- 7 minutes ago
This news broadcast covers developments across politics, corporate law, governance, and weather updates. TVK MLA VS Babu passed away in Chennai at age 75 following cardiac arrest, prompting condolences from Tamil Nadu Chief Minister Vijay, Governor Rajendra Vishwanath Arlekar, and MK Stalin, alongside discussions regarding the Kolathur assembly constituency bypoll.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Good evening, hello and welcome. You're watching Super 6 here on India Today. I'm Akashita Nanda Gopalo.
00:05The next one hour we'll get you all the top stories of the day with our focus on the southern
00:11states.
00:11We've got lots lined up for you on this edition of Super 6 and let's kick things off by giving
00:16you a sense of the two big stories that we'll be tracking on this edition of Super 6.
00:21We're going to first focus on Tamil Nadu where the giant slayer of Tamil Nadu politics, the man who defeated
00:28M.K. Stalin in Kolodur.
00:30V.S. Babu, who went viral with that particular video, is no more.
00:34Breed his last after a prolonged illness that led to a nearly 70-day stay in hospital.
00:40The reason this is being spoken about is because of the huge political repercussions now of the demise of the
00:47TVK MLA.
00:48The Kolodur seat opens up, there will be a mandated bipolar and then we'll see M.K. Stalin attempt to
00:54return to the Tamil Nadu Assembly.
00:56We'll get your details on that.
00:58Also on the show this evening, we'll get you the latest on Cyclone Akwan, set to make landfall tomorrow.
01:04Already pockets of Andhra Pradesh receiving high rainfall.
01:07But at this point, between Andhra and Odisha is where we're going to be seeing landfall.
01:12We will get you a ground report on what to expect.
01:15At 6.30 this evening, we're going to be talking about what's happening as far as the TVS Family Feud
01:20is concerned.
01:21And exclusive conversations with both sides, Kapil Sibyl and Abhishek Manu Singhvi, coming your way at 6.30 this evening.
01:27In a Business Today exclusive.
01:29Let's begin with the headlines.
01:35The super power handshake at Shenzhen.
01:38Trump, Xi, Putin hold trilateral meat in China.
01:42Xi bats for ban and destruction of nukes.
01:44Putin bats for peaceful nuke energy.
01:47Trump claims U.S. helped establish global peace.
01:55Prime Minister Modi's GTA 6-style attack on UPA era.
01:59Modi compares online game GTA 5 and GTA 6 to slam the Congress post 13 years that changed the game.
02:13Rahul makes it official.
02:15Congress will not boycott polls.
02:17Despite vote show recharges, Rahul says will contest polls, won't end democracy.
02:21BJP lashes out, says Rahul maligning India on foreign soil.
02:26If we say that we are not going to contest elections, we end Indian democracy that minute.
02:34And we don't want to end the structure of Indian democracy.
02:42Akhilesh's Gorakhpur yatra turns tragic.
02:4514-year-old crushed by a bulldozer in S.P. Ratyadra.
02:48Chief Minister Yogi accuses S.P. of anarchy.
02:51Wants of harshest possible punishment to culprits.
03:01Anthropic price its IPO at $83 per share, valuing the artificial intelligence giant at $1.5 trillion.
03:29And let's begin with the political repercussions of the shocking, untimely demise of TVK Emily V.S. Babu.
03:37He was referred to as the giant slayer. Why?
03:40Because he's the one who defeated M.K. Stalin in a DMK bastion in Stalin's turf of Kolatur in Chennai.
03:47Since then, there's been a lot of focus on what's been happening in Kolatur.
03:51Remember, the MLA has been hospitalized for the last three months, which means that there wasn't really much that the
03:57TVK could do on ground.
03:58The reason we're speaking of political repercussions today is, remember, M.K. Stalin, after the defeat, never made it to
04:04the Tamil Nadu Assembly.
04:05Now, with the demise of V.S. Babu, we're going to be seeing a bipolar necessitator, of course, in Kolatur.
04:12And will that mean that M.K. Stalin will choose to contest?
04:16Will he seek a comeback into the Tamil Nadu Assembly with this particular development?
04:20We'll be talking about that with analysts, but here's a detailed report first.
04:29A political upset that made headlines.
04:32A victory that shook the DMK's stronghold.
04:36And now, a sudden end of the journey of the man who defeated M.K. Stalin in Kolatur.
04:42TVK, MLA, V.S. Babu passed away on Thursday after suffering a cardiac arrest.
04:48According to MGM Healthcare, where he was undergoing treatment, Babu breathed his last at 2.24pm.
04:55Babu had been admitted to Chennai Hospital on September 9th after complaining of breathing difficulties.
05:01He had remained hospitalized for more than two months.
05:05Just a day before his death, a Kolatur resident had moved the Madras High Court seeking information about the MLA's
05:12health.
05:12The petitioner, G. Devarajan, had sought disclosure of information that could legally be made public,
05:19while also seeking what alternative arrangements had been made to address the constituency's need during MLA's absence.
05:27Babu's political journey was one of several party switches and a landmark electoral upset.
05:34He was previously with the DMK and represented Pura Swalkkam between 2006 and 2011.
05:42He joined the AIA-DMK in 2016 before moving to Vijay's TVK in February 2026.
05:50In the assembly elections, he defeated M.K. Stalin in Kolatur by the margin of 8,795 votes.
05:57Babu polled 82,997 votes, while Stalin managed 74,202.
06:30The tribute has begun to pour in.
06:32Chief Minister Vijay expressed deep sadness, remembering Babu as a leader who lived among the people and earned their love
06:39and trust.
06:41Former Chief Minister M.K. Stalin also expressed shock, saying reports had indicated that Babu's condition was improving.
06:48Tamil Nadu Governor Rajinder Vishwanath R. Lekar also paid condolences, remembering Babu's public service.
06:55From defeating a chief minister in his own bastion to his untimely demise after a prolonged hospital stay,
07:02V.S. Babu's death leaves the Kolatur constituency and the TVK camp in mourning.
07:07Bureau Report, India Today.
07:14Let me bring in Anika Keshav on this broadcast.
07:17She's joining us live from Chennai.
07:19Anika, for the TVK, of course, this is a huge loss.
07:22Because, you know, he is someone who kind of shaped the electoral narrative post the results in Tamil Nadu.
07:29Has barely managed to really work on the ground because was hospitalized for the last three months as a result
07:36of a prolonged illness.
07:37And so, for them, it's starting from scratch on Kolatur.
07:42You're absolutely right on that.
07:43In fact, he was one of the most senior, most MLAs in TVK who had won Kolatur.
07:49It's quite interesting that he was previously in BMK and had worked earlier to make sure that Stalin won from
07:56the very own Kolatur constituency.
07:59And then later on, he left the BMK and then joined the TVK.
08:03He has been under treatment in the last three months.
08:06And today afternoon, he has breached his last.
08:08What they're learning from the hospital is that he has died out of cardiac arrest.
08:12Very shocking.
08:13In fact, even the governor and the chief minister have responded on this matter.
08:17His body is taken away to his residence in Chennai, Sperambur, where his family, friends and relatives and everybody in
08:24political circles can visit him to pay their last respects.
08:27He was one of the most senior, most leaders in Tamil Nadu, widely revered.
08:31In fact, he shot to fame after he defeated MK Stalin.
08:35Before that, not many really knew who V.S. Babu was.
08:38It's only after he defeated a sitting chief minister, that's when V.S. Babu really shot to fame and his
08:45iconic hand gesture that went super viral on social media.
08:48It's a tragic story that's coming in from Tamil Nadu of V.S. Babu's demise.
08:52He was age 75.
08:54All right.
08:55Thanks, Anika, for those details.
08:56Now, the question that will be asked is also about what happens next now in Kolatur.
09:07Will we see, in fact, MK Stalin enter the poll fray once again?
09:11There will be a bi-poll announced soon now as a result of this.
09:14Let me bring in on this broadcast Mr. Suman C. Raman, as well as Sandhya Ravi Shankar, senior journalist.
09:20Mr. Suman C. Raman is a political analyst.
09:22Thank you both for your time.
09:23And, of course, while messages of condolences pour in, Mr. Suman C. Raman,
09:28there will be a question of what will be the impact of this kind of development for the TVK.
09:36Oh, absolutely.
09:38But, Akshay, I think this has been sort of anticipated for some time, very unfortunate.
09:46But he had a chronic lung illness and had to be hospitalized for two to three months.
09:53So, I think that the TVK, from their perspective, are not going to make this a very high-stakes
10:02by-election, but for the DMK, it's a huge gamble if they are going to think of putting
10:08Mr. M.K. Stalin back in the fray.
10:10I don't think they will do it, because the risk of a defeat far outweighs the benefits
10:17of a victory.
10:18So, I don't believe that the DMK will be risking Mr. Stalin in a contest.
10:22Imagine, just imagine, if the TVK put up another relatively lightweight and Mr. Stalin
10:30loses again, I mean, that would be a disaster for the DMK.
10:34So, I don't think that that would happen.
10:36In any case, there are several by-elections which are already due in Tamil Nadu, of which
10:41we have no idea when they are going to be held, whether it is Perindurai, whether it is Virali
10:45Malai, whether it is Pichiti.
10:46Many of them, we don't know when Amba Samudaram, we don't know when these by-elections will be
10:50held.
10:50So, this will be added to the list of those constituencies, and there may be five or six
10:56by-elections which come up.
10:57Again, depending on when the election commission decides that the time is right to handle.
11:02Certainly not before December, because the monsoons are there now.
11:06So, I don't think it's feasible to have an election anytime.
11:10My guess is probably in the early part of January, once the monsoons have subsided, that's
11:16when we can think of a by-election.
11:19Mr. Subhansi Raman, you know, the reason we're talking about what really happens for
11:23the DMK and MK Stalin is because, in a sense, this is a catch-22 situation.
11:27If he chooses not to contest, like you suggest could happen, the TVK is going to go all guns
11:32blazing saying, oh, look, Stalin doesn't have the courage to take us on in what's considered
11:37or what was considered to be his bastion.
11:39Yeah, but look, yeah, look, Akshita, the TVK can go ahead and try to blame or, you know,
11:49ridicule Mr. Stalin if he doesn't contest, but that could be something which would last
11:53for a few days.
11:54If Mr. Stalin contests and loses, then that creates a massive setback for the DMK.
12:01And I don't see the benefits.
12:03It's okay.
12:04Mr. Udenidi is now the leader of the opposition.
12:06He is running, you know, he is running the DMK campaign inside the assembly.
12:11Now, just to get Mr. Stalin back in the assembly, if, would they take a risk?
12:18And mind you, this is not by any stretch of imagination, the safest seat available in Tamil
12:25Nadu for the DMK.
12:26So, I would think, not twice, but maybe a dozen times before, you know, putting Mr. Stalin
12:33in the fray.
12:34And I honestly can't, I don't think that they will take such a risk.
12:39Okay, so we'll have to see what really plays out.
12:42But even for the TVK, Mr. Sumansi Raman, this will be challenging.
12:46What has Babu managed to pull off?
13:21The impact of V.S. Babu's demise on Tamil Nadu politics.
13:25I was talking to Mr. Sumansi Raman.
13:27He suggests that in all likelihood, there is no way that really V.S., that MK Stalin will
13:32contest in a bipolar in Kulatur.
13:35What do you think?
13:58Okay, apologies.
14:00We're going to, in fact, connect with, in fact, our guests and panelists in just a bit
14:06as we continue to decode what's really playing out in Tamil Nadu.
14:11What will happen?
14:12What will be the impact of the demise of V.S. Babu?
14:21Let's get your details now of a big story that's coming from Tamil Nadu of allegations
14:26that those who were helping the investment pitch of Tamil Nadu were actually working in
14:32cahoots with Andhra Pradesh.
14:33What's the story all about?
14:35Well, the TVK government has said that they've actually unearthed details of several officials
14:40who were part of Tamil Nadu's core team in bringing in investments, that that team, many
14:48of them were compromised, were moles within the Vijay government.
14:52Who are these moles?
14:53Well, 15 officials have been identified.
14:55They've been removed and essentially removed saying that they breached the confidentiality clause.
15:02Now, according to, in fact, the details that have emerged, many of them were linked to the Andhra government.
15:10Many of them have now been hired by the Andhra government.
15:13They're working with the Andhra Pradesh government, which they say is more evidence that they were
15:18actually in cahoots with Andhra.
15:20This is a major controversy, serious allegations of a possible scam in the investment promotion agency.
15:26Now, they're being linked to, in fact, DMK-era government as well.
15:31A group of officials appointed during the previous regime, essentially, have been found working
15:36in coordination with counterparts in Andhra Pradesh.
15:39This misconduct, alleged misconduct, centers around crucial information related to companies
15:45looking to invest in Tamil Nadu.
15:47Our sources have indicated that this group is suspected of sharing sensitive investment-related
15:52information with officials in Andhra Pradesh, potentially giving the neighboring state access
15:57to details of companies, their investment plans in Tamil Nadu.
16:01It's triggered a major shake-up within the Tamil Nadu government's investment promotion machinery,
16:06leading to the removal of several senior officials who were believed to be a part of that group
16:12that was in touch with Andhra Pradesh.
16:14So, the fight between two states for investments, usually healthy competition, has taken a rather
16:19ugly turn.
16:20It's also rather political because the allegation is that these were officials who were hired
16:24by the previous DMK government.
16:27Three individuals from that group reportedly are now working with the Andhra Pradesh government
16:30and that's raised further questions about how sensitive information may have been accessed,
16:36shared and potentially used.
16:38Is this merely an information leak?
16:40Is it part of a larger conspiracy to undermine Tamil Nadu's investment prospects?
16:44Those are questions right now being asked.
16:48But remember, this comes under Industries Minister Kirtana.
16:51And so, questions about whether the minister here is deliberately being targeted.
17:02And in fact, as we get you the details of that story, let's move on now to an update also
17:08on Cyclone Aquan.
17:10It's intensified into a severe cyclonic storm.
17:13It's going to be making a landfall tomorrow at around noon in parts of Andhra Pradesh as
17:18well as Odisha.
17:20North Andhra is where it's expected to hit.
17:22Red alert has already been sounded across several parts of India's eastern coastline.
17:28Heavy rainfall already being reported in some pockets of Andhra Pradesh.
17:32Now, it's also changed trajectory.
17:34Cyclone Aquan previously was set to completely lash Andhra's coast.
17:39It's moved a bit more northwards, which means that it's the tip of Andhra.
17:43And South Odisha that will bear the brunt of, in fact, this cyclone tomorrow.
17:48November 20th is when it makes landfall.
17:52Apurva Jai Chandran is joining us live with more details on really when the landfall is expected.
18:01She's joining us live from Vizag.
18:02Apurva, take us through what you're picking up on the preparations on ground.
18:06How bad is it going to be?
18:08Because we understand that this cyclone has changed its trajectory slightly.
18:16Well, that's right, Akshita.
18:17Like I had mentioned yesterday, the trajectory of cyclone Aquan has been constantly changing over the last 24 hours.
18:24In fact, we're here at Rushi Konda here in Vishakapatnam.
18:27And what we were told this morning was that Vizag might be the eye of the storm of cyclone Aquan.
18:34But unfortunately, now it has moved a lot further upwards towards this Odisha side,
18:39which is where Gopalpur is what has been earlier stated this afternoon.
18:44But now, just a couple of minutes back, IMD has predicted that this will be the eye of the storm
18:50is moving down closer towards, you know, Itchapuram, right across the border of Odisha and Uttar Andhra Pradesh as well.
18:57In fact, even as I'm speaking, it's just started drizzling over here.
19:00Since morning, there has been continuously light drizzles that has been going on across Uttar Andhra Pradesh regions,
19:06particularly Rishi Konda, you know, Vishakapatnam, Shrikakulam, Vijayanagara, all of these areas as well.
19:13Since last night, the IMD has predicted that this cyclone will only intensify as it is all likely to cross
19:20across Itchapuram earlier tomorrow morning.
19:23That's a prediction that IMD has stated and that the crossing that is the eye of the storm when it
19:28makes a landfall,
19:30the speed will be likely over 140 kilometers per hour is what the IMD has predicted.
19:35For now, there's already been close to over 20 plus teams, be it ADRF or SDP, SDRF teams that have
19:43already been deployed on the ground there,
19:45particularly in these regions which might be bearing the brunt of Cyclone Akwin.
19:50And in these regions as well, there's also potential that much like we saw the storm surge,
19:55cyclonic storm surge that took place during, you know, Cyclone Ornab and Cyclone Murasu.
20:00Murasu, this time as well, there might be a possible storm surge that will take place following the aftermath of
20:07Cyclone Akwin.
20:08So, all of the preparations that have been taken up,
20:10the collectors constantly in meeting with the Chief Minister of Andhra Pradesh Jaya, Sandhra Babunaidu,
20:16who is taking stock of the situation.
20:18Apart from this, there's also, you know, a lot of evacuation measures that have been taken up,
20:23particularly in these areas, Ishaapuram, you know, Anakapalli, all of these areas, Parvati Mandiam,
20:29all of these areas are hili regions and which is where most of the tribal belt resides here in Andhra
20:34Pradesh.
20:35So, evacuations taking place, all precautions, Andhra Pradesh, whether they like it or not,
20:40have become pros at handling cyclones.
20:42That's because this is the third one in a matter of three weeks to hit the coast of Andhra.
20:47Thanks very much, Apoorva, for joining us with those details.
20:50Tomorrow is when the cyclone makes landfall.
20:53We'll be tracking all the updates that come in from both Andhra Pradesh and Odisha.
20:56Both those states will bear the brunt of Cyclone Akwin.
21:00Let's move on to what everyone's talking about on the internet today.
21:05After 13 years of waiting, Grand Theft Auto 6 is finally here.
21:09The response has been nothing short of extraordinary.
21:11From billions of dollars in pre-launch revenue and record-breaking anticipation
21:16to rave reviews and gamers even taking time off work.
21:19GTA 6 has become much more than just a game launch.
21:23The craze has reached India too, with fans and even politicians joining the midnight countdown.
21:29Analysts believe the impact could go beyond Rockstar,
21:32potentially giving the wider gaming industry the biggest boost ever.
21:56After 13 long years of waiting, Grand Theft Auto 6 has finally arrived.
22:04And the response has been nothing short of extraordinary.
22:08From record-breaking sales estimates to glowing reviews and gamers around the world counting down to the launch,
22:15GTA 6 has become an entertainment phenomenon.
22:24The game takes players back to Vice City, a fictional version of Miami with two central characters, Lucia and Jason.
22:33But this time, the expectations were enormous.
22:37The previous installment, GTA 5, went on to sell more than 230 million copies worldwide.
22:45And the new game is already making history, even before its global rollout.
22:52According to estimates by market research firm, Censor Tower, GTA 6 has generated around $1.65 billion in pre-launch
23:00revenue from an estimated 17 million units.
23:03The publisher, Take-Two Interactive, has confirmed that pre-orders are far above expectations,
23:09although it hasn't disclosed official sales figures.
23:15Critics, meanwhile, have been equally impressed.
23:18The game has received overwhelmingly positive reviews, scoring 99 on Metacritic.
23:23Are we going to be okay?
23:25For a game that had an entire generation waiting, that's quite a start.
23:31But perhaps the biggest story is what GTA 6 is doing to people's lives.
23:39Gamers are taking days off work, making plans with their partners to secure uninterrupted game time
23:44and staying up through the night to be amongst the first to play.
23:49Some employers have even joined the excitement.
23:52Logitech announced a paid day off for its 7,000 employees to play games of their choice.
23:58And the craze has reached India as well.
24:03Rajya Sabha MP Raghav Chadda shared a video of himself waiting for the game to unlock at midnight.
24:09His caption read,
24:1011.59pm has never felt this long.
24:14A little glimpse of life beyond parliament, as he put it.
24:20And social media has been flooded with countdown memes, gameplay reactions and celebrations.
24:25For millions, this is not just another game release.
24:29It's the return of a world they have been waiting to revisit for over a decade.
24:34But the impact of GTA 6 could go well beyond Rockstar Games.
24:38Analysts at Oppenheimer estimate that the game could generate around $1.85 billion in revenue in its first three days.
24:46That's almost double of what GTA 5 made during its launch in 2013.
24:51I told Brian I thought you two were both dead for sure.
24:55Now what have you gotten yourselves into?
24:57I want to know everything.
25:03I don't know what this is.
25:06Look, I was just sightseeing with my girl.
25:08Did you risk carrying these?
25:11We need to see it.
25:12Does this mean we're in his crew?
25:14Yeah, I think so.
25:16You think he can help us?
25:18We don't have any better ideas, do we?
25:20Where are we?
25:22Back in Bayside.
25:23Want to take a look around?
25:27And the excitement could give the wider gaming industry much-needed boost.
25:33Industry researchers expect GTA 6 to help drive growth in the global console gaming market this year.
25:38More players could mean more spending on consoles, gaming accessories, subscriptions, and online services.
25:46And the buzz isn't restricted to gaming platforms.
25:50YouTube, Reddit, and social media are expected to see a surge in engagement as players share their experiences and discoveries.
25:58In the end, GTA 6 is a reminder of how big gaming has become.
26:02The freeway!
26:06Negative.
26:07Stay low.
26:09It's competing for people's time, money, and attention with films, music, and even mainstream entertainment.
26:18And if the opening response is anything to go by, Rockstar hasn't just released a new game.
26:23It has launched a global event.
26:52Let's get your breaking news that's coming in right now.
26:55Now, in a tragic incident that took place yesterday during Akhileshun's Ratyatra in Gorakpur, a 14-year-old died after
27:03one of the bulldozers in the area ran over the child.
27:07Now, UP Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath has visited Gorakpur, met with the family members of the 14-year-old teen
27:15who died in that unfortunate incident yesterday.
27:18Yogi Adityanath was accompanied by MP Ravi Kishan as well as they met with the family members.
27:23As the family has pinned the blame on SP chief Akhilesh Yadav, saying it happened at his event, he must
27:30be held responsible for what's happened.
27:32But politics playing out over this tragedy that took place yesterday in Gorakpur, which is Yogi's bastion, it is his
27:40turf, and Akhileshun's visit taking a controversial turn after the demise of a 14-year-old teenager.
27:48Crushed to death, as we're putting out for you there, before Akhileshun's rally because of the bulldozers that were on
27:53the streets as part of his big show of strength that took place in Gorakpur yesterday.
27:58Since then, family members of the victim have also spoken out, pinning the blame on Akhilesh Yadav, saying it was
28:05a lack of preparations, it was in fact the chaos on ground in Gorakpur that led to the death of
28:11their son.
28:12And the parents therefore are demanding justice.
28:14Yogi Adityanath has touched down in Gorakpur on your screens and the images of his meeting also with family members.
28:23Ashish Srivastava is joining us with the latest updates on this.
28:29And now, the authentic DESA is the latest updates on our screens.
28:33It is the case, which is a positive response, and you can see it all the time.
28:37The new mögliche images are on the streets as well.
28:45The new ones are watching this or the new ones are
28:50and the old ones are walking on the streets as well.
29:15Ashrish filing that report follows the moment that Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath was there
29:19and speaking to the family members.
29:21He is joining us live from Gorakhpur right now as he tracks the latest updates.
29:25Ashrish, take us to what the family has to say.
29:27There's a lot of politics, yes, but what's the family's version here of what happened?
30:05There's a lot of politics, yes, it's a lot of politics, yes, it's a lot of politics, it's a lot
30:20of politics.
30:20And I think that's what I'm going to say.
30:22Now, when you look back, they said that there will be a lot of politics.
30:27Because those who were in front of it will be a lot of politics and it will be a lot
30:32of politics.
30:33because a family has made a place with a family and then Atya has done it.
30:40And in this case, the Zamaadwadi Party had said that the Zamaadwadi Party had done it.
30:49So Ashish is telling us right now that the U.P. Chief Minister has assured the family
30:53that there will be a detailed investigation on who is to be held accountable
30:57for the death of their 14-year-old child.
31:00Thanks Ashish for these details.
31:04And here on India Today, yesterday on Super 6, we told you about a dispute,
31:09a family feud and a succession dispute within one of India's best-known business families,
31:14the TVS Group.
31:15It's raising important questions about daughters' inheritance rights
31:19and that's because Lakshmi Venu, the daughter of Venu Srinivasan,
31:22has spoken out about how she believes that her brother has been given
31:27a larger chunk of the TVS family assets versus her,
31:31which is why it's opened up the scan of worms on familial wealth distribution
31:35and whether daughters inevitably don't get the shorter end of the stick
31:40when it comes to the division of assets.
31:43She's now put forward also this in a letter to Vedu Srinivasan
31:47and her legal position is that accepting a management arrangement
31:50does not amount to surrendering ownership rights.
31:54She's saying that she deserves to get as much as her brother is.
31:57Let's get you a legal perspective on this.
31:59Senior advocate Kapil Sybil has explained the legal arguments
32:03in this exclusive conversation with Siddharth Zarabi.
32:11It's one of India's oldest and best-known business families.
32:15The TVS name goes back more than a hundred years.
32:19The flagship TVS Motor Company has a market cap of over 2 lakh crore rupees.
32:24But a family dispute has moved from the boardrooms to legal notices now.
32:30This week, Lakshmi Venu, Managing Director of Sundaram Clayton,
32:34served a formal partition notice on her father, Venu Srinivasan,
32:38Chairman Emeritus of TVS Motor.
32:41She invokes the Hindu Succession Act and says that as a daughter,
32:46she is entitled to an equal share of her branch family assets.
32:50She says her brother, Sudarshan, now holds the larger beneficial interest.
32:56Her mother, Malika Srinivasan, has publicly backed her.
33:01Venu Srinivasan's position is different.
33:03He says these are his own assets that he was free to divide them
33:08and that both his children received a fair share.
33:12Clearly, this is not just a family disagreement over valuations.
33:17It raises a larger question that India's business families perhaps can no longer avoid.
33:24Is running a business the same as owning it?
33:26And when control goes to one, what happens to the other's share?
33:32To unpack the law behind these headlines,
33:35I am joined by noted lawyer and senior advocate Kapil Simbal.
33:39Mr. Simbal, welcome to the show.
33:41Let me begin by asking that big point to you.
33:45Is running a business really the same as owning it in today's India?
33:52It depends on your attitude.
33:54You know, in a patriarchal society, the father claims to exercise all the rights
34:01that may well be vested in his other members of the family.
34:05So he always claims himself to be a patriarch, that I am the owner.
34:09That's, you know, central to a lot of businesses in this country,
34:12a lot of families in this country.
34:14The Lakshmi in the family is always considered to be the other.
34:18And of course, in this particular case, Lakshmi is Lakshmi in this particular family,
34:24which is most unfortunate that a father who says that I built, I am the owner of this business.
34:30Well, the father should remember where he got his business from.
34:34This is family business started by his great-grandfather in 1911, right?
34:41And then his father took it forward.
34:43T.S. Srinivasan took it forward.
34:45It's a third generation.
34:47Then the business came to him.
34:49And he said, it's my family business.
34:51But the larger family was partitioned in 2020.
34:55And then the assets were divided.
34:57And TV Motors, TVS Motors, the TVS branch, came to him.
35:02TVS Holdings, subsidiaries, including TVS Credit, came to him.
35:08And then, of course, certain monies were to be paid to the family,
35:13because this is a very valuable part of the business that came to him.
35:17So the funds were raised from the assets of the company, loans were taken, and the others were paid.
35:24And then suddenly we find the patriarch is saying, it's my business, unfortunately.
35:30Well, Mr. Sibyl, the matter has been reported now for quite some time,
35:35but clearly a daughter has sent her father a partition notice.
35:41What I want to understand, and hopefully we'll also get to hear from Mr. Venu Srinivasan,
35:46his side and his version of this entire dispute.
35:50But you are helping us unpack and understand one element.
35:54Is this a family dispute or a test of how far daughters equal rights have actually reached in the Indian
36:04business family context?
36:05Well, you know, I think when you say it's a family dispute, you have to understand the context, right?
36:12If you say that your daughter is the other, right?
36:16And suddenly the daughter finds from newspaper reports that 95 percent of the business has been given to Sudarshan, right?
36:23She's something that she's surprised at. And this is not something that has happened overnight.
36:31I mean, a notice for partition has not been sent overnight.
36:35This has been going on. She's been asking the father, be open with me.
36:40How did you give him 95 percent of the business of the company?
36:46I am an equal shareholder, you know, in Tamil Nadu, way back in 1989, that law was passed.
36:53Then, of course, the parliament in 2005 said daughters are equal shareholders.
36:58This is co-parsenary property. It's not you built it.
37:01All of us, all businesses, but the assets belong to the to the to the family assets from which this
37:08business was built.
37:08So both Sudarshan, my brother, as well as Lakshmi, are entitled to an equal share.
37:15I mean, there are no two ways about it.
37:18The problem is, after 50 years of independence, our law told her daughter that she's not a guest.
37:27This happened in 2005. That you're not a guest. You're part of the family.
37:32And I think Venu Srinivasan should listen to that law and recognize that even before 2005, Tamil Nadu in 1989
37:41had said the same thing.
37:43So I think that he should step back and make sure there is equitable distribution.
37:51He should step back and make sure that there is equitable distribution.
37:55But, you know, then that would also raise the point, Mr. Sybil, about what has happened in the past.
38:05The 2005 amendment and the Supreme Court's 2020 Vinita Sharma judgment.
38:11Does the law, and I'm trying to understand here for the benefit of our viewers,
38:16does the law see any difference between a son and a daughter when it comes to joint family property?
38:22Not at all. Not at all. Because the property is not the sole ownership of the father.
38:29I mean, the father himself has inherited the property from his ancestors.
38:34And therefore, I have an equal share when it comes to distribution.
38:38And there are no two ways on it. I don't think that any legal expert will say otherwise.
38:44So you assume that you are the patriarch, you assume that you are entitled to distribute the way you like,
38:52forgetting that that's not the law.
38:56And that's not even a fair manner of dealing with members of the family.
39:01That's, you know, the problem is a patriarchal mindset that often discriminates against the daughters.
39:08Often. Not always, but often. This is one of those occasions.
39:12A patriarchal mindset that discriminates against daughters.
39:17The other question that would be put is the argument that Mr. Venu Srinivasan says that these are his personal
39:27assets.
39:27You've dwelt on that.
39:29Ah, well. I'd like to know how he got those assets.
39:32He got those assets from the family business because he grew the business.
39:36So if I inherit something from my father and I grow the business, that doesn't become my personal asset.
39:43Because the beneficiary of the family's business went into building the business.
39:48And therefore, I'm equally entitled to it.
39:51Now, the problem is he considers himself to be the owner.
39:55That's the problem.
39:59But Mr. Sibbal, isn't that in the Indian context of, you know, generation upon generation managing the family business and
40:09then growing it?
40:10Of course, with professional executives and a board, why wouldn't they have a right to say that they built it
40:16and therefore make a claim to those assets?
40:19Well, that's the difference. That's the difference between self-acquired property and acquired from the family.
40:26Conceptually, these are two different things.
40:28If I, for example, from my own earnings, buy a particular piece of property, I can give it to anybody
40:34who I like.
40:35Why? Because I can will it.
40:37But if I inherit a business, inherit property from my parents, then I can't will it because my children will
40:45have equal right on it.
40:46So, my children can object. I mean, that's simple. There's nothing complicated.
40:51So, you know, a karta is a custodian of the family's wealth, not its owner, not its owner.
40:59But equally, Mr. Sibbal, isn't that karta, does he not have the right and isn't he free to leave the
41:08assets, the wealth, the property to either child, whether son or daughter?
41:12No, no, no, no, no. He can't will it. He can't will it because that's not his personal property.
41:18That's the problem. He has to account. Karta means he's a custodian of the property. He has to account for
41:26it. He cannot appropriate it.
41:31What would Lakshmi need to prove to show this is joint family property?
41:37Well, that's the admitted position. There's no dispute on that. The assets that he inherited were from the larger family
41:48business that came down from 1911.
41:53Those are the facts. Nobody disputes it. But his part of the family dissociated. There was a larger partition in
41:592020 with other members of the larger Srinivasan family.
42:04They bought these assets, right? And thereafter, these assets were kept in trust through an MOU, right? And he really
42:14was managing the trust.
42:15And in that process, he gave management of a company to the son and management of another company to Lakshmi.
42:24Now, managing a company doesn't necessarily, or not necessarily, in law, doesn't result in ownership.
42:33So, you heard there from senior advocate Kapil Sibal, who has essentially advocated what Lakshmi Venu says.
42:39Says, it's not Venu's assets to go ahead and decide that Lakshmi has every right to go ahead and put
42:45forth this claim.
42:46Let's get to the other side. Here's an exclusive conversation with Abhishek Manoj Singhvi, who represents Venu Srinivasan.
42:57Hello and welcome to Business Today. I am Siddharth Zarabi.
43:02The dispute within the Venu Srinivasan branch of the TVS family has now become a formal legal claim.
43:10Lakshmi Venu has served a partition notice on her father, Venu Srinivasan, the chairman emeritus of TVS Motor.
43:16She seeks an equal share of the family's assets under the Hindu Succession Act and her mother, Malika Srinivasan, is
43:26backing her.
43:27Mr. Venu Srinivasan has said the separation between his children was settled and done so fairly.
43:35To hear Mr. Srinivasan's side of the story, I am now joined by Dr. Abhishek Manoj Singhvi, eminent jurist,
43:43fifth-term member of parliament, member of the Congress Working Committee, senior national spokesperson of the Congress Party,
43:50and most importantly, lead counsel for Mr. Srinivasan.
43:54Dr. Singhvi, welcome. The first big question that I want to dive in straight away.
44:00And we start with the people. You have Mr. Srinivasan and his son on one side.
44:05On the other are Mrs. Malika Srinivasan and Dr. Lakshmi.
44:11How do you see this divide? Is this really a story of a father going against his daughter?
44:19Well, as I have been saying elsewhere, the first is, of course, the feeling of sadness.
44:25I know all of them very closely and well, except perhaps Lakshmi, I don't know personally.
44:30All of them are very eminent, amiable people.
44:33In fact, Ms. Malika Srinivasan is a very well-known entrepreneur in her own right,
44:38a leading tractor and otherwise a leading figure in the not only tractor production,
44:44but also in government circles, in selection boards, etc.
44:49I know, of course, Mr. Venu Srinivasan, his son, etc. very well.
44:54So it's sad that this has come to such a pass.
44:56But the prima donnas are few and far between.
44:59There are just two males, father and son, and two females, mother and daughter.
45:04The entities are also not all that many.
45:06There is broadly, I mean, you could forget the details of the companies or the entities,
45:10but the entities are broadly the auto entities, the ones which do auto, TVS being the main,
45:16the tractor entity, the TAFE so-called, the die-casting entities like Sundaram Clayton, etc.
45:24And of course, an assortment of private, residential or other properties.
45:29This is a broad pot.
45:32And the rest, of course, is the detail of how partitions and settlements occurred over time.
45:40Dr. Singhvi, Mr. Srinivasan, your client has said in the past that he divided the businesses openly,
45:49and after consulting his family, and we have also spoken to the other side, so to say,
45:55if everyone was consulted, why do Malika Srinivasan, why does the wife and the daughter now say
46:05no economic settlement was ever reached?
46:09Now, Siddhar, this is important, minimizing the minutiae and the detail and the jargon.
46:15It's important to know some facts.
46:17First and foremost, if it is not ancestral property,
46:21let me tell you, a part of this chunk of the pot is not ancestral property.
46:26We'll come to the ancestral soon.
46:29Then, even assuming, and I'm not saying it happened at all remotely,
46:32but even assuming I, the patriarch, decide to give more to you and less to X and Y,
46:38it is my decision, my will.
46:40There is nothing unfair about something where a living person, not a deceased person,
46:45decides to give X to somebody and Y to somebody.
46:49That's as far as non-ancestral property is concerned,
46:52which is also there involved in this pot.
46:54The impression that it's all ancestral is wrong, completely factually.
46:59But now let us look at the best case of the other side,
47:02and you'll understand why the facts are a little, you know,
47:06very different from what is being projected.
47:09Way back 10 years ago, 2017 is just under 10 years ago,
47:14there is a family partition between these four.
47:18It is signed, it is in writing.
47:21As you know, in law, you can even have an oral partition,
47:25but this is signed and in writing.
47:26It says that this is final binding and nobody shall challenge in any manner this.
47:32What does it do?
47:33It broadly lays down that the ancestral property,
47:39which is the highest case, is to be divided in X, Y, Z.
47:42Now forget the division.
47:46This is, if you sign that the X will come to you and Y will come to me and all
47:51four of us signed,
47:52then a retrospective dissatisfaction, because somebody has done well in auto,
47:59because the values have increased after 10 years, cannot justify your wriggling out.
48:04Can anybody deny that the entire ancestral property, including the dissolution of the HUF,
48:11happened way back in 2017?
48:14And broadly the understanding then was, although everything is not stated there,
48:18that's only an ancestral property division.
48:20The understanding is also very important.
48:24Look, tractors ultimately, although as I said,
48:26Ms. Malika is a very well-known entrepreneur, very successful.
48:30Ultimately, her creation, the tractor business, will go to the daughter or the daughter's family.
48:36Ultimately, the auto will go to the son.
48:39In between is an auto-related activity, die-casting,
48:43which also eventually will go to the daughter's side,
48:46though it has gone through a company called Sundaram Clayton,
48:50controlled by a trust, which is Venu Srinivasan's,
48:53the beneficiary of which is already made, Ms. Lakshmi's son.
48:58Plus, there will be residential property given.
49:00So, this is a division, which is signed, agreed.
49:04And it is followed by two further settlements, which I'll tell you about in a moment.
49:07Just for the sake of clarity, for the understanding of our viewers,
49:11who may not know the complete intricacies,
49:14you know, whose property is it really?
49:17Are these his personal assets or the assets of the family branch?
49:23So, this is important, Siddharth.
49:25If there is personal assets, he doesn't have to ask anybody,
49:28he can throw the whole thing to a charity.
49:31I can give my personal assets to a stranger.
49:35I can give my personal assets to, you know, outer space.
49:40That is, nobody can, you can only say that, look, this man is crazy, he's done it,
49:44but you have no right over it.
49:46Absolutely, that's why I'm asking you this.
49:48But the best...
49:49So, that part is also there.
49:51There are assets which are his, but he took everybody into consideration.
49:57There are professional...
49:58But why was Lakshmi, Dr. Singhvi, why was Lakshmi not named a beneficiary of the trust,
50:05the VS trust that holds a controlling stake in TVS holdings?
50:09This is a very big...
50:10That's very important.
50:11This is a very, very big, you know, misinformation piece.
50:14I'm very sorry.
50:16You are right, she's not a beneficiary.
50:19The VS trust principally controls what, Siddharth?
50:22The shares of Sundaram Clayton, which is a major company of die-casting, etc.
50:27Who is the beneficiary?
50:29Please ask that question.
50:33Lakshmi's son.
50:33From what we understand that...
50:35Lakshmi's son, not Sudarshan, not Venu Srinivasan.
50:39Venu Srinivasan has created the trust, he's the setter, he controls it.
50:43But he has made it clear, and I'm saying it on his behalf, Lakshmi's son.
50:48What is the tractor business?
50:50This is India's largest, one of the world's most well-known tractors.
50:54Nobody...
50:54Sudarshan is not saying, look, mother, give it to me.
50:57That will go to the daughter also.
50:59Now it is true, technically Clayton doesn't go to Lakshmi.
51:03But the whole, all the shares are for the benefit of her son.
51:08So clearly the hotspot is Siddharth Zarabi in one box, Singvi in the other box.
51:14Singvi is not getting it.
51:15It's Siddharth Zarabi who's getting it, maybe your son is getting it.
51:18That's the division.
51:21Putting it out there.
51:23And you are forgetting two other things.
51:25This 17, this is 10 years ago, 9 and a half years ago.
51:28This is followed in 2020.
51:33There is a larger family of Mr. Venu Srinivasan, his four or five brothers, etc.
51:38The wider family settlement.
51:39Wider family.
51:40Now this is very, very important.
51:42In that wider family document, you know, the shares are of the father.
51:47That's the ancestral property part, right?
51:50So they have to be divided.
51:52Now in that division, Venu Srinivasan wants to get control of the auto.
51:56Now obviously all the other brothers will not give away the auto shares in which they also have a right
52:01without somebody paying them money.
52:04To get control of auto, Venu Srinivasan has to pay just under 2000 crores.
52:11He actually asks or hopes that maybe Miss Malika and Miss Lakshmi will give part of that money.
52:17They say no, there's a specific clause.
52:20We have nothing to do with paying money towards that.
52:23So he borrows, gets, pays out of his kitty.
52:27He's including that means, you know, Venu's kitty or you can call Venu oblique Sudarshan kitty.
52:32That 2000 crores to get control of auto shares.
52:35And the debt for that 2000 therefore lies with the Venu Sudarshan category.
52:39but we've created money for our money to get control of this year.
52:39It's so long, that's because, of course we can take control of this year.
52:40We're doing a fairly low cost of the interest in the future.