And so their choices as shoppers are being guided invisibly.
03:14Our testers go live.
03:15What I want you to do now is add an item to your cart and see if you can check
03:20out.
03:20Almost instantly, Ryan spots a red flag.
03:24It's asking me to sign in.
03:26It's also asking me to sign in.
03:27Yeah, same.
03:28Even with Walmart, I need to create an account.
03:31They're forcing you to sign up and sign in to the website.
03:34Right.
03:34And that's called a coercive dark pattern because what they want you to do is they want you to shop
03:38on their website,
03:39but they want you to do it on their terms, not your terms.
03:42Next up, Ryan points out a pressure tactic to watch for when you're shopping.
03:47You often see these in-stock notices, that they have low stock or only one left.
03:52Might be true, might not.
03:53Well, in our tracking test, we see these leggings on Amazon.
03:58Only one left.
03:59Cute pair of leggings, yeah?
04:01There's only one pair left.
04:04We were shopping.
04:05Mm-hmm.
04:06And so we bought it, as you can see.
04:09So about eight minutes later, guys, we were able to buy a second pair of leggings.
04:15I don't think that's fair at all.
04:17Like, I take those counts seriously, usually.
04:20So the fact that they said there's only one pair left, like, it might actually drive you to go ahead
04:25and buy it
04:25without doing checks, without comparing with other websites, without doing your due diligence.
04:30Bronwyn, you're our Amazon shopper.
04:33What do you think?
04:33If I see, yeah, like a reminder that there's only one in stock, then I'm more likely to purchase it
04:40immediately instead of comparing.
04:42Now, the second pair, we were told, would come a little bit later.
04:47Should that matter, though?
04:49I think that if they're telling you there's only one left, that should be an honest statement.
04:53Otherwise, they are deceiving consumers.
04:56It's unfair.
04:57The next trick we track?
04:59A timer trap.
05:00We see a 24-hour countdown for these coupons on Shein.
05:04But when time's up, the exact same coupons are back with a new 24-hour timer.
05:11Say what?
05:12These can be used to create a sense of urgency in the consumer, that if they don't pull the trigger
05:18now, they'll miss out on a deal forever.
05:21The consumer is being induced to make an impulsive purchase that may not be in their best interest when other
05:27better options might be available to them.
05:28They're playing you, right?
05:30Throwing it out to the shoppers.
05:31Have you felt pressure by a countdown timer?
05:34Yeah, definitely.
05:35Definitely.
05:37As Trisha shops Shein, Ryan flags a hook to keep you going.
05:41As you scroll, you just keep going and going and going.
05:45So what they're doing here is they're enticing you to keep browsing, keep shopping, until they finally hit on something
05:50that you just can't say no to.
05:51It can be very time-consuming.
05:53Sometimes I actually have to delete the app.
05:56Wow.
05:57I have to remove it from my phone because it could be a distraction.
06:01That's addictive design to the point where you have to delete the thing to free yourself of it.
06:06Now Ryan spots what can be another deceptive design, pre-selected options.
06:12Bronwyn, so you're on Amazon.
06:14Yes.
06:14I see a bag of coffee to buy here, and it looks like they have pre-selected an option for
06:20you.
06:20By my eye, it looks like they've pre-selected the largest possible bag of coffee you can buy.
06:26I'm not sure if that was your intention, but pre-selection is a classic dark pattern where they're trying to
06:32guide the consumer to just say,
06:34um, sure, I'll take that, and then just move on with the purchase.
06:38A pre-selected option appears in our tracking test, too.
06:42When we're checking out those black leggings on Amazon, it says we're eligible for free shipping.
06:47Yet paying $7.98 for faster delivery is actually the pre-selected option.
06:54What's up with that?
06:55The consumer who's just trying to get something done in the middle of a busy day
06:58might not be able to spend all day reading this website to figure out what all the different options are
07:03and might be inclined just to click place your order.
07:06You might not realize that there's a better option here.
07:09When we uncheck the paid shipping option, we get hit with this message pushing Amazon's Prime membership.
07:16So notice this button in yellow.
07:19Yep.
07:20Start 30-day free trial.
07:21You know, they're trying to get you to click on that while, like, you know, under-emphasizing that you have
07:26this option, too.
07:27How can that trip a consumer up?
07:29Um, they want you to think that one decision is a terrible, terrible choice.
07:33Without Prime, look at that. It's not colorful.
07:35Well, I have been presented with this prompt before, and it makes the decision almost easier for you.
07:41So you're prompted to go ahead and click.
07:44Amazon tells us they offer customers a transparent and trustworthy shopping experience
07:49and comply with Canadian laws.
07:51As for the leggings, they say the stock count shows inventory on hand with a specific delivery estimate.
07:58In our tracking on Walmart, when we check out, there's a subscription prompt and a blue button pops up that
08:05says confirm plan.
08:06And look at this.
08:08The no thanks button is down below in white.
08:11If you're in a hurry and you want something, do you go through the motions?
08:17Yeah, if you're in a rush, your eyes do follow, like, those, you know, the bright blue button, let me
08:23just click yes, yes, yes, get through this and make the purchase.
08:26Walmart Canada says their goal is to provide an easy, transparent shopping experience, and creating a Walmart account supports their
08:34customers when they shop.
08:36That offer to become a Walmart member, they say the option to close it is clearly presented, and members can
08:43cancel if they choose.
08:44They also say they're committed to complying with all laws and regulations.
08:49Something else we see in our tracking, nagging notifications.
08:53When we leave stuff in our cart on Timu and then jump off the site, we immediately get an email
08:59saying, action required, and a cart reminder with a price drop.
09:04They email us again, four minutes later, saying, complete checkout.
09:09The next night, they text us about our cart and email us again.
09:15Then text us once more, two days later, saying, congratulations, your cart's reduced.
09:23From $19.65 to $1.07.
09:27What they're doing is they're hounding you and chasing you.
09:30It's, like, invasive, especially, like, when they start texting you, when they start sending you notifications on your phone.
09:36It's, it, it just, they're bombarding you with, you know, buy this, buy this.
09:40And then at that point, I feel like at that point, it turns me off.
09:44Not all of our shoppers have a problem with it.
09:47I feel like it's a bit enticing for me.
09:51Enticing?
09:51Yes.
09:52Okay.
09:52Because if it was on my cart, chances are I was somewhat ready to check out, but just not quite.
10:00And then so that price drop ultimately convinces me to move forward with the, with the purchase.
10:07Ryan's bottom line?
10:09Dropping the price with all these inducements.
10:11You know, why not give me the best deal right off the top?
10:17Coming up.
10:18It's very, very addicting.
10:20We find games being played.
10:23So they string you along and then they pull the rug.
10:25Are they playing you?
10:30Get more Marketplace.
10:32Sign up for our weekly newsletter at cbc.ca slash marketplace.
10:46We're tracking deceptive designs on popular shopping sites and apps.
10:51And we find there are games being played, literally.
10:55That's why we're heading to Beaver Dam, New Brunswick.
10:58Because Lori Cummings has seen just about every play in the book.
11:02Hi.
11:03Hi.
11:03It's so nice to see you.
11:04Nice to meet you.
11:06She's a Timu super shopper.
11:08This is a Timu.
11:09This is one of my favorite in the winter.
11:12I got it for Valentine's Day.
11:14Timu dresses.
11:14And as a piano teacher, stuff on Timu serves her and her students well.
11:27This part of it is from Timu and there's not a music lesson go by that I don't use this.
11:32Well, just so you know, full disclosure, this is a Timu blouse.
11:35Oh, it's beautiful.
11:38I haven't seen that one on there.
11:40The earrings.
11:41Did you see my earrings?
11:42Oh, that's so cute.
11:43They're bubblegum machines and they're pink, one of my favorite colors.
11:47Do you buy more than you plan when you enter the app, go shopping?
11:52Always.
11:53I'll go through and it's so easy just to browse and browse and browse.
11:57The next thing you know, you've got an hour just browsing.
11:59My phone is just constantly, oh, you're getting this.
12:02Oh, you've won this.
12:03Oh, look, you've earned this much.
12:05Now, so you've got this much credit.
12:07I'm like, okay, well, let's go spend it.
12:09So I'll go on to do and then next thing I know, I've spent a huge amount again.
12:13It's very, very addicting.
12:15So this is a game.
12:16It's a watering game.
12:17It's called farmland.
12:19Lori says it's easy to get caught up.
12:21And you can win, win prizes through this.
12:25It tells you how much water you can get back from each, from purchasing each of these items.
12:29But because I made purchases today, hopefully I've got some water in here.
12:32So let's go.
12:33Let's see.
12:34Here we go.
12:34Here we go.
12:34You've got a water reward.
12:36570 grams of water.
12:38There you go.
12:39More orders, more water.
12:41Yeah.
12:41Five more stamps to get extra water reward.
12:44There's always something more you have to do.
12:47Yeah.
12:47Purchase more.
12:49Play more.
12:52It's ongoing and it's very, very time consuming.
12:55I want to show you this farmland game.
12:58There we go.
12:58Lawyer Ryan Fritsch says it's designed that way.
13:02Look what they're doing here.
13:04But ultimately what it means is that the consumer gets locked in.
13:06In our tracking test, we see gains as well.
13:10Like this, spin to win cash on Timu.
13:13When we get a $350 credit, we're told we're just one step away from claiming it.
13:23And you'll see it says reward confirmed.
13:26Yeah.
13:27But you're still a few steps away from getting it.
13:29Yeah.
13:29Yeah.
13:29So they just keep moving the goalposts.
13:31What do you think, shoppers?
13:33You're spending money and still not sure if you're getting the credit.
13:36That would really frustrate me.
13:37Yeah.
13:38It feels like I'm getting scammed.
13:40It does feel like deceptive marketing.
13:43So take a look at this.
13:45So we wanted to leave.
13:47Mm.
13:47And this is what comes up.
13:49Mm.
13:50Cancel your account rewards.
13:52You can either, in blue, stay and withdraw.
13:57So withdraw your $350.
14:00Or, I don't want cash.
14:02Who would click on that?
14:04So Asha, this is a design pattern called confirmation shaming.
14:07The idea here is that a consumer has made a choice and they want to exercise that choice.
14:12And then at the last step, the vendor says, whoa, whoa, whoa, are you sure you want to do this?
14:17You're walking away from all this potential money.
14:19They're trying to, like, shame you against doing it.
14:22I want your reaction to leave this page and the $350 cash goes to the next user.
14:30I don't want my $350 going to someone else.
14:34You know?
14:35Yeah, they're trying to make you jealous, right?
14:36Reel you in and keep you and make you make that purchase.
14:40Moving over to Shein, we score a chance to win big prizes.
14:44Two iPhones and a pair of AirPods Max.
14:48Grab three items for free.
14:49Asha, this is looking like my lucky day.
14:51I know.
14:53Turns out it's not that simple.
14:55We've got to wait about a week to try our luck.
14:59What they're doing is they're stringing you along to keep your attention, right?
15:02And I want to show you what happens next.
15:05Many others are grabbing it with you.
15:08Oops, you're a bit late.
15:10The free items all grabbed.
15:12Thank you for your participation.
15:16The stock is limited to one of each.
15:19So they string you along and then they pull the rug and all the meanwhile you're coming back to their
15:24site and getting in the habit of visiting the site and kind of captured as a customer even though they're
15:29treating you this way.
15:30So reading the fine print.
15:32Yeah.
15:33Right?
15:33At the bottom it says, get a chance to grab free items with qualifying order.
15:38Stocks of freebies are limited to first come, first served.
15:42The fact that they also put that down in the fine print means that a lot of people aren't going
15:46to catch that.
15:47Sheehan tells us they're committed to complying with the law everywhere they operate.
15:51They provide a transparent shopping experience and look for ways to improve it for customers.
15:56Timu tells us their interactive elements make shopping more engaging and they can unlock extra discounts.
16:03They say users can shop without playing games.
16:07They can turn off notifications, unsubscribe from promotional emails and texts, adding they continue to listen to customer feedback.
16:16What message do you have for Timu?
16:19Timu, stop all this gaming and all these promises.
16:23You've got great stuff in there to buy.
16:25Just focus on selling.
16:32Coming up, is there a better way?
16:35We set up this phone and the VPN makes it look like we're in Sweden.
16:40From a consumer's perspective, this is in the consumer's interest.
16:43So we need to reach that level where the Wild West is completely over in the online world.
16:49Where platforms operate in a regulated environment just like shops do in real life.
16:58Do you have a story you want us to investigate?
17:01Write to us, marketplace at cbc.ca.
17:15We've seen some sneaky shopping tactics online designed to get you to buy more.
17:20I think these sites should be quick and easy to use, not deceptive and disingenuous.
17:24While Canada has laws prohibiting misleading sales, in the EU there's a push to specifically stop dark patterns.
17:33So does online shopping look different overseas?
17:37We set up this phone and the VPN makes it look like we're in Sweden.
17:43Right.
17:43Check this out.
17:44Remember how paid shipping was the pre-selected option on Amazon in Canada?
17:49In Sweden, free shipping is the pre-selected option.
17:53From a consumer's perspective, this is in the consumer's interest.
17:56Also, we don't get those nagging emails from Timu when we leave stuff in our cart.
18:02And the coupons we spot on Shein seem to actually expire.
18:06We take this to the European Commission in Belgium to find out more.
18:11Hello from Toronto.
18:13Hello from Brussels.
18:14Thomas Renier is the spokesperson for digital tech sovereignty.
18:18Dark patterns are completely influencing the online experience that our consumers are having.
18:24From basically a neutral service into a service that is actually dragging you into compulsive buying.
18:32The EU has something called the Digital Services Act, with regulations to stop companies from using deceptive designs.
18:40It also gives consumers the right to complain.
18:43It's really holding online platforms accountable, but also giving the power back where it belongs.
18:49Its citizens, its consumers, they should be in the driver's seat.
18:53They want companies to comply. If not, they can face fines.
18:57And the European Commission is currently investigating Timu and Shein for potentially addictive design.
19:04Both companies have publicly stated they are cooperating with regulators and comply with the Digital Services Act.
19:12What about our spot check in Sweden?
19:14I want to walk you through what we found.
19:17Mm-hmm.
19:18Okay.
19:18Very curious about it.
19:19On Amazon Canada, when we went to checkout, we noticed that the paid shipping was the pre-selected option.
19:27But in Sweden, it was the opposite.
19:31Free shipping was the pre-selected option.
19:34What do you make of that?
19:36Well, this shows that our legislation is working.
19:38This is precisely what our services are monitoring.
19:41This has never been our objective to fine e-commerce platforms, social media platforms.
19:45Nobody is winning from that.
19:47What we want is not a fine but a change of behaviour, a change of practices for the benefit of
19:53our consumers.
19:54His take on no nagging?
19:57This is a clear obligation.
19:58What does our Digital Services Act say?
20:01It says stop to push notifications.
20:04And the sale we see in Sweden that actually ended?
20:08Indeed.
20:09Let coupons expire.
20:10If a consumer is interested, he will go there.
20:12If he's not interested, let's not renew it and let's not push again a consumer into compulsive buying.
20:19Overall, hearing what we found, what do you think?
20:22It shows how consumers are less protected abroad if they don't benefit from equal levels of protection.
20:29These topics need to be addressed at the global level.
20:33Canada's Competition Bureau can't comment on our findings, but say dark patterns raise important concerns for Canadians.
20:40And if you see anything you think is potentially false or misleading, reach out to them.
20:45Still, deceptive designs haven't completely disappeared in the EU just yet.
20:50That's why regulators plan to strengthen the rules even further.
20:54What are you hoping for with this new proposed Digital Fairness Act?
20:58What we're hoping is to reach a level of online security for our consumers.
21:05So we need to reach that level where the Wild West is completely over in the online world.
21:11Where platforms operate in a regulated environment, just like shops do in real life.
21:18Would you like to see those types of regulations here in Canada?
21:22Absolutely.
21:23Yeah, absolutely.
21:24I think like all the dark patterns that we're talking about today, they've been so normalized.
21:30It would help protect consumers and also revert back the experience into a shopping experience rather than a maximization of
21:41transactions.
21:44Coming soon.
21:46Strawberry salad, please.
21:47You think you're making a healthy choice, but what if your salad is hiding a salty secret?
21:54Okay, here's number one.
21:55Here's number two.
21:56Three.
21:57We're definitely going to need a few more.
21:59Six.
22:00Seven.
22:01We're still going.
22:02That healthier option could pack more sodium than a burger.
22:06Wow.
22:07My goodness.
22:08That's ridiculous.
22:09Plus, we put some supermarket favorites to the test.
22:13I really have no idea why they would actually increase the level of sodium in a product.
22:17Coming soon only on your Marketplace.