- 18 minutes ago
Brahma Chellaney analysed China's rapid nuclear expansion and its strategic goals after the Shenzhen trilateral talks, including shifts in global power and diplomatic developments.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00I want to bring in Sandeep Unnithan and Pranayopadhyay who've been waiting and listening very patiently.
00:04Key takeaway, Sandeep, if there is one headline that emerges beyond the beautiful optics here in Shenzhen, what's that headline
00:12for you, Sandeep?
00:14Well, Gaurav, I've just seen the photograph of the post-Cold War world.
00:21The post-Cold War world began in 1991, it ended roughly around 2020.
00:27The post-Cold War world is what we're living through.
00:29And today, that picture of the three leaders standing side by side, one a manufacturing superpower, another a resource superpower,
00:37and the third, a country that used to be the sole superpower, which is now having to share space with
00:44China and the Russian Federation.
00:46This is the ultimate image in my appreciation, Gaurav, the fact that we have finally seen in the last five
00:53or six years,
00:53the end of U.S. primacy, the way the United States used to dominate the world after the post-Cold
01:00War, during the post-Cold War era, that has come to an end.
01:04And that is literally this photograph that we're looking at.
01:07It, of course, remains to be seen how things will play out in the next five or ten years.
01:11But for now, I think this is one of the biggest takeaways for me.
01:15The fall of the Berlin Wall was one big image which defined the end of the Cold War.
01:20This is going to be one of those big images that define the post-post-Cold War world, Gaurav.
01:51Let's talk about the three takeaways for all these three countries.
01:55Gaurav first, what did President Xi Jinping got?
01:58He got validation.
01:59And the thing which he mentioned during his last meeting with President Donald Trump,
02:03about the suiciditis trap, President Donald Trump ended up validating that.
02:07And in fact, China has emerged as a meeting ground of both these big powers to come to China,
02:13talk about their issues and discuss and make it a G3.
02:17A bipolar world has become a G3 world kind of a structure.
02:20And President of the United States has validated it.
02:22For President Vladimir Putin, this is a showcasing of his mainstreaming.
02:27Those who were trying to alienate Russia, this is his comeback and to show to them
02:32that, look, I am still relevant and I am still powerful and I am still on the big table.
02:36But as far as the U.S. President Donald Trump is concerned, his only takeaway is a spectacle.
02:41He wanted to show to the world that he can pull, he can bring all these three leaders,
02:46you know, these two leaders to one table and he wanted to make an optics of it.
02:51So he got an optics of it.
02:52But beside that, I will be compelled to reiterate what I have been saying since morning,
02:56that this is high on optics, very low on deliverables and tangibles.
03:03Okay.
03:05Okay.
03:05So, Professor Brabha Chalani wants to bring in, before I bring in, Tathya Khuraganeva from Russia.
03:10But, Professor Chalani, go ahead.
03:12Win for China, win for Russia, but a loss for the United States of America.
03:17What's that big gain for U.S. that comes out of this?
03:21Well, Trump tried very hard to bring China into nuclear arms control.
03:29The reason is that China's nuclear force is growing by about 100 warheads every year.
03:37This is a frenzied nuclear weapons buildup by China.
03:41Far from hiding this nuclear frenzy, China is flaunting it as if to underline that its rapidly
03:50growing arsenal is driven more by political than military considerations.
03:56And the unprecedented speed and scale of the nuclear buildup appears to be linked to Xi Jinping's
04:02international expansionism as China seeks global privacy by 2049, the centenary of communist rule.
04:11China wants to be, by 2049, a world power second to none.
04:19In other words, it's seeking to supplant the U.S. as the world's foremost power.
04:24That's its ambition.
04:26That's its goal by 2049.
04:29And the nuclear weapons buildup is part and parcel of that ambition.
04:35So, with the U.S., sorry, with the U.S., Russia, New START clearly having expired in February this year.
04:44The U.S. and Russia do not want to get into a bilateral nuclear arms control agreement,
04:52a grain, without bringing in China.
04:54But in Shenzhen, we heard some lovely words from Xi Jinping about, you know, nuclear weapons,
05:06the need to eliminate them, but no willingness to be part of nuclear arms control.
05:12And, of course, there are larger implications for India from this.
05:16Absolutely.
05:17Lovely words.
05:18Lovely words.
05:19But will they be followed by action on ground?
05:22I'll come to implications for India in just a moment, sir.
05:24But for a moment, I want to talk about the elephant in the room,
05:27or if I may, the bear in the room on the Russia-Ukraine front.
05:31Tatiana Khurewa, do you see any let-up in the war between Russia and Ukraine?
05:38President Trump indicated that both he and President Putin had a long conversation about ending war.
05:44Now it remains to be seen whether the other side wants it.
05:47Is the other side Ukraine?
05:48Is the other side Europe?
05:49What do you see happen on the Russia-Ukraine war front now,
05:53after this conversation here in Shenzhen?
05:56Well, first of all, Gaurav, I see a big problem that we're actually discussing war
06:01in terms of an economic gathering, right?
06:04And AIPAC is Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation, so it's not about war.
06:12And this is why primarily, you know, we got the most that we wanted out of this conversation
06:19between the three leaders, their commitment to kind of, you know, restoring world peace
06:25and their commitment to the concept in general.
06:28In the meantime, while we're still talking about economics,
06:32I would really like to remind everybody that there was one point in that four-point declaration
06:38that we keep forgetting about, the three countries and the three leaders agreeing to boost
06:44refined oil production.
06:46And we also keep forgetting that the U.S. is right now...
06:50I'll come to oil in just a moment.
06:51Hold on, hold on.
06:52No, no, Tatiana, Tatiana.
06:53Exactly.
06:53Let me follow, let me follow, no, Tatiana, let me follow the line.
06:57I want to stay on the Russia-Ukraine war for one.
07:00I'll come to oil in just a moment because that's in the Iran segment.
07:03When we talk about Russia-Ukraine war, is there any let-up or will this war continue despite
07:10this conversation?
07:11Whether it's an economic forum, war is also all about economics and it's upsetting global
07:16economy in a big way, including the APEC economy.
07:20Even though Russian president said that, you know, Russia has been providing as a stable
07:24partner and has been providing oil and fertilizers and all of that, global economy isn't tailspin.
07:31Russia-Ukraine war is one reason.
07:33In your view, do you see any let-up in the war after this conversation?
07:38You're reading.
07:40Global economy is in tailspin, but not because of Russia-Ukraine war, because of a different
07:45war in a different part of the world and with different powers involved.
07:50Also because of this?
07:51Primarily because of this.
07:53No, both are involved.
07:55To answer your question, every single conversation that Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin hold brings
08:04us closer to a form of compromise.
08:08Look, we need to remember, we've been five years we've been into this, almost, and the
08:15fact that we still think that this is a war between Russia and Ukraine is ridiculous at
08:22this moment in time.
08:23Ukraine is being financed by very certain powers.
08:26One of them, wait, one of them, and the biggest one to date has been the U.S.
08:33So they do have a lot to talk about.
08:35They do have a lot to agree on before Europeans even have any place in this conversation, because
08:42they didn't quite decide on their own either.
08:45You know, that was about NATO expansion.
08:48So this does bring us closer to a resolution, but we need to stop sensationalizing every summit
08:55in the way where we expect a big breakthrough or an announcement of peace or an announcement
09:01of something to come out of one summit.
09:03This is a very complex issue that was many, many years in the building.
09:12Sure.
09:13I mean, if no headline, it's a great photo op, as Pranay and Sandeep were also saying.
09:19Wonderful photo opportunity, but nothing substantive, at least on the face of it, Dr. Tara Kartha,
09:24before I bring in Sandeep Unitan and Pranay Upadhyay, which means Russia and Ukraine continue
09:29to go after each other.
09:31And what was achieved here, apart from great photographs?
09:38I would agree that the fact that these three met is a step forward, right?
09:43It's a step, presumably from global peace, which in our segment on India, we can say,
09:48we really need that peace and we need it badly.
09:51Did it, like I said, the Russians have come away with a lot.
09:55There's no doubt.
09:57He's come with the positioning.
09:59He's got the G20, all the rest of it, which I just mentioned.
10:02Putin has got what he wanted out of this war.
10:05Number two, it's not a coincidence that that Crimea bridge was attacked at that point of
10:10time.
10:11Who pushed that?
10:13That was off limits.
10:14So there is a question there.
10:16I think Europe is trying to sabotage this.
10:18They don't want a peace done over their heads.
10:21That is number two.
10:23The takeaway, Gaurav, I think is very, it's very interesting.
10:28You know, they're talking of non-proliferation.
10:31Who is the non-proliferator?
10:33The proliferator here is China.
10:34Okay, that's a different issue too.
10:36I think what US was also trying to say is that, you know, the whole message is Iran will
10:41not get a nuclear weapon.
10:42So is he saying that these are the countries who are helping Iran to get that nuclear deal?
10:49I don't think so because China never ever wanted Iran to go nuclear.
10:53That's a different issue.
10:54So the whole, the nuclear non-proliferation thing, I am not sure how it is being framed.
11:01And I would watch that very carefully to see which way it is going.
11:09Okay, no, as far as this Russia-Ukraine war is concerned, Sandeep, the fact that Jared
11:14Kushner and Steve Witkoff have flown off to Berlin from Shenzhen and the fact that they're
11:18reaching out to both Vladimir Zelensky and European leaders, which means there's some
11:23back channel that's happening.
11:24But will President Zelensky agree after losing 20% of his country and lakhs of his soldiers,
11:30if he signs the dotted line without any semblance of a give from Russia, he might as well start
11:36a comedy show in another part of the world, but he wouldn't be able to survive in Ukraine?
11:41Well, absolutely, Gaurav.
11:42You know, it's going to be a very hard, you know, act to follow on losing 20% of your
11:48territory.
11:48And that is something that the Ukrainians have been opposed to.
11:52And what President Putin has said today is significant.
11:55He said that, look, you have to accept the reality on the ground.
11:59Yalta was about the reality on the ground, and so is the Russia-Ukraine war.
12:03It's a different matter.
12:03It wasn't mentioned in the joint statement, but the fact is that it is going to be extremely
12:07difficult for Ukraine to, you know, accept the loss of territory, the entire Donbass,
12:13which is what Russia wants.
12:15What does Ukraine get in exchange for that?
12:18Will it get those ironclad guarantees that Russia will not attack it again?
12:23Does it get NATO membership?
12:25But if it gets NATO membership, then the Russians are going to be upset because this is exactly
12:29what they began the war for, to deny Ukraine NATO membership.
12:34They said that NATO was creeping at their doorstep.
12:37If Ukraine becomes a NATO member, that's NATO at Russia's doorstep, exactly what they began
12:43this war for, so it's extremely complex, Gaurav, and that is one of the reasons why this war
12:48has been dragging on for as long as it has been.
12:51And, you know, as one of our panelists mentioned, it is a fact that Russia is fighting not just
12:56Ukraine, it is fighting the entire West.
12:59It is fighting NATO.
13:00It's a proxy war of a huge, probably the biggest proxy war that we've seen in the 21st century.
13:07And, you know, that's why there are many capitals that are, you know, involved in the peace process.
13:14It's not just Moscow, Kiev, and Washington, D.C., Gaurav.
13:21And that's why perhaps this conversation in Berlin, but Berlin has also been arming Ukraine
13:27to the teeth so far, even if it, as many have argued, Europe has been cutting its nose to
13:32spite its face.
13:33And, Professor Chalani, before I bring you in, Pranay, what are European capitals, is there
13:39any word from there?
13:40How are they viewing the Shenzhen declaration, the dialogue in Shenzhen and the journey of the
13:46special envoys to Berlin?
13:48I think Europe has largely given up on President Donald Trump because they have their own concerns.
13:54They could see that the Russia-Ukraine war is not going to come to some kind of a solution,
14:01which Europe expects or Europe wants.
14:03And therefore, they are grappling on one side with their own energy crisis.
14:07They have to find some solution.
14:09Also, they have to go for their own deployment.
14:12And if you see the advancement of the European military armament production, the kind of partnerships
14:19they are forging, this clearly shows that Europe is quite unnerved with that.
14:24And they have to deal with the situation.
14:26And they really had to beg United States to be included on the big table.
14:32And that's why this Berlin round of talks is taking shape or taking place.
14:36But we have to see that, you know, whether and how, you know, Vinatia States balances this.
14:43You know, their old partners, their old allies.
14:46President Donald Trump also proposed the idea of a trilateral meeting.
14:50You know, after Alaska, you can recall, Gaurav.
14:53He proposed the idea of having a trilateral with Zelensky and Putin together.
14:57So far, that hasn't happened as yet.
15:01But we have to see that, you know, what these trilateral powers, because, you know, India
15:06always said that, you know, I mean, I would like to reiterate what Prime Minister Modi has
15:10said, you know, earlier, Gaurav, that the trust deficit is the biggest challenge in the
15:15current geopolitical setup.
15:17And that is the bigger problem here.
15:19So, on one side, earlier you excluded Ukraine.
15:22And at all the conversations, including Ukraine, you excluded Russia and have all the conversation
15:29with Ukraine on table.
15:30And now you are including Russia and not including Ukraine on the table.
15:36And either ways, it's unlikely to work, given the fact that Second World War lasted between
15:4139 and 45 for five years.
15:43And this war from February 2022, now November 2026, it's almost five years.
15:49Another three months, it will be five years.