• 13 minutes ago
A Shenzhen broadcast covers the trilateral summit and the Shenzhen Declaration, highlighting geopolitical shifts and strategic issues including nuclear risk and AI competition.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Hello and a very warm welcome to an India Today special broadcast that comes to you from Shenzhen in China.
00:06I am Gaurav Savan. The optics were all right. The photo op is done. The Shenzhen declaration is out.
00:13There are four points that have been decided between the heads of the world's most powerful nuclear weapons states,
00:21the largest number of nuclear weapons, Russia, United States and China.
00:26And they're talking about nuclear arms reduction. In fact, President Xi Jinping of China took it one step ahead.
00:33He said, why should the sword of democracies hang on the heads of the world and talk about reduction?
00:40They should be comprehensively done away with get rid of nuclear weapons entirely.
00:46While it makes great headlines, the big question is, how will this be actioned?
00:51Who will start reducing the number of nuclear weapons? Will the U.S. take the lead? Will Russia take the
00:57lead?
00:57Or will China take the lead? That's point one. Point two, the three also spoke of a multipolar world.
01:06They spoke of U.N. reforms. And this has been a longstanding demand because, remember,
01:11the United Nations came after the end of the Second World War.
01:1420th century architecture cannot serve the interests of the 21st century world.
01:18The world's most populous nation, India. Now, when you talk of U.N. reforms,
01:23will India be a part of the United Nations Security Council?
01:26Same set of rules for all. And that remains to be seen.
01:31So while there is talk of U.N. reforms, who will bell the cat?
01:35Will China do it? Will the United States do it? Will Russia do it?
01:39And then, talking about limiting the role of the ICC, the International Criminal Court,
01:46this is something that would be a shot in the arm for Russian President Vladimir Putin.
01:51We will get you to listen in to what U.S. President Donald Trump had to say about this.
01:55And, extremely important, the three decided, with global economy and tailspin,
02:01that more oil will be pumped. There will be normalization of supplies,
02:06an increased supply of oil across the world.
02:10The big question, what happens to the Strait of Hormuz?
02:13On the 28th of February, when U.S. and Israel started bombing Iran,
02:18the Strait of Hormuz was open.
02:20So will there be a back channel?
02:24Will China and Russia reach out to Iran and get Iran to accept that it will open the Strait of
02:30Hormuz
02:30so that more oil can be pumped?
02:32Even if more oil is going to be pumped, if Strait of Hormuz is shut,
02:35then that oil cannot be sent down to other countries.
02:39India, ASEAN countries, rest of Asia, China, all adversely impacted.
02:43And the world in tailspin because of wars being waged between Russia and Ukraine and U.S., Israel and Iran.
02:51And then, of course, what happens on the Russia-Ukraine front?
02:54Because American President Donald Trump, he spoke of it.
02:57He said he's had a long conversation with the Russian President Vladimir Putin
03:01about ending the Russia-Ukraine war.
03:04But what about the other side?
03:06Does the other side also want it?
03:09And his special envoy, son-in-law Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff,
03:14they've flown to Berlin from Shenzhen.
03:16They will be briefing the Ukrainian President Vladimir Zelensky and the European leadership.
03:21Will they be on board?
03:23Many, many questions.
03:25We'll try and seek answers during the course of this broadcast
03:28because the optics have all been right.
03:32What about the deliverables?
03:34Is there something substantive that emerges from it?
03:37We'll get you perspective from China.
03:39We'll get you perspective from Russia, from the United States.
03:42And, of course, what does this mean for India?
03:45360-degree perspective.
03:47I'll be reporting from Shenzhen.
03:49Our guests will be joining us from across the world.
03:51But first, we get you this ground report from Shenzhen.
04:00Three leaders, three nuclear powers, one historic summit.
04:07Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping came together in Shenzhen,
04:13issuing a joint peace declaration with commitments on nuclear security,
04:18global stability, UN reform and energy cooperation.
04:22The three powers have agreed to hold dialogue on reducing nuclear risk
04:27and preventing proliferation, reaffirming that nuclear war can not be won
04:32and must never be fought.
04:35They've also called for UN reforms, greater production and supply of refined petroleum products,
04:41stable energy flows and respect for state sovereignty.
04:49We naturally discuss the potential reform and enhancement of the United Nations' capabilities.
04:55We all acknowledge the necessity of this,
04:57of adapting the work of this universal organization to the realities of the present day.
05:04We addressed security issues in the broadest sense,
05:07including the prevention of the proliferation of weapons,
05:10of mass destruction and nuclear weapons.
05:15But several major global issues find no mention.
05:19The Ukraine and Iran wars, artificial intelligence,
05:23semiconductors, Taiwan and global supply chains are all absent from the joint statement.
05:29Xi Jinping called nuclear weapons a sword of Damocles,
05:33hanging over humanity, demanding their complete prohibition and destruction.
05:37Trump backed nuclear arms reduction, but he drew a firm red line on Iran.
05:43We're going to be discussing the war between Russia and the United States, Russia and China,
05:48uniquely positioned to discuss how to reduce the number of nuclear weapons on earth
05:52and also to lessen the risk that those weapons will ever be used.
05:57But it's also vital that we cooperate to combat the threat of nuclear proliferation
06:02in other countries around the world.
06:04That's what we're doing in Iran.
06:06We're not going to let Iran have a nuclear weapon.
06:09Russian President Putin invoked the legacy of the Second World War,
06:14recalling that the three countries were on the victorious side
06:17and stressing that they shared responsibility for international peace and security.
06:25For my part, I'm convinced that Russia, China and the United States
06:29and our respective people are capable of making a significant contribution
06:33to strengthening global security and stability,
06:36providing they engage in constructive partnership-based cooperation
06:40rooted in mutual respect, equality and a balance of interests.
06:46On Ukraine, Trump revealed that he and Putin had held a lengthy discussion.
06:52We are going to be discussing the war between Russia and Ukraine,
06:56and we already have.
06:57President Putin and I have had a long discussion today for quite a while.
07:01That's pretty much what the discussion was about.
07:06And I think things are happening. I think that...
07:09Putin's Yalta reference added historical significance to the summit.
07:13But unlike the wartime allies of 1945,
07:17today's three leaders represent competing powers with different strategic interests.
07:24For India, the message from Shenzhen is clear.
07:27As major powers shape the emerging world order,
07:31New Delhi must safeguard its strategic autonomy,
07:34protect its national interests,
07:36and ensure its voice remains central to every global conversation.
07:44So, while there is a four-point consensus
07:46in the broad framework of the Shenzhen peace declaration,
07:50the fine print is still awaited.
07:53But the big question does remain,
07:55does the road to peace between Russia and Ukraine
07:58and US and Iran go through Shenzhen in China?
08:03We're tracking that very closely.
08:05Gaurav Savant in Shenzhen, China, for India Today.
08:11So, let me now get you a 360-degree perspective
08:14on this big developing story.
08:17The Shenzhen declaration is out.
08:19Is this just optics?
08:22Is there something substantive here?
08:24There is an intent that the three powerful world leaders
08:27have decided or discussed what next.
08:31Will it bring peace on the Russia-Ukraine front or the US-Iran front?
08:36What about UN reforms?
08:38Let's take this step-by-step and, of course, denuclearization.
08:41The first big takeaway, let me get our guests in.
08:44Let me introduce our guests joining us on this special broadcast.
08:47Aynar Tanjan, Senior Fellow,
08:49Center for International Governance Innovation,
08:51joins us on this broadcast.
08:53Tatiana Kokhreva is a strategist who joins us from Russia.
08:56Dr. Tara Kartha, Strategic Affairs Experts,
08:59Professor Brahma Chalani,
09:00one of India's foremost strategic voices,
09:03joins us on the show.
09:04Also with me, two of my colleagues,
09:05Sandeep Unnithan and Pradayopadhyay.
09:07Ladies and gentlemen, welcome.
09:09Aynar Tanjan, you're, according to you,
09:14the biggest takeaway from the big three meeting here in Shenzhen.
09:19Talking about if the American president said,
09:22reduce nuclear weapons,
09:23the Chinese president said,
09:25why reduce?
09:26Just get rid of them.
09:28Comprehensively get rid of nuclear weapons.
09:30Very noble thought, sir.
09:31But how will this be translated into action on ground?
09:38Well, as you pointed out,
09:39there were four agreements,
09:40but these are kind of like,
09:42as we say in America,
09:43apple pie and mother's milk.
09:45These were not things
09:48that have a roadmap to them.
09:50They're aspirational.
09:53And the question is,
09:55what was this meeting about?
09:57Remember, this is APEC.
09:58This is not the UN.
10:00Generally, this would be the subject
10:01for the UN denuclearization.
10:03You have three of the five
10:05Security Council members.
10:07Why couldn't they meet there?
10:09Instead,
10:10you had both
10:12the United States and Russia
10:14bringing, in essence,
10:15their dirty laundry
10:16to China
10:18and, you know,
10:22it's something that has
10:23absolutely nothing to do with that.
10:25Yes,
10:26all of these countries
10:27are suffering.
10:28Yes,
10:28there needs to be addressed,
10:29but this was not the forum.
10:31You have to remember,
10:34APEC
10:34consisted,
10:35since last year,
10:36of 10,000 participants
10:38who met
10:39in 300 meetings
10:41over 10 different areas
10:43of commerce
10:44and dialogue
10:45trying to hammer out
10:47a way in which
10:48you could create
10:48a regional stability.
10:50And this
10:50has nothing to do with that.
10:52So,
10:53yes,
10:53it's fine that they said that.
10:55I agree with it.
10:56But how do you get it done?
11:02Absolutely.
11:03And that question remains.
11:04So,
11:04is this more optics,
11:06great visuals,
11:07but not substantive?
11:09Professor Brahmachalani,
11:10your reading of,
11:12one,
11:12the joint declaration,
11:13and then subsequently
11:14we'll take this
11:15point by point,
11:16especially on the
11:17Russia-Ukraine war
11:18and the U.S.-Iran war.
11:20But overall,
11:20the big picture,
11:21what does it look like
11:23to you, sir?
11:25From Putin
11:26and Xi Jinping
11:27presented themselves
11:29in their opening remarks
11:30as joint guardians
11:32of global security,
11:34with Trump saying
11:35that all three of them
11:36had a special responsibility
11:37to maintain communication
11:39with one another.
11:40Yet the three leaders
11:41walked away from the summit
11:43with little to show,
11:44beyond their big talk
11:45and their photo ops.
11:48To be sure,
11:49expectations for the summit
11:50were low from the beginning,
11:52and the trilateral lived up
11:53to those low expectations.
11:56The biggest loser
11:57from the trilateral
11:58was without doubt
11:59the United States.
12:01The trilateral
12:02was confirmation
12:03that the U.S.
12:04has lost its global primacy
12:06and that it's willing
12:08to settle
12:09on being one of three
12:10big powers.
12:11And the biggest winner
12:13from the trilateral
12:14was China.
12:15The trilateral
12:16underscored
12:17the world has entered
12:18the post-U.S.
12:20primacy era.
12:22So we are now
12:23looking at a
12:25tri-polar order.
12:27By sitting as equals
12:30at, you know,
12:31at this villa
12:33on the sidelines
12:34of the apex of it,
12:35Washington gave
12:36Xi Jinping
12:37and Vladimir Putin
12:38the exact stage
12:39they have spent
12:40years demanding.
12:42They have been, you know,
12:43they have been looking
12:44at a three-way
12:46direct rate
12:48of great powers
12:49managing global stability.
12:52And for years
12:52Beijing has pushed
12:53quote-unquote
12:54multi-polarity
12:55to dilute U.S.
12:57hegemony.
12:58And by hosting
12:59the first ever
13:00U.S.-China-Russia
13:01summit
13:01Chinese soil,
13:04it, you know,
13:04it has boosted
13:05its own image.
13:06And in fact,
13:07Beijing
13:08has presented itself
13:10as the indispensable
13:11convener.
13:13China didn't just
13:14host the trilateral.
13:16It shaped
13:17the output.
13:19The four-point
13:21declaration,
13:23joint declaration
13:23released through
13:24Chinese and Russian
13:25media
13:26mirrors Beijing's
13:28long-standing
13:29talking points.
13:30What are those
13:31long-standing
13:31talking points?
13:32U.N. reform,
13:33state humility,
13:34skepticism of
13:35international
13:36like the ICC.
13:38And while
13:39leaving out
13:39concrete U.S.
13:40priorities,
13:41like, you know,
13:42like enforceable
13:43nuclear caps
13:44or breakthroughs
13:46on Ukraine and
13:48Iraq.
13:49So, China has
13:50positioned itself
13:52as the pivot
13:53between Washington
13:54and Moscow.
13:59So, let me now
14:00take it to
14:01Tatiana Kukareva
14:02who joins us
14:02from Moscow
14:03on the story.
14:04Very interesting.
14:05So, it's a big
14:06gain for China,
14:07also a big gain
14:09for Russian
14:09President
14:09Vladimir Putin
14:10because both
14:11United States
14:12under Joe
14:13Biden and
14:14Europe till
14:14now have
14:15tried to
14:16isolate the
14:17Russian
14:17president.
14:18Not only did
14:19they fail
14:19spectacularly,
14:20today, both
14:22Europe and
14:23President Zelensky
14:25are out of
14:26the, you know,
14:27they're not in
14:28the room,
14:28they're out,
14:29and President
14:31Putin is not
14:32only in,
14:33he's firmly
14:34taking the
14:34decisions along
14:35with the
14:37American
14:37president and
14:38the Chinese
14:38president,
14:39and on
14:39ICC,
14:41that ICC
14:41that was being
14:42seen as
14:42targeting the
14:44Russian president,
14:45the three have
14:46decided that ICC
14:47needs to be put
14:48in its place.
14:48Tatiana Kukareva,
14:50what's the reading
14:50of this declaration
14:51in Moscow?
14:53Well, the
14:55reading, look,
14:58first of all,
14:59the ICC has not
15:00just targeted
15:01Vladimir Putin,
15:02right, and it
15:03makes perfect sense
15:04that, for instance,
15:05Donald Trump would
15:06step in there
15:07because one of
15:08the people who've
15:10been condemned
15:10by the ICC is
15:11actually Benjamin
15:12Netanyahu, for
15:13example, with whom
15:14Donald Trump has
15:15obviously had
15:16quite a productive
15:18relationship.
15:19But let me
15:22reframe this
15:24conversation for
15:25a tiny bit
15:26because the
15:27way I see it
15:28right now with
15:29all of us
15:30seriously discussing
15:31the fact that
15:32Europe or
15:33Ukraine were
15:34not in the
15:34room at an
15:35APEC summit,
15:36which has
15:37nothing to do
15:37with Europe
15:38or Ukraine,
15:39or the fact
15:41that we're
15:41looking at a
15:42trilateral order
15:44actually makes
15:45some of the
15:46European powers
15:47the winner
15:48because that
15:48was the
15:49narrative, the
15:50whole framing
15:51of this as
15:52a trilateral
15:54G2 plus
15:55one or
15:56Yalta summit,
15:57that was very
15:57much a
15:58European narrative
15:59or a US
16:00democratic one
16:01for that matter
16:02because they're
16:03the only ones
16:03who would
16:04benefit from
16:04this narrative
16:05altogether.
16:06Look, this
16:07was an APEC
16:09summit.
16:09The three
16:10people in the
16:11room were the
16:12leaders, of
16:14course, of the
16:15biggest powers
16:17within APEC
16:19in response to
16:21Professor
16:21Chilani.
16:22Well, I
16:23don't think, I
16:24wouldn't say
16:24that the
16:25resolution actually
16:26mirrors the
16:27Chinese position
16:27because India
16:28has been pushing
16:29for a UN
16:30reform for
16:31quite a while.
16:32So this
16:33actually represents
16:34a BRICS
16:35perspective for
16:36that matter
16:36because the
16:37UN Security
16:37Council does
16:38not reflect the
16:39realities of
16:40the, yes, the
16:41multipolar world,
16:42but that is not
16:43just the Chinese
16:44position, is
16:45it?
16:46It is very
16:47much a BRICS
16:48kind of position
16:49and the Russian
16:50position as well.
16:52Absolutely.
16:53And a long
16:55standing Indian
16:55position too
16:56that UN
16:57Security Council
16:58has to be
16:59reformed, has to
17:00reflect realities
17:01of the 21st
17:01century because
17:02in its current
17:03form, UN is
17:03way past its
17:04sell by date
17:05or use by date.
17:06I want to
17:06bring in
17:06Professor
17:07Inart Anjan
17:07once again
17:08before I
17:08bring in
17:09Dr. Tara
17:09Kartha, on
17:11the issue
17:12of countries
17:13will pump
17:14more oil
17:15for stabilizing
17:16global markets
17:16or words to
17:17that effect
17:17in this
17:18declaration,
17:19they may
17:19pump more
17:20oil but
17:21the oil
17:22market or
17:23the global
17:23economy will
17:24not get
17:24stabilized as
17:25long as
17:26Strait of
17:26Hormuz remains
17:27shut and
17:28that's a
17:28huge choke
17:29point, sir.
17:30Is there
17:31in your
17:32appreciation
17:32any back
17:33channel that
17:34China and
17:36Russia may
17:36mount some
17:37kind of
17:37pressure or
17:38use some
17:39leverage on
17:39Iran to
17:40open the
17:40Strait of
17:41Hormuz?
17:44No, I
17:44mean you
17:45can't impose
17:45peace and
17:46I disagree
17:47with this
17:47idea that
17:48China is
17:48trying to
17:49be part of
17:49some sort
17:50of directorate
17:51or triumvirate.
17:52You look at
17:52exactly what
17:53they've been
17:53doing, it's
17:54quite the
17:55opposite.
17:55The Belt and
17:56Road Initiative
17:56was not about
17:57seizing power
17:58or taking
17:59things.
17:59It wasn't
18:00about taking
18:01Venezuela or
18:02claiming that
18:02you should
18:04have Greenland
18:04and things like
18:05that.
18:05They are not
18:07trying to
18:08engage in
18:08empire building.
18:09They've done
18:11consistently and
18:12what they've
18:13been doing for
18:13the last year
18:14at AIPAC is
18:15trying to put
18:15together a
18:16multilateral,
18:17multipolar world
18:18which is based
18:18on making the
18:19pie bigger.
18:20More trade,
18:21less tariffs,
18:22more certainty,
18:23more predictability.
18:25So right now
18:27this, as I
18:28said, it was
18:29hijacked.
18:30You have people
18:31running around
18:32saying this was
18:32Yalta 2.0
18:33including references
18:34by Putin.
18:36Nothing
18:36further from
18:37the truth
18:37because China
18:38doesn't want
18:39to play that
18:40game.
18:40That is the
18:42colonial past
18:43and it's
18:44unfortunate that
18:45we still have
18:46leaders who
18:47believe that
18:48they are back
18:49in that kind
18:50of frame of
18:51reference.
18:51Who's on top?
18:52Who gets to
18:53tell who what
18:53to do?
18:54Of all countries,
18:56India should be
18:57very, very wary
18:58of this.
18:58The idea that
19:00the power should
19:01be deciding
19:02what happens.
19:03Why wasn't
19:03India there?
19:05I mean,
19:05certainly he
19:06paid, what,
19:07a 55-minute
19:08including photo
19:10visit to
19:11the Philippines
19:13but it was
19:14a joke.
19:15I mean,
19:16come on.
19:17If you're going
19:18to have a real
19:18multipolar world,
19:20you're going to
19:20have real peace.
19:21It requires all
19:22of the actors
19:23to be there.
19:24I mean,
19:24Ukraine wasn't
19:25there, obviously.
19:26Europe wasn't
19:27there, so how
19:28are you going to
19:28solve that issue?
19:30And then with
19:30Iran, this idea
19:31that you can
19:32impose on it,
19:33how?
19:33They'll fight.
19:34They'll continue
19:35to fight.
19:35They are very,
19:37very ideological,
19:38the IRGC.
19:39They're not going
19:39to do other
19:41people.
19:42Is this,
19:43then,
19:44isn't that just
19:46a photo op?
19:47Was this then
19:48just a photo op?
19:49Because if I may,
19:50when China talks
19:51of a multipolar
19:52world, does it
19:53also talk about
19:54a multipolar
19:55Asia?
19:56You know,
19:57Asia has
19:57multiple powers
19:58and not just
19:59China is the
19:59supreme power,
20:00point one,
20:01point two.
20:01When China
20:02sees more
20:03access,
20:03seeks more
20:04access to
20:04the global
20:05economy or
20:07more integrated
20:07global supply
20:08chains,
20:09does China
20:09want to give
20:10India more
20:11access to the
20:12Chinese markets
20:12that India has
20:13been seeking
20:14for a very
20:15long time?
20:15So is there,
20:17Professor Aynar
20:18Tanjin,
20:19before I let you
20:19go, I believe
20:20you have another
20:21appointment,
20:22you know,
20:23will China also
20:24have to practice
20:24what it preaches
20:26to the world
20:27in terms of
20:28giving more
20:28access to others
20:29to its markets,
20:30sir?
20:32Okay,
20:33access to your
20:34markets isn't
20:34simply saying,
20:35okay, you get to
20:36sell your things
20:37and you don't have
20:38to be competitive.
20:40Indian firms have
20:41to be competitive
20:41to go on the market.
20:42I mean, they have
20:43access to the
20:44Russian market,
20:45but they don't sell
20:46well because they
20:47don't have the
20:47brands that are
20:48there.
20:48It's not a question
20:49of quality or
20:50anything like that.
20:51It's just they
20:51haven't developed
20:52the games,
20:53which is very
20:54odd given that
20:54in the United
20:55States, many of
20:56the leading
20:56companies,
20:57especially in the
20:58tech field,
20:59are run by
20:59people of Indian
21:00or Indian descent.
21:02So, I mean,
21:03it's a question
21:04of India upping
21:05its game.
21:06No one's going
21:06to give India
21:07anything.
21:07And when people
21:08get into this
21:09whole issue
21:10about, well,
21:11look at the
21:12trade imbalance
21:13between China
21:14and India.
21:14Well, most of
21:15that trade imbalance
21:16is due to the
21:17fact that India
21:18buys inputs
21:19from China.
21:20And those inputs,
21:22including a lot
21:23of the chemicals
21:24that go into
21:25generic drugs
21:26and things like
21:27that, are then
21:28resold abroad.
21:29And that is why
21:30India, to a large
21:32extent, has a
21:33surplus with other
21:34nations because it's
21:35using what it gets
21:37from China and then
21:38repackaging and
21:40upping the value
21:41of it and then
21:41selling.
21:42So, this is a
21:44situation where you
21:45cannot blame
21:45that comic.
21:45Chinese market,
21:47but there is
21:47opacity in the
21:49Chinese market.
21:50There's also
21:50opacity in the
21:51Chinese market.
21:52So, when there's
21:53predictability that
21:54President Xi
21:54Jinping talks about
21:56globally, that same
21:57predictability should
21:58be there in
21:59accessing Chinese
22:00markets, for
22:01example.
22:01And as far as
22:02the Russian markets
22:02are concerned,
22:03it's not about
22:04quality, it's about
22:05sanctions.
22:06And sanctions not
22:07imposed by the
22:08United Nations, but
22:09sanctions imposed by
22:10the United States,
22:11that was in the
22:12room right here in
22:13Shenzhen.
22:13And that is where
22:14it's a very unequal
22:16place, Dr. Tara
22:17Kartha, you know,
22:18where the big
22:20three do not
22:21practice what they
22:22preach.
22:23Hold on.
22:24Hold on.
22:26And the United
22:27States, really?
22:28There are no
22:28sanctions?
22:29There were 25%
22:30additional sanctions
22:31imposed on India for
22:33buying Russian oil,
22:34and companies fear if
22:35they were to sell to
22:36Russia, they would
22:37come under the U.S.
22:38sanction regime and
22:39not the U.N.
22:40sanction regimes.
22:41Dr. Tara Kartha.
22:43Listen, it's absolute
22:44hypocrisy, okay?
22:45I'm sorry, I'm going to
22:46say this is not clear.
22:48Talking of U.N.
22:48reforms, these three
22:49countries, they are the
22:50worst.
22:51The U.S. has
22:52absolutely ignored the
22:54U.N. in terms of
22:55sanctions, in terms of
22:56rules, in terms of
22:57everything.
22:58China doesn't care about
22:59the U.N. in terms of
23:00when it actually comes to
23:02the ground in South
23:03China Sea or anywhere
23:04else.
23:04So this is just sheer
23:05hypocrisy.
23:07China, by the way,
23:08blocked us in terms of
23:09our Security Council
23:10membership.
23:11So I don't know what
23:12reform they're talking
23:13of.
23:13If, however, big if,
23:16if, however, I mean,
23:17I'm open to the fact
23:18that maybe they genuinely
23:20want reform, will they
23:21let in countries like
23:22India?
23:23If they do, fantastic.
23:25That is a huge, huge,
23:28what shall I say, plus
23:29point for India-China
23:30relations.
23:31Number two, who took
23:33away the spoils, Russia
23:35did.
23:35Russia and China, Russia
23:37got its oil energy
23:38flowing.
23:39So that's a big plus.
23:40It says it's going to
23:41hammer the hell out of
23:42Ukraine now, which it
23:44didn't say it all this
23:45time.
23:45In response to the
23:46Crimea attack, two
23:48attacks, he kept quiet.
23:50Third attack, finally he
23:51says, yeah, we're going
23:52to hit you back.
23:53He says, I'm going to
23:54G20.
23:55He's got his energy
23:56flowing again.
23:57At least that's what
23:57has been agreed.
23:58So he gets, and he
24:00also has a stake in
24:02making this look even
24:03bigger than it actually
24:04is.
24:05You know, he's been
24:06talking this up, saying
24:07it's, you know, this is
24:08a great thing and
24:09things.
24:10So that is one part.
24:11We don't know how much
24:12of it is actually going
24:13to work.
24:14China walked away with
24:15energy.
24:16What did the US get?
24:18I really don't know
24:19because they're going to
24:21lose out in terms of
24:23their LNG which they're
24:24selling to Europe.
24:25If this war halts, these
24:29guys stopped making
24:29money, right?
24:31They stopped selling
24:32weapons to Europe.
24:34So I'm really puzzled.
24:36I mean, I'm sure there's
24:37something there which we
24:38guys, you don't know.
24:39What is it that the US
24:41got from this deal?
24:44That if we know, then
24:45you know where this is
24:46going.
24:46Otherwise, this is, I
24:47mean, if the energy
24:48flows, there it is.
24:49So, if the energy
24:54flows, it's good.
24:55Before I bring in
24:56Ms. Kukreva once again,
24:58I want to bring in
24:59Sandeep Unnithan and
25:00Pranayopadhyay who have
25:00been waiting and
25:01listening very patiently.
25:02Key takeaway, Sandeep,
25:04if there is one headline
25:05that emerges beyond the
25:07beautiful optics here in
25:09Shenzhen, what's that
25:10headline for you,
25:11Sandeep?
25:12Well, Gaurav, I've just
25:15seen the photograph of
25:17the post-Cold War world.
25:20The post-Cold War world
25:21began in 1991.
25:22It ended roughly around
25:242020.
25:25The post-post-Cold War
25:27world is what we're
25:27living through.
25:28And today, that picture
25:29of the three leaders
25:30standing side by side,
25:31one, a manufacturing
25:32superpower, another, a
25:34resource superpower, and
25:35the third, a country
25:38that used to be the
25:39sole superpower, which is
25:40now having to share
25:41space with China and
25:43the Russian Federation.
25:44This is the ultimate
25:45image in my
25:48appreciation, Gaurav, the
25:49fact that we have
25:49finally seen in the
25:51last five or six years
25:52the end of U.S.
25:53primacy, the way the
25:54United States used to
25:55dominate the world
25:57after the post-Cold
25:58War, during the
26:00post-Cold War era,
26:01that has come to an
26:02end.
26:03And that is literally
26:03this photograph that
26:04we're looking at.
26:05It, of course, remains to
26:06be seen how things will
26:08play out in the next
26:09five or ten years.
26:10But for now, I think
26:11this is one of the
26:12biggest takeaways for me.
26:14The fall of the
26:14Berlin Wall was one
26:15big image which defined
26:17the end of the Cold
26:18War.
26:19This is going to be one
26:20of those big images that
26:22define the post-post-Cold
26:23War world, Gaurav.
26:27Okay, Pranay, it's the
26:29rise of China, it's the
26:31rise of Russia, but does
26:33it show America on a
26:35decline?
26:35Because both China and
26:37Russia have something to
26:38boast about.
26:39What does U.S.
26:41President walk back to
26:42United States or fly back
26:43to United States with?
26:45What is one tangible gain
26:47for him from this
26:48journey?
26:50Let's talk about the
26:51three takeaways for all
26:52these three countries.
26:53Gaurav, first, what did
26:55President Xi Jinping got?
26:56He got validation and the
26:58thing which he mentioned
27:00during his last meeting
27:01with President Donald
27:01Trump about the
27:02Thucydides trap, President
27:04Donald Trump ended up
27:05validating that and, in
27:06fact, China has emerged as
27:08a meeting ground of both
27:09these big powers to come
27:11to China, talk about their
27:12issues and discuss and make
27:14it a G3, a bipolar world
27:16has become a G3 world kind
27:17of a structure and
27:18President of the United
27:19States has validated it.
27:21But for President Vladimir
27:23Putin, this is a
27:23showcasing of his
27:24mainstreaming.
27:26Those who were trying to
27:27alienate Russia, this is
27:28his comeback and to show
27:30to them that, look, I am
27:31still relevant and I am
27:33still powerful and I am
27:34still on the big table.
27:35But as far as the U.S.
27:36President Donald Trump
27:36is concerned, his only
27:38takeaway is a spectacle.
27:39He wanted to show to the
27:41world that he can pull, he
27:43can bring all these three
27:44leaders, you know, these
27:46two leaders to one table
27:47and he wanted to make an
27:49optics of it.
27:50So he got an optics of it.
27:51But beside that, I will be
27:52compelled to reiterate what
27:54I have been saying since
27:55morning, that this is high
27:56on optics, very low on
27:57deliverables and tangibles.
28:02Okay.
28:03Okay.
28:04Okay.
28:04So, Professor Brabha Chalani
28:05wants to bring in, before I
28:06bring in, Tathya Khuraghan
28:07from Russia.
28:08But, Professor Chalani, go
28:10ahead.
28:11Win for China, win for Russia,
28:13but a loss for the United
28:14States of America.
28:15What's that big gain for U.S.
28:17that comes out of this?
28:20Well, Trump tried very hard to
28:25bring China into nuclear arms
28:27control.
28:28The reason is that China's
28:30nuclear force is growing by
28:33about 100 warheads every year.
28:36This is a frenzied nuclear weapons
28:38buildup by China.
28:40Far from hiding this nuclear frenzy,
28:45China is flaunting it, as if to
28:47underline that its rapidly growing
28:49arsenal is driven more by
28:50political than military
28:53considerations.
28:54And the unprecedented speed and
28:56scale of the nuclear buildup
28:58appears to be linked to Xi Jinping's
29:00international expansionism, as China
29:03seeks global privacy by 2049, the
29:07centenary of communist rule.
29:09China wants to be, by 2049,
29:14a world power second to none.
29:17In other words, it's seeking to
29:19supplant the U.S. as the world's
29:21foremost power.
29:23That's its ambition.
29:24That's its goal by 2049.
29:27And the nuclear weapons buildup
29:29is part and parcel of that ambition.
29:34So with the U.S., sorry, with the U.S.,
29:38Russia, New START clearly having expired
29:41in February this year, the U.S. and
29:44Russia do not want to get into a
29:47bilateral nuclear arms control
29:50agreement, a grain, without bringing
29:52in China.
29:53But you...
29:55Yes.
29:55China.
29:55But in Shenzhen...
29:57Yes.
29:57Yeah, in Shenzhen, we heard some
30:00lovely words from Xi Jinping about,
30:02you know, nuclear weapons, the need to
30:05eliminate them, but no willingness to
30:08be part of nuclear arms control.
30:10And of course, there are larger
30:11implications for India from...
30:14Oh, absolutely.
30:15Lovely words.
30:16Lovely words.
30:18But will they be followed by action
30:20on ground?
30:20I'll come to implications for India
30:22in just a moment, sir.
30:23But for a moment, I want to talk
30:24about the elephant in the room, or if
30:26I may, the bear in the room, on the
30:29Russia-Ukraine front.
30:30And Tatiana Khureva, do you see any
30:33let-up in the war between Russia and
30:36Ukraine?
30:36President Trump indicated that both
30:39he and President Putin had a long
30:40conversation about ending war.
30:42Now it remains to be seen whether the
30:44other side wants it.
30:45Is the other side Ukraine?
30:47Is the other side Europe?
30:48What do you see happen on the Russia-Ukraine
30:50war front now, after this conversation
30:53here in Shenzhen?
30:54Well, first of all, Gaurav, I see a big
30:57problem that we're actually discussing
30:58war in terms of an economic gathering,
31:02right?
31:03And AIPAC is Asia-Pacific Economic
31:06Corporation.
31:08So it's not about war.
31:11And this is why primarily, you know,
31:14we got the most that we wanted out of
31:17this conversation between the three
31:18leaders, their commitment to kind of,
31:21you know, restoring world peace and
31:24their commitment to the concept in
31:26general.
31:27In the meantime, while we're still
31:29talking about economics, I would
31:31really like to remind everybody that
31:33there was one point in that four-point
31:36declaration that we keep forgetting
31:37about, the three countries and the
31:40three leaders agreeing to boost
31:43refined oil production.
31:45And we also keep forgetting that the
31:47U.S. is right now...
31:49I'll come to oil in just a moment.
31:49Hold on, hold on.
31:50No, no, Tatiana, Tatiana.
31:51Exactly.
31:52Let me follow.
31:52Let me follow.
31:53No, Tatiana.
31:54Let me follow the line.
31:55I want to stay on the Russia-Ukraine war
31:58for one.
31:58I'll come to oil in just a moment
32:00because that's in the Iran segment.
32:02When we talk about Russia-Ukraine war,
32:04is there any let-up or will this war
32:07continue despite this conversation?
32:10Whether it's an economic forum, war is
32:12also all about economics and it's upsetting
32:14global economy in a big way, including the
32:17APEC economy.
32:18Even though Russian president said that,
32:20you know, Russia has been providing as a
32:22stable partner and has been providing oil
32:24and fertilizers and all of that.
32:27Global economy isn't tailspin.
32:30Russia-Ukraine war is one reason.
32:32In your view, do you see any let-up in the war
32:35after this conversation?
32:37You're reading.
32:38Global economy is in tailspin, but not because
32:41of Russia-Ukraine war.
32:43Because of a different war in a different part
32:46of the world and with different powers
32:48involved.
32:48Also because of this?
32:50Primarily because of this.
32:52No, I'm-
32:53Both are involved.
32:54It's not-
32:55No, no, it's both.
32:56To answer your question, every single
32:58conversation that Donald Trump and Vladimir
33:01Putin hold brings us closer to a form
33:05of compromise.
33:07Look, we need to remember, we've been five
33:10years we've been into this almost, and the
33:13fact that we still think that this is a war
33:15between Russia and Ukraine is ridiculous
33:20at this moment in time.
33:22Ukraine is being financed by very certain
33:24powers.
33:25One of them, wait, one of them, and the
33:28biggest one to date has been the U.S.
33:31So they do have a lot to talk about.
33:34They do have a lot to agree on before
33:36Europeans have even have any place in this
33:40conversation, because they didn't quite
33:41decide on their own either.
33:43You know, that was about NATO expansion.
33:46So, this does bring us closer to a resolution,
33:50but we need to stop sensationalizing every
33:53summit in the way where we expect a big
33:56breakthrough or an announcement of peace
33:58or an announcement of something to come
34:01out of one summit.
34:02This is a very complex issue that was many,
34:06many years in the building.
34:11Sure.
34:11I mean, if no headline, it's a great photo op,
34:15as Pranay and Sandeep were also saying.
34:17Wonderful photo opportunity, but nothing
34:20substantive, at least on the face of it,
34:22Dr. Tara Kartha, before I bring in Sandeep
34:24Unitan and Pranay Upadhyay, which means Russia
34:27and Ukraine continue to go after each other.
34:29And what was achieved here, apart from great photographs?
34:36I don't agree that the fact that these three met
34:40is a step forward, right?
34:41It's a step, presumably, from global peace,
34:44which in our segment on India, we can say,
34:47we really need that peace and we need it badly.
34:49Did it, like I said, the Russians have come away with a lot.
34:54There's no doubt.
34:55He's come with the positioning, he's got the G20,
34:59all the rest of it, which I just mentioned.
35:01Putin has got what he wanted out of this war.
35:03Number two, it's not a coincidence that that Crimea bridge
35:07was attacked at that point of time.
35:09Who pushed that?
35:11That was off limits.
35:13So there is a question there.
35:14I think Europe is trying to sabotage this.
35:17They don't want a peace done over their heads.
35:20That is number two.
35:21The takeaway, Gaurav, I think is very, it's very interesting.
35:27You know, they're talking of non-proliferation.
35:29Who is the non-proliferator?
35:31The proliferator here is China.
35:32Okay, that's a different issue.
35:34I think what US was also trying to say is that,
35:37you know, the whole message is Iran will not get a nuclear weapon.
35:41So is he saying that these are the countries
35:43who are helping Iran to get that nuclear deal?
35:48I don't think so,
35:48because China never ever wanted Iran to go nuclear.
35:52That's a different issue.
35:53So the whole, the nuclear non-proliferation thing,
35:57I am not sure how it is being framed.
35:59And I would watch that very carefully
36:01to see which way it is going.
36:07Okay, no, as far as this Russia-Ukraine war is concerned, Sandeep,
36:11the fact that Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff
36:14have flown off to Berlin from Shenzhen,
36:16and the fact that they're reaching out
36:17to both Vladimir Zelensky and European leaders,
36:20which means there's some back channel that's happening,
36:23but will President Zelensky agree
36:25after losing 20% of his country
36:27and lakhs of his soldiers,
36:28if he signs the dotted line
36:30without any semblance of a gift from Russia,
36:33he might as well start a comedy show
36:35in another part of the world,
36:36but he wouldn't be able to survive in Ukraine.
36:39Well, absolutely, Gaurav.
36:41You know, it's going to be a very hard,
36:42you know, act to follow
36:44on losing 20% of your territory,
36:47and that is something that
36:48the Ukrainians have been opposed to.
36:51And what President Putin has said today
36:53is significant.
36:54He said that, look,
36:55you have to accept the reality on the ground.
36:57Yalta was about the reality on the ground,
36:59and so is the Russia-Ukraine war.
37:01It's a different matter.
37:02It wasn't mentioned in the joint statement,
37:04but the fact is that
37:05it is going to be extremely difficult
37:07for Ukraine to, you know,
37:10accept the loss of territory,
37:11the entire Donbass,
37:12which is what Russia wants.
37:14What does Ukraine get in exchange for that?
37:16Will it get those ironclad guarantees
37:19that Russia will not attack it again?
37:21Does it get NATO membership?
37:23But if it gets NATO membership,
37:25then the Russians are going to be upset
37:26because this is exactly
37:27what they began the war for,
37:29to deny Ukraine NATO membership.
37:33They said that
37:33NATO was creeping at their doorstep.
37:35If Ukraine becomes a NATO member,
37:38that's NATO at Russia's doorstep,
37:40exactly what they began this war for.
37:42So it's extremely complex, Gaurav,
37:45and that is one of the reasons
37:46why this war has been dragging on
37:47for as long as it has been.
37:49And, you know,
37:50as one of our panelists mentioned,
37:52it is a fact that
37:53Russia is fighting not just Ukraine,
37:55it is fighting the entire West,
37:57it is fighting NATO,
37:58it's a proxy war
38:00of a huge,
38:01it's probably the biggest proxy war
38:03that we've seen in the 21st century.
38:06And, you know,
38:06that's why there are many capitals
38:09that are, you know,
38:11involved in the peace process.
38:13It's not just Moscow,
38:15Kiev,
38:15and Washington, D.C.
38:17Gaurav.
38:20And that's why perhaps
38:21this conversation in Berlin,
38:23but Berlin has also been
38:24arming Ukraine to the teeth so far,
38:27even if it,
38:28as many have argued,
38:29Europe has been cutting its nose
38:31to spite its face.
38:32And Professor Chalani,
38:33before I bring you in,
38:34Pranay,
38:34what are European capitals,
38:36is there any word from there?
38:38How are they viewing
38:39the Shenzhen declaration,
38:41the dialogue in Shenzhen,
38:42and the journey
38:44of the special envoys to Berlin?
38:46I think Europe
38:47has largely given up
38:49on President Donald Trump
38:50because they have
38:52their own concerns.
38:53They could see
38:54that the Russia-Ukraine war
38:56is not going to come
38:58to some kind of a solution,
39:00which Europe expects
39:01or Europe wants.
39:02And therefore,
39:02they are grappling
39:03on one side
39:04with their own energy crisis.
39:05They have to find some solution.
39:07Also,
39:08they have to go
39:09for their own deployment.
39:10And if you see
39:11the advancement
39:12of the European military,
39:14you know,
39:15armament production,
39:16the kind of partnerships
39:18they are forging,
39:18this clearly shows
39:19that Europe is quite
39:21unnerved with that
39:23and they have to deal
39:24with the situation
39:24and they really had to bag,
39:27really had to bag
39:27United States
39:28to be included
39:29on the big table.
39:30And that's why
39:31this Berlin round of talks
39:32is taking shape
39:34or taking place.
39:35But we have to see
39:36whether and how
39:38Vinatia States
39:40balances this.
39:42Their old partners,
39:43their old allies.
39:45President Donald Trump
39:46also proposed the idea
39:47of a trilateral meeting.
39:49After Alaska,
39:50you can recall,
39:51Gaurav,
39:51he proposed the idea
39:52of having a trilateral
39:54with Zelensky
39:55and Putin together.
39:56So far,
39:57that hasn't happened as yet.
39:59But we have to see
40:00that, you know,
40:01what these trilateral powers,
40:03because, you know,
40:04India always said
40:05that, you know,
40:06and I would like to reiterate
40:08what Prime Minister Modi
40:08has said,
40:09you know,
40:09earlier,
40:10that the trust deficit
40:12is the biggest challenge
40:13in the current
40:14geopolitical setup.
40:15And that is the bigger
40:16problem here.
40:17So, on one side,
40:19earlier,
40:19you excluded Ukraine
40:20and had all the conversations
40:22including Ukraine.
40:24You excluded Russia
40:26and have all the conversation
40:27with Ukraine on table.
40:28And now,
40:29you are including Russia
40:30and not including Ukraine
40:31on the table.
40:35And either ways,
40:36it's unlikely to work
40:37given the fact
40:38that Second World War
40:39lasted between
40:3939 and 45
40:40for five years.
40:41And this war
40:42from February 2022
40:43now November 2026.
40:45It's almost five years.
40:47Another three months,
40:48it will be five years.
40:50But I want to do
40:52in this last part,
40:53last segment
40:54of our special show
40:55from Shenzhen,
40:56Professor Chilani,
40:57when these three
40:59big powers
41:00talk about pumping
41:01more oil
41:01to stabilize
41:02the world market,
41:03again,
41:04a noble thought.
41:05But if straight-off
41:06Hormuz remains shut,
41:07whatever amount
41:08of oil is pumped
41:09by countries,
41:10if it cannot cross
41:11the Strait of Hormuz,
41:12the problem remains.
41:1320% of the world
41:14oil supplies
41:16remain impacted.
41:18So,
41:18would there be
41:19some kind of
41:20a back channel
41:20that Russia
41:21and China
41:22wane on Iran
41:23to open
41:24the Strait of Hormuz?
41:25Is that a likely option
41:27to ensure
41:28that Shenzhen declaration
41:29is not just on paper
41:31and there's some
41:32positive action
41:32on ground?
41:34There's little
41:35to indicate,
41:36Gaurav,
41:36that any agreement
41:38on any
41:39major issue
41:41was reached
41:42in Shenzhen.
41:43There are all
41:44these nice-sounding
41:45phrases
41:47in the declaration,
41:48but there's
41:49no indication
41:50whatsoever
41:51that anything
41:52will be translated
41:53into concrete terms,
41:56including
41:56on the energy front.
41:59But I think
42:01the summit's
42:02long-term
42:03geopolitical optics
42:04cut directly
42:06against India's
42:07core strategic interests.
42:09A G3
42:11direct rate
42:12of Washington,
42:13Beijing,
42:13and Moscow
42:14setting the rules
42:15of global order,
42:17can that be
42:18in sync
42:19with India's
42:20long-term interests?
42:21Obviously not.
42:23And a managed
42:24detente
42:25between Washington
42:25and Beijing
42:26can only dilute
42:28India's
42:29Indo-Pacific leverage.
42:31It'll reduce
42:32the urgency
42:32for the U.S.
42:33to rely on India
42:34as a nation
42:36counterweight
42:36to China.
42:38And if
42:39the U.S.
42:40and China
42:41were to
42:42stabilize
42:43their relationship,
42:45New Delhi
42:45loses
42:46bargaining power.
42:48India has been,
42:50has spent
42:51decades
42:51under successive
42:52governments.
42:53permit me
42:54to intervene
42:54on this.
42:56While I may
42:57agree with you
42:58in part,
42:59permit me
43:00to disagree
43:00and bring in
43:01Dr. Tara
43:01Kharta so that
43:02both of you
43:02weigh in on this.
43:04The U.S.
43:05is world
43:05number one
43:06power.
43:06China aspires
43:07to be world
43:08number one
43:09power.
43:09Would U.S.
43:11continue to
43:11cut its nose
43:12to spite its
43:13face like
43:13Europe did,
43:15realizing in
43:16the long term
43:17it impacted
43:18Europe adversely,
43:19in the long term
43:20it will impact
43:20China,
43:21it will impact
43:22the United States
43:23adversely.
43:23Dr. Tara
43:24Kharta,
43:25if there's
43:26genuine talk
43:26about a
43:27multipolar world,
43:28China may use
43:29multipolar
43:29till the time
43:30it replaces
43:31U.S.
43:32as the only
43:33superpower.
43:33Would the
43:34U.S.
43:34let that
43:35happen?
43:36Never.
43:38No way.
43:39That's not
43:39going to happen.
43:40That is not
43:41part of U.S.
43:42policy and
43:42it never
43:43has been.
43:44All this,
43:45I mean,
43:45Brahma's right
43:46in some ways
43:47that there's a
43:47sort of amicability
43:48going on.
43:49It suits the U.S.
43:50right now.
43:51But they will
43:52not yield the
43:53number one
43:53place.
43:54That is against
43:55everything that
43:56the U.S.
43:56has ever stood
43:57for.
43:58Number two,
43:58the fact is
44:00that even if
44:01there is a,
44:02you know,
44:03maybe they had
44:04something really
44:04written out in
44:05this whole
44:06Schengen summit,
44:07they had a
44:07detailed,
44:08you know,
44:09readout,
44:09it still will
44:10not affect,
44:11you know,
44:12the quad.
44:13And by the
44:13way,
44:13I disagree with
44:14the fact the
44:15U.S.
44:15is a spent
44:16power.
44:16It is not.
44:17I think
44:17somebody,
44:18one of your
44:18panelists said
44:19that the
44:20U.S.
44:21is no
44:21longer,
44:22you know,
44:23that is not
44:24the case.
44:25I mean,
44:25China,
44:26a lot of
44:26things are
44:27hidden.
44:27I don't
44:27want to go
44:28there into
44:28all the
44:28problems that
44:29are within
44:29China.
44:30China.
44:30But if I
44:31can just add
44:32one point
44:33here,
44:34Gaurav,
44:34what they
44:34are talking
44:35of,
44:35when we
44:36talk of
44:36this,
44:37the importance
44:37of these
44:38three meetings,
44:39we badly
44:40need stability.
44:42We badly
44:43need inflation
44:44to come down.
44:45And there
44:46is one event
44:47which happened
44:47recently,
44:48which was
44:48Germany
44:49developing a
44:50long-range
44:51missile.
44:52Okay,
44:52that is
44:53dangerous.
44:54So which
44:55way are we
44:56going?
44:57So somewhere
44:57you have to
44:58slam the
44:59brakes on
44:59and say
44:59enough is
45:00enough.
45:01So hopefully
45:03this will go
45:04somewhere.
45:05I mean,
45:05certainly China
45:06wants this
45:06to go.
45:07So let's
45:07see.
45:09As far as
45:10the oil issue
45:10is concerned,
45:11I just wanted
45:11to add one
45:12point here.
45:12You wanted
45:13to come in
45:13because somewhere
45:14down the line.
45:15Yes.
45:15Yes.
45:16I just
45:16briefly wanted
45:17to bring a
45:18point here
45:18that these
45:19three countries
45:20have decided
45:20to increase
45:21the oil
45:22production.
45:23Certainly
45:23their oil
45:23production
45:24facility,
45:25obviously China
45:26is the biggest
45:26buyer of the
45:27oil,
45:27not the
45:28producer of
45:28the oil.
45:29But the
45:29Russian oil
45:30and the
45:30Chinese oil
45:31doesn't have
45:31to go to
45:32the state
45:32of Hormuz.
45:33But what
45:33here,
45:34what's
45:34happening here?
45:35It's the
45:36United States
45:36making offer
45:37to the
45:37world's
45:38biggest buyer
45:39that lets
45:39buy from
45:40both of
45:41us,
45:41Russian oil
45:42and the
45:42US oil
45:43and don't
45:44get,
45:44you know,
45:45don't support
45:46the Iranian
45:47oil manufacturing
45:48or oil
45:48production
45:48facilities.
45:54Fair
45:54enough.
45:55But either
45:55ways that
45:56may benefit
45:57these three,
45:57we're looking
45:58at how
45:58will it
45:59impact
45:59countries
46:00like India
46:01or ASEAN
46:01countries
46:02that have
46:03been
46:03adversely
46:04impacted
46:04by this
46:05war and
46:06that is
46:06why
46:06multipolarity
46:07becomes
46:08extremely
46:08important.
46:09But
46:09Sandeep,
46:10there are
46:10also some
46:10very critical
46:11issues if
46:12they were
46:12discussed.
46:13The information
46:14is not there
46:14in public
46:14domain.
46:15For example,
46:16what happens
46:16to that
46:16high-end
46:17technology,
46:18that chip,
46:19the big
46:19battle between
46:20the United
46:20States and
46:21China?
46:22We haven't
46:22heard of it.
46:23We haven't
46:23heard of
46:24what happens
46:25next on the
46:26Jensen
46:26Huang case.
46:27What happens
46:28on so many
46:28of these
46:29critical issues,
46:30there is
46:30still no
46:30clarity?
46:33Well,
46:33Gaurav,
46:34what's going
46:34on in the
46:35Jensen
46:35Huang case,
46:36it's a bit
46:36like what
46:39used to
46:39play out
46:40during the
46:40Cold War.
46:40The space
46:41race between
46:42the USSR
46:42and the
46:43US is
46:44where China
46:45and the
46:45United States
46:46are today
46:46with the
46:46AI race.
46:47And that
46:48explains why
46:49Silicon Valley
46:49has suddenly
46:51closed forces
46:52and come
46:53back behind
46:54Jensen
46:55Huang,
46:55why Trump
46:56wants Jensen
46:57Huang to
46:57come back
46:58and lead
47:00NVIDIA.
47:01The fact is
47:01that he's
47:02too big to
47:02fail and
47:02they've
47:03realized that
47:03it is
47:04people like
47:05Jensen
47:05Huang that
47:06possibly hold
47:07the Trump
47:07card for
47:08them.
47:09And I
47:09mentioned
47:10this with
47:11a lot
47:11of going
47:14off what
47:16I've been
47:16looking at
47:17over the
47:17last
47:17couple of
47:18race is
47:18the fact
47:19that they
47:21have been
47:24reassessing
47:24their war
47:26strategy that
47:26if Jensen
47:27Huang takes
47:28down the
47:28US AI
47:29market,
47:30they're going
47:31to come
47:31off worse
47:32against China.
47:33So this
47:33is a race
47:35that Trump
47:36has called
47:36not just
47:37AI, he's
47:38calling it
47:38super
47:39intelligence.
47:39And that
47:40tells you
47:40where they
47:41are at
47:41this point
47:43in time,
47:44the two
47:44countries.
47:45And that
47:46is a
47:46separate
47:46issue,
47:47Gaurav.
47:48I think
47:48it's not
47:48being taken
47:49up adequately,
47:50but that
47:50will play
47:51out.
47:51And I
47:51want to
47:52come back
47:52to Professor
47:53Brahmachalani.
47:54I want to
47:54come back
47:56exactly and
47:57I want to
47:57bring in
47:58Professor
47:58Brahmachalani
47:59back on
48:00this because
48:00the number
48:01one power
48:01and the
48:02number two
48:02power,
48:03do you
48:03actually see
48:04them being
48:04best friends
48:05in times to
48:06come,
48:06sir,
48:06and deciding
48:07the new
48:07world order
48:08amongst
48:09themselves,
48:09I mean,
48:10Russia,
48:10China,
48:10and the
48:12United States
48:13of America,
48:13Professor
48:13Chilani,
48:14realistically.
48:16You're not
48:17talking about
48:17these three
48:18powers which
48:19are rivals
48:20forging a
48:21united front.
48:22No.
48:24Or building
48:25strategic cooperation.
48:27No.
48:27Nobody expects
48:28that.
48:28But what's
48:29happening is
48:31that they
48:32are positioning
48:33themselves as
48:35joint guardians
48:37of international
48:38order.
48:40They met
48:41in a way
48:42as if they
48:43can decide
48:44for the
48:44world.
48:46These are
48:47three competing
48:48powers that
48:49believe that
48:50if they
48:53negotiate
48:54between and
48:55among themselves
48:57they can
48:58carve out
49:00spheres of
49:00influence,
49:01for example,
49:01or set the
49:03rules for
49:04others.
49:05That's not
49:05what the
49:08rest of
49:08the world
49:08will accept,
49:09and certainly
49:10not India.
49:11A tri-polar
49:13concert of
49:14nuclear superpowers
49:17will be
49:18inimical to
49:19the interests
49:20of all
49:20middle powers,
49:21including India,
49:22and also
49:23the Moscow's
49:26deeper pivot
49:27to Beijing
49:27also holds
49:29important
49:29implications
49:30for India.
49:32The Sino-Russian
49:33axis,
49:34the tirade
49:34becomes,
49:36the greater
49:37the concern
49:37in India
49:38because
49:39Russia has
49:41been pivotal
49:41to India's
49:42long-term
49:43strategic planning.
49:44I can't hear
49:47Brahma at
49:48all.
49:49Sorry?
49:50Okay.
49:51What did she
49:52say?
49:53So, I will
49:53let that be the
49:54last word on
49:55this part of
49:55the show.
49:56You're absolutely
49:57right.
49:58You know,
50:00the geoeconomics
50:01and geopolitics,
50:02we see a
50:03change here,
50:04but is this
50:05like really
50:07permanent?
50:08Is this a new
50:09world order that's
50:10taking shape?
50:10We'll be tracking
50:11that story very,
50:12very closely.
50:13I want to
50:13thank Dr.
50:14Tara Kartha,
50:14Brahmachalani,
50:15Professor Brahmachalani,
50:16Sandeep Unnithan,
50:17and Pranayupadhyay for
50:19joining me here on
50:19this part of
50:20India first.
50:22That is all I have
50:23for you on this
50:24special broadcast from
50:25Shenzhen in China.
50:27As I sign off,
50:29thank you very much
50:30for watching.
50:31Keep watching
50:32India Today.
50:33Thank you very much

Recommended