• il y a 6 heures
Watch Marketplace, Season 54 Episode 3 on Dailymotion (2026).

Catégorie

📺
TV
Transcription
00:30We're looking at years of our hidden camera investigations.
00:33We can shut cancer down in one treatment.
00:35To show you how we decide to capture such candid moments.
00:39No ink glass. No ink for ink glass.
00:41No ink, nothing? No.
00:43Before you protest, I will trade you 100% for everything.
00:47And what guides our use of such clandestine methods.
00:51I want you to apologize. I want you to apologize. I want you to apologize.
00:57I want you to apologize. I will be calling you again and again.
01:03Now I will remove your IP address. I will block each and every security.
01:08And your computer will go for my admission down.
01:12Hello?
01:13We use the mic.
01:15Hidden cameras have been an essential tool at Marketplace for decades.
01:20In 2022, we use them to expose things like mortgage fraud.
01:24Income we can make.
01:26Capturing real estate agents instructing home buyers to lie about how much they make.
01:31So they can qualify for financing.
01:33They will do some documentation.
01:36Okay.
01:36Showing that you guys are making more.
01:38Okay.
01:38And they'll get you all your friends.
01:40Wow.
01:42There's nothing grey area about it. It is absolutely fraud.
01:51In 2023, we go undercover to popular diamond retailers to hear the sell on that sparkle.
02:07And it's not just about the investment.
02:10We're testing what they tell us about how they source their diamonds.
02:14Everything is called with grease. So it's like Kimberly's source. They regulate so make sure there is no blood diamonds.
02:21Does that mean like there's no like forced labour or like...
02:26No forced labour.
02:27Not true. The Kimberly process does not cover that.
02:33In 2025, we take hidden cameras to the vet.
02:37So you're looking at about $46.32.
02:42To show different prices for the same test.
02:45So if you're in-house, it's $175.
02:48It is about $100 to do an analysis.
02:51Okay.
02:51If you're okay with that.
02:52But I should be able to get the results back.
02:55We do it in-house.
02:57How many people know that you could actually clap the tumour until it's gone?
03:01In 2023, we go undercover in Mexico to expose a Canadian pushing questionable cures.
03:08So we talked about belly button therapy earlier.
03:11It kills cancer cells.
03:12Sir, we've been trying to reach you.
03:14I think as you know, there are many claims that you've made about being able to cure cancer.
03:18Never have.
03:22Hi there.
03:24Good morning.
03:25We take our hidden cameras inside places that are difficult to access.
03:30To expose moments that are difficult to see.
03:33I don't have five minutes.
03:34I don't even have two minutes.
03:36Yeah.
03:37Over the span of weeks, we volunteer in a long-term care home in 2019.
03:49Showing the dire consequences of understaffing for the vulnerable people who live there.
03:55Help me, help me, help me.
04:00She's been waiting to use the washroom for like an hour.
04:04Turn this on.
04:05In 2022, we uncover a world of misleading sales pitches for prospective students.
04:13Hi.
04:13Hi.
04:14You having a fight for this?
04:15Yeah.
04:15I kind of talked a lot about the fact that I wanted to do it online.
04:19So I'm a little surprised that you're telling me now that I can't do it online now that I've come
04:23all the way.
04:2380 to 85% of all of our graduates find jobs in the fields that they study.
04:28It's across all the programs.
04:30Okay.
04:32And in 2021, we rig up a house with hidden cameras to test how your race could impact your home
04:38appraisal.
04:41And you have no owner?
04:42Yeah.
04:44You have no owner?
04:45Mm-hmm.
04:45Yes.
04:46He asks me twice if I'm the homeowner.
04:49That didn't happen to anyone else.
04:55I can see you.
04:56There's a lot that goes into our approach.
04:58It's recording.
04:59Okay.
05:00That's great.
05:01And it all starts with our team who digs deep to find the truth.
05:05Hi.
05:06My name is Jenny Cowley, and I am a producer at Marketplace.
05:09My name is Bobby Herstova, and I'm a senior writer here at Marketplace.
05:13Hi.
05:13I'm Jeremy McDonald.
05:14I'm a producer with Marketplace.
05:16This is definitely rolling.
05:22There are a lot of circumstances where we're looking into anti-social or possibly even illegal incidents or issues.
05:30And if we were to walk in with cameras rolling, that would definitely change what would unfold.
05:34We don't just walk into some place willy-nilly with hidden cameras.
05:38We have journalistic standards and practices.
05:41That's where Francis D'Souza comes in.
05:43Part of his job is deciding whether to approve any news gathering we do that is not traditional.
05:48I think it's important for the public to understand that there is a lot of thought, there's a lot of
05:54consideration, and there's a lot of oversight into this kind of journalism-gathering tool.
05:59It all starts with CBC's Journalistic Standards and Practices, or JSP.
06:04You can actually just Google CBC JSP, and it's right there.
06:10What I use is exactly what's published online here, so the public can see it.
06:15The JSP outlines the principles that CBC journalists follow.
06:20That's what guides our journalists, to ensure that we're accurate, that we're fair, that we're balanced, that we're impartial to
06:26every piece of journalism that we create.
06:30One of the things that surprises me when we're doing these hidden camera investigations is how much people are willing
06:36to share if they don't think anyone is listening.
06:39Recently, we went to far dealerships.
06:44We had a salesperson look at an ad with us for a car, and in the advertisement, it said one
06:50thing, but in reality, it didn't match up to what we could actually buy.
06:54The color that you see in the car, the company doesn't make that.
06:59That's not true.
07:00Sadly, they put a picture of an upgrade.
07:03Just need to put the button on.
07:05It's all about showing you a first-hand account of what's happening in real time.
07:09Okay, can you check to make sure? It looks like you're recording.
07:12Like the 2024 story we do on driving schools, where hidden cameras end up playing a key role.
07:19I see you. Yeah.
07:21The schools are supposed to teach the rules of the road, but we've been tipped off that some instructors are
07:28willing to cheat the system.
07:30Hey man, how's it going?
07:31This is good.
07:32Yeah, it's me.
07:33You?
07:33Oh, he's my friend, Jeff.
07:35Pay them enough, and they'll give you a certificate that says you've completed beginner driver education without taking a single
07:43lesson.
07:44I have the cash and the license, but Jeff has some questions.
07:48Yeah, I just want to make sure he's not going to get burned or anything down the road for something
07:51like that.
07:52If true, it's illegal behavior that threatens public safety.
07:57So how best to prove it?
08:02We begin by gathering evidence, calling up instructors who, we've been told, advertise on websites like Kijiji and Facebook.
08:11They promise low prices, nearly perfect passing rates, early road test bookings, and a coveted beginner driver education certificate that
08:23helps get you insurance discounts.
08:27So we phone 20 instructors to see what they can do for us.
08:32Yeah, yeah, we will provide it.
08:34It's $200 for BDE certificate.
08:37Okay.
08:38Out of the 20 we contact, 14 offer to sell us a certificate.
08:43No questions asked.
08:45No lessons required.
08:47Like this school.
08:50And is there any test I have to take for BDE or classes?
08:54No, no, no, no.
08:54No, no, no.
08:55Don't worry.
08:55I can manage it in the system.
08:58But will they really go through with it?
09:01It has to be in the public interest.
09:03Is there evidence based on our research of a legal activity?
09:07Is there any antisocial behaviors that we've come across in our research that we've already done some validation on?
09:14And if that is true, then we have to balance, okay, what are the privacy considerations involved in making a
09:21decision?
09:22We have to be very mindful that we're under public scrutiny as well.
09:26And public trust is so important.
09:28We received, you know, evidence of wrongdoing just from those calls.
09:33So why go any further?
09:35I think there's something about showing the public how it's done.
09:40Back on our driving schools test, our hidden cameras capture disturbing practices.
09:46This driving instructor wants us to go to a nearby school to sign forged documents.
09:52I'm going to have to go there.
09:54You have to fill out the paper with you and sign the form.
09:57The forms, he says, will be registered with the Ministry of Transportation.
10:01And then we'll get our certificate.
10:04The only thing that you're going to sign is that you've attended the driving school.
10:08That's it.
10:08So it's just a paper that says I've done the driving school.
10:10That's it.
10:11Oh, okay.
10:12All right.
10:12That's how we do it.
10:13I've done it thousands of times.
10:15He makes it clear we've got nothing to worry about.
10:18People get unsure.
10:19Yeah.
10:19I've done it thousands of times.
10:21Tables of thousands of times.
10:22Yeah.
10:22Sometimes you might feel like, oh, it's a time, but it's not.
10:24That's true.
10:25Truth is, we have no intention of going through with a transaction that sure seems illegal.
10:30So we tell him we need to think about it.
10:33I think he should just take some time to think about it.
10:35That's not how it works.
10:36Yeah.
10:36Because this guy is just waiting for me.
10:38As we back away from the deal, the instructor becomes threatening.
10:42All right, let's go.
10:43All right, let's go.
10:44All right.
10:54Thank you.
10:56Thank you.
10:56Thanks for your time.
11:00I'll find you.
11:04Come here.
11:05Come, come, come, come.
11:06This way.
11:06This way.
11:07This way.
11:08We take refuge in a supermarket while he pulls up out front.
11:13He sits in his car for a good hour.
11:19Sending a text.
11:20You won't like how this is going to end, it says.
11:25But eventually, he leaves.
11:28It is risky.
11:29So we take precautions and we take steps and we do risk assessments.
11:33If we are going into a high risk situation with the team, we'll also review all the parameters
11:38around what could happen and the possibilities.
11:41Members of our team go through various trainings so they know there's always a route to safety.
11:47Put back in.
11:48That's you?
11:49Yeah.
11:49Thank you.
11:50Another example, our 2022 investigation into moving companies.
11:55Here we go.
11:57That was a hidden camera investigation that was, again, pretty extensive where we staged a move.
12:02We've got these trackers.
12:04We're going to turn it on, put it inside, hidden one of our boxes.
12:08When the items were being delivered, we were on site ready to document how it unfolded.
12:14Where's the last place you see them there on the map?
12:16It looks like they've stopped.
12:18There was a little bit of unpredictability about what might happen, right?
12:22We don't know who these people are.
12:23We don't know their backgrounds.
12:25We don't know their temperament.
12:26And in that situation, you know, you worry about things possibly going sideways.
12:31Using hidden cameras is one thing.
12:33Whether to broadcast it after is another, and also whether to blur the people in the video.
12:39In a lot of cases, our hidden camera investigations touch on systemic issues.
12:43So things that we know are not just isolated or a one-off.
12:46And often we find that with systemic situations, the answers and the accountability usually lies at the top,
12:52and not with the people who are kind of on the lower level that we're interacting with in our hidden
12:56camera.
12:57Often, it's the case that when we actually air that footage, we choose to blur those people.
13:02Whether we choose to identify or blur, we always make sure to give them the opportunity to respond.
13:09We actually show that process in our driving schools investigation in 2024.
13:14To get your perspective on why you tried to sell a BDE certificate to our colleagues.
13:20Excuse me, with all due respect ma'am, I haven't tried to sell a certificate and I have no idea
13:26about what you're talking about.
13:28We jog his memory with details from that day, and he says he was just trying to be helpful.
13:34I knew something was wrong from the beginning.
13:37But those tribes were trying to corner me.
13:39Can you give me a certificate? Can you give me a certificate?
13:41Can you give me a certificate of all that?
13:41I can't give me a certificate, but I can help you by taking you to the school.
13:46And you can negotiate with the school owner in a way that you can get a driving certificate.
13:52Of course, leave away.
13:53What does negotiate mean then?
13:55What does negotiate mean?
14:05From what I understand, that is absolutely against the rules.
14:09But you can reduce the in-car lessons if you would like to.
14:13Because if you're practicing at home with your family members with your...
14:15No, you can't. Not if you take this...
14:17Not if you take this program, you can't.
14:22You're not supposed to.
14:24That's the problem here.
14:26So maybe that's the problem.
14:28But what I'm saying is that if people don't want to practice the in-car,
14:32you're not going to force them. Are you going to force them?
14:34I mean, that's a job as the instructor or the driving school, yes.
14:39That's what they're paying for.
14:40The instructor refuses to do a formal interview and later sends another threatening text
14:46that's too graphic to share.
14:51When you're watching the episode, just know we reach out to everybody far in advance
14:55and we give them a chance to try to respond, right?
14:58We want to be fair. We want to be balanced.
15:00We're playing it and letting the public see for themselves and judge for themselves
15:04what the situation is.
15:06Again, our job is to show the truth.
15:08And this does show the truth.
15:10Like our investigation into airline accessibility.
15:14It was actually quite challenging because of the fact that we were traveling.
15:18So can I board first?
15:20You're dealing with security screening.
15:22You're dealing with long wait times between parts of the process.
15:26So figuring out when to get the cameras rolling,
15:30when we could actually put the cameras on myself
15:32and also on the guest who was helping us
15:35was a bit of a logistical thing that had to be planned beforehand.
15:39But not all our hidden cameras document such serious behavior.
15:46When we come back...
15:48So that's our price list today.
15:50...how we sometimes use them in social experiments
15:52to capture everyday Canadians in action.
15:56Women's price is $3 and the men's price is $2.50.
15:59Why?
16:00It's called the pay tax.
16:01$3 for women.
16:03They're trying to make a point.
16:17We use hidden cameras to expose scams, abuse, and deception.
16:23Why is this driving school?
16:26Even shady practices.
16:28I think I'm ready for the balcony.
16:30So we did a story on tipping where we went to a hundred businesses
16:36and documented whether or not they were asking for a tip.
16:39Honestly, tipping culture has gotten a little bit outrageous.
16:42Do you get these tips?
16:43No.
16:43Does the owner take them?
16:44Yeah.
16:46We found out that a lot of these places that were asking for tips,
16:49those tips weren't going to workers.
16:50And that's something that if I went in as a journalist,
16:53they may not be willing to disclose to me.
16:56When we use hidden cameras in social experiments,
16:59the reactions are revealing.
17:01So I love a social experiment.
17:02I think it's a really good way to bring to light a phenomenon
17:06that we've kind of accepted in the consumer world
17:09and make people think about it in a different way.
17:13So after we visit all those businesses
17:16to find out about their tipping practices,
17:18we turn the cameras on you.
17:21Would you like to add a tip of 18, 20 or 25 percent?
17:25No?
17:27Asking for tips in a situation where you wouldn't typically see them.
17:31A pop-up shop.
17:33You can put 18 or 20 or 25 percent.
17:35What are you selling?
17:3620 is fine.
17:37That is very generous of you.
17:39Since you're a nice moment, I'm going to do 18.
17:41That is super sweet of you.
17:44I don't know what's one anymore.
17:46I buy a coffee and they're asking for a tip.
17:48I don't know.
17:49Then there was the time we charged women more than men
17:52for a cup of coffee to illustrate the pink tax.
17:55We have to pay more.
17:57That's where products and services aimed at women
18:00cost more than identical versions designed for men.
18:02That doesn't make sense.
18:04Why is this so expensive for women?
18:06Aren't we, like, making less money than them?
18:09Yep.
18:10That's sick.
18:11I think it goes back to us being able to expose the truth
18:16and the reality of a situation.
18:18Frances D'Souza helps enforce CBC's Journalistic Standards
18:22and Practices, or JSP.
18:24That's the only way that we can do that
18:27and then present it to the audience
18:30in a way that, again, aligns with our JSP,
18:34then it's justified.
18:35If there's another way to gather that information
18:38or convey that information to the public
18:41so they can have what they need before them
18:44to assess the situation,
18:45then we'll think about the alternative ways.
18:48What about stories that use it for candid camera,
18:52if you will?
18:53We want to see what people do in that moment.
18:56Right.
18:57Is that a credible way of using hidden camera?
18:59Well, I think we're getting an honest reaction.
19:02And the one thing that we will never do
19:04is put someone into a situation where they're a customer,
19:08maybe as a real customer in that case,
19:11we would never put them into a situation
19:13where they would feel uncomfortable.
19:15So we make sure that as soon as we reveal
19:17there's hidden cameras around,
19:19we get everyone's consent
19:20that if they want to appear on the Marketplace episode,
19:24they give us permission to use that footage.
19:29I just want to share something with you guys.
19:31I'm actually with Marketplace,
19:32so there are some hidden cameras over here.
19:36Belle, Dave?
19:38I knew it. I knew it. I knew it.
19:40I knew it. Something was off.
19:41First off, did you guys think it was weird
19:43that I asked her a tip?
19:44I mean, we're kind of used to it now.
19:46Uh, it was a little odd.
19:47So there's a camera there. And there. Yeah.
19:51And my mic's hiding in the plant.
19:53Oh, okay.
19:53What do you think about that?
19:54That you would have to pay more than a man
19:56for the exact same thing?
19:57Don't I already, though?
19:58Yeah.
19:58Like, all the time?
19:59It's like, I just have to pay more for everything.
20:01We don't want the general public to think
20:03that we're just out and about with hidden cameras
20:05all the time recording everybody.
20:06Everything we do is in the public interest,
20:08in support of the consumer,
20:10and we touch a lot of topics
20:12that are important to a lot of people.
20:14Everyone shops. Everyone has to buy stuff.
20:16So I think Marketplace is really important
20:18to keep those companies in line.
20:22Marketplace will be right back.
20:28Two victims.
20:30I lost all of our savings. Everything went.
20:32And that was my fault.
20:33Two countries.
20:34My head was spinning.
20:35I had to take a seat right away.
20:37Same scam.
20:38He said there have been multiple attempts
20:40made to purchase at this buy.
20:43Basically, two men had been arrested
20:45for duplicating my cards.
20:48But only one gets all their money back.
20:50How on earth you're putting it on me
20:52and saying that the onus is on me
20:54that the transaction happened?
20:56We take on a bank scammer.
20:58What I do, I impersonate the bank.
20:59That's not something I'm hiding.
21:01You keep talking about how it's other people's responsibility
21:04to stop these scams.
21:06Why is it them instead of you?
21:08And team up with La Facture to take you to the UK
21:12where fighting fraud is a priority.
21:15Why are British consumers getting treated better
21:17than Canadian consumers?
21:19And ask, who's really protecting you here at home?
21:22What do you say to those people who feel that
21:24perhaps government could have protected them more?
21:27We're acting. We're not waiting.
21:28Next week on your Marketplace.
21:35We want to bring your attention to something that's unfortunately becoming a lot more common these days.
21:41Scam ads have taken over social media using AI to pretend to be us and convince you to send scammers
21:48money.
21:48But in reality, they're all fake.
21:51Know that CBC News would never endorse companies, push investments or ask you to send us money.
21:58So if companies promise high returns or pressure you to invest, you might want to think twice.
22:04And if you see one of these scam ads, make sure to email us.
22:09Marketplace at cbc.ca
22:11We've got your back.
22:12This.
22:13This.
22:14This is your Marketplace.
22:20This is your Marketplace.
22:21This is your Marketplace.
22:25This is your Marketplace.
22:29This is your Marketplace.
22:29This is your Marketplace.
22:29This is your Marketplace.

Recommandations