• 18 minutes ago
Professor Brahma Chellaney analyses the geopolitical fallout of a US China Russia tripolar directorate post Shenzhen declaration, highlighting risks to India's strategic interests and global challenges related to energy, inflation, and technology competition.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Professor Chilani, when these three big powers talk about pumping more oil to stabilize the world market,
00:07again, a noble thought, but if Strait of Hormuz remains shut,
00:11whatever amount of oil is pumped by countries, if it cannot cross the Strait of Hormuz,
00:16the problem remains. 20% of the world oil supplies remain impacted.
00:22So, would there be some kind of a back channel that Russia and China wane on Iran to open the
00:28Strait of Hormuz?
00:29Is that a likely option to ensure that Shenzhen declaration is not just on paper and there's some positive action
00:36on ground?
00:38There's little to indicate, Gaurav, that any agreement on any major issue was reached in Shenzhen.
00:47There are all these nice-sounding phrases in the declaration,
00:52but there's no indication whatsoever that anything will be translated into concrete terms, including on the energy front.
01:03But I think the summit's long-term geopolitical optics cut directly against India's core strategic interests.
01:13A G3 direct rate of Washington, Beijing, and Moscow setting the rules of global order.
01:21Can that be in sync with India's long-term interests? Obviously not.
01:26And a managed detente between Washington and Beijing can only dilute India's Indo-Pacific leverage.
01:34It will reduce the urgency for the U.S. to rely on India as a nation counterweight to China.
01:42And if the U.S. and China were to stabilize their relationship, New Delhi loses bargaining power.
01:52India has been, has spent decades under successive governments.
01:56But permit me to intervene on this.
01:57Permit me to intervene on this.
01:59No, while I may agree with you in part,
02:03permit me to disagree and bring in Dr. Tara Kharta so that both of you weigh in on this.
02:08The U.S. is world number one power.
02:10China aspires to be world number one power.
02:13Would U.S. continue to cut its nose to spite its face like Europe did,
02:19realizing in the long term it impacted Europe adversely,
02:23in the long term it will impact China, it will impact the United States adversely.
02:27Dr. Tara Kharta, if there's genuine talk about a multipolar world,
02:32China may use multipolar till the time it replaces U.S. as the only superpower.
02:37Would the U.S. let that happen?
02:40Never.
02:42No way.
02:42That's not going to happen.
02:44That is not part of U.S. policy and it never has been.
02:48All this, I mean, Brahma's right in some ways.
02:51There is a sort of amicability going on.
02:53It suits the U.S. right now.
02:55But they will not yield the number one place.
02:58That is against everything that the U.S. has ever stood for.
03:01Number two, the fact is that even if there is a, you know,
03:07maybe they had something really written out in this whole sentience summit.
03:10They had a detailed, you know, readout, it still will not affect, you know, the quad.
03:16And by the way, I disagree with the fact the U.S. is a spent power.
03:20It is not.
03:21I think somebody, one of your panelists said that the U.S. is no longer, you know, that is not
03:28the case.
03:29I mean, China, a lot of things are hidden.
03:31I don't want to go there into all the problems that are within China.
03:34But if I can just add one point here, Gaurav, what they are talking of,
03:39when we talk of this, the importance of these three meetings,
03:43we badly need stability.
03:46We badly need inflation to come down.
03:49And there is one event which happened recently,
03:52which was Germany developing a long-range missile.
03:55Okay, that is dangerous.
03:58So, which way are we going?
04:00So, somewhere you have to slam the brakes on and say enough is enough.
04:04Okay.
04:05So, hopefully, this will go somewhere.
04:09I mean, certainly China want this to go.
04:11So, let's see.
04:13As the oil issue is concerned, I just wanted to add one point here.
04:16You wanted to come in because somewhere down the line.
04:18Yes.
04:19Yes.
04:19I just briefly wanted to bring a point here that, you know,
04:23these three countries have decided to increase the oil production.
04:26Certainly, their oil production facility,
04:29obviously, China is the biggest buyer of the oil,
04:31not the producer of the oil.
04:32But the Russian oil and the Chinese oil doesn't have to go to the state of Hormuz.
04:37But what's happening here?
04:39It's the United States making offer to the world's biggest buyer
04:42that let's buy from both of us, Russian oil and the U.S. oil
04:47and don't get, you know, don't support the Iranian oil manufacturing
04:51or oil production facilities.
04:58Fair enough.
04:59But either ways, that may benefit these three.
05:01We are looking at how will it impact countries like India
05:05or ASEAN countries that have been adversely impacted by this war.
05:10And that is why multipolarity becomes extremely important.
05:13But, Sandeep, there are also some very critical issues.
05:15If they were discussed, the information is not there in public domain.
05:19For example, what happens to that high-end technology,
05:22that chip, the big battle between the United States and China?
05:26We haven't heard of it.
05:27We haven't heard of, you know, what happens next on the Jensen-Huong case.
05:31What happens on so many of these critical issues?
05:34There is still no clarity.
05:37Well, Gaurav, you know, what's going on in the Jensen-Huong case,
05:39it's a bit like what's playing out in the,
05:43what used to play out during the Cold War.
05:44The space race between the USSR and the U.S.
05:47is where China and the United States are today with the AI race.
05:51And that explains why Silicon Valley has suddenly,
05:54you know, closed forces and come back behind Jensen-Huong.
05:59Why Trump wants Jensen-Huong to come back and lead NVIDIA.
06:04The fact is that he's too big to fail.
06:06And they've realized that, that it is people like Jensen-Huong
06:09that possibly hold the Trump card for them.
06:12And I mentioned this with a lot of, you know,
06:18going off what I've been looking at over the last couple of days.
06:22It's the fact that they've been, you know,
06:28reassessing their war strategy that if Jensen-Huong takes down the U.S. AI market,
06:34they're going to come off worse against China.
06:37So this is a race, this is a race that Trump has called not just AI,
06:42he's calling it super intelligence.
06:43And that tells you where they are at, you know,
06:46at this point in time, at the two countries.
06:49And that is a separate issue, Gaurav.
06:52I think it's not being taken up adequately,
06:54but that will play out in the next couple of weeks.
06:56And I want to come back to Professor Brahmachalani.
06:57I want to come back.
07:00Exactly.
07:00And I want to bring in Professor Brahmachalani back on this
07:04because the number one power and the number two power,
07:06do you actually see them being best friends in times to come, sir?
07:10And deciding the new world order amongst themselves,
07:13I mean, Russia, China and the United States of America,
07:17Professor Chalani, realistically.
07:20You're not talking about these three powers, which are rivals,
07:24forging a united front.
07:26No.
07:27Or building strategic cooperation.
07:30No.
07:31Nobody expects that.
07:32But what's happening
07:33is that they are positioning themselves
07:38as joint guardians of international order.
07:43They met in a way as if they can decide for the world.
07:50These are three competing powers that believe that if they negotiate between and among themselves,
08:01they can carve out spheres of influence, for example, or set the rules for others,
08:09that's not what the rest of the world will accept, and certainly not India.
08:15A tri-polar concert of nuclear superpowers will be inimical to the interests of all middle powers,
08:25including India.
08:26And also, the Moscow's deeper pivot to Beijing also holds important implications for India.
08:36The Sino-Russian axis, the tirade becomes, the greater the concern in India,
08:42because Russia has been pivotal to India's long-term strategic planning.
08:56So, I will let that be the last word on this part of the show.
09:00You're absolutely right.
09:02You know, the geoeconomics and geopolitics,
09:06we see a change here,
09:08but is this, like, really permanent?
09:12Is this a new world order that's taking shape?
09:14We'll be tracking that story very, very close.

Recommended