- 9 minutes ago
Trump, Xi Jinping, and Putin met in Shenzhen for a peace summit covering nuclear and energy security. India’s leaders debated economic progress and social issues.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:14All right, three of the world's most powerful leaders on one table in Shenzhen,
00:19U.S. President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin
00:23all came together for the first time ever trilateral summit.
00:27On the sidelines of the APEC gathering, with the meeting lasting about an hour and a half,
00:34the Shenzhen trilateral has produced a joint peace declaration outlining areas of cooperation
00:39on nuclear security, global stability, U.N. reform, and energy security.
00:44The declaration mentions reducing nuclear risks and preventing proliferation,
00:50reaffirming that nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought.
00:54The leaders have also called for stable energy flows and respect for state sovereignty.
00:58The declaration also takes aim at the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court.
01:04But it does also leave out any mention of the Ukraine or Iran wars.
01:09Artificial intelligence, semiconductors, Taiwan and global supply chains,
01:14some of the biggest geopolitical and economic fault lines also find no place in this joint statement.
01:24And today we'll be talking about all of the problems that are really being discussed in the world.
01:32We are going to be discussing the war between Russia and Ukraine, and we already have.
01:37President Putin and I have had a long discussion today for quite a while.
01:41That's what pretty much what the discussion was about.
01:46And I think things are happening.
01:48I think that he and I hope the other side would like to see an end to that.
01:52But it's also vital that we cooperate to combat the threat of nuclear proliferation in other countries around the world.
02:00That's what we're doing in Iran.
02:01We're not going to let Iran have a nuclear weapon.
02:04And to that end today, we'll be talking about all of the problems that are really being discussed in the
02:13world.
02:13We are going to be discussing the war between Russia and Ukraine, and we already have.
02:18President Putin and I have had a long discussion today for quite a while.
02:22That's pretty much what the discussion was about.
02:27And I think things are happening.
02:29I think that he and I hope the other side would like to see an end to that.
02:34In another area of potential cooperation between us,
02:37I'll be suggesting ways to protect our nation's sovereignty from rogue globalist organizations,
02:43such as the International Criminal Court, which has gotten out of control,
02:48which I believe we all agree has really strayed far from beyond its jurisdiction.
02:55For my part, I'm convinced that Russia, China and the United States and our respective people
03:01are capable of making a significant contribution to strengthening global security and stability,
03:06providing they engage in constructive partnership-based cooperation
03:10rooted in mutual respect, equality, and a balance of interests.
03:15To respond to constantly emerging global challenges,
03:19we should strengthen capacity building,
03:21promote regional cooperation on energy and food security,
03:25and deepen anti-corruption governance across borders.
03:29We should coordinate the development of the resources, the environment, and population,
03:35scale up the rational utilization and protection of natural resources,
03:40and expand green and low-carbon cooperation to achieve sustainable economic growth.
03:47We should support livelihood improvements and invest in the people,
03:51launch healthy aging programs,
03:54facilitate employment and the development of vocational skills,
03:58and support women's economic empowerment and young talent exchanges.
04:07All right, joining me right now from China is my colleague,
04:10Senior Managing Editor, Gaurav Savant,
04:13getting us all the action and the ringside view of this trilateral.
04:17Gaurav, you know, 48 hours, Gaurav, after meeting Quad leaders,
04:22President Trump for this unprecedented historic trilateral,
04:26what does it speak to you of possibly maybe shifting priorities of Washington?
04:36Well, it does speak of great optics.
04:40In terms of optics, this was spectacular.
04:43Three of the world's most powerful nuclear weapons states,
04:47you know, the United States has about 5,000 nuclear warheads,
04:50Russia has about 5,400,
04:52China's trying to catch up and get close to about 1,000,
04:55according to a CIPRI report.
04:57And they're talking about one.
04:59President Trump talks about reducing the number of nuclear weapons.
05:02China says,
05:02Why should this throne of democracy hang over your head,
05:05get rid of all nuclear weapons comprehensively and thoroughly?
05:09Now, that's a very noble idea.
05:11How will that happen?
05:12Will others agree?
05:13So, in principle,
05:15great agreements.
05:16Actionable on ground is the biggest question.
05:19Time frame?
05:20Absolutely no question about that.
05:22So, three world leaders meeting.
05:24Will they set up a new security architecture?
05:26Well, Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff,
05:29U.S. President's special envoys,
05:31they've flown from Shenzhen all the way to Berlin
05:35and they will be engaging now with the Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky
05:38and the European leadership.
05:39They were not on the table
05:41and they don't agree that there should be a Yalta 2.0
05:43where the three victors, as President Putin seemed to indicate,
05:47the three victors of the Second World War
05:49have a responsibility to decide stability and peace.
05:53Will Europe accept it?
05:54It appears unlikely.
05:56Will Ukraine accept it?
05:57Remains to be seen.
05:58But the situation on ground remains very volatile.
06:00So, optics have been great.
06:03Substantive in terms of outcomes.
06:05There is a four-point declaration.
06:07That four-point declaration omits out a lot
06:10in terms of nuts and bolts.
06:12Will there be peace along the Strait of Hormuz?
06:15They'll say they'll pump more oil.
06:17For sure, you want to pump more oil.
06:18But how will you transport that oil
06:20through the Strait of Hormuz?
06:21That challenge still remains.
06:23Or at least in public domain,
06:24that answer is still not there, Preeti.
06:27Got to stay with me.
06:28Let me also quickly bring in our colleague Pranay Upadhyay
06:31into this conversation.
06:32Pranay Upadhyay, you know,
06:34it does seem, you know, or mirror
06:36the shifting geopolitical sands as such.
06:3948 hours, Trump is meeting Quad leaders.
06:42Then unprecedented visit to China.
06:44Mixed signals there where China is concerned
06:47and where does it leave the Quad?
06:49If you take a larger picture here, Preeti,
06:52you can very well see that, you know,
06:54the old world order is crumbling.
06:56It is no longer relevant.
06:58And the new world order is taking shape.
07:00What will be the face and structure
07:02and nuts and bolts of that world order
07:03is yet to be decided.
07:05But, you know, the world is drifting
07:07towards a multipolarity.
07:08So, unipolar world from a Cold War era
07:11to unipolar world era
07:12to now multipolarity,
07:14a new structure is trying to take
07:16some kind of shape.
07:17But what will be the future and destiny
07:18of this new structure?
07:21We don't know.
07:22Because here,
07:23the only meeting itself
07:25or its optics was the headline.
07:27The rest of the thing
07:28is only good English, good intent,
07:30but very weak on delivery
07:32as Gaurav also mentioned
07:33that as far as the statement
07:34is concerned put out by these leaders,
07:37either they actually discuss this thing
07:39which doesn't mean anything
07:40in terms of delivery
07:41or if they discuss something else
07:43and decided to put out this
07:45as a lowest common denominator
07:47of their discussion,
07:48we don't know as yet.
07:50But certainly,
07:50if you see what exactly
07:52they have agreed
07:53and where the national priorities,
07:54you know,
07:55are at loggerhead
07:56with what they have expressed
07:58in this joint statement,
07:59because it's the same United States
08:02and the same president
08:02under whose signature
08:04the United States
08:05has imposed penal tariffs
08:07on India
08:07for buying Russian oil.
08:09It is the same United States
08:11which,
08:11or President Trump,
08:13who's having those power
08:14to impose
08:15over 100% tariff
08:16for any country
08:17which buys Russian oil.
08:19And it's the same United States
08:20which is buying Russian oil
08:21or Russian diesel.
08:23So,
08:23there are intrinsic conflicts
08:25and, you know,
08:26dichotomies
08:27as far as these national positions
08:28are concerned.
08:29But still,
08:30the very fact
08:31that they decided
08:32to meet,
08:33obviously,
08:33from India's perspective,
08:35any such development
08:36has its own caution
08:38and, you know,
08:39has its own relevance
08:40because this thing
08:41is taking shape
08:42in our close proximity
08:44in our neighborhood.
08:46You know,
08:47from the macro picture
08:47Pranay painted,
08:49Gaurav,
08:49would you want to go
08:49a bit micro in it
08:51and enable our viewers
08:52to understand
08:53in what is,
08:53you know,
08:55in it for India
08:55with clearly
08:56our new moves
08:58coming in from
08:58Washington
08:59vis-a-vis China?
09:04A multipolar world
09:05is India's message
09:07to the world
09:07anyways.
09:08So,
09:09you no longer
09:09do you have
09:10that Cold War
09:10architecture
09:11that you have
09:12an American block
09:13or a NATO block
09:14or a Soviet block
09:16behind the Iron Curtain
09:17countries.
09:17Those two blocks
09:18disintegrated.
09:19Is America
09:20a rising power?
09:21It does remain
09:22the number one power
09:23but it's challenged
09:24by the number two power
09:25which is China.
09:26Will both enable
09:27each other to grow?
09:28Clearly not.
09:29Are they trying
09:30to make common ground?
09:31Somewhere yes
09:32but will they,
09:33is it tactical
09:34or is it strategic?
09:35It's tactical,
09:36it can never be strategic
09:37when you look
09:38at the bigger picture.
09:39Where does India stand?
09:41India has to wait
09:42and watch.
09:43India's growth story
09:44is so powerful
09:45right now.
09:47China,
09:47Russia
09:48and the United States.
09:49All of us
09:50need each other
09:51in this world
09:52to grow.
09:53Where does it
09:54leave India?
09:55We'll watch
09:56how this multipolar
09:57world emerges
09:58is it a threat
10:00to India?
10:00Clearly not.
10:01Look at India's
10:02engagement with
10:02ASEAN countries.
10:04Are we putting
10:04all our eggs
10:05in either the
10:05Russian basket
10:06or the American
10:07basket?
10:07No.
10:08You're engaging
10:08with Europe,
10:09you're engaging
10:10with Canada,
10:10you're engaging
10:11with ASEAN countries,
10:12you're engaging
10:13with Australia,
10:14you're engaging
10:14with New Zealand,
10:15you remain engaged
10:16with China
10:16and Russia remains
10:18a very close
10:19strategic partner
10:19as does the
10:20United States
10:21barring the
10:22remaining two years
10:23of the Trump
10:24presidency.
10:25You know,
10:25in the history
10:26of a nation,
10:26what's another
10:27two years,
10:27Preeti?
10:29All right,
10:29Prane,
10:29you want to
10:29weigh in on
10:30that question?
10:30How would
10:31India be
10:31watching this?
10:32I know you've
10:32been raising
10:32your hand.
10:33Go ahead,
10:33Prane.
10:34Yeah,
10:34I just wanted
10:35to make a
10:35point here,
10:36Preeti,
10:37and got to
10:38add to
10:40this joint
10:40statement.
10:41If you see
10:41every paragraph
10:43here,
10:43as far as the
10:44promise of
10:45reform in
10:45the United
10:46Nations,
10:46it's the same
10:47President Donald
10:47Trump who
10:48has formed
10:49Board of Peace
10:49as an alternative
10:50to the United
10:51Nations,
10:51though it didn't
10:52work.
10:52But as far as
10:53the reform of
10:54the United
10:54Nations is
10:55concerned,
10:55India always
10:56advocated.
10:58Successively,
10:58our Prime
10:59Ministers have
11:00voiced the
11:00same concern
11:01that the
11:02current state
11:02and structure
11:03of the United
11:03Nations is
11:04not reflecting
11:05the current
11:06reality of the
11:06world.
11:07The most
11:07populous country
11:08on the planet
11:09is not even
11:09part of the
11:10United Nations
11:10Security Council.
11:11And all these
11:12three member
11:12states who are
11:13sitting on that
11:13table are the
11:14P5 members,
11:15the Security
11:15Council members.
11:16Who has
11:17stopped so far
11:18the reform
11:18process of the
11:19United Nations
11:20and who hasn't
11:21delivered?
11:21So they are
11:22talking about
11:22United Nations
11:23reform.
11:24They want,
11:25it's a good
11:25intent, but
11:26they actually
11:27have to implement
11:28and get the
11:30ball rolling as
11:31far as the
11:31UN reform is
11:32concerned.
11:32As far as the
11:33denuclearization is
11:34concerned, see
11:35the state and
11:35as Gaurav
11:36mentioned, one
11:37country which
11:38has used
11:38nuclear weapon
11:39on this planet
11:40for the first
11:40time, we would
11:42like it to be
11:43last time, but
11:44that is the
11:44United States.
11:45The country
11:45which has the
11:46largest nuclear
11:46arsenal is Russia.
11:47The country
11:48which has the
11:48fastest growing
11:49nuclear arsenal
11:50or nuclear
11:51weapon armory,
11:52that is China,
11:53and they all
11:53three are talking
11:54about denuclearization.
11:55Good, welcome.
11:56But what exactly
11:58is the implementation
11:58and what is the
11:59format?
12:00Can they enforce
12:02whatever they
12:03agree?
12:03Obviously, there
12:04are questions
12:05regarding that,
12:05but good that
12:06they have decided
12:07to come on
12:08table and decide
12:08about the
12:09peace and if
12:11they are able
12:11to implement,
12:12the world
12:13would welcome
12:14that.
12:14Thank you,
12:15gentlemen, for
12:16joining us.
12:17Gaurav, all the
12:17way from China,
12:18Pranik, giving
12:18us the picture
12:19back home.
12:20Appreciate you
12:21two there.
12:21With that, I
12:22want to quickly
12:23shift focus to
12:24all the domestic
12:25news that is
12:26coming in of
12:27Rahul Gandhi
12:28making statements
12:30offshore.
12:31From a war
12:31rewards to a
12:32battle of scorecards,
12:33Prime Minister
12:34Modi and Rahul
12:35Gandhi are trading
12:35blows over India's
12:36growth story.
12:37While Modi flaunts
12:39a decade of
12:40transformation GTA
12:41style, Rahul
12:42questions the
12:42economy's
12:43foundations.
12:43Two very
12:44contrasting
12:44narratives.
12:45One, political
12:46showdown.
12:51From the
12:52fragile five to
12:53the fastest
12:54growing major
12:55economy.
12:56From 27%
12:57extreme poverty
12:58to 2.6%
13:00and from 2.82
13:02gigawatts of
13:03solar power to
13:04175 gigawatts.
13:07Keeping up with
13:08the launch of
13:09Grand Theft Auto
13:106, Prime
13:10Minister Narendra
13:11Modi has put up
13:12an on-theme post
13:13saying India has
13:15levelled up between
13:16GTA 5 and 6.
13:18Drawing a parallel
13:19between India in
13:202013 and India in
13:222026, PM Modi
13:23declared that India
13:25is now playing a
13:26whole new game.
13:28The Prime
13:29Minister's post
13:29highlights progress
13:30across nine sectors
13:32from the economy
13:33and sanitation to
13:34solar energy, space
13:35and defence.
13:37PM Modi also
13:38hailed India's
13:39economic growth at
13:40the Fikhi convention
13:40in New Delhi
13:41saying the economy
13:42is projected to
13:43grow at about
13:447%.
14:08Prime Minister Modi's
14:10dig came as
14:11leader of
14:11opposition
14:11Rahul Gandhi
14:12reiterated vote
14:13chori charges
14:14from foreign
14:15soil.
14:16Speaking at the
14:16University of
14:17Chicago, Rahul
14:18said the Congress
14:19would never
14:19abandon the
14:20electoral process
14:21because democracy
14:22is sacred to him.
14:24if we say that we
14:26are not going to
14:27contest elections, we
14:29end Indian democracy
14:30that minute.
14:31We do not want to
14:34break the electoral
14:37structure because
14:39once, if the
14:40opposition was to
14:41say we are not
14:42going to fight
14:43election, in the
14:45mind of the Indian
14:46people, that process
14:47is now illegitimate.
14:49We don't want that.
14:50Earlier, during an
14:51interaction at
14:51Columbia University
14:52in New York, Rahul
14:54Gandhi questioned
14:54the government over
14:55its economic vision,
14:56approach to
14:57education and
14:58unemployment.
14:59The blunt thing is
15:01that India is
15:01sitting on an
15:02economic disaster.
15:05That's the reality
15:06of it.
15:07And one can
15:09brush it aside,
15:11the media can
15:12brush it aside,
15:12but India has
15:15got a massive
15:15unemployment problem.
15:17India has got a
15:18massive problem
15:19with its education
15:20system.
15:21And these are
15:22things that you
15:23are not going to
15:23get away from.
15:24When Rahul took
15:25stock of economic
15:26distress abroad,
15:27PM Modi flashed a
15:29scorecard of
15:29transformation.
15:30As the war of
15:31words turns into a
15:32game of levelling up
15:33and upgrading, the
15:35real mission now is
15:36winning the
15:36narrative.
15:37Bureau Report,
15:38India Today.
15:42All right, let's
15:43cut across to our
15:44panelists this evening.
15:45Joining me, Priyanka
15:45Tibriwal, spokesperson,
15:47Bharatiya Janata
15:47Party, Dr. Nishant
15:48Anand, National
15:49Spokesperson, Congress,
15:50Rajat Sethi, political
15:51analyst, Arati
15:53Jairat, senior
15:54journalist.
15:54All of you will get
15:55two minutes' time to
15:56put your perspective
15:58forward.
15:59I'd like to begin with
16:00Ms. Priyanka
16:01Tibriwal.
16:02Priyanka Tibriwal, this
16:03is a question which
16:04has become a tad
16:05rhetorical by now.
16:07Why is it that the
16:08BJP and the
16:09government constantly
16:10compares to what
16:12Rahul Gandhi or
16:13conflates?
16:13Rahul Gandhi
16:14criticising the
16:15Indian government
16:16to criticising
16:17India.
16:18Both are extremely
16:19separate.
16:20He's the leader of
16:20opposition.
16:21His views in India
16:22are the ones he'll
16:23possibly echo abroad
16:24as well.
16:26Well, Priyanka, going
16:27on a foreign land
16:28and saying that, you
16:29know, we are in a
16:30very fearful situation
16:32or we are in a very
16:33bad situation or
16:34something very bad
16:35is going to happen
16:36in India and this is
16:37not just the first
16:38time.
16:38On a number of
16:39occasions he has done
16:40this.
16:40Now, if we just think
16:42about, you know,
16:42our relationship
16:43with Chicago, I
16:45think everybody
16:46will remember the
16:47speech delivered by
16:48Swami Vivekanandji
16:49which put India on
16:51a different platform
16:51where he spoke about
16:52our culture, where he
16:54spoke about our
16:54knowledge and everybody
16:56remembers that speech
16:57and today Rahul Gandhi
16:59goes and what does he
16:59say?
17:00That India is not
17:02growing, India is not
17:03developing.
17:04Although all the
17:04agencies, whether it
17:05is the IMF, whether it
17:06is the World Bank,
17:07everybody is saying
17:09that, you know, India
17:10is going towards
17:10development, India is
17:12growing.
17:12But it is only Rahul
17:14Gandhi who cannot see
17:15the growth.
17:15This is nothing but
17:16his political frustration.
17:18This is nothing but
17:19after losing 90
17:20elections, this is what
17:21happens.
17:23You still have a
17:24minute to go, ma'am.
17:25Are you done?
17:27No, no, I'm not
17:27done.
17:28I can still continue.
17:29See, he speaks about
17:30vote chori, he speaks
17:31about saying that there
17:33is no democracy in
17:34India.
17:35If there is no
17:35democracy, day and
17:37night, evening to
17:38morning, we are seeing
17:38that Congress and their
17:39leaders are just
17:41abusing the Prime
17:42Minister.
17:42If there is no
17:43democracy, how are you
17:44doing that?
17:46Then he says that
17:48people are not allowed
17:49to vote here or people
17:51are voting more than
17:52once.
17:52He spoke about some
17:53Brazilian women also.
17:54But where are the
17:56evidences?
17:57No evidences.
17:58So it is, again, every
17:59time, fake things which
18:01he is trying to, you
18:02know, prove a point.
18:04I'll hold your timer,
18:05but I'll hold your
18:06timer, ma'am.
18:06But the question I'll
18:07ask you again is, you
18:09know, you quote
18:10Swami Vivekanand, but
18:11multiple times even
18:12after that, while
18:13Prime Minister Modi has
18:14been Prime Minister, and
18:15I can take you through a
18:16number of speeches that
18:17he's made on foreign
18:18small, criticizing the
18:20government before his
18:22period.
18:22So the criticism of
18:24government cannot be
18:25conflated with criticism
18:26of the country.
18:28That's exactly what I am
18:30saying.
18:30That whether he was
18:32criticizing the government
18:33or whether he was
18:34criticizing the country,
18:36because you can
18:37criticize the government
18:38110 times if they are
18:41not being able to do
18:42anything for the
18:43country.
18:43But here, where the
18:44country is already
18:45growing, there you are
18:46saying that India is in
18:48a bad state.
18:49You are asking foreign
18:50nations to interfere in
18:51our internal matters.
18:53Well, he forgets that
18:54India is a self-reliant
18:55sovereign power.
18:56Okay, now your time is
18:57up.
18:57I'll circle back to you
18:59because while you are
19:01quoting GDP data, Rahul
19:03Gandhi has brought up the
19:04GDP data abroad and said
19:06that it's not really
19:07reliable.
19:08And there are multiple,
19:08you know, data sets that
19:10can be interpreted
19:11differently.
19:12But having said that, I
19:13want to bring in the
19:14Congress spokesperson into
19:15this conversation.
19:16The fact, sir, is, yes,
19:18Rahul Gandhi is critical of
19:20the government and being
19:21leader of opposition, he's
19:22really not going to change
19:24his views when he speaks
19:25abroad.
19:25Yet, a question that has
19:27been raised multiple times
19:28is, what is the road map?
19:30So allow me to ask you
19:31this question.
19:32When Rahul Gandhi says
19:33that unemployment is a
19:35huge concern where India
19:36comes into question, what
19:38is the solution that Rahul
19:40Gandhi brings to it?
19:41Does he elucidate that
19:42abroad or he stops at
19:43criticizing?
19:45Hi, good evening to all.
19:47See, after 12 years,
19:48Prime Minister Narendra
19:49Modi finally answered what
19:51he has been doing to this
19:52country, he has been playing
19:54Grand Theft Auto, GTA.
19:56For 12 years, there was no
19:58answer for unemployment, no
20:00answers on inflation, no
20:02answers on broken promises.
20:04Today, by posting GTA 5 and
20:06GTA 6 graphics, he clarified
20:07that for 12 years, he
20:09treated governments like a
20:11video game.
20:12Narendra Modi played with
20:13India and Indians.
20:1412 years in office and the
20:15PM still treats Indians like
20:17NPC in his GTA fantasy.
20:19He has bending institutions
20:21like cheat codes in the game,
20:23running vote chori and
20:24chanda chori and staggering
20:25GTA 6 cut scenes while
20:27education, health,
20:29infrastructure, youth,
20:30farmers, citizens pay the
20:31price.
20:32Corruption, deceit and
20:34extortion...
20:34Mr. Anam, will you allow
20:35me to hold your timer?
20:37Because I understand, you
20:38know, instead of rehearsed
20:39replies of an attack on
20:40Prime Minister Modi, you're
20:41free to choose your time
20:42and do that, sir.
20:44You know, nobody's denying
20:45it.
20:45But I asked you a very
20:46pointed question.
20:47What is the solution?
20:48What is the troubleshooting
20:49that the leader of
20:50opposition brings to
20:51fore where he says we're
20:54out of jobs, which
20:55possibly we are, but
20:56what's the roadmap?
20:58Riti ji, you will get the
20:59answer within my two
21:00minutes of time.
21:01I'm going to come to that
21:02point.
21:03Four years after the
21:05government's own 2022
21:06deadlines, the promises
21:08remain unmet.
21:09Doubling farmers' income
21:10hasn't happened.
21:11Two crore jobs a year
21:13hasn't happened.
21:13PAKKA housing for every
21:15family.
21:16It has not happened.
21:17175, renewal capacity
21:19has not happened.
21:20The government set these
21:22deadlines itself in 2022
21:23has already come and gone
21:25without any accountability.
21:26Now, in Shanghai and
21:28Seoul, in May 20, 2015,
21:30speaking to Indian
21:31diaspora, diaspora
21:33audiences, Modi said
21:34people were once ashamed
21:35of being born in India.
21:37And if you remember that
21:38remark trended in India,
21:40if he thinks he can win
21:42over Gen Z with video
21:43game graphics, he is
21:45living in La La Land.
21:46The reference to
21:47Grand Theft Auto is
21:48deeply ironic because
21:49the game is about
21:50hardened criminals who
21:52indulge in theft, robbery,
21:54violence and chaos.
21:55And Modi ji is
21:56celebrating.
21:58Now tell me, what is
21:59GTA 1?
22:00Rozgaar Chori.
22:01What is GTA 2?
22:02No Chori.
22:03What is GTA 3?
22:04Saval Chori.
22:05No press conference,
22:06attack on protesters,
22:07social media takedowns.
22:08What is GTA 4?
22:09Your time is up and you
22:10did not answer my
22:11question.
22:12You said you will,
22:12but you didn't answer my
22:13question.
22:14I'll give you two minutes
22:14later, you know, to maybe
22:16come down to it.
22:17Rajat Sethi, well, this
22:18conversation is pretty much
22:20on the one we had last
22:21night at 9pm, but allow me
22:22to ask you the question
22:23again, because things have
22:25moved on in the last 24
22:26hours.
22:27It is, Rajat, if you admit
22:28it, it's getting rather
22:29jaded to constantly
22:30criticize the leader of
22:31opposition or call him
22:32anti-national or
22:33attacking India.
22:34People see through it.
22:35He's not attacking India.
22:36He's not being
22:37anti-national.
22:38He's clearly attacking the
22:39policies of this government
22:40abroad.
22:43So why are you pointing
22:44that question to me?
22:45I see, I'm free to
22:46analyze.
22:47No, no, I'm free to
22:48analyze.
22:48Because I'm just saying,
22:49you know, one needs to
22:50come up with better
22:51criticism is the question.
22:52Okay, let me try.
22:53Because now it's gone.
22:55Okay, so let me try and
22:58convince you that the
22:59argument now is far
23:00better than last night.
23:02No, no, not about last
23:03night, but go ahead.
23:04I'm just saying the one
23:04which is coming in from
23:05the BJP or the
23:06government is that this
23:07is anti-India and
23:08anti-national and he's
23:09attacking the country.
23:10That's getting a tad
23:11old.
23:12No, no.
23:13So again, he might be
23:15doing his politics.
23:16He feels that going at
23:17Columbia University gives
23:18him an international
23:19platform and perhaps if
23:21not through Indian
23:22platforms, it is this
23:23international platform
23:24from where he speaks,
23:26then the Indian voters
23:27will eventually hear him.
23:28I think that should be
23:29the political logic behind
23:30this, doing this.
23:31I'm sure that addressing
23:33the American audience is
23:34not the objective of
23:35Rahul Gandhiji on this
23:37because he's been doing
23:38these tactics for the
23:40past 12 years.
23:41This is not the first
23:42time that he has gone to
23:44one of the Ivy Leagues.
23:45So people have been
23:46listening, the voters have
23:48been listening and trying
23:49to adjust and understand
23:50whether there is an
23:51intent behind what he
23:52says or not.
23:53And for the past 12 years,
23:55the voters have
23:56unanimously decided that
23:58what he is saying is
24:00nothing more than, you
24:01know, political, sorry,
24:03philosophical sort of
24:05word salad.
24:07Beyond this philosophical
24:08word salad, they don't
24:09see any substance.
24:10If they see a substance
24:12or this leader coming in
24:14with a plethora of new
24:16ideas who are going to
24:17transform their lives,
24:18they would have voted
24:19for him.
24:20They would have voted for
24:21him in multiple states
24:22and in the national
24:23election.
24:23You cannot say that I won
24:2599 seats and that is my
24:26trophy.
24:27Clearly you are sitting in
24:28opposition for the third
24:29consecutive time.
24:30And if this carries on,
24:31he is going to continue
24:33in opposition.
24:33So my point is, you
24:35will have to come out
24:36because there is a lot
24:38of baggage that sits on
24:39the Gandhi family of not
24:41delivering in the
24:42previous tenures when
24:44they were in power and
24:45absolute power for decades
24:46and decades.
24:47So the people are going
24:49to ask this question that
24:50where is the substance
24:51behind your accusations?
24:52What do you honestly feel
24:54you can transform about
24:55India's growth story?
24:57Because otherwise he will
24:58keep on saying self-
24:59contradictory things.
25:00Today he said election
25:01is problematic, but he
25:02also said that he cannot
25:04break the democracy.
25:05In India he said democracy
25:06is already dead and
25:07boring.
25:08Okay.
25:09So your two minutes is up.
25:11Aarti Jairat, allow me to
25:13ask you the question which
25:14Ranjit also raised.
25:15What is the intent of Rahul
25:17Gandhi of saying what he
25:19does abroad?
25:20Who is he speaking with?
25:22Is it narrative building?
25:23And if so, does it really
25:24matter back home in India?
25:25It's not something he hasn't
25:26done before.
25:27While in India, while he's
25:29taking the issue of vote
25:30chori, of the election
25:32commission to the people,
25:34he's seemingly getting under
25:35the skin of the government.
25:36This is resorting to an old
25:38playbook which the BJP knows
25:40very well to exploit.
25:45Priti, I would also, you
25:47know, I'd like to ask a
25:49counter question.
25:50Ask a counter question.
25:51What is the purpose of Narendra
25:54Modi going abroad and
25:56addressing NRI gatherings as if
25:59he's addressing an election
26:00rally?
26:01Does that serve, what is the
26:03purpose that that serves?
26:05So, I mean, I think it's very
26:08much in the same genre.
26:10He's not addressing, you know,
26:13a Madison Square Garden rally,
26:14which has lots of NRIs present.
26:17He's addressing, you know,
26:20universities.
26:21And if you look at the, you
26:23know, composition of the
26:24crowd, a lot of them are
26:25Indian students because we do
26:28have a huge number of Indian
26:29students studying in the United
26:31States, particularly in the top
26:33colleges because Indians are, you
26:35know, good and they get into
26:37these top colleges.
26:38So, I think he is, just like
26:41Narendra Modi, addresses NRIs
26:44when he goes abroad, the Indian
26:46diaspora when he goes abroad, to
26:48send a message back home through
26:50them because they will
26:52communicate to their families.
26:54I think, you know, Rahul Gandhi
26:56does a similar thing through
26:57these Indian students who are
26:59studying in these universities
27:00who will communicate to their
27:02families back home.
27:04I mean, it's much the same thing.
27:06You know, why should we
27:07criticize him for doing exactly
27:10what the prime minister does on a
27:12slightly, on a much smaller
27:14scale?
27:15So, you know, I mean, honestly,
27:18and I, you know, completely agree
27:20with your point that criticizing
27:22the government's policy should not
27:24be conflated with
27:26anti-nationalism or a criticism of
27:28the country.
27:29It is to do specifically with
27:32policies of the Indian
27:33government.
27:34And yes, I think you do have a
27:36point that while criticizing, it
27:39would be good if he were to offer
27:40an alternative vision.
27:42I think that alternative vision
27:44still has to be crafted by the
27:46government.
27:47All right.
27:47OK.
27:48I would reckon this would be final
27:49comments.
27:50I want to go back to the BJP
27:51spokesperson.
27:52And ma'am, the question that I
27:53asked you earlier and possibly the
27:55question at the cost of repetition
27:56that I had asked Rajat as well.
27:58The point is data can be
28:01interpreted various ways.
28:02And there's multiple set of data
28:04which seems to corroborate the
28:06points that you make on the
28:07economy and other markers or
28:11possibly which Rahul Gandhi makes.
28:13But at the end of it, to
28:14constantly attack him and berate
28:16him, to call him anti-national,
28:19anti-India, would you reckon that
28:20charge has gotten a tad too old
28:22right now?
28:23That the government and the BJP
28:24needs to come up with a new form
28:26of attacking the leader of
28:27opposition?
28:29We don't need to attack him.
28:31We don't need to attack him.
28:33Anybody for that matter in India
28:34would say that being a true
28:36nationalist or an Indian, you
28:38would not go on a foreign land
28:40and speak bad about your own
28:41country.
28:42If you cannot add anything to it
28:44or do anything additional for
28:45the development of the nation,
28:47at least you should not go and
28:48defame your own country.
28:50And forget whatever allegations,
28:52whatever he's saying against the
28:54government.
28:54I mean, he's the leader of
28:56opposition.
28:57That is his work he can do.
28:59But every time he is resorting to
29:01Photoshop and fabricated
29:02evidences when asked to
29:04Madam, allow me to hold your
29:06timer.
29:06Allow me to hold your timer.
29:07And the reason when you say
29:08what you said, and again, at the
29:11cost of repetition, because I
29:12think it's been repeated multiple
29:13times over many years since
29:15Rahul Gandhi has been going
29:16abroad and making charges at the
29:18government, what the prime
29:20minister said, and I will give it
29:21to you with date.
29:23Denmark, May 2022.
29:26India was one of the most
29:27backward nations a few years ago.
29:29This was the words of an
29:29incumbent prime minister.
29:32Berlin, Germany, May 2022.
29:34A hand used to snatch away
29:3685 paisa in one rupee.
29:38Multiple other charges, the
29:39biggest of them in Shanghai,
29:41China.
29:41Earlier, you were ashamed of
29:42India, but today you are proud.
29:44I don't think anybody was quite
29:44ashamed of India, ma'am.
29:46But the fact is, he was
29:46allowed to say, and he should
29:49say exactly what he feels like.
29:51Him criticizing an earlier
29:53government or government policies
29:55didn't tantamount to
29:56criticizing India before.
29:58The Congress spokesperson, I
30:00heard him speaking where he
30:01was saying that, you know,
30:03this did not happen, this did
30:04not happen, this did not
30:05happen.
30:05Since 2014, the BGP is in
30:08power in India.
30:10We have also seen that scams
30:12like 2G spectrum did not
30:13happen.
30:14Scams like coal block allocation
30:15did not happen.
30:16Commonwealth Chori did not
30:17happen.
30:17Cash forwards did not happen.
30:19Bofors did not happen.
30:20National Herald did not
30:21happen.
30:22When my prime minister was
30:23speaking abroad and saying
30:25what India had suffered in the
30:26past, I think he meant about
30:28all these scams, which India
30:30has not witnessed after
30:32Narendra Modi has become the
30:34prime minister of India.
30:37Okay, ma'am.
30:37I just want to remind you that
30:392G scam and coal scam all
30:40were acquitted.
30:41So it seems it didn't happen,
30:43but that's just a factual
30:45check.
30:45But I take your submissions on
30:48everything else.
30:49I want to go back to the
30:50Congress spokesperson and I
30:51want to bring him back and
30:53hopefully he will ask the
30:54question that I had posed
30:55earlier.
30:55So, Dr.
30:57Anand, would you care to
30:59elucidate what does the
31:02leader of opposition have to
31:03offer?
31:04Let's take his word that
31:05there are no jobs in this
31:07country, abysmal inflation.
31:10What does he have on the
31:11table in terms of solutions?
31:15Yes.
31:15See, what did Rahul Gandhiji
31:16say today and yesterday?
31:18That look at the
31:18government's own number of
31:20jobs and prices.
31:21The periodic labor forces
31:23survey puts youth on
31:24unemployment at 15%.
31:26Real wages for
31:27salaried employees has
31:28increased till 2019.
31:31Rice went from 28 rupees to
31:33over 48 rupees a kilo.
31:34Toordal has increased from
31:3670 to 136.
31:38So it had three times as
31:39increased.
31:40And as I said earlier,
31:41farmers income and creating
31:42two crore jobs a year,
31:44none of these promises have
31:45made it to the
31:46practical.
31:47Instead of answering a
31:48single unscripted press
31:50conference in 12 years, the
31:51government attacks Rahul
31:52Gandhiji for stating these
31:54exact published facts at the
31:56Columbia University and
31:57Chicago, calling the
31:58government's own inflation,
32:00debt and job numbers,
32:01anti-India is not a
32:03rebuttal, it is an
32:03invasion.
32:04As Rahul Gandhiji made
32:05clear in Chicago, Indian
32:07democracy is sacred and the
32:08opposition will never
32:09boycott elections.
32:11We will stay on the field,
32:12contest and expose every
32:13regard.
32:14Mr. Anand Alami, to hold
32:15your timer, how is the
32:17LOP suggesting that he
32:19will, what's his vision for
32:21job creation in this
32:22country?
32:24As Rahul Gandhiji said,
32:25that first of all, we have
32:26to make sure that the
32:28grand theft which has been
32:29happening, Prime Minister
32:31Modi, wherein we talk
32:32about from Ram Mandir to
32:33Vodchori, now they have
32:34come up with Rade Rade
32:36Kamal Khilade, they have
32:37already have 470 Kamal
32:38Mahal.
32:39So the question is why
32:40there is no answer for
32:41the education, why there is
32:42no answer on unemployment?
32:44Why there is no answer on
32:46infrastructure?
32:46What's his answer, sir?
32:48What is the LOP's answer
32:50to the issue of
32:51unemployment?
32:52The manufacturing should
32:53be increased, the
32:54industries should be
32:55increased, the China, the
32:57America, they should not
32:58guide Pradhan Mantri
32:59Modi way to buy the oil,
33:01way to do the
33:02investment.
33:02They should be like the
33:04import duty in trading,
33:05like 500 billion
33:06investments is being
33:08forced upon India because
33:09Modi could not answer
33:11Trump.
33:11So all these points have
33:13been raised and the
33:14main point is that BJP has
33:15a government in 22
33:16states, but they have not
33:18come up with a single
33:19school or a university that
33:21they have created in the
33:21last 12 years.
33:23So how will the students
33:23will study and how will
33:25these people will get the
33:26job?
33:27All right, sir, your time is
33:28up.
33:28I need to give one minute
33:29each to our political
33:30analysts.
33:31Ranjit Sethi, would you
33:32want to go first?
33:33Closing comment, sir.
33:36Okay, so how do I close?
33:38Okay, my point is that see
33:40Rahul Gandhi, I think
33:41Aarti ji got me wrong.
33:43There is absolutely no
33:44problem in how he wants to
33:46conduct his politics.
33:47Rahul Gandhi decides that
33:49organizational building in
33:50Uttar Pradesh, which is
33:51about to go into elections
33:53three or four months, maybe
33:54three months from now, that
33:56is not a priority.
33:57You don't want to go out and
33:58do the laborious task, but
34:01instead you want to, at the
34:02first opportune moment that
34:03you get, you will fly out
34:04either to Taiwan, Vietnam or
34:06US and you go and project
34:08there.
34:08Maybe that is his political
34:09strategy.
34:10Good luck to him.
34:11But is the pendulum swinging
34:13in his favor?
34:14Are his advisors not seeing
34:16that things are not
34:17translating into the ground?
34:19What is he trying to do
34:20over there when his
34:21organization is hollowed out
34:22and corroded from inside?
34:24And then he will go out and
34:25again blame the election
34:27process are rigged when you
34:28haven't put up a solid fight
34:30that you should have by doing
34:31the laborious task.
34:33Contrast to this, to the
34:34BJP, if a Prime Minister
34:35Modi goes out and speaks.
34:38Okay, sir, one minute.
34:39Aarti Jairath, one minute
34:41time, ma'am.
34:41Closing comments.
34:44I would like to ask the same
34:45question as Rajat Sethi.
34:47How do I close?
34:49Well, I mean, listen, as I
34:52said earlier, Narendra Modi
34:53goes and, you know, addresses
34:55the diaspora.
34:56Rahul Gandhi goes and addresses
34:58the diaspora.
34:58Yes, he does have an
35:00organization problem and he
35:02needs to address that very
35:03seriously.
35:04And I hope he will.
35:06So for the sake of for the
35:08sake of Indian democracy,
35:09actually, because Indian
35:10democracy needs a vibrant
35:13and robust opposition.
35:15It's you know, it cannot be a
35:17one sided affair with the ruling
35:18party just dominating
35:19everything.
35:20So it is vitally important that
35:23the opposition is present in
35:26enough numbers to question the
35:28government.
35:29It is equally important that the
35:31government answer those
35:32questions because we need
35:35transparency from the
35:36government.
35:36That is what parliament is all
35:38about.
35:38It's unfortunate that parliament
35:40is not allowed to function the
35:41way it should.
35:42So we never get answers from
35:44anybody.
35:44Time up, ma'am.
35:46I appreciate all, Porofi, for
35:47taking the time out this evening
35:48and joining us.
35:49You know, ultimately, on both
35:51sides of the divide, new
35:52narratives need to be built.
35:53If Rahul Gandhi is going to
35:54criticise issues that plague
35:56India, then he should also be
35:58able to offer solutions.
35:59What does he have to offer?
36:01On the other hand, the old
36:03script of being anti-India,
36:05anti-national, if you
36:06criticise government policies
36:07abroad, is a tad bit too old.