• 11 hours ago
Willard and Dibs discuss if the 49ers can beat the Vikings on Sunday in Mexico City if Mike Evans doesn't play. Is their defense too good for the 49ers without Evans?
Transcript
00:00Hot damn, this is a big football game.
00:02So big.
00:03It's only Wednesday, and I'm like, this is a big game.
00:06And some people are like, it's four days away still, Mark.
00:11This is a big game, though, Dibs.
00:12It's a monster game.
00:15It's huge.
00:16And you've got to have Mike Evans.
00:19You want to have Mike Evans.
00:21No, you need.
00:21You want him on that wall.
00:23You need him.
00:25And you want him on that wall.
00:25You need him on that wall.
00:27Because, you know, I think that the 49ers have got a bunch of people like 100 yards away in Guantanamo.
00:36So listen to what you're saying.
00:38You're saying that Brock Purdy, with McCaffrey and Black behind him, George Kittle, Keenan Allen, Debo Samuel, Demarcus Robinson, and
00:52Jordan Watkins is not good enough.
00:54You're saying that that is not good enough.
00:57Listen to what you're saying about this Vikings defense.
00:59That's not good enough.
01:00It's because this Viking defense is not quite historic yet.
01:04But yesterday we had Mark Schlereth, a.k.a. Stink, invoke such things as the 2000 Ravens.
01:11And if that doesn't catch you and, like, make you, you know, catch your breath a little bit, that just
01:16shows you how good this defense has been.
01:18And so you need all your weapons.
01:20But especially, you need your guy who can get open on third and seven and get you eight.
01:25Keenan Allen can't get open?
01:27Of course he can.
01:28He's a separation monster.
01:29Which, by the way, we were told, this is what's funny about it to me.
01:33And again, like, we're sort of splitting hairs here.
01:37It's not like I'm out here being like, Mike Evans, Mike Schmevins.
01:40I mean, sure, like, you really, really want to be whole.
01:45But we left last year.
01:47Niners could not function against Seattle.
01:49And the whole discourse was, well, they don't have any wide receivers who can separate.
01:54Then they bring in Mike Evans, who, is he a good separator, Dibs?
02:00No.
02:00No.
02:01But it doesn't matter.
02:02He's one of the lowest separators in the game.
02:04But he's wonderful one-on-one at a traditional boundary X.
02:08Like, I understand all that, but what does Keenan Allen do that has made him special through the years?
02:14And I know they're both old, but they're still both pretty effective.
02:16And what has made Keenan Allen special through the years is not winning the one-on-one battles like Mike
02:22Evans does physically.
02:23He is a wonderful player with footwork and leverage at creating separation.
02:29He is actually the guy we said we were asking for at the end of last season.
02:37But this defense is not a defense that's just going to let you, you know, run a little route and
02:43then separate like Dallas did and like, you know, Vegas did.
02:47I know that Allen wasn't there for the Vegas game, but this Minnesota defense is going to basically bait you
02:52to try to run those routes that Keenan Allen runs,
02:55which is, you know, the little crossers and the underneath and whatnot.
02:58So you need to have somebody who can go out there on the X side of the field and get
03:03open in one-on-one and you can throw up the ball and he'll go up there and get it.
03:07Here's what Kyle Shanahan said today about Mike Evans.
03:11Yeah, hopefully we'll see.
03:12Can't go today, but hopefully he'll be able to go tomorrow.
03:15I'm not sure yet, but taking it day by day right now.
03:18All right, the word hopefully, by the way, usually is a positive thing from Kyle Shanahan.
03:23Like, I've just noticed that.
03:24It's not a guarantee by any stretch, but hopefully, like he's better than his usual possibly.
03:30Yeah, but it's usually like it to me, it represents them not tapping the brakes.
03:34Possibly.
03:35Like when they say, you know, sometimes Kyle will be like, you know, a little surprise if we can get
03:43that.
03:43We're not expecting it.
03:45I mean, a questionable amount of optimism.
03:46Exactly, but hopefully, to me, that's fingers crossed, good sign.
03:51And then here's what Shanahan said about the Brian Flores defense.
03:55I mean, he just, he does it, he's more unique than all the other 31 guys.
03:59You know, he's the one guy who commits to this and it's not just a fad for these nine games
04:02or whatever.
04:03He's been doing it his whole time, his whole time in Minnesota.
04:06He did the same thing in Miami.
04:08He's as good as it gets to that stuff.
04:10I mean, anybody who lives in that world as much as he does, it's usually a matter of time.
04:14I think office coaches used to like to say that early on, but it's too many years of it and
04:19it's too many games in this year that they're sound.
04:22They put so much pressure on the quarterback, the play caller, the whole line, the receivers on everybody.
04:27A lot of times when you go into NFL game, the pressure's really on people on third down and stuff
04:32like that because those are the things where everything can come.
04:34And when you play against Brian, it's 70 straight plays of that.
04:38Okay.
04:40It's like being on third down every single play is essentially what he just said.
04:46And if you look at just like the raw numbers of blitz percentage and, oh, I know he likes to
04:51blitz a lot, but he blitzes almost more than twice as often as the number two team.
04:56He blitzes on 67% of passing downs, which means you're not just bringing four, you're bringing five, maybe six.
05:05You probably don't need to bring seven because your guys are phenomenal.
05:08Number two is the Giants at 37%.
05:10Yeah.
05:11So it's almost twice as often.
05:13So basically when you're in a passing down, if it's third and medium, third and long, you're going to have
05:18to expect like five or six guys coming at you.
05:21Big Kalon Black game, I think.
05:24The only vulnerability they have shown this year is against the run.
05:28He's your battering ram.
05:29I know McCaffrey is your lead, but Kalon Black and like the tough yards, if you will, I just, I
05:36think each passing week we're seeing him become more and more of a key.
05:40And I think he's a big deal in this game.
05:42One more, and we'll kind of push this to Thursday and Friday once we have more information as to whether
05:48or not Mike Evans is practicing.
05:49But if he practices, we get to play wide receiver survivor because Kyle Shanahan seems to be indicating that Jacob
05:57Cowling will continue to return putts.
06:00I'm confident, Jake, especially his return abilities.
06:03You know, I don't think we've got a ton of good looks, haven't got a lot of returns.
06:07I know our numbers are very bad in that area, but Jake has the ability to be a very good
06:11punt returner.
06:12I hope he keeps getting more confidence and consistent at catching the ball.
06:15And I hope we continue to get better at blocking and hopefully get some more opportunities because Jake can make
06:20plays.
06:20Hasn't gotten that on a punt return yet, but something that I know we can do.
06:24Okay.
06:25I hate this quote.
06:25I hate this quote more than I've hated any quote all year.
06:29I hope he can continue to be confident in catching the ball.
06:33Catching the ball?
06:35I hope he builds confidence in cat.
06:38The punt returner is building confidence in catching the ball?
06:43Right.
06:44Yo.
06:45Totally.
06:46Scary.
06:46Yo.
06:48All right.
06:48So, if Jake continues to build confidence in catching the ball, Mike Evans practices.
06:56The 49ers only keep four on game day beyond the punt returner.
07:00Mike Evans, Keenan Allen, Debo Samuel, Demarcus Robinson, Jordan Watkins, who's out?
07:06You keep six.
07:07I mean, you have to keep six.
07:09You said that last week, and they did not keep six.
07:12Well, they've kept six before, and I do think against Dallas, you don't really need to keep
07:16six because you're not that worried about punt return, but if you look at this game and
07:21you think about, what is it, like 11 or 12 possessions each way, and you're thinking,
07:26okay, if they stop us seven times, if we have to punt seven times, and they have to punt
07:32seven times, well, that's seven times I need somebody to be able to, like, catch the ball.
07:36And if he's the guy who's been trying to go back there and catch the ball, I do think you
07:40kind of have to keep him up, but you don't want to have him out there on offense, and
07:44they haven't used him on offense very often unless they've been desperate.
07:47I wonder.
07:48I really, really do.
07:50I wonder if Demarcus Robinson would be deactivated for this game.
07:54I really do.
07:56925 Willard, are you worried about Kalon Black fumbling?
07:59He's done it a few times.
08:01I am worried about everything in this football game.
08:06Every single play is going to be anxiety, which is why I cannot stand that I'm going
08:13to be trying to do a radio show in the middle of it.
08:15Yeah, it's tough.
08:16I can't stand it, but I'm not complaining.
08:18Like, we'll have fun, and I'll survive.
08:20I've done this before.
08:21I was on the radio when the Cavs and Warriors were playing in game seven, and I watched them
08:26lose.
08:27Brutal.
08:27And it was absolutely one of the worst moments of my career.
08:32I mean, yeah.
08:33Like, can you imagine, right?
08:34You lose a championship, and you're like, well, I don't know, Bob.
08:36Like, boy, they weren't able to make the shot.
08:39Like, oh, God.
08:42Kevin loves shutting down Steph Curry.
08:44I just wanted to curl up in a ball.
08:46No doubt.
08:46Yeah.
08:46And that's tough.
08:47And this is a regular season game, and I understand that.
08:49It's a big regular season game, and it's going to be an awesome Sunday night spectacle.
08:53But even if they lose, they're still in a great spot for A, B, C, and D.
08:59And if they win, they kind of have a little bit of an inside track on doing what everyone
09:03wants them to do.
09:04I think a big inside track.
09:06Depends on what you do against Seattle, and that's a tough spot.
09:08I know.
09:09But even still, even if you lose to Seattle, you're still up by two with six to play.
09:13Right.
09:13But, I mean, tiebreaker-wise, that puts you in a little bit of a spot, because Seattle
09:18has, you know, the head-to-head is no longer there, and you would have, I think, an equal
09:23record in the division, although, and you still have the Rams in Arizona, and they have
09:27the Rams twice.
09:29Right.
09:29So.
09:30Yeah, Seattle's current division record is two and one, and the 49ers is three and
09:36oh, so it would be even.
09:37It would be tied, yes.
09:38It would be even.
09:38But, yes, they still would have two games against the Rams to go.
09:41Exactly, and you have Arizona, and you have the Rams, and, you know, I'm not sure what
09:45the Rams will be at that spot.
09:47I don't think that they're just going to fade away because they have all these injuries.
09:50Like, the Rams are going to keep going out there and fighting for, you know, 10 wins
09:54in a wild card.
09:54No, I think the Rams are, like, they look like they're getting better, because their defense
09:58at least is getting whole.
09:59Yep.
09:59Their offense is not.
10:02Okay, how about Fred in Richmond?
10:04Hi, Fred.
10:04Thanks for the call.
10:05What you got?
10:07Well, it is.
10:08Thanks for having me on.
10:09You know, I'm so, I'm like you, Willard.
10:12I'm so excited for this game coming up.
10:14It's like, I have anxiety at work.
10:17I'm just looking at people like, I don't want to hear nobody talking crazy come Sunday,
10:22Monday when I go back to work.
10:24All the Niners suck.
10:25Okay.
10:25I just, I don't know.
10:27I just really feel like Keenan Allen, what he did last week from four days of practice,
10:34I can only imagine what he's going to do on Sunday after a full week of practice.
10:38Keenan Allen is a man-to-man beater, and I think Kittle is going to have a hell of a
10:45game
10:46because of how the Minnesota does a lot of blitzings with that safety.
10:52Harrison Smith, I believe his name is, number 22.
10:57I feel that if Kittle can utilize and take him out the game by working the middle of the field
11:03and they scheme it up right, we'll win a close one, 24-16.
11:11I'll take it.
11:12I'll take it, Fred.
11:13Yeah.
11:14Hey, Fred, thanks so much.
11:16Do you want to, let me throw this in there.
11:18So here's what I'm saying about Mike Evans.
11:20Again, do you want him?
11:21Sure.
11:22Obviously not.
11:24But here's why, to me, he's not the linchpin.
11:27The linchpin is the five big guys up front.
11:31If you want to go back to where the 49ers lost and were so overwhelmed against Seattle last year,
11:37and I'm confident that Greg Cosell will back me on this, they got beat up in the trenches.
11:42If Brock Purdy drops back and there are Vikings in his face, I don't care if you've got Mike Evans
11:49or Randy Moss, for that matter.
11:51You're in trouble.
11:53But if the offensive line gives Brock a minute, and Brock does his normal thing where he's able to buy
11:59some time and whatnot here and there,
12:01if he's able to function, he can do that with multiple skill position people.
12:07And I believe if he has time, Keenan Allen, Debo Samuel, Demarcus Robinson, and Jordan Watkins,
12:15I believe that that is, and George Kittle, for that matter, and CMC, that's a group to me you can
12:20go win a football game with.
12:22That's going to be the whole deal to me, is how much time does the offensive line provide,
12:29and how often does that offense avoid major mistakes?
12:33Penalties, turnovers, sacks.
12:35Well, that's the bit.
12:36The bit for me is avoiding obvious pass downs, because I'm just looking at the numbers,
12:40and Minnesota is number one in sacks, number one in pressure rate, number one in blitzes,
12:46number one in yards allowed, blah, blah, blah.
12:49So if you get into third and six and third and seven, to me it doesn't really matter if you
12:53have Mike Evans or not.
12:55You're in a tough spot, because they're going to pin their ears back, they're coming for you,
12:59and they tend to get home when they come for you.
13:01Can you go from first and ten, to second and six, to third and two?
13:05If you get to third and two, now it's Shanahan and that lovely laminated spreadsheet,
13:10and now you can think, all right, it might be run, it might be pass.
13:13We've got Debo and McCaffrey and Kittle all in the huddle, and we've got Evans,
13:18and we also have whoever other receiver you want.
13:21And when you break the huddle, you don't know what they might be doing.
13:23It might be a Debo jet sweep.
13:25It might be Debo in the backfield and McCaffrey in the slot.
13:28If you're in a third and short situation, that's where Shanahan has the advantage.
13:32If you're in third and medium and third and long, and they're able to come out and get you,
13:36I just don't know if, like Mike Evans, he's great, but he needs to get down the field a little
13:42bit.
13:43And Keenan Allen, I'm sorry, but if you're in that spot, they're probably not going to play man,
13:47and you might not have that much time to throw.
13:49Remember, remember, to me this is really, really, this is key.
13:53So two weeks ago on Monday Night Football, the Minnesota Vikings hosted the Buffalo Bills.
14:00Does everybody like the Bills offense?
14:02Do we like their quarterback?
14:04Their offense is different.
14:05It's a different offense, yes.
14:07It's very different.
14:08However, it's effective.
14:10They're a very, very good offense.
14:12They move the ball.
14:13Well, at the end of three quarters, the score of that football game was Buffalo 13 and Minnesota 6.
14:22Now, eventually, the Bills were able to kind of overwhelm and pull away.
14:28Oh, God.
14:29And that is because...
14:30Carson Wentz.
14:32He went eight for 25...
14:34My God.
14:35...for 81 yards and two interceptions against the Bills defense, which, checks notes, is not good.
14:43It's bend and do break.
14:44Right.
14:45By the fourth quarter, the Vikings had given Max Brosmer the ball,
14:49and he went out there and he did whatever the hell he did because the game was kind of decided.
14:54But Josh Allen in that game grinds it out.
14:5821 of 31, 234 yards, a touchdown, a pick, sacked four times, a quarterback rating of 87.3 in the
15:07game.
15:08James Cook runs for a buck 07, but they had to give him 31 carries in order to do it.
15:14Average 3.5 yards a carry.
15:16So you really have to grind your gears to win this game.
15:21And what we tend to do...
15:22I remember this when they played Seattle the first time.
15:25We get so caught up in one side of the ball.
15:29Remember how everyone wanted to see Kyle's offense against Mike McDonald's defense.
15:33And I'd argue the Niners won that game because of what the Niner defense did to the Seattle offense.
15:38Same thing here.
15:40Like, is Brock Purdy going to win every drive?
15:43Hell no.
15:45But if the Niners can limit...
15:47What I'm looking for is one turnover or less in this football game by the Niner offense.
15:52And if they can grind out 20 to 24 points.
15:57But what happens on the other side of the ball?
16:00We're going to do Shanahan Flores all week long.
16:02But what happens when it's Raheem Morris against Kevin O'Connell?
16:08Especially because this defense has been injured and maligned of late.
16:12If they play well.
16:14If they can make Kirk Cousins look like bad Kirk.
16:18Not you like that Kirk.
16:20If they can do that, then the 49ers can win the game.
16:24But if the Minnesota offense is able to move the ball in ways that the offenses have against the Niners
16:31defense
16:31the last couple of weeks, I think they're in trouble.
16:34That's what I think.
16:35Especially if you're...
16:36Like, we always look at Shanahan and, oh, they can't come from behind.
16:39Although they've had some fourth quarter comebacks and they're allowed to.
16:42But against this defense, if you're down 17-7 in the third quarter,
16:47and now you're kind of in a pass-first mode,
16:50I do think that that formula is a little bit of a trouble spot.
16:53And I'm just looking at last week where Kirk Cousins went out there
16:57and they had the ball for 35 minutes.
16:58And so that defense that is so bloodthirsty and ready to get after you,
17:02if the offense has it for 35 minutes and the defense is fresh and only plays 25 minutes,
17:07that's a formula for disaster.
17:09I agree.
17:10The two-score thing to me is the key.
17:12Remember now, oh, they never do anything in the fourth quarter
17:16against a good defense when they were behind.
17:17Well, they were in Seattle on the road down 26-21 in the fourth quarter
17:22with the ball in their own territory.
17:23They won the football game.
17:24Mike Evans.
17:26No doubt.
17:28So, you know, can they do that?
17:30Yes.
17:30Can they fall behind by two scores in the fourth quarter and win?
17:33I don't believe so.
17:34I don't believe so.
17:37Jonathan in the city.
17:38Hi, Jonathan.
17:39Thanks for calling.
17:41Hey, I just want to say, Mark, you kind of stole my thunder.
17:45And then another, Mark, I heard him.
17:47You know, I listen all the time.
17:48I've been listening since the inception of this station.
17:51I listen to all the shows.
17:52And I kind of heard Mark compared and likened this defense to the old-timers.
17:59So I just got a fact-checked him because I was like, no,
18:03oh, that doesn't sound right because I heard Monte Ceevins, Tampa Bay,
18:08you know, the Legion of Boom, No Fly Zone.
18:10I remember, and if my facts are straight and correct,
18:14those defenses are top five in both categories, run defense, pass defense.
18:19This defense, like you alluded to, Mark, their weeks off is the run defense.
18:25They are number 17.
18:27They're giving up 117 yards per game.
18:30So this is going to be a game for our big boys, Trent Williams in the O-line,
18:36Kyle Juszczyk, George Kittle, Kittle on Black, TMC.
18:43Just put on your big boys fad.
18:46Your lunch pail is going to be an all-cake-for-all type of a duo,
18:52you know, a Gangs of New York type of a rumble.
18:55And, yeah, let's get it on.
18:57Let's go, Niners.
18:58Let's go, Jonathan.
19:00Jameer Gibbs, three weeks ago, 23 carries, 153 yards against this defense.
19:06But, A, that's Jameer Gibbs.
19:09And, B, the Lions still only scored 19 points in that game
19:12and had to grind out a four-point win.
19:14So, again, they've got to run the ball,
19:17but then you've got to pair that with don't turn it over
19:21and give Minnesota a short field because that football team had Kyler Murray at quarterback.
19:28This is why Minnesota becomes such a pickle now because what you could do before was you're like,
19:33let's grind it out and just hope that their offense is going to stink.
19:36And they'd be like, cool, we do.
19:37But now I don't know if that's the case anymore.
19:41At minimum, they are more competent than they were before.
19:43Yeah, and this is where if you look at, like, the advanced metrics and the DVOA,
19:47and I was looking at it with their offense,
19:49and offensively they are ranked, like, pretty far down.
19:52They're 29th in offense.
19:54And DVOA is defensive-adjusted value over average,
19:57which means based on who you face, how did you do on each individual play,
20:02and they're 29th.
20:03Well, the 29th was built on Brosmer, Murray, and Wentz, not as much about Cousins.
20:09And so I take that with a little bit of a grain of salt.
20:12And so is the Minnesota offense something that you should fear?
20:15Absolutely not.
20:16But I do think that both ways it comes down to turnovers,
20:19and Minnesota's offense is now better having Kirk Cousins because he's an actual quarterback.
20:25Minnesota was in Indianapolis, or hosted Minneapolis.
20:28I'm sorry.
20:29Indianapolis.
20:30Indianapolis.
20:31I like it.
20:31They hosted the Colts four weeks ago.
20:33Jonathan Taylor, 5.3 a carry.
20:36Seth McGowan, 4.2 a carry.
20:38The Colts ran the ball on them, only lost by six.
20:42The difference is, again, like you watched them with Kirk Cousins last week,
20:45and they kind of, once they get a short field,
20:48and they're able to start putting the ball in the end zone the way Kirk Cousins did,
20:53they ended up beating the Packers by three touchdowns at Lambeau.
20:57And even at that, like, just the numbers you rolled out about Jonathan Taylor and Indy,
21:01they scored 10 points.
21:02And so I do think that the defense can be a little bit of a bend but don't break.
21:07And if you can run it, yes, you can keep their offense off the field.
21:11And, I mean, before Kirk Cousins came, you want their offense on the field.
21:15But even at that, the Colts only were able to score 10 points.
21:19Take your field goals and stop yelling at the coach.
21:25Coach, fans, that's another little point I'd like to make about this game.
21:30Please.
21:31Take your field goal and get the hell off of the field without taking a zero.
21:37Speak on that because I'm looking at the game two years ago.
21:40It was fourth and two at the two, and Kyle wanted to go for it and stuff,
21:43and they didn't get it.
21:45And so maybe now you put a little bit more respect on their defense,
21:48and you just take the three even if it's a 20-yard field goal.
21:51I mean, you know, it depends on what's going on with the game.
21:54But, yeah, like don't scoff at three in this one by any stretch.
21:58Zach in Concord.
21:59Hi, Zach.
21:59Thanks for the call.
22:01Oh, hey, gentlemen.
22:02How you doing?
22:02Love you guys.
22:03You guys are amazing.
22:03I learn something every time.
22:05I had forgotten that the Niners played Miami when Brian Flores was the coach,
22:10and he owned them then.
22:12You guys are talking some Jim Schwartz ownage of Kyle Shanahan there.
22:16I wanted to touch on what you said about can they win without Mike Evans.
22:20Yes, they absolutely can win without Mike Evans.
22:23Will it be easier for them with Mike Evans?
22:25Yes, and Shanahan knows that, and he's probably got a play sheet with him,
22:28a play sheet without, and it's icing on the cake if he plays,
22:32and it makes it easier for everybody, harder on Brian Flores.
22:36Another thing I was listening to, Dibs, you described the way it's going to be –
22:40it's an uncomfortable game.
22:43Brian Flores wants to make Purdy uncomfortable in the pocket.
22:46It's going to be an uncomfortable watch as well for all of us.
22:49Man, I am anxious.
22:50This gives us – there's a lot on the table.
22:52Can we win?
22:53Yes.
22:54And will we?
22:55Man, I don't know, but I sure as heck hope so.
22:57And the guy who I think is going down is Demarcus Robinson if they don't carry six,
23:02like you said.
23:02I mean, Zach, thanks.
23:04The snap count last week would suggest that.
23:08If Evans is –
23:09If you keep cowing in.
23:09If cowing is in and Evans is in and you're only keeping five receivers,
23:14the snap count suggests that Demarcus Robinson will be the next to be deactivated.
23:18And I get that because not that he is a, quote, finesse receiver,
23:22but if this game is going to be a really tough, like, it's third and six,
23:27and we need six, we'd love to have seven, who do we go to?
23:31It's Mike Evans, of course, and it's Keenan Allen and George Kittle.
23:34Like, those are your three, and obviously McCaffrey, that goes without saying,
23:38and the little option route where he comes out of the backfield.
23:40But I think Demarcus Robinson is a little bit more of a luxury piece,
23:43as is Jordan Watkins, but I think Watkins is a little bit more explosive right now.
23:48I mean, they seem to feel that way.
23:50More on that as the week unfolds and if we see if Mike does indeed practice tomorrow or not.

Recommended