• 7 minutes ago
Marc Grandi gives out his grades from the 49ers' Week 10 win over the Cowboys while Willard and Dibs offer theirs.

Category

🥇
Sports
Transcript
00:00Good to be back with the Grandy's grades.
00:02As you mentioned, Willard, after a week off,
00:04hell of a win for the Niners in Dallas, 46 points.
00:07They allowed 40, so we're probably going to have some good grades on offense,
00:11some bad grades on defense.
00:13We shall find out.
00:14Let's begin with the quarterback.
00:16What can we say about Brock Purdy?
00:18You guys just talking about his viability as an MVP candidate
00:22and this performance in front of a national audience
00:25just about as national of an audience
00:27as a non-Sunday night, Monday night, Thursday night game can get.
00:30He was incredible.
00:32He threw for 389 yards, only six incompletions,
00:37three touchdowns, did not turn the ball over,
00:39and I thought his offensive line didn't do a good job
00:41of giving him time to throw.
00:42It was his legs that created a lot of those passing lanes and those yards.
00:47He was awesome.
00:48I cannot find a thing that he did wrong
00:50aside from maybe one wayward pass towards Kean Allen,
00:53but that doesn't drop anything for me.
00:54I gave him an A+.
00:55Yeah, he threw one ball to Kean Allen over the middle low
00:58on a third down that would have been a big first down.
01:05But listen, Brock Purdy in the face of pressure
01:09and in the face of a defense having a hard time on the other end
01:15was absolutely damn near perfect.
01:18His quarterback rating would actually suggest damn near perfect.
01:22He was accurate.
01:23He did not turn the ball over.
01:24He threw three touchdown passes.
01:26He used his legs.
01:28He was an improvisation sensation.
01:32Divs does not like it when I give A-pluses, so I won't.
01:37Instead, thank you.
01:39Instead, I will give an A+++.
01:42Oh, yeah.
01:43To Brock Purdy, the president of Brockistan, has spoken.
01:47Yes, and I mean, thank you.
01:50A triple plus felt a little bit like you're pandering,
01:54but the way you guys laid it out is accurate.
01:56And the one throw to Kean Allen, it was low and turned out to not be that effectual.
02:02He bought time.
02:03He made big throws.
02:05He had a couple of throws that were, quite frankly, fairly easy.
02:08The last one when they went zero blitz and McCaffrey just ran by Von Miller.
02:11But he made the throw, and he made the play.
02:14And I don't believe in it, but the peer pressure part of this bid has gotten to me.
02:19I gave him an A+.
02:20Yeah!
02:23Wow!
02:24I mean...
02:25Whoa!
02:25First and only A-plus ever?
02:27I mean, how do you...
02:29You can look at six incompletes, and...
02:32Whoa!
02:32One was batted down at the line of scrimmage.
02:35He had the one underthrow, which was underthrown by like a half a foot.
02:38It was damn near perfection.
02:40So there, A-plus.
02:42Fade, fade, fade!
02:44Cave, cave, cave, cave!
02:45I caved in!
02:46I think the A-plus suggests it was perfect, Dibs.
02:49Well, that would be A-plus, plus, plus.
02:51I have this poster in my room.
02:52Yeah, A-plus.
02:53It's right there.
02:53Okay.
02:54A-plus, plus.
02:54It's right there.
02:55Up next is the guys that he was handing the ball off to and throwing to.
02:59Skill positions, running backs, tight ends, wide receivers.
03:03I mean, what can we say about Christian McCaffrey?
03:05He had 161 receiving yards, add in 62 yards on the ground, three total touchdowns.
03:11Debo Samuel took a couple of carries, took one of them for 70 yards and a touchdown on
03:17a reverse.
03:17Kittle is just ho-hum, give you 74 yards, no big deal off the Achilles.
03:22Keenan Allen looked like a vet in this Niner system.
03:25He had five for 61.
03:27One, Jordan Watkins is flashing every game now with big plays down the field, and Caelan
03:33Black was phenomenal.
03:34Other than putting the ball on the turf twice, neither of them turned into turnovers, but
03:39that's really the only negative I can think of, and it's why it's not an A-plus for me.
03:43I give skill positions an A.
03:44They were phenomenal, and McCaffrey with a couple of big plays.
03:47Debo with the reverse off the toss from Black.
03:50Black running people over.
03:52They were just awesome.
03:53George Kittle made the catch as he needed to.
03:56Keenan Allen was as serviceable as you would think, but you mentioned it, Grandy.
04:00He put the ball on the ground twice, Caelan Black, including when it was time to suffocate
04:05the game, and he's fortunate that it went down and came right back up into his biscuit, into
04:10his basket.
04:11So because of those two hiccups, I gave him an A-minus.
04:15Yep, as did I.
04:16Exact same thing, because what would we be saying about this entire group?
04:20Clearly phenomenal.
04:21And by the way, stats coming out today that the 49ers are literally the best in the NFL
04:26with drop passes.
04:28They just don't do it.
04:29And I was even trying to think of how many drops I can remember this year.
04:32There are so few.
04:33They have been so clean.
04:34They've been so good, especially in the face of a lot of roster turnover.
04:40Like, it's a new group each week, and they just come in and execute, so they were incredible.
04:44But how would we feel if the Cowboys had recovered that fumble and gone up 47-46?
04:51We would have been absolutely sick to our stomachs, A-minus for me.
04:55Up next, it is the offensive line.
04:58Look, they ran the ball very well, though a big chunk of it was the 70-yard run to Debo,
05:03which was more about the design of the play than, I think, great blocking by the offensive
05:07line.
05:07But they give credit for that.
05:08They ran for 7.4 yards per carry, 214 rushing yards in this game.
05:15But the other half of the offensive line work was not good.
05:19And for my money, probably their worst performance of the season in terms of the pass protection
05:23for Brock Purdy.
05:25It got better in the second half, but man, that first half was really, really rough.
05:30The Cowboys sacked Brock Purdy, what was five times in this game?
05:34They had a few other tackles for loss.
05:36Look, it wasn't terrible because it was better in the second half, and the running half of
05:41their job was good.
05:43But man, that pass protection was bad.
05:45I give them a C overall.
05:46Interesting.
05:46I gave them a B just because, to me, I think there's always a lot of stuff that we can't
05:51see on the offensive line.
05:52And if your team scores 46 points, then the offensive line must have done something right.
05:58Yeah.
05:59Are the running metrics kind of skewed by Debo Samuel going on a 70-yard run?
06:04Sure.
06:04However, if I go person by person, McCaffrey, 4.8 yards a carry.
06:10Caelan Black, 4.8 yards a carry.
06:12Did they do some of that work on their own?
06:14I'm sure, but if Brock Purdy and the entire 49er offense are not going to turn the ball
06:19over, then, to me, there's some good blocking going on at some point.
06:24Five sacks, that's too many.
06:26Would love to see it be much better.
06:28As Kyle Shanahan said it, Quinton Williams is a problem.
06:30You've got to give the other team a little bit of credit here, too.
06:33But to me, they've got to be better than average when they score 46 points, so I go B.
06:37Yeah, 5.1 per carry if you take out the big 70-yard Debo run, which is still very, very
06:43good, but the five sacks do kind of offset it, and they had a few penalties that I thought
06:48were what I like to call the parking tickets, where it was pre-snap, and they opened up the
06:52third quarter with a false start on Dominic Poonie, so not completely clean, but still effective
06:57enough to, as you guys said, put up 46.
07:00I gave them a B-.
07:01All right, up next, we transition to the defense and gear up for some bad grades, because
07:06they allowed 40 points to the Cowboys.
07:09We begin with the front seven.
07:11That's your down linemen and your linebackers.
07:14This was just bad, I think, for the vast majority of the game.
07:18Not just the fourth quarter.
07:19That's when it was at its worst, absolutely, but the game opened with Osa Odigizua roughing
07:24the passer penalty that I think took a second and long and turned it into a first down.
07:30You can disagree with the call if you want, but you can't land with your full body weight
07:34on the quarterback like that.
07:35Osa knows that.
07:37And then the second half, specifically the fourth quarter, was really, really bad.
07:41They got no pressure on Dak essentially the entire game.
07:45One sack, but I don't even really credit the Niners with that sack because it was more
07:49of a Dak scramble, and he didn't quite get past the line of scrimmage.
07:53They didn't really lose any yards on that play.
07:55Only one tackle for loss entirely.
07:56And this is a group now that is, other than Grayson Halton, healthy and full of proven
08:02veteran dudes with Bosa and Odigizua and now DeForest Buckner.
08:08And they've flatly been bad, I think, for a couple of weeks.
08:11I gave the front seven an F.
08:12There's not much to write home about for me.
08:15Grumpy Grandy.
08:16Grumpy Grandy's in the building.
08:17I looked at it in a slightly different way through a different lens because when you're
08:22up 38-19 and they're going to go hurry up, you're going to give up a certain amount of
08:27yardage.
08:27And there were some gash plays, and I don't think that it was exclusively on the front
08:31seven.
08:32I also want to highlight the Fred Warner punch out, which I thought was one that could have
08:37been maybe challenged.
08:38And also, Mikel Williams with a forced fumble, but Diomedo Lenore held on the play, so that
08:43one got denied as well.
08:45I look at the points they gave up late as being mostly situational.
08:49They controlled the run game throughout the ball game.
08:52And yes, they still aren't getting enough pressure.
08:54I gave them a flat C.
08:56That's exactly where I am as well.
08:58Grandy, way too hard.
08:59Somebody did something to your Cheerios today.
09:02See, they gave up 40.
09:04Yeah, so again, that's a little bit of a gravy train thought, considering that 21 of them
09:08were in the fourth quarter.
09:10They weren't great.
09:11And the fourth quarter was really bad, but 19 points at the end of the third quarter.
09:16And if you really want to dive into the metrics, Javante Williams is held under four yards per
09:22carry.
09:23You had multiple defensive linemen put five pressures on Dak.
09:28How would you feel about the defensive line if Dre Greenlaw grabs an interception?
09:34The linebackers, actually, they were pretty good.
09:38I think to give the front seven an F is actually not putting enough pressure on the back four.
09:44And we're going to get to them.
09:46So were they great?
09:48Of course they were not.
09:49But this is a group that held Javante Williams under four yards per carry.
09:54And at the end of three quarters, you're looking at a 19-point lead early fourth quarter.
10:02So this, to me, can't be an F.
10:04I give them a C.
10:05What would it take for them to get an F?
10:07Give up 60 points?
10:08You would have had to have had no pressures.
10:12You would have had to have constant penalties.
10:15You would have had to...
10:16Give up 200 yards on the ground.
10:19Lost the game?
10:19Well, they're not going to give up 200 yards on the ground because they were ahead.
10:22How about lose the game?
10:23How about that?
10:24Can we start with that?
10:25The offense was amazing.
10:26Fs go for losses.
10:27Okay.
10:28And we'll get to the secondary.
10:29That's what's coming up right now, the secondary.
10:32Look, I have a little bit more appreciation for the struggles the secondary was going through
10:37because of the injuries to that group.
10:41Okay.
10:42Okay.
10:43The injuries to that group.
10:44We're mad at the front seven.
10:45We're mad at the front seven.
10:46I bet they're all perfectly healthy.
10:48Let the teacher grade.
10:49I am very mad at the front seven.
10:51And I'm frustrated with the secondary, but I think their performance wasn't as bad as
10:56the front seven because, as you guys well know, of course,
10:59the relationship between the two, it's connected.
11:02If a front seven can get to the quarterback, it's going to help out the secondary in this
11:08group.
11:08And look, did Lenore get beat by George Pickens on multiple occasions?
11:12Yes, of course he did.
11:13But they also held CeeDee Lamb without a catch in the first half.
11:16And if you would have told me that was possible, I wouldn't have believed you considering how
11:21good this cowboy offense is.
11:23It was bad late.
11:24Absolutely.
11:25But I blame more on the front seven for not being able to get to the quarterback with
11:30any kind of regularity.
11:31And when you're asked, you're asking a beat up secondary to defend 51 Dak Prescott passes
11:37to those wide receivers, you're going to get beat here and there.
11:40They got beat more than you would have liked.
11:42But I don't think they were the problem as much as the front seven was.
11:45Not a good day at all.
11:46I gave him a D plus, but not an F for me.
11:48Okay, and I think we've sort of arrived at why we see it a little bit differently.
11:52If you want to put more of this on the front seven, I get it.
11:55I put a little bit more of it on the secondary.
11:57Normally, I am a believer in like what you just said, that the pass rush is what affects
12:02the secondary.
12:03But when I watch quarterbacks each week getting rid of the ball in what is considered almost
12:08record time when they're going against the 49ers, those are those first two seconds that
12:13as a secondary, you're supposed to be able to hold with the wide receivers that long.
12:17If he's back there for five seconds, now it's on the front seven.
12:21If you're back there for two and the wide receiver is wide open, I'm going to give it to the
12:26secondary.
12:27Now, two reasons it's a D plus and not worse.
12:30One, I too have sympathy for the injuries.
12:34Oh.
12:34Yeah.
12:35It was a tough day.
12:36Anyway, sympathy for the injuries.
12:38I get that they're not 100% and Renardo Green had to leave again.
12:41And I got to give him something for an interception, even though they'd have been better off with
12:48him dropping it.
12:49But I give him something for that.
12:51Mustafa made a couple plays, in fact, over the middle and he got the pick as well.
12:56So that brings it up a little bit so that they do pass.
12:58They get to go on to the next semester.
13:00But it's a D plus for me.
13:01And the interception for Mustafa and a drive later, he got called for unnecessary roughness,
13:07which I didn't think was unnecessary roughness.
13:09But you get flagged because you're Malik Mustafa.
13:12The penalty moved Dallas down to the six yard line.
13:15You guys said just about everything that needed to be said.
13:18Diamant Lenore was compromised and we all can, you know, shed a tear for that.
13:22But he got targeted 17 times and he got absolutely owned.
13:27And then Ephesians, Prysock, talk about baptism by fire.
13:31He was running around, not knowing which way to go.
13:33We all agree with different measures of our commentary.
13:36It's a D plus.
13:38Yeah, not great.
13:39Definitely from the secondary.
13:40OK, up next, it is special teams.
13:43I know that we just freak out every time they go back there to catch a punt.
13:48And those fears came up again in this game.
13:50Didn't result in a turnover.
13:52So while I'm frustrated that he's still back there receiving punts, it didn't cost him at all.
13:58So I'm not going to, you know, downgrade him all that much.
14:01Pinero didn't have to do all that much other than, you know, kick extra points for the most part.
14:06And the kick coverage, you know, wasn't bad at all.
14:10The biggest play of the game, I think, was the last punt of the game where Corliss Waitman
14:15downed it inside the 10 yard line, essentially giving the Cowboys no chance to win down the stretch.
14:20So it wasn't a whole lot that happened on special teams in this game, in my opinion, but it was
14:25mostly good.
14:26I gave him an A minus.
14:27Eddie Pinero, baby.
14:28I mean, make your kicks.
14:29He's back to making kicks.
14:31And I like Waitman now on kickoffs.
14:33He sent a bunch of them down there inside the two or the three.
14:35They did have a hold to start the third quarter.
14:38They had, I think, a face mask on a punt where the gunner, Sirhan Neal, went down and just grabbed
14:44the other guy's face mask.
14:45And the punt, I wrote down, backspin delicious.
14:48You know, I'm a fan of the punter.
14:50I thought all in all the special teams were good.
14:52But my God, Jacob Cowling, catch the ball on your feet if you wouldn't mind.
14:57It's a B for me.
14:59Yeah.
14:59I'm going to echo everything you guys are saying.
15:01They largely did a really good job.
15:03Pinheiro makes all his kicks.
15:04Corliss Waitman kicking off did really well.
15:08And then the punt was a chef's kiss.
15:11And Kyle even called out the kick return coverage for doing a great job against the Dallas group that's done
15:19pretty well in that metric so far this year.
15:22So I'm looking at everything.
15:23No turnovers.
15:24It's clean.
15:25I'm giving them an A until Jacob Cowling made my heart fly through the floor.
15:32So you go to a B plus just for laying down.
15:37That's it.
15:38You're an A.
15:38And now you're B plus just because you laid down.
15:41Fair enough.
15:42Fair enough.
15:42And last but not least, it is coaching.
15:45Look, we could poke some holes maybe in what happened in the fourth quarter from a defensive standpoint.
15:50I always hate the you got a big lead in the fourth.
15:53We're going to just not get beat over the top for a 70 yard touchdown.
15:55And you give up everything underneath.
15:57We can be frustrated by that.
15:59And maybe there is some truth to that.
16:02I wait Kyle Shanahan's portion of the coaching grade way heavier than anything else.
16:07And I thought this was an absolute masterclass by Kyle Shanahan from start to finish setting up the Debo reverse
16:13with the Kalon Black touchdown run earlier.
16:16I mean, it's becoming commonplace for Kyle Shanahan.
16:19And we are blessed as fans of this team over the last decade because he makes those things look easy
16:24like nobody else does.
16:26It's a bad Dallas defense.
16:28I get it.
16:29But you put up 46.
16:30That deserves some major major kudos to Kyle Shanahan.
16:34Coaching for me, it's an A minus mainly because of Shanahan on offense.
16:37Interesting.
16:38So here's where I'm at on the coaching thing.
16:40Kyle Shanahan's portion of this, the play calling portion of this is A plus plus plus.
16:46However, Kyle is the coach of the entire team.
16:49I think from a schematic standpoint, there are probably some things that Raheem Morris could have done a little bit
16:55differently to help that pass rush out.
16:58Yes, again, sympathy for what's going on in the defensive backfield and the injuries.
17:03But I think there's an aspect you didn't get to here, Grandy.
17:06And it's a concerning little trend of too many penalties.
17:09There were 11 of them, 11 flags on the Niners in this game.
17:13And I don't care if these were temp refs or whatever.
17:16That's too many.
17:18You go up against the Cowboys and have more than twice as many penalties as they do, the Cowboys?
17:23That has to, on some level, I know the players do that.
17:27But on some level, that reflects on the coaching as well.
17:30How does Nick Bosa get flagged for the same penalty three times?
17:34Somebody get in that dude's face and, like, remind him, like, you can't do that.
17:40So that drops the whole thing down a little bit for me, and I gave him a B.
17:44Yeah, I think Bosa's just kind of trying to cheat because he's not as explosive as he normally is.
17:49So he's trying to guess the snap count.
17:50And I guess I look at penalties, for the most part, in a different way.
17:54And you had Kittle with a false start, which is rare.
17:56You had Poonie as well.
17:58I put those on the players because the coach calls the play.
18:01And if you jump, that's a you problem.
18:04I just look at what Grandy said about the master class of play calling.
18:08And even the last touchdown, where it's a zero blitz, and instead of keeping McCaffrey
18:13in to protect, he sends him out right past Von Miller.
18:16Pitch, catch, touchdown.
18:17I thought that it was an absolute Shanahan beauty.
18:20He gets an A.
18:22All right.
18:22And it results in a win, somehow, 46-40.
18:26There's Grandy's grades for week number 10.
18:28How good is Kyle Shanahan that he can coach a team to a win while this front seven gets an
18:35F?
18:36Yeah.
18:37That's a pretty good coach.
18:37Oh, she's amazing.
18:39Their offense, they had more yards on offense than anyone ever in the history of games in Dallas.
18:46In Dallas.
18:47I know it.
18:47Amazing.
Comments

Recommended