• 15 minutes ago
Kapil Sibal explains legal details of TVS family succession and inheritance rights, focusing on ownership and daughters' rights.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:01And here on India Today, yesterday on Super 6, we told you about a dispute, a family feud
00:07and a succession dispute within one of India's best known business families, the TVS Group.
00:12It's raising important questions about daughters' inheritance rights.
00:16And that's because Lakshmi Venu, the daughter of Venu Srinivasan, has spoken out about how
00:21she believes that her brother has been given a larger chunk of the TVS family assets versus
00:28her, which is why it's opened up the scan of worms on familial wealth distribution and
00:33whether daughters inevitably don't get the shorter end of the stick when it comes to the
00:38division of assets.
00:40She's now put forward also this in a letter to Venu Srinivasan and her legal position is
00:46that accepting a management arrangement does not amount to surrendering ownership rights.
00:51She's saying that she deserves to get as much as her brother is.
00:55Let's get you a legal perspective on this.
00:57Senior advocate Kapil Sibyl has explained the legal arguments in this exclusive conversation
01:01with Siddharth Zarabi.
01:08It's one of India's oldest and best known business families.
01:12The TVS name goes back more than a hundred years.
01:16The flagship TVS motor company has a market cap of over two lakh crore rupees.
01:21But a family dispute has moved from the boardrooms to legal notices now.
01:28This week, Lakshmi Venu, managing director of Sundaram Clayton, served a formal partition notice
01:33on her father, Venu Srinivasan, chairman emeritus of TVS Motor.
01:38She invokes the Hindu Succession Act and says that as a daughter, she is entitled to an equal share
01:45of her branch family assets.
01:48She says her brother, Sudarshan, now holds the larger beneficial interest.
01:53Her mother, Malika Srinivasan, has publicly backed her.
01:58Venu Srinivasan's position is different.
02:01He says these are his own assets that he was free to divide them and that both his children
02:07received a fair share.
02:09Clearly, this is not just a family disagreement over valuations.
02:14It raises a larger question that India's business families perhaps can no longer avoid.
02:21Is running a business the same as owning it?
02:24And when control goes to one, what happens to the other's share?
02:29To unpack the law behind these headlines, I am joined by noted lawyer and senior advocate
02:35Kapil Sibbal.
02:36Mr. Sibbal, welcome to the show.
02:38Let me begin by asking that big point to you, is running a business really the same
02:46as owning it in today's India?
02:49It depends on your attitude.
02:52You know, in a patriarchal society, the father claims to exercise all the rights that may
02:58well be vested in his other members of the family.
03:02So he always claims himself to be a patriarch, that I am the owner.
03:07That's, you know, central to a lot of businesses in this country and a lot of families in this
03:11country.
03:12The Lakshmi in the family is always considered to be the other.
03:15And of course, in this particular case, Lakshmi is Lakshmi in this particular family, which
03:22is most unfortunate that a father who says that I built, I am the owner of this business.
03:27Well, the father should remember where he got his business from.
03:31This is family business, started by his great-grandfather in 1911, right?
03:38And then his father took it forward.
03:41T.S. Srinivasan took it forward.
03:42It's a third generation.
03:44Then the business came to him.
03:46And he said, it's my family business.
03:48But the larger family was partitioned in 2020.
03:52And then the assets were divided, and TV Motors, TVS Motors, the TVS branch, came to him.
04:00TVS Holdings, subsidiaries, including TVS Credit, came to him.
04:06And then, of course, certain monies were to be paid to the family, because this is a very
04:12valuable part of the business that came to him.
04:14So the funds were raised from the assets of the company, loans were taken, and the others
04:20were paid.
04:21And then suddenly we find the patriarch is saying, it's my business, unfortunately.
04:28Mr. Sibyl, the matter has been reported now for quite some time, but clearly a daughter
04:35has sent her father a partition notice.
04:39Anyway, what I want to understand, and hopefully we'll also get to hear from Mr. Venu Srinivasan,
04:44his side and his version of this entire dispute, but you are helping us unpack and understand
04:50one element.
04:51Is this a family dispute or a test of how far daughters equal rights have actually reached
05:00in the Indian business family context?
05:03Well, you know, I think when you say it's a family dispute, you have to understand the
05:07context, right?
05:09If you say that your daughter is the other, right, and suddenly the daughter finds from
05:15newspaper reports that 95 percent of the business has been given to Sudarshan, right, she's something
05:21that she's surprised at.
05:23And this is not something that has happened overnight.
05:28I mean, a partition, notice for partition has not been sent overnight.
05:32This has been going on.
05:34She's been asking the father, be up, be open with me.
05:38How did you allow, how did you give him 95 percent of the business of the company?
05:44I am an equal shareholder, you know, in Tamil Nadu, way back in 1989 that law was passed.
05:50Then, of course, the parliament in 2005 said daughters are equal shareholders.
05:55This is co-parcenary property.
05:57It's not, you built it, all of us, all of us, businesses, but the assets belong to the family
06:03assets from which this business was built.
06:06So both Sudarshan, my brother, as well as Lakshmi, are entitled to an equal share.
06:12I mean, there are no two ways about it.
06:16The problem is, after 50 years of independence, our law told her daughter that she's not a guest.
06:24This happened in 2005.
06:26That you're not a guest.
06:28You're part of the family.
06:30And I think Venu Srinivasan should listen to that law and recognize that even before 2005,
06:36Tamil Nadu in 1989 had said the same thing.
06:40So I think that he should step back and make sure there is equitable distribution.
06:48He should step back and make sure that there is equitable distribution.
06:53But, you know, then that would also raise the point, Mr. Sibbal, about what has happened in the past.
07:02The 2005 amendment and the Supreme Court's 2020 Vinita Sharma judgment,
07:08does the law, and I'm trying to understand here for the benefit of our viewers,
07:13does the law see any difference between a son and a daughter when it comes to joint family property?
07:20Not at all.
07:21Not at all.
07:22Because the property is not the sole ownership of the father.
07:26I mean, the father himself has inherited the property from his ancestors.
07:32And therefore, I have an equal share when it comes to distribution.
07:35And there are no two ways on it.
07:37I don't think that any legal expert will say otherwise.
07:42So you assume that you are the patriarch.
07:46You assume that you are entitled to distribute the way you like, forgetting that that's not the law.
07:53And that's not even a fair manner of dealing with members of the family.
07:58That's, you know, the problem is a patriarchal mindset that often discriminates against the daughters.
08:06Often.
08:07Not always, but often.
08:08This is one of those occasions.
08:10A patriarchal mindset that discriminates against daughters.
08:14The other question that would be put is the argument that Mr. Venu Srinivasan says that these are his personal
08:24assets.
08:25You've dwelt on that.
08:26I'd like to know how he got those assets.
08:29He got those assets from the family business because he grew the business.
08:33So if I inherit something from my father and I grow the business, that doesn't become my personal asset.
08:40Because the beneficiary of the family's business went into building the business.
08:46And therefore, I'm equally entitled to it.
08:49Now, the problem is he considers himself to be the owner.
08:52That's the problem.
08:54That's the patriarchal mindset.
08:57But, Mr. Sibbal, isn't that in the Indian context of, you know, generation upon generation managing the family business and
09:06then growing it, of course, with professional executives and a board, why wouldn't they have a right to say that
09:13they built it and therefore make a claim to those assets in some ways?
09:16But that's the difference.
09:17That's the difference between self-acquired property and acquired from the family.
09:23Conceptually, these are two different things.
09:25If I, for example, from my own earnings, buy a particular piece of property, I can give it to anybody
09:32who I like.
09:33Why?
09:33Because I can will it.
09:35But if I inherit a business, inherit property from my parents, then I can't will it because my children will
09:42have equal right on it.
09:44So my children can object.
09:45I mean, that's simple.
09:46There's nothing complicated.
09:48So, you know, a karta is a custodian of the family's wealth.
09:53Not its owner.
09:57But equally, Mr. Sibbal, isn't that karta, does he not have the right and isn't he free to leave the
10:06assets, the wealth, the property to either child, whether son or daughter?
10:10No, no, no, no.
10:11He can't will it.
10:12He can't will it because that's not his personal property.
10:15That's the problem.
10:17He has to account.
10:19Karta means he's a custodian of the property.
10:22He has to account for it.
10:24He cannot appropriate it.
10:28What would Lakshmi need to prove to show this is joint family property?
10:35Well, that's the admitted position.
10:38There's no dispute on that.
10:40The assets that he inherited were from the larger family business that came down from 1911.
10:50Those are the facts.
10:52Nobody disputes it.
10:53But his part of the family dissociated.
10:55There was a larger partition in 2020 with other members of the larger Srinivasan family.
11:01They bought these assets, right?
11:05And thereafter, these assets were kept in trust through an MOU.
11:09And he really was managing the trust.
11:13And in that process, he gave management of a company to the son and management of another company to Lakshmi.
11:20Now, managing a company doesn't necessarily or not necessarily in law doesn't result in ownership.

Recommended