• il y a 9 heures
Watch Dateline NBC 11 20 Tick Tick Boom PCOK, Season 35 Episode 9 on Dailymotion (2026).

Catégorie

📺
TV
Transcription
00:02C'est parti !
00:30I could hear her screaming on both sides.
00:32She was afraid for her life.
00:35Her story is he grabbed her by the throat.
00:38She couldn't breathe.
00:40I grabbed her and I said, don't come anywhere close to me.
00:42She stabbed him.
00:43He bled out to death.
00:45This has devastated our family.
00:48We are charging Courtney Taylor-Clenny with second-degree murder.
00:52Good teacher, sir.
00:54There is a history between the two of them.
00:57For you, this is a case of self-defense.
01:00No doubt in my mind.
01:01She'll never be able to escape what she did.
01:05We demand justice for Christian.
01:08Inside the case that rocks social media.
01:11I'm Lester Holt, and this is Dateline.
01:23Here's Andrea Canning with Tick, Tick, Boom.
01:31Their world was fast-paced, in the spotlight,
01:35where even the most ordinary moments became content for millions.
01:40Glitz and glam and living the life that most people could only dream about.
01:45Christian Obamselli dabbled in cryptocurrency.
01:49His girlfriend, Courtney Clenny, was a popular influencer.
01:52She's bringing in millions.
01:54A lot.
01:55Did she eat it up?
01:57The fame, the money, the attention.
02:00Yeah, she loved it.
02:01They were in their 20s, taking trips to the Maldives and Dubai.
02:07Splurging on fancy cars, a luxury condo.
02:10They look happy.
02:11They look healthy.
02:12They look like everything was going well.
02:15But beneath the veneer of their high-flying life,
02:18an ugly and dangerous reality was unfolding.
02:21Behind closed doors, things were not as they appeared.
02:24I think the social media especially, you pick what you upload.
02:29You can edit what you upload.
02:30You control the narrative.
02:32I'm fed up with that.
02:33You f***ing creepies.
02:34There was a dark side to this relationship.
02:37It's like a Romeo and Juliet type of thing almost,
02:40where it's like nobody needed to die.
02:46April 3rd, 2022, was a hot and humid day in Miami.
02:50Courtney and Christian were in their condo overlooking Biscayne Bay.
02:54Dancing, playing with their dogs.
02:57Yo.
02:58Hey.
03:01It seemed like a good day until it suddenly wasn't.
03:05Courtney's upset.
03:06She's upset.
03:07She's crying.
03:08Courtney's mom, Deborah Clunney,
03:10says it was late afternoon when her daughter called her at home in Texas.
03:14And does she say if Christian is there with her in the condo?
03:18I could hear him.
03:19Are you aware of how bad?
03:21I wasn't aware of how bad it was.
03:23I could hear her screaming on both sides.
03:26Then she heard something alarming.
03:28Christian was hurt.
03:29Deborah raced to find her husband, Kim.
03:32What does she say happened?
03:33Christian was injured.
03:35And I said, hang up and call 911.
03:37You know, Deborah hangs up.
03:39My understanding, Courtney calls 911.
03:47That 911 call was a jumble of voices, questions, and confusion.
03:55Ma'am, listen to me.
03:56You need to stop screaming on the line and give me the address.
03:59I can't see my arm.
04:00I can't see my arm.
04:05Ma'am.
04:06But my boyfriend is dying.
04:08I'm so sorry.
04:10Ma'am, can you hear me?
04:13We're here.
04:14We're here.
04:15We're here.
04:16Within minutes, Miami police arrived and found Courtney holding Christian in her lap.
04:20Hey, come here, come on.
04:22Come on.
04:23Come here.
04:23Get up.
04:24What?
04:24Get up.
04:26He was unconscious, bleeding, with a stab wound to his chest.
04:30Get up right now.
04:31Baby, baby, baby, baby, wake up.
04:33Wake up.
04:33Officers moved her to another room.
04:35I'm terrified.
04:37So, right now, yeah, don't worry.
04:38They're helping him.
04:39EMTs put Christian on a sheet and dragged him to the elevator.
04:42The apartment was too cluttered for a gurney.
04:45Need lift.
04:46Just drag.
04:46And drag this lift.
04:47Christian had a knife wound.
04:49That much was clear.
04:50But how did it happen?
04:52And why?
04:53So, what happened today?
04:54Courtney told police she was responsible, but that it was self-defense.
04:59How many times did you stab him?
05:01I did not stab him once.
05:03I just threw it because I was scared.
05:04Threw it?
05:06Officers needed to know more.
05:08As EMTs rushed Christian to the hospital, they drove Courtney to the Miami Police Department.
05:14Please, God.
05:15Please, please, God.
05:17Christian, you okay?
05:19Manny Morales, Miami's chief of police at the time, knew this was no ordinary case.
05:24This is not a who done it.
05:25We knew that Courtney had done it from the very beginning.
05:28This is a, why did she do it?
05:30Detectives, take a look at that.
05:32A very long look.
05:34It would take them years to get to the truth of what really happened in that condo.
05:39How exactly did you throw it?
05:41Oh, I just flung it.
05:42This case went viral.
05:44Yes, it did.
05:44And to answer the question, who was really the victim?
05:48One minute you think he's the bad guy.
05:51I see him.
05:52Bam!
05:53Punching her?
05:53Oh yeah, hitting her.
05:54And then the next minute, it's her.
05:57Then it's flip-flopping two seconds later again.
05:59This was like a tick-tick boom situation.
06:01It looked like it was an escalating cycle of violence.
06:18Hours after calling 911, 25-year-old Courtney Clunney sat in an interrogation room telling
06:23detectives what happened.
06:25But I swear to God, I was scared.
06:27You have to walk that fine line of, was Courtney a victim or was Courtney the aggressor?
06:33And remember, it's one of those things that Florida, we do have to stand your ground.
06:37So you do have a right to protect yourself.
06:39We just want to hear your side of the story and what occurred.
06:43Courtney told detectives their relationship was volatile.
06:46They'd broken up briefly, then gotten back together just the night before.
06:50I felt very, very loved when I woke up this morning.
06:53Courtney said the trouble started after Christian went out to get sandwiches
06:56and she noticed on her phone he'd stopped sharing his location.
07:00When he returned, she confronted him.
07:02And I said something about like, oh, are you going to like reshare your location with me?
07:06Like, did you want to share it?
07:09And I said, yeah.
07:11But Courtney said when Christian asked her to do the same, she hesitated and that made him angry.
07:17He ended up pinning me against the wall.
07:20And then, I mean, I said like choking me on the floor.
07:25And this happened twice before, where I couldn't breathe and I was on the floor.
07:30I could not breathe.
07:32She said Christian let her go.
07:34That's when she called her mom.
07:35I went in his living room, took us on the couch.
07:38He came in there and tried to put the phone out of my hand.
07:40So I went back into the kitchen.
07:42And then he just like, I could see like all the eyes in his eyes and it was like, like
07:47coming at me.
07:48I grabbed my knife and I said, don't come anywhere closer to me.
07:50I had absolutely no intention of using it.
07:53I was like, don't come any closer.
07:56Coming at me.
07:57And I drew it.
07:58How exactly did you throw it?
08:00Oh, I just flung it.
08:02I'm not, I just for dang sure did not stab him.
08:07That would be insane.
08:08When you flung it, how close was he at that time?
08:13I mean, I said 10 feet, but if this is 10 feet, it was definitely more than 10 feet.
08:18Despite what happened, Courtney kept asking about Christian's condition.
08:22Is he okay?
08:24He's still at the hospital.
08:25They're still, you know, monitoring him and talking to him.
08:29So we're waiting.
08:30Oh my God.
08:31So he's not even, he didn't even have to have surgery.
08:33Well, I don't know.
08:34They're still, they're still doing x-rays and stuff like that.
08:40So I don't know yet.
08:42I'm waiting to hear a response.
08:44That's all I have to know.
08:44Thank God.
08:45The detectives are telling her that he's in the hospital.
08:48They're not saying exactly what's going on yet.
08:50Yeah, that's part of their investigative tactics, right?
08:53And by her asking, she's showing the detectives, hey, I'm concerned, which goes along with her
08:59story of being the victim and being an incident of self-defense.
09:02After Courtney's dad learned she was being questioned by police, he moved quickly to
09:06protect her.
09:07That night, he hired local attorney, Frank Prieto.
09:11Are you able to see Courtney?
09:14Yeah, I was able to.
09:15They brought me to the interview room.
09:17I feel so much better once they just say, he's stable.
09:21Yeah.
09:22And I've been asking, I've been asking.
09:23And that's what we're waiting for.
09:25Minutes later, investigators came back in with an update.
09:28The news wasn't good.
09:30We have to inform you that Christian did not make it.
09:33Okay.
09:36Unfortunately, the doctors did what they could.
09:39Christian is dead.
09:40Yeah.
09:43Oh, my God.
09:45No, that's not true.
09:47That's not, that didn't, that's not real, right?
09:49That is real.
09:49Christian is dead.
09:51Yes.
09:53No.
09:54It'll be okay.
09:55It's going to be fine.
09:58In those early chaotic hours, are you thinking Courtney will be arrested?
10:04My impression was that detectives needed to do follow-up before they would make any kind
10:09of charging decision or arrest decisions.
10:11Instead, police sent Courtney to a mental health facility, concerned she might harm herself.
10:17It was very traumatic for her, obviously.
10:19She loved him, and she was having a difficult time dealing with the fact that he had taken
10:25and that he died.
10:27Their story began a year and a half earlier.
10:30Courtney's parents say she and Christian met in Mexico through mutual friends.
10:34He was with another girl there.
10:36and then decided he wanted to pursue Courtney.
10:40Christian was on vacation.
10:42He said he was a stocks and crypto trader.
10:45Courtney was there for a content shoot.
10:47By then, she'd spent years building a lucrative career as an influencer.
10:51So she started doing Instagram, and then she started getting some endorsements, and they'd pay her,
10:58they'd get her products or whatever.
11:00And picking up, just really gaining steam?
11:02Yes.
11:03I remember when she had a million followers, kind of celebrating that.
11:07That's a lot of followers.
11:09So we were here shooting at the marina.
11:11Her parents say Courtney was living her dream, a life she'd imagined since she was a young girl
11:16watching Keeping Up with the Kardashians.
11:18I think she's got kind of a warped sense of what...
11:21What a glamorous life might be.
11:23And money.
11:25Just tons of money.
11:26Not only had Courtney found an audience on Instagram,
11:29her parents learned she'd become a content creator on OnlyFans.
11:33We didn't know what OnlyFans was.
11:34And, you know, she told me that at the beginning especially, it wasn't all that explicit.
11:41Hey, guys.
11:42That's when her following and her income soared.
11:45She reportedly made $3 million in two years from subscribers paying to view her racy content.
11:51Were you aware of just how successful she was and how much money she was raking in?
11:56We were aware of how much money she was making.
11:59That didn't mean...
12:00We did think it was for less explicit material than it probably was.
12:04Not long after Mexico, Courtney and Christian moved into a luxury apartment in Austin.
12:09At first, they just seemed like a...
12:12kind of like a normal couple.
12:14But soon it was obvious they weren't.
12:17Aidan Nesvisky lived below them.
12:19We could hear them all the time.
12:21And it was not pleasant.
12:23No, it was a lot of fighting, a lot of breaking glass, a lot of shouting.
12:27The one time that it was really crazy was they threw a painting that they had off the balcony.
12:32And it landed on our balcony.
12:34What?
12:35Yeah.
12:35And so we had it.
12:37And it was this crazy tiger painting that was...
12:40We called it the murder tiger.
12:42A tiger almost feels...
12:44It felt like an omen.
12:45After more than a year in Texas, they moved to Miami.
12:49But Debra and Kim, who spoke to Courtney nearly every day, thought it was a bad idea.
12:54They'd seen behind the couple's picture-perfect image.
12:57When times were good, what worked for Courtney and Christian?
13:00This is not the answer you wanted, but it's the answer I'll give you.
13:03What worked is that he got money from her.
13:05Her father says Christian didn't make any money trading crypto.
13:08He was living off Courtney, who was footing the bill for their lavish lifestyle.
13:12Courtney was paying for the condo?
13:14Oh, in Miami?
13:15Yeah.
13:15It was all her?
13:16Yes.
13:17The couple hoped Miami would be a fresh start.
13:20But as Courtney's mom helped her make the move, she continued to see signs of trouble.
13:25When did things start to sour when they moved to Miami?
13:29Well, as we're driving into town, they're in a fight on the phone before we get here.
13:35Three months later, Christian would be dead, and his family would begin a fight for justice
13:41they never could have imagined.
13:43They are concluding that it's self-defense, and all of this is less than 24 hours.
14:0427-year-old Christian Obamselli was killed on a Sunday.
14:08Monday morning, his mother, Chio, a registered nurse in Texas, was at work when her phone rang.
14:13I said, can I help you?
14:16And she said, I want to get the consent from you.
14:22Christian can donate his eyes or cornea.
14:26And I'm like, ma'am, are you sure you have the right number?
14:32Because you haven't...
14:33I haven't heard anything.
14:35...been told that...
14:35I haven't been told.
14:36...that he's even died.
14:37No.
14:38And she said, ma'am, did they not inform you that he died yesterday?
14:45Yesterday?
14:46Yes.
14:47And when I said, what?
14:50Well, what do you mean?
14:51What do you mean?
14:52And she hung up the phone, and I started screaming, screaming.
14:56His mother found out that Christian died from a woman talking about organ donation.
15:03That should not have happened.
15:04I own that.
15:05That should have never happened, and I apologize to Christian's family for that.
15:10How do you find out that something has happened to Christian?
15:14My mom calls me and, come home.
15:17You know, she's crying.
15:18She's distraught.
15:20Come home.
15:21You know, Toby, as we call him, he's gone.
15:24He's dead.
15:25Christian's older brother, Jeffrey Obamselli, and their cousin, Karen Ebuna, a lawyer,
15:29say they were desperate to find out how Christian died.
15:33So, Jeffrey, I think he's trying to contact Courtney.
15:36I even, like, sent her a DM, and I was like, hey, we just heard that Christian is dead.
15:43Do you know what happened?
15:45No response from her, but a detective soon reached out and gave them the horrific details.
15:51Courtney killed Christian with a knife, and there was more.
15:55They are concluding that it's self-defense, and all of this is less than 24 hours.
16:02That was not sitting well with you or your family.
16:05I don't think it would sit well with anybody.
16:08Christian's death hit them hard.
16:10I like this over here.
16:11Yeah.
16:12His mother, originally from Nigeria, says Christian had a happy childhood growing up in Plano, Texas.
16:19As captain of his high school football team, he was a bit of a hometown hero.
16:23How proud were you when you would see him out on the field?
16:41He earned a spot on the Division I football team at Abilene Christian University.
16:45After college, his family says he landed a job in communications at a local TV station.
16:50He was laid off during the pandemic, and so he was like in a transition, trying to figure out himself.
16:59Now, Christian would never get that chance.
17:03Their focus turned to justice for Christian.
17:06And so we had to kind of galvanize community support.
17:10You know, we were posting on Instagram, like, trying to get as much attention to this because nothing was happening.
17:18The family also reached out to Larry Hanfield, a defense attorney and former Miami-Dade prosecutor.
17:25So I immediately got on the phone.
17:27I called the state attorney's office and set up a meeting with the chief assistant.
17:32Are they cooperative with you?
17:34Very cooperative.
17:35Are they saying, we're going to take a look?
17:36What's happening?
17:39But still, the family heard nothing from police.
17:43Then they learned that after two days in a mental health facility, Courtney had been released with no restrictions.
17:50Outraged, Christian's family flew to Miami and held a press conference.
17:54We have no cause to believe that this was a case of self-defense.
17:59He is kind.
18:01He's caring.
18:02He's soft-spoken.
18:03And the idea that this was somehow warranted is unthinkable.
18:12What his family didn't know was that police were searching for answers and had uncovered a side of Christian and
18:18Courtney's relationship they knew nothing about.
18:21On the day he died, a neighbor came forward.
18:24I see you guys are all up there, and I'm like, I gotta go say something.
18:26Had you ever met Courtney Clenny or heard of Courtney Clenny?
18:29Mm-mm, no.
18:31From his 21st floor apartment, Arthur Cupp had a clear view into Courtney and Christian's on the 22nd.
18:37And about a week earlier, around 4 a.m., you see something that gave you pause, that concerned you.
18:45Yeah, it was a Saturday, and when I walked up to the glass, I noticed her up against the wall,
18:52Christian facing her with his back towards me.
18:55And I saw him start swinging like this towards her, and I saw her manage to somehow sneak under his
19:02arms that way.
19:04And she went around, and when he turned and started going towards her, he noticed me standing in the living
19:10room.
19:10Oh, how unsettling is that?
19:12Um, yeah, it put me into a little shock because I wasn't sure what I should do at that point.
19:17Yeah.
19:17When he realized I'm there, he ended up pulling the blinds down.
19:21He says he didn't call the police because he thought no one would take him seriously.
19:25They're gonna be like, dude, it's 4 in the morning, go home, like we have no reports of any...
19:30This is like the old Alfred Hitchcock movie, Rear Window.
19:34Mm-hmm.
19:35Now he was telling an officer on the scene about the alleged abuse he'd witnessed.
19:39I see him, and my girl saw two, in that bedroom that's facing out to our street.
19:44Bam!
19:45Punching her?
19:46Oh, yeah, hitting her.
19:46And detectives discovered it wasn't the only violent incident that week.
19:51Less than 48 hours before the fatal fight, during their short breakup, officers had been called to Courtney and Christian's
19:57building.
19:58Hi, how are you?
19:59Their body cams captured the tense scene, the aftermath of a domestic dispute.
20:04Excuse me, hold on. What's going on?
20:07Okay.
20:07Courtney told them she and her mom had been trying to get Christian to leave, but he wouldn't go.
20:11He slept inside of a couch in my elevator room, which is Stockholm.
20:16I walked my dogs, and he was telling me he wouldn't be me alone.
20:19The security guard explained what the staff had witnessed.
20:22We get down here to the lobby area.
20:25Her boyfriend comes charging towards her, and we actually try to get in the middle of it.
20:31It does seem like a woman who was crying out for help.
20:34It kind of brought some validation to Courtney's story that it was potentially self-defense.
20:42But detectives were about to uncover a pattern of escalating violence and a fuzzy picture of who was responsible.
20:49The confusion was just beginning.
20:52It does show that she was the aggressor at that point.
20:54And also that she was throwing something.
20:56Correct.
21:11Shortly after her release from police custody, Courtney celebrated her 26th birthday.
21:16A few months later, she bought a house.
21:19For Christian's family, time had stood still.
21:22Courtney is not arrested.
21:24How does that sit with your family?
21:26It does bring up emotions.
21:28It was insane.
21:31We took the time to make sure that no stone was left unturned, and that we put together a solid
21:36case.
21:37During that time, detectives were combing through a mountain of evidence, including videos of Courtney and Christian.
21:43One jumped out.
21:45An incident in Las Vegas eight months before Christian died.
21:48Courtney called hotel security from their room, and security called the police.
21:53They both at one point admit to a physical altercation inside of the room.
21:59The room upstairs was a disaster.
22:01Christian told police Courtney had gotten violent with him.
22:04Like, I was on the couch, like, she threw the glass thing, and I'm on my face.
22:13Then I went back to bed, and I was like, why did you do that?
22:17When it was Courtney's turn, she did admit she'd thrown things at Christian in the past.
22:22I've thrown a glass at him, and a plate.
22:26But wasn't sure what happened this time.
22:28Did you remember throwing the glass?
22:30No, I don't.
22:33But that sounds like me, so.
22:36The officer pressed her several more times.
22:38Okay, once again, do you think you did it, or you did it?
22:42I did.
22:43Police handcuffed Courtney and charged her with domestic battery.
22:47Is this like an overnight ordeal?
22:5012-hour hold.
22:5112-hour hold?
22:52These charges were later dropped.
22:54Yes, but that's not unusual in domestic violence investigations.
22:58For detectives, the Las Vegas case provided a new perspective on the couple's relationship.
23:03It does show that she was the aggressor at that point, so very plausible it could have been
23:08that she was the aggressor in this case.
23:10And also that she was throwing something.
23:12Correct.
23:13Detectives were also examining forensic evidence.
23:16In her police interview, Courtney had insisted she didn't stab Christian.
23:21She said she flung the knife at him as he attacked her.
23:24According to the medical examiner, the blade plunged three inches into his chest, severing a major artery.
23:30The medical examiner wasn't buying that Courtney had thrown the knife 10 feet.
23:36Correct.
23:37I think that's the most telling piece of evidence that there is.
23:40Another troubling video released by an attorney for Christian's family also got detectives' attention.
23:46Shut up!
23:47You will never see me again.
23:48You are the most...
23:49Good, dude.
23:50Shut up!
23:50Good, I remember that.
23:51I remember that.
23:51I remember that.
23:52I remember that.
23:52The couple was fighting during an OnlyFans trip to Aspen, two months before Christian's death.
23:57Christina Santa, Courtney's friend and fellow OnlyFans model, was there, too.
24:02How did Courtney and Christian end up on the Aspen trip?
24:05So, we've done a bunch of OnlyFans content creator trips at this point, and this was just another one with
24:11the same crew.
24:12So, Courtney's making all kinds of content in the snow?
24:15Yes.
24:16You ready for the Chanel bag challenge?
24:18Yes.
24:19Let's do it.
24:19One, two, three, two, one.
24:22You did it.
24:23We did it!
24:24Christian was tagging along as usual and, you know, enjoying himself as well.
24:29But the fun trip suddenly turned ugly.
24:32Like, I was sober for two weeks.
24:34Two weeks!
24:35Two weeks!
24:36And now why am I not sober?
24:37Because I'm you!
24:38It was like a four-story house, and I was a story below that, and I could hear it happening.
24:42And I saw the video after, and it was almost foreshadowing what happened later.
24:48Yeah, no, no, it's not going to be the next time.
24:51Get the f*** out!
24:52When you look at that video, what crosses your mind?
24:56I mean, that does give you an idea of how little disregard Courtney had for being able to put hands
25:05on somebody.
25:06Actually, done.
25:07Okay, fine.
25:07F***ing done.
25:08Done!
25:09What is your take on that when you watch that video?
25:13Emotional.
25:14Um, just sad that, you know, my brother went through that.
25:18Karen, I feel like it's hitting you hard talking about it.
25:22I was really angry because, um...
25:28I couldn't understand, like, why he didn't just leave.
25:32I wish that we had an inkling of what was going on because the support and the response would have
25:44been so different, um, had we had known.
25:47Um, but we did it.
25:52Yeah, we did.
25:53Meanwhile, Courtney's parents say she was struggling.
25:56Four months after Christian's death, she went to Hawaii and checked into a Ritzy rehab facility.
26:01They say alcohol had been a problem for years.
26:04Courtney had been arrested twice for drunk driving.
26:07Really?
26:08Yes, ma'am.
26:08She was always saying she wanted to get better.
26:11She wanted to stop drinking.
26:12She seemed to be doing very well, um, on the program and doing well, doing much better emotionally.
26:17Had you heard anything from investigators that they were looking into this or that there might be, you know, more
26:22conversations had?
26:24So what happened next would take everyone by surprise, especially Courtney.
26:29Something huge happens in this rehab facility in Hawaii.
26:34Huge.
26:35It's insanity.
26:36They sent helicopters and then the SWAT team.
27:05She called me, um, crying.
27:08And I asked her what was going on, and they said they were there to arrest her.
27:12Jeffrey, what's that moment like for you when you find out Courtney has been arrested?
27:17I felt like there was a first step in justice, uh, for my brother.
27:21It was bittersweet.
27:22It, it, it was something that we were fighting for.
27:26But it should have happened months ago.
27:29And, you know, the reality is that if it had been the inverse, he would have been arrested immediately.
27:37We are charging 26-year-old Courtney Taylor Clenny with one count of second-degree murder in Christian's death.
27:46At a press conference the next day, the Miami-Dade state attorney presented evidence of a toxic relationship.
27:52So let's play that video if we could now.
27:55The security camera footage was taken six weeks before Christian's death.
27:59It captured Courtney and Christian getting on the elevator in the lobby of their apartment building.
28:03Immediately, Courtney got violent.
28:06The elevator video definitely helps bolster the state's case against her, showing that she holds her own and she is
28:14very capable of throwing down some violence with him.
28:19Mark Eiglarsh is a defense attorney and former Miami-Dade prosecutor.
28:23He wasn't involved with the case, but followed it closely.
28:26Why second-degree?
28:28Because the prosecutor is saying that while she didn't intend to kill him, it showed she had a depraved mind,
28:34meaning she did an act that was so reckless.
28:37It was such a disregard of human life that it warrants a second-degree murder conviction.
28:43Three months later, a toned-down and shackled Courtney entered a Miami-Dade courtroom for her evidentiary hearing.
28:49For the first time, the state laid out its case.
28:52The issue is whether the defendant's conduct in stabbing or killing Christian was justified.
28:58It was a question Courtney herself brought up to police the night Christian died.
29:03I don't know. I really don't know if this is justified at all. I really don't know.
29:11I really don't know because I knew I was scared, but I really don't know.
29:15The state called the lead detective to the stand.
29:18The truth, the how-truth, and nothing but the truth?
29:20I don't.
29:21He testified about violence between the couple, including accusations that this wasn't the only time Courtney injured Christian.
29:28In the six months before his death, Courtney allegedly stabbed him in the leg and another time cut his face.
29:34Will you just describe the court to what those injuries were?
29:38It was a large laceration that goes from the lip to the bottom of the chin.
29:44Prosecutors zeroed in on the final fight that ended Christian's life.
29:47They found inconsistencies in Courtney's claim that Christian choked her.
29:51I mean, I said, like, choking me on the forehead.
29:54Did you see any bruising on her neck?
29:56No.
29:57Did you see any hand marks on her neck?
30:00No.
30:00For every action, there's a reaction.
30:02You would find bruising if that really did take place.
30:05Perhaps the state's most incriminating evidence focused on Courtney's claim that she flung the knife at Christian.
30:11The chief medical examiner took the stand.
30:14Is it your opinion that she could not run the knife?
30:16I would say that that is not something that could have happened given the injury that this person has.
30:22The evidence was stacking up.
30:24To help with Courtney's defense, Frank Prieto brought on seasoned trial attorney Sabrina Puglisi.
30:29Is Courtney the killer the prosecution paints her out to be?
30:34Well, it's the complete opposite.
30:38Courtney's attorney said the state cherry-picked evidence to make its case, starting with that elevator video played at the
30:44press conference.
30:45They challenged the lead detective.
30:47Did you interview any witnesses that told you what happened before that incident in the elevator?
30:52No.
30:53The narrative that's been left out for the most part is that she gets on that elevator to go down
30:59to the lobby to call the police.
31:01Because her and Christian were in a fight, and in fact, she was cut and bleeding.
31:05The defense said Christian followed her down to the lobby, wiping up Courtney's blood with his shoe.
31:11Eventually, the two re-entered the elevator, and that's the portion the state prosecutor released to the press.
31:17He had the key fob, and you can kind of see he's like a basketball player.
31:20He's boxing her out to get access to that control panel with the only fob.
31:25The elevator opened directly into the apartment.
31:28And Courtney, in her desperation, knew if he gets up to the floor, he's in the apartment, and he's a
31:34big guy.
31:35She's not going to be able to get him out of that apartment.
31:37The defense raised more questions about the police investigation, asking if they'd followed up with Courtney's neighbor, Arthur Kupp.
31:44Were you able to locate the witness that said he saw Christian hitting Courtney in the head prior to April
31:513rd, 2022?
31:52I could not find him.
31:53Arthur Kupp is a prime example of their failure to investigate further.
31:59He went to the police on that day, and we see from their body cam that he says,
32:04Hey, a few days ago, I just saw this incident.
32:07This man was, like, beating on her.
32:09Nobody ever from Miami PD reached out to me.
32:12Nobody.
32:13As for the allegation Courtney stabbed Christian in the leg, the defense argued there was no evidence.
32:19You didn't notice any healing scars on legs, did you?
32:25Legs, no.
32:26And the gash on Christian's chin?
32:28Courtney's attorneys had an entirely different account.
32:31How did he get the cuts on his face?
32:34She tried to break up with him, and he said he was going to kill himself.
32:39He grabbed the knife.
32:40She tried to stop him, and he pulled, and it ended up cutting himself.
32:47Courtney's team wasn't done.
32:49They would be back in court with a surprising piece of evidence.
32:52You got a pig.
32:54You actually got a real pig.
32:56And Courtney wouldn't be the only Clennian handcuffs.
32:59You know, they have a legal warrant for your arrest.
33:02And now you're in the middle of a murder investigation.
33:05Yes.
33:06Now we're becoming a story.
33:21For more than a year, Courtney's parents watched prosecutors go after their daughter.
33:26Then one day, those same prosecutors came for them.
33:29It's like any other day, and suddenly, police show up to arrest you.
33:35Yeah, it's insanity.
33:38There are warrants for you and your wife's arrest?
33:40What?
33:41They are now surrounding your house.
33:44Right.
33:44We had no idea what we could possibly be arrested for.
33:47This is insane.
33:48They accused Courtney and her parents of illegally accessing a computer they say belonged to Christian
33:53and charged them with a felony.
33:55What do you think when you look at these charges against her parents?
34:00Absurd.
34:01Absolutely absurd.
34:02It didn't fit in.
34:04I mean, it was really a legal term, a WTF moment.
34:08The Clenny's attorneys, Jude Fachadomo and Mickey Ratson, say Kim found that computer in Courtney's apartment.
34:14One of the items in there that the police left behind because it had no evidentiary value
34:20was this laptop, and Kim, cleaning everything up, took it.
34:24Prosecutors alleged Courtney's parents then illegally logged into the computer using passcodes from Courtney.
34:30But the Clenny's attorneys say it wasn't a crime because Courtney and Christian shared the computer.
34:35They say this was a strategy by the state.
34:38You and your attorneys, you believe that you were arrested to discredit you because you are a witness?
34:45Yes, because I'm supposed to be telling kind of what was happening with Courtney on the phone when it all
34:50happened.
34:51And I think that if they can discredit me, that would help them with their case.
34:56The state denies that claim.
34:58Prosecutors found out about the computer after obtaining access to the Clenny's iCloud accounts during the murder investigation.
35:04In there, they are able to find, and while they shouldn't have, did review, very confidential messages between the attorneys
35:14and Kim and Debra.
35:16I mean, this is just not the right thing for the state attorney's office to be trying to do.
35:23The defense argued prosecutors had violated the Clenny's rights.
35:26The judge finds that they did breach attorney-client privilege.
35:30She excludes the quote-unquote evidence, and the state is left with nothing.
35:37Without the messages, the state dropped the charges against the Clenny's, and the lead prosecutor ultimately withdrew from the murder
35:43case.
35:44Three months later, Courtney's attorneys were back in court for a hearing on the murder charge, this time with their
35:51own expert.
35:53Their independent medical examiner challenged the basis of the state's whole case.
35:58He reviewed the photos police took of Courtney.
36:01Unlike the lead detective, the expert did see something.
36:04There's a faint blue-green discoloration here, and some faint reddish discoloration here.
36:10Indicating to him that pressure might have been applied to Courtney's neck.
36:14He also disputed the prosecution's claim that Courtney stabbed Christian.
36:19I favor it being a thrown knife rather than it being a directly inserted knife as in the usual stabbing.
36:27He said given how sharp the knife was, he believes it would have gone much deeper if Courtney had stabbed
36:32Christian at close range.
36:34The difference in penetration, in my mind, is one of the desensit factors that they were one over another.
36:41Then, Courtney's attorney set out to prove it was, in fact, possible that she threw the knife.
36:47They hired experts to recreate the fatal event.
36:50You got a pig. You actually got a real pig.
36:53It's the closest thing to human flesh.
36:57The defense asked their knife-throwing expert to fling the same type of knife that killed Christian.
37:02What we've been able to prove through our experts is that a knife being thrown, albeit an expert, right,
37:09but it just takes that one throw, and that knife penetrated into a pig carcass just over five inches.
37:16I can tell you, I also threw the knife while we were doing the demonstration, and it did stick into
37:22the pig.
37:23So, it is possible.
37:24Prosecutors pushed back, arguing the expert threw the knife from a much closer distance than what Courtney told police.
37:30The state also pointed out the obvious size difference between Courtney and the man throwing the knife.
37:36Someone who can generate that, or has that much weight to them, would be able to generate a much larger
37:42amount of force stepping forward.
37:45Yes.
37:46As the trial loomed, the defense filed a series of motions, hoping to expose weaknesses in the state's case and
37:52push for a deal.
37:53There's a time and a place to resolve it, and that was the point that we were already at.
37:58Three weeks before the trial, the state offered Courtney the chance to plead guilty to a lesser charge.
38:03If convicted of second-degree murder, she faced a possible life sentence.
38:07A plea deal would be much safer.
38:09Not because we think that she's guilty, but just to reduce risk.
38:15Please state your full name for the record.
38:17Courtney Taylor-Honey.
38:18On August 10, 2026, Courtney pleaded guilty to manslaughter with a deadly weapon.
38:24Are you pleading guilty because you are, in fact, guilty or do you believe this is in your best interest?
38:30Christian's cousin Karen read a statement from his mother.
38:33For more than four years, we've lived with the loss every day and waited for accountability.
38:40Today closes a legal chapter, but it certainly doesn't close our grief.
38:46The judge sentenced Courtney to six years in prison.
38:50With time served, she could be out in less than two.
38:54After filing out of the courtroom, Christian's family's attorney told the crowd something haunting.
38:59Just five weeks before Christian's death, he texted Courtney,
39:03Is love going to kill me?
39:05He predicted it.
39:06He indicated that he believed that his love will eventually cause his demise at her hands.
39:15Courtney's parents also addressed the media.
39:18Before anything else, I want to acknowledge that a young man lost his life.
39:22Nothing I can say today diminishes that tragedy.
39:26Courtney has the future ahead of her.
39:29As her father, I'm looking forward to the day I can sit across from her face to face and hug
39:33her
39:34and tell her how much I love her.
39:37Something Christian's family will never get to do.
39:40How do you want Christian to be remembered?
39:44Someone who was kind-hearted would literally give you anything.
39:48A very jovial, a gentle heart, and somebody who was there for you.
39:56I want Christian to be remembered as someone who was kind, you know, for people to learn from his story.
40:04That it's not all that glitters is gold.
40:08For people to value their life and their safety more than the promise of love,
40:21especially when it hurts and it harms.
40:25Taken far too soon.
40:28Yes.
40:34That's all for now.
40:36I'm Lester Holt.
40:37Thanks for joining us.

Recommandations