- 18 minutes ago
United States President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin convened for a trilateral summit in Shenzhen on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Good evening, you're watching To The Point. I am Preeti Chaudhary. Lots lined up for you.
00:05First up, allow me to take you through the headlines.
00:13The superpower handshake at Shenzhen. Trump, Xi, Putin hold trilateral meet in China.
00:19Xi bats for ban and destruction of nukes. Putin bats for peaceful nuke energy.
00:24Trump claims US helped establish global peace.
00:34Prime Minister Modi's GTA 6-style attack on UPA era.
00:38Modi compares online games GTA 5 and GTA 6 to slam UPA era posts.
00:4313 years that changed the games as Fragile 5 during GTA 5 to the top now.
00:54Rahul Gandhi makes it official. Congress will not boycott polls.
00:58Despite vote-chory charges, Rahul says will contest polls, will not end democracy.
01:04BJP lashes out, says Rahul maligning India on foreign soil.
01:11If we say that we are not going to contest elections, we end Indian democracy, that will not.
01:19And we don't want to end the structure of Indian democracy.
01:27Akhilesh's Gorakhpur Yatra turns tragic.
01:3014-year-old crushed by a bulldozer in Samajwadi Party Rathiyatra.
01:34Chief Minister Yogi accuses SPF anarchy, one's harshest punishment possible to culprits.
01:46Antropic priced its IPO at $83 per share, valuing the artificial intelligence giant at USD $1.5 trillion
01:54in the biggest Wall Street debut of all times.
02:20All right, three of the world's most powerful leaders on one table in Shenzhen.
02:25U.S. President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin
02:30all came together for the first time ever trilateral summit on the sidelines of the APEC gathering,
02:37with the meeting lasting about an hour and a half.
02:40The Shenzhen trilateral has produced a joint peace declaration,
02:44outlining areas of cooperation on nuclear security, global stability, UN reform, and energy security.
02:50The declaration mentions reducing nuclear risks and preventing proliferation,
02:56reaffirming that nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought.
03:01The leaders have also called for stable energy flows and respect for states of renuity.
03:05The declaration also takes aim at the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court,
03:10but it does also leave out any mention of the Ukraine or Iran wars.
03:15Artificial intelligence, semiconductors, Taiwan and global supply chains,
03:21some of the biggest geopolitical and economic fault lines also find no place in this joint statement.
03:30And today we'll be talking about all of the problems that are really being discussed in the world.
03:39We are going to be discussing the war between Russia and Ukraine, and we already have.
03:44President Putin and I have had a long discussion today for quite a while.
03:48That's what pretty much what the discussion was about.
03:53And I think things are happening.
03:54I think that he and I hope the other side would like to see an end to that.
03:59But it's also vital that we cooperate to combat the threat of nuclear proliferation in other countries around the world.
04:06That's what we're doing in Iran.
04:08We're not going to let Iran have a nuclear weapon.
04:11And to that end today, we'll be talking about all of the problems that are really being discussed in the
04:19world.
04:19We are going to be discussing the war between Russia and Ukraine, and we already have.
04:25President Putin and I have had a long discussion today for quite a while.
04:29That's pretty much what the discussion was about.
04:33And I think things are happening.
04:35I think that he and I hope the other side would like to see an end to that.
04:40In another area of potential cooperation between us,
04:43I'll be suggesting ways to protect our nation's sovereignty from rogue globalist organizations
04:50such as the International Criminal Court, which has gotten out of control,
04:55which I believe we all agree has really strayed far from beyond its jurisdiction.
05:01For my part, I'm convinced that Russia, China and the United States and our respective people
05:07are capable of making a significant contribution to strengthening global security and stability,
05:13providing they engage in constructive partnership-based cooperation
05:17rooted in mutual respect, equality and a balance of interests.
05:22To respond to constantly emerging global challenges,
05:26we should strengthen capacity building,
05:28promote regional cooperation on energy and food security,
05:31and deepen anti-corruption governance across borders.
05:36We should coordinate the development of resources, the environment and population,
05:41scale up the rational utilization and protection of natural resources,
05:46and expand green and low-carbon cooperation to achieve sustainable economic growth.
05:53We should support livelihood improvements and invest in the people,
05:58launch healthy aging programs, facilitate employment and the development of vocational skills,
06:05and support women's economic empowerment and young talent exchanges.
06:13All right, joining me right now from China is my colleague,
06:17Senior Managing Editor, Gaurav Savant,
06:19getting us all the action and the ringside view of this trilateral.
06:24Gaurav, you know, 48 hours, Gaurav, after meeting Quad leaders,
06:29President Trump for this unprecedented historic trilateral,
06:32what does it speak to you of possibly maybe shifting priorities of Washington?
06:43Well, it does speak of great optics.
06:47In terms of optics, this was spectacular.
06:49Three of the world's most powerful nuclear weapons states,
06:53you know, the United States has about 5,000 nuclear warheads,
06:57Russia has about 5,400,
06:58China's trying to catch up and get close to about 1,000,
07:02according to a CIPRI report.
07:03And they're talking about one.
07:05President Trump talks about reducing the number of nuclear weapons,
07:08China says, why should this sort of debacleese hang over your head,
07:12get rid of all nuclear weapons comprehensively and thoroughly?
07:15Now, that's a very noble idea.
07:17How will that happen?
07:18Will others agree?
07:20So, in principle, great agreements.
07:23Actionable on ground is the biggest question.
07:26Time frame, absolutely no question about that.
07:29So, three world leaders meeting,
07:31will they set up a new security architecture?
07:33Well, Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff,
07:36U.S. President's special envoys,
07:38they've flown from Shenzhen all the way to Berlin,
07:41and they will be engaging now with the Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy
07:45and the European leadership.
07:46They were not on the table,
07:47and they don't agree that there should be a Yalta 2.0,
07:50where the three victors, as President Putin seemed to indicate,
07:53the three victors of the Second World War
07:55have a responsibility to decide stability and peace.
07:59Will Europe accept it?
08:01It appears unlikely.
08:02Will Ukraine accept it?
08:03Remains to be seen.
08:04But the situation on ground remains very volatile.
08:07So, optics have been great,
08:09substantive in terms of outcomes.
08:11There is a four-point declaration.
08:13That four-point declaration omits out a lot in terms of nuts and bolts.
08:18Will there be peace along the Strait of Hormuz?
08:21They'll say they'll pump more oil.
08:23Sure, you want to pump more oil,
08:25but how will you transport that oil through the Strait of Hormuz?
08:28That challenge still remains,
08:30or at least in public domain,
08:31that answer is still not there, Preeti.
08:34Got to stay with me.
08:34Let me also quickly bring in our colleague Pranay Upadhyay
08:37into this conversation.
08:38Pranay Upadhyay, you know,
08:40it does seem, you know,
08:42or mirror the shifting geopolitical sands as such.
08:4648 hours, Trump is meeting quad leaders,
08:49then unprecedented visit to China,
08:51now mixed signals there where China is concerned,
08:53and where does it leave the quad?
08:56If you take a larger picture here, Preeti,
08:58you can very well see that, you know,
09:00the old world order is crumbling.
09:02It is no longer relevant,
09:04and the new world order is taking shape.
09:07What will be the face and structure
09:08and nuts and bolts of the world order
09:09is yet to be decided.
09:11But, you know,
09:12the world is drifting towards a multipolarity.
09:15So, unipolar world,
09:16from a Cold War era,
09:18to unipolar world era,
09:19to now multipolarity,
09:20a new structure is trying to take some kind of shape.
09:23But what will be the future and destiny
09:25of this new structure?
09:27We don't know.
09:29Because here,
09:29the only meeting itself,
09:31or its optics,
09:32was the headline.
09:33The rest of the thing
09:34is only good English,
09:35good intent,
09:36but very weak on delivery,
09:38as Gaurav also mentioned,
09:40that as far as the statement is concerned,
09:42put out by these leaders.
09:43Either they actually discuss this thing,
09:45which doesn't mean anything
09:46in terms of delivery,
09:48or if they discuss something else
09:50and decided to put out this
09:51as a lowest common denominator
09:54of their discussion,
09:54we don't know as yet.
09:56But certainly,
09:57if you see what exactly they have agreed
09:59and where the national priorities,
10:01you know,
10:02are at loggerhead
10:03with what they have expressed
10:04in this joint statement,
10:05because it's the same United States
10:08and the same president
10:09under whose signature
10:10the United States
10:11has imposed penal tariff
10:13on India
10:14for buying Russian oil.
10:16It is the same United States
10:17which,
10:18or President Trump,
10:19who's having those power
10:20to impose
10:21over 100% tariff
10:23for any country
10:24which buys Russian oil.
10:25And it's the same United States
10:26which is buying Russian oil
10:28or Russian diesel.
10:30So,
10:30there are intrinsic conflicts
10:32and,
10:32you know,
10:33dichotomies
10:33as far as
10:34these national positions
10:35are concerned.
10:36But still,
10:37the very fact
10:37that they decided
10:38to meet,
10:39obviously,
10:40from India's perspective,
10:41any such development
10:42has its own caution
10:44and,
10:45you know,
10:45has its own relevance
10:47because this thing
10:48is taking shape
10:49in our close proximity
10:51in our neighborhood.
10:52You know,
10:53from the macro picture
10:54Pranay painted,
10:55Gaurav,
10:55would you want to go
10:56a bit micro in it
10:57and enable our viewers
10:58to understand
10:59and what is,
11:00you know,
11:01in it for India
11:02with clearly
11:03our new moves
11:04coming in from
11:05Washington
11:05vis-a-vis China.
11:10A multipolar world
11:12is India's message
11:13to the world
11:14anyways.
11:15So,
11:15you no longer
11:16do you have
11:16that Cold War
11:17architecture
11:17that you have
11:18an American block
11:20or a NATO block
11:20or a Soviet block
11:22behind the Iron Curtain
11:23countries.
11:23Those two blocks
11:25disintegrated.
11:26Is America
11:27a rising power?
11:28It does remain
11:28the number one power
11:29but it's challenged
11:30by the number two power
11:31which is China.
11:32Will both enable
11:33each other to grow?
11:34Clearly not.
11:36Are they trying
11:36to make common ground?
11:37Somewhere,
11:38yes,
11:39but will they,
11:39is it tactical
11:40or is it strategic?
11:41It's tactical,
11:42it can never be strategic
11:44when you look
11:45at the bigger picture.
11:46Where does India stand?
11:47India has to wait
11:48and watch.
11:50India's growth story
11:51is so powerful
11:52right now.
11:52China,
11:54Russia
11:54and the United States.
11:56All of us
11:57need each other
11:58in this world
11:59to grow.
12:00Where does it
12:01leave India?
12:02We'll watch
12:03how this
12:03multipolar world
12:04emerges.
12:05Is it a threat
12:06to India?
12:07Clearly not.
12:08Look at India's
12:08engagement with
12:09ASEAN countries.
12:10Are we putting
12:11all our eggs
12:11in either the
12:12Russian basket
12:13or the American basket?
12:14No.
12:14You're engaging
12:15with Europe,
12:16you're engaging
12:16with Canada,
12:17you're engaging
12:17with ASEAN countries,
12:19you're engaging
12:19with Australia,
12:20you're engaging
12:20with New Zealand,
12:21and you remain
12:22engaged with China
12:23and Russia remains
12:24a very close
12:25strategic partner
12:26as does the
12:27United States
12:27barring the
12:28remaining two
12:29years of the
12:30Trump presidency.
12:31You know,
12:32in the history
12:32of a nation,
12:33what's another
12:33two years,
12:34Preeti?
12:35All right,
12:35Pranay,
12:36you want to weigh
12:36in on that
12:36question?
12:37How would
12:37India be
12:37watching this?
12:38I know you've
12:38been raising
12:39your hand.
12:39Go ahead,
12:40Pranay.
12:40Yeah,
12:40I just wanted
12:41to make a
12:41point here,
12:42Preeti,
12:43and got to
12:45add to
12:46this joint
12:47statement.
12:47If you see,
12:48every paragraph
12:49here,
12:50as far as the
12:51promise of
12:51reform in
12:52the United
12:52Nations,
12:53it is the
12:53same President
12:53Donald Trump
12:54who has
12:55formed
12:55Board of
12:56Peace as
12:56an alternative
12:57to the
12:57United Nations,
12:58though it
12:58didn't work.
12:59But as far as
13:00the reform of
13:00the United Nations
13:01is concerned,
13:01India always advocated.
13:04Successively,
13:05our Prime
13:05Ministers have
13:06voiced the
13:07same concern
13:08that the
13:08current state
13:09and structure
13:09of the
13:10United Nations
13:10is not
13:11reflecting the
13:12current reality
13:12of the world.
13:13The most
13:13populous country
13:15on the planet
13:15is not even
13:16part of the
13:16United Nations
13:17Security Council.
13:17And all these
13:18three member states
13:19who are sitting
13:19on that table
13:20are the P5
13:21members,
13:21the Security
13:22Council members.
13:23Who has
13:23stopped so far
13:24the reform
13:25process of the
13:26United Nations
13:26and who hasn't
13:27delivered?
13:28So they are
13:28talking about
13:29United Nations
13:29reform.
13:30They want,
13:31it's a good
13:32intent,
13:32but they
13:33actually have to
13:34implement and
13:35get the ball
13:36rolling as
13:37far as the
13:37UN reform
13:38is concerned.
13:38As far as
13:39the denuclearization
13:40is concerned,
13:41see the state
13:42and as Gaurav
13:42mentioned,
13:43one country
13:44which has
13:44used nuclear
13:45weapon on
13:46this planet
13:46for the
13:46first time,
13:47we would like
13:49it to be
13:49last time,
13:50but that is
13:50the United
13:50States.
13:51The country
13:52which has
13:52the largest
13:52nuclear arsenal
13:53is Russia.
13:54The country
13:54which has
13:55the fastest
13:55growing nuclear
13:56arsenal or nuclear
13:57weapon armory,
13:59that is China,
13:59and they all
14:00three are talking
14:00about denuclearization.
14:02good,
14:02welcome,
14:03but what
14:04exactly is the
14:04implementation and
14:05what is the
14:06format?
14:06Can they enforce
14:08whatever they
14:09agree?
14:10Obviously,
14:10there are
14:11questions regarding
14:11that,
14:12but good that
14:13they have
14:13decided to
14:14come on table
14:14and decide
14:15about the
14:16piece,
14:16and if they
14:17are able to
14:18implement,
14:19the world
14:19would welcome
14:20that.
14:20Thank you
14:22gentlemen for
14:22joining us,
14:23Gaurav all the
14:23way from China,
14:24Pranik giving
14:25us the picture
14:26back home,
14:26appreciate you
14:27two there.
14:28With that,
14:29I want to
14:29quickly shift
14:30focus to all
14:31the domestic
14:32news that
14:32is coming in
14:33of Rahul
14:34Gandhi making
14:35statements offshore.
14:37From a war
14:38of words to a
14:39battle of scorecards,
14:40Prime Minister
14:40Modi and Rahul
14:41Gandhi are
14:42trading blows
14:42over India's
14:43growth story.
14:44While Modi
14:45flaunts a decade
14:46of transformation,
14:47GTA style,
14:48Rahul questions
14:48the economy's
14:49foundations,
14:50two very
14:50contrasting
14:51narratives,
14:52one political
14:53showdown.
14:58From the
14:59fragile five
15:00to the fastest
15:00growing major
15:01economy,
15:02from 27%
15:04extreme poverty
15:05to 2.6%
15:06and from
15:072.82
15:08gigawatts of
15:09solar power
15:10to 175
15:12gigawatts.
15:14Keeping up
15:15with the launch
15:15of Grand Theft
15:16Auto 6,
15:17Prime Minister
15:17Narendra Modi
15:18has put up
15:19an on-theme
15:19post saying
15:20India has
15:21levelled up
15:22between GTA
15:235 and 6.
15:25Drawing a
15:25parallel between
15:26India in
15:272013 and
15:28India in
15:282026,
15:29PM Modi
15:30declared that
15:31India is now
15:32playing a whole
15:32new game.
15:34The Prime
15:35Minister's post
15:36highlights progress
15:37across nine
15:38sectors, from
15:39the economy and
15:40sanitation to
15:41solar energy,
15:42space and
15:42defence.
15:43PM Modi
15:44also hailed
15:45India's
15:45economic growth
15:46at the
15:46Fikhi
15:46convention in
15:47New Delhi,
15:48saying the
15:48economy is
15:49projected to
15:50grow at
15:50about 7%.
16:15Prime Minister Modi's
16:16dig came as leader of
16:18opposition Rahul Gandhi
16:19reiterated vote-chori
16:20charges from foreign
16:21soil.
16:22Speaking at the
16:23University of Chicago,
16:24Rahul said the
16:25Congress would never
16:26abandon the electoral
16:27process because democracy
16:28is sacred to him.
16:30If we say that we are
16:33not going to contest
16:34elections, we end
16:36Indian democracy
16:37that minute.
16:37We do not want to
16:41break the electoral
16:43structure because
16:45once, if the
16:47opposition was to
16:48say we are not
16:48going to fight
16:49elections, in the
16:51mind of the
16:52Indian people, that
16:53process is now
16:54illegitimate.
16:55We don't want that.
16:56Earlier, during an
16:57interaction at Columbia
16:58University in New York,
17:00Rahul Gandhi questioned
17:01the government over
17:02its economic vision,
17:03approach to education
17:04and unemployment.
17:06The blunt thing is
17:07that India is sitting
17:08on an economic
17:09disaster.
17:11That's the reality.
17:14And one can brush
17:16it aside, the media
17:18can brush it aside,
17:19but India has got a
17:21massive unemployment
17:22problem.
17:23India has got a
17:24massive problem with
17:25its education system.
17:27And these are things
17:29then you're not going
17:29to get away from it.
17:31When Rahul took
17:32stock of economic
17:33distress abroad, PM
17:34Modi flashed a
17:35scorecard of
17:36transformation.
17:37As the war of
17:38words turns into a
17:39game of levelling up
17:40and upgrading, the
17:41real mission now is
17:42winning the narrative.
17:44Your report, India
17:45today.
17:49All right, let's cut
17:50across to our panelists
17:50this evening.
17:51Joining me, Priyanka
17:52Tibriwal, spokesperson,
17:53Bharatiya Janata
17:54Parti, Dr. Nishant
17:55Anand, national
17:55spokesperson, Congress,
17:57Rajat Sethi, political
17:58analyst, Arati
17:59Jairat, senior
18:00journalist.
18:01All of you will get
18:02two minutes' time to
18:02put your perspective
18:05forward.
18:05I'd like to begin with
18:07Ms. Priyanka
18:08Tibriwal.
18:08Priyanka Tibriwal, this
18:09is a question which has
18:10become a tad
18:11rhetorical by now.
18:13Why is it that the
18:14BJP and the government
18:15constantly compares to
18:18what Rahul Gandhi or
18:19conflates, Rahul Gandhi
18:20criticizing the Indian
18:22government to
18:23criticizing India?
18:24Both are extremely
18:25separate.
18:26He's the leader of
18:27opposition.
18:27His views in India are
18:29the ones he'll possibly
18:29echo abroad as well.
18:32Well, Priyanka, going
18:33on a foreign land and
18:34saying that, you know,
18:35we are in a very
18:37fearful situation or
18:38we are in a very bad
18:40situation or something
18:41very bad is going to
18:42happen in India.
18:42And this is not the
18:43just the first time
18:44on number of
18:45occasions he has done
18:46this.
18:47Now, if we just think
18:48about, you know, our
18:49relationship with
18:50Chicago, I think
18:51everybody will remember
18:53the speech delivered by
18:54Swami Vivekanan ji, which
18:56put India on a
18:57different platform where
18:58he spoke about our
18:59culture, where he spoke
19:00about our knowledge and
19:02everybody remembers that
19:03speech.
19:04And today Rahul Gandhi
19:05goes and what does he
19:06say?
19:07That India is not
19:08growing.
19:09India is not
19:09developing.
19:10Although all the
19:11agencies, whether it is
19:12the IMF, whether it is
19:13the World Bank,
19:14everybody is saying
19:15that, you know, India
19:16is going towards
19:17development.
19:18India is growing.
19:19But it is only Rahul
19:20Gandhi who cannot see
19:21the growth.
19:22This is nothing but his
19:23political frustration.
19:24This is nothing but
19:25after losing 90
19:26elections, this is what
19:27happens.
19:29You still have a minute to
19:31go, ma'am.
19:31Are you done?
19:33No, no, I'm not done.
19:34I can still continue.
19:35See, he speaks about
19:36vote shori.
19:37He speaks about saying
19:38that there is no
19:39democracy in India.
19:41If there is no
19:42democracy, day and
19:43night, evening to
19:44morning, we are seeing
19:45that Congress and their
19:46leaders are just
19:47abusing the Prime
19:48Minister.
19:49If there is no
19:50democracy, how are you
19:51doing that?
19:52Then he says that
19:54people are not allowed
19:56to vote here or
19:57people are voting
19:58more than once.
19:59He spoke about some
19:59Brazilian women also.
20:01But where are the
20:02evidences?
20:03No evidences.
20:04So it is, again,
20:05every time, fake
20:07things which he is
20:08trying to, you know,
20:09prove a point.
20:10I'll hold your
20:11timer, but I'll hold
20:12your timer, ma'am.
20:13But the question I'll
20:13ask you again is,
20:15you know, you quote
20:16Swami Vivekanand, but
20:17multiple times even
20:18after that, while
20:19Prime Minister Modi
20:20has been Prime
20:21Minister and I can take
20:22you through a number
20:23of speeches that he's
20:24made on foreign
20:24while criticizing.
20:25criticizing the
20:27government before
20:28his period.
20:29So the criticism of
20:30government cannot be
20:31conflated with
20:32criticism of the
20:32country.
20:35That's exactly what
20:36I am saying.
20:37That whether he was
20:38criticizing the
20:39government or whether
20:40he was criticizing
20:41the country, because
20:43you can criticize the
20:45government 110 times
20:46if they are not being
20:48able to do anything
20:49for the country.
20:50But here, where the
20:51country is already
20:51growing, there you are
20:53saying that India is
20:54in a bad state.
20:55You are asking
20:56foreign nations to
20:57interfere in our
20:58internal matters.
20:59Well, he forgets that
21:01India is a self-reliant
21:02sovereign power.
21:03Okay, now your time is
21:04up.
21:04I'll circle back to you
21:05because while you are
21:07quoting GDP data, Rahul
21:09Gandhi has brought up the
21:11GDP data abroad and said
21:12that it's not really
21:13reliable.
21:14And there are multiple,
21:15you know, data sets that
21:17can be interpreted
21:18differently.
21:18But having said that, I
21:19want to bring in the
21:20Congress spokesperson into
21:21this conversation.
21:22The fact, sir, is, yes,
21:25Rahul Gandhi is critical
21:26of the government and
21:27being leader of
21:28opposition.
21:28He's really not going to
21:30change his views when he
21:31speaks abroad.
21:32Yet, a question that has
21:34been raised multiple times
21:35is, what is the road
21:36map?
21:37So allow me to ask you
21:37this question.
21:38When Rahul Gandhi says
21:39that unemployment is a huge
21:41concern where India comes
21:43into question, what is the
21:45solution that Rahul Gandhi
21:46brings to it?
21:47Does he elucidate that
21:48abroad or he stops at
21:50criticising?
21:52Hi, good evening to all.
21:53See, after 12 years,
21:54Prime Minister Narendra
21:56Modi finally answered what
21:57he has been doing to this
21:58country.
21:59He has been playing grand
22:01theft auto, GTA.
22:03For 12 years, there was no
22:05answer for unemployment,
22:06no answers on inflation,
22:08no answers on broken
22:09promises.
22:10Today, by posting GTA 5 and
22:12GTA 6 graphics, he
22:13clarified that for 12 years,
22:15he treated governments like
22:17a video game.
22:18Narendra Modi played with
22:19India and Indians.
22:2012 years in office and the
22:22PM still treats Indians like
22:24NPC in his GTA fantasy.
22:26He has bending institutions
22:27like cheat codes in the game,
22:29running vote chori and
22:30chanda chori and stagging
22:32GTA 6 cutscenes while
22:34education, health,
22:35infrastructure, youth,
22:36farmers, citizens pay the
22:38price.
22:39Corruption, deceit and
22:40extortion.
22:41Mr. Anam, will you allow me
22:42to hold your timer?
22:43Because I understand, you
22:44know, instead of rehearsed
22:45replies of an attack on
22:47Prime Minister Modi, you're
22:48free to choose your time and
22:49do that, sir.
22:51You know, nobody's denying
22:51it.
22:52But I asked you a very
22:52pointed question.
22:53What is the solution?
22:55What is the troubleshooting
22:56that the leader of
22:56opposition brings to for
22:59where he says we're out of
23:01jobs, which possibly we are,
23:02but what's the road map?
23:04Riti ji, you will get the
23:05answer within my two minutes
23:07of time.
23:07I'm going to come to that
23:09point.
23:09Four years after the
23:12government's own 2022
23:13deadlines, the promises
23:14remain unmet.
23:16Doubling farmers income
23:17hasn't happened.
23:18Two crore jobs a year
23:19hasn't happened.
23:20Pakka housing for every
23:21family, it has not
23:23happened.
23:23175, renewable capacity
23:26has not happened.
23:27The government set these
23:28deadlines itself in 2022
23:30has already come and gone
23:31without any accountability.
23:33Now, in Shanghai and
23:34Seoul, in May 2015,
23:36speaking to Indian
23:38diaspora audiences,
23:40Modi said people were
23:41once ashamed of being
23:42born in India.
23:43And if you remember
23:44that remark rendered in
23:46India, if he thinks he
23:48can win over Gen Z with
23:49video game graphics, he
23:51is living in La La
23:52Land.
23:53The reference to Grand
23:54Tech Auto is deeply
23:55ironic because the game
23:56is about hardened
23:57criminals who indulge in
23:59theft, robbery,
24:01violence and chaos.
24:02And Modi ji is
24:03celebrating.
24:04Now tell me, what is
24:05GTA 1?
24:06Rozgar Chori.
24:08What is GTA 2?
24:08Note Chori.
24:10What is GTA 3?
24:11Saval Chori.
24:12No press conference,
24:12attack on protesters,
24:13social media takedowns.
24:15What is GTA 4?
24:15Your time is up and you
24:17did not answer my
24:17question.
24:18You said you will, but
24:19you didn't answer my
24:20question.
24:20I'll give you two
24:21minutes later, you
24:21know, to maybe come
24:23down to it.
24:23Rajat Sethi, well, this
24:24conversation is pretty
24:26much on the one we had
24:27last night at 9pm, but
24:28allow me to ask you the
24:29question again, but
24:30because things have
24:31moved on in the last
24:3224 hours.
24:33It is, Rajat, if you
24:34admit it, it's getting
24:35rather jaded to
24:36constantly criticise the
24:37leader of opposition or
24:38call him anti-national or
24:40attacking India.
24:41People see through it.
24:42He's not attacking India.
24:43He's not being anti-national.
24:44He's clearly attacking the
24:46policies of this government
24:47abroad.
24:49So, why are you pointing
24:50that question to me?
24:51See, I'm free to analyse.
24:53No, no, go ahead.
24:55Because I'm just saying,
24:56you know, one needs to
24:57come up with better
24:57criticism is the question.
24:59Okay, let me try.
25:00Because now it's gone.
25:02Okay, so let me try and
25:04convince you that the
25:05argument now is far better
25:07than last night.
25:08No, no, not about last
25:09night, but go ahead.
25:10I'm just saying, the one
25:11which is coming in from the
25:12BJP or the government is
25:14that this is anti-India and
25:15anti-national and he's
25:16attacking the country.
25:16That's getting a tad old.
25:19No, no.
25:19So, again, he might be
25:21doing his politics.
25:22He feels that going at
25:23Columbia University gives
25:25him an international
25:26platform and perhaps, if
25:28not through Indian
25:29platforms, it is this
25:29international platform from
25:31where he speaks, then the
25:32Indian voters will
25:33eventually hear him.
25:35I think that should be the
25:36political logic behind
25:37this, doing this.
25:37I'm sure that addressing
25:40the American audience is
25:41not the objective of Rahul
25:42Gandhiji on this.
25:43Because he's been doing
25:44these tactics for the
25:46past 12 years.
25:48This is not the first time
25:49that he has gone to one of
25:50the Ivy Leagues.
25:51So, people have been
25:53listening, the voters have
25:54been listening and trying to
25:55adjust and understand whether
25:57there is an intent behind what
25:59he says or not.
26:00And for the past 12 years, the
26:01voters have unanimously
26:03decided that what he is
26:05saying is nothing more than,
26:07you know, political, sorry,
26:10philosophical sort of word
26:12salad.
26:13Beyond this philosophical word
26:15salad, they don't see any
26:16substance.
26:17If they see a substance or this
26:19leader coming in with a
26:22plethora of new ideas who are
26:23going to transform their lives,
26:25they would have voted for him.
26:26They would have voted for him in
26:28multiple states and in the
26:29national election.
26:30You cannot say that I won 99
26:31seats and that is my trophy.
26:33Clearly, you are sitting in
26:34opposition for the third
26:35consecutive time.
26:36And if this carries on, he is
26:38going to continue in opposition.
26:40So my point is you will have to
26:42come out because there is a lot
26:44of baggage that sits on the
26:46Gandhi family of not delivering
26:48in the previous tenures when
26:50they were in power and absolute
26:51power for decades and decades.
26:54So the people are going to ask
26:55this question that where is the
26:57substance behind your
26:58accusations?
26:59What do you honestly feel you can
27:01transform about India's growth
27:02story?
27:03Because otherwise he will keep on
27:05saying self-contradictory
27:06things.
27:07Today he said election is
27:08problematic.
27:08problematic, but he also said
27:09that he cannot break the
27:10democracy.
27:11In India, he said democracy is
27:13already dead and boring.
27:14Okay.
27:15So your two minutes is up.
27:18Aarti Jairat, allow me to ask
27:20you the question which Ranjit
27:21also raised.
27:21What is the intent of Rahul
27:23Gandhi of saying what he does
27:26abroad?
27:27Who is he speaking with?
27:28Is it narrative building?
27:29And if so, does it really matter
27:31back home in India?
27:32It's not something he hasn't done
27:33before.
27:33While in India, while he's taking
27:35the issue of vote-chory of the
27:38election commission to the people,
27:41he's seemingly getting under the
27:42skin of the government.
27:43This is resorting to an old
27:45playbook, which the BJP knows
27:47very well to exploit.
27:51Priti, I would also, you know,
27:54I'd like to ask a counter-question.
27:56Ask a counter-question.
27:57What is the purpose of Narendra Modi
28:01going abroad and addressing NRI
28:04gatherings as if he's addressing an
28:07election rally?
28:08Does that serve, what is the purpose
28:10that that serves?
28:11So, I mean, I think it's very much in
28:15the same genre.
28:17He's not addressing, you know, a
28:19Madison Square Garden rally, which has
28:21lots of NRIs present.
28:23He's addressing, you know, universities.
28:27And if you look at the, you know,
28:29composition of the crowd, a lot of
28:31them are Indian students because we do
28:34have a huge number of Indian students
28:36studying in the United States,
28:39particularly in the top colleges,
28:40because Indians are, you know, good and
28:42they get into these top colleges.
28:44So, I think he is, just like Narendra
28:48Modi, addresses NRIs when he goes
28:51abroad, the Indian diaspora when he
28:53goes abroad, to send a message back
28:55home through them because they will
28:58communicate to their families.
29:01I think, you know, Rahul Gandhi does a
29:03similar thing through these Indian
29:05students who are studying in these
29:06universities who will communicate to
29:09their families back home.
29:10I mean, it's much the same thing.
29:13You know, why should we criticize him
29:15for doing exactly what the Prime
29:17Minister does on a slightly, on a much
29:20smaller scale?
29:22So, you know, I mean, honestly, and I,
29:25you know, completely agree with your
29:27point that criticizing the government's
29:29policy should not be conflated with
29:32anti-nationalism or a criticism of the
29:35country.
29:35It is to do specifically with policies of
29:39the Indian government.
29:40And yes, I think you do have a point
29:43that while criticizing, it would be good
29:46if he were to offer an alternative
29:48vision, we, I think that alternative
29:50vision still has to be crafted by the
29:53government.
29:53All right.
29:54Okay.
29:54I would reckon this would be final
29:56comments.
29:56I want to go back to the BJP spokesperson.
29:59And ma'am, the question that I asked you
30:00earlier and possibly the question at the
30:02cost of repetition that I had asked
30:04Rajat as well.
30:04The point is, data can be interpreted
30:08various ways.
30:09And there's multiple set of data which
30:11seems to corroborate the points that you
30:13make on the economy and other, you know,
30:16markers or possibly which Rahul Gandhi
30:19makes.
30:20But at the end of it, to constantly attack
30:22him and berate him, to call him anti-national,
30:25anti-India, would you reckon that charge has
30:27gotten a tad too old right now?
30:29That the government and the BJP needs to
30:31come up with a new form of attacking the
30:33leader of opposition?
30:36We don't need to attack him.
30:38We don't need to attack him.
30:39Anybody for that matter in India would say
30:42that being a true nationalist or an Indian,
30:44you would not go on a foreign land and
30:46speak bad about your own country.
30:48If you cannot add anything to it or do
30:51anything additional for the development
30:52of the nation, at least you should not go
30:55and defame your own country.
30:57And forget whatever allegations, whatever
30:59he's saying against the government.
31:00I mean, he's the leader of opposition.
31:04That is his work.
31:04He can do.
31:05But every time he is resorting to Photoshop
31:07and fabricated evidences.
31:09When asked to...
31:10Madam, allow me to hold your timer.
31:12Allow me to hold your timer.
31:14And the reason when you say what you said,
31:16and again, at the cost of repetition,
31:18because I think it's been repeated multiple times
31:20over many years since Rahul Gandhi has been
31:23going abroad and making charges at the government,
31:26what the prime minister said,
31:27and I will give it to you with date.
31:30Denmark, May 2022.
31:32India was one of the most backward nations
31:34a few years ago.
31:35This was the words of an incumbent prime minister.
31:38Berlin, Germany, May 2022.
31:41A hand used to snatch away 85 paisa in one rupee.
31:44Multiple other charges, the biggest of them
31:46in Shanghai, China.
31:48Earlier you were ashamed of India,
31:49but today you are proud.
31:50I don't think anybody was quite ashamed of India, ma'am.
31:52But the fact is he was allowed to say,
31:54and he should say exactly what he feels like.
31:57Him criticizing an earlier government
32:00or government policies
32:01didn't tantamount to criticizing India before.
32:04The Congress spokesperson,
32:06I heard him speaking where he was saying that,
32:09you know, this did not happen,
32:10this did not happen,
32:11this did not happen.
32:12Since 2014, the BJP is in power in India.
32:16We have also seen that scams like 2G spectrum
32:19did not happen.
32:20Scams like coal block allocation did not happen.
32:22Commonwealth story did not happen.
32:24Cash for words did not happen.
32:26Bofors did not happen.
32:27National Herald did not happen.
32:28When my prime minister was speaking abroad
32:31and saying what India had suffered in the past,
32:33I think he meant about all these scams,
32:36which India has not witnessed
32:37after Narendra Modi has become
32:40the prime minister of India.
32:43Okay, ma'am.
32:44I just want to remind you
32:45that 2G scam and coal scam all were acquitted.
32:48So it seems it didn't happen,
32:50but that's just a factual check.
32:52But I take your submissions on everything else.
32:55I want to go back to the Congress spokesperson,
32:57and I want to bring him back,
32:59and hopefully he will ask the question
33:01that I had posed earlier.
33:02So, Dr. Ranand,
33:04would you care to elucidate
33:07what does the leader of opposition have to offer?
33:10Let's take his word
33:12that there are no jobs in this country,
33:14abysmal inflation.
33:16What does he have on the table
33:18in terms of solutions?
33:21Yes.
33:22See, what did Rahul Gandhi said today and yesterday?
33:24That look at the government's own number of jobs
33:26and prices.
33:28The periodic labor forces survey
33:29puts youth unemployment at 15%.
33:33Real wages for salaried employees
33:35has increased till 2019.
33:37Rice went from 28 rupees
33:39to over 48 rupees a kilo.
33:41Toordal has increased from 70 to 136.
33:44So it had three times as increased.
33:46And as I said earlier,
33:47farmers' income and creating two crore jobs a year,
33:50none of these promises have made it to the practical.
33:54Instead of answering a single unscripted press conference
33:56in 12 years,
33:57the government attacked Sri Rahul Gandhi
33:59for stating these exact published facts
34:02at the Columbia University and Chicago
34:04for calling the government's own inflation,
34:06debt and job numbers.
34:08Anti-India is not a rebuttal.
34:09It is an invasion.
34:11As Rahul Gandhi made clear in Chicago,
34:13Indian democracy is sacred
34:14and the opposition will never boycott elections.
34:17We will stay on the field,
34:18contest and expose every regality.
34:21Sir Anand Alami, to hold your timer,
34:22how is the LOP suggesting that he will,
34:26what's his vision for job creation in this country?
34:30As Rahul Gandhi said,
34:32that first of all,
34:33we have to make sure
34:34that the grand theft
34:35which has been happening,
34:36Prime Minister Modi,
34:38wherein we talk about
34:38from Ram Mandir to Vodchori,
34:40now they have come up with
34:41Rade Rade Kamal Khilade,
34:43they have already have 470 Kamal Mahal.
34:45So the question is,
34:46why there is no answer for the education?
34:48Why there is no answer on unemployment?
34:51Why there is no answer on infrastructure?
34:52What's his answer, sir?
34:54What is the LOP's answer
34:56to the issue of unemployment?
34:58The manufacturing should be increased.
35:00The industries should be increased.
35:03The China, the America,
35:04they should not guide Pranamantri Modi
35:06way to buy the oil,
35:07way to do the investment.
35:09They should be,
35:10like the import duty and trading,
35:12like 500 billion investments
35:13is being forced upon India
35:15because Modi could not answer Trump.
35:18So all these points have been raised.
35:20And the main point is that
35:21BJP has a government in 22 states,
35:23but they have not come up
35:25with a single school or a university
35:27that they have created
35:28in the last 12 years.
35:29So how will the students will study?
35:31And how will these people
35:32will get the job?
35:33All right, sir, your time is up.
35:34I need to give one minute each
35:36to our political analysts.
35:38Ranjit Sethi,
35:39would you want to go first?
35:39Close in comment, sir.
35:42Okay, so how do I close?
35:44My, okay, my point is that,
35:46see, Rahul Gandhi,
35:47I think Aarti ji got me wrong.
35:49There is absolutely no problem
35:51in how he wants to conduct his politics.
35:54Rahul Gandhi decides
35:55that organizational building
35:57in Uttar Pradesh,
35:58which is about to go into elections
35:59three or four months,
36:00maybe three months from now,
36:02that is not a priority.
36:03You don't want to go out
36:05and do the laborious task,
36:07but instead you want to,
36:08at the first opportune moment
36:09that you get,
36:10you will fly out either to Taiwan,
36:11Vietnam or US,
36:13and you go and project there.
36:14Maybe that is his political strategy.
36:16Good luck to him.
36:17But is the pendulum swinging
36:20in his favor?
36:21Are his advisors not seeing
36:23that things are not translating
36:24into the ground?
36:25What is he trying to do over there
36:27when his organization
36:28is hollowed out
36:29and corroded from inside?
36:30And then he will go out
36:31and again blame
36:32the election process, sir,
36:34rigged.
36:34When you haven't put up
36:35a solid fight
36:36that you should have
36:37by doing the laborious task,
36:39contrast to this
36:40to the BJP,
36:41if Prime Minister Modi
36:42goes out and speaks.
36:44Okay, sir,
36:45one minute,
36:46Aarti Jairat,
36:47one minute time, ma'am.
36:48Closing comments.
36:50I would like to ask
36:52the same question
36:52as Rajat Sethi.
36:53How do I close?
36:55Well, I mean, listen,
36:57as I said earlier,
36:59Narendra Modi goes
37:00and, you know,
37:01addresses the diaspora.
37:03Rahul Gandhi goes
37:04and addresses the diaspora.
37:05Yes, he does have
37:06an organization problem
37:07and he needs to address
37:09that very seriously
37:10and I hope he will.
37:12So for the sake of,
37:13for the sake of
37:15Indian democracy,
37:16actually,
37:16because Indian democracy
37:17needs a vibrant
37:19and robust opposition.
37:21It's, you know,
37:22it cannot be
37:23a one-sided affair
37:24with the ruling party
37:25just dominating everything.
37:27So it is vitally important
37:29that the opposition
37:30is present
37:32in enough numbers
37:33to question the government.
37:35It is equally important
37:37that the government
37:37answer those questions
37:40because we need transparency
37:42from the government.
37:43That is what parliament
37:44is all about.
37:45It's unfortunate
37:46that parliament
37:46is not allowed to function
37:48the way it should
37:48so we never get answers
37:50from anybody.
37:51Time up, ma'am.
37:52I appreciate all four of you
37:53for taking the time out
37:54this evening and joining us.
37:56You know, ultimately,
37:57on both sides of the divide,
37:58new narratives
37:59need to be built.
38:00If Rahul Gandhi
38:00is going to criticize issues
38:02that plague India,
38:03then he should also be able
38:05to offer solutions.
38:06What does he have to offer?
38:08On the other hand,
38:08the old script
38:10of being anti-India,
38:11anti-national
38:12if you criticize
38:13government policies abroad
38:14is a tad bit too old.
38:17With that,
38:17I want to quickly dip
38:18into some news breaks
38:19that we are getting in,
38:20both coming in
38:21from Uttar Pradesh.
38:22The first one,
38:23UP Chief Minister
38:24Yogi Adityanath
38:25has met the family
38:27of the young boy
38:28who died in Gorakhpur.
38:30Victims' parents say
38:31Akhilesh Yadav
38:32is responsible.
38:33Yogi rains fire
38:35says roads are meant
38:37for travel,
38:37not for creating anarchy.
38:39The actions
38:39of the Samajwadi Party
38:40chief and his people
38:42are a disgrace
38:43to humanity.
38:44Having previously
38:45devastated the state
38:46through the mafia,
38:47they are now attempting
38:48to revive such
38:49hooliganism.
38:50This at the back
38:51of the unfortunate
38:53demise of a young boy
38:54during a Samajwadi Party rally.
39:02CMA Yogi Adityanath
39:03is now coming to be
39:05You can see
39:05that he is here
39:05and he is here
39:06and he is talking about
39:07the people who are
39:09and he is talking about
39:20the people who are
39:24talking about
39:24and they are talking about
39:26I am
39:26a
39:28a
39:29a
39:30a
39:32a
39:35a
39:36a
39:44a
39:45a
39:45a
39:45a
39:45a
39:46a
39:46a
39:47a
39:54a
39:56a
39:56a
39:57a
40:00a
40:01a
40:01a
40:02a
40:02a
40:04a
40:08a
40:09a
40:09a
40:13a
40:13a
40:14a
40:14a
40:14a
40:15a
40:16a
40:17a
40:18a
40:18a
40:19a
40:19a
40:21a
40:22a
40:23a
40:23a
40:23a
40:23a
40:23a
40:24a
40:24a
40:25a
40:26a
40:27a
40:28a
40:29a
40:30a
40:30a
40:30a
40:30a
40:34a
40:34a
40:34a
40:34a
40:34a
40:34a
40:37a
40:37a
40:37a
40:37a
40:48a
40:50a
40:52a
40:53a
40:53a
40:53a
40:55a
40:57a
40:58a
41:03a
41:04a
41:04a
41:04a
41:06a
41:06a
41:06a
41:07a
41:08a
41:08a
41:14a
41:16a
41:17a
41:17a
41:17a
41:18a
41:22a
41:23a
41:27a
41:29a
41:30a
41:32a
41:33a
41:34a
41:35a
41:35a
41:36a
41:41a
41:42a
41:44a
41:44a
41:44a
41:48a
41:50a
41:52a
41:57a
41:58a
41:58a
42:01a
42:04a
42:04a
42:04a
42:04a
42:04a
42:04a
42:16a
42:16a
42:16a
42:16a
42:17a
42:17a
42:17a
42:17a
42:17a
42:17a
42:17a
42:17a
42:17a
42:18a
42:18a
42:18a
42:19a
42:20a
42:22a
42:26a
42:27a
42:27a
42:28a
42:28a
42:30a
42:30a
42:30a
42:40a
42:41a
42:45a
42:45a
42:46a
42:47a
42:47a
42:51a
42:52a
42:55a
43:03a
43:04a
43:10a
43:11a
43:12a
43:12a
43:12a
43:15a
43:15a
43:16a
43:17a
43:17a
43:18a
43:20a
43:21a
43:21a
43:21a
43:23a
43:24a
43:26a
43:28a
43:28a
43:33a
43:35a
43:36a
43:36a
43:36a
43:36a
43:37a
43:39a
43:40a
43:42a
43:44a
43:53a
43:55a
43:55a
43:56a
43:56a
43:57a
43:57a
43:57a
43:57a
43:57a
43:57a
43:57a
44:08a
44:08a
44:09a
44:11a
44:21a
44:22a
44:24a
44:25a
44:26a
44:27a
44:27a
44:27a
44:27a
44:27a
44:35a
44:36a
44:36a
44:37a
44:37a
44:37a
44:37a
44:38a
44:48a
44:50a
44:50a
44:50a
44:50a
45:05a
45:05a
45:06this time
45:07around
45:07the complaint
45:08is from
45:08india blog
45:09saying that
45:11rampur
45:12rampur had
45:12well in
45:12advance
45:13alerted
45:14india blog
45:14about
45:15the
45:15problems
45:15the
45:16one
45:16on the cards how rampur by polls were elections were looted and nobody raised that question and
45:22he indicated as to how he's facing a lot of legal trouble and possibly that is why the opposition
45:27parties did not come together on his name but it is very interesting the way he responded to that
45:33question of sadhavesi because we had seen in the past as to how mim made the entry you know you
45:39have chan shikhar azad and sadhavesi's party being in alliance and yet also expressed his concerns
45:46about well-being of azan khan today he said responding to my question in the earlier briefing
45:53as well that you know if he was so concerned about me uh my house was a few kilometers away
46:01from the
46:01spot he made that statement could have easily gone to my house spoken to my wife my family
46:06and expressed his uh greetings or wishes for me well wishes for me and along with that he also
46:13made that uh in his own style the uh style that he's known for he said that uh in this
46:19particular
46:19area where we are sitting hyderabad the biryani is not much like uh so his messaging is clear in that
46:25manner as well and this particular statement would be a big sigh of relief for uh samadwadi party chief
46:31fakalisha adhava as well back to you priti all right amit thank you there with that uh quick update
46:37lots uh going to go down especially uh where the up elections are concerned this is just the beginning
46:43much like what azam khan said