- 6 minutes ago
Willard and Dibs debate if Brock Purdy's draft spot is impacting his case for MVP this season. Why shouldn't he be the MVP favorite?
Category
🥇
SportsTranscript
00:00So I did some research.
00:02We're just past the halfway point.
00:06In the NFL?
00:07Uh-huh.
00:08And I'm not trying.
00:11Like, honestly, I think most 49er fans feel this way.
00:15Who gives a flying schmuck who wins NFL MVP?
00:21We want a Super Bowl trophy.
00:24Obviously, if you had your choice between the two,
00:26you would take the Lombardi over the MVP.
00:29However, I thought something was interesting.
00:32So check out the Calciad.
00:33So Joe Burrow goes on Sunday night football
00:35and throws four touchdown passes and blows out the Steelers.
00:38So Joe Burrow is currently trading at a 48% probability to win NFL MVP.
00:44And just so people who are not totally Calciad literate,
00:47it is all determined by the money that comes in.
00:50So people who see that, they flood the market.
00:52His percentage goes up.
00:54It's not necessarily totally indicative of, like, the Vegas money,
00:59which was a much larger pool,
01:00but it is indicative of action and movement in the market.
01:04Yeah.
01:04Well, if you want me to do odds, just regular current odds NFL MVP,
01:10and, like, go over to FanDuel, and we can play that game as well.
01:14So right now, current odds to win the NFL MVP, Joe Burrow is minus.
01:21Okay?
01:22That's how heavy of a favorite he is.
01:24And that actually, when people use the expression odds-on favorite,
01:27you're only an odds-on favorite when you have the minus.
01:30Okay.
01:30That's the definition of odds-on.
01:32Joe Burrow is minus 105.
01:35It's roughly almost even money for him to win MVP.
01:41Second in the odds goes to Josh Allen, plus 380.
01:45Third in the odds, Brock Purdy, plus 450.
01:48I want to start this conversation by saying,
01:51I don't really have a problem with that.
01:53Okay?
01:53If your name is right after Joe Burrow and Josh Allen
01:56and tucked in front of Trevor Lawrence and Patrick Mahomes, fine.
02:01Fine.
02:01Like, I don't even know that I wouldn't vote that way.
02:04Like, I ran the numbers.
02:06I was curious.
02:07I saw this, and I'm like, okay, why is everybody...
02:10You're, like, losing your minds over Joe Burrow.
02:12And here's why, in my opinion, draftism still exists.
02:18There's a conversation to be had around Brock Purdy's MVP case,
02:24and it always lands in the same spot.
02:26Well, hold on a second.
02:28And, sure, he's not a system guy anymore.
02:31We can tell that he can improv and make a play.
02:34He's playing great.
02:35Man, he's getting a lot better.
02:36But, you know, it kind of goes to Cowherd's point.
02:39Well, this is the greatest offense I've ever seen.
02:42And he's just surrounded by greatness.
02:45The left tackle, the tight end, the running back.
02:48And now we're putting Hall of Fame receivers,
02:50Keenan Allen and Mike Evans with them, good God.
02:53How can we give it to Brock Purdy when he's surrounded by all that?
02:58All right, now do this exercise.
03:00If I asked you, who's got the best receiving core in the entire NFL?
03:04The best receiving core?
03:06I mean, you could argue Cincinnati.
03:08They've got, as far as their one-two punch,
03:11like how deep do you want to go in the core and all the rest of it?
03:14Like, as far as your top two, and they run a lot of three-receiver sets,
03:18but you've got two of the fanciest, highest-paid guys in football.
03:22So they're definitely on the short list.
03:24I think most people—
03:25The Rams would be up there, too, when healthy.
03:27When healthy, sure, which they're not.
03:29But, like, I look at this right now, and if we did a poll of,
03:34hey, who's got the best one-two punch at wide receiver in football,
03:37I have zero doubt that the Cincinnati Bengals would be the choice
03:42with Jamar Chase and Tee Higgins.
03:44The Rams is a fair answer.
03:46We can bounce around the league a little bit.
03:49And, you know—
03:50Like, who would the Lions 2 be after Amon Ra?
03:54Yeah, well, now it's that guy like Tesla.
03:58Isaac Tesla.
03:59Yeah, not Tesla.
04:00Tesla.
04:01Yep.
04:02Yeah.
04:04Who else has got really good receiving cores?
04:06I mean, the Jags have a good receiving core.
04:09You know, the Bears.
04:13It's a young group, but the Bears is a really good one-two punch
04:17with Adunze and Luther Burden.
04:19I think Green Bay with Watson and Golden is an emerging, somewhat underrated combo.
04:25I think the team the 49ers just saw last week would probably actually be the second answer.
04:29Fair.
04:30For a one-two punch with CeeDee Lamb and George Pickens.
04:32But anyway, my point is, do you notice how what's going on around you, that affects Brock?
04:41But not anybody else.
04:43You will never—and I promise you this for the remainder of the year.
04:47And I say this also under the caveat, if I had a vote today, I would vote for Joe Burrow.
04:55I would.
04:56But it's close.
04:57Brock Purdy would be my number two.
04:59Josh Allen would be my number three.
05:01And I've run the numbers.
05:02And I can explain where I'm coming from on that, if anybody cares.
05:06But I don't have a vote, and we're only 10 games in, so whatever.
05:09But the bottom line is, is I'd vote for Joe.
05:12I'm not saying that's a bad vote.
05:14I'm just saying, how come no one ever says that about Joe?
05:18No one ever says that about Joe.
05:21They only say that about Brock Purdy.
05:24What, that Joe's got this amazing supporting cast, and that should be a demerit?
05:27Oh, man.
05:27He's got T. Higgins and Jamar Chase to throw to.
05:31Meanwhile, by the way, Brock Purdy, does he have a good offense?
05:33He sure does.
05:34Does anyone want to bring up that his starting five receivers when camp opened
05:40basically have spent more time on the shelf than playing?
05:44I mean, two of them are out.
05:46One of them's out for the year.
05:47One of them's been out since game one.
05:50One of them has missed the last three games.
05:52Yep.
05:52How many games did Debo miss?
05:54He missed the last four games.
05:58And Demarcus Robinson missed five games.
06:02With the high ankle, yeah.
06:03Those are the first five.
06:05That's who it was supposed to be.
06:07Those are the five receivers.
06:09And so now we're grabbing, you know, we're grabbing big-bearded Keenan Allen
06:16and Jordan Watkins and turning him into a thing, and it's still like, yeah,
06:21Brock is surrounded by greatness.
06:22And it's like, okay, yeah, he's got a great offense.
06:25There's no two ways about it.
06:25He's also got, I think, the best play caller in the game.
06:28But my point is, is that draftism remains because this world would much rather give the award
06:35to Joe Burrow or Josh Allen than they would Brock Purdy because that makes sense to people.
06:41And I get it.
06:42Yeah, I think there's a piece of that, but also the thing that, for me, it comes down to,
06:47it just comes down to the numbers part of it.
06:50And I'm looking at just some of the numbers right now, and the one that pops to me is
06:53Joe Burrow has attempted 76 more passes than Brock Purdy.
06:58Burrow's got a higher QB rating.
07:00He throws for more yards a game.
07:02He's got a higher success rate.
07:03His completion percentage is at 74.7, which is bananas when you think about the fact that
07:09he's completed the most passes.
07:11Brock has more yards per attempt, more air yards, et cetera, et cetera.
07:15The QBR is higher.
07:16You can go numbers versus numbers back and forth, but I think when you look at just the
07:21big numbers, which are always like yards, percentage, rating, and touchdowns, the fact that
07:27he's going to end up throwing the ball 130 more times than Brock, that puts Brock in
07:32a disadvantage more so than the draft is.
07:34No question, but I do want to bring up what those numbers that you reference actually are.
07:39Like when you say Joe Burrow's QB rating is higher, it's 117.7.
07:43Two and a half points.
07:43Yeah.
07:43Brock's is 115.2.
07:45These are both otherworldly numbers.
07:47Correct.
07:47Joe Burrow, 27.95 in terms of yardage.
07:50Brock is 23.69.
07:52Joe is ahead in all these things.
07:53He's 27 touchdowns to six picks.
07:55Brock is 20 touchdowns to five picks.
07:58Joe Burrow's completion percentage, as you said, is 74.7.
08:01That's bananas.
08:02A little bit less, but still bananas is the 70.1 that Brock has got.
08:08And when people go, okay, Josh Allen has thrown for way fewer yards.
08:13His TD to interception ratio is actually awful in this conversation, at least.
08:19It's 13 to seven.
08:21And what will everyone say?
08:22Hold on, Mark.
08:24What about the rushing?
08:26Okay, then how about if we do that with Brock versus Joe Burrow?
08:30What about the rushing?
08:32Would it shock everybody to know that Josh Allen has only run for 68 more yards this year than Brock
08:39Purdy?
08:40Now, I know he's got 11 touchdowns and Brock has two.
08:44This is just rushing.
08:45But we get it.
08:47This is the way the Bills do their red zone offense.
08:50If you get to the two-yard line, that's it.
08:52We're done here.
08:53Josh is going to run the ball in.
08:56But Brock Purdy has 222 rushing yards this year.
09:00Joe Burrow has 85.
09:01Right.
09:01So, if we're going to slant it and go, hey, but what about the rushing with Josh?
09:06Same thing then when you do Brock versus Joe.
09:09Look, they're all phenomenal.
09:11Let's throw Trevor Lawrence into the conversation as well.
09:13Yeah, thank you.
09:13He deserves to be there.
09:15He, in fact, you could make a case that he's, you could put him ahead of Josh Allen and make
09:21a case.
09:22You really could.
09:23And you could actually make a case to put him alongside Brock Purdy in many metrics.
09:28Because if you look at just the stats of it, Trevor Lawrence throws the ball about as often as Brock.
09:33In fact, he throws it less often than Brock.
09:36So, for me, and I'm not a voter, but the things that I really look at are percentages.
09:40Touchdown percentage, interception percentage.
09:43What percentage of your throws are touchdowns?
09:45What percentage are interceptions?
09:47And if you look at Joe and Brock and Trevor, they're all identical in interception percentage, which is a little
09:54bit less than two.
09:55And Trevor Lawrence leads in touchdown percentage.
09:58So, things like that, because it's a little bit unfair that Burrow's going to lead the league in so many
10:04different metrics because they have the ball a lot more.
10:07They're trailing a lot.
10:08They throw it a lot.
10:09It's just the way they build their team.
10:10Red zone percentage, as we know, 49ers are going to break a record if they stay where they are.
10:15They're at 82.76% touchdowns.
10:20And to me, this is a quarterback stat as well.
10:21All these guys are good.
10:23The Bengals are at 71%.
10:25The Jags are at 64%.
10:26The Bills and Chiefs are at 66%.
10:28The Niners are at 82.7%.
10:32And that thing plummeted because they only went two for three.
10:34Correct.
10:35This past weekend.
10:36Well, they couldn't get in the red zone.
10:38They kept scoring from 60 and 70 yards out.
10:40The Cowboys wouldn't let them in the red zone.
10:42And then here's one more just for fun.
10:45If you want to nerd out in this conversation,
10:47EPA expected points added per drop back.
10:53Okay?
10:54This is actually wild when you think about it.
10:56So every time Brock Purdy drops back to throw,
11:02in theory, it adds, it is expected to add a third of a point to the scoreboard.
11:09Yep.
11:09Every time he drops back.
11:11So he leads the NFL at 0.3.
11:16And Burrow's 0.29.
11:170.26 is what I saw.
11:19I saw 0.26.
11:21Trevor Lawrence is 0.23.
11:23Mahomes and Josh Allen are all the way down at 0.15.
11:26Half of a Brock every time they drop back.
11:30So throw that all into the mix.
11:32And clearly, look, I think the record and where things sort of develop from here,
11:37if Brock struggles against the Vikings and Seahawks,
11:40and they have a hard time scoring points,
11:42then this is going to kind of go away.
11:45But that's where we're at.
11:47The larger thing is the size of the favorite that Burrow is.
11:51Because I think all these guys, they're all phenomenal.
11:53You can really, I think, make a case for Burrow, Purdy, and Lawrence,
11:58and then kind of an alternative case for Josh Allen.
12:02But the size of the favorite that Burrow is, that suggests draftism to me.
12:09Well, that's the calcium metric, and I'd have to look to see.
12:12No, but even the odds.
12:14Well, the odds are not that dramatically bigger.
12:16Yes, he's minus 105, which is, and I just was looking at it,
12:20and he, like, Allen is basically 4-1, and Joe Burrow's even money.
12:24And so we're, like you said, about halfway through the year.
12:27Purdy's right on the heels of Allen, and then Lawrence is a shade behind Brock.
12:31And so I do think that that, the odds, and FanDuel reacted to Sunday night.
12:36And you look at the numbers, and you look at his completion percentage,
12:39and he's on track to have the most accurate year in history.
12:43And he might have 50 touchdown passes, and they're a high-flying, high-falutin offense.
12:49And I think that you could look at Buffalo and say, oh, my God, they're 8-1,
12:54and, you know, the Niners are 8-1, and Cincinnati's 7-2.
12:57For me, if all these guys, Jacksonville 7-2, if all these top four or five candidates,
13:03because you can even throw in Mahomes, because you know his name,
13:06and he's a fancy quarterback, I think the team that winds up with the best record,
13:11if all these quarterbacks wind up mostly even, I think you could look at the MVP and say,
13:17your team went 15-2, you get the award.
13:19Well, I think there's also a high-profile nature of games aspect of this that I want to add in,
13:25and then we'll take a couple calls on it.
13:27We got Grandy's grades coming up in a little bit.
13:28You're listening to 95.7 The Game, KGMZ FM and HD1 San Francisco,
13:32and Odyssey Sports Station, home of the Golden State Warriors and Valkyries,
13:35and always live on the free Odyssey app, and coming to you live from the Laughing Monk Studios.
13:40Football coverage on 95.7 The Game is brought to you by Xfinity,
13:43introducing Xfinity Shield, a force field for your home team.
13:46I don't think it is, it's not lost on me that what Burrow just did was on Sunday Night Football.
13:53And remember, the last time Brock Purdy was an MVP candidate, what happened?
13:58Christmas night, Ravens, four picks, thanks for your time.
14:01You're out.
14:02Mike McDonald.
14:03So what happens, same thing here this weekend, okay?
14:06Sunday Night Football, Mexico City, best defense in the game.
14:10If Brock performs well, this is going to elevate the hell out of him.
14:15If he throws three picks, night-night.
14:18Now, look ahead, and Brock's got to do Minnesota and Seattle in back-to-back weeks.
14:22Now, Burrow, Burrow's got back-to-back games against Cleveland and Kansas City coming up in a few weeks.
14:28Those are good defenses.
14:29In fact, he's still got to play Cleveland twice.
14:32But outside of that, he doesn't have a whole lot of scary defenses out there.
14:35He's got a New Orleans, and he's got an Indy, and he's got a Carolina.
14:38And so that's a piece of this action, too, when you look at it.
14:43Josh Allen's got two Dolphins, a Jets, a Patriots, a Bears, which their defense is better than it was.
14:51Their defense is getting better, no doubt.
14:52Look out, Jeffrey Simmons, look out.
14:53He's got the Broncos, and he's got the Packers, but as far as like—
14:56Those are good defenses.
14:57Yeah, but, I mean, Buffalo's got the Dolphins this weekend.
15:00They go to Miami.
15:01They host the Jets at the end of it, and he may not actually play in that game because they
15:05might already be sewn up.
15:07But their schedule is not complete with world-beating defenses, that's for sure.
15:12Trevor Lawrence has to go to Chicago.
15:14He has to go to Houston.
15:16That used to be a good defense.
15:17But watch out for Trevor.
15:20Trevor's got Sunday night football at Dallas two nights after Christmas.
15:24What do you think's going to happen there?
15:26132 points.
15:2740-burger for sure, yeah.
15:28All for Jacksonville.
15:30So, you know, just track that.
15:32I think the high-profile nature of it.
15:35So, in other words, this is a game this weekend.
15:38For those of you who care about this, Brock can really vault himself in this conversation.
15:43If he's to go, like, one or zero turnovers and keep the red zone efficiency high and win the football
15:52game, I don't think he needs to sparkle.
15:54But he needs to not turn it over, and the Niners need to win.
15:58If you do that against this defense, the way people are talking about it, it's going to fire up the
16:03board for sure.
16:04No doubt.
16:05And, you know, basically for me, it's just avoid the turnovers and win the game.
16:08And I will make this prediction right here, right now, on this great day, November 17th.
16:14The MVP will be from a team with the best record in football or tied for the best record in
16:20football.
16:21In other words, if there's a 14-3, if there's a couple of 14-3s, the MVP will be from
16:26one of the teams or the team with the best record in football.
16:29Because I think it will be that close between Cincinnati, Jacksonville, Buffalo, Kansas City, and the Niners.
16:36Those are your five teams, and apologies to Minnesota, but if you go out and you have the best record,
16:41I don't think that you're getting the MVP because you've started 11 different quarterbacks and you're carried by your defense.
16:47They may even have Trent Dilfer come quarterback them just for old time's sake.
16:51But outside of Minnesota, any of those other five teams with the best record, you're getting the MVP.
16:57Strength of schedule the rest of the way.
16:59I'm looking at it right now, okay?
17:03Cincinnati Bengals, 22nd.
17:05So the higher the number, the easier the schedule.
17:09They have the 22nd hardest remaining schedule.
17:12Buffalo Bills, 24th.
17:15Yep.
17:16Jacksonville Jaguars, 28th.
17:20Kansas City Chiefs, let's keep Mahomes in there, 5th.
17:2549ers?
17:279th?
17:2817th.
17:28Oh, 17th, okay.
17:2917th.
17:30I'm actually a little surprised by that.
17:32But we forget that while they've got to go to play Minnesota and Seattle's coming and the Rams are coming
17:37and they have to go to Arrowhead,
17:39they get a Chargers, they get a Cardinals, they get an Eagles, and then the other team is the New
17:45York Giants,
17:46which is moonlighting as a good team and they're not.
17:49Right, first place.
17:50You know what I mean?
17:51That's a cross country, I think it's a 10 a.m. game.
17:53Yeah, yeah.
17:56I'm not going to go there yet.
17:57I'm not calling it a scheduled loss.
17:59No, they're just not.
18:00They're not what they're cracked up to be.
18:02They just happen to be the only team out of two divisions in the NFC that currently has a winning
18:07record.
18:07But they're not very good.
18:08They're not, but they have a very, very good coach, and that is, it's a bit of a spot.
18:14It's a 10 a.m. game in the Eastern time zone on a field that no one wants to play
18:19on because it'll chomp your knee.
18:21It's an ACL waiting to happen.
18:23Has it happened this year?
18:25I don't feel like anybody, I haven't heard anything about the turf monster in New Jersey this year.
18:29Yeah, I haven't seen it with the Jets or the Giants.
18:31I did see that my guy Aaron Glenn is now the favorite to be, well, I mean, come on, Jets.
18:39Hang in there, Jets.
18:40My buddy's on the staff, and he's got a young kid, like.
18:44He'll be all right.
18:46He'll be all right.
18:46And they're not going to hang in there.
18:48No, but are they two and seven?
18:50They're not going to hang in there.
18:50Yeah, of course not.
18:51They're two and eight.
18:52Yeah.
18:52They're two and eight.
18:53They do the play of the Chargers this week.
18:55Chargers and Jets this week.
18:57Who wins?
18:57Somebody.
18:58This is the weirdest slate of NFL games maybe I've ever seen.
19:03I actually hate it.
19:04I hate it for people who are still in survivor pools because there are games that are so easy.
19:09Like, the Arizona Cardinals could play at Arrowhead with this current version of them.
19:14They could play at Arrowhead 137 times, and they would win none of them.
19:21Like, there's no chance.
19:23There's no chance.