00:00Senior Counsel and former Attorney General Ramesh Lawrence Maraj said in a statement that the Judicial Committee of the Privy
00:07Council, the JCPC, upheld the validity of the decision of the then-UNC-led government to declare the state of
00:14emergency in 2011, which lasted three and a half months.
00:18However, he added that the JCPC held that the constitutional rights of two of the appellants were violated by the
00:25state and restored the order made by the High Court to award Earl Eli and Dominic Petalal the sum of
00:32$50,000 each.
00:34Senior Counsel Maraj also said that the JCPC in its judgment also gave guidance to courts in determining decisions made
00:42by governments to declare public emergencies based on criminal activities and actions of individuals and groups.
00:49The Office of the Attorney General said in a media release that the importance of this judgment by the JCPC
00:55about the validity of the state of emergency in 2011 is that it recognizes the heavy responsibility that is placed
01:03upon elected officials who are accountable to the citizenry in exercise of powers that are conferred by the Constitution to
01:11protect public safety and our democracy in the most challenging times.
01:15The former Attorney General in his statement made reference to the state of emergency under the former PNM-led government
01:23from December 20, 2024 to April 2025, the state of emergency under the UNC-led government from July 18, 2025
01:31to January 2026, and the SOE under the UNC-led government from March 3, 2026 to September 15, 2026.
01:41Senior Counsel Maraj said, quote, the JCPC's decision ought not to be interpreted as deciding that the repeated declarations of
01:49state of emergencies made since 2024 were valid.
01:53The appeals concerning the 2011 state of emergency arose from a specific proclamation made in response to circumstances prevailing at
02:03that time, including an escalation in gang-related murders, and intelligence concerning retaliatory violence following substantial drug seizures, as well
02:13as a report of conspiracy to assassinate the Prime Minister.
02:16End quote.
02:17End quote.
02:18The former Attorney General added that the frequency and duration of the recent states of emergency raised additional constitutional questions
02:26which are to be considered in light of the principles endorsed by the JCPC in the appeal of Earl Eli
02:33and others, which include that a state of emergency should be short-lived.
02:37The restrictions on fundamental rights must be temporary, not indefinite, and ought not to be used to address problems arising
02:46from ongoing problems of inadequate resourcing or lax enforcement of the ordinary criminal law.
02:53Senior Counsel Maraj added that those are matters which require the state to enforce existing laws and effectively administer policies,
03:01as he also said prior to the 2011 state of emergency in Trinidad and Tobago,
03:06the declaration of a state of emergency was a rare event, such as in 1970 and in response to the
03:13coup attempt in 1990.
03:15Senior Counsel Maraj said, quote,
03:17A finding that the 2011 regulations were lawful does not establish that the regulations made under the subsequent states of
03:23emergencies were valid.
03:25Regulations made under the subsequent states of emergencies will be judged by asking whether they are reasonably justified by the
03:32circumstances which existed at the time.
03:35End quote.
03:37Jewel Brown, TV6 News.
03:39Jewel Brown, TV6 News.
Comments